diff --git "a/data/en109/text/00000000.txt" "b/data/en109/text/00000000.txt"
new file mode 100644--- /dev/null
+++ "b/data/en109/text/00000000.txt"
@@ -0,0 +1,13593 @@
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00000-00000016-00000271 do voter legislation laws ensure secure
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00001-00000272-00000511 and trustworthy elections or are they a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00002-00000512-00000743 way for political parties to manipulate
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00003-00000744-00001015 the democratic process in their favor at
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00004-00001016-00001223 a september 8 debate in new york city
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00005-00001224-00001423 hosted by the soho forum eliza
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00006-00001424-00001655 swarenbecker from nyu's brennan center
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00007-00001655-00001830 for justice argued that state
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00008-00001832-00002087 legislators are using arbitrary rules to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00009-00002088-00002334 suppress the voting rights of vulnerable
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00010-00002335-00002567 citizens the heritage foundation's hans
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00011-00002568-00002791 von spakovsky countered that these rules
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00012-00002792-00003023 are necessary to guarantee that every
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00013-00003024-00003286 vote cast is valid noting that in states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00014-00003288-00003519 where voter id laws already exist
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00015-00003520-00003735 registration rates have risen this was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00016-00003736-00003903 an oxford style debate in which the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00017-00003904-00004119 audience voted before and after the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00018-00004120-00004351 event to see which side swayed more
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00019-00004352-00004567 people it was moderated by soho forum
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00020-00004568-00004806 director gene epstein
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00021-00004807-00005102 legislators in multiple states are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00022-00005103-00005399 actively making making it harder for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00023-00005400-00005606 americans to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00024-00005607-00005975 defending the resolution eliza swearin
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00025-00005976-00006839 becker eliza please come to the stage
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00026-00006840-00007083 opposing and taking the negative on the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00027-00007084-00007455 resolution hans von spakovsky
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00028-00007456-00008039 hans please come to the stage
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00029-00008040-00008255 it's okay it's okay
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00030-00008256-00008423 it's okay eliza you can sit there
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00031-00008424-00008687 because you are coming to the podium
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00032-00008688-00008927 right now to defend the resolution you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00033-00008928-00009606 have 15 minutes take it away eliza
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00034-00009607-00009783 hello everyone
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00035-00009784-00010159 it's nice to be with people in person
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00036-00010160-00010271 and thank you so much for the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00037-00010272-00010438 introduction and and thank you all for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00038-00010439-00010678 being here in person
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00039-00010679-00010895 in last year's general election voters
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00040-00010896-00011183 turned out in historic numbers and used
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00041-00011184-00011406 male and early voting at unprecedented
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00042-00011407-00011519 levels
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00043-00011520-00011759 presidential election turnout was seven
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00044-00011760-00012055 percentage points higher than in 2016
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00045-00012056-00012335 and the number of ballots cast by mail
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00046-00012336-00012567 or in person before election day more
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00047-00012568-00012879 than doubled that of 2016. that is good
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00048-00012880-00013143 news for american democracy
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00049-00013144-00013319 but the response for many state houses
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00050-00013319-00013535 across the country has been clear
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00051-00013536-00013847 by july at least 18 states had enacted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00052-00013847-00014111 30 laws that make it harder to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00053-00014112-00014399 and more have been signed since
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00054-00014400-00014566 the reality is actually worse than those
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00055-00014568-00014766 numbers suggest because states like
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00056-00014768-00015063 georgia florida iowa and texas
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00057-00015063-00015279 have enacted omnibus bills that contain
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00058-00015280-00015479 multiple restrictions
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00059-00015480-00015630 the brennan center has been tracking
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00060-00015631-00015815 state voting legislation for more than a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00061-00015816-00016030 decade decade excuse me i get a little
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00062-00016031-00016215 winded these days
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00063-00016216-00016327 um
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00064-00016328-00016550 this is without a doubt the biggest wave
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00065-00016551-00016775 of new laws to make voting harder that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00066-00016776-00017071 we have seen in recent memory it cannot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00067-00017072-00017319 reasonably just be disputed that many
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00068-00017320-00017822 state legislators across the country
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00069-00017823-00018047 you guys can hear me okay
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00070-00018048-00018214 thanks
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00071-00018215-00018391 it cannot reasonably be disputed that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00072-00018392-00018543 many state legislators across the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00073-00018544-00018735 country are actively working to make it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00074-00018736-00018950 harder for americans to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00075-00018951-00019143 first when you actually look at the text
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00076-00019144-00019343 of these laws it's clear they put
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00077-00019344-00019550 barriers in the path of eligible voters
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00078-00019551-00019750 on the way to the ballot box
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00079-00019751-00019847 second
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00080-00019848-00019991 studies show that these kinds of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00081-00019992-00020239 restrictions burden american voters and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00082-00020240-00020511 in particular voters of color
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00083-00020512-00020799 third there's a tightness of fit problem
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00084-00020800-00020991 supporters of these new restrictions
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00085-00020992-00021222 argue that they are necessary to protect
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00086-00021223-00021414 the integrity of american elections to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00087-00021415-00021671 prevent voter fraud or at a minimum to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00088-00021672-00021839 restore public confidence in our
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00089-00021840-00021967 elections
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00090-00021968-00022207 but the laws don't largely improve
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00091-00022208-00022367 american elections
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00092-00022368-00022558 and that's because study after studies
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00093-00022559-00022775 show that our elections are not actually
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00094-00022776-00022935 plagued by fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00095-00022936-00023199 in other words the downside is big these
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00096-00023200-00023383 new laws impose greater costs and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00097-00023384-00023614 burdens on voters in some cases
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00098-00023615-00023911 decreasing turnout but the upside is nil
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00099-00023912-00024158 that is a bum deal for american voters
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00100-00024159-00024399 and american democracy
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00101-00024400-00024614 taking those three steps in turn let's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00102-00024615-00024871 first look at these new laws and i won't
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00103-00024872-00025047 describe every feature of the dozens of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00104-00025048-00025263 laws that have been enacted this year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00105-00025264-00025439 but starting first with florida for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00106-00025440-00025542 example
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00107-00025543-00025846 the state's omnibus legislation sb90
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00108-00025847-00026062 strictly limits the availability of mail
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00109-00026063-00026302 ballot drop boxes which have been used
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00110-00026304-00026462 in the state for many years without
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00111-00026463-00026623 incident
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00112-00026624-00026846 these boxes are now accessible only at
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00113-00026847-00027039 certain government offices
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00114-00027039-00027183 but that's not withstanding the fact
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00115-00027183-00027367 that mail ballots can be dropped off at
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00116-00027368-00027662 any blue mail excuse me blue mailbox on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00117-00027663-00027887 the corner 24 hours a day seven days a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00118-00027888-00027974 week
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00119-00027975-00028167 so why did florida lawmakers decide to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00120-00028168-00028343 make it harder for voters to access
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00121-00028344-00028487 dropboxes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00122-00028488-00028655 it seems like the popularity of these
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00123-00028656-00028870 boxes might have something to do with it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00124-00028872-00029062 during the 2020 general election at
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00125-00029063-00029367 least 51 of florida's 67 counties
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00126-00029368-00029574 offered a dropbox that was available 24
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00127-00029575-00029646 7
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00128-00029647-00029895 and as a result 1.5 million floridian
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00129-00029895-00030158 voters used a dropbox to vote making up
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00130-00030160-00030439 more than 10 percent of voters overall
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00131-00030439-00030751 and more than a quarter excuse me
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00132-00030752-00030911 and more than a quarter of those who
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00133-00030912-00031095 voted by mail
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00134-00031095-00031231 it's also worth noting that the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00135-00031232-00031399 percentage of black voters who cast
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00136-00031400-00031631 their ballots by mail doubled in florida
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00137-00031632-00031951 from 2016 to 2020.
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00138-00031952-00032111 state policies that make it harder to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00139-00032112-00032302 vote in florida are not new
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00140-00032303-00032590 in 2019 after the state voters adopted a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00141-00032591-00032758 constitutional amendment to restore
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00142-00032760-00032902 voting rights to people with past
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00143-00032903-00033151 convictions the state enacted a law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00144-00033152-00033351 conditioning eligibility on the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00145-00033352-00033551 repayment of court debts arising from
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00146-00033552-00033718 criminal convictions
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00147-00033719-00033895 in other words for hundreds of thousands
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00148-00033896-00034127 of floridians the only thing determining
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00149-00034128-00034279 whether they can vote is the balance in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00150-00034280-00034423 their bank account
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00151-00034424-00034583 expert analysis has found that this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00152-00034584-00034887 denies eligibility to more than 700 000
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00153-00034888-00035127 floridians who are disproportionately
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00154-00035128-00035271 black
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00155-00035272-00035407 georgia 2 has restricted the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00156-00035408-00035655 availability in hours of drop boxes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00157-00035656-00035839 now the four major metro counties
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00158-00035840-00035999 surrounding atlanta will be limited to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00159-00036000-00036374 an estimated 23 boxes total by contrast
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00160-00036375-00036671 there were 111 such boxes last year and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00161-00036672-00036967 more than 300 000 voters used them
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00162-00036968-00037102 to put that into context the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00163-00037103-00037343 presidential race was decided in georgia
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00164-00037344-00037607 by less than 12 000 votes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00165-00037608-00037830 george's omnibus law also prohibits
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00166-00037831-00038055 election officials from affirmatively
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00167-00038056-00038230 sending out mail ballot applications to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00168-00038231-00038495 voters gives voters less time to apply
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00169-00038496-00038735 for absentee ballots and criminalizes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00170-00038736-00038902 the act of giving snacks and water to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00171-00038903-00039183 voters waiting in line at polling places
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00172-00039184-00039318 it's hard to see how any of these
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00173-00039319-00039487 policies has anything to do with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00174-00039488-00039718 improving our elections but it's easy to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00175-00039719-00039855 see how they incrementally make it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00176-00039856-00040007 harder to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00177-00040008-00040223 most recently texas enacted omnibus
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00178-00040224-00040502 legislation as well the law bans 24-hour
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00179-00040503-00040687 early voting locations drive-through
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00180-00040688-00040830 voting and mobile polling place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00181-00040831-00040935 structures
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00182-00040936-00041087 without any basis for why these
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00183-00041088-00041239 conveniences could undermine our
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00184-00041240-00041407 elections
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00185-00041408-00041599 the law makes it a crime for public
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00186-00041600-00041799 officials to encourage voters who may be
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00187-00041800-00041958 eligible to submit mail ballot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00188-00041959-00042167 applications yet places no such
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00189-00042168-00042430 restriction on party officials
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00190-00042431-00042639 at the same time the law makes all
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00191-00042640-00042830 voting fraud offenses misdemeanors
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00192-00042831-00043062 instead of felonies which seems like an
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00193-00043063-00043279 especially odd thing to do in a law that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00194-00043280-00043495 supporters and the texas governor claim
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00195-00043496-00043695 was designed to discourage such
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00196-00043696-00043935 such misconduct
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00197-00043936-00044255 in iowa sf-413 shortens the early voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00198-00044256-00044462 period by nine days and limits election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00199-00044463-00044695 officials discretion to offer additional
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00200-00044696-00044887 early voting locations
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00201-00044888-00045318 why in alabama hb 285 prohibits curbside
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00202-00045319-00045535 voting entirely an essential voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00203-00045536-00045758 method for voters with disabilities
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00204-00045759-00045895 one of the bill's supporters in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00205-00045896-00046062 assembly there claimed that the law was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00206-00046063-00046207 intended to ensure that there was no
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00207-00046208-00046430 fraud in that voting procedure even as
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00208-00046431-00046583 he acknowledged that that didn't happen
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00209-00046584-00046807 in alabama last year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00210-00046808-00047030 i could go on but won't what's clear
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00211-00047031-00047255 from the plain text of these policies is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00212-00047256-00047430 that these laws add to the hurdles that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00213-00047431-00047630 voters must overcome to exercise their
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00214-00047631-00047846 fundamental right to vote and that the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00215-00047847-00048046 purported justification for these rules
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00216-00048047-00048230 is simply pretext
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00217-00048231-00048439 you don't have to take that from me the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00218-00048440-00048599 proponents of these restrictions have
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00219-00048600-00048846 said so themselves during supreme court
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00220-00048847-00049030 arguments earlier this year the lawyer
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00221-00049031-00049239 for the arizona republican party
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00222-00049240-00049471 defended arizona's law in validating
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00223-00049472-00049702 votes cast in the wrong precinct by
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00224-00049703-00049895 saying that not having that policy on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00225-00049896-00050055 the books would put them at a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00226-00050056-00050255 competitive disadvantage relative to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00227-00050256-00050471 democrats it's the difference between
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00228-00050472-00050711 winning an election 50 49 and losing an
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00229-00050712-00050830 election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00230-00050831-00051023 similarly an arizona lawmaker when
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00231-00051024-00051190 justifying new restrictions in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00232-00051191-00051414 state's mail voting process this year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00233-00051415-00051599 stated that quote everybody shouldn't be
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00234-00051600-00051790 voting and quote the quality of votes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00235-00051791-00052023 mattered and when discussing proposals
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00236-00052024-00052223 to expand access to male voting last
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00237-00052224-00052423 year president trump stated that an
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00238-00052424-00052638 expansion of early and male voting would
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00239-00052639-00052830 lead to quote levels of voting that if
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00240-00052832-00052999 you agreed to it you'd never have a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00241-00053000-00053335 republican elected in the country again
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00242-00053336-00053575 second a mountain of research shows that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00243-00053576-00053759 these kinds of voting restrictions do
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00244-00053760-00053999 indeed burden voters and make it harder
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00245-00054000-00054159 to vote particularly for racial
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00246-00054160-00054366 minorities and other groups like voters
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00247-00054367-00054599 with disabilities
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00248-00054600-00054799 on one hand data show that measures that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00249-00054800-00055015 make voting more convenient like
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00250-00055016-00055175 increasing the proximity of voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00251-00055176-00055471 locations adding more voting days
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00252-00055472-00055647 those things matter to voters and to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00253-00055648-00055782 turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00254-00055783-00055942 voters surveyed as to why they didn't
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00255-00055944-00056166 vote in the 2018 midterm elections for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00256-00056167-00056399 example most commonly responded that it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00257-00056400-00056575 was because they were quote too busy and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00258-00056576-00056759 had a conflicting schedule
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00259-00056760-00056942 others cited an inconvenient polling
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00260-00056944-00057103 place while others said they faced
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00261-00057104-00057287 transportation problems
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00262-00057288-00057447 that's why reforms that make it more
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00263-00057448-00057623 convenient to vote have been shown to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00264-00057624-00057854 increase turnout for example one
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00265-00057855-00058023 peer-reviewed study showed that for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00266-00058024-00058215 every additional early voting day in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00267-00058216-00058454 ohio turnout increased by a quarter of a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00268-00058455-00058663 percentage point and that joins other
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00269-00058664-00058838 research showing the positive effects of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00270-00058839-00059071 early voting on turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00271-00059072-00059279 enacting no excuse mail voting has been
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00272-00059279-00059487 shown to increase turnout by between one
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00273-00059488-00059615 and two percent
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00274-00059616-00059766 and studies show that mail voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00275-00059767-00059966 especially increases turnout for younger
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00276-00059967-00060215 voters voters of color voters with less
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00277-00060216-00060494 education and voters with disabilities
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00278-00060495-00060694 on the other hand the inverse is true
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00279-00060695-00060879 policies that make it less convenient to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00280-00060879-00061103 vote decrease turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00281-00061104-00061326 a 2017 study of a local new york
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00282-00061327-00061503 election found that polling place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00283-00061504-00061703 consolidation decreased voter turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00284-00061704-00061982 substantially by about seven percent
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00285-00061983-00062247 in a 2020 study of cities in minnesota
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00286-00062248-00062463 and and massachusetts found that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00287-00062464-00062638 increasing voters travel distance to the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00288-00062639-00062879 polls by a quarter mile decreased the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00289-00062879-00063079 number of ballots by two to five percent
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00290-00063079-00063382 across four elections
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00291-00063383-00063671 a 2021 study indicates that every hour
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00292-00063672-00063959 spent waiting in line reduces
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00293-00063960-00064166 turnout in subsequent elections by about
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00294-00064167-00064287 one percent
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00295-00064288-00064526 and other studies demonstrate that wait
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00296-00064527-00064711 times and polling place closures
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00297-00064712-00064879 disproportionately affect black and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00298-00064879-00065063 latino voters
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00299-00065064-00065279 notwithstanding all of this data many
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00300-00065279-00065487 states are going backwards by enacting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00301-00065488-00065679 laws that make it harder to vote by mail
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00302-00065680-00065911 make dropboxes harder to access make
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00303-00065912-00066126 polling places less convenient and cut
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00304-00066127-00066311 early voting days
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00305-00066312-00066503 additionally several states have imposed
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00306-00066504-00066750 harsher voter id requirements this year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00307-00066751-00067006 including georgia florida texas montana
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00308-00067007-00067150 and arkansas
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00309-00067151-00067311 yet there is no data showing a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00310-00067312-00067494 correlation between voter id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00311-00067495-00067703 requirements and the occurrence or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00312-00067704-00067894 prevention of fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00313-00067895-00068055 what the research does show in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00314-00068056-00068263 peer-reviewed studies is that strict
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00315-00068264-00068494 voter id laws decrease turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00316-00068495-00068743 for example after north carolina adopted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00317-00068744-00068991 a strict voter id law in 2013
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00318-00068992-00069150 researchers at stanford found that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00319-00069151-00069423 voters who lacked id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00320-00069424-00069638 turned out in fewer numbers and that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00321-00069639-00069879 turnout effect continued even after an
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00322-00069880-00070063 appellate court struck down that strict
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00323-00070064-00070343 id law a study published last year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00324-00070344-00070519 showed that the adoption of strict voter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00325-00070520-00070799 id in alabama mississippi virginia and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00326-00070800-00071079 wisconsin caused turnout to decline by
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00327-00071080-00071247 about one percent by more than one
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00328-00071248-00071487 percentage point an effect size larger
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00329-00071488-00071638 than the presidential vote margin in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00330-00071639-00071831 many states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00331-00071832-00071999 other work shows that people of color
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00332-00072000-00072223 are less likely to have the required id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00333-00072224-00072375 and that strict voter id laws
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00334-00072376-00072575 disproportionately reduce non-white
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00335-00072576-00072767 turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00336-00072768-00072935 let me pause here to emphasize that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00337-00072936-00073119 overall voter turnout is not the only
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00338-00073120-00073262 thing that matters
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00339-00073263-00073375 in fact
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00340-00073376-00073606 focusing exclusively on overall turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00341-00073607-00073767 numbers can gloss over the way that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00342-00073768-00073943 changing voting rules affects racial
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00343-00073944-00074206 minorities and other subgroups
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00344-00074207-00074415 voting restrictions can change who votes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00345-00074416-00074638 in a given jurisdiction even if they
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00346-00074639-00074815 don't change the overall number of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00347-00074816-00075006 voters in that area
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00348-00075007-00075247 for example even with historic overall
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00349-00075248-00075479 turnout in 2020 there remains a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00350-00075480-00075671 significant turnout gap between white
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00351-00075672-00075903 and non-white voters
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00352-00075904-00076119 overall 71 percent of eligible white
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00353-00076120-00076326 voters cast ballots in the 2020 general
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00354-00076327-00076567 elections compared to only 58 percent of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00355-00076568-00076719 non-white voters
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00356-00076720-00076911 and the racial turnout gap has actually
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00357-00076912-00077247 grown since the 2012 elections notably
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00358-00077248-00077479 the supreme court shelby county decision
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00359-00077480-00077767 came down in 2013 that decision stopped
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00360-00077768-00077959 what's known as pre-clearance which is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00361-00077960-00078126 the process by which states and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00362-00078127-00078311 jurisdictions with a history of racial
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00363-00078312-00078511 discrimination and voting had to get
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00364-00078512-00078687 pre-approval for changes to their voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00365-00078688-00078855 rules
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00366-00078856-00079047 the evidence is overwhelming that voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00367-00079048-00079247 laws do in fact matter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00368-00079248-00079423 but we shouldn't need a study to tell us
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00369-00079424-00079719 that fair free and equal voting access
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00370-00079720-00079911 is a core democratic value that needs to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00371-00079912-00080126 be defended and expanded
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00372-00080127-00080326 voting restrictions are harmful even if
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00373-00080327-00080623 they have no impact on overall turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00374-00080624-00080799 putting aside all of the evidence the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00375-00080800-00080894 intent
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00376-00080895-00081111 intent of these state measures is clear
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00377-00081112-00081367 to make it harder for americans to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00378-00081368-00081519 and it would be strange to argue that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00379-00081520-00081719 simply because state lawmakers may not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00380-00081720-00081903 succeed in shutting millions out of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00381-00081904-00082135 democratic process they should be able
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00382-00082136-00082406 to continue these efforts unimpeded
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00383-00082407-00082591 whether a given anti-voter policy will
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00384-00082592-00082799 have a large partisan racial or turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00385-00082800-00082982 effect the bottom line is that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00386-00082983-00083150 restricting access to the ballot is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00387-00083151-00083375 wrong and inconsistent with a free and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00388-00083376-00083575 democratic form of government
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00389-00083576-00083750 legislators proposing these changes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00390-00083751-00083862 because they want to limit the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00391-00083863-00084071 electorate may continue introducing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00392-00084072-00084206 these bills until they find something
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00393-00084207-00084359 that works
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00394-00084360-00084567 third and finally state lawmakers and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00395-00084568-00084750 others have justified the need for new
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00396-00084751-00084967 voting restrictions by pointing to their
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00397-00084968-00085182 desire to protect election integrity and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00398-00085183-00085335 prevent fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00399-00085336-00085526 but the truth is that extensive research
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00400-00085527-00085679 reveals that the incidence of voter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00401-00085680-00085926 fraud in contemporary u.s elections is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00402-00085927-00086199 exceedingly rare voter impersonation is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00403-00086200-00086423 virtually non-existent and many
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00404-00086424-00086687 instances of alleged fraud are in fact
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00405-00086688-00086847 mistakes by voters or election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00406-00086848-00086999 administrators
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00407-00087000-00087191 that's the same goes for mail ballots as
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00408-00087192-00087415 it does for voting in person
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00409-00087416-00087582 even taking the heritage foundation's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00410-00087583-00087831 own database of purported voter fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00411-00087832-00087982 and putting aside mathematical
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00412-00087983-00088135 methodological questions about that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00413-00088136-00088391 database the organization claims it has
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00414-00088392-00088523 identified
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00415-00088524-00088815 1333 instances of voter fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00416-00088816-00089015 but that's over the course of 40 years
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00417-00089016-00089262 and billions of votes cast in other
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00418-00089263-00089415 words the incidence of fraud is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00419-00089416-00089550 infinitesimal
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00420-00089551-00089726 indeed president trump's voter fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00421-00089727-00090015 commission was disbanded in 2018 after
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00422-00090016-00090255 failing to find evidence supporting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00423-00090256-00090815 to support widespread claims of fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00424-00090816-00091015 it is not an accident that we don't see
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00425-00091016-00091191 widespread election misconduct in this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00426-00091192-00091382 country that's because there are many
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00427-00091383-00091575 protections already in place that ensure
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00428-00091576-00091791 the integrity of american elections like
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00429-00091792-00092031 paper ballots poll books ballot bar
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00430-00092032-00092118 codes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00431-00092119-00092318 mail ballot tracking through usps
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00432-00092319-00092455 penalties for those who commit
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00433-00092456-00092671 misconduct voterless maintenance and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00434-00092672-00092926 risk limiting audits in other words it's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00435-00092927-00093079 quite difficult for an individual to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00436-00093080-00093343 commit fraud and if a person does so the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00437-00093344-00093535 effect of any one person's misdeed is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00438-00093536-00093703 necessarily limited
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00439-00093704-00093911 when candidates or officials attempt to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00440-00093912-00094150 perpetrate more systematic fraud on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00441-00094151-00094350 voters those schemes are generally
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00442-00094351-00094606 caught for example the north carolina
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00443-00094607-00094871 state board of elections detect
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00444-00094872-00095031 thanks
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00445-00095032-00095231 detected a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00446-00095232-00095518 consultant's effort to rig a 2018
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00447-00095519-00095799 congressional election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00448-00095800-00095959 this year the los angeles district
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00449-00095960-00096103 attorney has filed a criminal case
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00450-00096104-00096318 against a candidate for city council who
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00451-00096319-00096543 won his race by a single vote alleging
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00452-00096544-00096735 conspiracy to commit election fraud and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00453-00096736-00096935 that criminal case is ongoing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00454-00096936-00097199 in other words our system is working
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00455-00097200-00097399 as i described the downside of imposing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00456-00097400-00097631 more restrictions on voting is high but
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00457-00097632-00097791 the upside is low
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00458-00097792-00097974 the pop the problem these laws purport
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00459-00097975-00098231 to fix is not a significant risk 30
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00460-00098232-00098367 seconds
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00461-00098368-00098550 it's possible that an asteroid falls to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00462-00098551-00098703 earth or you get struck by lightning
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00463-00098704-00098918 just like voter fraud as possible but we
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00464-00098919-00099087 don't ask every person to incur the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00465-00099088-00099287 costs and burdens of buying asteroid or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00466-00099288-00099518 lightning insurance especially when are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00467-00099519-00099831 already effective protections in place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00468-00099832-00099999 to the extent americans have a lack of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00469-00100000-00100215 confidence in our electoral system that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00470-00100216-00100399 distrust has been sown by activists
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00471-00100400-00100687 making misrepresentations about fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00472-00100688-00100847 before putting obstacles in the way of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00473-00100848-00100999 americans exercising their most
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00474-00101000-00101191 fundamental right there should be a good
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00475-00101192-00101438 reason to do so and that reason simply
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00476-00101439-00101567 is not present
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00477-00101568-00101774 rather than instilling mistrust based on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00478-00101775-00101991 often racialized lies about fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00479-00101992-00102143 lawmakers should be telling the truth
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00480-00102144-00102343 about our elections the department of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00481-00102344-00102518 homeland security called the 2020
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00482-00102519-00102734 general election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00483-00102735-00103030 the most secure in american history
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00484-00103031-00103206 even with historic voter turnout this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00485-00103207-00103406 year voter participation in this country
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00486-00103407-00103615 is not what it should be just two-thirds
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00487-00103616-00103694 of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00488-00103695-00103894 eligible americans cast ballots last
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00489-00103895-00103990 year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00490-00103991-00104166 lawmakers should be making working to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00491-00104167-00104366 make it easier for americans to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00492-00104367-00104590 freely and fairly not relying on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00493-00104591-00104790 unsubstantiated claims of voter fraud to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00494-00104791-00105023 burden voters our democracy is more
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00495-00105024-00105239 accountable and more representative when
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00496-00105240-00105631 every eligible american participates
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00497-00105632-00105792 thank you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00498-00105793-00106063 [Applause]
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00499-00106064-00106295 speaking speaking for the negative
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00500-00106296-00106527 take it away hands i guess you get an
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00501-00106528-00106766 extra 60 seconds
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00502-00106767-00107463 to speak for the negative
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00503-00107464-00107671 well it is nice to see people in person
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00504-00107672-00107799 it's been a while since i've been able
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00505-00107800-00107951 to do that because of zoom and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00506-00107952-00108102 everything else so
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00507-00108103-00108319 it's nice to have an audience here today
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00508-00108320-00108478 i do want to before i start just very
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00509-00108479-00108702 quickly thank the reason foundation
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00510-00108703-00109023 thank gene thank the soho forum
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00511-00109024-00109223 because one thing that we have seen
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00512-00109224-00109366 unfortunately in this country is a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00513-00109367-00109599 steady erosion of the ability to have
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00514-00109600-00109734 civil debates
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00515-00109735-00109958 even about contentious issues and i
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00516-00109959-00110223 applaud the soho forum for continuing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00517-00110224-00110358 what i think is a great american
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00518-00110359-00110566 tradition that is in sad decline
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00519-00110567-00110678 especially
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00520-00110679-00111007 on american campuses
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00521-00111008-00111158 second i want to emphasize something
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00522-00111159-00111383 that i learned from my immigrants
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00523-00111383-00111599 immigrant parents who experienced some
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00524-00111600-00111847 of the worst dictatorships of the last
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00525-00111848-00112086 century and that is voting is the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00526-00112088-00112247 essential ingredient
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00527-00112248-00112415 in maintaining and protecting our
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00528-00112416-00112654 democratic republic and the liberty and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00529-00112655-00113007 freedom we enjoy as citizens
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00530-00113008-00113295 our goal should be to ensure that every
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00531-00113296-00113463 eligible citizen
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00532-00113464-00113751 is able to vote but we also have to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00533-00113752-00114015 safeguard that vote so that it is not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00534-00114016-00114319 voided or stolen through fraud errors
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00535-00114320-00114599 mistakes or other problems
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00536-00114600-00114839 we do have an obligation to it to ensure
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00537-00114840-00115007 fair and secure elections and that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00538-00115008-00115247 should be a bipartisan goal
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00539-00115248-00115447 regardless of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00540-00115448-00115583 actually with the reason foundation
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00541-00115583-00115902 should be a tripartisan goal
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00542-00115903-00116102 regardless of what political party based
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00543-00116103-00116231 support
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00544-00116232-00116543 the mistake that opponents of election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00545-00116544-00116686 reform make
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00546-00116688-00116910 is that they believe you cannot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00547-00116911-00117158 guarantee both access and security and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00548-00117159-00117302 that is wrong
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00549-00117303-00117583 you can have both and if you talk to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00550-00117583-00117799 members of the public you will find they
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00551-00117800-00118095 want both access and security
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00552-00118096-00118319 now the claim that there's been a wave
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00553-00118320-00118566 of voter suppression going on across the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00554-00118567-00118678 country
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00555-00118679-00118871 for the past decade
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00556-00118872-00119086 that's when these claims first started
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00557-00119088-00119358 this first started in 2005
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00558-00119359-00119575 more than a decade ago when states like
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00559-00119576-00119839 indiana and georgia passed some of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00560-00119840-00119934 first
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00561-00119935-00120371 photo id laws requirements for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00562-00120372-00120847 elections um it's false because the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00563-00120848-00121031 efforts to improve the integrity of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00564-00121032-00121231 election process whether it's requiring
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00565-00121232-00121454 an id and keep in mind
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00566-00121455-00121775 every single state that has put in an id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00567-00121776-00122071 requirement provides a free id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00568-00122072-00122358 to anyone who doesn't already have one
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00569-00122359-00122471 and that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00570-00122472-00122719 one requirement is overwhelmingly
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00571-00122720-00122966 supported by americans
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00572-00122967-00123119 all the polling shows whether it's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00573-00123120-00123390 liberal polls or conservative polls
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00574-00123391-00123590 americans overwhelmingly support that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00575-00123591-00123743 they think it's a common sense
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00576-00123744-00123951 requirement and it doesn't matter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00577-00123952-00124151 what party they support it doesn't
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00578-00124152-00124383 matter what their color or ethnic
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00579-00124383-00124543 background is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00580-00124544-00124886 and it's no doubt because they have to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00581-00124888-00125134 show an id almost every day in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00582-00125135-00125414 everything they do from boarding a plane
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00583-00125415-00125623 to going to the pharmacy to seeing a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00584-00125624-00125878 doctor to cashing a check to buying
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00585-00125879-00125983 alcohol
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00586-00125983-00126110 now
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00587-00126111-00126334 in states that have put in measures like
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00588-00126335-00126623 voter id and keep in mind
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00589-00126624-00126886 what i just said the first voter id laws
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00590-00126888-00127078 in georgia and indiana were in effect in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00591-00127079-00127383 the 2008 election so we've got more than
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00592-00127383-00127671 a decade's worth of data turnout data
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00593-00127672-00127886 from those states to show what it does
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00594-00127888-00128166 not only did turnout not go down
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00595-00128167-00128407 including of minority of voters in those
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00596-00128408-00128639 states in fact it went up
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00597-00128640-00129023 there's also been a steady decrease
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00598-00129024-00129214 in enforcement enforcement actions by
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00599-00129215-00129431 the u.s justice department
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00600-00129432-00129614 okay i used to work there i used to work
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00601-00129615-00129743 in the civil rights division whose
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00602-00129744-00129983 responsibility is enforcing the voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00603-00129983-00130151 rights act
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00604-00130152-00130343 okay the most powerful tool in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00605-00130344-00130623 voting rights act is section two
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00606-00130624-00130910 of the act it's a permanent nationwide
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00607-00130911-00131031 provision
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00608-00131032-00131271 it prohibits racial discrimination and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00609-00131272-00131407 voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00610-00131408-00131647 and you would think obviously that if
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00611-00131648-00131887 there was voter suppression going on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00612-00131888-00132111 that's the term created
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00613-00132112-00132478 by opponents of election reform
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00614-00132479-00132695 the justice department would be busy
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00615-00132696-00132854 filing suits
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00616-00132855-00133071 because the whole point supposedly voter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00617-00133072-00133247 suppression is to keep for example
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00618-00133248-00133599 racial minorities from voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00619-00133600-00133783 the obama administration i'm sure you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00620-00133784-00134014 would agree would not exactly be shy
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00621-00134015-00134199 about using the tools of the justice
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00622-00134200-00134351 department including the voting rights
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00623-00134352-00134431 act
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00624-00134432-00134871 yet in the entire eight years
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00625-00134872-00135166 of the obama administration they only
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00626-00135167-00135399 filed four
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00627-00135400-00135623 enforcement actions under section two of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00628-00135624-00135823 the voting rights act claiming that a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00629-00135824-00136047 state or jurisdiction was engaging in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00630-00136048-00136231 racial discrimination the trump
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00631-00136232-00136495 administration in four years filed too
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00632-00136496-00136727 so basically it was the same rate
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00633-00136728-00136983 uh if there was this huge wave of voter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00634-00136984-00137159 suppression going on and there was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00635-00137160-00137366 actual evidence
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00636-00137367-00137678 that measures like voter id were keeping
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00637-00137679-00137839 people from voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00638-00137840-00138071 lawsuits would have been filed about all
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00639-00138072-00138454 of these
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00640-00138455-00138647 let me make a quick point about georgia
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00641-00138648-00138878 to just give you an example of this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00642-00138879-00139078 georgia passed a voter id law first
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00643-00139079-00139343 effective in the 2008 election a lawsuit
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00644-00139344-00139527 was filed against it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00645-00139528-00139735 the lawsuit was eventually dismissed
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00646-00139736-00139983 with once after one slight change in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00647-00139984-00140199 law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00648-00140200-00140471 the judge in the case
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00649-00140472-00140839 who was a democratic nominee
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00650-00140840-00141031 said that after two years of litigation
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00651-00141032-00141175 the plaintiffs in that case including
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00652-00141176-00141447 the aclu were unable to come up with a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00653-00141448-00141711 single witness who would be unable to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00654-00141712-00141927 vote because of the georgia voter id law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00655-00141928-00142126 and it's been in place ever since and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00656-00142127-00142343 they've seen record registration and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00657-00142344-00142502 turnout in the state in fact in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00658-00142503-00142766 first election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00659-00142767-00143039 this is the official turnout numbers
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00660-00143040-00143278 the turnout of black voters in the state
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00661-00143279-00143671 of georgia in 2008 compared to 2004 when
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00662-00143672-00144023 there was no voter id law in place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00663-00144024-00144439 had a percentage increase of 140 percent
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00664-00144440-00144831 hispanic turnout went up 42
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00665-00144832-00145199 white's turnout went up 8
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00666-00145200-00145454 in 2010
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00667-00145455-00145695 congressional elections barack obama not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00668-00145696-00145911 on the ballot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00669-00145912-00146159 compared to 2006 when there was no voter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00670-00146160-00146543 id in place black turnout went up 66.5
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00671-00146544-00146959 percent hispanic turnout went up over 44
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00672-00146960-00147295 white turnout went up 11 now when i cite
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00673-00147296-00147599 those figures for 2008 about the huge
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00674-00147600-00147783 increase in turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00675-00147784-00147911 in georgia in fact they had record
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00676-00147912-00148143 turnout people say well of course
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00677-00148144-00148335 barack obama was on the ballot that's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00678-00148336-00148583 true we had a big increase in turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00679-00148584-00148919 across the country but in fact
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00680-00148920-00149247 the democratic turnout in 2008
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00681-00149248-00149575 in the general election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00682-00149576-00149719 in georgia
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00683-00149720-00149999 was 6.1 percentage points which was the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00684-00150000-00150366 fifth largest increase in the nation
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00685-00150367-00150599 far above other states like new york
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00686-00150600-00150799 which has no voter id law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00687-00150800-00151014 the overall turnout in the general
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00688-00151015-00151343 election in georgia in the 2008
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00689-00151344-00151471 election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00690-00151472-00151751 it went up 6.7 percentage points over
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00691-00151752-00152014 the prior election the second largest
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00692-00152015-00152263 increase in the country
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00693-00152264-00152535 indiana the same thing happened remember
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00694-00152536-00152654 indiana
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00695-00152655-00152847 put in a voter id law it was in place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00696-00152848-00153199 for the first time in 2008
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00697-00153200-00153459 democratic turnout in the state was up
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00698-00153460-00153807 8.32 percentage points over 2004 when
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00699-00153808-00153966 there was no id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00700-00153967-00154214 that was the largest increase in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00701-00154215-00154414 democratic turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00702-00154415-00154790 in the nation
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00703-00154791-00155023 the whole point of this is that the data
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00704-00155024-00155254 actually shows that all these claims
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00705-00155255-00155447 that voter id is going to keep people
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00706-00155448-00155647 from voting is just not true
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00707-00155648-00155839 don't if you doubt me
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00708-00155840-00156071 google a study two years ago from the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00709-00156072-00156399 national bureau of economic research
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00710-00156400-00156575 they looked at more than a decade's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00711-00156576-00156814 worth of turnout data in all 50 states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00712-00156815-00157047 in the district of columbia
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00713-00157048-00157326 and their conclusion
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00714-00157327-00157519 which i quote is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00715-00157520-00157735 voter id had no negative effect on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00716-00157736-00157975 registration or turnout overall or for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00717-00157976-00158207 any specific group defined by race
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00718-00158208-00158543 gender age or party affiliation
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00719-00158544-00158783 now all the extraordinary claims you've
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00720-00158784-00158959 seen about
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00721-00158960-00159199 georgia texas
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00722-00159200-00159407 doing all these terrible things people
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00723-00159408-00159647 keep people out to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00724-00159648-00159854 let me give an example of what was in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00725-00159855-00160151 the georgia reform that so
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00726-00160152-00160366 outraged uh people in the media and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00727-00160367-00160495 elsewhere
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00728-00160496-00160775 as i said georgia's had a a voter id law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00729-00160776-00160926 in place for in-person voting for more
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00730-00160927-00161126 than a decade they've had no problems
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00731-00161127-00161254 they've had big increases in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00732-00161255-00161439 registration and turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00733-00161440-00161559 so
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00734-00161560-00161702 what happened in the election they had a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00735-00161703-00161926 huge increase in absentee ballots so
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00736-00161927-00162135 they said well look we really ought to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00737-00162136-00162271 extend
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00738-00162272-00162590 the id requirement to absentee ballots
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00739-00162591-00162854 made it extraordinarily easy
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00740-00162855-00163023 to comply
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00741-00163024-00163207 when you reply when you apply for an
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00742-00163208-00163487 absentee ballot you simply wrote in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00743-00163488-00163639 the serial number of your driver's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00744-00163640-00163823 license or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00745-00163824-00164207 the serial number of the free id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00746-00164208-00164390 that they would provide for you and if
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00747-00164391-00164623 you had neither of those
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00748-00164624-00164823 you wrote in the last four digits of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00749-00164824-00165159 your social security number
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00750-00165160-00165495 and if you didn't have any of that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00751-00165496-00165743 you could send in a photocopy of a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00752-00165744-00166087 utility bill bank statement paycheck or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00753-00166088-00166263 any government document with your name
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00754-00166264-00166423 and address on it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00755-00166424-00166623 now if that language sounds familiar it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00756-00166624-00166807 should be because that's a federal
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00757-00166808-00167031 requirement first
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00758-00167032-00167247 put in place in 2002 and to help america
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00759-00167248-00167631 vote act congress passed a law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00760-00167632-00167871 92 senators voted for including the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00761-00167872-00168038 current president
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00762-00168039-00168271 that said the first time you registered
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00763-00168272-00168390 a vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00764-00168391-00168607 if you vote by mail the first time you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00765-00168608-00168719 go vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00766-00168720-00168999 you have to provide either a picture id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00767-00169000-00169102 or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00768-00169103-00169447 a copy of a utility bill bank statement
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00769-00169448-00169663 paycheck or government document that is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00770-00169664-00169926 what supposedly is keeping people out of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00771-00169927-00170159 the polls but we know from the numbers
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00772-00170160-00170511 that's just simply not true
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00773-00170512-00170966 um
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00774-00170967-00171151 the other thing to keep in mind is that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00775-00171152-00171383 many of the other provisions
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00776-00171384-00171559 that people are saying are somehow going
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00777-00171560-00171719 to restrict people to vote when you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00778-00171720-00171863 actually look at the content of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00779-00171864-00172351 bills it's just not the case
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00780-00172352-00172671 one of the things that texas just did
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00781-00172672-00173302 is they said that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00782-00173303-00173526 they are going to put in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00783-00173527-00173790 a requirement in large counties to put
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00784-00173791-00174047 in video surveillance
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00785-00174048-00174383 in the locations where votes are being
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00786-00174384-00174614 counted and tabulated
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00787-00174615-00174790 now does anybody think there's actually
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00788-00174791-00174966 something wrong with that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00789-00174967-00175223 transparency is the heart of having fair
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00790-00175224-00175366 elections
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00791-00175367-00175631 right we want transparency that's why
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00792-00175632-00175878 the u.s state department
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00793-00175879-00176175 sends teams of american observers
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00794-00176176-00176383 to fledgling democracies all over the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00795-00176384-00176519 world
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00796-00176520-00176854 and yet this is being criticized
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00797-00176855-00177014 as somehow going to keep people from
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00798-00177015-00177166 voting that there's going to be video
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00799-00177167-00177326 surveillance to make sure that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00800-00177327-00177447 everything's being done the way it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00801-00177448-00177623 should
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00802-00177624-00177814 they're also criticizing the fact that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00803-00177815-00178111 texas strengthened its laws on election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00804-00178112-00178366 observers
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00805-00178367-00178575 now let's make it clear election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00806-00178576-00178751 observers can do nothing other than
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00807-00178752-00178854 observe
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00808-00178855-00178990 if they interfere with the voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00809-00178991-00179183 process they can be ejected from a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00810-00179184-00179283 polling
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00811-00179284-00179575 place and in fact if they engage in any
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00812-00179576-00179766 kind of intimidation or coercion or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00813-00179767-00179911 pressure they can be criminally
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00814-00179912-00180078 prosecuted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00815-00180079-00180414 but you all saw in the last election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00816-00180415-00180590 observers
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00817-00180591-00180814 being ejected from polling places not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00818-00180815-00181031 because they had engaged in bad behavior
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00819-00181032-00181247 but to apparently
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00820-00181248-00181438 not allow them to see what's going on or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00821-00181439-00181743 you saw them play so far back
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00822-00181744-00181911 that they could not effectively see what
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00823-00181912-00182054 was going on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00824-00182055-00182278 so texas simply has strengthened its law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00825-00182279-00182519 they've made it very clear
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00826-00182520-00182726 observers cannot interfere with the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00827-00182727-00182878 election process they can't interfere
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00828-00182879-00183126 with voters but election officials
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00829-00183127-00183311 cannot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00830-00183312-00183551 simply decide to eject observers out
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00831-00183552-00183702 because they don't want observers there
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00832-00183703-00183878 seeing what they're doing again why
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00833-00183879-00184166 would anybody be against that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00834-00184167-00184423 that is the kind of thing we want we
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00835-00184424-00184766 want observers of all of the parties
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00836-00184767-00184959 whether it's democrats libertarians
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00837-00184960-00185183 republicans to be able to be in polling
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00838-00185184-00185431 places and not allow election officials
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00839-00185432-00185671 to throw them out
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00840-00185672-00185831 another big
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00841-00185832-00186223 claim that has been constantly made
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00842-00186224-00186590 is that uh when when texas and other
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00843-00186591-00186911 states when they ban what's what people
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00844-00186912-00187126 call vote harvesting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00845-00187127-00187350 i call it vote trafficking that that's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00846-00187351-00187543 somehow going to keep people from voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00847-00187544-00187687 what does that mean
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00848-00187688-00187887 look you can vote by absentee ballot in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00849-00187888-00188023 new york
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00850-00188024-00188271 and other states and you can mail your
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00851-00188272-00188478 ballot back depending on the postal
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00852-00188479-00188759 service to get it back for you or you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00853-00188760-00188935 can personally deliver it yourself a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00854-00188936-00189095 member of your family can personally
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00855-00189096-00189326 deliver it a designated caregiver can
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00856-00189327-00189550 personally deliver it but in about half
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00857-00189551-00189678 the states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00858-00189679-00189943 they have a wise policy of banning
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00859-00189944-00190159 third-party strangers from able to come
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00860-00190160-00190343 to your front door
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00861-00190344-00190519 and pick up your ballot and deliver it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00862-00190520-00190766 why is that a good policy do you really
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00863-00190767-00191111 think it's a good idea for candidates
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00864-00191112-00191423 campaign activists
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00865-00191424-00191575 party uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00866-00191576-00191902 volunteers and political guns for hire
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00867-00191903-00192207 to be able to go to voters homes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00868-00192208-00192399 and pick up their ballots that does two
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00869-00192400-00192590 things one it puts them in a position to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00870-00192591-00192863 pressure and coerce voters
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00871-00192864-00193071 which has been a problem in texas
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00872-00193072-00193271 they've had
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00873-00193272-00193543 numerous prosecutions there of that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00874-00193544-00193959 but it also puts them in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00875-00193960-00194126 it gives them the ability to handle
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00876-00194127-00194375 something very valuable to them all of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00877-00194376-00194550 those individuals have a stake in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00878-00194551-00194759 outcome of the election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00879-00194760-00195007 and yet you're giving them ballots
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00880-00195008-00195207 which means that they could potentially
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00881-00195208-00195423 alter or change them which is what
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00882-00195424-00195614 happened in the ninth congressional
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00883-00195615-00196014 district in north carolina in 2018.
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00884-00196015-00196175 that's why more than half a dozen
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00885-00196176-00196359 individuals there were
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00886-00196360-00196502 arrested
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00887-00196503-00196711 because they were collecting absentee
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00888-00196712-00196926 ballots they were in some cases filling
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00889-00196927-00197143 them out altering the choices made by
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00890-00197144-00197495 voters signing them
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00891-00197496-00197719 and the election was overturned one
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00892-00197720-00198007 minute because of that fortunately
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00893-00198008-00198254 um i'm not saying that there is massive
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00894-00198255-00198447 voter fraud in the united states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00895-00198448-00198607 but there's enough that we should be
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00896-00198608-00198823 concerned about it and that's not just
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00897-00198824-00199054 me saying it it's the u.s supreme court
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00898-00199055-00199166 saying that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00899-00199167-00199711 in 2008 when they upheld
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00900-00199712-00199943 indiana's voter id law and what the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00901-00199944-00200263 supreme court said is that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00902-00200264-00200375 there have been
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00903-00200376-00200599 flagrant examples of such fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00904-00200600-00200823 throughout our history
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00905-00200824-00201150 documented by historians and journalists
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00906-00201151-00201319 and it could make the difference in a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00907-00201320-00201487 close election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00908-00201488-00201743 and we have close elections all the time
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00909-00201744-00202047 in this country like
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00910-00202048-00202183 the compton
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00911-00202184-00202383 case that was just mentioned
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00912-00202384-00202647 where half a dozen individuals have been
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00913-00202648-00202878 indicted criminally indicted for using
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00914-00202879-00203150 absentee ballots to apparently steal a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00915-00203151-00203423 city council election this june
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00916-00203424-00203647 including a city council member who they
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00917-00203648-00203895 wanted to make sure got elected who won
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00918-00203896-00203983 by
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00919-00203984-00204111 one vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00920-00204112-00204293 thanks
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00921-00204294-00204783 [Applause]
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00922-00204784-00204990 uh thank you hands and uh five minutes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00923-00204991-00205175 for rebuttal ellen you can take the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00924-00205176-00205710 podium if you'd like yeah
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00925-00205711-00205966 thanks and i absolutely agree that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00926-00205967-00206166 voting access and the security of our
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00927-00206167-00206446 elections are not mutually exclusive
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00928-00206448-00206679 that's why we encourage policies like
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00929-00206680-00206903 automatic voter registration where
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00930-00206904-00207103 voters automatically get registered when
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00931-00207104-00207342 they interact with the dmv for example
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00932-00207344-00207510 unless they opt out
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00933-00207511-00207694 that has been shown to increase
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00934-00207696-00207886 registration numbers in all in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00935-00207887-00208134 states that has it has been implemented
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00936-00208135-00208358 and it simultaneously keeps our voter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00937-00208359-00208551 roles accurate because people's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00938-00208552-00208742 addresses are updated when they interact
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00939-00208744-00208903 with those
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00940-00208904-00209055 voter registration and government
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00941-00209056-00209310 agencies so that our voter rolls are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00942-00209311-00209462 accurate and clean
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00943-00209463-00209655 those are not the kinds of policies that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00944-00209656-00209910 are being introduced and enacted this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00945-00209911-00210006 year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00946-00210007-00210239 we heard a lot about voter id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00947-00210240-00210431 but we didn't hear a lot about all of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00948-00210432-00210646 the very many policies that make it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00949-00210648-00210831 harder to vote by mail and then make it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00950-00210832-00211127 harder to vote early those policies that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00951-00211128-00211239 that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00952-00211240-00211463 increase voting methods and make voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00953-00211464-00211623 more convenient that have been
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00954-00211623-00211982 conclusively shown to increase turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00955-00211983-00212158 those policies that voters took
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00956-00212159-00212398 advantage of in unprecedented numbers
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00957-00212400-00212510 last year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00958-00212511-00212703 those are precisely the methods of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00959-00212704-00212967 voting that have been attacked by new
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00960-00212967-00213191 laws this year by shortening early
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00961-00213192-00213423 voting periods by making it harder to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00962-00213423-00213671 drop off ballots by making it harder to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00963-00213671-00213951 obtain an absentee ballot by prohibiting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00964-00213952-00214119 election officials from sending out
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00965-00214119-00214398 applications
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00966-00214400-00214542 i think it's worth it particularly
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00967-00214544-00214887 touching on texas and the um example of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00968-00214888-00215151 um the ex strength the quote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00969-00215152-00215375 strengthening of laws on election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00970-00215376-00215503 observers
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00971-00215504-00215679 one of the other things that the texas
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00972-00215680-00216023 law did was criminally prohibit the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00973-00216023-00216319 removal of a poll watcher
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00974-00216319-00216487 unless
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00975-00216488-00216719 an election judge which is a local local
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00976-00216719-00216903 poll worker election official working in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00977-00216904-00217087 a polling place in texas
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00978-00217088-00217358 personally observes that that watcher
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00979-00217359-00217558 violated texas law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00980-00217559-00217767 that means that a dozen voters can
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00981-00217767-00217982 report to an election judge working the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00982-00217983-00218167 polling place that they have been
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00983-00218167-00218375 intimidated by that by a particular
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00984-00218376-00218487 watcher
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00985-00218488-00218694 and that election judge still cannot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00986-00218696-00218863 remove that watcher
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00987-00218864-00219023 without risking
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00988-00219023-00219503 felony prosecution
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00989-00219504-00219663 i also want to note that we heard we
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00990-00219664-00219839 heard a bit about vote harvesting and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00991-00219840-00220158 the risks there but just like the risk
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00992-00220159-00220398 of election fraud for voting in person
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00993-00220400-00220623 the risk of committing male
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00994-00220623-00220903 ballot fraud is still more rare than
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00995-00220904-00221134 being struck by lightning
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00996-00221135-00221279 and turning
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00997-00221280-00221591 again to voter id it's true that that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00998-00221592-00221823 states typically provide those ids for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-00999-00221823-00222127 free um and i have a job many of you may
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01000-00222128-00222334 have jobs where you can run out on your
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01001-00222335-00222631 lunch break and go to the dmv and get a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01002-00222632-00222782 new license if you've moved to a new
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01003-00222783-00222942 state or get a license for the first
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01004-00222944-00223110 time
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01005-00223111-00223334 but but time isn't free and for many
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01006-00223335-00223567 americans they don't have the ability to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01007-00223567-00223934 do that so if you don't have that time
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01008-00223935-00224134 if you don't have the accessibility to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01009-00224135-00224406 get to a dmv or another government
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01010-00224407-00224655 agency if you are a voter with a dis if
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01011-00224656-00224871 you are an american with a disability if
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01012-00224871-00225006 you are a person with limited
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01013-00225007-00225191 transportation access
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01014-00225192-00225487 actually obtaining that identification
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01015-00225488-00225719 is difficult even if financially it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01016-00225719-00225975 doesn't come at a cost to you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01017-00225976-00226175 likewise we heard about the georgia law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01018-00226176-00226471 which requires somebody to submit a copy
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01019-00226471-00226663 of a utility bill if they don't have an
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01020-00226664-00226903 id number of course that requires
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01021-00226904-00227039 somebody to have access to a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01022-00227040-00227294 photocopying machine and a printer
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01023-00227296-00227519 many of us may have that many of us may
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01024-00227519-00227679 have gained access to that as we've been
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01025-00227680-00227839 working from home over the course of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01026-00227840-00228134 last 18 months but for many georgians
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01027-00228135-00228431 that may very well not be accessible so
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01028-00228432-00228710 these are policies that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01029-00228711-00228863 many of which have been
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01030-00228864-00229046 policies like restricting mail voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01031-00229048-00229246 restricting early voting that have been
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01032-00229248-00229479 shown to decrease turnout and to the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01033-00229480-00229663 extent that these policies don't
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01034-00229664-00229958 decrease overall turnout we've seen that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01035-00229959-00230151 they disproportionately burden certain
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01036-00230152-00230310 voters who
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01037-00230311-00230606 who rely on methods like mail voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01038-00230607-00230823 if you're a voter with disabilities who
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01039-00230823-00231087 don't have access to be able to run over
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01040-00231088-00231319 to a government agency
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01041-00231319-00231742 i've got the one minute
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01042-00231744-00231967 and or who don't have access to a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01043-00231967-00232134 printer
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01044-00232135-00232439 what is clear is that states even even
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01045-00232440-00232606 in instances where they are not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01046-00232607-00232863 successful at decreasing voter turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01047-00232864-00233071 or registration
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01048-00233071-00233239 are trying to make it harder for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01049-00233240-00233479 americans to vote and they have told us
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01050-00233480-00233703 that time and time again
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01051-00233704-00233967 it's important that we push back on that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01052-00233967-00234134 and realize that these lawmakers should
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01053-00234135-00234334 be trying to make it easier for eligible
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01054-00234335-00234591 americans to to vote rather than trying
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01055-00234592-00234871 to find ways to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01056-00234871-00235119 go after voting access in death by a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01057-00235119-00235358 thousand cuts making small changes over
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01058-00235359-00235558 the course of an election code that make
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01059-00235559-00235782 it harder overall for voters to overcome
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01060-00235783-00236015 those burdens burdens that americans
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01061-00236016-00236167 eligible americans shouldn't have to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01062-00236167-00236382 overcome to exercise their fundamental
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01063-00236383-00236534 right to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01064-00236535-00236710 thank
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01065-00236711-00236958 all you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01066-00236959-00237575 five minutes for you for rebuttal hans
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01067-00237576-00237742 i really need an hour for rebuttal but
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01068-00237744-00238158 i'll try to do it in five minutes um
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01069-00238159-00238310 a couple things first of all there was a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01070-00238311-00238479 mention of the heritage
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01071-00238480-00238646 election fraud database it has an
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01072-00238648-00238903 important caveat yeah it's got over uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01073-00238904-00239255 1300 proven cases of fraud and by proven
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01074-00239256-00239455 i mean somebody was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01075-00239456-00239655 convicted in a court of law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01076-00239656-00239894 or a judge or a state agency ordered a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01077-00239896-00240031 new election like happened in north
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01078-00240032-00240263 carolina in 2018 because of the absentee
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01079-00240264-00240423 ballot fraud there
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01080-00240423-00240646 it is just a sampling of cases there's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01081-00240648-00240871 no central database for this you want to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01082-00240871-00241071 find these often small cases you got to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01083-00241071-00241191 go to every
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01084-00241192-00241351 county courthouse in the country we
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01085-00241352-00241494 don't have the resources to do that and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01086-00241496-00241655 we very carefully say it's just a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01087-00241656-00241879 sampling of cases but you want to know
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01088-00241880-00242127 how much bigger this problem potentially
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01089-00242128-00242215 is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01090-00242216-00242510 i'll give you a quick uh example of this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01091-00242511-00242630 uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01092-00242631-00242742 there's an organization called the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01093-00242744-00242942 public interest legal foundation it's a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01094-00242944-00243071 non-profit
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01095-00243071-00243294 and they did something that nobody else
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01096-00243296-00243591 really has done they obtained
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01097-00243592-00243791 and bought in some cases the voter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01098-00243792-00244055 registration lists of 42 states and the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01099-00244056-00244310 voter histories from 42 states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01100-00244311-00244479 now a lot of that information
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01101-00244480-00244639 unfortunately in voter registration
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01102-00244640-00244879 databases is pretty sparse
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01103-00244880-00245206 so they supplemented their database with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01104-00245207-00245430 commercial data
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01105-00245431-00245663 particularly from credit agencies
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01106-00245664-00245903 you all would be scared if you knew how
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01107-00245904-00246087 much information credit agencies have on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01108-00246088-00246175 you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01109-00246176-00246423 the point of that was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01110-00246423-00246663 they used the credit agency data to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01111-00246664-00246958 obtain unique identifiers on each
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01112-00246959-00247239 registered voter in each state
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01113-00247240-00247503 that way when they compared the lists
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01114-00247504-00247758 they would know whether the john smith
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01115-00247759-00247903 born on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01116-00247904-00248087 march 11th
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01117-00248088-00248351 in georgia was the same or a different
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01118-00248352-00248527 john smith
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01119-00248528-00248751 born on march 11 born
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01120-00248752-00248982 registered in alabama
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01121-00248983-00249230 then they compared the data so they were
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01122-00249231-00249551 not getting false positives as other
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01123-00249552-00249758 people who have tried to done this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01124-00249759-00249958 done they released the report last year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01125-00249959-00250087 it's called critical conditions you can
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01126-00250088-00250334 find it on their website they found over
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01127-00250335-00250567 144
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01128-00250567-00250919 000 potential cases of fraud arising out
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01129-00250919-00251246 of the 2016 and 2018 election let me
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01130-00251248-00251406 give you a quick summary of some of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01131-00251407-00251542 these
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01132-00251544-00251934 they found 8 300 people who voted who
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01133-00251935-00252103 were registered and voted in two
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01134-00252104-00252319 different states during the 2018
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01135-00252319-00252567 election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01136-00252567-00252710 they found
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01137-00252711-00252998 almost 8 000 deceased individuals who
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01138-00253000-00253239 the state said voted in the 2016
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01139-00253240-00253551 election and almost 7 000 who voted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01140-00253552-00254030 in the 2018. that's our 2018 election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01141-00254031-00254406 they found over 43 000 individuals who
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01142-00254407-00254598 are registered more than once at the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01143-00254600-00254871 same address in the same state and voted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01144-00254871-00255158 twice in the 2016 election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01145-00255159-00255239 and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01146-00255240-00255503 38 000 people registered more than once
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01147-00255504-00255710 at the same address who cast two votes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01148-00255711-00255919 in the 2018 election now you might
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01149-00255919-00256094 wonder how that can happen that's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01150-00256096-00256279 because election officials aren't very
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01151-00256280-00256463 good
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01152-00256464-00256767 at realizing that somebody whose name is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01153-00256767-00256927 slightly expelled with a slight
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01154-00256928-00257191 discrepancy is actually the same person
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01155-00257192-00257375 and these individuals were able to take
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01156-00257376-00257687 advantage of that to vote twice
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01157-00257688-00257839 they found
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01158-00257840-00258127 uh 5500 individuals registered at two
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01159-00258128-00258503 different addresses in the same state
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01160-00258504-00258782 who voted twice in the 2018 election and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01161-00258783-00259082 they found 34 000
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01162-00259083-00259398 individuals who voted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01163-00259400-00259646 in the 2018 election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01164-00259648-00259815 who were you remember you're supposed to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01165-00259816-00260079 be registered where you live right
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01166-00260080-00260334 and they found them registered at
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01167-00260335-00260615 everything from a commercial addresses
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01168-00260616-00260951 such as gas stations casinos
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01169-00260952-00261327 they found vacant lots they found a mine
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01170-00261328-00261510 in nevada it's just one thing after
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01171-00261511-00261687 another like that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01172-00261688-00262006 now the point of this is that our system
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01173-00262007-00262206 unfortunately is not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01174-00262207-00262406 very good in catching things like that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01175-00262407-00262575 election officials aren't very good at
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01176-00262576-00262830 it either this report's been out since
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01177-00262831-00263175 last year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01178-00263176-00263479 not a single election official in any of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01179-00263480-00263727 the 42 states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01180-00263728-00263910 contacted the public interest legal
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01181-00263911-00264134 foundation and said can you send us the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01182-00264135-00264375 data you've got on people in our states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01183-00264376-00264543 so that we can investigate this and see
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01184-00264544-00264782 if this is valid not a single law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01185-00264783-00265030 enforcement official
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01186-00265031-00265295 in any of those states contacted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01187-00265296-00265534 them to say can you send us information
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01188-00265535-00265743 so we can investigate it and see if this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01189-00265744-00265927 is correct
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01190-00265928-00266110 which shows you something that i've
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01191-00266111-00266303 encountered now for over 20 years
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01192-00266304-00266439 including when i was at the justice
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01193-00266440-00266727 department which is that unfortunately
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01194-00266728-00266943 a lot of prosecutors is not a priority
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01195-00266944-00267047 for them
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01196-00267048-00267271 when they are working on murders and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01197-00267272-00267495 rapes and bank robberies they just don't
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01198-00267496-00267719 think this is very important
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01199-00267720-00267887 time's out yeah okay
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01200-00267888-00268782 so 30 seconds thanks okay
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01201-00268783-00269110 well we now get to the q a portion of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01202-00269111-00269399 the evening we have a microphone just on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01203-00269400-00269758 that side for people to line up and ask
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01204-00269759-00269910 questions
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01205-00269911-00270175 we the format also includes the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01206-00270176-00270439 opportunity for each of you to ask the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01207-00270440-00270710 other question at any time
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01208-00270711-00270999 eliza and hans would you pick up those
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01209-00271000-00271206 mics and make sure that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01210-00271207-00271471 you speak clearly into them
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01211-00271472-00271639 and i
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01212-00271640-00271887 want to ask you eliza would you like to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01213-00271888-00272255 put a question to hands at this point
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01214-00272256-00272382 i would love to hear first from the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01215-00272383-00272599 audience okay folks have questions all
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01216-00272600-00272799 right uh and uh hands would you like to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01217-00272800-00272991 put maybe our only agreement of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01218-00272992-00273206 evening
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01219-00273207-00273463 i'm gonna i'm gonna start uh with a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01220-00273464-00273758 moderator's prerogative uh ask a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01221-00273759-00274087 question uh eliza i take it uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01222-00274088-00274327 just to verify something in this case i
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01223-00274328-00274639 take it you believe that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01224-00274640-00275030 the idea of providing identification
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01225-00275031-00275263 as with a driver's license or passport
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01226-00275264-00275399 or whatever
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01227-00275400-00275663 should not apply because it is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01228-00275664-00275879 discriminatory against people of limited
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01229-00275880-00276223 means and time who cannot so provide
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01230-00276224-00276543 do i have that correct in your case
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01231-00276544-00276695 well you should correct me if i'm
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01232-00276696-00276879 misunderstanding the question but i
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01233-00276880-00277134 think
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01234-00277135-00277367 voter id laws are not created equally
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01235-00277368-00277647 across the country some of them are in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01236-00277648-00277855 fact discriminatory and have been found
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01237-00277856-00278143 to be discriminatory like the 2013 law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01238-00278144-00278375 that i mentioned out of north carolina
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01239-00278376-00278575 like a law out of texas
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01240-00278576-00278782 that was challenged and the fifth
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01241-00278783-00278991 circuit found to be discriminatory and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01242-00278992-00279247 the texas legislature amended the law as
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01243-00279248-00279455 a result
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01244-00279456-00279630 i see okay so you're opposed to those
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01245-00279631-00279887 particular voter id laws but not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01246-00279888-00280151 necessarily is there a particular
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01247-00280152-00280455 voter right kind of a voter id law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01248-00280456-00280719 requiring proof of identification that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01249-00280720-00280927 you would accept and support
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01250-00280928-00281071 i think it really depends on the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01251-00281072-00281303 circumstances of that law what the law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01252-00281304-00281519 provides what it enables what the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01253-00281520-00281830 communities in the state have access to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01254-00281831-00282063 and that's not something that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01255-00282064-00282230 one can answer in hypothetical
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01256-00282231-00282406 empirically is there any
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01257-00282407-00282647 voter id law in any state in any area
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01258-00282648-00282967 that you say is fine and empirically
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01259-00282968-00283151 is it any are any of them fine i would
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01260-00283152-00283295 have to take a look at the particular
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01261-00283296-00283495 laws all right uh can you comment on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01262-00283496-00283791 that hands on uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01263-00283792-00284039 uh i'm not sure there's any voter id law
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01264-00284040-00284310 passing any state hasn't been attacked
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01265-00284311-00284463 by various groups claiming it's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01266-00284464-00284663 discriminatory they
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01267-00284664-00284871 have in the past claimed every
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01268-00284872-00285087 voter id law is discriminatory what you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01269-00285088-00285254 all don't know because if you read the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01270-00285255-00285510 new york times you wouldn't realize this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01271-00285511-00285806 but the overwhelming majority of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01272-00285807-00286079 lawsuits filed against state id laws
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01273-00286080-00286223 have lost
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01274-00286224-00286534 okay there's been one or two wins
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01275-00286535-00286775 a handful of wins but the overwhelming
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01276-00286776-00287143 majority of them have lost because
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01277-00287144-00287399 when it came to actually showing that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01278-00287400-00287623 there's somebody in the state that can't
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01279-00287624-00287815 comply with it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01280-00287816-00287967 they've been unable to do that that was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01281-00287968-00288215 certainly the case in the georgia
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01282-00288216-00288463 lawsuit that was the case in the indiana
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01283-00288464-00288758 lawsuit where the the judges noted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01284-00288759-00289087 in their opinions you can go find this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01285-00289088-00289254 that the planners couldn't produce
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01286-00289255-00289519 anyone who would uh be unable to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01287-00289520-00289687 because the id requirement and if you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01288-00289688-00290030 think that's discriminatory
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01289-00290031-00290175 then obviously
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01290-00290176-00290399 groups here need to be suing the state
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01291-00290400-00290575 of new york and the city of new york
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01292-00290576-00290782 because i before i came up here i
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01293-00290783-00290975 checked the websites
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01294-00290976-00291158 and if you want to get a marriage
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01295-00291159-00291487 license in new york state
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01296-00291488-00291775 you need to prove who you are with a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01297-00291776-00292054 driver's license passport
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01298-00292055-00292303 employment picture id or an immigration
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01299-00292304-00292415 record
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01300-00292416-00292719 okay
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01301-00292720-00292879 that's the kind of id requirement what
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01302-00292880-00293095 you need there the new york office of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01303-00293096-00293327 temporary and disability assistance they
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01304-00293328-00293558 have a question on the website says
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01305-00293559-00293895 what proof may i need to provide to get
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01306-00293896-00294103 public assistance
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01307-00294104-00294310 well in order to prove who you are they
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01308-00294311-00294599 have the list three things
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01309-00294600-00294951 a photo id a driver's license or a us
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01310-00294952-00295063 passport
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01311-00295064-00295279 so the idea that this is somehow a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01312-00295280-00295375 problem
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01313-00295376-00295630 is just not the case and for any and in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01314-00295631-00295751 fact
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01315-00295752-00296206 i i i will say this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01316-00296207-00296487 i think it is patronizingly racist to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01317-00296488-00296751 believe that minority voters cannot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01318-00296752-00297039 obtain a free id and if you want to see
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01319-00297040-00297334 an extraordinary statement on this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01320-00297335-00297591 look up the testimony of the lieutenant
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01321-00297592-00297958 governor of north carolina mark robinson
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01322-00297959-00298182 first african-american elected
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01323-00298183-00298334 lieutenant governor the state of north
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01324-00298335-00298551 carolina who testified in april before
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01325-00298552-00298654 the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01326-00298655-00298895 house judiciary committee
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01327-00298896-00299271 and gave an extraordinary uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01328-00299272-00299606 testimony about this and saying
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01329-00299607-00299847 i'll just give you one quote from it the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01330-00299848-00300063 notion that people must be protected
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01331-00300064-00300351 from a free id to secure their votes is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01332-00300352-00300695 not just insane it is insulting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01333-00300696-00300958 thank you hans uh okay uh audience
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01334-00300959-00301199 questions uh please no need to identify
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01335-00301200-00301406 yourself and please state your question
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01336-00301407-00301599 as a question and tell us to whom it's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01337-00301600-00301695 addressed
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01338-00301696-00301934 take it away i have a factual question
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01339-00301935-00302175 uh for for either one of you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01340-00302176-00302343 when they have mail-in ballots or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01341-00302344-00302534 absentee ballots
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01342-00302535-00302679 i i vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01343-00302680-00303110 in person do they ever compare to see if
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01344-00303111-00303327 they're been double voting under the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01345-00303328-00303479 same name
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01346-00303480-00303734 yes they do that's what e poll books are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01347-00303735-00303999 in polling places and that will indicate
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01348-00304000-00304239 when somebody has already voted by mail
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01349-00304240-00304454 or has requested a mail ballot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01350-00304455-00304663 on the polling book
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01351-00304664-00304951 so when you check in to vote in person
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01352-00304952-00305230 the polling the election workers will
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01353-00305231-00305543 know that and if they see that in many
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01354-00305544-00305719 states if they see that you have in fact
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01355-00305720-00305903 voted already by mail or you've
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01356-00305904-00306119 requested a mail ballot they will ask
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01357-00306120-00306310 you to vote provisionally which means
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01358-00306311-00306503 you get to submit a ballot but it won't
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01359-00306504-00306695 count if you've already voted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01360-00306696-00306871 uh comment from you han
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01361-00306872-00307119 just just keep in mind the effectiveness
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01362-00307120-00307319 effectiveness of that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01363-00307320-00307503 catching somebody who's trying to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01364-00307504-00307639 twice like that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01365-00307640-00307830 depends on the efficiency of election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01366-00307831-00307951 officials
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01367-00307952-00308230 okay and in fact i think it was last
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01368-00308231-00308375 year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01369-00308376-00308543 the secretary of state of georgia
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01370-00308544-00308734 actually forwarded the names of a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01371-00308735-00308934 thousand individuals
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01372-00308935-00309134 to the attorney general's office there
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01373-00309135-00309334 because they discovered after the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01374-00309335-00309503 election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01375-00309504-00309639 that those individuals
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01376-00309640-00309854 had voted twice they had voted with an
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01377-00309855-00310047 absentee ballot in the primary election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01378-00310048-00310239 not the general election they had voted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01379-00310240-00310567 twice um in person and with the absentee
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01380-00310568-00310775 ballot and the only way that could have
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01381-00310776-00310910 happened was because the election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01382-00310911-00311182 officials in the polling place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01383-00311183-00311391 didn't catch the fact that an absentee
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01384-00311392-00311591 ballot had already been submitted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01385-00311592-00311799 next question
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01386-00311800-00311999 i grew up partly in europe and i'm
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01387-00312000-00312223 struck by the fact that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01388-00312224-00312479 there are 47 countries in europe
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01389-00312480-00312687 and as of this month every single one
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01390-00312688-00312943 requires an id at the polls i'm just
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01391-00312944-00313079 wondering why
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01392-00313080-00313287 and i also note that in canada in two
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01393-00313288-00313399 weeks they're all going to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01394-00313400-00313543 nationally
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01395-00313544-00313823 and even if you file a mail-in ballot or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01396-00313824-00313975 you vote anywhere in canada you're going
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01397-00313976-00314151 to have to prove your identity is that a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01398-00314152-00314382 question and canada well i'm just asking
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01399-00314383-00314582 since canada is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01400-00314583-00314734 ranking much higher than the united
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01401-00314735-00315047 states by the u.n human rights records
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01402-00315048-00315247 why in the world are the canadians so
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01403-00315248-00315423 obnoxious about
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01404-00315424-00315599 these issues of voting who is that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01405-00315600-00315943 question addressed mr fund to both okay
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01406-00315944-00316134 either of you want to take it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01407-00316135-00316399 well i also point out that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01408-00316400-00316558 mexico
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01409-00316559-00316854 which is a country with a much greater
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01410-00316855-00316943 uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01411-00316944-00317134 rate of poverty than we do actually i
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01412-00317135-00317319 think in the 1990s
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01413-00317320-00317551 put in a requirement for people to have
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01414-00317552-00317791 a photo id when they go vote and a lot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01415-00317792-00318023 of people credit
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01416-00318024-00318382 their implementation of that id uh with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01417-00318383-00318591 the fact that the opposition party won
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01418-00318592-00318823 for the first time in decades
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01419-00318824-00319039 uh and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01420-00319040-00319254 we we are just kind of an outlier in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01421-00319255-00319471 fact that we don't require id and i will
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01422-00319472-00319671 just tell you one one quick story if i
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01423-00319672-00319782 may about this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01424-00319783-00320103 every election you all probably know the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01425-00320104-00320199 um
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01426-00320200-00320279 uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01427-00320280-00320503 european union sends election observers
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01428-00320504-00320663 actually to the united states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01429-00320664-00320871 to observe our elections and for the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01430-00320872-00321071 past
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01431-00321072-00321295 oh more than a decade i've been one of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01432-00321296-00321551 the individuals asked to brief
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01433-00321552-00321806 um the observers on how the election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01434-00321807-00321982 process works in the u.s et cetera and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01435-00321983-00322215 i'm usually on a panel
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01436-00322216-00322334 with folks
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01437-00322335-00322591 like from the asu aclu and others who
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01438-00322592-00322830 are sitting there talking about
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01439-00322831-00323134 voter id and how terrible it is and the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01440-00323135-00323343 reaction of the observers is always like
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01441-00323344-00323543 they don't really understand why that's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01442-00323544-00323751 an issue because in every single one of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01443-00323752-00323958 their countries they have to show an id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01444-00323959-00324071 to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01445-00324072-00324375 comment from you uh elijah yes well
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01446-00324376-00324495 certainly i'm not going to comment on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01447-00324496-00324799 the character of canadians um but
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01448-00324800-00325054 but one thing i will note again
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01449-00325055-00325310 is that voter id has not been shown to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01450-00325311-00325687 be correlated with preventing fraud or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01451-00325688-00325887 the lack of voter id requirements has
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01452-00325888-00326071 not been correlated
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01453-00326072-00326334 or shown to have any relationship to the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01454-00326335-00326630 existence or presence of fraud and we
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01455-00326631-00326782 live in a country where we don't
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01456-00326783-00327063 automatically provide national id's to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01457-00327064-00327287 people so there is a big difference in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01458-00327288-00327463 terms of the international context that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01459-00327464-00327599 we're operating
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01460-00327600-00327847 and i think given those things you have
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01461-00327848-00328127 to wonder why are states trying to put
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01462-00328128-00328430 voter id laws in place if we don't have
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01463-00328431-00328615 data showing that it's helping our
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01464-00328616-00328854 election integrity and people have to go
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01465-00328855-00329071 out and affirmatively get id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01466-00329072-00329358 and in another example of uh somebody
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01467-00329359-00329639 saying the quiet part out loud and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01468-00329640-00329887 this is you know back in 2011
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01469-00329888-00330063 pennsylvania's then republican house
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01470-00330064-00330303 leader um said that the state's new id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01471-00330304-00330503 law which was in fact struck down by the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01472-00330504-00330727 pennsylvania supreme court was going to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01473-00330728-00330919 quote allow governor romney to win the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01474-00330920-00331110 state of pennsylvania so these are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01475-00331111-00331295 provisions that are being put in place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01476-00331296-00331519 specifically to make it harder to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01477-00331520-00331687 without the data to show that they
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01478-00331688-00331967 actually improve our elections
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01479-00331968-00332295 um maybe you'll respond i see hans
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01480-00332296-00332406 shaking his head so i'll give him a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01481-00332407-00332623 chance to shake his head verbally and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01482-00332624-00332847 then you can respond go ahead yes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01483-00332848-00332967 uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01484-00332968-00333230 i wrote a paper ten years ago i'd urge
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01485-00333231-00333478 you all to read it it's called stolen
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01486-00333479-00333710 identities stolen votes a case study and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01487-00333711-00333871 voter impersonation do you all remember
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01488-00333872-00334039 elizabeth holtzman
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01489-00334040-00334239 former democratic congresswoman right
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01490-00334240-00334399 and she became the district attorney in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01491-00334400-00334758 kings county when she came back right
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01492-00334759-00335110 in the mid-1980s she convened a state
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01493-00335111-00335375 grand jury and she released the report
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01494-00335376-00335510 of the grand jury
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01495-00335511-00335703 most of you know grandeur usually
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01496-00335704-00335854 operate in secret so it was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01497-00335855-00336039 extraordinary that she released this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01498-00336040-00336158 public
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01499-00336159-00336310 report of the grand jury let me tell you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01500-00336311-00336551 what the grand jury found in kings
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01501-00336552-00336710 county brooklyn
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01502-00336711-00337110 she found that for 14 years
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01503-00337111-00337382 a voter fraud conspiracy had occurred in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01504-00337383-00337599 kings county
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01505-00337600-00337895 successfully without detection
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01506-00337896-00338239 in which
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01507-00338240-00338471 the practices included the forgery of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01508-00338472-00338703 voter registration cards with the names
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01509-00338704-00338943 of fictitious persons the filing of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01510-00338944-00339191 those cards with the board of elections
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01511-00339192-00339399 the recruitment of people to cast
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01512-00339400-00339695 multiple votes on behalf of specified
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01513-00339696-00340047 candidates using those forged names as
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01514-00340048-00340199 well as
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01515-00340200-00340478 the registrations of deceased
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01516-00340479-00340678 and other persons and your point hands
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01517-00340679-00340863 is that as that voter id could have
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01518-00340864-00340967 dealt with that is that what you're
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01519-00340968-00341175 saying the grand jury recommended at the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01520-00341176-00341439 end of it that the state should
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01521-00341440-00341663 consider putting in an id requirement
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01522-00341664-00341839 because that could have potentially
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01523-00341840-00341982 prevented i'm sure you've read that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01524-00341983-00342206 paper eliza and i'm sure you know what
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01525-00342207-00342423 the problem is with it could you tell us
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01526-00342424-00342599 yeah
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01527-00342600-00342727 i i
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01528-00342728-00342934 can see that i have not read the paper
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01529-00342935-00343063 recently
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01530-00343064-00343295 but again i would say that the data is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01531-00343296-00343495 not there to back up the efficacy of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01532-00343496-00343734 voter id with respect to voter fraud the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01533-00343735-00343927 data is there to show that these
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01534-00343928-00344230 instances are extraordinarily rare
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01535-00344231-00344478 and again i i would urge you to do a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01536-00344479-00344671 cost-benefit analysis
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01537-00344672-00344958 of the costs and burdens on voters when
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01538-00344959-00345215 you impose restrictions and the benefit
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01539-00345216-00345447 that you get out of them
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01540-00345448-00345663 and i also want to make sure folks are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01541-00345664-00345847 thinking not just about voter id that's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01542-00345848-00346006 not the only kind of restriction that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01543-00346007-00346199 states are putting in place this year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01544-00346200-00346430 once again they are making it harder to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01545-00346431-00346654 vote by mail making harder to drop off
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01546-00346655-00346927 your mail ballot shortening early voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01547-00346928-00347182 periods making it harder to throw out
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01548-00347183-00347447 intimidating poll watchers from from a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01549-00347448-00347582 polling place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01550-00347583-00347847 there is a wide range of restrictions
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01551-00347848-00348071 that states are enacting this year and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01552-00348072-00348287 it's quite clear what the overall trend
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01553-00348288-00348430 shows
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01554-00348431-00348678 uh next question
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01555-00348679-00348806 i got something i've been wondering
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01556-00348807-00349158 about that maybe you can help me with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01557-00349159-00349343 either or both of you there's a large
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01558-00349344-00349519 number of people in this country quite
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01559-00349520-00349703 remarkably large like in the millions
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01560-00349704-00349927 who are completely mentally incapable of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01561-00349928-00350119 voting and i'm talking about people with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01562-00350120-00350254 alzheimer's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01563-00350255-00350447 and people with what's called
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01564-00350448-00350630 developmental disabilities used to be
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01565-00350631-00350878 called mentally but put the two
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01566-00350879-00351006 of them together it's in the millions
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01567-00351007-00351215 first of all as far as i know they're
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01568-00351216-00351399 entitled to vote if they're over 21
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01569-00351400-00351671 maybe you can uh answer that for me and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01570-00351672-00351871 and my second question is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01571-00351872-00352110 if you if you take like the people with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01572-00352111-00352327 alzheimer's or tend to be in nursing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01573-00352328-00352582 homes and they're probably registered to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01574-00352583-00352782 vote because they were once capable of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01575-00352783-00352999 voting what's to keep the person who
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01576-00353000-00353199 runs the nursing home or their their
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01577-00353200-00353358 friendly
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01578-00353359-00353558 political operative from rounding up
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01579-00353559-00353703 ballots from all those people filling
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01580-00353704-00353919 them out having them sign up dropping
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01581-00353920-00354054 dropping them back off is there any
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01582-00354055-00354310 control on that whatsoever
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01583-00354311-00354575 you get to i'm sorry go ahead look
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01584-00354576-00354815 unless a court declares you legally
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01585-00354816-00355063 incompetent you have a right to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01586-00355064-00355151 but
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01587-00355152-00355343 um
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01588-00355344-00355567 the an example of someone trying to take
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01589-00355568-00355999 advantage of this is that last summer
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01590-00356000-00356423 a woman who works in a state supported
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01591-00356424-00356639 home for the developmentally challenged
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01592-00356640-00356823 in texas
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01593-00356824-00357039 was indicted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01594-00357040-00357247 because the individuals who were there
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01595-00357248-00357406 were had all been declared legally
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01596-00357407-00357543 incompetent that's why they were in this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01597-00357544-00357639 particular
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01598-00357640-00357847 this particular home she was indicted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01599-00357848-00358047 because she was filling out and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01600-00358048-00358303 completing voter registration forms for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01601-00358304-00358471 all of them i i think the number was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01602-00358472-00358719 like 140 of them that she had submitted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01603-00358720-00358958 basically filling it out signing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01604-00358959-00359110 their names
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01605-00359111-00359375 and it clearly she was she was going to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01606-00359376-00359599 then uh request absentee ballots and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01607-00359600-00359806 vote them in their case the problem in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01608-00359807-00360054 nursing homes is an acute problem
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01609-00360055-00360239 that's that's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01610-00360240-00360487 you may not recall this but there was a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01611-00360488-00360767 congressman from pennsylvania who about
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01612-00360768-00360958 20 years ago was in fact
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01613-00360959-00361167 criminally charged for doing exactly
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01614-00361168-00361510 that going into nursing homes to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01615-00361511-00361734 obtain uh obtain and vote absentee
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01616-00361735-00361927 ballots from individuals there but
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01617-00361928-00362071 you're not opposed to people with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01618-00362072-00362230 alzheimer's voting as long as they're
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01619-00362231-00362406 ideas if they are unless they've been
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01620-00362407-00362615 declared legally incompetent they have a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01621-00362616-00362791 right to vote what needs to happen
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01622-00362792-00362982 though is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01623-00362983-00363247 local election officials and the local
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01624-00363248-00363399 parties
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01625-00363400-00363727 need to do a better job of for example
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01626-00363728-00364023 example what ought to happen is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01627-00364024-00364239 they ought to set up
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01628-00364240-00364463 a polling day like an early voting day
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01629-00364464-00364615 in a nursing home
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01630-00364616-00364767 where people will be able to vote there
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01631-00364768-00364951 will be election officials there to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01632-00364952-00365223 supervise it and there'll be observers
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01633-00365224-00365310 there
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01634-00365311-00365478 from the democratic party republican
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01635-00365479-00365671 party libertarian party green party to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01636-00365672-00366030 make sure that the it's the residents by
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01637-00366031-00366158 themselves
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01638-00366159-00366375 making the the decision on who to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01639-00366376-00366575 for and you don't have staff and other
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01640-00366576-00366806 people basically filling out the ballot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01641-00366807-00367015 and signing their name and submitting it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01642-00367016-00367206 but you need better supervision of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01643-00367207-00367406 any comments of your lives are better
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01644-00367407-00367654 yeah i mean i think the um the the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01645-00367655-00367854 answer to your question is in what hans
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01646-00367855-00368039 just described which is that woman was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01647-00368040-00368327 indicted in texas and what what you're
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01648-00368328-00368551 what the anecdote reveals is that there
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01649-00368552-00368782 was fraud being committed against
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01650-00368783-00369054 americans not fraud being committed by
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01651-00369055-00369263 the voters themselves
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01652-00369264-00369454 there are criminal prohibitions against
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01653-00369455-00369654 that kind of misconduct they are working
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01654-00369655-00369806 they are resulting in criminal
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01655-00369807-00369982 prosecutions
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01656-00369983-00370175 the kinds of restrictions that we are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01657-00370176-00370375 seeing enacted this year banning
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01658-00370376-00370630 curbside voting shortening early voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01659-00370631-00370878 periods those kinds of restrictions
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01660-00370879-00371110 don't solve that problem they just make
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01661-00371111-00371319 it harder for eligible americans to cast
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01662-00371320-00371582 their ballots in a convenient method
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01663-00371583-00371958 next question
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01664-00371959-00372054 for those
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01665-00372055-00372327 laws that have either been uh presented
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01666-00372328-00372678 or passed since the 2020 election um do
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01667-00372679-00372999 you have the breakdown on the states um
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01668-00373000-00373151 where i guess the sponsors of those
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01669-00373152-00373327 bills whether you know which side of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01670-00373328-00373575 aisle they fell on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01671-00373576-00373671 the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01672-00373672-00373958 laws that are being enacted to that the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01673-00373959-00374167 brandon center characterizes as making
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01674-00374168-00374399 it harder for americans to vote are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01675-00374400-00374575 being enacted are being introduced
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01676-00374576-00374895 predominantly by republican sponsors and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01677-00374896-00375134 are be and are being enacted in large
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01678-00375135-00375223 part
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01679-00375224-00375527 virtually on party lines comment uh bad
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01680-00375528-00375678 hand hands
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01681-00375679-00376087 no comment next question
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01682-00376088-00376375 hello my name is chloe um i have two
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01683-00376376-00376630 questions but i only asked one um my
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01684-00376631-00376847 question is for the gentleman so i read
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01685-00376848-00377063 the supreme court decision
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01686-00377064-00377239 regarding arizona
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01687-00377240-00377487 and the minority opinion specifically
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01688-00377488-00377751 brought up the issue of native american
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01689-00377752-00377991 communities having a precedent with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01690-00377992-00378295 having a member of their tribe deliver
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01691-00378296-00378599 mail-in ballots to officials and that is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01692-00378600-00378887 no longer allowed in arizona
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01693-00378888-00379039 and i'm just wondering if you had any
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01694-00379040-00379223 thoughts on that because you brought up
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01695-00379224-00379519 the potential fraud with third party
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01696-00379520-00379727 third parties collecting votes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01697-00379728-00379895 but there is no evidence of fraud
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01698-00379896-00380167 happening particularly in this community
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01699-00380168-00380391 and there's also precedent for this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01700-00380392-00380654 community being allowed to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01701-00380655-00380823 do this kind of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01702-00380824-00380982 delivery of voting just because of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01703-00380983-00381175 way their communities are set up so just
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01704-00381176-00381471 curious to know your thoughts
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01705-00381472-00381599 just so you all know what we're talking
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01706-00381600-00381839 about the the arizona case was called
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01707-00381840-00382134 bronovich versus dnc
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01708-00382135-00382302 and the issue in that case there were
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01709-00382303-00382551 two issues
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01710-00382552-00382847 one is uh the state like more than half
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01711-00382848-00383127 of the states across the country ban
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01712-00383128-00383327 what i call vote trafficking third
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01713-00383328-00383502 unrelated third parties being able to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01714-00383503-00383678 pick up and deliver ballots because of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01715-00383679-00383927 the potential danger from that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01716-00383928-00384158 california actually for a long time
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01717-00384159-00384310 banned it they only legalized it a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01718-00384311-00384510 couple of years ago
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01719-00384511-00384823 the second issue in arizona
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01720-00384824-00385071 was the fact that for decades they've
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01721-00385072-00385278 had the same rule that is the rule in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01722-00385279-00385527 almost every other state which is you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01723-00385528-00385687 have to vote in the precinct to which
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01724-00385688-00385878 you're assigned
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01725-00385879-00386063 okay there's two important reasons for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01726-00386064-00386158 that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01727-00386159-00386278 one
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01728-00386279-00386430 if you don't vote if you vote in your
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01729-00386431-00386558 precinct they're going to be able to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01730-00386559-00386663 vote for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01731-00386664-00386806 all the offices for which you're
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01732-00386807-00387119 qualified not just president and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01733-00387120-00387382 and u.s senator but local city council
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01734-00387383-00387527 and county commission raises state
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01735-00387528-00387695 legislative races
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01736-00387696-00387910 if the state says well you can go vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01737-00387911-00388134 anywhere then you may end up in a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01738-00388135-00388287 precinct where
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01739-00388288-00388447 you may be able to vote for the top of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01740-00388448-00388630 the ticket but you can't vote for all
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01741-00388631-00388839 the rest so in effect
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01742-00388840-00388954 you're get you're going to be
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01743-00388955-00389134 disenfranchising folks
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01744-00389135-00389254 are you specifically addressing the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01745-00389255-00389454 young ladies and on the on the vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01746-00389455-00389678 harvesting thing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01747-00389679-00389943 one of the reasons the court said
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01748-00389944-00390206 the state can do this is because
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01749-00390207-00390399 arizona actually has one of the most
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01750-00390400-00390575 expansive
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01751-00390576-00390847 ways to vote there they have long period
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01752-00390848-00391023 of early voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01753-00391024-00391215 they have a long period of absentee
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01754-00391216-00391575 balloting and this one restriction
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01755-00391576-00391782 in fact the dnc was able unable to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01756-00391783-00392039 produce any evidence
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01757-00392040-00392206 that it was going to keep anyone from
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01758-00392207-00392375 being able to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01759-00392376-00392639 right uh congratulations yeah i think
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01760-00392640-00392751 that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01761-00392752-00393078 particularly that example reflects um
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01762-00393079-00393254 what we see all over the country was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01763-00393255-00393423 which is that voting restrictions can
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01764-00393424-00393615 burden certain communities more than
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01765-00393616-00393815 others and that's why it's so important
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01766-00393816-00394039 to look beyond the top line voter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01767-00394040-00394302 turnout numbers and see who is affected
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01768-00394303-00394567 by these kinds of laws this arizona case
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01769-00394568-00394799 the brnovich decision is the one in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01770-00394800-00394887 which
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01771-00394888-00395182 the arizona state republican party
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01772-00395183-00395430 lawyer said the reason why we need these
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01773-00395431-00395599 laws on the books is because we want to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01774-00395600-00395823 win elections that there was really a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01775-00395824-00395991 partisan interest
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01776-00395992-00396143 that this had nothing to do with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01777-00396144-00396415 election integrity um but and i should
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01778-00396416-00396606 note that with respect to out of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01779-00396607-00396887 precinct voting many states do allow you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01780-00396888-00397127 to vote out of precinct but they only
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01781-00397128-00397334 allow you to vote a provisional ballot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01782-00397335-00397606 and you only get to vote your votes only
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01783-00397607-00397782 count for the races for which you're
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01784-00397783-00397975 qualified so only for senate and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01785-00397976-00398206 president not for city council if you're
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01786-00398207-00398391 in the wrong place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01787-00398392-00398551 next question
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01788-00398552-00398734 thank you um first i'd just like to say
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01789-00398735-00398839 i couldn't agree with you more on the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01790-00398840-00398967 importance of civil debate and i'd like
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01791-00398968-00399110 to thank you both for being here in that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01792-00399111-00399351 spirit uh to take us back to the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01793-00399352-00399630 resolution which is um that legislators
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01794-00399631-00399999 are actively working to suppress voter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01795-00400000-00400334 uh suppressed voters um i'd like to my
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01796-00400335-00400463 question is for the gentleman i was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01797-00400464-00400695 hoping that he could address directly
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01798-00400696-00400799 the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01799-00400800-00400927 other
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01800-00400928-00401102 voter restrictions that the that the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01801-00401103-00401430 lady mentioned um not including voter id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01802-00401431-00401623 which i think we've covered pretty
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01803-00401624-00401902 thoroughly uh specifically fewer ballot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01804-00401903-00402206 boxes fewer drop-offs uh drive-in voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01805-00402207-00402478 uh cut cutting down on early voting days
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01806-00402479-00402782 um and a how those are not making it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01807-00402783-00402975 harder to vote and b even if they're not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01808-00402976-00403119 making harder to vote in what way are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01809-00403120-00403239 they justified
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01810-00403240-00403623 sure um what texas did is they actually
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01811-00403624-00403734 said
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01812-00403735-00403919 uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01813-00403920-00404127 curbside voting can only be used by
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01814-00404128-00404375 somebody who is disabled and can't make
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01815-00404376-00404551 it into a polling place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01816-00404552-00404854 okay and that's the rule in the vast
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01817-00404855-00405110 majority of states so i don't think it's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01818-00405111-00405367 somehow keeping people from voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01819-00405368-00405639 uh if you ban curbside voting for anyone
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01820-00405640-00405758 unless they're disabled if you're
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01821-00405759-00405895 disabled
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01822-00405896-00406095 you can drive up in your car the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01823-00406096-00406254 election official will come out that's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01824-00406255-00406575 the standard rule in in in many states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01825-00406576-00406791 um so i don't think it's a problem given
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01826-00406792-00407063 the fact that if you're
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01827-00407064-00407206 able to get into a polling place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01828-00407207-00407430 particularly early voting day with early
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01829-00407431-00407615 voting analytic on election day i don't
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01830-00407616-00407751 think that's a problem
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01831-00407752-00407967 look the problem with dropboxes is what
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01832-00407968-00408102 what they have said is they're going to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01833-00408103-00408375 have a if you're going to have a dropbox
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01834-00408376-00408710 it's got to be a dropbox that is secured
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01835-00408711-00408895 under surveillance
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01836-00408896-00409102 it can't just be a drop box out on the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01837-00409103-00409343 street that anyone can access here's the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01838-00409344-00409534 way to look at that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01839-00409535-00409855 okay
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01840-00409856-00410078 does anybody in here think it would be a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01841-00410079-00410282 good idea
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01842-00410283-00410599 if uh what you go and you vote in a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01843-00410600-00410910 precinct uh you drop your paper ballot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01844-00410912-00411118 into the ballot box you leave
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01845-00411119-00411263 at the end of the day
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01846-00411264-00411463 what states uh what what happens in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01847-00411464-00411718 states that use paper ballots like that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01848-00411719-00411847 is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01849-00411847-00412030 the election official
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01850-00412031-00412303 seals the box
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01851-00412304-00412526 he puts it in his car with the assistant
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01852-00412527-00412830 manager and they drive the box of sealed
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01853-00412831-00413118 ballots downtown to the election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01854-00413119-00413255 headquarters
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01855-00413256-00413526 where it's then opened and counted
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01856-00413527-00413695 do you all think anybody in here think
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01857-00413696-00413870 would be a good idea to take that ballot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01858-00413871-00414022 box which is filled with something
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01859-00414023-00414143 valuable
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01860-00414143-00414318 ballots
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01861-00414319-00414566 and the the precinct manager simply went
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01862-00414567-00414807 and put it out on the street
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01863-00414808-00415055 and left it unattended
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01864-00415056-00415270 and said well somebody will be by here
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01865-00415271-00415478 in a while to pick it up i don't think
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01866-00415479-00415639 anybody agree with that that would be a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01867-00415639-00415959 good idea well that's what dropboxes are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01868-00415960-00416095 and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01869-00416096-00416247 the problems with them could be
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01870-00416247-00416534 everything from people uh stealing the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01871-00416535-00416766 box to what happened last year you may
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01872-00416767-00416910 have seen prior to the election when
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01873-00416912-00417070 some mailboxes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01874-00417071-00417318 were set on fire that contained
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01875-00417319-00417510 apparently absentee ballots like in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01876-00417512-00417718 richmond and the postal service had to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01877-00417719-00417910 send out a notice saying
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01878-00417912-00418118 if if you dropped an absentee ballot in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01879-00418119-00418278 this mailbox
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01880-00418279-00418478 you'd need to check on it because it may
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01881-00418479-00418630 have been destroyed that's the problem
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01882-00418631-00418710 with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01883-00418712-00419103 with drop boxes as long as they're
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01884-00419104-00419303 under surveillance they're guarded so
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01885-00419304-00419470 that kind of thing can't happen that's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01886-00419471-00419647 not a problem and that's what texas has
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01887-00419647-00419822 said
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01888-00419823-00419918 um
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01889-00419919-00420022 okay
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01890-00420023-00420399 comment yes i think context is key
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01891-00420400-00420470 so
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01892-00420471-00420622 while
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01893-00420623-00420807 it is true that in texas if you have a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01894-00420808-00421070 disability you can still vote curbside
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01895-00421071-00421366 this law was enacted after counties in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01896-00421367-00421622 texas allowed drive-through voting last
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01897-00421623-00421887 year because of the risks of gathering
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01898-00421888-00422047 during the pandemic
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01899-00422047-00422151 and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01900-00422152-00422375 voters turned out in record numbers in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01901-00422376-00422559 harris county where that policy was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01902-00422560-00422855 implemented and then lo and behold we
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01903-00422856-00423095 see a policy that bans drive-through and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01904-00423096-00423343 curbside voting for all voters and again
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01905-00423343-00423583 you have to ask why just because it's
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01906-00423584-00423710 still allowed for voters with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01907-00423712-00423910 disabilities why should it not be
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01908-00423912-00424135 allowed for other voters if there has
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01909-00424135-00424431 been no proven problem with that method
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01910-00424432-00424543 of voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01911-00424543-00424775 likewise context is key when considering
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01912-00424776-00425070 dropboxes dropboxes have been used
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01913-00425071-00425287 largely without incident in states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01914-00425288-00425566 across the country for many many years
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01915-00425567-00425743 this is the first year where we are
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01916-00425743-00426007 seeing laws limit the availability of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01917-00426008-00426214 drop boxes and that's because lots of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01918-00426215-00426447 voters used them last year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01919-00426447-00426551 and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01920-00426552-00426839 just as you can drop a your mail ballot
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01921-00426839-00427095 off in any blue mailbox on the corner
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01922-00427096-00427303 which is not monitored which is not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01923-00427304-00427543 staffed that's the way that drop boxes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01924-00427543-00427783 have largely operated in states across
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01925-00427784-00428070 the country very successfully and again
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01926-00428071-00428255 that's the kind of convenience
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01927-00428256-00428470 measure that makes it easier for people
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01928-00428471-00428751 to vote and therefore increases turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01929-00428752-00428991 because that convenience that the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01930-00428992-00429287 proximity to where you vote actually has
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01931-00429288-00429614 been shown to increase turnout and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01932-00429615-00429831 increasing that distance from where you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01933-00429832-00430039 vote has been shown to decrease turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01934-00430039-00430231 so there's lots of data on this showing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01935-00430232-00430487 that these are successful policies
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01936-00430488-00430622 uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01937-00430623-00430847 good question
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01938-00430847-00431191 okay so um this is primarily for ms
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01939-00431192-00431479 swearin becker so uh you said on a few
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01940-00431480-00431775 occasions that we don't have data about
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01941-00431776-00432047 the connection between these measures or
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01942-00432047-00432231 the lack of them and fraud are there
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01943-00432232-00432470 cases where even in the absence of data
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01944-00432471-00432703 even in uncertainty we should still act
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01945-00432704-00432863 one way because
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01946-00432864-00433007 you know
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01947-00433008-00433214 the consequences of not doing this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01948-00433215-00433327 though we don't know that they will
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01949-00433328-00433470 happen they could and that there might
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01950-00433471-00433655 be a low cost so that we should still
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01951-00433656-00433879 take such measures
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01952-00433880-00434039 thank you and thank you for dating to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01953-00434039-00434231 pronounce my last name which i know is a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01954-00434232-00434614 mouthful so i appreciate that um i think
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01955-00434615-00434903 that the data that we do have shows that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01956-00434904-00435191 the risks are very low and we're dealing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01957-00435192-00435343 with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01958-00435343-00435614 one of if not the most precious right in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01959-00435615-00435839 a free society and i think we both agree
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01960-00435839-00436022 on the on the value of that right to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01961-00436023-00436103 vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01962-00436104-00436287 and so when you're talking about
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01963-00436288-00436518 measures that make it harder to exercise
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01964-00436519-00436718 that most fundamental right
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01965-00436719-00436959 you need a really good reason to make
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01966-00436960-00437222 that more difficult and i don't think we
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01967-00437223-00437422 have the data to show that what we do
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01968-00437423-00437599 have the data to show is that these
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01969-00437600-00437918 risks are infinitesimally small and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01970-00437919-00438303 don't justify taking those measures that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01971-00438304-00438470 haven't been shown to be helpful in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01972-00438471-00438631 first place
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01973-00438632-00438966 uh comment tense
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01974-00438967-00439191 oh your wife well i'll just say i just i
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01975-00439192-00439614 just don't i just don't agree with it uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01976-00439615-00439879 the u.s has a long history of election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01977-00439880-00440079 fraud especially unfortunately in new
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01978-00440080-00440247 york city
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01979-00440247-00440327 and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01980-00440328-00440535 to just to tell you quickly how easy it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01981-00440535-00440766 is to cheat in this city i suggest all
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01982-00440767-00441039 of you google and find a report put out
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01983-00441039-00441239 by the new york
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01984-00441239-00441431 department of investigations after the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01985-00441432-00441791 2013 de blasio election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01986-00441792-00441918 they did an investigation of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01987-00441919-00442095 election department
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01988-00442096-00442295 because they got
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01989-00442296-00442487 two complaints one that everyone in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01990-00442488-00442614 board elections was high they were
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01991-00442615-00442751 hiring their family which you're not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01992-00442752-00442879 supposed to do
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01993-00442880-00443055 but second that they weren't doing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01994-00443056-00443247 anything to maintain the accuracy of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01995-00443247-00443439 voter list
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01996-00443439-00443759 and to test this on election day they
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01997-00443760-00444070 sent their undercover agents into new
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01998-00444071-00444343 york precincts all over the city
+MLnHM2_a0oy-01999-00444343-00444575 and got their undercover agents to ask
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02000-00444576-00444799 for the ballots of individuals who were
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02001-00444800-00444918 dead
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02002-00444919-00445207 had moved away or otherwise uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02003-00445208-00445351 ineligible to vote because they were
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02004-00445352-00445566 still on the voter list and they tried
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02005-00445567-00445743 to make it as obvious as possible the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02006-00445743-00445975 best example i recall was one of the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02007-00445976-00446079 undercover age as a young
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02008-00446080-00446279 african-american woman in her 20s she
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02009-00446280-00446479 went in and asked for the ballot of a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02010-00446480-00446631 woman who was still registered to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02011-00446632-00446918 who was in her 80s caucasian was dead
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02012-00446919-00447191 in every single case they were handed
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02013-00447192-00447422 the ballot without question
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02014-00447423-00447622 so they could have voted the ballot and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02015-00447623-00447975 there was only one person who was caught
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02016-00447976-00448191 and that person was caught because they
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02017-00448192-00448455 went in and asked for the ballot of an
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02018-00448456-00448631 individual who is currently in the state
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02019-00448632-00448870 penitentiary and therefore can't vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02020-00448871-00449031 and it so happened that the woman
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02021-00449032-00449263 working at the registration desk was the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02022-00449264-00449447 prisoner's mother and realized that was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02023-00449447-00449655 not her son
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02024-00449656-00449918 we now move to the uh summation portion
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02025-00449919-00450335 of the evening uh uh eliza uh your
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02026-00450335-00450535 summation your five minute summation
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02027-00450535-00450799 take the podium eliza oh i was not aware
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02028-00450800-00451087 that we had a five five-minute summation
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02029-00451088-00451159 i'm
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02030-00451160-00451518 sure that you've got a lot to say anyway
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02031-00451519-00451607 um
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02032-00451608-00451799 as i mentioned off mike i was not aware
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02033-00451800-00452007 that we had a five-minute submission so
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02034-00452008-00452247 i have nothing particularly prepared um
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02035-00452247-00452439 but i think i would just
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02036-00452439-00452695 refer all of you back to the resolution
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02037-00452696-00452943 which is that state lawmakers across the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02038-00452943-00453151 country are actively working to make it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02039-00453152-00453359 harder for americans to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02040-00453360-00453599 i haven't heard anything today that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02041-00453600-00453863 disproves that what we have seen our
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02042-00453864-00454110 policies enacted dozens of policies
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02043-00454112-00454391 enacted just this year that cut back on
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02044-00454392-00454575 early voting that cut back on mail
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02045-00454576-00454775 voting that cut back on disability
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02046-00454776-00454887 access
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02047-00454888-00455135 and and these policies have been proven
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02048-00455135-00455343 time and time again to make it harder to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02049-00455343-00455583 vote these are precisely the policies
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02050-00455584-00455814 that states many states adopted for the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02051-00455815-00456110 first time last year or that voters took
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02052-00456112-00456399 advantage of in record numbers last year
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02053-00456400-00456575 in order to vote safely during the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02054-00456576-00456831 pandemic and now those policies are the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02055-00456832-00457079 target of these state lawmakers because
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02056-00457080-00457359 we've seen so many people turn out
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02057-00457360-00457599 and nothing i've heard today shows that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02058-00457600-00457799 shows that state lawmakers
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02059-00457800-00457966 or that many state lawmakers are not
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02060-00457967-00458207 making it trying to make it harder for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02061-00458208-00458375 vote eligible voters to cast their
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02062-00458376-00458599 ballots and again i would urge you all
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02063-00458600-00458863 to look behind the overall turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02064-00458864-00459183 numbers from the 2020 election and see
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02065-00459184-00459431 what see what lawmakers are actually
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02066-00459432-00459583 trying to do
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02067-00459584-00459799 because it matters what their motivation
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02068-00459800-00459999 is it matters that there are efforts
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02069-00460000-00460231 being undertaken by state lawmakers to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02070-00460232-00460503 undermine our democracy to undermine
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02071-00460504-00460766 americans participation to undermine our
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02072-00460767-00460983 faith in the electoral system without
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02073-00460984-00461191 being based on particular data to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02074-00461192-00461807 substantiate those laws
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02075-00461808-00462559 five minutes
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02076-00462560-00462710 just one quick thing i keep hearing
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02077-00462712-00462879 early voting days cut back that was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02078-00462880-00463055 actually claim made about the georgia
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02079-00463056-00463279 reform bill we even heard joe biden make
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02080-00463280-00463487 it that is absolutely false
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02081-00463488-00463695 you can look at the bill you can see
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02082-00463696-00463910 that they did not reduce the number of
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02083-00463912-00464207 early voting days and in fact
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02084-00464208-00464463 they have about the same average number
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02085-00464464-00464670 uh that other states do in fact texas
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02086-00464671-00464799 was one of the first states in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02087-00464800-00464959 entire united states to put in early
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02088-00464960-00465175 voting
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02089-00465176-00465383 they still have more early voting than
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02090-00465384-00465622 the state of new york
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02091-00465623-00465791 they have more early voting than the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02092-00465792-00466039 state of delaware which currently has no
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02093-00466039-00466222 early voting and i don't seem to hear
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02094-00466223-00466327 anyone
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02095-00466328-00466495 saying we're going to have to sue new
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02096-00466496-00466791 york and delaware because
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02097-00466792-00466975 they have less early voting days and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02098-00466976-00467231 delaware has none they have passed
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02099-00467232-00467366 a law they're going to start having it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02100-00467367-00467735 in 2022 but it still will be fewer days
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02101-00467735-00468247 then texas and and georgia
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02102-00468247-00468510 it is important that we
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02103-00468512-00468703 maintain the security of our elections
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02104-00468704-00468951 it can be done and it's been shown to be
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02105-00468952-00469135 done
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02106-00469135-00469575 by now 13 years worth of data you know
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02107-00469576-00469775 everybody's talking as if the only
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02108-00469776-00469975 election reforms ever passed when this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02109-00469976-00470255 it's past legislative session no
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02110-00470256-00470487 as i said the first voter id laws were
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02111-00470488-00470959 passed in 2005 in georgia indiana other
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02112-00470960-00471127 states have been putting them in over
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02113-00471128-00471327 the years everywhere from
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02114-00471328-00471591 north carolina to arizona to other
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02115-00471592-00471870 states and in that entire time turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02116-00471871-00472214 has just been going up and registration
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02117-00472215-00472583 has been going up and if you doubt me
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02118-00472584-00472839 on that issue
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02119-00472839-00472991 here's something else for you to google
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02120-00472992-00473207 pull up the 20
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02121-00473208-00473518 the u.s census report on the 2020
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02122-00473519-00473735 election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02123-00473735-00473999 we had the biggest turnout in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02124-00474000-00474303 last year's election in
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02125-00474304-00474487 this century
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02126-00474488-00474655 and it was the second highest turnout
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02127-00474656-00474863 according to the census bureau since the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02128-00474864-00475231 92 election so this entire time where
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02129-00475232-00475351 people have been doing things like
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02130-00475352-00475607 putting in id laws to try to prevent
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02131-00475608-00475855 fraud registration and turnout have been
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02132-00475856-00476103 going up and the attitudes about this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02133-00476104-00476255 show this ex like i said this
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02134-00476256-00476510 extraordinarily patronizing attitude
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02135-00476512-00476751 towards the american public
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02136-00476752-00476943 as if for example they can't deal with
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02137-00476943-00477487 the free getting a free id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02138-00477488-00477799 i want to end by quoting uh former
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02139-00477800-00478031 president jimmy carter and former
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02140-00478032-00478255 secretary of state james baker
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02141-00478256-00478535 in 2005 they issued a report this was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02142-00478535-00478718 after the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02143-00478719-00478999 florida election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02144-00479000-00479151 they formed a commission on federal
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02145-00479152-00479318 election reform
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02146-00479319-00479527 and they said this which i think is
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02147-00479528-00479759 extraordinarily correct
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02148-00479760-00479959 uh and by the way one of the things that
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02149-00479960-00480183 both jimmy carter and james baker in the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02150-00480184-00480614 report recommended was voter id
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02151-00480615-00480879 elections are the heart of democracy
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02152-00480880-00481062 they are the instrument for the people
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02153-00481063-00481262 to choose leaders and hold them
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02154-00481263-00481383 accountable
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02155-00481384-00481607 at the same time elections are a core
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02156-00481608-00481839 public function upon which all other
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02157-00481839-00482095 government responsibilities depend if
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02158-00482096-00482327 elections are defective the entire
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02159-00482328-00482662 democratic system is at risk
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02160-00482663-00482831 i agree with that and i don't think we
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02161-00482832-00483110 should put it at risk by
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02162-00483112-00483407 having a system that makes it easy
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02163-00483408-00483614 for people to
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02164-00483615-00483799 vote without authenticating their
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02165-00483800-00483951 identity
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02166-00483952-00484295 without authenticating their citizenship
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02167-00484296-00484535 that makes it easy for them to register
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02168-00484535-00484718 in two different states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02169-00484719-00484959 and not get caught because states don't
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02170-00484960-00485143 do a good job of comparing their voter
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02171-00485143-00485247 lists
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02172-00485247-00485487 and while in some cases it might just be
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02173-00485488-00485759 one person cheating
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02174-00485760-00485983 like the student we just added to our
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02175-00485984-00486183 database who was prosecuted he's a
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02176-00486184-00486455 resident of massachusetts
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02177-00486456-00486575 he's going to the university of new
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02178-00486576-00486791 hampshire and he voted in both states
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02179-00486792-00486991 illegally
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02180-00486992-00487207 or if it's a group of individuals who
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02181-00487208-00487447 have acted together to steal an election
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02182-00487447-00487743 like the half dozen individuals who were
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02183-00487743-00488022 criminally charged in north carolina
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02184-00488023-00488183 in the congressional race that was
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02185-00488184-00488431 overturned because of their fraud we
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02186-00488432-00488670 should be concerned about it
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02187-00488671-00488855 and we can do things
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02188-00488856-00489062 to make sure that doesn't happen at the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02189-00489063-00489199 same time
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02190-00489200-00489462 that we allow and make it possible for
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02191-00489463-00489679 eligible americans to vote
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02192-00489680-00489814 access
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02193-00489815-00490047 does not prevent security and security
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02194-00490047-00490239 does not prevent access thank you very
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02195-00490239-00490274 much
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02196-00490275-00490791 [Music]
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02197-00490792-00491151 well it was an interesting uh heat
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02198-00491152-00491391 the yes votes began with a little over
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02199-00491392-00491551 31
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02200-00491552-00491910 and uh ended with 44 percent took up and
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02201-00491912-00492199 gained more than 13 points
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02202-00492200-00492495 and that's the number to beat the no
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02203-00492496-00492655 votes uh
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02204-00492656-00493022 gained uh gained 18 points so beat the
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02205-00493023-00493287 that by five points the tootsie roll
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02206-00493288-00493503 therefore goes to the negative
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02207-00493504-00494283 congratulations to you
+MLnHM2_a0oy-02208-00494284-00494600 both you
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00000-00000176-00000463 okay recording is in progress right now
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00001-00000463-00000799 as i don't know if gabo is coming
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00002-00000800-00001127 because he has certain problems
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00003-00001128-00001447 and well i pers i have to proceed
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00004-00001448-00001743 recording his class do you accept
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00005-00001744-00002079 recording this class for gabo omero
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00006-00002080-00002415 and sure there there's no problem for me
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00007-00002416-00002702 no problem for you how about you do you
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00008-00002703-00002926 accept recording this class for
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00009-00002927-00003238 for gabo emilio should we yes this year
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00010-00003239-00003599 no problem okay how about you
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00011-00003600-00003879 do you accept the record in this class
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00012-00003879-00004159 yeah no problem okay if you don't want
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00013-00004160-00004559 anybody else to see you you can omit the
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00014-00004560-00004863 video if you want whenever you want
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00015-00004864-00004959 okay
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00016-00004960-00005254 no problem okay so this class is being
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00017-00005255-00005560 recorded and let me share the screen um
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00018-00005561-00005718 [Music]
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00019-00005719-00005975 what time what what is the day today
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00020-00005976-00006286 what's the day today is um
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00021-00006287-00006375 uh
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00022-00006376-00006567 22nd
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00023-00006568-00006823 of march
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00024-00006823-00007183 all right okay it's tuesday march 22nd
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00025-00007184-00007527 2022 so here we are we were here
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00026-00007528-00007798 yesterday we finished this we answered
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00027-00007800-00008142 this exercise on the video resource book
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00028-00008143-00008607 but we have to continue here on part b
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00029-00008608-00008855 you remember part a
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00030-00008856-00009142 chewie you remember
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00031-00009143-00009503 not bishop no no okay it's necessary to
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00032-00009504-00009767 to watch the video again not only for
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00033-00009768-00010110 you but for mr omero who probably
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00034-00010111-00010327 doesn't understand what we are talking
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00035-00010328-00010423 about
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00036-00010424-00010646 omero we are talking about these
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00037-00010647-00010878 four people here
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00038-00010879-00011095 this is person number one person two
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00039-00011096-00011383 person three person four okay and they
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00040-00011384-00011646 are talking about entertainment okay
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00041-00011647-00011870 and if you didn't listen to it if you
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00042-00011871-00012006 didn't watch it
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00043-00012007-00012263 so here's the answer uh for the
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00044-00012264-00012463 questions here you are
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00045-00012464-00012695 okay you're gonna circle
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00046-00012696-00012910 which people gave
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00047-00012911-00013255 these opinions okay
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00048-00013256-00013551 your circle which person
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00049-00013552-00013694 gave
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00050-00013695-00013919 these opinions okay
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00051-00013919-00014158 what are the opinions number one special
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00052-00014159-00014351 effects are better
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00053-00014352-00014671 on the big screen
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00054-00014672-00014927 another one is okay can you repeat
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00055-00014928-00015175 number one repeat everybody
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00056-00015176-00015503 special effects are better on the big
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00057-00015504-00015727 screen
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00058-00015728-00016199 special effects are better
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00059-00016200-00016455 that's good okay uh
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00060-00016456-00016703 gabriel is entering right now but in
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00061-00016704-00016991 order not to stop this let's continue
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00062-00016992-00017327 repeating number two everybody repeats
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00063-00017328-00017543 all movies are better
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00064-00017544-00018191 on the big screen
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00065-00018192-00018407 okay and the other one number three can
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00066-00018408-00018599 you please repeat
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00067-00018600-00018791 it's a night
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00068-00018792-00019255 on the town it's a night on the town
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00069-00019256-00019575 that's right and opinion number four
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00070-00019576-00019991 would be watching movies is more fun
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00071-00019992-00020183 in a group
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00072-00020184-00020599 watching watching movies
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00073-00020600-00020943 okay now i can see gabriel's boys
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00074-00020944-00021214 gabrielle's boys great gabriel is here
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00075-00021215-00021455 hello gabriel how are you
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00076-00021456-00021655 i'm finding a new teacher
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00077-00021656-00022063 i'm okay here you are mr omero
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00078-00022064-00022575 chui and rasa romero julian hassan
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00079-00022576-00022727 okay say hello
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00080-00022728-00023094 okay observe um let me stop having this
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00081-00023095-00023367 uh recorded because it is not necessary
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00082-00023368-00023494 you are here
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00083-00023495-00023767 okay so let me stop recording no more
+MNEMNYOMwqA-00084-00023768-00024184 recording this was to be sent to you
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00000-00000000-00000221 pollution live stream this is democracy
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00001-00000222-00000443 now democracynow.org the war and peace
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00002-00000444-00000586 report I'm Amy Goodman with Juan
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00003-00000587-00000848 Gonzalez well we turn now to look at the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00004-00000849-00001033 Occupy Wall Street movement and its
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00005-00001034-00001274 legacy on its second anniversary on
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00006-00001275-00001607 September 17 2011 thousands of people
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00007-00001607-00001852 marched on the financial district then
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00008-00001853-00002047 formed an encampment in Zuccotti Park
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00009-00002048-00002282 launching a movement that shifted the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00010-00002283-00002495 conversation and economic inequality
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00011-00002496-00002675 here in New York activists marked the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00012-00002676-00002858 occasion Tuesday with a march New York
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00013-00002859-00003037 Stock Exchange and the United Nations
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00014-00003038-00003278 highlighting a call for taxing Wall
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00015-00003279-00003481 Street transactions and directing the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00016-00003482-00003659 funds to public causes or more we're
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00017-00003660-00003869 joined by two guests Nicole cardi is an
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00018-00003870-00004022 actions coordinator with the other
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00019-00004022-00004202 ninety eight percent during Occupy Wall
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00020-00004203-00004415 Street you as a facilitator at General
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00021-00004416-00004604 Assemblies and spokes council meetings
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00022-00004605-00004751 and she was a member of the Occupy
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00023-00004752-00004976 people of color caucus Nathan Schneider
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00024-00004977-00005165 is also with us editor of the website
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00025-00005166-00005336 waging nonviolence author of the new
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00026-00005337-00005558 book Thank You anarchy notes from the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00027-00005559-00005840 Occupy apocalypse we welcome you both to
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00028-00005841-00006154 Democracy Now why occupy apocalypse
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00029-00006155-00006403 Nathan it's a great question it's a
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00030-00006404-00006653 question I get a lot the word in Greek
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00031-00006654-00006959 meant unveiling right it described a
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00032-00006959-00007348 moment in which in which something is
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00033-00007350-00007570 revealed that changes our perception of
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00034-00007572-00007787 everything and I think that pretty
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00035-00007788-00007960 accurately describes what happened with
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00036-00007961-00008170 Occupy Wall Street both for us as a
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00037-00008172-00008474 society in revealing the depth of income
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00038-00008475-00008687 inequality of the corruption of the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00039-00008688-00008914 political system and also of the power
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00040-00008915-00009155 of the militarized police state but also
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00041-00009156-00009356 for so many individuals who took part
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00042-00009357-00009635 across the country I've been privileged
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00043-00009636-00009866 to meet so many people and to watch them
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00044-00009867-00010049 as their lives were changed by this
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00045-00010050-00010256 movement as they became activated and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00046-00010257-00010513 haven't been able to go back to the way
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00047-00010514-00010874 their lives were before well listen you
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00048-00010875-00011006 right in the in the beginning of the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00049-00011007-00011171 book you say for nearly two months in
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00050-00011172-00011378 the fall of two thousand eleven a square
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00051-00011379-00011627 block of granite and honey locust trees
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00052-00011628-00011824 in New York's financial district right
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00053-00011825-00011963 between Wall Street in the World Trade
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00054-00011964-00012227 Center became a canvas for the image of
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00055-00012228-00012628 another world two years later how as
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00056-00012629-00013019 that canvas been preserved and and what
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00057-00013019-00013238 is some of the activities that the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00058-00013238-00013329 Occupy
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00059-00013330-00013631 now evolved well to talk about the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00060-00013632-00013926 canvas itself it's interesting to see
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00061-00013927-00014127 the ways in which the movement is
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00062-00014128-00014366 memorialized kind of informally in the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00063-00014368-00014550 financial district there's still a wall
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00064-00014551-00014769 of barricades around the charging bull
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00065-00014769-00014933 statue there are still regularly
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00066-00014934-00015180 barricades in Zuccotti Park there are
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00067-00015181-00015453 still barricades around chase manhattan
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00068-00015454-00015747 plaza which was the original planned
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00069-00015747-00015996 kind of decoy site for the occupation
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00070-00015997-00016218 it's amazing how the security state is
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00071-00016219-00016440 still living in fear of this movement
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00072-00016441-00016749 but at the same time activists who were
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00073-00016750-00016965 involved in it many of them are spread
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00074-00016966-00017265 out across the country in in all kinds
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00075-00017266-00017442 of networks that have formed through the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00076-00017443-00017607 course of this movement putting their
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00077-00017608-00017748 bodies in the way of the Keystone
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00078-00017749-00018243 pipeline calling attention to two issues
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00079-00018244-00018431 like a financial transaction tax
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00080-00018432-00018717 bringing housing activists together
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00081-00018718-00018906 around the country to create a stronger
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00082-00018907-00019137 movement there are a number of campaigns
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00083-00019138-00019326 that have been profoundly strengthened
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00084-00019327-00019590 by networks formed an Occupy movement
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00085-00019591-00019743 Nicole cardi where were you two years
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00086-00019744-00020094 ago two years ago I was working for
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00087-00020095-00020334 Sundance Channel doing content
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00088-00020335-00020547 management I was just one of many
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00089-00020548-00020775 precariat who didn't really have a solid
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00090-00020776-00021027 job and I came in to occupy because it
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00091-00021028-00021180 was the first time I ever had seen
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00092-00021181-00021384 people my own age or anyone for that
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00093-00021385-00021552 matter talking about the deep and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00094-00021553-00021831 equality within this country it was just
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00095-00021832-00022071 kind of the secret and I feel like part
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00096-00022072-00022269 of the legacy is that that is so
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00097-00022270-00022437 unveiled at this point it's not even
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00098-00022438-00022608 question so talk about what it was
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00099-00022609-00022850 really like so what day did you go to
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00100-00022851-00023187 occupy and describe the community their
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00101-00023188-00023562 first day I went so I've been stalking
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00102-00023563-00023819 occupy on livestream for a full week I
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00103-00023820-00024012 was glued to it before I went down there
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00104-00024013-00024174 and the first day that I stepped down
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00105-00024175-00024363 there was October first which I don't
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00106-00024364-00024497 know if you remember but that was the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00107-00024498-00024722 Brooklyn Bridge day and so me and my
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00108-00024723-00024861 friend were down there chanting and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00109-00024862-00025011 having a great time because we don't act
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00110-00025012-00025221 was in the past and we this was old hat
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00111-00025222-00025533 to us but we did not expect what was
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00112-00025534-00025694 going to happen on the bridge that day
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00113-00025695-00025744 and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00114-00025745-00026189 after after 10 let me go back so people
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00115-00026189-00026435 just stormed the bridge as opposed to
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00116-00026436-00026683 taking the pedestrian route / over the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00117-00026684-00027251 bridge and about God 400 people hundreds
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00118-00027252-00027433 hundreds of people got arrested on the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00119-00027434-00027745 Brooklyn Bridge October first 2011 and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00120-00027747-00028012 we were kind of just witnessing the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00121-00028013-00028233 police state and witnessing some slowly
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00122-00028234-00028502 taking people from the bridge putting
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00123-00028502-00028693 them in custody and it was really
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00124-00028694-00028855 transformative and I couldn't I couldn't
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00125-00028856-00029036 shake it I had to go back every day
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00126-00029037-00029233 since then and I don't think I've really
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00127-00029234-00029681 ever left to be entirely honest you were
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00128-00029682-00029957 involved actually from before the start
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00129-00029958-00030077 of the events and could you talk about
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00130-00030077-00030317 those early days before the actual
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00131-00030318-00030581 encampment yeah yeah I was just reminded
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00132-00030582-00030796 of it by watching myself briefly being
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00133-00030797-00031012 depicted on the newsroom on the HBO show
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00134-00031013-00031321 as they were re-enacting those meetings
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00135-00031322-00031817 but I showed up at the third planning
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00136-00031818-00032137 meeting before the occupation began and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00137-00032138-00032414 announced myself as a journalist and and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00138-00032414-00032662 a debate ensued about whether I could
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00139-00032663-00032876 stay I mean that everything was being
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00140-00032877-00033077 worked out from scratch yes was wearing
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00141-00033078-00033262 tom this was in Tompkins Square Park in
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00142-00033263-00033512 New York City yeah and it was an amazing
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00143-00033513-00033731 thing to come across because there were
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00144-00033732-00034007 all these you know pockets of activists
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00145-00034008-00034181 many of them didn't know each other they
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00146-00034182-00034436 were united by this kind of odd call
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00147-00034437-00034668 that Adbusters had made but they were
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00148-00034669-00034924 committed to making it their own and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00149-00034925-00035140 explained the odd Buster's call the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00150-00035141-00035440 initial adbusters called in call in july
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00151-00035441-00035927 of or in the summer of two thousand
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00152-00035928-00036127 eleven was to occupy wall street and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00153-00036128-00036358 there was a picture of a ballerina on
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00154-00036359-00036542 top of that charging bull statue and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00155-00036543-00036715 then it asked the question what is our
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00156-00036716-00036940 one demand at the top and over the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00157-00036941-00037283 course of these meetings that call that
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00158-00037284-00037465 idea of bringing people to Wall Street
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00159-00037466-00037727 shifted these activists decided that
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00160-00037728-00037933 what they were more interested in was
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00161-00037934-00038126 building a movement they weren't ready
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00162-00038127-00038282 to make one demand they weren't powerful
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00163-00038283-00038477 enough what they needed to do was
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00164-00038478-00038693 empower people around the country in
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00165-00038694-00038853 communities around the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00166-00038854-00039208 in every city in every neighborhood to
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00167-00039209-00039421 build their own occupations to build
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00168-00039422-00039625 their own assemblies and to build power
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00169-00039626-00039853 so that they could make demands and that
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00170-00039854-00040168 they could change the world but of
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00171-00040169-00040375 course they although there were many
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00172-00040376-00040624 demands the one that entered the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00173-00040625-00040954 American lexicon of the 99 percent and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00174-00040955-00041335 clearly President Obama then seized on
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00175-00041336-00041503 that his campaign we have a mayoral
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00176-00041504-00041743 candidate right now New York City Bill
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00177-00041744-00041968 DeBlasio who has seized on the income
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00178-00041969-00042265 inequality issue and is now poised
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00179-00042266-00042430 perhaps to become the next New York City
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00180-00042431-00042670 Mayor what has happened again to the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00181-00042671-00042831 movement since then because obviously
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00182-00042832-00043228 once the groups were busted up by the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00183-00043229-00043507 police in the various cities all kinds
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00184-00043508-00043768 of ideas of how to keep the movement
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00185-00043769-00044151 going I'm interested in what's been the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00186-00044152-00044407 responses of various activists to how to
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00187-00044408-00044599 keep the movement going well the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00188-00044600-00044788 movement is a network at this point and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00189-00044789-00044953 that's what's most important is that we
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00190-00044954-00045157 met each other and you've seen us crop
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00191-00045158-00045391 back up with occupy sandy just last year
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00192-00045392-00045610 the people still know each other I don't
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00193-00045611-00045802 think those helping people in hurricane
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00194-00045803-00046160 right exactly recovery relief but a
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00195-00046161-00046342 political undercurrent to all of that as
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00196-00046343-00046588 well and I think that as long as those
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00197-00046589-00046708 people still know each other the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00198-00046709-00046910 movement always exists and it's networks
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00199-00046911-00047218 in its connections it's not latent you
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00200-00047219-00047347 know people are still active they're
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00201-00047348-00047632 still doing their own act like work and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00202-00047633-00047749 organizing and they're bringing the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00203-00047750-00048010 analysis from occupy to it and I think
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00204-00048011-00048208 it really is the first moment it's the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00205-00048209-00048340 first kind of instance we see of
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00206-00048341-00048610 intersectional organizing that is taking
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00207-00048611-00048811 for its new kind of organizing its we
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00208-00048812-00048964 created a space for people to bring all
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00209-00048965-00049090 their issues and see how they're tied
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00210-00049091-00049309 rather than leading with just one issue
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00211-00049310-00049582 or one demand so every from today's New
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00212-00049583-00049801 York Times report on the latest census
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00213-00049802-00050152 data well Manhattan retained the dubious
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00214-00050153-00050413 distinction of having the biggest income
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00215-00050414-00050752 gap of any big country in the world any
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00216-00050753-00051037 big county in the country the mean
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00217-00051038-00051415 income of the lowest fifth was 9635
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00218-00051416-00051698 dollars compared with 389 thousand and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00219-00051699-00051889 seven dollars for the top fifth and said
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00220-00051890-00052339 199 969 dollars for the top 5% more than
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00221-00052340-00052675 an 80 full difference between bottom and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00222-00052676-00052996 tongue nipple you're now with a group
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00223-00052997-00053248 called the other ninety eight percent
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00224-00053249-00053644 what's your response to this i mean the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00225-00053645-00053902 beautiful thing about this legacy post
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00226-00053903-00054253 occupy is that that is now people see
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00227-00054254-00054391 the inequality it was always there and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00228-00054391-00054559 the ninety-eight percent kind of hits on
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00229-00054560-00054847 the same topics is occupied economic and
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00230-00054848-00055090 equality intersectionality environmental
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00231-00055091-00055366 justice and you know racial justice all
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00232-00055366-00055639 of those same points that were really
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00233-00055640-00055849 articulated through occupier also worked
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00234-00055850-00055992 on by the daring ninety-eight percent
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00235-00055994-00056275 and so I think that what's amazing about
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00236-00056276-00056590 that is that was all true in 2011 but
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00237-00056591-00056740 now people have a lens through which to
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00238-00056741-00057004 view it and see oh this is unequal this
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00239-00057004-00057307 is a systemic issue you wrote a piece in
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00240-00057308-00057472 addition to your book thank you enter
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00241-00057473-00057666 key Nathan call breaking up with
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00242-00057667-00057919 occupying where do you go from here well
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00243-00057920-00058177 I think as I've been talking with
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00244-00058178-00058378 occupiers spread out around the country
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00245-00058379-00058627 I've noticed that there coming to terms
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00246-00058628-00058873 with a moment that happened something
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00247-00058874-00059091 really important really transformative
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00248-00059091-00059314 something that shifted the rhetorical
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00249-00059315-00059655 landscape of our country for sure but I
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00250-00059657-00059979 think there's still a need to push that
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00251-00059980-00060184 further and if we look at the history of
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00252-00060185-00060400 movements they never just happened in a
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00253-00060401-00060535 few months they happen over the course
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00254-00060536-00060745 of years and I think there's a craving
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00255-00060746-00061000 among people who were awakened by that
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00256-00061001-00061297 moment of the occupations to step it up
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00257-00061298-00061558 to a different level to be able to enact
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00258-00061559-00061779 the kind of pressure to make their
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00259-00061780-00061987 dreams something more like a real I have
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00260-00061988-00062161 to leave it there Nathan Schneider your
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00261-00062162-00062338 new book Thank You Anarchy notes from
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00262-00062339-00062541 the Occupy apocalypse and thank you so
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00263-00062542-00062776 much to Nicole cardi who is now with the
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00264-00062777-00063251 other ninety eight percent in a facility
+Mpm3bHXLbrg-00265-00063252-00063458 you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00000-00000003-00000292 there's specific programs and government
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00001-00000293-00000643 they select them and then provide a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00002-00000644-00001031 government-funded to the University so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00003-00001032-00001541 it's this kind of like a one-way but as
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00004-00001542-00001923 I mentioned before my model is actually
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00005-00001925-00002359 called the University they have to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00006-00002360-00002617 develop their own MOOC courses and then
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00007-00002618-00002947 test and revise it and then government
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00008-00002948-00003454 is kind of rent their course for three
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00009-00003455-00003722 years of course the government they have
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00010-00003722-00004226 to pay they give some developing and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00011-00004227-00004479 operating fees for three years
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00012-00004480-00004700 and again the problem that the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00013-00004701-00005070 university can revise their courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00014-00005071-00005695 based open that fun like we are
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00015-00005696-00007646 considering actually so I think maybe
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00016-00007647-00008135 yes one officers he is in charge of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00017-00008136-00009031 chemo and also he
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00018-00009032-00009325 know we have public selection process we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00019-00009326-00009634 have yeah so the university is say and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00020-00009635-00010051 maybe University they have to hand in
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00021-00010052-00010633 some proportion and then the Minister of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00022-00010634-00010948 Education they established tentative
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00023-00010949-00011230 committee selection committee and then
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00024-00011231-00011757 they evaluate the proposals and then
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00025-00011758-00012081 finalize which university will
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00026-00012082-00012745 participate in or not but from this year
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00027-00012746-00012999 I think from last year actually we as a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00028-00013000-00013576 pilot program we invite some non
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00029-00013577-00013975 participating University to develop the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00030-00013976-00014155 MOOC courses and operating for example
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00031-00014156-00014374 the prompting University they are not
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00032-00014375-00014722 our member University but they use their
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00033-00014722-00015655 own funds developing MOOC and operating
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00034-00015656-00016041 so I think in four areas
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00035-00016043-00016494 I think the j mo kamo and time o we can
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00036-00016495-00016921 communicate and exchange and consider
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00037-00016922-00017857 some possible cooperation how many
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00038-00017858-00018180 courses intended to be self-paced
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00039-00018181-00018679 learning in ke moko self-paced you don't
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00040-00018680-00019009 have so everything would run on schedule
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00041-00019010-00019609 yes sir master so some courses might be
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00042-00019610-00019813 offered only one time only and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00043-00019814-00019894 disappeared
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00044-00019895-00020359 yes not disappeared just one up one time
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00045-00020360-00020929 in a year so at least three years their
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00046-00020930-00021193 course should be operated at least once
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00047-00021194-00021825 a year but if the university can US
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00048-00021826-00022549 government fund they should all point
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00049-00022550-00022837 yes our actually government regulation
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00050-00022838-00023062 is our organization so we have a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00051-00023063-00023227 contract with the participating
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00052-00023228-00023488 university and then we have we give some
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00053-00023489-00024429 kind of duty to the part to put it
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00054-00024430-00025015 up-up-up rate once a year or twice a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00055-00025016-00025591 twice here and then for three years it's
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00057-00033425-00033712 the office of higher education college
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00058-00033713-00034234 do you have yes yes but but not
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00059-00034235-00034585 inclusive mean that the teacher can use
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00060-00034586-00034828 the the intellectual property in that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00061-00034829-00035071 teaching and also they can use for their
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00062-00035072-00035521 promotion in the economic promotion no
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00063-00035522-00035797 problem no no need to ask for permission
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00064-00035798-00036154 but the office of higher education have
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00065-00036155-00036508 the right to keep and to open open it
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00066-00036509-00036948 yes the issue is I think you need to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00067-00036949-00037332 revise or improve the course because
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00068-00037333-00037849 like a if a course operated by offered
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00069-00037850-00038227 it for two years the contents may be out
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00070-00038228-00038662 of dating so you need to improve or
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00071-00038663-00039598 update the course how random method and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00072-00039599-00039940 as a terms to revise because but now we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00073-00039941-00040309 can we can select what caught that very
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00074-00040310-00040579 popular or famous or the quality is good
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00075-00040580-00040912 and then we can them to revise the cost
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00076-00040913-00041238 but with Invisalign the cost we have him
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00077-00041239-00041649 to provide as a self as mean that any
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00078-00041650-00041914 learning activity that need the teacher
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00079-00041915-00042223 interaction we will submit it on the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00080-00042224-00042538 course and then repeat has surpassed
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00081-00042539-00042985 model so learner they can learn by their
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00083-00061269-00061591 and you need to consider in the future
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00084-00061591-00062746 this is this kind of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00085-00062747-00063265 you mean like also answer or lifelong
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00086-00063266-00063559 process cause some causes for life from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00087-00063560-00064016 learning not exactly
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00088-00064017-00064482 most of courses are has been have been
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00089-00064483-00064755 provided by higher education
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00090-00064757-00065478 institutions yes but some courses is for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00091-00065479-00065929 adult learners so we do not have a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00092-00065930-00066307 specific courses for specific like a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00093-00066308-00066613 lifelong courses we do not have but most
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00094-00066614-00066949 of courses are utilized and learned by
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00095-00066950-00067423 adult learners so we say the kamo will
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00096-00067424-00068680 be a lifelong learning
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00097-00068681-00069155 sighs some or lifelong learning
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00098-00069156-00069431 yeah so I should wonder that eople
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00099-00069432-00069692 lifelong learning you normally left on
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00100-00069693-00069955 learn learning questions
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00101-00069956-00070406 not offered by university but our
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00102-00070407-00070994 regulation to it we have to under
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00103-00070995-00071327 university and that quite contrast
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00104-00071328-00071633 because you try to like a make formal
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00105-00071634-00072176 education to the informal education and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00106-00072177-00072416 that's why if Corian doesn't have that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00107-00072417-00072755 it then we we cannot we cannot learn
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00108-00072756-00073451 with love you sorry just just honest on
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00109-00073452-00073643 this issue I have been thinking about
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00110-00073644-00074087 the business model for time MOOC in the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00111-00074088-00074402 birth of time MOOC one thing that I have
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00112-00074403-00074708 been thinking office the concept of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00113-00074709-00075383 udemy that is sustainable by mass but it
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00114-00075384-00076070 would become knowledge market not higher
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00115-00076071-00076328 education not formal degree program a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00116-00076329-00076703 lot more practical issue but in Asian
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00117-00076704-00076886 countries we haven't got something like
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00118-00076887-00077123 that yet so I'm not quite sure maybe one
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00119-00077124-00077612 day if we are at the right time thinking
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00120-00077613-00077932 about this kind of MOOC just for the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00121-00077933-00078284 sustainability and for practical courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00122-00078285-00078686 not not for more horses maybe one day we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00123-00078687-00079196 will so maybe this year maybe you or
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00124-00079197-00079646 someone in our platform can organize
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00125-00079647-00080294 small meeting about this MOOCs
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00126-00080295-00080705 sustainability so we can consider the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00127-00080706-00081257 many propping models like udemy model or
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00128-00081258-00081617 rent rent models
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00129-00081618-00081878 social contribution models there are
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00130-00081879-00082316 lots of models so we cannot uniformly
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00131-00082317-00082607 apply that model to our platforms but
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00132-00082608-00083032 still you can have some insight from our
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00133-00083033-00083607 discussions I think
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00134-00083608-00083967 hmm yes right that it's kind of a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00135-00083968-00084150 conflict yes of course
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00136-00084151-00084896 but Japan J MOOC has an advantage for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00137-00084897-00085344 the profit models because your courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00138-00085345-00085746 most of courses focused on the skill
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00139-00085747-00085971 development and job related courses so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00140-00085972-00086162 you have an advantage
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00141-00086163-00086690 and also the Cayman will we change our
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00142-00086691-00087051 course contents into skill development
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00143-00087052-00087462 and job related courses higher higher
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00144-00087463-00087803 education contents it's not for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00145-00087804-00088329 retraining the company employers so we I
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00146-00088330-00088626 think the next director of the chemo
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00147-00088627-00089102 will seriously consider the changing
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00148-00089103-00089430 contents of our key MOOC otherwise we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00149-00089431-00090249 cannot survive yes right yes yes so so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00150-00090250-00090519 maybe I think open market can be kind of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00151-00090520-00090795 like accommodate yes something like that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00152-00090796-00091116 so udemy of course a very good profit
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00153-00091117-00091644 model but you mentioned some complete or
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00154-00091645-00092016 even only you open like a public free
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00155-00092017-00092559 corns for everyone now you asked the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00156-00092560-00093247 learners to pay for your course yes
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00157-00093248-00093904 no ya achieve a fist on Fuji to provide
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00158-00093905-00094312 a platform called wisdom and some of the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00159-00094313-00094642 course is Jane MOOC certificated courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00160-00094643-00095017 but some apply barely registered courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00161-00095018-00095413 and for example some course include how
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00162-00095414-00095903 to use Microsoft Office product like
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00163-00095904-00096410 food it has the learning education
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00164-00096411-00096679 related food it's a group company so we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00165-00096680-00096913 asked them to create that kind of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00166-00096914-00097294 content and also we have some course for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00167-00097295-00097930 the school teachers too about how to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00168-00097931-00098347 teach programming in high school or in
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00169-00098348-00098581 junior high school so that course is
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00170-00098582-00098844 more related to I think lifelong
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00171-00098845-00099160 education and a little bit different
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00172-00099161-00099619 from academia so piece DOM and Japanese
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00173-00099620-00100210 are platform provider might know some
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00174-00100211-00100628 kind of business oriented or a lifelong
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00176-00103692-00104216 yeah
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00177-00104217-00104790 or others should be below this course
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00178-00104791-00105052 this course is close to school and if
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00179-00105053-00105574 the learners finish this and they test
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00180-00105575-00106041 them if they pass and then they get a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00181-00106042-00106290 certificate from your platform or fidget
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00182-00106291-00106710 and then if they apply four digits maybe
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00183-00106711-00107056 they may be employing something like
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00184-00107057-00107599 that so that is Kate course they should
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00185-00107600-00107968 be paid course not free but it's
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00186-00107969-00108331 different from the courses that we are
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00187-00108332-00108856 providing now so that is the nano model
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00188-00108857-00109254 nano degree model of you decision so the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00189-00109255-00109824 company certified approve the courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00190-00109825-00110193 and then actually we are still doing
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00191-00110194-00110620 brainstorming mean how to earn money
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00192-00110621-00111171 room platform but another
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00193-00111172-00111699 another case is recharge the platform
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00194-00111700-00112398 service fee for the spoke you so if we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00195-00112399-00112668 if the university wants to provide
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00196-00112669-00113073 courses for the massive online then we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00197-00113074-00113424 don't charge but if if the university
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00198-00113425-00114174 want to only fund MOOC they adopt that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00199-00114175-00114434 model
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00200-00114435-00114849 so if a company wants to use that course
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00201-00114850-00115507 as a spoke they should pay so still we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00202-00115508-00116004 still open the course but we can get
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00203-00116005-00116801 some money
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00204-00116802-00117038 may be quite different from the Japanese
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00205-00117039-00117259 because Japanese you have good
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00206-00117260-00117419 discipline
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00207-00117420-00117835 for the tie we will we never will pay if
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00208-00117836-00118249 we can get it for free
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00209-00118250-00118873 is it may be different on this presense
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00210-00118874-00119324 and if you if you have choice and if you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00211-00119325-00119635 want to use you have to pay and another
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00212-00119636-00119951 one we can used for free and then for me
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00213-00119952-00120115 I understand that for company with you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00214-00120116-00120650 people to pay duct-tape repo friend but
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00215-00120651-00120976 I think for tie between undercover see
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00216-00120977-00121467 we will take everything for free first
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00217-00121468-00121906 so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00218-00121907-00122282 in Japan there are some many many free
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00219-00122283-00122618 premium models because this so the I
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00220-00122619-00123038 think the the comp content charge the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00221-00123039-00123332 model is the out-of-date so the content
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00222-00123333-00123599 is serviceable free free over church but
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00223-00123600-00124250 the certification if you want and so sad
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00224-00124251-00124760 strong really satified maybe it should
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00225-00124761-00125348 be searched yes the certificate turn so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00226-00125349-00125711 for what if I have a certificate from J
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00227-00125712-00126035 mu course if some company they
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00228-00126036-00126407 acknowledged our my certificate it will
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00229-00126408-00126884 be useful so like a our puppy mothers
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00230-00126885-00127316 should like go like in tandem with the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00231-00127317-00127649 social recognition and you see something
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00232-00127650-00128093 like that I think that's one of our
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00233-00128094-00128444 parts models we are considering now so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00234-00128445-00128870 we are consider about eleven now so like
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00235-00128871-00129314 YouTube model and social contribution
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00236-00129315-00129993 model so if just the big companies they
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00237-00129994-00130355 develop and operating books for social
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00238-00130356-00130652 contributions so it means we need to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00239-00130653-00130913 find
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00240-00130914-00131116 identify the company
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00241-00131117-00131545 and then we appreciate them if you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00242-00131546-00131857 upload some contents on our platform you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00243-00131858-00132127 have some this kind of benefits blah
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00244-00132128-00132396 blah blah all right and oh yeah skills
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00245-00132397-00132862 something like that it's very hard but
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00246-00132863-00133544 still worse but yes or as the case of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00247-00133545-00133834 the Coursera and Udacity like a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00248-00133835-00134335 subscription rate month monthly based or
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00249-00134336-00134994 yearly barefaced subscription but hey
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00250-00134995-00135309 so this is a problem
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00251-00135310-00135945 well another question I remember the you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00252-00135946-00136419 mentioned before the university would
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00253-00136420-00136749 direct to create and provide their
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00254-00136750-00136809 courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00255-00136810-00137713 if you certify that you provide the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00256-00137714-00138162 50,000 the USL yes per course and up to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00257-00138163-00138399 two courses you provide for the grant
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00258-00138400-00138870 right first year courses development
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00259-00138871-00139229 operating PE and second year to record
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00260-00139230-00139449 three courses development and operating
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00261-00139450-00140000 team and if last year you develop the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00262-00140001-00140336 two courses this year we provide an
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00263-00140337-00141009 operating fee for the two courses so now
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00264-00141010-00141416 we don't we are not going to select more
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00265-00141417-00141779 leading MOOC universities but until last
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00266-00141780-00142281 year we select 10 University as a MOOC
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00267-00142282-00142586 leading University so they have kind of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00268-00142587-00143114 privilege of every year they get secured
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00269-00143115-00143525 they look development operating funds
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00270-00143526-00143840 from government so first year two
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00271-00143841-00144086 courses second year white three courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00272-00144087-00144369 and thirdly our three courses so in
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00273-00144370-00145086 total 8 courses and then every year they
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00274-00145087-00145397 get operating one
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00275-00145398-00145660 from the government
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00276-00145661-00146101 not discarded still same same the price
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00277-00146102-00146665 after three years no puns for operating
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00278-00146666-00147013 in so that's the problem so we are
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00279-00147014-00147310 seriously considering introducing the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00280-00147311-00147982 profit we only serious already the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00281-00147983-00148455 participating university which which
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00282-00148456-00149083 entered that came in 2015 yes as you can
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00283-00149084-00149428 see our presentations to Seoul
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00284-00149429-00149775 Koreans say top-notch universities they
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00285-00149776-00150498 don't get any further fund promise so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00286-00150499-00151009 maybe they drop so you have to introduce
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00287-00151010-00151717 the via new some monetization method
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00288-00151718-00152734 from Viet 2019 2020 serious serious
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00289-00152735-00152800 problems
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00290-00152801-00153292 really
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00291-00153293-00153703 so at the end of this year we plan to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00292-00153704-00154093 have over 500 courses in our platform
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00293-00154094-00154585 but 500 is very important granular
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00294-00154586-00154885 kitchens numbers key yes it's kind of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00295-00154886-00155317 entry very important and 2020 maybe
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00296-00155318-00155680 about thousand courses but I'm not sure
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00297-00155681-00156428 how can secure that those
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00298-00156429-00156807 and also after three years the courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00299-00156808-00157199 developed in the last three years out of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00300-00157200-00157739 18 so we need to improve their the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00301-00157740-00158178 courses so we have no fun
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00302-00158179-00158522 it's really
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00303-00158523-00159220 or recurring issues
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00304-00159221-00159753 yes but from from this coming Mars the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00305-00159754-00160116 courses which are which were interred on
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00306-00160117-00160282 in 2015
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00307-00160283-00160835 27 courses will not operate anymore
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00308-00160836-00161257 actually we lost we have lost already 27
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00309-00161258-00162360 course so currently now so the 10
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00310-00162361-00162897 University they asked us to find out
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00311-00162898-00163464 some way of supporting their courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00312-00163465-00164162 operating
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00313-00164163-00164474 no they don't they don't most of them
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00314-00164475-00164825 they'd only because of the mystic
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00315-00164826-00165940 restricted pond
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00316-00165941-00166239 but still they they need some funda to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00317-00166240-00167285 give the king
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00318-00167286-00167576 how can you motivate your high
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00319-00167577-00167941 universities to continue operating
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00320-00167942-00168281 courses I don't know but for my course I
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00321-00168282-00168818 haven't got paid but you should give
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00322-00168819-00169307 some no no not not only me that is a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00323-00169308-00169772 delay because we need to get the money
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00324-00169773-00170029 at the bunch with al-qasas so this is
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00325-00170030-00170273 not a campaign but the driving force is
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00326-00170274-00170603 not about the money it is about knowing
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00327-00170604-00170849 how to teach time MOOC and be able to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00328-00170850-00171386 continue with this I'm not sure if for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00329-00171387-00171536 time MOOC we are talking now about
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00330-00171537-00171911 gamification for time MOOC it it is
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00331-00171912-00172382 going to be one of the integral part I'm
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00332-00172383-00172718 not sure if Japan MOOC and curry move to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00333-00172719-00172928 have gamification and features for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00334-00172929-00173182 example certain kind of badges or
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00335-00173183-00173565 certain ways how to motivate learners
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00336-00173566-00173979 for intrinsic motivation if so then I
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00337-00173980-00174314 would like to hear from you and if
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00338-00174315-00174706 possible maybe if we can think of common
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00339-00174707-00175097 gamification system so we can encourage
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00340-00175098-00175378 our learners in the same direction for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00341-00175379-00175637 example if we utilize open badges from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00342-00175638-00175940 open passionate oag then that is a kind
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00343-00175941-00176363 of unification format so we can utilize
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00344-00176364-00176786 that to to promote our courses together
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00345-00176787-00177209 and also for the provider the provider
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00346-00177210-00177503 can also get some kind of badges so it
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00347-00177504-00177778 will be meaning to them if they
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00348-00177779-00178052 contributed many good causes good
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00349-00178053-00178370 content they get one kind of bash so I'm
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00350-00178371-00179384 not sure if you you have we select the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00351-00179385-00179619 best courses and best
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00352-00179620-00180183 look based on some indicator and from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00353-00180184-00180456 this year we will it's kind of like
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00354-00180457-00181052 amazon.com cookbook so with the ask
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00355-00181053-00181485 learners to evaluate the chords so put
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00356-00181486-00181884 some stars and then they can write a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00357-00181885-00182628 review and then maybe I'm not sure but
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00358-00182629-00183284 they will give some patch to the line
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00359-00183285-00183720 yes yes public yes it's kind of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00360-00183721-00184207 evaluation of courses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00361-00184208-00184597 for learners
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00362-00184598-00185016 not ours not us they can take and choose
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00363-00185017-00185613 on the basis of review it will require
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00364-00185614-00185976 further investigation it's not like when
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00365-00185977-00186216 you enroll in Khan Academy where you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00366-00186217-00186465 pass one course then you get higher
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00367-00186466-00186840 batch if you has very well Highmark
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00368-00186841-00187062 high score you get another kind of bash
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00369-00187063-00187978 so it's not like that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00370-00187979-00188641 and also in terms of course design I
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00371-00188642-00188926 think Dave gamification is one of the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00372-00188927-00189427 essential picture of course design so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00373-00189428-00189730 some low courses in Coursera and some
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00374-00189731-00190003 some courses they use they adopt the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00375-00190004-00190691 gamification on their course design
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00376-00190692-00191168 so learners they can like enter and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00377-00191169-00191695 follow and they can make something to me
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00378-00191696-00191927 with this more than a little bit more
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00379-00191928-00192110 than that for example we can identify
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00380-00192111-00192491 which learner tend to be serious learner
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00381-00192492-00192779 this group of learners tend to finish
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00382-00192780-00192868 the course
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00383-00192869-00193208 another group window-shopping another
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00384-00193209-00193534 cook just login for the sake of of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00385-00193535-00193931 having that name in the cost list there
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00386-00193932-00194093 would be four groups of people actually
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00387-00194094-00194489 so so we can then predict so many things
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00388-00194490-00194849 predict number of people who really pass
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00389-00194850-00195134 then we can allocate enough resource in
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00390-00195135-00195356 advance so that would be one thing and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00391-00195357-00195605 of course we can identify stock horses
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00392-00195606-00196097 star tutor star lecturers so four-time
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00393-00196098-00196391 MOOC we see this one as a big potential
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00394-00196392-00196700 but in terms of implementation it would
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00395-00196701-00196973 be challenging not quite sure yet how to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00396-00196974-00197369 do that but I hope that since this is a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00397-00197370-00197579 kind of collaboration between Japan
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00398-00197580-00197882 Korea and Thailand MOOC if we can think
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00399-00197883-00198089 of something in the same direction to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00400-00198090-00198458 begin with and then maybe in a few years
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00401-00198459-00198779 from now we may have something that we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00402-00198780-00199250 can utilize in common like you you have
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00403-00199251-00199558 to break down our area of cooperation
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00404-00199559-00199912 into very small ones like a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00405-00199913-00200333 communication and profit model something
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00406-00200334-00200737 like that so I mentioned like around 12
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00407-00200738-00201322 well issues area of issues issue area so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00408-00201323-00201535 we can break down on each and then we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00409-00201536-00201816 have small workshop and then we consider
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00410-00201817-00201898 together
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00411-00201899-00202657 and then maybe one performs they apply
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00412-00202658-00202939 adopt first and then maybe other
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00413-00202940-00203272 platform maybe later because it depends
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00414-00203273-00204139 on the local context so this
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00415-00204140-00204404 not be here this morning so I miss out
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00416-00204405-00204683 of your presentations I'm not quite sure
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00417-00204684-00204988 when you said 12 areas of cooperation
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00418-00204989-00205319 would that already have gamification in
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00419-00205319-00206363 it or keep some an orange star professor
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00420-00206364-00207200 and course but in the future we put some
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00421-00207201-00207876 badge on the best course and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00422-00207877-00208428 now come I would like to to have for you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00423-00208429-00208769 powerful you consider about how work
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00424-00208769-00209235 discussion can be find some opportunity
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00425-00209236-00209865 or some some possible activities to do
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00426-00209866-00210252 together from now on maybe some activity
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00427-00210253-00210542 maybe uh next year on the third year
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00428-00210544-00210857 maybe some activity we can starting now
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00429-00210858-00211275 can be can be find some possible
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00430-00211276-00211517 opportunity possible activity to do
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00431-00211519-00211914 together for example that I I propose
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00432-00211915-00212273 somehow from the point of view from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00433-00212275-00212619 Michael about the communication with
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00434-00212619-00212996 some interested from professor in
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00435-00212998-00213435 Versailles to find some new way of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00436-00213436-00213732 teaching or new strategy or teaching you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00437-00213733-00214005 think Emma situation may be that another
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00438-00214006-00214459 possibility
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00439-00214460-00215065 I wish allow me to back to my last
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00440-00215066-00215607 saliva of course about the area of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00441-00215608-00216042 collaborative activities I would like to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00442-00216044-00216394 to ask you to consider one by one for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00443-00216396-00216665 example each an exiting heart is as
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00444-00216666-00217126 possible I mean that we we exchange the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00445-00217127-00217579 cost that we have already in our MOOC
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00446-00217580-00217846 system but this freedom
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00447-00217848-00218144 maybe we can select on some criteria for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00448-00218144-00218417 the cost at exiting that we can share
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00449-00218417-00218824 for example language Japanese frankly to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00450-00218825-00219157 foreign people Thailand quest to foreign
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00451-00219158-00219349 people something like this this will
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00452-00219350-00219825 benefit people in our country or maybe
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00453-00219826-00220606 some culture in this country that you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00454-00220607-00220897 prefer for example you may may be for a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00455-00220898-00221146 Thai food to cook Thai food cost maybe
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00456-00221148-00221404 we have some you can exchange with you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00457-00221405-00221632 how to cook Japanese or Korean food
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00458-00221633-00221800 something like this maybe it's at a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00459-00221801-00222103 starting point that we can learn from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00460-00222104-00222355 that we can learn from their their
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00461-00222356-00222671 behavior of the culture of the Rena
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00463-00231821-00232162 one of the model for the translation
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00464-00232163-00232504 it's not to be actual jamoke mother but
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00465-00232505-00233233 the NPO I'm a service in popular dia a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00466-00233234-00233592 president of that NPO it's the named
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00467-00233594-00234184 asked Academy they provide the world all
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00468-00234185-00234604 year contents to the japanese runners
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00469-00234605-00234892 after the translation the translation is
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00470-00234892-00235377 made by the totally completely by
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00471-00235378-00235846 volunteers and the volunteers it's just
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00472-00235846-00236059 a dear personal protest not only just
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00473-00236060-00236341 frontiers of atrocity ax organizational
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00474-00236342-00236835 translation translators bonito means the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00475-00236836-00237289 university level activity or the high
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00476-00237290-00237429 school level activity
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00477-00237430-00237778 those are translations very effective
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00478-00237779-00238428 and very high quality because the they
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00479-00238429-00239389 have the pride to beat to burn tears for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00480-00239390-00239965 the social activity as the social
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00481-00239966-00240139 contribution one of the social
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00482-00240140-00240648 contribution so this is maybe one of the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00483-00240648-00241186 case the gem abroad at the moment has
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00484-00241187-00241615 not the standard activity but the ask
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00485-00241616-00241866 Academy is the one of the gimmicks
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00486-00241867-00242839 members so I think not be not impossible
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00487-00242840-00243446 may be possible way and the Uniting dear
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00488-00243448-00243754 English and Korean
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00489-00243755-00244126 maybe it's relatively easier to find out
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00490-00244127-00244473 the a bell ringer in Japan unfortunately
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00491-00244475-00244723 maybe attire and bureaucracies something
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00492-00244723-00245077 I am Not sure but in Thailand
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00493-00245078-00245482 I think the fighting guard tear engage
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00494-00245483-00245875 and the Japanese language you can we can
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00495-00245876-00246379 find they're not difficult it's my image
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00496-00246380-00246544 post my image matter
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00497-00246544-00247140 so the exchanging with the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00498-00247141-00247552 contents is I think also a very nice
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00499-00247553-00249298 idea to education we can fund that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00500-00249298-00249621 University time University 2008 did you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00501-00249623-00249814 have a Japanese to increase our Korean
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00502-00249815-00250189 increase we can fund them to translate
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00503-00250190-00250519 and and on on top of the translation
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00504-00250519-00250780 maybe we can connect a university that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00505-00250781-00251169 you met that is the provider providing
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00506-00251171-00251464 university with the university that was
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00507-00251465-00251680 fun to translate they will connect and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00508-00251681-00251991 maybe they can discuss about the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00509-00251992-00252317 correctness of the translation maybe
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00510-00252319-00252583 develop more collaboration among
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00511-00252584-00252979 university there may be many modules but
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00512-00252980-00253126 but on honey
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00513-00253127-00253623 they will provide a platform if we agree
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00514-00253625-00253990 we can continue to depend upon their
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00515-00253991-00256792 their the this project about a king
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00516-00256792-00257067 in Japan similar situation so the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00517-00257069-00257690 copyright existing University the GMAC
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00519-00261210-00262244 our idea is they're using the volunteer
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00520-00262245-00262646 is it more easy if each country's
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00521-00262647-00262946 answering from local language to English
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00522-00262947-00263321 and they may be exchanged with more more
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00523-00263322-00263651 easier for other country translating it
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00524-00263652-00264004 to their own local language that we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00525-00264005-00264368 should find the good model but can
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00526-00264369-00264694 isomerize that this is a possible
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00527-00264695-00265400 collaborative activity among give you we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00528-00265401-00265868 will find review work in detail of how
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00529-00265869-00266318 to do together hi I would like to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00530-00266319-00266600 propose about the earlier hochter costs
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00531-00266601-00267188 that vary in context of the country not
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00532-00267189-00267740 the science really I mean about the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00533-00267741-00268064 culture the languages there everything
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00534-00268065-00268555 that very specialized if we learn from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00535-00268556-00268901 the native is very very good and very
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00536-00268902-00269345 motivated to learn that I recorded if
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00537-00269346-00269744 this area is the priority technically of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00538-00269745-00269915 course it'll be looking forward to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00540-00274617-00274956 yeah we can we don't we don't need
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00541-00274957-00275799 translation we just learning you mean
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00542-00275800-00276018 the Korean courses is there to the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00543-00276019-00276356 person food director Lang Korea in
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00544-00276357-00277263 English right
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00545-00277264-00279737 three
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00546-00279738-00280084 the report also I think like elementary
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00547-00280085-00280471 fourth and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00548-00280472-00280771 and then
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00549-00280772-00281212 we we have a we have a proposal for a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00550-00281213-00281977 linear type of arena
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00552-00285223-00285513 what is that the target of this court
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00553-00285514-00285789 for the foreign foreign air let go to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00554-00285790-00287081 Korean in Thailand there is a Korean
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00555-00287082-00287289 education and cultural center nearby
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00556-00287290-00287783 here they're responsible for teaching :
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00557-00287784-00288027 language to many Thai people for
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00558-00288028-00288378 different reasons first Thai wife Thai
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00559-00288379-00288659 women get married to Korean guy before
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00560-00288660-00288881 they can migrate to Korea they have to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00561-00288882-00289215 pass as a level of examination and two
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00562-00289216-00289551 years ago topic base and three years ago
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00563-00289552-00289855 I see on cyber University project did
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00564-00289856-00290289 Commission's Korea's cyber university to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00565-00290290-00291460 create some content already available
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00566-00291461-00291774 no but this is government by Korean
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00567-00291775-00291939 government so it has that kind of
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00568-00291940-00292248 privilege so if it is not just by any
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00569-00292249-00292454 school it is by Korean government
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00570-00292455-00292706 entrustment level is very high second
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00571-00292707-00292968 thing is there to a guide tied to a kind
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00572-00292969-00293301 who look after Korean tourists tight
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00573-00293302-00293544 work I do already have permit but they
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00574-00293545-00293727 don't really understand Korean culture
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00575-00293728-00293927 so they could not look after Korean
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00576-00293928-00294203 people were enough so they have another
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00577-00294204-00294495 kind of program but they cannot cope the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00578-00294496-00294768 office is small they could not train
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00579-00294769-00295098 enough so they need something like this
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00580-00295099-00295314 so if we can have something in common
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00581-00295315-00295626 that they can utilize well I think we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00582-00295627-00296105 already have market yes yes from from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00583-00296106-00296319 this Center under Korean government
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00584-00296320-00299099 maybe in partnership with our initiative
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00585-00299100-00299563 I think for the Japanese academia site
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00586-00299564-00299996 one of the motivation might be to get
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00587-00299997-00300320 more following student from for example
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00588-00300321-00300755 Korea or Thailand studying in Japan so I
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00589-00300756-00301031 think the beginner level of their
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00590-00301032-00301435 Japanese language course might be good
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00591-00301436-00301844 for not for only for the course learners
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00592-00301845-00302105 but also the host provider University
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00593-00302106-00304293 can also benefit
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00594-00304294-00304701 I would like to suggest that may be a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00595-00304702-00305097 bit difficult because you have many very
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00596-00305098-00305373 strong copyright issues in Japanese and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00597-00305374-00305670 maybe in Korean also so maybe difficult
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00598-00305671-00305967 to to exchange
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00599-00305968-00306260 I mean to upload the content in other
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00600-00306261-00306588 platform
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00601-00306589-00306806 differing from from from Europe your own
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00602-00306807-00306878 headphone
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00603-00306879-00307176 maybe we can starting from you open and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00604-00307177-00307494 allow higher country people to learn
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00605-00307495-00307767 from your platform but have had some
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00606-00307768-00308309 special conditions to allow from the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00607-00308310-00309041 phone
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00608-00309042-00309440 anybody want me yes right anybody people
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00609-00309441-00310380 for New Year's right
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00610-00310381-00310842 it's a very limited courses but some
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00611-00310843-00311049 course is provided in English in from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00612-00311050-00311591 Japan Japanese Japanese patents and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00613-00311592-00312174 wisdom course of provided the English
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00614-00312175-00312654 courses there as a first course and the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00615-00312655-00312807 training course the open language
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00616-00312808-00313149 Japan's or so they can provide not only
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00617-00313150-00313407 the Japanese English and maybe Korean
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00618-00313408-00315714 the Chinese
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00619-00315715-00315993 luxury for the Brahmin and the Muslim
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00620-00315994-00316326 said the progeny is a university person
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00621-00316327-00316725 the aim is to get more student from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00622-00316726-00317013 their foreign countries so to rewrite
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00623-00317014-00317660 that the better way is to provide from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00624-00317661-00318012 the those countries bottom like a Korea
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00625-00318013-00318675 and China I just worry about your copy
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00626-00318676-00318948 like human but is it possible this is
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00627-00318949-00319202 the best best way we can change and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00628-00319203-00320964 provide with our own platform
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00629-00320965-00321444 the possible activity okay I could good
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00630-00321445-00321540 night
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00631-00321541-00322106 go to the next perk or do we can do a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00632-00322107-00322473 chorus of comparative research this is
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00633-00322474-00322733 the topic that we mentioned in this
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00634-00322734-00323118 morning about quality excellent evil
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00635-00323119-00323429 possible maybe we nominate the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00636-00323430-00323723 researcher from East platform and maybe
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00637-00323724-00324546 they can work together and yeah
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00638-00324547-00325445 yeah
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00639-00325446-00326598 the procedure
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00640-00326599-00327149 to share the current version of their
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00641-00327150-00327501 cost guiding each other we agree with
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00642-00327502-00328156 that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00643-00328157-00328844 so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00644-00328845-00329356 from from time aside the head of the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00645-00329357-00329591 researcher maybe dr. Provine yeah but
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00646-00329592-00329969 maybe more researcher from Tyson but you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00647-00329970-00331459 can nominate
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00648-00331460-00331897 I think we can do it just only provide
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00649-00331898-00332272 our current version so it's very
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00650-00332273-00332608 difficult to translate from now in a
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00651-00332609-00332974 short time
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00652-00332975-00334171 no just a Japanese only okay
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00653-00334172-00334531 I think if you have any researcher you
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00654-00334532-00334786 know the teacher faculty member in the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00655-00334787-00334990 university that interest in this area
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00656-00334991-00335239 you can nominate that they can work
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00657-00335240-00335746 together so but the it's my at the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00658-00335747-00336034 moment my personal in your level but we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00659-00336035-00336376 are not trying to make the translation
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00660-00336377-00336979 in a Jamie coffees the current version
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00661-00336980-00337356 to the English but after the discussion
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00662-00337357-00337759 the at the moment we can I cannot
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00663-00337760-00338412 promise
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00664-00338413-00338688 okay so I will symbolize that this is
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00665-00338689-00339045 another possibility to and will be lit
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00666-00339046-00339321 by read by time or research online and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00667-00339322-00339786 then ot mo ang mo kio provide the color
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00668-00339787-00340265 in maybe in English English version and
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00669-00340266-00340554 providing support for the time
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00671-00351096-00351484 thank you so how about analyte analyzer
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00672-00351485-00351875 and learning behavior in our cooperating
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00674-00359035-00359407 have you suggested maybe when the Korea
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00675-00359408-00359662 University open the more cars maybe
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00677-00363807-00364120 tomorrow in the abstinence session I
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00678-00364121-00364505 have you care about our symbolized in
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00679-00364506-00364709 this session and with true program
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00680-00364710-00365009 together maybe we can some align our
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00681-00365010-00365273 conclusion some possible activity with
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00682-00365274-00365501 with the agreement from our stakeholders
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00683-00365502-00366538 carpeting
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00684-00366539-00366867 okay and the regarding their running
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00685-00366868-00367508 analytics people in Japan will start the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00686-00367509-00367802 research group or the running analytics
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00687-00367803-00368574 at the moment the biggest group of the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00688-00368575-00368842 Reina Valera texting Japanese nervously
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00689-00368843-00369674 this is Cote University and the riddler
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00690-00369675-00369967 running analytics center in Kyoto
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00691-00369968-00370065 University
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00692-00370066-00370499 agreed to cooperate with the agenda so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00693-00370500-00371550 we like to join that for the project as
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00694-00371551-00373561 there are research projects cooperation
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00695-00373562-00373792 it mean that men had a time up Cory
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00696-00373793-00373948 University Rhonda book
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00697-00373949-00374206 Rhonda more cars maybe with any custom
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00698-00374207-00375162 still came from
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00699-00375163-00375387 take a Cosmo Cordia
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00700-00375388-00375846 yeah so the tree nation to country
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00701-00375847-00376083 students learn the same past same cost
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00702-00376084-00378375 and then we will see what will happen
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00703-00378376-00380672 okay
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00704-00380673-00380980 yes you can conduct a really small
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00705-00380981-00381323 expert meeting consultative meeting
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00706-00381324-00381706 something and a faculty member that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00707-00381707-00381902 participated in this project you can
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00708-00381903-00382081 discuss about your result and maybe
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00709-00382082-00383479 co-published some ethical Channel yeah
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00710-00383480-00383902 okay so I bought two possible agenda
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00711-00383903-00384237 then the turret agenda I think I
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00712-00384238-00384520 couldn't have your Chi mission saying if
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00713-00384521-00384849 you are out daughter so you have any
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00714-00384850-00386284 idea about cohorts and SEM or as a more
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00715-00386285-00387909 Porthos take right
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00716-00387910-00388326 if they it is a DSM looks first as a mr.
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00717-00388327-00388390 Cruthers
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00718-00388391-00388840 Samet be a chemical host that they are
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00720-00392592-00393301 okay
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00721-00393302-00393400 Oh
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00722-00393401-00394437 [Music]
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00723-00394438-00395248 every way every year anyway oh I have to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00724-00395249-00396753 so in the middle here
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00725-00396754-00397075 it's a long case study for the open
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00726-00397076-00397414 education consortium and your meeting it
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00727-00397415-00397957 is that from the mm actuary mm AB six or
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00728-00397958-00398005 something
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00729-00398006-00398314 so the first three years the Utah State
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00730-00398315-00398778 University hosted the after the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00731-00398779-00399258 organization launched the the host
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00732-00399259-00399627 University changed rotated rotation
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00733-00399628-00400289 rotated system the first host company
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00734-00400290-00400531 was that Japan the acute University
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00735-00400532-00401001 hosted that in 2000 it is 2006
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00736-00401002-00401912 so maybe 2004 six four five the three
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00737-00401913-00402223 four five so you use the university
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00738-00402224-00402654 instead then the many University hosted
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00739-00402655-00403347 actually the this year yet the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00740-00403348-00403555 technological university of Delta tu
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00742-00414545-00415149 okay
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00743-00415150-00415439 okay so how can i summarize the third
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00745-00419447-00419797 which are aware former representative so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00747-00426534-00427076 so I have a assemble I that we you have
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00748-00427077-00427543 a nest neck nesting in - neck misting
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00749-00427545-00427813 hopper has to be I can has a more
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00750-00427814-00430589 confident maybe on me 2018 right
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00751-00430589-00431809 mei-mei our October October life
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00752-00431810-00432010 okay
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00753-00432010-00432160 kekeke okay
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00754-00432162-00432421 well
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00755-00432422-00433066 I think I need coachable okay I this is
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00756-00433067-00433450 all these free herself from like that we
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00757-00433451-00433735 have already discussed you have helped
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00758-00433736-00434564 over so to to propose me the there has
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00759-00434564-00434845 been a discussion since last year that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00760-00434846-00435231 Malaysia MOOC would like to also join us
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00761-00435232-00436762 JMO JMO time MOOC but and also yes yes I
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00762-00436763-00438171 know yes welcome no problem to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00763-00438172-00438643 opportunities here they are happier
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00764-00438644-00439622 there's no more platform
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00765-00439622-00440078 so we how can we study do we have to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00766-00440079-00440426 invite by our sera we take the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00767-00440427-00440666 opportunity of as a MOOC to discuss
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00769-00446834-00447087 and the final
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00770-00447088-00447539 practically in the East Asian region the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00773-00466732-00467281 we we have a discussion and we still
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00774-00467282-00467589 consider that we have to to carefully
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00775-00467590-00467922 think about it but very positive I think
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00776-00467923-00468312 very positive but a team and many
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00777-00468313-00468789 resources and also time that we have to
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00778-00468790-00469120 contribute but very very good thing that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00779-00469121-00469479 we should to read everything about have
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00780-00469480-00469791 a internal meeting but this year in this
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00781-00469792-00470154 year CCU you have many activity
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00782-00470155-00470493 including many expert forum some
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00783-00470494-00470743 accomplished journalist so maybe there's
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00784-00470743-00471118 a good opportunity to to take that that
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00785-00471118-00471747 even some meeting and we will be across
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00786-00471748-00472014 we will let you know very first person
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00787-00472015-00472422 have to be my decision okay so at least
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00788-00472423-00472722 we have two possible collaborative
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00789-00472723-00473095 activities together maybe more in the
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00790-00473096-00473535 future okay I think we work very hard
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00791-00473536-00473918 and from one local and union folk rock
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00792-00473919-00474285 without any break we serve we break
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00793-00474286-00474652 inside the room so do you have any point
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00794-00474653-00475179 to suggest to convene or to recommend
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00796-00479231-00479769 okay so I think the really tired now so
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00797-00479770-00480070 please take some rest we will have
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00798-00480071-00480433 dinner together on 6 o clock in the same
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00799-00480434-00480955 prayers Atlanta six today you see ya
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00800-00480956-00481279 so you knew we have some time to walk
+MPa9wM3xrd4-00802-00486588-00486934 [Music]
+MPcntT8OS6I-00000-00000030-00000434 George Edwin Mueller July 16th 1918 to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00001-00000436-00000696 October 12 2015 was an American
+MPcntT8OS6I-00002-00000697-00000897 electrical engineer who was an associate
+MPcntT8OS6I-00003-00000898-00001089 administrator at NASA who headed the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00004-00001090-00001257 office of manned spaceflight from
+MPcntT8OS6I-00005-00001258-00001638 September 1963 until December 1969
+MPcntT8OS6I-00006-00001639-00001950 haled is one of NASA's most brilliant
+MPcntT8OS6I-00007-00001951-00002187 and fearless managers he was
+MPcntT8OS6I-00008-00002188-00002388 instrumental in introducing the all up
+MPcntT8OS6I-00009-00002389-00002592 testing philosophy for the Saturn V
+MPcntT8OS6I-00010-00002593-00002801 launch vehicle which ensured the success
+MPcntT8OS6I-00011-00002802-00002984 of the Apollo program in landing a man
+MPcntT8OS6I-00012-00002985-00003185 on the moon and returning him safely to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00013-00003186-00003561 the earth by the end of 1969 Muller also
+MPcntT8OS6I-00014-00003561-00003704 played a key part in the design of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00015-00003705-00003938 Skylab and championed the space shuttles
+MPcntT8OS6I-00016-00003939-00004064 development which earned him the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00017-00004065-00004410 nickname the father of the space shuttle
+MPcntT8OS6I-00018-00004411-00004641 more recently Muller was chairman and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00019-00004642-00004803 chief vehicle architect of the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00020-00004804-00005297 now-defunct Kistler aerospace Corp
+MPcntT8OS6I-00021-00005298-00005891 topic early life in education
+MPcntT8OS6I-00022-00005892-00006109 George Mueller was born in st. Louis
+MPcntT8OS6I-00023-00006110-00006556 Missouri on July 16th 1918 his mother a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00024-00006558-00006760 high school graduate was from Belleville
+MPcntT8OS6I-00025-00006761-00006977 Illinois and had been a secretary but
+MPcntT8OS6I-00026-00006978-00007130 she never worked after marriage
+MPcntT8OS6I-00027-00007131-00007384 his father was an electrician who began
+MPcntT8OS6I-00028-00007386-00007580 working as a boy and never went to high
+MPcntT8OS6I-00029-00007581-00007763 school but later became superintendent
+MPcntT8OS6I-00030-00007764-00008002 of an electrical motor repair shop in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00031-00008003-00008258 st. Louis both parents were English
+MPcntT8OS6I-00032-00008259-00008503 speakers but also spoke German Muller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00033-00008504-00008663 never learned German well enough to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00034-00008664-00008957 converse he went to Benton School in st.
+MPcntT8OS6I-00035-00008958-00009166 Louis until the eighth grade when he and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00036-00009167-00009368 his parents moved to a larger house in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00037-00009369-00009548 the country called Belle Noir and later
+MPcntT8OS6I-00038-00009549-00009863 graduated from Normandy high school the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00039-00009864-00010046 young Mueller enjoyed reading science
+MPcntT8OS6I-00040-00010047-00010202 fiction and helped by his grandfather
+MPcntT8OS6I-00041-00010203-00010535 woodworking when he was aged 11 or 12
+MPcntT8OS6I-00042-00010536-00010741 Muller also built and raced model
+MPcntT8OS6I-00043-00010742-00010969 aircraft such as gliders and rubber band
+MPcntT8OS6I-00044-00010970-00011285 model airplanes always curious about how
+MPcntT8OS6I-00045-00011286-00011471 things worked he also built radios
+MPcntT8OS6I-00046-00011472-00011703 following in the footsteps of his father
+MPcntT8OS6I-00047-00011704-00011927 interested in these activities the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00048-00011928-00012077 teenage Muller wanted to be an
+MPcntT8OS6I-00049-00012078-00012271 aeronautical engineer but discovered
+MPcntT8OS6I-00050-00012272-00012409 that where he could afford to go to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00051-00012410-00012631 school the Missouri School of Mines and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00052-00012632-00012844 metallurgy now Missouri University of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00053-00012845-00013109 Science and Technology in Rolla Missouri
+MPcntT8OS6I-00054-00013110-00013286 there was no aeronautical engineering
+MPcntT8OS6I-00055-00013287-00013538 department they did offer mechanical
+MPcntT8OS6I-00056-00013538-00013706 engineering so he enrolled in that
+MPcntT8OS6I-00057-00013707-00013909 program but found it discouraging and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00058-00013910-00014109 switched to electrical engineering
+MPcntT8OS6I-00059-00014110-00014338 Muller assumed he would end up working
+MPcntT8OS6I-00060-00014340-00014546 in industry and so in his senior year
+MPcntT8OS6I-00061-00014547-00014750 went on a tour of various suitable
+MPcntT8OS6I-00062-00014751-00015059 companies he applied to RCA General
+MPcntT8OS6I-00063-00015060-00015236 Electric and Emerson but when he
+MPcntT8OS6I-00064-00015237-00015509 graduated in 1939 the economy took
+MPcntT8OS6I-00065-00015510-00015688 another downturn and heat like most of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00066-00015690-00016019 the class had no job after applying to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00067-00016019-00016225 several graduate schools he got an offer
+MPcntT8OS6I-00068-00016226-00016484 of a television fellowship funded by RCA
+MPcntT8OS6I-00069-00016485-00016802 at Purdue University the fellowship led
+MPcntT8OS6I-00070-00016803-00016949 to his working on an early television
+MPcntT8OS6I-00071-00016950-00017246 project Purdue was building a television
+MPcntT8OS6I-00072-00017247-00017425 transmitter for the campus and it was
+MPcntT8OS6I-00073-00017426-00017605 the first of the kind that was using all
+MPcntT8OS6I-00074-00017606-00017887 vacuum tubes to produce the pictures it
+MPcntT8OS6I-00075-00017888-00018094 was also the first using a cathode ray
+MPcntT8OS6I-00076-00018095-00018386 tube for display purposes they still had
+MPcntT8OS6I-00077-00018387-00018584 mechanical discs for scanning but we're
+MPcntT8OS6I-00078-00018585-00018746 trying to develop an all-electronic
+MPcntT8OS6I-00079-00018747-00019110 approach
+MPcntT8OS6I-00080-00019111-00019630 topic Bell Labs
+MPcntT8OS6I-00081-00019631-00019876 near graduation he applied for a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00082-00019877-00020068 research job at Bell Labs which he
+MPcntT8OS6I-00083-00020069-00020283 received after a year to establish
+MPcntT8OS6I-00084-00020284-00020536 himself there he married Maude Rosenbaum
+MPcntT8OS6I-00085-00020537-00020749 whom he had met in st. Louis and dated
+MPcntT8OS6I-00086-00020750-00021004 while at Purdue the work Mueller did at
+MPcntT8OS6I-00087-00021005-00021169 Bell Labs deferred him from being
+MPcntT8OS6I-00088-00021170-00021358 drafted into the military during World
+MPcntT8OS6I-00089-00021359-00021672 War two he initially researched orthicon
+MPcntT8OS6I-00090-00021673-00021900 technology but as Bell Labs geared up
+MPcntT8OS6I-00091-00021901-00022117 for war it later became heavily involved
+MPcntT8OS6I-00092-00022118-00022438 in airborne radar technology as the war
+MPcntT8OS6I-00093-00022439-00022636 progressed his group was given the task
+MPcntT8OS6I-00094-00022637-00022849 of building the first airborne radar for
+MPcntT8OS6I-00095-00022850-00023140 Bell ultimately the radar designed by
+MPcntT8OS6I-00096-00023141-00023410 MIT was chosen over the Bell Labs system
+MPcntT8OS6I-00097-00023411-00023587 but not until after Mueller became
+MPcntT8OS6I-00098-00023588-00023809 spectacularly sick while flight testing
+MPcntT8OS6I-00099-00023810-00024003 bell labs radar on a visit to Wright
+MPcntT8OS6I-00100-00024004-00024292 airfield in Ohio he continued his work
+MPcntT8OS6I-00101-00024293-00024514 on magnetrons and said he came close to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00102-00024515-00024790 Co inventing the transistor if he and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00103-00024791-00024997 his co-workers had placed their contacts
+MPcntT8OS6I-00104-00024998-00025189 on a single crystal of zircon rather
+MPcntT8OS6I-00105-00025190-00025393 than working with multiple crystals they
+MPcntT8OS6I-00106-00025394-00025569 would have beaten Shockley's team also
+MPcntT8OS6I-00107-00025570-00025890 at Bell Labs topic PhD and Rhema
+MPcntT8OS6I-00108-00025891-00026100 Wooldridge Mueller increasingly believed
+MPcntT8OS6I-00109-00026101-00026283 that to move up in the hierarchy of the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00110-00026285-00026524 labs he would need a PhD and he began
+MPcntT8OS6I-00111-00026525-00026713 working towards this goal on a part-time
+MPcntT8OS6I-00112-00026714-00026952 basis at Princeton University getting up
+MPcntT8OS6I-00113-00026953-00027151 every morning at around 5 o'clock and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00114-00027152-00027337 driving to Princeton to take a couple of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00115-00027338-00027529 courses before driving back down to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00116-00027530-00027821 Holmdel to work all day at Bell Labs in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00117-00027822-00028117 1946 a colleague at the labs Milton boon
+MPcntT8OS6I-00118-00028118-00028369 a professor from Ohio State University
+MPcntT8OS6I-00119-00028370-00028545 on leave at Bell Labs during the war
+MPcntT8OS6I-00120-00028547-00028735 encouraged Mueller to help set up a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00121-00028736-00028885 vacuum tube lab and run the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00122-00028886-00029095 communications group at Ohio State
+MPcntT8OS6I-00123-00029095-00029326 moving to Columbus Muller taught
+MPcntT8OS6I-00124-00029327-00029520 electrical engineering and the new field
+MPcntT8OS6I-00125-00029522-00029731 of system engineering and continued his
+MPcntT8OS6I-00126-00029732-00029974 research focusing his PhD thesis on
+MPcntT8OS6I-00127-00029975-00030264 dielectric antennas upon obtaining his
+MPcntT8OS6I-00128-00030266-00030556 doctorate in physics in 1951 he became
+MPcntT8OS6I-00129-00030557-00030742 associate professor of Electrical
+MPcntT8OS6I-00130-00030743-00031033 Engineering Remo Wooldridge Corporation
+MPcntT8OS6I-00131-00031033-00031312 later part of TRW recruited him and he
+MPcntT8OS6I-00132-00031313-00031626 took a one-year sabbatical in 1953 a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00133-00031627-00031887 consultant to Remo Wooldridge Muller got
+MPcntT8OS6I-00134-00031888-00032104 involved in the review of radar designs
+MPcntT8OS6I-00135-00032105-00032308 and the Bell Labs radar for the Titan
+MPcntT8OS6I-00136-00032308-00032538 rocket which was originally radio guided
+MPcntT8OS6I-00137-00032539-00032779 Muller was peripherally involved with
+MPcntT8OS6I-00138-00032780-00032952 some of the developments of the inertial
+MPcntT8OS6I-00139-00032953-00032999 system
+MPcntT8OS6I-00140-00033000-00033173 and generally began to help out wherever
+MPcntT8OS6I-00141-00033174-00033463 there was a problem Mueller admitted in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00142-00033464-00033707 1987 that at this time he did not know
+MPcntT8OS6I-00143-00033708-00033977 anything about missiles after returning
+MPcntT8OS6I-00144-00033978-00034163 from his sabbatical year to Ohio State
+MPcntT8OS6I-00145-00034164-00034397 Mueller taught but was also retained as
+MPcntT8OS6I-00146-00034398-00034811 a part-time consultant to RW in 1957 he
+MPcntT8OS6I-00147-00034812-00035015 joined Rhema Wooldridge full-time as
+MPcntT8OS6I-00148-00035016-00035231 director of the electronics laboratories
+MPcntT8OS6I-00149-00035232-00035495 this laboratory soon merged with the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00150-00035496-00035690 mechanical group and then Muller became
+MPcntT8OS6I-00151-00035691-00035888 deputy leader of this larger research
+MPcntT8OS6I-00152-00035889-00036155 and development organization he was also
+MPcntT8OS6I-00153-00036156-00036392 program director for the Pioneer program
+MPcntT8OS6I-00154-00036393-00036563 and later took over as head of R&D
+MPcntT8OS6I-00155-00036564-00036865 research and development the Thompson
+MPcntT8OS6I-00156-00036866-00037112 products company bought RW and merged it
+MPcntT8OS6I-00157-00037113-00037427 into what became t RW while working on
+MPcntT8OS6I-00158-00037428-00037652 missile systems Muller became convinced
+MPcntT8OS6I-00159-00037653-00037847 that all up testing was essential as you
+MPcntT8OS6I-00160-00037848-00038024 don't want to be testing piecewise in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00161-00038025-00038321 space you want to test the entire system
+MPcntT8OS6I-00162-00038322-00038480 because who knows which one's going to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00163-00038481-00038636 fail and you'd better have it all
+MPcntT8OS6I-00164-00038637-00038849 together so that whatever fails you have
+MPcntT8OS6I-00165-00038850-00039032 a reasonable chance of finding the real
+MPcntT8OS6I-00166-00039033-00039221 failure mode not just the one you were
+MPcntT8OS6I-00167-00039222-00039428 looking for topic NASA and the Apollo
+MPcntT8OS6I-00168-00039429-00039608 program Muller became increasingly
+MPcntT8OS6I-00169-00039609-00039806 involved with NASA and the Apollo
+MPcntT8OS6I-00170-00039807-00040121 program NASA's Administrator James E
+MPcntT8OS6I-00171-00040122-00040360 Webb sounded Muller out for a top job
+MPcntT8OS6I-00172-00040361-00040615 Muller would only agree if the agency
+MPcntT8OS6I-00173-00040616-00040805 was restructured and so during the fall
+MPcntT8OS6I-00174-00040806-00041090 of 1963 Webb worked with associate
+MPcntT8OS6I-00175-00041091-00041267 administrator Robert seaman's to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00176-00041268-00041471 restructure NASA shifting three key
+MPcntT8OS6I-00177-00041472-00041732 centers manned spacecraft Center MSC
+MPcntT8OS6I-00178-00041733-00042032 Marshall Space Flight Center MSFC and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00179-00042033-00042233 the launch Operations Center locked to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00180-00042234-00042428 report directly to Muller as well as a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00181-00042429-00042698 local staff at headquarters Muller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00182-00042699-00042871 accepted the job and took a substantial
+MPcntT8OS6I-00183-00042872-00043181 pay cut the reorganization of NASA in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00184-00043182-00043421 the office of manned spaceflight OMS F
+MPcntT8OS6I-00185-00043422-00043696 was announced in November 1963
+MPcntT8OS6I-00186-00043697-00043961 encouraged by Webb Muller had studied
+MPcntT8OS6I-00187-00043962-00044153 the three centers speaking with people
+MPcntT8OS6I-00188-00044154-00044282 he knew from his work at Rhema
+MPcntT8OS6I-00189-00044283-00044549 Wooldridge his impression there wasn't
+MPcntT8OS6I-00190-00044550-00044798 any management system in existence more
+MPcntT8OS6I-00191-00044799-00045023 seriously Muller found no means to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00192-00045024-00045182 determine and control hardware
+MPcntT8OS6I-00193-00045183-00045368 configurations which gave no way to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00194-00045369-00045659 determine costs her schedules Muller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00195-00045660-00045877 concluded he would have to teach people
+MPcntT8OS6I-00196-00045878-00046090 what was involved in doing program
+MPcntT8OS6I-00197-00046091-00046385 control in August 1960
+MPcntT8OS6I-00198-00046386-00046552 three muller invited each of his three
+MPcntT8OS6I-00199-00046553-00046783 field center directors to visit him and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00200-00046784-00046976 explained how his proposed changes would
+MPcntT8OS6I-00201-00046977-00047186 put Apollo back on schedule and solve
+MPcntT8OS6I-00202-00047187-00047370 problems with the Bureau of the budget
+MPcntT8OS6I-00203-00047371-00047648 change did not come easy and he had some
+MPcntT8OS6I-00204-00047649-00047849 problems with Wernher von Braun who gave
+MPcntT8OS6I-00205-00047850-00048086 one of his impassioned speeches about
+MPcntT8OS6I-00206-00048087-00048260 how you can't change the basic
+MPcntT8OS6I-00207-00048261-00048574 organization of Marshall after some
+MPcntT8OS6I-00208-00048575-00048776 argument von Braun accepted Mueller's
+MPcntT8OS6I-00209-00048777-00049018 proposals and reorganized MSFC
+MPcntT8OS6I-00210-00049019-00049217 strengthening its capacity and running
+MPcntT8OS6I-00211-00049218-00049529 large projects Mueller's position was
+MPcntT8OS6I-00212-00049530-00049817 strengthened by directors at MSC MSFC
+MPcntT8OS6I-00213-00049818-00050083 and Locke reporting directly to OMS F
+MPcntT8OS6I-00214-00050084-00050348 Mueller also reduced attendance at the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00215-00050349-00050567 manned spaceflight management council to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00216-00050568-00050785 just himself in the center directors
+MPcntT8OS6I-00217-00050786-00050999 borrowing from the US Air Force
+MPcntT8OS6I-00218-00051000-00051200 Minuteman Program Mueller formed the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00219-00051201-00051425 Apollo executive group which consisted
+MPcntT8OS6I-00220-00051426-00051571 of himself and the presidents of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00221-00051572-00051877 Apollo's main contractors the biggest
+MPcntT8OS6I-00222-00051878-00052102 problem Mueller still faced was Apollo's
+MPcntT8OS6I-00223-00052103-00052344 slipping schedule and huge cost overruns
+MPcntT8OS6I-00224-00052345-00052586 he had always thought the only way to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00225-00052587-00052807 resolve this and achieve a lunar landing
+MPcntT8OS6I-00226-00052808-00053063 before 1970 was to reduce the number of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00227-00053064-00053344 test flights Mueller wanted to use his
+MPcntT8OS6I-00228-00053345-00053660 all up testing concept with each flight
+MPcntT8OS6I-00229-00053661-00053840 using the full number of life stages
+MPcntT8OS6I-00230-00053841-00054076 this approach had been used successfully
+MPcntT8OS6I-00231-00054077-00054319 on the Titan 2 and Minuteman programs
+MPcntT8OS6I-00232-00054320-00054548 but violated von Braun's engineering
+MPcntT8OS6I-00233-00054549-00054856 concepts the von braun test plan called
+MPcntT8OS6I-00234-00054857-00055030 for the first live test to use the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00235-00055032-00055229 Saturn's first stage with dummy upper
+MPcntT8OS6I-00236-00055229-00055475 stages if the first stage worked
+MPcntT8OS6I-00237-00055476-00055651 correctly then the first two stages
+MPcntT8OS6I-00238-00055652-00055850 would be live with a dummy third stage
+MPcntT8OS6I-00239-00055851-00056068 and so on with at least 10 test flights
+MPcntT8OS6I-00240-00056069-00056242 before a manned version was put into
+MPcntT8OS6I-00241-00056244-00056554 low-earth orbit the Saturn V program
+MPcntT8OS6I-00242-00056555-00056788 manager Arthur Rudolph cornered Mueller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00243-00056789-00056950 with scale models of Saturn and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00244-00056951-00057181 Minuteman the saturn dwarfed the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00245-00057182-00057522 Minuteman but Muller replied so what
+MPcntT8OS6I-00246-00057523-00057750 eventually von Braun and the others were
+MPcntT8OS6I-00247-00057751-00058055 won over as von Braun stated it sounded
+MPcntT8OS6I-00248-00058057-00058275 reckless but George Mueller's reasoning
+MPcntT8OS6I-00249-00058276-00058545 was impeccable water ballast in lieu of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00250-00058546-00058785 a second and third stage would require
+MPcntT8OS6I-00251-00058786-00059016 much less tank volume than liquid
+MPcntT8OS6I-00252-00059016-00059277 hydrogen fueled stages so that a rocket
+MPcntT8OS6I-00253-00059278-00059487 tested with only a live first stage
+MPcntT8OS6I-00254-00059488-00059664 would be much shorter than the final
+MPcntT8OS6I-00255-00059665-00060009 configuration its aerodynamic shape and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00256-00060010-00060216 its body dynamics would thus not be
+MPcntT8OS6I-00257-00060216-00060516 representative filling the ballast tanks
+MPcntT8OS6I-00258-00060516-00060789 with liquid hydrogen fine but then why
+MPcntT8OS6I-00259-00060790-00061101 not burn it as a bonus experiment and so
+MPcntT8OS6I-00260-00061102-00061314 the arguments went on until George in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00261-00061315-00061454 the end prevailed
+MPcntT8OS6I-00262-00061454-00061710 Mueller's concept of all up testing
+MPcntT8OS6I-00263-00061711-00061955 worked the first two unmanned flights of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00264-00061957-00062175 the Saturn V were successful the second
+MPcntT8OS6I-00265-00062176-00062391 less so then the third Saturn V put
+MPcntT8OS6I-00266-00062391-00062610 Frank borman's Apollo 8 crew in orbit
+MPcntT8OS6I-00267-00062611-00062891 round the moon on Christmas 1968 and the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00268-00062892-00063114 sixth Saturn V carried Neil Armstrong's
+MPcntT8OS6I-00269-00063115-00063362 Apollo 11 to the first lunar landing in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00270-00063363-00063629 an interview Mueller acknowledged what
+MPcntT8OS6I-00271-00063630-00063791 would have happened if all up testing
+MPcntT8OS6I-00272-00063792-00064035 had failed the whole Apollo program and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00273-00064036-00064248 my reputation would have gone down the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00274-00064249-00064574 drain with this battle won in November
+MPcntT8OS6I-00275-00064575-00064869 1965 Mueller reorganized the Gemini and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00276-00064870-00065129 Apollo program offices creating a five
+MPcntT8OS6I-00277-00065130-00065457 box structure at HQ in field center this
+MPcntT8OS6I-00278-00065458-00065670 structure replicated Mueller's concept
+MPcntT8OS6I-00279-00065671-00065868 of system management and provided far
+MPcntT8OS6I-00280-00065869-00066153 better program overview the key part of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00281-00066154-00066453 the idea was that inside these gem boxes
+MPcntT8OS6I-00282-00066454-00066717 named from his initials managers and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00283-00066718-00066918 engineers communicated directly with
+MPcntT8OS6I-00284-00066919-00067110 their functional counterparts in NASA HQ
+MPcntT8OS6I-00285-00067111-00067353 by passing the usual chain of command
+MPcntT8OS6I-00286-00067354-00067731 and bureaucracy with another battle one
+MPcntT8OS6I-00287-00067732-00067914 Mueller still found that he could not
+MPcntT8OS6I-00288-00067915-00068073 always find the right people with the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00289-00068074-00068352 right skills using his background with
+MPcntT8OS6I-00290-00068353-00068562 Air Force projects Mueller sought Webb's
+MPcntT8OS6I-00291-00068563-00068751 permission to bring in skilled airforce
+MPcntT8OS6I-00292-00068752-00069054 program managers he proposed Minuteman
+MPcntT8OS6I-00293-00069055-00069267 program director Colonel Samuel C
+MPcntT8OS6I-00294-00069268-00069483 Phillips as Apollo program director in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00295-00069484-00069867 OMS F Webb agreed and so did AFSC chief
+MPcntT8OS6I-00296-00069868-00070137 General bernard Schriever phillips in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00297-00070138-00070347 turn agreed and brought with him 42
+MPcntT8OS6I-00298-00070348-00070650 mid-grade officers and eventually 124
+MPcntT8OS6I-00299-00070651-00070959 more junior officers ultimately Oh
+MPcntT8OS6I-00300-00070960-00071235 400 experienced military officers worked
+MPcntT8OS6I-00301-00071236-00071462 on Apollo and other NASA programs during
+MPcntT8OS6I-00302-00071463-00071912 the 1960's Siemens promoted in 1965 to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00303-00071913-00072159 deputy administrator stated that Muller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00304-00072160-00072435 didn't sell he dictated and without his
+MPcntT8OS6I-00305-00072436-00072624 Direction Apollo would not have
+MPcntT8OS6I-00306-00072625-00072942 succeeded also well-known were Mueller's
+MPcntT8OS6I-00307-00072943-00073181 project status reviews often held on
+MPcntT8OS6I-00308-00073182-00073428 Sundays and in brutal detail the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00309-00073429-00073676 presentations were nicknamed pasteurized
+MPcntT8OS6I-00310-00073677-00073971 as the tired managers ability to absorb
+MPcntT8OS6I-00311-00073972-00074160 the detail was waning and the charts
+MPcntT8OS6I-00312-00074161-00074450 were merely past your eyes after the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00313-00074451-00074547 Apollo 1 fire
+MPcntT8OS6I-00314-00074548-00074790 NASA Administrator James Webb became
+MPcntT8OS6I-00315-00074791-00074924 distrustful of Muller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00316-00074925-00075159 but commented even if I wanted to I
+MPcntT8OS6I-00317-00075160-00075378 couldn't fire him because he was manager
+MPcntT8OS6I-00318-00075379-00075642 of our successful Apollo project and one
+MPcntT8OS6I-00319-00075643-00075930 of the ablest men in the world
+MPcntT8OS6I-00320-00075931-00076206 the last thing I wanted was to lose him
+MPcntT8OS6I-00321-00076207-00076455 but I also had another desire which was
+MPcntT8OS6I-00322-00076456-00076676 not to let his way of working create too
+MPcntT8OS6I-00323-00076677-00077174 many difficulties
+MPcntT8OS6I-00324-00077175-00077807 topic Apollo applications in Skylab
+MPcntT8OS6I-00325-00077808-00078051 even while Apollo was progressing
+MPcntT8OS6I-00326-00078052-00078219 Mueller and others were pushing for an
+MPcntT8OS6I-00327-00078220-00078483 aggressive post Apollo program he
+MPcntT8OS6I-00328-00078484-00078675 established the Apollo applications
+MPcntT8OS6I-00329-00078676-00078999 office in 1965 the applications were
+MPcntT8OS6I-00330-00079000-00079221 extensive involving a manned lunar base
+MPcntT8OS6I-00331-00079222-00079458 an earth orbiting space station Apollo
+MPcntT8OS6I-00332-00079459-00079638 telescope a grand tour of the outer
+MPcntT8OS6I-00333-00079639-00079917 solar system and the original Voyager
+MPcntT8OS6I-00334-00079918-00080241 program of Mars Lander probes faced with
+MPcntT8OS6I-00335-00080242-00080427 congressional disapproval and infighting
+MPcntT8OS6I-00336-00080428-00080634 within NASA the ambitious Apollo
+MPcntT8OS6I-00337-00080635-00080859 applications program was cut back time
+MPcntT8OS6I-00338-00080860-00081403 and time again until just Skylab remain
+MPcntT8OS6I-00339-00081404-00081975 topic father of the Space Shuttle
+MPcntT8OS6I-00340-00081976-00082212 Muller is often credited as being the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00341-00082213-00082539 father of the space shuttle whether this
+MPcntT8OS6I-00342-00082540-00082785 is entirely true as debatable Scott pace
+MPcntT8OS6I-00343-00082786-00082950 propounded the view that in such a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00344-00082951-00083171 complex system with so many stakeholders
+MPcntT8OS6I-00345-00083172-00083508 everyone was a shuttle designer what is
+MPcntT8OS6I-00346-00083509-00083715 beyond doubt is that Muller played a key
+MPcntT8OS6I-00347-00083716-00083919 role in early space shuttle decisions
+MPcntT8OS6I-00348-00083920-00084075 and in championing the cause for a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00349-00084076-00084378 reusable space vehicle while perhaps not
+MPcntT8OS6I-00350-00084379-00084447 the father
+MPcntT8OS6I-00351-00084448-00084621 he has been accurately described by
+MPcntT8OS6I-00352-00084622-00084840 Professor John Logsdon as the policy
+MPcntT8OS6I-00353-00084841-00085041 father of the space shuttle Muller held
+MPcntT8OS6I-00354-00085042-00085227 a one-day symposium held at NASA
+MPcntT8OS6I-00355-00085228-00085536 headquarters in December 1967 to which
+MPcntT8OS6I-00356-00085537-00085728 eighty people from the Air Force NASA
+MPcntT8OS6I-00357-00085729-00085962 and industry were invited to discuss low
+MPcntT8OS6I-00358-00085963-00086130 cost space flight and shuttle like
+MPcntT8OS6I-00359-00086131-00086415 designs the designs ranged from simple
+MPcntT8OS6I-00360-00086416-00086685 concepts like Martin Marietta six person
+MPcntT8OS6I-00361-00086686-00086916 reusable craft similar to the dinosaur
+MPcntT8OS6I-00362-00086917-00087186 launched by a Titan III m2 partially
+MPcntT8OS6I-00363-00087187-00087408 reusable concepts like Lockheed Star
+MPcntT8OS6I-00364-00087409-00087588 clipper or tip tank from McDonnell
+MPcntT8OS6I-00365-00087589-00087798 Douglas to fully reusable two-stage
+MPcntT8OS6I-00366-00087799-00087972 vehicles like the one proposed by
+MPcntT8OS6I-00367-00087973-00088236 General Dynamics following this
+MPcntT8OS6I-00368-00088237-00088470 symposium Muller continued to champion a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00369-00088471-00088788 space shuttle he did not invent the term
+MPcntT8OS6I-00370-00088789-00089040 but he made it his own he was also a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00371-00089041-00089247 keen proponent of Space Station's and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00372-00089248-00089409 was well aware that the space shuttle
+MPcntT8OS6I-00373-00089410-00089550 was to shuttle to and from such a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00374-00089551-00089919 station while in London in August 1968
+MPcntT8OS6I-00375-00089920-00090102 to receive an award from the British
+MPcntT8OS6I-00376-00090103-00090306 interplanetary society he again
+MPcntT8OS6I-00377-00090307-00090592 trumpeted the cause of the shuttle
+MPcntT8OS6I-00378-00090593-00090801 there is a real requirement for an
+MPcntT8OS6I-00379-00090802-00091032 efficient earth to orbit transportation
+MPcntT8OS6I-00380-00091033-00091384 system an economical space shuttle
+MPcntT8OS6I-00381-00091385-00091690 I forecast that the next major thrust in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00382-00091691-00091881 space will be the development of an
+MPcntT8OS6I-00383-00091882-00092116 economical launch vehicle for shuttling
+MPcntT8OS6I-00384-00092117-00092353 between earth and the installations such
+MPcntT8OS6I-00385-00092354-00092574 as the orbiting space station that will
+MPcntT8OS6I-00386-00092575-00092931 soon be orbiting in space he also stated
+MPcntT8OS6I-00387-00092932-00093168 as many others would do later that the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00388-00093169-00093385 shuttle ideally would be able to operate
+MPcntT8OS6I-00389-00093386-00093571 in a mode similar to that of a large
+MPcntT8OS6I-00390-00093572-00093807 commercial air transports and be
+MPcntT8OS6I-00391-00093808-00094012 compatible with the environment of major
+MPcntT8OS6I-00392-00094013-00094453 airports Mueller's optimism grew in 1968
+MPcntT8OS6I-00393-00094454-00094654 and he chided Wernher von Braun who had
+MPcntT8OS6I-00394-00094655-00094816 been cautiously promoting a cheap
+MPcntT8OS6I-00395-00094817-00095035 interim shuttle type craft you'd be
+MPcntT8OS6I-00396-00095036-00095215 telling me that my shuttle was in the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00397-00095216-00095474 future and you needed an interim system
+MPcntT8OS6I-00398-00095475-00095692 Muller was sure that the incoming
+MPcntT8OS6I-00399-00095693-00095899 president Richard Nixon would want to go
+MPcntT8OS6I-00400-00095900-00096219 all-out and that this may be the big
+MPcntT8OS6I-00401-00096220-00096592 program for Nixon in 1987 Muller had
+MPcntT8OS6I-00402-00096593-00096778 this to say about the shuttle it was
+MPcntT8OS6I-00403-00096779-00096975 clear to us at that time that we needed
+MPcntT8OS6I-00404-00096976-00097188 to have a joint program between the Air
+MPcntT8OS6I-00405-00097189-00097396 Force and NASA and that that program
+MPcntT8OS6I-00406-00097397-00097593 ought to be aimed at providing low-cost
+MPcntT8OS6I-00407-00097594-00097840 space transportation for all of our
+MPcntT8OS6I-00408-00097841-00098191 needs it's just in my view unfortunate
+MPcntT8OS6I-00409-00098192-00098418 that we made the compromise after I left
+MPcntT8OS6I-00410-00098419-00098647 NASA in terms of the partially reusable
+MPcntT8OS6I-00411-00098648-00098896 vehicle and all that that implies in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00412-00098897-00099069 terms of not only the cost of the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00413-00099070-00099324 throwaway parts but also the cost of the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00414-00099325-00099537 ground troops that have to process it
+MPcntT8OS6I-00415-00099538-00099712 and put it together and fly it every
+MPcntT8OS6I-00416-00099713-00100099 time that combination and ground support
+MPcntT8OS6I-00417-00100100-00100368 as a not insignificant part of a shuttle
+MPcntT8OS6I-00418-00100369-00100650 cost was a set of decisions that doomed
+MPcntT8OS6I-00419-00100651-00100893 low-cost space transportation for that
+MPcntT8OS6I-00420-00100894-00101424 generation of vehicles
+MPcntT8OS6I-00421-00101425-00101998 topic mueller's working style
+MPcntT8OS6I-00422-00101999-00102241 almost everyone who worked with Muller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00423-00102242-00102421 and Apollo agreed he was technically
+MPcntT8OS6I-00424-00102422-00102703 brilliant and exceedingly capable even
+MPcntT8OS6I-00425-00102704-00102885 those who frequently disagreed with him
+MPcntT8OS6I-00426-00102886-00103066 like Christopher Kraft or George Lowe
+MPcntT8OS6I-00427-00103067-00103351 recognized his abilities while Muller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00428-00103352-00103530 could be described as intellectually
+MPcntT8OS6I-00429-00103531-00103734 arrogant he was not an office tyrant one
+MPcntT8OS6I-00430-00103735-00103944 of his colleagues John Disher describes
+MPcntT8OS6I-00431-00103945-00104256 working for him as a piece of cake nor
+MPcntT8OS6I-00432-00104257-00104430 did he try to belittle others or shut
+MPcntT8OS6I-00433-00104431-00104658 them down while appearing affable and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00434-00104659-00104872 reasonably charming with the epitome of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00435-00104873-00105088 politeness but you know down deep he's
+MPcntT8OS6I-00436-00105089-00105453 just as hard as steel
+MPcntT8OS6I-00437-00105454-00105634 you
+MPcntT8OS6I-00438-00105635-00106215 topic resignation from NASA
+MPcntT8OS6I-00439-00106216-00106488 Muller resigned from NASA on November 10
+MPcntT8OS6I-00440-00106489-00106872 1969 effective from December 10th rumors
+MPcntT8OS6I-00441-00106873-00107067 had been circulating for a while that he
+MPcntT8OS6I-00442-00107068-00107333 wanted to return to private industry the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00443-00107334-00107526 New York Times stated that informed
+MPcntT8OS6I-00444-00107527-00107742 sources alleged clashes with
+MPcntT8OS6I-00445-00107743-00107997 administrator Thomas Paine over space
+MPcntT8OS6I-00446-00107998-00108252 priorities for 70s and disputes with
+MPcntT8OS6I-00447-00108253-00108461 subordinates he has twice been passed
+MPcntT8OS6I-00448-00108463-00108846 over for deputy a DMR post in an
+MPcntT8OS6I-00449-00108847-00109034 interview Mueller gave different reasons
+MPcntT8OS6I-00450-00109035-00109269 for leaving one is that the decision had
+MPcntT8OS6I-00451-00109270-00109436 been made to terminate the Apollo
+MPcntT8OS6I-00452-00109438-00109671 program and that was a good time then to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00453-00109672-00109893 leave before and let someone else take
+MPcntT8OS6I-00454-00109894-00110196 over for the next phase from a practical
+MPcntT8OS6I-00455-00110197-00110418 point of view I needed to go make some
+MPcntT8OS6I-00456-00110419-00110715 money so I could keep my family going it
+MPcntT8OS6I-00457-00110716-00110928 was costly for us to join the Apollo
+MPcntT8OS6I-00458-00110929-00111216 program my salary was half what I was
+MPcntT8OS6I-00459-00111217-00111429 making an industry when I went there and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00460-00111430-00111603 it was just as strained to keep the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00461-00111604-00111809 family going and work going at the same
+MPcntT8OS6I-00462-00111810-00112208 time so I went back to industry after a
+MPcntT8OS6I-00463-00112209-00112436 short time at General Dynamics Muller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00464-00112438-00112623 became chairman and president of the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00465-00112624-00112854 system Development Corporation a spinoff
+MPcntT8OS6I-00466-00112855-00113144 from the RAND Corporation in 1971 he
+MPcntT8OS6I-00467-00113145-00113403 remained with SDC following the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00468-00113404-00113592 burroughs corporation's acquisition of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00469-00113593-00113772 the company and retired after growing
+MPcntT8OS6I-00470-00113773-00114114 the company successfully in 1984 while
+MPcntT8OS6I-00471-00114115-00114348 at SDC Muller married his second wife
+MPcntT8OS6I-00472-00114349-00114669 Darla after a short retirement Mueller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00473-00114670-00114785 became the president of the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00474-00114786-00115014 International Academy of astronautics in
+MPcntT8OS6I-00475-00115015-00115167 addition to consulting and other
+MPcntT8OS6I-00476-00115168-00115440 volunteer work yearning to return to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00477-00115441-00115632 full-time employment he became the CEO
+MPcntT8OS6I-00478-00115633-00115932 of Kistler aerospace in 1996 and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00479-00115933-00116091 remained with the company for a number
+MPcntT8OS6I-00480-00116092-00116440 of years
+MPcntT8OS6I-00481-00116441-00117115 topic post NASA career senior vice
+MPcntT8OS6I-00482-00117116-00117256 president of General Dynamics
+MPcntT8OS6I-00483-00117257-00117643 Corporation Falls Church Virginia 1969
+MPcntT8OS6I-00484-00117644-00118063 to 1971 system Development Corporation
+MPcntT8OS6I-00485-00118064-00118378 Santa Monica California chairman
+MPcntT8OS6I-00486-00118379-00118906 president 1971 to 1987 chief executive
+MPcntT8OS6I-00487-00118907-00119320 officer 1981 to 1983 Burroughs
+MPcntT8OS6I-00488-00119321-00119701 corporation senior vice president 1980
+MPcntT8OS6I-00489-00119702-00119901 to 1983
+MPcntT8OS6I-00490-00119902-00120319 consultant 1984 date unknown Kistler
+MPcntT8OS6I-00491-00120320-00120693 aerospace Rocketplane Kistler from 2006
+MPcntT8OS6I-00492-00120694-00121213 CEO 1995 to 2004 chairman and chief
+MPcntT8OS6I-00493-00121214-00121498 vehicle architect 2004 mueller died of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00494-00121499-00121683 congestive heart failure in Irvine
+MPcntT8OS6I-00495-00121684-00122023 California on October 12 2015 at the age
+MPcntT8OS6I-00496-00122024-00122408 of 97
+MPcntT8OS6I-00497-00122408-00122935 topic references
+MPcntT8OS6I-00498-00122936-00123358 specific general Murray C and Cox CB
+MPcntT8OS6I-00499-00123359-00124016 2004 Apollo pages 151 to 160 to South
+MPcntT8OS6I-00500-00124017-00124367 Mountain books Burkittsville MD is B and
+MPcntT8OS6I-00501-00124368-00124871 O nine seven six ooo 806 one Heppenheim
+MPcntT8OS6I-00502-00124872-00125327 er ta the Space Shuttle decision 1965 to
+MPcntT8OS6I-00503-00125328-00125707 1972 history of the space shuttle vol 1
+MPcntT8OS6I-00504-00125708-00126083 Smithsonian Institution press ISBN one
+MPcntT8OS6I-00505-00126083-00126310 five eight eight three four oh one four
+MPcntT8OS6I-00506-00126311-00126770 seven pace scott 1982 engineering design
+MPcntT8OS6I-00507-00126771-00126994 and political choice the Space Shuttle
+MPcntT8OS6I-00508-00126995-00127418 1969 to 1972 thesis MS Massachusetts
+MPcntT8OS6I-00509-00127419-00127636 Institute of Technology Department of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00510-00127638-00127939 aeronautics and Astronautics 1982
+MPcntT8OS6I-00511-00127940-00128329 Slotkin Arthur L 2012 doing the
+MPcntT8OS6I-00512-00128330-00128399 impossible
+MPcntT8OS6I-00513-00128400-00128591 Georgie Muller and the management of
+MPcntT8OS6I-00514-00128592-00128752 NASA's human space flight program
+MPcntT8OS6I-00515-00128753-00129038 springer praxis scientific publications
+MPcntT8OS6I-00516-00129039-00129519 New York
+MPcntT8OS6I-00517-00129520-00129957 external links
+MPcntT8OS6I-00518-00129958-00130368 George Edwin Muller dr. George Muller
+MPcntT8OS6I-00519-00130369-00130827 interview NASM oral history project
+MQU90q_-fgM-00000-00000011-00000292 the physiology of decompression involves
+MQU90q_-fgM-00001-00000293-00000470 a complex interaction of gas solubility
+MQU90q_-fgM-00002-00000471-00000674 partial pressures and concentration
+MQU90q_-fgM-00003-00000675-00000881 gradients diffusion bulk transport and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00004-00000882-00001139 bubble mechanics in living tissues glass
+MQU90q_-fgM-00005-00001140-00001322 is breathed at ambient pressure and some
+MQU90q_-fgM-00006-00001323-00001478 of this gas dissolves into the blood and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00007-00001479-00001754 other fluids inert gas continues to be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00008-00001755-00001930 taken up until the gas dissolved in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00009-00001932-00002057 tissues is in a state of equilibrium
+MQU90q_-fgM-00010-00002058-00002348 with the gas in the lungs see saturation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00011-00002349-00002558 diving or the ambient pressure is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00012-00002559-00002723 reduced until the inert gases dissolved
+MQU90q_-fgM-00013-00002724-00002864 in the tissues are at a higher
+MQU90q_-fgM-00014-00002865-00003052 concentration than the equilibrium state
+MQU90q_-fgM-00015-00003053-00003215 and start diffusing out again the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00016-00003215-00003401 absorption of gases in liquids depends
+MQU90q_-fgM-00017-00003402-00003593 on the solubility of the specific gas in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00018-00003594-00003776 the specific liquid the concentration of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00019-00003777-00003965 gas customarily measured by partial
+MQU90q_-fgM-00020-00003965-00004213 pressure and temperature in the study of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00021-00004214-00004388 decompression Theory the behavior of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00022-00004389-00004544 gases dissolved in the tissues is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00023-00004545-00004729 investigated and modeled for variations
+MQU90q_-fgM-00024-00004730-00004958 of pressure over time once dissolved
+MQU90q_-fgM-00025-00004959-00005152 distribution of the dissolved gas may be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00026-00005153-00005360 by diffusion where there is no bulk flow
+MQU90q_-fgM-00027-00005361-00005545 of the solvent or by diffusion where the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00028-00005546-00005729 solvent blood is circulated around the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00029-00005730-00005911 divers body where gas can diffuse to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00030-00005912-00006091 local regions of lower concentration
+MQU90q_-fgM-00031-00006092-00006304 given sufficient time at a specific
+MQU90q_-fgM-00032-00006305-00006467 partial pressure in the breathing gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00033-00006468-00006656 the concentration in the tissues will
+MQU90q_-fgM-00034-00006656-00006835 stabilize or saturate at a rate
+MQU90q_-fgM-00035-00006836-00007025 depending on the solubility diffusion
+MQU90q_-fgM-00036-00007026-00007270 rate and perfusion if the concentration
+MQU90q_-fgM-00037-00007272-00007442 of the inert gas in the breathing gas is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00038-00007443-00007609 reduced below that of any of the tissues
+MQU90q_-fgM-00039-00007611-00007778 there will be a tendency for gas to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00040-00007779-00007937 return from the tissues to the breathing
+MQU90q_-fgM-00041-00007938-00008177 gas this is known as outgassing and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00042-00008178-00008348 occurs during decompression when the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00043-00008349-00008495 reduction in ambient pressure or a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00044-00008496-00008663 change of breathing gas reduces the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00045-00008664-00008831 partial pressure of the inert gas in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00046-00008832-00008873 lungs
+MQU90q_-fgM-00047-00008874-00009059 the combined concentrations of gases in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00048-00009060-00009214 any given tissue will depend on the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00049-00009215-00009385 history of pressure and gas composition
+MQU90q_-fgM-00050-00009386-00009653 under equilibrium conditions the total
+MQU90q_-fgM-00051-00009654-00009830 concentration of dissolved gases will be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00052-00009831-00010024 less than the ambient pressure as oxygen
+MQU90q_-fgM-00053-00010025-00010192 is metabolized in the tissues and the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00054-00010193-00010394 carbon dioxide produced is much more
+MQU90q_-fgM-00055-00010395-00010663 soluble however during a reduction in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00056-00010664-00010817 ambient pressure the rate of pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00057-00010818-00010963 reduction may exceed the rate at which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00058-00010964-00011162 gas can be eliminated by diffusion and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00059-00011163-00011338 perfusion and if the concentration gets
+MQU90q_-fgM-00060-00011339-00011485 too high it may reach a stage where
+MQU90q_-fgM-00061-00011486-00011663 bubble formation can occur in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00062-00011664-00011914 supersaturated tissues when the pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00063-00011915-00012074 of gases in a bubble exceeds the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00064-00012075-00012251 combined external pressures of ambient
+MQU90q_-fgM-00065-00012252-00012395 pressure and the surface tension from
+MQU90q_-fgM-00066-00012396-00012574 the bubble liquid interface the bubbles
+MQU90q_-fgM-00067-00012575-00012719 will grow and this growth can cause
+MQU90q_-fgM-00068-00012720-00012983 damage to tissues symptoms caused by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00069-00012984-00013115 this damage are known as decompression
+MQU90q_-fgM-00070-00013116-00013336 sickness the actual rates of diffusion
+MQU90q_-fgM-00071-00013337-00013366 and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00072-00013368-00013558 fusion and the solubility of gases in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00073-00013559-00013733 specific tissues are not generally known
+MQU90q_-fgM-00074-00013734-00013863 and vary considerably
+MQU90q_-fgM-00075-00013865-00014099 however mathematical models have been
+MQU90q_-fgM-00076-00014100-00014236 proposed which approximate the real
+MQU90q_-fgM-00077-00014237-00014416 situation to a greater or lesser extent
+MQU90q_-fgM-00078-00014418-00014608 and these models are used to predict
+MQU90q_-fgM-00079-00014609-00014783 whether symptomatic bubble formation is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00080-00014784-00014936 likely to occur for a given pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00081-00014937-00016075 exposure profile topic solubility
+MQU90q_-fgM-00082-00016076-00016322 solubility is the property of a gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00083-00016322-00016550 liquid or solid substance the solute to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00084-00016551-00016717 be held homogeneously dispersed as
+MQU90q_-fgM-00085-00016718-00016925 molecules or ions in a liquid or solid
+MQU90q_-fgM-00086-00016926-00017174 medium the solvent in decompression
+MQU90q_-fgM-00087-00017175-00017350 Theory the solubility of gases in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00088-00017351-00017528 liquids is of primary importance as it
+MQU90q_-fgM-00089-00017529-00017699 is the formation of bubbles from these
+MQU90q_-fgM-00090-00017700-00017872 gases that causes decompression sickness
+MQU90q_-fgM-00091-00017873-00018086 solubility of gases in liquids is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00092-00018087-00018355 influenced by three main factors the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00093-00018356-00018500 nature of the solvent liquid and the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00094-00018501-00018761 solute temperature gases are less
+MQU90q_-fgM-00095-00018762-00018955 soluble in water but may be more soluble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00096-00018956-00019111 in organic solvents at higher
+MQU90q_-fgM-00097-00019112-00019405 temperatures pressure solubility of a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00098-00019406-00019580 gas in a liquid is proportional to the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00099-00019581-00019720 partial pressure of the gas on the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00100-00019721-00019906 liquid henry's law the presence of other
+MQU90q_-fgM-00101-00019907-00020053 solutes in the solvent can also
+MQU90q_-fgM-00102-00020054-00020252 influence solubility body tissues
+MQU90q_-fgM-00103-00020253-00020431 include aqueous and liepard components
+MQU90q_-fgM-00104-00020432-00020630 in varying ratios and the solubility of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00105-00020631-00020812 the gas is involved in decompression in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00106-00020813-00020971 these tissues will vary depending on
+MQU90q_-fgM-00107-00020972-00022050 their composition topic diffusion
+MQU90q_-fgM-00108-00022051-00022286 diffusion is the movement of molecules
+MQU90q_-fgM-00109-00022287-00022462 or ions in a medium when there is no
+MQU90q_-fgM-00110-00022463-00022642 gross mass flow of the medium and can
+MQU90q_-fgM-00111-00022643-00022871 occur in gases liquids or solids or any
+MQU90q_-fgM-00112-00022872-00023119 combination diffusion is driven by the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00113-00023120-00023261 kinetic energy of the diffusing
+MQU90q_-fgM-00114-00023262-00023464 molecules it is faster in gases and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00115-00023465-00023621 slower in solids when compared with
+MQU90q_-fgM-00116-00023622-00023830 liquids due to the variation in distance
+MQU90q_-fgM-00117-00023831-00023999 between collisions and diffusion is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00118-00024000-00024172 faster when the temperature is higher as
+MQU90q_-fgM-00119-00024173-00024340 the average energy of the molecules is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00120-00024341-00024608 greater diffusion is also faster in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00121-00024609-00024764 smaller lighter molecules of which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00122-00024765-00024949 helium is the extreme example
+MQU90q_-fgM-00123-00024950-00025189 diffusivity of helium is two point six
+MQU90q_-fgM-00124-00025190-00025384 five times faster than nitrogen the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00125-00025385-00025567 partial pressure gradient also known as
+MQU90q_-fgM-00126-00025568-00025742 the concentration gradient can be used
+MQU90q_-fgM-00127-00025743-00025909 as a model for the driving mechanism of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00128-00025910-00026183 diffusion the partial pressure gradient
+MQU90q_-fgM-00129-00026183-00026365 is the variation of partial pressure or
+MQU90q_-fgM-00130-00026366-00026567 more accurately the concentration of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00131-00026568-00026744 solute dissolved gas from one
+MQU90q_-fgM-00132-00026745-00026887 point to another in the solvent the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00133-00026888-00027133 solute molecules will randomly collide
+MQU90q_-fgM-00134-00027135-00027289 with the other molecules present and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00135-00027291-00027470 tend over time to spread out until the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00136-00027470-00027652 distribution is statistically uniform
+MQU90q_-fgM-00137-00027654-00027889 this has the effect that molecules will
+MQU90q_-fgM-00138-00027891-00028001 diffuse from regions of higher
+MQU90q_-fgM-00139-00028002-00028199 concentration partial pressure to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00140-00028200-00028373 regions of lower concentration and the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00141-00028374-00028544 rate of diffusion is proportional to the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00142-00028545-00028702 rate of change of the concentration
+MQU90q_-fgM-00143-00028702-00028937 tissues in which an inert gas is more
+MQU90q_-fgM-00144-00028938-00029095 soluble will eventually develop the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00145-00029097-00029282 higher dissolved gas content in tissues
+MQU90q_-fgM-00146-00029283-00030020 where the gas is less soluble topic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00147-00030020-00030638 inert gas uptake in gassing in this
+MQU90q_-fgM-00148-00030639-00030863 context inert gas refers to a gas which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00149-00030864-00031127 is not metabolically active atmospheric
+MQU90q_-fgM-00150-00031127-00031333 nitrogen n2 is the most common example
+MQU90q_-fgM-00151-00031335-00031552 and helium P is the other inert gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00152-00031554-00031736 commonly used in breathing mixtures for
+MQU90q_-fgM-00153-00031737-00031910 divers atmospheric nitrogen has a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00154-00031911-00032162 partial pressure of approximately 0.78
+MQU90q_-fgM-00155-00032163-00032429 bars at sea level air in the alveoli of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00156-00032430-00032642 the lungs is diluted by saturated water
+MQU90q_-fgM-00157-00032643-00032960 vapor h2o and carbon dioxide co2 a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00158-00032961-00033149 metabolic product given off by the blood
+MQU90q_-fgM-00159-00033150-00033362 and contains less oxygen o2 then
+MQU90q_-fgM-00160-00033363-00033548 atmospheric air is some of it is taken
+MQU90q_-fgM-00161-00033549-00033791 up by the blood for metabolic use the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00162-00033792-00033941 resulting partial pressure of nitrogen
+MQU90q_-fgM-00163-00033942-00034295 is about zero 758 bars at atmospheric
+MQU90q_-fgM-00164-00034296-00034442 pressure the body tissues are therefore
+MQU90q_-fgM-00165-00034443-00034745 normally saturated with nitrogen at 0.75
+MQU90q_-fgM-00166-00034746-00035144 eight bars 569 millimeters of mercury at
+MQU90q_-fgM-00167-00035145-00035330 increased ambient pressures due to depth
+MQU90q_-fgM-00168-00035331-00035546 or habitat pressurization a divers lungs
+MQU90q_-fgM-00169-00035547-00035678 are filled with breathing gas at the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00170-00035679-00035810 increased pressure and the partial
+MQU90q_-fgM-00171-00035811-00035987 pressures of the Constituent gases will
+MQU90q_-fgM-00172-00035988-00036278 be increased proportionately for example
+MQU90q_-fgM-00173-00036279-00036551 at 10 meters seawater MSW the partial
+MQU90q_-fgM-00174-00036552-00036731 pressure of nitrogen in air will be one
+MQU90q_-fgM-00175-00036732-00036911 point five eight bars the inert gases
+MQU90q_-fgM-00176-00036912-00037049 from the breathing gas in the lungs
+MQU90q_-fgM-00177-00037050-00037211 diffuse into blood in the alveolar
+MQU90q_-fgM-00178-00037212-00037394 capillaries move down the pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00179-00037395-00037628 gradient and are distributed around the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00180-00037629-00037832 body by the systemic circulation in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00181-00037833-00038537 process known as perfusion topic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00182-00038538-00039158 perfusion perfusion is the mass flow
+MQU90q_-fgM-00183-00039159-00039371 through the tissues dissolved materials
+MQU90q_-fgM-00184-00039372-00039557 are transported in the blood much faster
+MQU90q_-fgM-00185-00039558-00039677 than they would be distributed by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00186-00039678-00039827 diffusion alone order of minutes
+MQU90q_-fgM-00187-00039828-00040007 compared to hours the dissolved gas in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00188-00040008-00040190 the alveolar blood is transported to the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00189-00040191-00040358 body tissues by the blood circulation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00190-00040359-00040571 there are diffuses through the cell
+MQU90q_-fgM-00191-00040572-00040751 membranes and into the tissues where it
+MQU90q_-fgM-00192-00040752-00040976 may eventually reach equilibrium the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00193-00040977-00041162 greater the blood supply to a tissue the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00194-00041163-00041324 faster it will reach equilibrium with
+MQU90q_-fgM-00195-00041325-00042046 gas at the new partial pressure topic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00196-00042047-00042638 saturation and super saturation if the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00197-00042639-00042842 supply of gas to a solvent is unlimited
+MQU90q_-fgM-00198-00042843-00043007 the gas will diffuse into the solvent
+MQU90q_-fgM-00199-00043008-00043154 until there is so much dissolved that
+MQU90q_-fgM-00200-00043155-00043307 equilibrium is reached in the amount
+MQU90q_-fgM-00201-00043308-00043460 diffusing back out is equal to the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00202-00043461-00043679 amount diffusing in this is called
+MQU90q_-fgM-00203-00043680-00043871 saturation if the external partial
+MQU90q_-fgM-00204-00043872-00044048 pressure of the gas in the lungs is then
+MQU90q_-fgM-00205-00044049-00044231 reduced more gas will diffuse out than
+MQU90q_-fgM-00206-00044232-00044459 in this is a condition known as super
+MQU90q_-fgM-00207-00044460-00044639 saturation the gas will not necessarily
+MQU90q_-fgM-00208-00044640-00044828 form bubbles in the solvent at this
+MQU90q_-fgM-00209-00044829-00045047 stage but super saturation is necessary
+MQU90q_-fgM-00210-00045048-00045287 for bubble growth a supersaturated
+MQU90q_-fgM-00211-00045288-00045518 solution of gases in a tissue may form
+MQU90q_-fgM-00212-00045519-00045704 bubbles if suitable nucleation sites
+MQU90q_-fgM-00213-00045705-00045998 exist super saturation may be defined as
+MQU90q_-fgM-00214-00045999-00046175 a sum of all gas partial pressures in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00215-00046176-00046322 the liquid which exceeds the ambient
+MQU90q_-fgM-00216-00046323-00047072 pressure in the liquid topic tissue half
+MQU90q_-fgM-00217-00047073-00047657 times if an exponential uptake of gas is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00218-00047658-00047843 assumed which is a good approximation of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00219-00047844-00048047 experimental values for diffusion in non
+MQU90q_-fgM-00220-00048048-00048251 living homogeneous materials half time
+MQU90q_-fgM-00221-00048252-00048431 of a tissue is the time it takes for the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00222-00048432-00048626 tissue to take up or release 50 percent
+MQU90q_-fgM-00223-00048627-00048758 of the difference in dissolved gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00224-00048759-00048941 capacity at a change partial pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00225-00048942-00049199 for each consecutive half time the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00226-00049200-00049361 tissue will take up or release half
+MQU90q_-fgM-00227-00049362-00049520 again of the cumulative difference in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00228-00049521-00049658 the sequence one half three quarters
+MQU90q_-fgM-00229-00049659-00049934 seven eighths fifteen sixteenths 31
+MQU90q_-fgM-00230-00049935-00050147 thirty Seconds sixty three sixty fourths
+MQU90q_-fgM-00231-00050148-00050432 etc the number of half times chosen to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00232-00050433-00050630 assume full saturation depends on the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00233-00050631-00050822 decompression model and typically ranges
+MQU90q_-fgM-00234-00050823-00051131 from 490 3.75 percent to six ninety
+MQU90q_-fgM-00235-00051132-00051353 eight point four four percent tissue
+MQU90q_-fgM-00236-00051354-00051545 compartment 1/2 times range from one
+MQU90q_-fgM-00237-00051546-00051878 minute to at least 720 minutes for
+MQU90q_-fgM-00238-00051879-00052097 example a five minute tissue will be 50
+MQU90q_-fgM-00239-00052098-00052342 percent saturated in five minutes 75
+MQU90q_-fgM-00240-00052344-00052541 percent in 10 minutes eighty-seven point
+MQU90q_-fgM-00241-00052541-00052721 five percent in 15 minutes and for
+MQU90q_-fgM-00242-00052722-00052946 practical purposes saturated in about 30
+MQU90q_-fgM-00243-00052947-00053101 minutes ninety eight point four four
+MQU90q_-fgM-00244-00053102-00053312 percent saturated at six half times a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00245-00053313-00053486 specific tissue compartment will have
+MQU90q_-fgM-00246-00053487-00053648 different half times for gases with
+MQU90q_-fgM-00247-00053649-00053806 different solubilities and diffusion
+MQU90q_-fgM-00248-00053807-00054037 rates this model may not adequately
+MQU90q_-fgM-00249-00054038-00054232 describe the dynamics of outgassing if
+MQU90q_-fgM-00250-00054233-00054971 gas phase bubbles are present topic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00251-00054972-00055567 outgassing of tissues gas remains
+MQU90q_-fgM-00252-00055569-00055724 dissolved in the tissues until the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00253-00055725-00055867 partial pressure of that gas in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00254-00055869-00056032 lungs is reduced sufficiently to cause a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00255-00056033-00056216 concentration gradient with the blood at
+MQU90q_-fgM-00256-00056216-00056387 a lower concentration than the relevant
+MQU90q_-fgM-00257-00056388-00056632 tissues a lowered partial pressure in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00258-00056633-00056776 the lungs will result in more gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00259-00056777-00056944 diffusing out of the blood into the lung
+MQU90q_-fgM-00260-00056945-00057106 gues and less from the lung gas into the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00261-00057107-00057386 blood a similar situation occurs between
+MQU90q_-fgM-00262-00057387-00057560 the blood and each tissue as the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00263-00057561-00057725 concentration in the blood drops below
+MQU90q_-fgM-00264-00057726-00057907 the concentration in the adjacent tissue
+MQU90q_-fgM-00265-00057908-00058079 the gas will diffuse out of the tissue
+MQU90q_-fgM-00266-00058079-00058216 into the blood and will then be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00267-00058217-00058379 transported back to the lungs where it
+MQU90q_-fgM-00268-00058379-00058531 will diffuse into the lung gas and then
+MQU90q_-fgM-00269-00058532-00058778 be illuminated by exhalation if the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00270-00058779-00058946 ambient pressure reduction is limited
+MQU90q_-fgM-00271-00058947-00059143 this desaturation will take place in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00272-00059144-00059305 dissolved phase but if the ambient
+MQU90q_-fgM-00273-00059307-00059479 pressure is lowered sufficiently bubbles
+MQU90q_-fgM-00274-00059480-00059650 may form and grow both in blood and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00275-00059651-00059828 other supersaturated tissues when the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00276-00059829-00060011 gas in a tissue is at a concentration
+MQU90q_-fgM-00277-00060012-00060151 where more diffuses out than in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00278-00060152-00060343 tissue is said to be supersaturated with
+MQU90q_-fgM-00279-00060344-00060466 that gas relative to the surrounding
+MQU90q_-fgM-00280-00060467-00060775 tissues super saturation can also be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00281-00060776-00060938 defined as when the combined partial
+MQU90q_-fgM-00282-00060939-00061103 pressures of gases dissolved in a tissue
+MQU90q_-fgM-00283-00061104-00061291 exceeds the total ambient pressure on
+MQU90q_-fgM-00284-00061292-00061436 the tissue and there is a theoretical
+MQU90q_-fgM-00285-00061437-00061628 possibility of bubble formation or
+MQU90q_-fgM-00286-00061629-00062782 growth topic inherent unsaturation there
+MQU90q_-fgM-00287-00062783-00062963 is a metabolic reduction of total gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00288-00062964-00063185 pressure in the tissues the sum of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00289-00063186-00063343 partial pressures of the gas that the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00290-00063344-00063526 diver breathes must necessarily balance
+MQU90q_-fgM-00291-00063527-00063688 with the sum of partial pressures in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00292-00063689-00063974 lung gas in the alveoli the gas has been
+MQU90q_-fgM-00293-00063975-00064141 humidified by a partial pressure of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00294-00064142-00064403 approximately 63 millibars 47
+MQU90q_-fgM-00295-00064404-00064567 millimeters of mercury and has gained
+MQU90q_-fgM-00296-00064569-00064816 about 55 millibars 41 millimeters of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00297-00064817-00065017 mercury carbon dioxide from the venous
+MQU90q_-fgM-00298-00065019-00065297 blood oxygen has also diffused into the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00299-00065298-00065479 arterial blood reducing the partial
+MQU90q_-fgM-00300-00065480-00065672 pressure of oxygen in the alveoli by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00301-00065673-00065930 about 67 millibars 50 millimeters of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00302-00065931-00066095 mercury as the total pressure in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00303-00066096-00066281 alveoli must balance with the ambient
+MQU90q_-fgM-00304-00066282-00066455 pressure this dilution results in an
+MQU90q_-fgM-00305-00066456-00066581 effective partial pressure of nitrogen
+MQU90q_-fgM-00306-00066582-00067016 of about 758 MB 569 millimeters of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00307-00067017-00067157 mercury in air at normal atmospheric
+MQU90q_-fgM-00308-00067158-00067361 pressure at a steady state when the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00309-00067362-00067541 tissues have been saturated by the inert
+MQU90q_-fgM-00310-00067542-00067732 gases of the breathing mixture metabolic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00311-00067733-00067910 processes reduce the partial pressure of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00312-00067911-00068093 the less soluble oxygen and replace it
+MQU90q_-fgM-00313-00068094-00068240 with carbon dioxide which is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00314-00068241-00068486 considerably more soluble in water in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00315-00068487-00068669 the cells of a typical tissue the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00316-00068670-00068851 partial pressure of oxygen will drop to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00317-00068852-00069059 around 13 millibars 10 millimeters of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00318-00069060-00069215 mercury while the partial pressure of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00319-00069216-00069428 carbon dioxide will be about 65
+MQU90q_-fgM-00320-00069429-00069728 millibars 49 millimeters of mercury the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00321-00069729-00069887 sum of these partial pressures water
+MQU90q_-fgM-00322-00069888-00070151 oxygen carbon dioxide and nitrogen comes
+MQU90q_-fgM-00323-00070152-00070490 to roughly 900 millibars 675 millimeters
+MQU90q_-fgM-00324-00070491-00070742 of mercury which is some 113 millibars
+MQU90q_-fgM-00325-00070743-00070961 85 millimeters of mercury less than the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00326-00070962-00071134 total pressure of the respiratory gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00327-00071135-00071423 this is a significant saturation deficit
+MQU90q_-fgM-00328-00071424-00071594 and it provides a buffer against super
+MQU90q_-fgM-00329-00071595-00071753 saturation and a driving force for
+MQU90q_-fgM-00330-00071754-00071957 dissolving bubbles experiments suggest
+MQU90q_-fgM-00331-00071958-00072053 that the degree of unsaturation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00332-00072054-00072260 increases linearly with pressure for a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00333-00072261-00072389 breathing mixture of fixed composition
+MQU90q_-fgM-00334-00072390-00072605 and decreases linearly with fraction of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00335-00072606-00072836 inert gas in the breathing mixture as a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00336-00072837-00072992 consequence the conditions for
+MQU90q_-fgM-00337-00072993-00073136 maximizing the degree of unsaturation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00338-00073137-00073322 are a breathing gas with the lowest
+MQU90q_-fgM-00339-00073323-00073538 possible fraction of inert gas ie pure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00340-00073539-00073685 oxygen at the maximum permissible
+MQU90q_-fgM-00341-00073686-00073982 partial pressure this saturation deficit
+MQU90q_-fgM-00342-00073983-00074228 is also referred to as the oxygen window
+MQU90q_-fgM-00343-00074229-00075032 or partial pressure vacancy topic bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00344-00075033-00075632 formation growth and elimination the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00345-00075633-00075824 location of micro nuclei or where
+MQU90q_-fgM-00346-00075825-00076027 bubbles initially form is not known
+MQU90q_-fgM-00347-00076028-00076253 heterogeneous nucleation and tribo
+MQU90q_-fgM-00348-00076254-00076403 nucleation are considered the most
+MQU90q_-fgM-00349-00076404-00076621 likely mechanism for bubble formation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00350-00076622-00076856 homogeneous nucleation requires much
+MQU90q_-fgM-00351-00076857-00076991 greater pressure differences than
+MQU90q_-fgM-00352-00076992-00077141 experienced in decompression the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00353-00077142-00077378 spontaneous formation of nano bubbles on
+MQU90q_-fgM-00354-00077379-00077567 hydrophobic surfaces is a possible
+MQU90q_-fgM-00355-00077568-00077768 source of micro nuclei but it is not yet
+MQU90q_-fgM-00356-00077769-00077939 clear if these can grow to symptomatic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00357-00077940-00078119 dimensions as they are very stable the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00358-00078120-00078290 incorporation of bubble formation and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00359-00078291-00078455 growth mechanisms in decompression
+MQU90q_-fgM-00360-00078456-00078596 models may make the models more
+MQU90q_-fgM-00361-00078597-00078725 biophysical and allow better
+MQU90q_-fgM-00362-00078726-00078911 extrapolation flow conditions and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00363-00078912-00079085 perfusion rates are dominant parameters
+MQU90q_-fgM-00364-00079086-00079241 in competition between tissue and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00365-00079242-00079319 circulation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00366-00079320-00079499 and between multiple bubbles for
+MQU90q_-fgM-00367-00079500-00080222 dissolved gas for bubble growth topic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00368-00080223-00080786 bubble mechanics equilibrium of forces
+MQU90q_-fgM-00369-00080787-00080999 on the surface is required for a bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00370-00081000-00081067 to exist
+MQU90q_-fgM-00371-00081068-00081422 these are ambient pressure exerted on
+MQU90q_-fgM-00372-00081423-00081581 the outside of the surface acting
+MQU90q_-fgM-00373-00081582-00081800 inwards pressure due to tissue
+MQU90q_-fgM-00374-00081801-00081989 distortion also on the outside and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00375-00081990-00082247 acting inwards surface tension of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00376-00082248-00082388 liquid at the interface between the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00377-00082389-00082601 bubble and the surroundings this is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00378-00082602-00082763 along the surface of the bubble so the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00379-00082764-00082922 resultant acts towards the center of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00380-00082923-00083153 curvature this will tend to squeeze the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00381-00083154-00083309 bubble and is more severe for small
+MQU90q_-fgM-00382-00083310-00083483 bubbles as it is an inverse function of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00383-00083484-00083765 the radius the resulting forces must be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00384-00083766-00083906 balanced by the pressure on the inside
+MQU90q_-fgM-00385-00083907-00084134 of the bubble this is the sum of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00386-00084135-00084284 partial pressures of the gases inside
+MQU90q_-fgM-00387-00084285-00084476 due to the net diffusion of gas to and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00388-00084477-00084725 from the bubble the force balance in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00389-00084726-00084896 bubble may be modified by a layer of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00390-00084897-00085064 surface active molecules which can
+MQU90q_-fgM-00391-00085065-00085262 stabilize a micro bubble at a size where
+MQU90q_-fgM-00392-00085263-00085433 surface tension on a clean bubble would
+MQU90q_-fgM-00393-00085434-00085673 cause it to collapse rapidly this
+MQU90q_-fgM-00394-00085674-00085847 surface layer may vary in permeability
+MQU90q_-fgM-00395-00085848-00086057 so that if the bubble is compressed it
+MQU90q_-fgM-00396-00086058-00086237 may become impermeable to diffusion at
+MQU90q_-fgM-00397-00086238-00086387 sufficient compression if the solvent
+MQU90q_-fgM-00398-00086388-00086567 outside the bubble is saturated or
+MQU90q_-fgM-00399-00086568-00086759 unsaturated the partial pressure will be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00400-00086760-00086909 less than in the bubble and the surface
+MQU90q_-fgM-00401-00086910-00087077 tension will be increasing the internal
+MQU90q_-fgM-00402-00087078-00087254 pressure in direct proportion to surface
+MQU90q_-fgM-00403-00087255-00087416 curvature providing a pressure gradient
+MQU90q_-fgM-00404-00087417-00087584 to increase diffusion out of the bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00405-00087585-00087827 effectively squeezing the gas out of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00406-00087828-00088034 bubble and the smaller the bubble the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00407-00088035-00088271 faster it will get squeezed out a gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00408-00088272-00088430 bubble can only grow at constant
+MQU90q_-fgM-00409-00088431-00088595 pressure if the surrounding solvent is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00410-00088596-00088787 sufficiently supersaturated to overcome
+MQU90q_-fgM-00411-00088788-00088958 the surface tension or if the surface
+MQU90q_-fgM-00412-00088959-00089135 layer provides sufficient reaction to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00413-00089136-00089324 overcome surface tension clean bubbles
+MQU90q_-fgM-00414-00089325-00089453 that are sufficiently small will
+MQU90q_-fgM-00415-00089454-00089615 collapse due to surface tension if the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00416-00089616-00089873 super saturation is low bubbles with
+MQU90q_-fgM-00417-00089874-00090041 semi permeable surfaces will either
+MQU90q_-fgM-00418-00090042-00090263 stabilize at a specific radius depending
+MQU90q_-fgM-00419-00090264-00090419 on the pressure the composition of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00420-00090420-00090590 surface layer and the super saturation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00421-00090591-00090776 or continue to grow indefinitely if
+MQU90q_-fgM-00422-00090777-00091505 larger than the critical radius topic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00423-00091506-00092066 bubble nucleation bubble formation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00424-00092067-00092312 occurs in the blood or other tissues one
+MQU90q_-fgM-00425-00092313-00092483 of the hypothetical loci bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00426-00092484-00092654 nucleation is in crevice in macro
+MQU90q_-fgM-00427-00092655-00092719 molecule
+MQU90q_-fgM-00428-00092720-00092867 a solvent can carry a supersaturated
+MQU90q_-fgM-00429-00092868-00093142 load of gas in solution whether it will
+MQU90q_-fgM-00430-00093143-00093301 come out of solution in the bulk of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00431-00093302-00093485 solvent to form bubbles will depend on a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00432-00093486-00093710 number of factors something which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00433-00093711-00093923 reduces surface tension or its orbs gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00434-00093924-00094154 molecules or locally reduces solubility
+MQU90q_-fgM-00435-00094155-00094349 of the gas or causes a local reduction
+MQU90q_-fgM-00436-00094350-00094531 in static pressure in a fluid may result
+MQU90q_-fgM-00437-00094532-00094721 in a bubble nucleation or growth
+MQU90q_-fgM-00438-00094722-00094961 this may include velocity changes in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00439-00094962-00095153 turbulence in fluids and local tensile
+MQU90q_-fgM-00440-00095154-00095437 loads in solids and semi solids lipids
+MQU90q_-fgM-00441-00095438-00095611 and other hydrophobic surfaces may
+MQU90q_-fgM-00442-00095612-00095792 reduce surface tension blood vessel
+MQU90q_-fgM-00443-00095793-00096049 walls may have this effect dehydration
+MQU90q_-fgM-00444-00096050-00096238 may reduce gas solubility in a tissue
+MQU90q_-fgM-00445-00096239-00096418 due to higher concentration of other
+MQU90q_-fgM-00446-00096419-00096613 solutes and less solvent to hold the gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00447-00096614-00096811 another Theory presumes that microscopic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00448-00096812-00097010 bubble nuclei always exist in aqueous
+MQU90q_-fgM-00449-00097011-00097292 media including living tissues these
+MQU90q_-fgM-00450-00097293-00097486 bubble nuclei are spherical gas phases
+MQU90q_-fgM-00451-00097487-00097640 that are small enough to remain in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00452-00097641-00097807 suspension yet strong enough to resist
+MQU90q_-fgM-00453-00097808-00097979 collapse their stability being provided
+MQU90q_-fgM-00454-00097980-00098176 by an elastic surface layer consisting
+MQU90q_-fgM-00455-00098177-00098342 of surface active molecules which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00456-00098343-00098992 resists the effect of surface tension
+MQU90q_-fgM-00457-00098993-00099655 topic bubble growth once a micro bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00458-00099656-00099824 forms it may continue to grow if the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00459-00099825-00100079 tissues are still supersaturated as the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00460-00100080-00100213 bubble grows it may distort the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00461-00100214-00100375 surrounding tissue and cause damage to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00462-00100376-00100559 cells and pressure on nerves resulting
+MQU90q_-fgM-00463-00100560-00100709 in pain or may block a blood vessel
+MQU90q_-fgM-00464-00100710-00100879 cutting off blood flow and causing
+MQU90q_-fgM-00465-00100880-00101090 hypoxia in the tissues normally perfused
+MQU90q_-fgM-00466-00101091-00101315 by the vessel bubbles can also damage
+MQU90q_-fgM-00467-00101316-00101474 the vascular endothelium through
+MQU90q_-fgM-00468-00101475-00101650 ischemia and reperfusion physical
+MQU90q_-fgM-00469-00101651-00101816 contact with the endothelium or by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00470-00101817-00102071 physical deformation this damage may
+MQU90q_-fgM-00471-00102072-00102248 release endothelial membrane micro
+MQU90q_-fgM-00472-00102249-00102398 particles if a bubble or an object
+MQU90q_-fgM-00473-00102399-00102610 exists which collects gas molecules this
+MQU90q_-fgM-00474-00102611-00102802 collection of gas molecules may reach a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00475-00102803-00102979 size where the internal pressure exceeds
+MQU90q_-fgM-00476-00102980-00103124 the combined surface tension and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00477-00103125-00103264 external pressure and the bubble will
+MQU90q_-fgM-00478-00103265-00103492 grow if the solvent is sufficiently
+MQU90q_-fgM-00479-00103493-00103700 supersaturated the diffusion of gas into
+MQU90q_-fgM-00480-00103701-00103838 the bubble will exceed the rate at which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00481-00103839-00104032 it diffuses back into solution and if
+MQU90q_-fgM-00482-00104033-00104189 this excess pressure is greater than the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00483-00104190-00104341 pressure due to surface tension the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00484-00104342-00104557 bubble will continue to grow when a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00485-00104558-00104699 bubble grows the surface tension
+MQU90q_-fgM-00486-00104700-00104870 decreases and the interior pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00487-00104871-00105091 drops allowing gas to diffuse in faster
+MQU90q_-fgM-00488-00105092-00105281 and diffuse out slower so the bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00489-00105282-00105443 grows or shrinks in a positive feedback
+MQU90q_-fgM-00490-00105444-00105727 situation the growth rate is reduced as
+MQU90q_-fgM-00491-00105728-00105875 the bubble grows because the surface
+MQU90q_-fgM-00492-00105876-00106036 area increases as the square of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00493-00106038-00106084 radius
+MQU90q_-fgM-00494-00106085-00106247 while the volume increases as the cube
+MQU90q_-fgM-00495-00106248-00106472 of the radius if the external pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00496-00106473-00106691 is reduced due to reduced hydrostatic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00497-00106692-00106850 pressure during ascent the bubble will
+MQU90q_-fgM-00498-00106851-00107057 also grow and conversely an increased
+MQU90q_-fgM-00499-00107058-00107222 external pressure will cause the bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00500-00107223-00107378 to shrink but may not cause it to be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00501-00107379-00107536 eliminated entirely if a compression
+MQU90q_-fgM-00502-00107538-00107726 resistant surface layer exists the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00503-00107727-00107906 variable permeability model ordering
+MQU90q_-fgM-00504-00107907-00108083 hypothesis states that nuclei and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00505-00108083-00108259 neither created nor totally eliminated
+MQU90q_-fgM-00506-00108260-00108391 during the pressure cycle and the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00507-00108392-00108563 initial ordering according to size is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00508-00108564-00108827 preserved therefore each bubble count is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00509-00108828-00109003 determined by the properties in behavior
+MQU90q_-fgM-00510-00109004-00109244 of a nominal critical nucleus which is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00511-00109245-00109427 at the threshold of bubble formation all
+MQU90q_-fgM-00512-00109428-00109636 larger nuclei will form bubbles and all
+MQU90q_-fgM-00513-00109638-00110399 smaller nuclei will not topic bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00514-00110400-00110921 distribution decompression bubbles
+MQU90q_-fgM-00515-00110922-00111083 appear to form mostly in the systemic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00516-00111083-00111239 capillaries where the gas concentration
+MQU90q_-fgM-00517-00111240-00111452 is highest often those feeding the veins
+MQU90q_-fgM-00518-00111453-00111691 draining the active limbs they do not
+MQU90q_-fgM-00519-00111692-00111875 generally form in the arteries provided
+MQU90q_-fgM-00520-00111876-00112015 that ambient pressure reduction is not
+MQU90q_-fgM-00521-00112016-00112226 too rapid as arterial blood has recently
+MQU90q_-fgM-00522-00112227-00112408 had the opportunity to release excess
+MQU90q_-fgM-00523-00112409-00112658 gas into the lungs the bubbles carried
+MQU90q_-fgM-00524-00112658-00112802 back to the heart in the veins may be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00525-00112803-00112958 transferred to the systemic circulation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00526-00112958-00113213 via a patent foramen ovale in divers
+MQU90q_-fgM-00527-00113214-00113378 with this septal defect after which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00528-00113379-00113509 there is a risk of occlusion of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00529-00113510-00113657 capillaries in whichever part of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00530-00113658-00113825 body they end up in bubbles are also
+MQU90q_-fgM-00531-00113826-00114016 known to form within other tissues where
+MQU90q_-fgM-00532-00114017-00114154 they may cause damage leading to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00533-00114155-00114395 symptoms of decompression sickness this
+MQU90q_-fgM-00534-00114396-00114545 damage is likely to be caused by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00535-00114546-00114749 mechanical deformation and stresses on
+MQU90q_-fgM-00536-00114750-00114926 the cells rather than local hypoxia
+MQU90q_-fgM-00537-00114927-00115090 which is an assumed mechanism in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00538-00115091-00115753 case of gas embolism of the capillaries
+MQU90q_-fgM-00539-00115754-00116383 topic bubble elimination bubbles which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00540-00116384-00116515 are carried back to the heart in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00541-00116516-00116686 veins will normally pass into the right
+MQU90q_-fgM-00542-00116688-00116840 side of the heart and from there they
+MQU90q_-fgM-00543-00116841-00116965 will normally enter the pulmonary
+MQU90q_-fgM-00544-00116966-00117154 circulation and eventually pass through
+MQU90q_-fgM-00545-00117155-00117310 or be trapped in the capillaries of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00546-00117311-00117476 lungs which are around the alveoli and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00547-00117477-00117683 very near to the respiratory gas where
+MQU90q_-fgM-00548-00117683-00117827 the gas will diffuse from the bubbles
+MQU90q_-fgM-00549-00117828-00117979 though the capillary and alveolar walls
+MQU90q_-fgM-00550-00117980-00118214 into the gas in the lung if the number
+MQU90q_-fgM-00551-00118215-00118349 of lung capillaries blocked by these
+MQU90q_-fgM-00552-00118350-00118547 bubbles is relatively small the diver
+MQU90q_-fgM-00553-00118548-00118733 will not display symptoms and no tissue
+MQU90q_-fgM-00554-00118733-00118889 will be damaged lung tissues are
+MQU90q_-fgM-00555-00118890-00119086 adequately oxygenated by diffusion the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00556-00119088-00119219 bubbles which are small enough to pass
+MQU90q_-fgM-00557-00119220-00119363 through the lung capillaries may be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00558-00119364-00119533 small enough to be dissolved due to a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00559-00119534-00119699 combination of surface tension and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00560-00119700-00119876 diffusion to a lowered concentration in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00561-00119877-00120026 the surrounding blood though the varying
+MQU90q_-fgM-00562-00120027-00120218 permeability model nucleation theory
+MQU90q_-fgM-00563-00120219-00120377 implies that most bubbles passing
+MQU90q_-fgM-00564-00120378-00120539 through the pulmonary circulation will
+MQU90q_-fgM-00565-00120540-00120689 lose enough gas to pass through the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00566-00120690-00120835 capillaries and return to the systemic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00567-00120836-00121043 circulation as recycled but stable
+MQU90q_-fgM-00568-00121044-00121210 nuclei bubbles which form within the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00569-00121211-00121403 tissues must be eliminated in situ by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00570-00121404-00121574 diffusion which implies a suitable
+MQU90q_-fgM-00571-00121575-00122363 concentration gradient topic isobaric
+MQU90q_-fgM-00572-00122364-00123047 counter diffusion ICD isobaric counter
+MQU90q_-fgM-00573-00123048-00123218 diffusion is the diffusion of gases in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00574-00123219-00123391 opposite directions caused by a change
+MQU90q_-fgM-00575-00123392-00123533 in the composition of the external
+MQU90q_-fgM-00576-00123533-00123695 ambient gas or breathing gas without
+MQU90q_-fgM-00577-00123696-00123938 change in the ambient pressure during
+MQU90q_-fgM-00578-00123939-00124118 decompression after a dive this can
+MQU90q_-fgM-00579-00124119-00124265 occur when a change is made to the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00580-00124266-00124427 breathing gas or when the diver moves
+MQU90q_-fgM-00581-00124428-00124589 into a gas filled environment which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00582-00124590-00124757 differs from the breathing gas while not
+MQU90q_-fgM-00583-00124758-00124901 strictly speaking a phenomenon of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00584-00124902-00125072 decompression it is a complication that
+MQU90q_-fgM-00585-00125073-00125252 can occur during decompression and that
+MQU90q_-fgM-00586-00125253-00125429 can result in the formation or growth of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00587-00125430-00125560 bubbles without changes in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00588-00125561-00125815 environmental pressure two forms of this
+MQU90q_-fgM-00589-00125816-00125959 phenomenon have been described by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00590-00125960-00126229 Lambertson superficial ICD also known as
+MQU90q_-fgM-00591-00126230-00126389 steady state isobaric counter diffusion
+MQU90q_-fgM-00592-00126390-00126589 occurs when the inert gas breed by the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00593-00126590-00126803 diver diffuses more slowly into the body
+MQU90q_-fgM-00594-00126804-00126968 than the inert gas surrounding the body
+MQU90q_-fgM-00595-00126969-00127135 an example of this would be breathing
+MQU90q_-fgM-00596-00127136-00127397 air in a helix environment the helium in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00597-00127398-00127585 the helix diffuses into the skin quickly
+MQU90q_-fgM-00598-00127586-00127789 while the nitrogen diffuses more slowly
+MQU90q_-fgM-00599-00127790-00127958 from the capillaries to the skin and out
+MQU90q_-fgM-00600-00127958-00128153 of the body the resulting effect
+MQU90q_-fgM-00601-00128154-00128372 generates super saturation in certain
+MQU90q_-fgM-00602-00128373-00128546 sites of the superficial tissues in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00603-00128547-00128734 formation of inert gas bubbles deep
+MQU90q_-fgM-00604-00128735-00128954 tissue ICD also known as transient
+MQU90q_-fgM-00605-00128955-00129146 isobaric counter diffusion occurs when
+MQU90q_-fgM-00606-00129147-00129299 different inert gases are breathed by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00607-00129300-00129533 the diver in sequence the rapidly
+MQU90q_-fgM-00608-00129533-00129715 diffusing gas is transported into the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00609-00129716-00129835 tissue faster than this
+MQU90q_-fgM-00610-00129836-00130022 flower defusing gas is transported out
+MQU90q_-fgM-00611-00130023-00130202 of the tissue this can occur as divers
+MQU90q_-fgM-00612-00130203-00130358 switch from a nitrogen mixture to a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00613-00130358-00130571 helium mixture diffusivity of helium is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00614-00130572-00130759 two point six five times faster than
+MQU90q_-fgM-00615-00130760-00130952 nitrogen or when saturation divers
+MQU90q_-fgM-00616-00130953-00131138 breathing hydraulics switched to a helix
+MQU90q_-fgM-00617-00131139-00131300 mixture there is another effect which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00618-00131301-00131444 can manifest as a result of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00619-00131445-00131636 disparity in solubility between inert
+MQU90q_-fgM-00620-00131637-00131801 breathing gas dillion's which occurs in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00621-00131802-00131960 isobaric gas switches near the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00622-00131961-00132113 decompression ceiling between a low
+MQU90q_-fgM-00623-00132114-00132323 solubility gas typically helium and a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00624-00132324-00132542 higher solubility gas typically nitrogen
+MQU90q_-fgM-00625-00132543-00132707 and inner-ear decompression model by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00626-00132708-00132854 Gillette and Mitchell suggests that a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00627-00132855-00133043 transient increase in gas tension after
+MQU90q_-fgM-00628-00133044-00133214 a switch from helium to nitrogen in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00629-00133215-00133358 breathing gas may result from the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00630-00133359-00133502 difference in gas transfer between
+MQU90q_-fgM-00631-00133503-00133745 compartments if the transport of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00632-00133746-00133925 nitrogen into the vascular compartment
+MQU90q_-fgM-00633-00133926-00134126 by perfusion exceeds removal of helium
+MQU90q_-fgM-00634-00134127-00134318 by perfusion while transfer of helium
+MQU90q_-fgM-00635-00134319-00134459 into the vascular compartment by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00636-00134460-00134629 diffusion from the Paralympian endolymph
+MQU90q_-fgM-00637-00134630-00134774 exceeds the counter diffusion of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00638-00134775-00134957 nitrogen this may result in a temporary
+MQU90q_-fgM-00639-00134958-00135149 increase in total gas tension as the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00640-00135150-00135341 input of nitrogen exceeds the removal of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00641-00135342-00135494 helium which can result in bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00642-00135495-00135764 formation and growth this model suggests
+MQU90q_-fgM-00643-00135765-00135923 that diffusion of gases from the middle
+MQU90q_-fgM-00644-00135924-00136054 here across the round window is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00645-00136055-00136301 negligible the model is not necessarily
+MQU90q_-fgM-00646-00136302-00136508 applicable to all tissue types Lambert's
+MQU90q_-fgM-00647-00136509-00136712 and made suggestions to help avoid ICD
+MQU90q_-fgM-00648-00136713-00136997 while diving if the diver is surrounded
+MQU90q_-fgM-00649-00136998-00137183 by or saturated with nitrogen they
+MQU90q_-fgM-00650-00137184-00137471 should not breathe helium rich gases gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00651-00137472-00137639 switches that involve going from helium
+MQU90q_-fgM-00652-00137640-00137831 rich mixtures to nitrogen rich mixtures
+MQU90q_-fgM-00653-00137832-00137993 would be acceptable but changes from
+MQU90q_-fgM-00654-00137994-00138143 nitrogen to helium should include
+MQU90q_-fgM-00655-00138144-00138338 recompression however do let in Michels
+MQU90q_-fgM-00656-00138339-00138479 more recent study of inner-ear
+MQU90q_-fgM-00657-00138480-00138749 decompression sickness ie DCs shows that
+MQU90q_-fgM-00658-00138750-00138904 the inner ear may not be well modeled by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00659-00138905-00139204 common eg Bullman algorithms do lead and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00660-00139205-00139358 Mitchell proposed that a switch from a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00661-00139359-00139550 helium rich mix to a nitrogen rich mix
+MQU90q_-fgM-00662-00139551-00139739 as is common in technical diving when
+MQU90q_-fgM-00663-00139740-00139913 switching from true mix to nitrox on
+MQU90q_-fgM-00664-00139914-00140081 ascent may cause a transient super
+MQU90q_-fgM-00665-00140082-00140261 saturation of inert gas within the inner
+MQU90q_-fgM-00666-00140262-00140585 ear and result in ie DCs they suggest
+MQU90q_-fgM-00667-00140586-00140744 that breathing gas switches from helium
+MQU90q_-fgM-00668-00140745-00140924 rich to nitrogen rich mixtures should be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00669-00140925-00141104 carefully scheduled either deep with due
+MQU90q_-fgM-00670-00141105-00141308 consideration to nitrogen narcosis or
+MQU90q_-fgM-00671-00141309-00141476 shallow to avoid the period of maximum
+MQU90q_-fgM-00672-00141477-00141665 super saturation resulting from the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00673-00141666-00141902 decompression switches should also be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00674-00141903-00142043 made during breathing of the largest
+MQU90q_-fgM-00675-00142044-00142244 inspired oxygen partial pressure that
+MQU90q_-fgM-00676-00142245-00142394 can be safely tolerated with due
+MQU90q_-fgM-00677-00142395-00142591 consideration to oxygen toxicity a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00678-00142592-00142760 similar hypothesis to explain the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00679-00142761-00142973 incidence of ie dcs when switching from
+MQU90q_-fgM-00680-00142974-00143168 trim externa trucks was proposed by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00681-00143169-00143237 Steve Burton
+MQU90q_-fgM-00682-00143238-00143387 who considered the effect of the much
+MQU90q_-fgM-00683-00143388-00143564 greater solubility of nitrogen than
+MQU90q_-fgM-00684-00143565-00143759 helium in producing transient increases
+MQU90q_-fgM-00685-00143760-00143939 in total inert gas pressure which could
+MQU90q_-fgM-00686-00143940-00144149 lead to dcs under isobaric conditions
+MQU90q_-fgM-00687-00144150-00144329 burden argues that effect of switching
+MQU90q_-fgM-00688-00144330-00144464 to night rocks from trimmings with a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00689-00144465-00144644 large increase of nitrogen fraction at
+MQU90q_-fgM-00690-00144645-00144797 constant pressure has the effect of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00691-00144798-00144965 increasing the overall gas loading
+MQU90q_-fgM-00692-00144966-00145130 within particularly the faster tissues
+MQU90q_-fgM-00693-00145131-00145301 since the loss of helium is more than
+MQU90q_-fgM-00694-00145302-00145474 compensated by the increase in nitrogen
+MQU90q_-fgM-00695-00145475-00145697 this could cause a media bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00696-00145698-00145889 formation and growth in the fast tissues
+MQU90q_-fgM-00697-00145890-00146189 a simple rule for avoidance of ICD when
+MQU90q_-fgM-00698-00146190-00146372 gas switching at a decompression sealing
+MQU90q_-fgM-00699-00146373-00146627 is suggested any increase in gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00700-00146628-00146756 fraction of nitrogen in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00701-00146757-00146915 decompression gas should be limited to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00702-00146916-00147068 one fifth of the decrease in gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00703-00147069-00147248 fraction of helium this rule has been
+MQU90q_-fgM-00704-00147249-00147443 found to successfully avoid ICD on
+MQU90q_-fgM-00705-00147444-00148202 hundreds of deep Tremec styves topic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00706-00148203-00148400 ultrasonic bubble detection in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00707-00148401-00148985 decompression research Doppler bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00708-00148986-00149156 detection equipment uses ultrasonic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00709-00149157-00149360 signals reflected from bubble surfaces
+MQU90q_-fgM-00710-00149361-00149558 to identify and quantify gas bubbles
+MQU90q_-fgM-00711-00149559-00149807 present in venous blood this method was
+MQU90q_-fgM-00712-00149808-00149975 used by dr. Meryl Spencer of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00713-00149976-00150152 institute of applied physiology and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00714-00150153-00150314 medicine in seattle who published a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00715-00150315-00150572 report in 1976 recommending that the ven
+MQU90q_-fgM-00716-00150573-00150731 current no decompression limits be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00717-00150732-00150911 reduced on the basis that large counts
+MQU90q_-fgM-00718-00150912-00151076 of venous gas bubbles were detected in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00719-00151077-00151271 divers exposed to the US Navy no
+MQU90q_-fgM-00720-00151272-00151484 decompression limits these non
+MQU90q_-fgM-00721-00151485-00151664 symptomatic bubbles have become known as
+MQU90q_-fgM-00722-00151665-00151940 silent bubbles and afford to contain
+MQU90q_-fgM-00723-00151941-00152114 nitrogen released from solution during
+MQU90q_-fgM-00724-00152115-00152315 ascent Doppler detection of venous
+MQU90q_-fgM-00725-00152316-00152501 bubbles has become an important tool in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00726-00152502-00152693 decompression research partly because it
+MQU90q_-fgM-00727-00152694-00152870 allows a non symptomatic endpoint for
+MQU90q_-fgM-00728-00152871-00153059 experimental work and partly because the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00729-00153060-00153188 equipment has become relatively
+MQU90q_-fgM-00730-00153189-00153404 affordable for field surveys on divers
+MQU90q_-fgM-00731-00153405-00153563 conducting ordinary recreational
+MQU90q_-fgM-00732-00153564-00153833 technical and professional dives Doppler
+MQU90q_-fgM-00733-00153834-00154022 bubble detection has also been used in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00734-00154023-00154214 saturation diving research Doppler
+MQU90q_-fgM-00735-00154215-00154391 signals for bubbles are generally output
+MQU90q_-fgM-00736-00154392-00154571 as an audible signal and may be graded
+MQU90q_-fgM-00737-00154572-00154721 according to the spencer scale or the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00738-00154722-00154982 kismet muscial scale the spencer scale
+MQU90q_-fgM-00739-00154983-00155171 was developed by Spencer and Johansson
+MQU90q_-fgM-00740-00155172-00155456 in 1974 and recognizes five grades of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00741-00155457-00155597 bubbles signal against the background
+MQU90q_-fgM-00742-00155598-00155933 sounds of cardiac function grade zero no
+MQU90q_-fgM-00743-00155934-00156185 bubbles signals detected gray dye
+MQU90q_-fgM-00744-00156186-00156392 occasional bubbles signals detected the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00745-00156393-00156587 majority of cardiac cycles are bubble
+MQU90q_-fgM-00746-00156588-00156663 free
+MQU90q_-fgM-00747-00156664-00156906 grade too many but less than half of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00748-00156907-00157129 cardiac cycles contain bubble signals
+MQU90q_-fgM-00749-00157130-00157419 grade three all cardiac cycles contain
+MQU90q_-fgM-00750-00157420-00157596 bubble signals but they do not obscure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00751-00157597-00157914 the signals of cardiac activity grade IV
+MQU90q_-fgM-00752-00157915-00158082 bubble signals are continuous and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00753-00158083-00158238 obscure the sounds of normal heart
+MQU90q_-fgM-00754-00158239-00158421 functions the Akismet muscle scale is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00755-00158422-00158550 similar and gives a more subtle
+MQU90q_-fgM-00756-00158551-00158700 gradation of bubbles but is more
+MQU90q_-fgM-00757-00158701-00158907 difficult to write proficiently the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00758-00158908-00159096 Spencer scale has been more popular in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00759-00159097-00159324 practice grade categories are nonlinear
+MQU90q_-fgM-00760-00159325-00159479 and cannot be averaged precordial
+MQU90q_-fgM-00761-00159480-00159651 monitoring of the pulmonary artery is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00762-00159652-00159849 the usual monitoring site as it combines
+MQU90q_-fgM-00763-00159850-00159996 all the blood returning to the body
+MQU90q_-fgM-00764-00159997-00160185 before it goes to the lungs so it is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00765-00160186-00160340 least likely to miss bubbles from a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00766-00160341-00160506 peripheral source and is most compatible
+MQU90q_-fgM-00767-00160507-00160737 with the Spencer and kam scales as heart
+MQU90q_-fgM-00768-00160738-00160971 sounds are clearly audible other sites
+MQU90q_-fgM-00769-00160972-00161103 which have been used include the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00770-00161104-00161325 subclavian vein carotid artery femoral
+MQU90q_-fgM-00771-00161326-00161607 vein and inferior vena cava protocols
+MQU90q_-fgM-00772-00161608-00161772 for ultrasonic investigation of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00773-00161773-00161922 decompression bubbles are still in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00774-00161923-00162057 development and may vary between
+MQU90q_-fgM-00775-00162058-00162210 researchers other methods of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00776-00162211-00162390 non-invasive bubble detection include
+MQU90q_-fgM-00777-00162391-00162576 two-dimensional echocardiography but
+MQU90q_-fgM-00778-00162577-00162747 Doppler appears to be more sensitive and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00779-00162748-00162941 picks up smaller bubbles two-dimensional
+MQU90q_-fgM-00780-00162942-00163103 imaging can provide a cross-sectional
+MQU90q_-fgM-00781-00163104-00163272 view along a single plane of all four
+MQU90q_-fgM-00782-00163273-00163401 chambers of the heart and therefore
+MQU90q_-fgM-00783-00163402-00163590 unlike Doppler which assesses blood
+MQU90q_-fgM-00784-00163591-00163785 prior to primary filtration by the lungs
+MQU90q_-fgM-00785-00163786-00163950 can also assess blood which will be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00786-00163951-00164204 circulated systemically echocardiography
+MQU90q_-fgM-00787-00164205-00164400 equipment has developed from bulky
+MQU90q_-fgM-00788-00164401-00164547 laboratory equipment to portable
+MQU90q_-fgM-00789-00164548-00164685 battery-powered with sufficient
+MQU90q_-fgM-00790-00164686-00164894 resolution suitable for field studies
+MQU90q_-fgM-00791-00164895-00165186 transthoracic echocardiogram is suitable
+MQU90q_-fgM-00792-00165187-00165363 for the sampling used in decompression
+MQU90q_-fgM-00793-00165364-00165558 studies to identify highly reflective
+MQU90q_-fgM-00794-00165559-00165803 gas bubbles detection of venous gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00795-00165804-00165987 bubbles by ultrasound imaging is a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00796-00165988-00166185 sensitive but not specific predictor of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00797-00166186-00166383 adverse effects of decompression similar
+MQU90q_-fgM-00798-00166384-00166521 to the published relationship between
+MQU90q_-fgM-00799-00166522-00166677 Doppler detected bubbles and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00800-00166678-00166926 decompression sickness the correlation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00801-00166927-00167078 between doppler detected intravascular
+MQU90q_-fgM-00802-00167079-00167283 bubbles and decompression sickness is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00803-00167284-00167502 that almost all divers who develop dcs
+MQU90q_-fgM-00804-00167503-00167688 after a dive produced large numbers of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00805-00167689-00167903 bubbles but even grade 3 or 4 bubbles
+MQU90q_-fgM-00806-00167904-00168087 could manifest without signs or symptoms
+MQU90q_-fgM-00807-00168088-00168303 of DCs and grade zero one and two
+MQU90q_-fgM-00808-00168304-00168486 bubbles are associated with very low
+MQU90q_-fgM-00809-00168487-00168768 risk in a series of tests by Sawatzky
+MQU90q_-fgM-00810-00168769-00168993 grade 3 bubbles were associated with a 5
+MQU90q_-fgM-00811-00168994-00169190 percent risk in grade four with about 10
+MQU90q_-fgM-00812-00169191-00169269 percent risk
+MQU90q_-fgM-00813-00169270-00169512 bubbles may occur after exposures that
+MQU90q_-fgM-00814-00169513-00169713 have very good safety records the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00815-00169714-00169884 utility of bubble detection is in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00816-00169885-00170058 assessing relative decompression stress
+MQU90q_-fgM-00817-00170059-00170274 the value of bubble detection in non
+MQU90q_-fgM-00818-00170275-00170451 symptomatic divers is that this can be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00819-00170452-00170643 used as a safer threshold for assessing
+MQU90q_-fgM-00820-00170644-00170814 acceptable decompression stress than the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00821-00170815-00170970 incidence of clinical symptoms for
+MQU90q_-fgM-00822-00170971-00171659 evaluating decompression algorithms
+MQU90q_-fgM-00823-00171660-00171918 topic decompression sickness and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00824-00171919-00172476 injuries intravascular bubbles caused
+MQU90q_-fgM-00825-00172477-00172638 clumping of red blood cells platelets
+MQU90q_-fgM-00826-00172639-00172865 are used up white blood cells activated
+MQU90q_-fgM-00827-00172866-00173165 vascular permeability is increased the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00828-00173166-00173319 gas in a bubble will equilibrate with
+MQU90q_-fgM-00829-00173320-00173460 the surrounding tissues and will
+MQU90q_-fgM-00830-00173461-00173678 therefore contain water vapor oxygen and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00831-00173679-00173936 carbon dioxide as well as the inert gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00832-00173937-00174156 vascular bubbles appear to form at the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00833-00174157-00174302 venous end of capillaries and pass
+MQU90q_-fgM-00834-00174303-00174444 through the veins to the right side of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00835-00174445-00174629 the heart and thereafter are circulated
+MQU90q_-fgM-00836-00174630-00175374 to the lungs topic problems due to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00837-00175375-00175944 vascular decompression bubbles bubbles
+MQU90q_-fgM-00838-00175945-00176097 may be trapped in the lung capillaries
+MQU90q_-fgM-00839-00176098-00176322 temporarily blocking them if this is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00840-00176323-00176601 severe the symptom called chokes may
+MQU90q_-fgM-00841-00176602-00176793 occur if the diver has a patent foramen
+MQU90q_-fgM-00842-00176794-00176958 ovale or a shunt in the pulmonary
+MQU90q_-fgM-00843-00176959-00177156 circulation bubbles may pass through it
+MQU90q_-fgM-00844-00177157-00177321 and bypass the pulmonary capillaries to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00845-00177322-00177549 enter the arterial blood if these
+MQU90q_-fgM-00846-00177550-00177711 bubbles are not absorbed in the arterial
+MQU90q_-fgM-00847-00177712-00177890 plasma and lodge in systemic capillaries
+MQU90q_-fgM-00848-00177891-00178076 that will block the flow of oxygenated
+MQU90q_-fgM-00849-00178077-00178257 blood to the tissues supplied by those
+MQU90q_-fgM-00850-00178258-00178425 capillaries and those tissues will be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00851-00178426-00178754 starved of oxygen moon and Kistler 1988
+MQU90q_-fgM-00852-00178755-00178899 concluded that the evidence suggests
+MQU90q_-fgM-00853-00178900-00179088 that the risk of serious neurological
+MQU90q_-fgM-00854-00179089-00179358 DCI or early onset DCI is increased in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00855-00179359-00179508 divers with a resting right to left
+MQU90q_-fgM-00856-00179509-00179927 shunting no evidence that P fo is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00857-00179928-00180601 related to mild or late onset bends
+MQU90q_-fgM-00858-00180602-00181277 topic extravascular bubbles bubbles may
+MQU90q_-fgM-00859-00181278-00181358 form within
+MQU90q_-fgM-00860-00181359-00181527 tissues as well as the blood vessels
+MQU90q_-fgM-00861-00181528-00181804 inert gas can diffuse into bubble nuclei
+MQU90q_-fgM-00862-00181805-00182053 between tissues in this case the bubbles
+MQU90q_-fgM-00863-00182054-00182210 can distort and permanently damage the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00864-00182211-00182476 tissue these bubbles may also compress
+MQU90q_-fgM-00865-00182477-00182675 nerves as they grow causing pain extra
+MQU90q_-fgM-00866-00182676-00182870 vascular or top furnace bubbles usually
+MQU90q_-fgM-00867-00182871-00183052 form in slow tissues such as joints
+MQU90q_-fgM-00868-00183053-00183196 tendons and muscles shades
+MQU90q_-fgM-00869-00183197-00183446 direct expansion causes tissue damage
+MQU90q_-fgM-00870-00183447-00183620 with the release of histamines and their
+MQU90q_-fgM-00871-00183621-00183899 associated effects biochemical damage
+MQU90q_-fgM-00872-00183900-00184094 may be as important as or more important
+MQU90q_-fgM-00873-00184095-00184876 than mechanical effects topic factors
+MQU90q_-fgM-00874-00184877-00185087 influencing uptake and elimination of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00875-00185088-00185593 dissolved gases and decompression risk
+MQU90q_-fgM-00876-00185594-00185837 the exchange of dissolved gases between
+MQU90q_-fgM-00877-00185838-00186004 the blood and tissues is controlled by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00878-00186005-00186178 perfusion and to a lesser extent by
+MQU90q_-fgM-00879-00186179-00186340 diffusion particularly in heterogeneous
+MQU90q_-fgM-00880-00186341-00186659 tissues the distribution of blood flow
+MQU90q_-fgM-00881-00186660-00186853 to the tissues is variable and subject
+MQU90q_-fgM-00882-00186854-00187121 to a variety of influences when the flow
+MQU90q_-fgM-00883-00187122-00187301 is locally higher that area is dominated
+MQU90q_-fgM-00884-00187302-00187513 by perfusion and by diffusion when the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00885-00187514-00187781 flow is low the distribution of flow is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00886-00187782-00187925 controlled by the mean arterial pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00887-00187926-00188120 and the local vascular resistance and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00888-00188121-00188321 the arterial pressure depends on cardiac
+MQU90q_-fgM-00889-00188322-00188526 output and the total vascular resistance
+MQU90q_-fgM-00890-00188527-00188779 basic vascular resistance is controlled
+MQU90q_-fgM-00891-00188780-00188953 by the sympathetic nervous system and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00892-00188954-00189163 metabolites temperature and local and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00893-00189164-00189340 systemic hormones have secondary and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00894-00189341-00189521 often localized effects which can vary
+MQU90q_-fgM-00895-00189522-00189706 considerably with circumstances
+MQU90q_-fgM-00896-00189707-00189935 peripheral vasoconstriction in cold
+MQU90q_-fgM-00897-00189936-00190114 water decreases overall heat loss
+MQU90q_-fgM-00898-00190115-00190288 without increasing oxygen consumption
+MQU90q_-fgM-00899-00190289-00190477 until shivering begins at which point
+MQU90q_-fgM-00900-00190478-00190663 oxygen consumption will rise though the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00901-00190664-00191387 vasoconstriction can persist topic
+MQU90q_-fgM-00902-00191388-00191912 breathing gas composition the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00903-00191913-00192071 composition of the breathing gas during
+MQU90q_-fgM-00904-00192072-00192253 pressure exposure and decompression is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00905-00192254-00192427 significant in a no gas uptake and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00906-00192428-00192560 elimination for a given pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00907-00192561-00192838 exposure profile breathing gas mixtures
+MQU90q_-fgM-00908-00192839-00192974 for diving will typically have a
+MQU90q_-fgM-00909-00192975-00193141 different gas fraction of nitrogen to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00910-00193142-00193378 that of air the partial pressure of each
+MQU90q_-fgM-00911-00193379-00193538 component gas will differ to that of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00912-00193539-00193726 nitrogen in air at any given depth and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00913-00193727-00193919 uptake an elimination of each inert gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00914-00193920-00194093 component is proportional to the actual
+MQU90q_-fgM-00915-00194094-00194345 partial pressure over time the two
+MQU90q_-fgM-00916-00194346-00194501 foremost reasons for use of mixed
+MQU90q_-fgM-00917-00194502-00194657 breathing gases are the reduction of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00918-00194658-00194752 nitrogen partial
+MQU90q_-fgM-00919-00194753-00194950 pressure by dilution with oxygen to make
+MQU90q_-fgM-00920-00194951-00195170 nitrox mixtures primarily to reduce the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00921-00195171-00195344 rate of nitrogen uptake during pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00922-00195345-00195557 exposure and the substitution of helium
+MQU90q_-fgM-00923-00195558-00195727 and occasionally other gases for the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00924-00195728-00195901 nitrogen to reduce the narcotic effects
+MQU90q_-fgM-00925-00195902-00196098 under high partial pressure exposure
+MQU90q_-fgM-00926-00196099-00196327 depending on the proportions of helium
+MQU90q_-fgM-00927-00196328-00196484 and nitrogen these gases are called
+MQU90q_-fgM-00928-00196485-00196696 helix if there is no nitrogen or Tremec
+MQU90q_-fgM-00929-00196697-00196879 sifter is nitrogen and helium along with
+MQU90q_-fgM-00930-00196880-00197041 the essential oxygen the inert gases
+MQU90q_-fgM-00931-00197042-00197236 used as substitutes for nitrogen have
+MQU90q_-fgM-00932-00197237-00197384 different solubility and diffusion
+MQU90q_-fgM-00933-00197385-00197578 characteristics in living tissues to the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00934-00197579-00197854 nitrogen they replace for example the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00935-00197855-00198058 most common inert gas diluent substitute
+MQU90q_-fgM-00936-00198059-00198221 for nitrogen is helium which is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00937-00198222-00198391 significantly less soluble in living
+MQU90q_-fgM-00938-00198392-00198608 tissue but also diffuses faster due to
+MQU90q_-fgM-00939-00198609-00198766 the relatively small size and mass of
+MQU90q_-fgM-00940-00198767-00198968 the he atom in comparison with the n2
+MQU90q_-fgM-00941-00198969-00199723 molecule topic body temperature and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00942-00199724-00200287 exercise blood flow to skin and fat are
+MQU90q_-fgM-00943-00200288-00200461 affected by skin and core temperature
+MQU90q_-fgM-00944-00200462-00200618 and resting muscle perfusion is
+MQU90q_-fgM-00945-00200619-00200758 controlled by the temperature of the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00946-00200759-00201032 muscle itself during exercise increased
+MQU90q_-fgM-00947-00201033-00201206 flow to the working muscles is often
+MQU90q_-fgM-00948-00201207-00201356 balanced by reduced flow to other
+MQU90q_-fgM-00949-00201357-00201559 tissues such as kidneys spleen and liver
+MQU90q_-fgM-00950-00201560-00201751 blood flow to the muscles is lower in
+MQU90q_-fgM-00951-00201752-00201964 cold water but exercise keeps the muscle
+MQU90q_-fgM-00952-00201965-00202135 warm and flow elevated even when the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00953-00202136-00202360 skin is chilled blood flow to fat
+MQU90q_-fgM-00954-00202361-00202564 normally increases during exercise but
+MQU90q_-fgM-00955-00202565-00202741 this is inhibited by immersion in cold
+MQU90q_-fgM-00956-00202742-00203021 water adaptation to cold reduces the
+MQU90q_-fgM-00957-00203022-00203209 extreme vasoconstriction which usually
+MQU90q_-fgM-00958-00203210-00203350 occurs with cold water immersion
+MQU90q_-fgM-00959-00203351-00203582 variations in perfusion distribution do
+MQU90q_-fgM-00960-00203583-00203788 not necessarily affect respiratory inert
+MQU90q_-fgM-00961-00203789-00203959 gas exchange though some gas may be
+MQU90q_-fgM-00962-00203960-00204154 locally trapped by changes in perfusion
+MQU90q_-fgM-00963-00204155-00204407 rest in a cold environment will reduce
+MQU90q_-fgM-00964-00204408-00204598 inert gas exchange from skin fat and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00965-00204599-00204646 muscle
+MQU90q_-fgM-00966-00204647-00204811 whereas exercise will increase gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-00967-00204812-00205052 exchange exercise during decompression
+MQU90q_-fgM-00968-00205053-00205267 can reduce decompression time and risk
+MQU90q_-fgM-00969-00205269-00205451 providing bubbles are not present but
+MQU90q_-fgM-00970-00205452-00205625 can increase risk if bubbles are present
+MQU90q_-fgM-00971-00205626-00205823 and no gas exchange is least favorable
+MQU90q_-fgM-00972-00205823-00206014 for the diver who is warm and exercises
+MQU90q_-fgM-00973-00206015-00206182 at depth during the in gassing phase and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00974-00206183-00206848 rests in is cold during decompression
+MQU90q_-fgM-00975-00206848-00207490 topic other factors other factors which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00976-00207491-00207564 can affect
+MQU90q_-fgM-00977-00207565-00207708 impression risk include oxygen
+MQU90q_-fgM-00978-00207709-00207946 concentration carbon dioxide levels body
+MQU90q_-fgM-00979-00207946-00208150 position vasodilators and constrictors
+MQU90q_-fgM-00980-00208151-00208308 positive or negative pressure breathing
+MQU90q_-fgM-00981-00208309-00208536 and dehydration blood volume individual
+MQU90q_-fgM-00982-00208537-00208710 susceptibility to decompression sickness
+MQU90q_-fgM-00983-00208711-00208878 has components which can be attributed
+MQU90q_-fgM-00984-00208879-00209094 to a specific cause and components which
+MQU90q_-fgM-00985-00209096-00209319 appear to be random the random component
+MQU90q_-fgM-00986-00209321-00209521 makes successive decompressions a poor
+MQU90q_-fgM-00987-00209521-00209754 test of susceptibility obesity and high
+MQU90q_-fgM-00988-00209755-00209928 serum lipid levels have been implicated
+MQU90q_-fgM-00989-00209929-00210151 by some studies as risk factors and risk
+MQU90q_-fgM-00990-00210152-00210417 seems to increase with age another study
+MQU90q_-fgM-00991-00210419-00210589 has also shown that older subjects
+MQU90q_-fgM-00992-00210590-00210717 tended to bubble more than younger
+MQU90q_-fgM-00993-00210719-00210913 subjects for reasons not yet known but
+MQU90q_-fgM-00994-00210914-00211090 no trends between wait body fat or
+MQU90q_-fgM-00995-00211091-00211273 gender and bubbles were identified and
+MQU90q_-fgM-00996-00211273-00211431 the question of why some people are more
+MQU90q_-fgM-00997-00211432-00211581 likely to form bubbles than others
+MQU90q_-fgM-00998-00211582-00212373 remains unclear topic saturation
+MQU90q_-fgM-00999-00212375-00212952 decompression saturation decompression
+MQU90q_-fgM-01000-00212953-00213151 is a physiological process of transition
+MQU90q_-fgM-01001-00213152-00213285 from a steady state of full saturation
+MQU90q_-fgM-01002-00213286-00213492 with inert gas that raised pressure to
+MQU90q_-fgM-01003-00213494-00213652 standard conditions at normal surface
+MQU90q_-fgM-01004-00213653-00213889 atmospheric pressure it is a long
+MQU90q_-fgM-01005-00213890-00214063 process during which inert gases are
+MQU90q_-fgM-01006-00214064-00214251 eliminated at a very low rate limited by
+MQU90q_-fgM-01007-00214252-00214419 the slowest affected tissues and the
+MQU90q_-fgM-01008-00214421-00214615 deviation can cause the formation of gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-01009-00214616-00214789 bubbles which can produce decompression
+MQU90q_-fgM-01010-00214790-00215050 sickness most operational procedures
+MQU90q_-fgM-01011-00215051-00215188 rely on experimentally derived
+MQU90q_-fgM-01012-00215189-00215409 parameters describing a continuous slow
+MQU90q_-fgM-01013-00215410-00215580 decompression rate which may depend on
+MQU90q_-fgM-01014-00215581-00215767 depth and gas mixture in saturation
+MQU90q_-fgM-01015-00215767-00215928 diving all tissues are considered
+MQU90q_-fgM-01016-00215929-00216094 saturated and decompression which is
+MQU90q_-fgM-01017-00216094-00216231 safe for the slowest tissues will
+MQU90q_-fgM-01018-00216232-00216408 theoretically be safe for all faster
+MQU90q_-fgM-01019-00216409-00216642 tissues in a parallel model direct
+MQU90q_-fgM-01020-00216644-00216787 descent from air saturation at
+MQU90q_-fgM-01021-00216788-00217056 approximately 7 MSW produces venous gas
+MQU90q_-fgM-01022-00217057-00217363 bubbles but not symptomatic DCs deeper
+MQU90q_-fgM-01023-00217364-00217516 saturation' exposures require
+MQU90q_-fgM-01024-00217517-00217707 decompression to saturation schedules
+MQU90q_-fgM-01025-00217708-00217884 the safe rate of decompression from a
+MQU90q_-fgM-01026-00217885-00218052 saturation dive is controlled by the
+MQU90q_-fgM-01027-00218053-00218205 partial pressure of oxygen in the
+MQU90q_-fgM-01028-00218206-00218448 inspired breathing gas the inherent
+MQU90q_-fgM-01029-00218450-00218646 unsaturation due to the oxygen window
+MQU90q_-fgM-01030-00218648-00218835 allows a relatively fast initial phase
+MQU90q_-fgM-01031-00218836-00218994 of saturation decompression in
+MQU90q_-fgM-01032-00218996-00219132 proportion to the oxygen partial
+MQU90q_-fgM-01033-00219133-00219303 pressure and then controls the rate of
+MQU90q_-fgM-01034-00219304-00219451 further decompression limited by the
+MQU90q_-fgM-01035-00219452-00219648 half time of inert gas elimination from
+MQU90q_-fgM-01036-00219650-00219901 the slowest compartment however some
+MQU90q_-fgM-01037-00219902-00220075 saturation decompression schedules
+MQU90q_-fgM-01038-00220076-00220206 specifically do not allow an
+MQU90q_-fgM-01039-00220207-00220344 decompression to start with an upward
+MQU90q_-fgM-01040-00220346-00220615 excursion neither the excursions nor the
+MQU90q_-fgM-01041-00220616-00220779 decompression procedures currently in
+MQU90q_-fgM-01042-00220780-00220959 use 2016 have been
+MQU90q_-fgM-01043-00220960-00221124 - cause decompression problems in
+MQU90q_-fgM-01044-00221125-00221266 isolation but there appears to be
+MQU90q_-fgM-01045-00221267-00221409 significantly higher risk when
+MQU90q_-fgM-01046-00221410-00221592 excursions are followed by decompression
+MQU90q_-fgM-01047-00221594-00221784 before non symptomatic bubbles resulting
+MQU90q_-fgM-01048-00221785-00221978 from excursions have totally resolved
+MQU90q_-fgM-01049-00221979-00222217 starting decompression while bubbles are
+MQU90q_-fgM-01050-00222217-00222375 present appears to be the significant
+MQU90q_-fgM-01051-00222376-00222538 factor in many cases of otherwise
+MQU90q_-fgM-01052-00222539-00222732 unexpected decompression sickness during
+MQU90q_-fgM-01053-00222733-00222906 routine saturation decompression
+MQU90q_-fgM-01054-00222907-00223152 application of a bubble model in 1985
+MQU90q_-fgM-01055-00223153-00223302 allowed successful modeling of
+MQU90q_-fgM-01056-00223303-00223489 conventional decompressions altitude
+MQU90q_-fgM-01057-00223490-00223677 decompression no stop thresholds and
+MQU90q_-fgM-01058-00223678-00223881 saturation dives using one setting of
+MQU90q_-fgM-01059-00223882-00224105 for global nucleation parameters
+MQU90q_-fgM-01060-00224106-00224344 research continues on saturation
+MQU90q_-fgM-01061-00224344-00224499 decompression modeling and scheduled
+MQU90q_-fgM-01062-00224500-00224794 testing in 2015 a concept named extended
+MQU90q_-fgM-01063-00224794-00224958 oxygen window was used in preliminary
+MQU90q_-fgM-01064-00224959-00225153 tests for a modified saturation
+MQU90q_-fgM-01065-00225154-00225378 decompression model this model allows a
+MQU90q_-fgM-01066-00225379-00225544 faster rate of decompression at the
+MQU90q_-fgM-01067-00225544-00225694 start of the ascent to utilize the
+MQU90q_-fgM-01068-00225694-00225873 inherent unsaturation due to metabolic
+MQU90q_-fgM-01069-00225874-00226087 use of oxygen followed by a constant
+MQU90q_-fgM-01070-00226088-00226269 rate limited by oxygen partial pressure
+MQU90q_-fgM-01071-00226271-00226503 of the breathing gas the period of
+MQU90q_-fgM-01072-00226504-00226663 constant decompression rate is also
+MQU90q_-fgM-01073-00226664-00226872 limited by the allowable maximum oxygen
+MQU90q_-fgM-01074-00226873-00227049 fraction and when this limit is reached
+MQU90q_-fgM-01075-00227050-00227226 decompression rate slows down again as
+MQU90q_-fgM-01076-00227227-00227373 the partial pressure of oxygen is
+MQU90q_-fgM-01077-00227374-00227577 reduced the procedure remains
+MQU90q_-fgM-01078-00227578-00227874 experimental as of May 2016 the goal is
+MQU90q_-fgM-01079-00227875-00228054 an acceptable safe reduction of overall
+MQU90q_-fgM-01080-00228055-00228210 decompression time for a given
+MQU90q_-fgM-01081-00228211-00228579 saturation depth and gas mixture
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00000-00000032-00000231 please all players put your phones away
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00001-00000231-00000327 um
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00002-00000328-00000471 the game's about slots please sell
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00003-00000472-00000719 players put your phones away
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00004-00000720-00000919 okay chad i mean
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00005-00000919-00001047 thrash
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00006-00001048-00001247 oh man
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00007-00001248-00002871 teresh is the first band guys
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00008-00002872-00003311 i have w and 10 okay he has no w i've w8
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00009-00003311-00003454 is here though right he just wants to
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00010-00003455-00003590 get purely
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00011-00003590-00004111 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00012-00004112-00005183 very nice
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00013-00005184-00005454 okay that's fine that's fine i will eat
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00014-00005455-00005777 i i will stun him wait let me
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00015-00005778-00006395 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00016-00006396-00007070 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00017-00007070-00008617 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00018-00008618-00009895 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00019-00009896-00010151 guys the game is like really unusable
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00020-00010152-00010838 just done it really unloseable
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00021-00010839-00011103 let's try to defend the nexus okay that
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00022-00011104-00012023 might be it actually
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00023-00012024-00012142 i don't know
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00024-00012143-00012319 and i think we have to fight okay so
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00025-00012320-00012559 yeah i catch all the leonardo's leona
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00026-00012560-00014063 flash
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00027-00014063-00015116 a
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00028-00015116-00015430 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00029-00015431-00015702 is
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00030-00015703-00017804 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00031-00017805-00018158 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00032-00018159-00018279 yeah i mean
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00033-00018280-00018463 at some point during the game i'm not
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00034-00018464-00018583 gonna say who
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00035-00018584-00018814 but a wise man said really unlosable
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00036-00018815-00019055 before elder drake and then we just
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00037-00019056-00019279 lost elder lost nash and almost all the
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00038-00019280-00019494 game but we still managed to win so oh
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00039-00019495-00019822 actually oh i just i just heard cameras
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00040-00019823-00020119 had to leave the room ah
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00041-00020120-00020311 sorry that's actually sad yeah
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00042-00020312-00020719 unfortunately he's lying
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00043-00020720-00021007 he's lying you're still here do we we
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00044-00021008-00021255 don't have hand warmers right or do we
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00045-00021256-00021391 nope
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00046-00021392-00021607 i don't think so oh yeah
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00047-00021608-00021743 because you're stressed out because you
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00048-00021744-00021943 play against wound there oh a little
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00049-00021944-00022207 because the [__] window was open
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00050-00022208-00022414 what is he gonna eat
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00051-00022415-00022601 my dick
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00052-00022602-00022999 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00053-00023000-00023183 yeah he's like
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00054-00023184-00023519 a cute way to say dick i guess
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00055-00023520-00023832 cool
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00056-00023833-00024807 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00057-00024808-00024942 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00058-00024943-00025335 this could be good
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00059-00025336-00026679 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00060-00026680-00026857 i'm
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00061-00026858-00027727 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00062-00027727-00027846 if we get one more i think we should
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00063-00027847-00028062 start okay
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00064-00028063-00028812 okay
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00065-00028813-00029479 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00066-00029480-00029831 i think we should look right now okay
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00067-00029832-00029951 i'm looking i'm looking this good this
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00068-00029952-00030079 is good
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00069-00030080-00030207 why they don't change don't try still
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00070-00030208-00030502 right crackers
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00071-00030503-00030662 we can only lose if we get like insane
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00072-00030663-00030823 flanked by iran you want me to stay in
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00073-00030824-00031046 front of you or do you want me to stay i
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00074-00031047-00031158 need you
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00075-00031160-00031335 because i think it's
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00076-00031336-00031599 i mean i'll try to mark my calendar
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00077-00031600-00031790 do you guys know flash i'm not sure
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00078-00031791-00031902 probably i mean i think you're going to
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00079-00031903-00032014 slash
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00080-00032016-00032152 everyone else
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00081-00032154-00032689 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00082-00032689-00033704 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00083-00033705-00034855 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00084-00034856-00035163 can maybe reach okay maybe enough yeah
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00085-00035164-00036366 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00086-00036367-00038774 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00087-00038775-00038974 good job good job good job good job
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00088-00038975-00039892 nice one well thank you guys
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00089-00039893-00040183 [Music]
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00090-00040184-00040363 let's go
+MS6CBbX-GOQ-00091-00040364-00042657 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00000-00000060-00000191 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00001-00000192-00000719 yellow darkness my old friend
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00002-00000720-00001035 i've come to talk with you again
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00003-00001036-00001303 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00004-00001304-00001721 because the visions of
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00005-00001722-00001771 [Applause]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00006-00001772-00002039 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00007-00002039-00002439 while i was sleeping
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00008-00002440-00002702 and a vision
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00009-00002703-00003131 that was planned
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00010-00003132-00003203 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00011-00003204-00003450 [Applause]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00012-00003451-00004279 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00013-00004280-00004606 dreams i walk alone
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00014-00004607-00004791 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00015-00004792-00005111 nail straight with cobblestone
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00016-00005112-00005127 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00017-00005128-00005359 [Applause]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00018-00005360-00005591 made a hell of a
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00019-00005592-00006349 straight line
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00020-00006350-00007175 [Applause]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00021-00007176-00007606 let's play tonight
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00022-00007608-00007956 and touch the sound of silence
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00023-00007956-00008223 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00024-00008224-00008391 and then make it
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00025-00008392-00008710 let us know
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00026-00008711-00009014 ten thousand people maybe more
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00027-00009015-00009327 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00028-00009328-00009839 people talking without speeding
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00029-00009840-00010588 people
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00030-00010589-00011174 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00031-00011175-00011911 no one there
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00032-00011912-00012153 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00033-00012154-00012646 [Applause]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00034-00012647-00012932 silence like a cancer grows
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00035-00012933-00012949 [Applause]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00036-00012950-00013230 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00037-00013231-00013743 in my words that might teach you
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00038-00013744-00014030 take my arms that might
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00039-00014031-00015358 reach you
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00040-00015359-00015483 in the
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00041-00015484-00016022 world a silence
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00042-00016023-00016511 and people bald and pray
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00043-00016512-00016892 to the neon god they make
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00044-00016893-00017556 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00045-00017557-00018816 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00046-00018817-00018823 [Applause]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00047-00018824-00019591 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00048-00019592-00019991 of silence
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00049-00019992-00020279 hello darkness my old friend
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00050-00020280-00020494 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00051-00020495-00020918 i've come to talk with you again
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00052-00020919-00022007 [Music]
+MSz7uR7JtBk-00053-00022008-00022215 you
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00000-00000110-00000463 I'm so tap tap and I don't know why but
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00001-00000465-00000877 let's play bomber bother so this this
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00002-00000878-00001244 was made kind of to honor each brahmer
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00003-00001245-00001745 guys oh no controller support H bar for
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00004-00001746-00001860 guys
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00005-00001861-00002456 dk64 24 hour stream let's turn up the
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00006-00002457-00002648 credits this is free on its on steam
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00007-00002649-00002870 Anand heo now so it was a bright to see
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00008-00002871-00003470 it on Steam made by man rig box full of
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00009-00003471-00004136 bats as a good name so it's got Shawn in
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00010-00004137-00004513 it it's got lots of youtubers probably
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00011-00004514-00004859 lots of people recognize like this skunk
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00012-00004860-00005375 badger whatever you are set up for his
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00013-00005376-00005591 bestie beaver goodness to steal our
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00014-00005592-00006641 funds so dk64 is kind of a mess there
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00015-00006642-00007687 there we are
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00016-00007688-00007996 he had a bit of a rough time with this
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00017-00007997-00008173 mini game in particular doing the
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00018-00008175-00009269 charity stream and I didn't have a great
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00019-00009270-00009610 time with dk64 as a kid and this is kind
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00020-00009611-00009839 of the worst part of it all put into one
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00021-00009840-00010064 game so that's that's great we got to
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00022-00010065-00010585 bother 10 beavers beat but be bothered
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00023-00010586-00010934 okay sorry don't get mad he was stuck on
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00024-00010935-00011149 this for like an hour or more I don't
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00025-00011150-00011423 even remember how long I didn't get it
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00026-00011424-00011591 catch too much of it live but it was a
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00027-00011592-00012004 pretty crazy stream
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00028-00012005-00012806 get in the hole I can Rd I can already
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00029-00012807-00013106 feel those dk64 memories coming back why
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00030-00013107-00013216 would you do this
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00031-00013218-00013478 even even for charity it's not worth it
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00032-00013479-00013805 I know people that think dk64 is great
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00033-00013806-00013872 night
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00034-00013874-00014078 you're already allowed to have your
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00035-00014079-00014696 opinion but like well done well done I
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00036-00014697-00015071 think you mean to say it's a thanks for
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00037-00015072-00015365 like 500 achievements continue
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00038-00015366-00015541 what do you mean continue I won that was
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00039-00015543-00015761 that was it right we have to get back
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00040-00015762-00016262 every penny they stole from us there's
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00041-00016263-00016894 more I don't know how long this is but
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00042-00016895-00017453 oh no all right we got to rob the
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00043-00017454-00017633 beavers back - got to get the money back
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00044-00017634-00017797 you get no get in the hole well you can
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00045-00017798-00018059 jump I don't know what purpose is to
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00046-00018060-00018340 jump in this be if you never play dk64
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00047-00018341-00018560 it's the game that made me realize the
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00048-00018561-00018781 video game is hard oh he's good
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00049-00018782-00019247 it's chock full of really hard to play
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00050-00019248-00019444 minigames that have like unique controls
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00051-00019445-00019757 just for them and it's like you have to
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00052-00019758-00019937 do all of them eventually in like the
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00053-00019938-00020063 worst thing really is that you have to
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00054-00020064-00020180 switch characters you have to play every
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00055-00020181-00020552 level like more than six times because
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00056-00020553-00020672 you have to play through it with every
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00057-00020673-00020834 character to get all the things but you
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00058-00020835-00020990 can't get all the things on your first
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00059-00020991-00021167 playthrough more or less so you're gonna
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00060-00021168-00021335 have to play multiple times as some of
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00061-00021336-00021514 the characters in each level and it's
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00062-00021515-00021997 it's really bad shit
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00063-00021998-00022197 and this this really does accurately
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00064-00022198-00022625 represent the she her frustration
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00065-00022626-00022930 thought they added there's new mechanics
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00066-00022931-00023032 I don't know why you would put more
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00067-00023033-00023208 mechanics and then already bad minigame
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00068-00023209-00023860 Oh Oh God there was a time line that was
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00069-00023861-00024175 2 percent difficulty classic fare
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00070-00024176-00024340 oh my god there's a fare difficulty oh
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00071-00024341-00024630 my god Donkey Kong 64 never had a fare
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00072-00024631-00025213 difficulty I did enjoy the game to some
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00073-00025214-00025606 small extent but I never did beat it
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00074-00025607-00025981 I got chunky Kong and I think I about
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00075-00025982-00026175 went there you had to get like 18
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00076-00026176-00026356 billion bananas to be allowed to fight
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00077-00026357-00026632 the boss and like I was a little stupid
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00078-00026633-00026857 kid that was like fighting a boss was
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00079-00026858-00027102 hard enough as it was to like make me
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00080-00027104-00027343 suffer just to be able to like fight a
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00081-00027344-00027720 boss a few times was like oh my god boss
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00082-00027722-00027852 I really loved the Donkey Kong Country
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00083-00027854-00028123 series on SNES I was like wow I'm gonna
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00084-00028124-00028324 play more Donkey Kong it's gonna be just
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00085-00028325-00028440 like the other ones it's gonna be great
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00086-00028441-00029114 as I oh oh
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00087-00029116-00029895 much more reasonable difficulty but yeah
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00088-00029895-00030225 the impetus for the charity stream was a
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00089-00030226-00030643 particulars stupid comedian in like 50
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00090-00030644-00030982 air clubs that said some really stupid
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00091-00030983-00031290 stuff but hey mad respects to people who
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00092-00031291-00031537 take stupid bad things and turn them
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00093-00031538-00032046 into good things oh I love this menu by
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00094-00032047-00032239 the way it's such an n64 money you don't
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00095-00032239-00032455 get menus like this anymore you don't
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00096-00032456-00032668 get these dumb oh no no put the game
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00097-00032669-00032974 like physical space menus they were like
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00098-00032975-00033349 oh it's 3d man bommie ba ba me bon 64 I
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00099-00033350-00033637 love that game what are my videos no
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00100-00033638-00034177 what no control
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00101-00034178-00034570 I don't know I expect I put it in awe I
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00102-00034571-00034807 can't put in mono it's not an n64 game
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00103-00034808-00035038 if you can't put it in mono what's up
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00104-00035039-00035389 Shawn how you he doing he's just their
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00105-00035390-00036400 boss score we need to make 300 okay
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00106-00036401-00036652 that's the amount of money the charity
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00107-00036653-00036964 got so I I'm not I'm not gonna play that
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00108-00036965-00037296 long you kind of get we kind of get the
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00109-00037297-00037693 this a steal one all right we'll take a
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00110-00037694-00038083 look at the third level great job it'll
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00111-00038084-00038479 be a lot of time accident actually but
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00112-00038480-00039073 we're just do one more I wonder how long
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00113-00039074-00039220 it takes to actually complete this
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00114-00039221-00039408 especially unlike regular difficulty
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00115-00039409-00039751 regular completely unfair on the money
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00116-00039752-00040201 back see and this one they kind of
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00117-00040202-00040486 actually get stay scared I think they
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00118-00040487-00040888 get a lot more money I do I don't
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00119-00040889-00041104 remember if I beat it or not I remember
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00120-00041105-00041271 this from that 64 days I'm sure I hated
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00121-00041272-00041461 it but I didn't like a lot of the
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00122-00041462-00041587 minigames in that game actually
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00123-00041588-00041820 [Music]
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00124-00041821-00042531 welcome to bonus stage that that
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00125-00042532-00042699 particular sound effect is still
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00126-00042700-00043177 ingrained in my head that Oh banana
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00127-00043178-00043431 which i think is actually the composer
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00128-00043432-00043761 saying that and I just pitch down to BDK
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00129-00043762-00044556 voice imagine uuuu paid to make like the
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00130-00044557-00044730 DK rap and then after all of that
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00131-00044731-00044964 embarrassment to like hey we got one
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00132-00044965-00045126 more thing for you to do and you just
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00133-00045127-00045327 dumb stand really close to this
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00134-00045328-00046008 microphone ago oh but uh poor guy crazy
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00135-00046009-00046346 psychic okay you get lots of chivos
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00136-00046347-00046743 getting lots of dip okay one one look
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00137-00046744-00047508 one quick look at the progress a lot of
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00138-00047509-00047676 people gotta be assholes on Twitter why
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00139-00047677-00047940 do people gotta like aggressive the
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00140-00047941-00048087 attempt to ruin other people's lives
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00141-00048088-00048362 that they never met through reasons to
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00142-00048363-00048711 just people with nominee
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00143-00048712-00048939 but hey some people are good and they
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00144-00048940-00049262 make games that make us suffer for you
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00145-00049263-00049482 they make me feel bad for good reasons
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00146-00049483-00049968 I guess how's this for emotional game
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00147-00049969-00050118 design that make you play beaver bother
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00148-00050119-00050312 that's then they're already making a
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00149-00050313-00050615 suffer the fair difficulty this is like
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00150-00050616-00050817 if dk64 was like this I would probably
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00151-00050818-00051083 like actually finish it maybe something
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00152-00051084-00051339 that's but I wonder if there's some like
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00153-00051340-00051491 romhack so just make it so you can get
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00154-00051492-00051657 all of the stuff is any character or
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00155-00051658-00051870 something like only certain stuff is
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00156-00051871-00052164 like not is like stupid and you have to
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00157-00052165-00052614 get it from everybody infuriating way to
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00158-00052615-00052653 do it
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00159-00052654-00052866 plus I played I think I played spyro
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00160-00052866-00053304 before I played dk64 and Spyro is like
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00161-00053304-00053529 18 billion times better of an open-world
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00162-00053529-00053940 collectathon kind of thing than dk64 not
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00163-00053941-00054141 even sure you could call dk64 open-world
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00164-00054141-00054309 because like there's very specific
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00165-00054310-00054707 things you have to do I'm already at 30%
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00166-00054708-00054894 this is not crazy bad but I mean we've
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00167-00054895-00055214 we get that we get the deal here
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00168-00055215-00055419 shoutouts that fair difficulty about
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00169-00055420-00055644 that is that is so much fun who's this
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00170-00055645-00056305 man hello Parker yes is that so
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00171-00056307-00056516 Parker's here to stop me from playing
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00172-00056517-00056862 more beaver bothered can I just die good
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00173-00056863-00057279 good good that's how we end beaver
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00174-00057279-00057654 bother good night everybody
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00175-00057655-00057923 tap-tap here if you liked the video make
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00176-00057924-00058097 sure to subscribe and leave a like if
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00177-00058098-00058286 you want I read every comment posted so
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00178-00058287-00058405 it don't embarrass yourself
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00179-00058407-00058619 social media links in the description
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00180-00058620-00058792 including my patreon and any relevant
+MSUcRZp9RHE-00181-00058794-00059080 links to the game
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00000-00000000-00000267 oh really and Latin Lucius Domitius
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00001-00000268-00000503 Aurelius Augustus the ninth of September
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00002-00000504-00000998 to 14 or 215 September or October 275
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00003-00000999-00001460 was Roman Emperor from 270 to 275 born
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00004-00001461-00001676 in humble circumstances he rose through
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00005-00001677-00001870 the military ranks to become emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00006-00001871-00002096 during his reign he defeated the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00007-00002097-00002392 allamani after a devastating war he also
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00008-00002393-00002635 defeated the Goths vandals Jew hungy
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00009-00002636-00002987 Sarmatian and Carpi Aurelian restored
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00010-00002988-00003206 the Empire's eastern provinces after his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00011-00003207-00003529 conquest of the Palmyra Empire in 273
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00012-00003530-00003763 the following year he conquered the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00013-00003764-00003992 Gallic Empire in the West reuniting the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00014-00003993-00004253 Empire in its entirety he was also
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00015-00004254-00004456 responsible for the construction of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00016-00004457-00004619 Aurelian walls in Rome and the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00017-00004620-00004919 abandonment of the province of Dacia his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00018-00004920-00005104 successes were instrumental in ending
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00019-00005105-00005315 the Roman Empire's crisis of the third
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00020-00005316-00005536 century earning him the title restitute
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00021-00005537-00005713 her Orbis or restorer of the world
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00022-00005714-00005963 although Domitian was the first emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00023-00005964-00006158 who had demanded to be officially hailed
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00024-00006159-00006416 as Dominus at dais master and god these
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00025-00006417-00006623 titles never occurred in written form on
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00026-00006623-00006788 official documents until the reign of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00027-00006789-00007152 Aurelian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00028-00007153-00007676 topic early life
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00029-00007677-00007884 Aurelian was born on the 9th of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00030-00007884-00008169 September most likely in 214 ad although
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00031-00008170-00008510 215 ad is also possible the ancient
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00032-00008511-00008724 sources do not agree on his place of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00033-00008725-00008883 birth although he was generally accepted
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00034-00008884-00009092 as being a native of Illyricum but
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00035-00009093-00009270 another common belief was that he was
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00036-00009271-00009537 born in Greece sirmium and Pannonia
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00037-00009538-00009717 inferior now Shrestha meet Rebecca
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00038-00009718-00009971 Serbia is the preferred location which
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00039-00009972-00010176 was created by Aurelian as Emperor when
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00040-00010177-00010326 he abandoned the old transdanubia
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00041-00010327-00010626 territory of Dacia the academic
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00042-00010627-00010821 consensus is that he was of humble birth
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00043-00010822-00011004 and that his father was a peasant farmer
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00044-00011005-00011180 who took his Roman nomen from his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00045-00011181-00011441 landlord a senator of the clan Aurelius
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00046-00011442-00011714 sander suggests that his family might in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00047-00011715-00011924 fact have been of Roman settler origin
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00048-00011925-00012144 and of much higher social status however
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00049-00012145-00012371 his suggestion has not been taken up by
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00050-00012372-00012579 his more recent academic colleagues such
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00051-00012580-00012834 as southern and Watson using the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00052-00012835-00013028 evidence of the ancient sources it was
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00053-00013029-00013236 at one time suggested that or aliens
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00054-00013237-00013416 mother was a freed woman of a member of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00055-00013416-00013587 the clan Aurelius and that she herself
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00056-00013588-00013791 was a priestess of the Sun God in her
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00057-00013791-00014006 native village these two propositions
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00058-00014007-00014219 together with the tradition that the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00059-00014220-00014400 clan Aurelius had been entrusted with
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00060-00014401-00014586 the maintenance of that deities cult in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00061-00014587-00014790 Rome inspired the notion that this could
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00062-00014791-00014997 explain the devotion to the Sun God that
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00063-00014997-00015213 Aurelian was to manifest as Emperor see
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00064-00015213-00015471 below however it seems that this
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00065-00015472-00015702 Pleasant extrapolation of dubious facts
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00066-00015703-00015897 has now generally accepted as being no
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00067-00015897-00016335 more than just that
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00068-00016336-00016834 topic military career
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00069-00016835-00017077 it is commonly accepted that Aurelian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00070-00017078-00017353 probably joined the Army in 235 ad at
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00071-00017354-00017620 around age 20 it is also generally
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00072-00017621-00017830 assumed that as a member of the lowest
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00073-00017831-00018142 rank of society albeit a citizen he
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00074-00018143-00018286 would have enlisted in the ranks of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00075-00018287-00018550 legions saunders suggests that his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00076-00018551-00018754 career is more easily understood if it
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00077-00018755-00018946 is assumed that his family was of roman
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00078-00018947-00019129 settler origins with a tradition of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00079-00019130-00019327 military service and that he enlisted as
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00080-00019328-00019564 an equestrian this would have opened up
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00081-00019565-00019819 for him the Tres militia the three steps
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00082-00019820-00020080 of the equestrian military career one of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00083-00020081-00020272 the routes to higher equestrian office
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00084-00020273-00020527 in the Imperial service this could be a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00085-00020528-00020704 more expeditious route to senior
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00086-00020705-00020944 military and procure toriel offices than
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00087-00020945-00021148 that pursued by ex rancors although not
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00088-00021149-00021430 necessarily less laborious however
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00089-00021431-00021652 Saunders is conjecture as to orally ins
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00090-00021653-00021847 early career as not supported by any
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00091-00021848-00022018 evidence other than his nomen which
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00092-00022019-00022237 could indicate Italian settler ancestry
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00093-00022238-00022438 although even this is contested and his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00094-00022439-00022618 rise to the highest ranks which is more
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00095-00022619-00022804 easily understood if he did not have to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00096-00022805-00022903 start from the bottom
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00097-00022904-00023152 his suggestion has not been taken up by
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00098-00023153-00023521 other academic authorities whatever his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00099-00023522-00023725 origins Aurelian certainly must have
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00100-00023726-00023941 built up a very solid reputation for
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00101-00023942-00024088 military competence during the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00102-00024089-00024376 tumultuous mid decades of the century to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00103-00024377-00024586 be sure the exploits detailed in the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00104-00024587-00024832 historia Augusta Vita DV oriani
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00105-00024833-00025018 while not always impossible are not
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00106-00025019-00025210 supported by any independent evidence
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00107-00025211-00025387 and one at least is demonstrably an
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00108-00025388-00025666 invention typical of that author however
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00109-00025667-00025864 he was probably associated with
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00110-00025864-00026103 Gallienus cavalry army and shown as an
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00111-00026104-00026269 officer of that Corps daylight because
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00112-00026270-00026425 when he finally emerged in a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00113-00026426-00026632 historically reliable context in the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00114-00026633-00026848 early part of the reign of Claudius ii
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00115-00026849-00027318 he seems to have been its commander
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00116-00027319-00027831 topic service under Gallienus
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00117-00027832-00028083 his successes as a cavalry commander
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00118-00028083-00028263 ultimately made him a member of Emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00119-00028264-00028683 Gallienus entourage in 268 Aurelian and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00120-00028683-00028893 his cavalry participated in general
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00121-00028894-00029091 Claudius victory over the Goths at the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00122-00029092-00029333 Battle of nasus later that year
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00123-00029335-00029532 Gallienus travelled to Italy and thought
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00124-00029533-00029742 or ulis his former general and now
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00125-00029743-00030027 usurper for the throne driving or Aeolus
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00126-00030027-00030147 back into Mediolanum
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00127-00030148-00030324 galley and his promptly besieged his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00128-00030325-00030612 adversary in the city however while the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00129-00030613-00030758 siege was ongoing the Emperor was
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00130-00030760-00031020 assassinated one source says Aurelian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00131-00031020-00031254 who is present at the siege participated
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00132-00031255-00031452 and supported general Claudius for the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00133-00031452-00031674 purple which is plausible Aurelian was
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00134-00031675-00031869 married to o pious every 'no about whom
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00135-00031870-00032139 little is known like Aurelian she was
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00136-00032139-00032339 from Dacia they are known to have had a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00137-00032341-00032707 daughter together
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00138-00032708-00033254 topic service under Claudius
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00139-00033255-00033482 Claudius was acclaimed emperor by the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00140-00033483-00033710 soldiers outside Mediolanum the new
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00141-00033711-00033893 emperor immediately ordered the senate
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00142-00033894-00034154 to deify Gallienus next he began to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00143-00034155-00034295 distance himself from those responsible
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00144-00034296-00034532 for his predecessors assassination
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00145-00034533-00034742 ordering the execution of those directly
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00146-00034743-00035039 involved or Aeolus was still besieged in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00147-00035040-00035252 Mediolanum and sought reconciliation
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00148-00035253-00035456 with the new emperor but Claudius had no
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00149-00035457-00035702 sympathy for a potential rival the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00150-00035703-00035891 Emperor had oriole is killed and one
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00151-00035892-00036092 source implicates Aurelian in the deed
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00152-00036093-00036293 perhaps even signing the warrant for his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00153-00036294-00036434 death himself during the reign of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00154-00036435-00036680 Claudius Aurelian was promoted rapidly
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00155-00036681-00036842 he was given command of the elite
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00156-00036843-00037034 Dalmatian cavalry and was soon promoted
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00157-00037035-00037283 to overall Magister equity effectively
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00158-00037284-00037451 the head of the army after the Emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00159-00037452-00037643 and the Emperor Claudius own positioned
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00160-00037644-00037892 before his acclamation the war against
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00161-00037893-00038081 Tory olace and the concentration of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00162-00038082-00038297 forces in Italy allowed the allamani to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00163-00038298-00038450 break through the raishin limes along
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00164-00038451-00038696 the upper danube marching through raesha
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00165-00038697-00038879 and the alps unhindered they entered
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00166-00038880-00039062 northern Italy and began pillaging the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00167-00039063-00039476 area in early 269 Emperor Claudius and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00168-00039477-00039638 Aurelian marched north to meet the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00169-00039639-00039851 allamani defeating them decisively at
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00170-00039852-00039980 the Battle of Lake Wanaka
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00171-00039981-00040145 while still dealing with the defeated
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00172-00040146-00040322 enemy news came from the Balkans
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00173-00040323-00040508 reporting large-scale attacks from the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00174-00040509-00040760 her uli Goths get bids and Bastion I
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00175-00040761-00041051 Claudius immediately dispatched orillian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00176-00041052-00041219 to the Balkans to contain the invasion
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00177-00041220-00041423 as best he could until Claudius could
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00178-00041424-00041675 arrive with his main army the Goths were
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00179-00041676-00041873 besieging Thessalonica when they heard
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00180-00041874-00042035 of Emperor Claudius approached
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00181-00042036-00042206 causing them to abandon the siege and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00182-00042207-00042500 pillage northeastern Macedonia Aurelian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00183-00042501-00042704 intercepted the Goths with his Dalmatian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00184-00042705-00042905 cavalry and defeated them in a series of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00185-00042906-00043109 minor skirmishes killing as many as
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00186-00043110-00043439 3,000 of the enemy Aurelian continued to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00187-00043440-00043637 harass the enemy driving them northward
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00188-00043638-00043808 into Upper moja where Emperor Claudius
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00189-00043809-00044102 had assembled his main army the ensuing
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00190-00044103-00044303 battle was indecisive the northward
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00191-00044304-00044492 advance of the Goths was halted but
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00192-00044493-00044627 Roman losses were heavy
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00193-00044628-00044783 Claudius could not afford another
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00194-00044784-00044966 pitched battle so he instead laid a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00195-00044967-00045196 successful ambush killing thousands
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00196-00045197-00045428 however the majority of the Goths
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00197-00045429-00045635 escaped and began retreating south the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00198-00045636-00045872 way they had come for the rest of year
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00199-00045873-00046049 or really and harassed the enemy with
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00200-00046050-00046268 his Dalmatian cavalry now stranded in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00201-00046269-00046367 Roman territory
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00202-00046368-00046565 the Goths lack of provisions began to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00203-00046566-00046662 take its toll
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00204-00046663-00046951 Aurelian sensing his enemy's desperation
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00205-00046952-00047128 attacked them with the full force of his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00206-00047129-00047317 cavalry killing many and driving the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00207-00047318-00047596 remainder westward into Thrace as winter
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00208-00047597-00047776 set in the Goths retreated into the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00209-00047777-00047962 Hemus mountains only to find themselves
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00210-00047963-00048214 trapped and surrounded the harsh
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00211-00048215-00048406 conditions now exacerbated their
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00212-00048407-00048640 shortage of food however the Romans
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00213-00048641-00048835 underestimated the Goths and let their
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00214-00048836-00049021 guard down allowing the enemy to break
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00215-00049022-00049182 through their lines and escape
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00216-00049183-00049414 apparently Emperor Claudius ignored
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00217-00049415-00049603 advice perhaps from Aurelian and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00218-00049604-00049786 withheld the cavalry and sent in only
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00219-00049787-00050080 the infantry to stop their breakout the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00220-00050081-00050257 determined Goths killed many of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00221-00050258-00050410 oncoming infantry and were only
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00222-00050411-00050572 prevented from slaughtering them all
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00223-00050573-00050770 when Aurelian finally charged in with
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00224-00050771-00051049 his Dalmatian cavalry the Goths still
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00225-00051050-00051232 managed to escape and continued their
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00226-00051233-00051492 march through Thrace the Roman army
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00227-00051494-00051679 continued to follow the Goths during the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00228-00051679-00052027 spring and summer of 270 meanwhile a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00229-00052028-00052198 devastating plague swept through the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00230-00052199-00052404 balkans killing many soldiers in both
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00231-00052405-00052716 armies Emperor Claudius fell ill on the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00232-00052717-00052894 march to the battle and returned to his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00233-00052895-00053113 regional headquarters in sirmium leaving
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00234-00053114-00053326 Aurelian in charge of operations against
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00235-00053327-00053629 the Goths Aurelian used his cavalry to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00236-00053629-00053815 great effect breaking the Goths into
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00237-00053816-00054010 smaller groups which were easier to deal
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00238-00054011-00054238 with by late summer the Goths were
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00239-00054239-00054445 defeated any survivors were stripped of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00240-00054446-00054607 their animals in booty and were levied
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00241-00054608-00054816 into the army or settled as farmers in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00242-00054817-00055108 frontier regions Aurelian had no time to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00243-00055109-00055333 relish his victories in late August news
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00244-00055334-00055501 arrived from sirmium that Emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00245-00055502-00055879 Claudius was dead
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00246-00055880-00056403 topic opposition to Quinn Tillis
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00247-00056404-00056643 when Claudius died his brother
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00248-00056644-00056854 quintilius seized power with support of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00249-00056854-00057085 the Senate with an act typical of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00250-00057086-00057294 crisis of the third century the army
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00251-00057295-00057468 refused to recognize the new emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00252-00057469-00057637 preferring to support one of its own
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00253-00057638-00057831 commanders Aurelian was proclaimed
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00254-00057832-00058116 emperor in September 270 by the legions
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00255-00058117-00058354 in sirmium or really in defeated
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00256-00058354-00058563 quintilius troops and was recognized as
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00257-00058564-00058737 emperor by the senate after quintilius
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00258-00058738-00058996 death the claim that Aurelian was chosen
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00259-00058997-00059203 by Claudius on his deathbed can be
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00260-00059204-00059412 dismissed as propaganda later probably
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00261-00059413-00059766 in 272 Aurelian put his own dies and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00262-00059767-00059947 parried the day of Claudius death thus
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00263-00059948-00060124 implicitly considering quintal as a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00264-00060125-00060342 usurper with his base of power secured
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00265-00060344-00060516 he now turned his attention to Rome's
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00266-00060517-00060766 greatest problems recovering the vast
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00267-00060766-00060973 territories lost over the previous two
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00268-00060974-00061541 decades and reforming the race pública
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00269-00061542-00061980 topic Emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00270-00061982-00062619 topic the Roman Empire in the 270's
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00271-00062620-00062937 in 248 Emperor Philip the Arab had
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00272-00062938-00063125 celebrated the Millennium of the city of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00273-00063126-00063356 Rome with great and expensive ceremonies
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00274-00063357-00063546 and games and the Empire had given a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00275-00063547-00063735 tremendous proof of self-confidence in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00276-00063736-00063915 the following years
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00277-00063916-00064119 however the Empire had to face a huge
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00278-00064120-00064319 pressure from external enemies while at
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00279-00064320-00064515 the same time dangerous civil wars
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00280-00064516-00064686 threatened the Empire from within with
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00281-00064687-00064850 usurpers weakening the strength of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00282-00064851-00065160 state also the economic substrate of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00283-00065161-00065387 state agriculture and commerce suffered
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00284-00065388-00065525 from the disruption caused by the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00285-00065526-00065796 instability on top of this an epidemic
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00286-00065797-00066056 swept through the empire around 250
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00287-00066057-00066267 greatly diminishing manpower both for
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00288-00066268-00066543 the army and for agriculture the end
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00289-00066544-00066723 result was that the Empire could not
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00290-00066724-00066857 endure the blow of the capture of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00291-00066858-00067150 Emperor Valyrian in 260 by the sassanids
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00292-00067151-00067404 the eastern provinces found their
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00293-00067405-00067590 protectors in the rulers of the city of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00294-00067591-00067836 Palmyra in Syria whose autonomy grew
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00295-00067837-00068000 until the formation of the Palmyra
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00296-00068001-00068217 Empire which was successful in defending
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00297-00068218-00068496 against the Sassanid threat the western
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00298-00068497-00068700 provinces those facing the limes of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00299-00068701-00068937 Rhine seceded to form a third autonomous
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00300-00068938-00069093 state within the territories of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00301-00069094-00069297 Roman Empire which is now known as the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00302-00069298-00069618 Gallic Empire in Rome the emperor was
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00303-00069619-00069818 occupied with internal menaces to his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00304-00069819-00070025 power and with the defense of Italia and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00305-00070026-00070405 the Balkans
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00306-00070406-00070950 topic reunification of the empire
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00307-00070951-00071160 the first actions of the new emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00308-00071161-00071310 were aimed at strengthening his own
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00309-00071311-00071679 position in his territories late in 270
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00310-00071680-00071910 Aurelian campaigned in northern Italia
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00311-00071911-00072090 against the Vandals Jew hungee and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00312-00072091-00072306 Sarmatian x' expelling them from Roman
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00313-00072307-00072569 territory to celebrate these victories
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00314-00072570-00072768 Aurelian was granted the title of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00315-00072769-00073059 Germanicus maximus the authority of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00316-00073060-00073185 Emperor was challenged by several
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00317-00073186-00073524 usurpers septimius Urbanists Domitian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00318-00073525-00073712 as' and the rebellion of Felice usamos
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00319-00073713-00073911 who tried to exploit the sense of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00320-00073912-00074079 insecurity of the Empire and the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00321-00074080-00074250 overwhelming influence of the armies in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00322-00074251-00074541 Roman politics Aurelian being an
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00323-00074542-00074742 experienced commander was aware of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00324-00074743-00074888 importance of the army and his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00325-00074889-00075072 propaganda known through his coinage
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00326-00075073-00075231 shows he wanted the support of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00327-00075232-00075576 legions
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00328-00075577-00075801 topic defending Italy against the youth
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00329-00075802-00076156 on gay
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00330-00076157-00076356 the burden of the northern barbarians
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00331-00076357-00076749 was not yet over however in 271 the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00332-00076750-00076978 allamani moved towards Italia entering
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00333-00076979-00077161 the Pope plane and sacking the villages
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00334-00077162-00077353 they passed the Po River occupied
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00335-00077354-00077582 Placentia and moved towards Fano
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00336-00077583-00077838 Aurelian who was in Pannonia to control
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00337-00077839-00078024 the Vandals withdrawal quickly entered
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00338-00078025-00078237 Italia but his army was defeated in an
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00339-00078238-00078657 ambush near Placentia January 271 when
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00340-00078658-00078831 the news of the defeat arrived in Rome
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00341-00078832-00079042 it caused great fear for the arrival of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00342-00079043-00079318 the barbarians but Aurelian attacked the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00343-00079319-00079480 allemande ii camping near the met horse
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00344-00079481-00079666 river defeating them in the battle of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00345-00079667-00079711 Fano
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00346-00079712-00079918 and forcing them to recross the Po River
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00347-00079919-00080149 Aurelian finally routed them at Pavia
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00348-00080150-00080374 for this he received the title
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00349-00080375-00080530 Germanicus Maximus
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00350-00080531-00080718 however the menace of the Germanic
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00351-00080719-00080955 people and a Germanic invasion was still
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00352-00080956-00081160 perceived by the Romans as likely so
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00353-00081161-00081357 Aurelian resolved to build a new system
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00354-00081358-00081523 of walls around Rome that became known
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00355-00081524-00081919 as the Aurelian walls
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00356-00081920-00082153 topic defeat of the Goths and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00357-00082154-00082571 abandonment of Dacia
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00358-00082572-00082775 the emperor led his legions to the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00359-00082776-00082973 balkans where he defeated and routed the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00360-00082974-00083153 Goths beyond the Danube killing the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00361-00083154-00083366 Gothic leader can about ace and assuming
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00362-00083367-00083549 the title of Gothic as Maximus
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00363-00083550-00083801 however he decided to abandon the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00364-00083802-00084017 province of Dacia on the exposed north
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00365-00084018-00084227 bank of the Danube as too difficult and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00366-00084228-00084524 expensive to defend he reorganized a new
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00367-00084525-00084734 province of Dacia south of the Danube
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00368-00084735-00084875 inside the former moja
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00369-00084876-00085112 called Dacia or Ileana with serdica as
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00370-00085113-00085422 the capital
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00371-00085423-00086022 topic conquest of the Palmyra Empire
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00372-00086023-00086391 in 272 Aurelian turned his attention to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00373-00086392-00086559 the lost eastern provinces of the Empire
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00374-00086560-00086940 the so called Palmyra nem pyar ruled by
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00375-00086941-00087171 Queen Zenobia from the city of Palmyra
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00376-00087172-00087393 Zenobia had carved out her own empire
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00377-00087394-00087675 encompassing Syria Palestine Egypt and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00378-00087676-00087954 large parts of Asia Minor the syrian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00379-00087955-00088044 queen cut off
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00380-00088045-00088206 Rome's shipments of grain and in a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00381-00088207-00088383 matter of weeks the Romans started
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00382-00088384-00088617 running low on bread in the beginning
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00383-00088618-00088845 Aurelian had been recognized as Emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00384-00088846-00089100 while the ballot asunción obeah held the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00385-00089101-00089387 title of rex an Imperator king and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00386-00089388-00089739 supreme military commander but Aurelian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00387-00089740-00089946 decided to invade the eastern provinces
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00388-00089947-00090141 as soon as he felt his army to be strong
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00389-00090142-00090465 enough a shoe minor was recovered easily
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00390-00090466-00090666 every city but Byzantium and tyanna
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00391-00090667-00090807 surrendered to him with little
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00392-00090808-00091116 resistance the fall of Tyana lend itself
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00393-00091117-00091329 to a legend Aurelian to that point had
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00394-00091330-00091518 destroyed every city that resisted him
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00395-00091519-00091707 but he spared ty andhe after having a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00396-00091708-00091869 vision of the great first century
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00397-00091870-00092121 philosopher Apollonius of Tyana whom he
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00398-00092122-00092454 respected greatly in a dream Apollonius
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00399-00092455-00092706 implored him stating Aurelian if you
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00400-00092707-00092949 desire to rule abstain from the blood of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00401-00092950-00093213 the innocent Aurelian if you will
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00402-00093214-00093519 conquer be merciful whatever the reason
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00403-00093520-00093750 or really in spared tyanna it paid off
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00404-00093751-00093972 many more cities submitted to him upon
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00405-00093973-00094143 seeing that the emperor would not exact
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00406-00094144-00094425 revenge upon them within six months his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00407-00094426-00094638 army stood at the gates of Palmyra which
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00408-00094639-00094833 surrendered when Zenobia tried to flee
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00409-00094834-00095139 to the Sassanid Empire the Palmyra
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00410-00095140-00095447 n'aime pyre was no more
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00411-00095448-00095650 eventually Zenobia and her son were
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00412-00095651-00095831 captured and made to walk on the streets
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00413-00095832-00096013 of Rome in his triumph the woman in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00414-00096014-00096299 golden chains with the grain stores once
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00415-00096300-00096524 again shipped to Rome Aurelian soldiers
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00416-00096525-00096718 handed out free bread to the citizens of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00417-00096719-00096884 the city and the emperor was hailed a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00418-00096885-00097022 hero by his subjects
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00419-00097023-00097276 after a brief clash with the Persians
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00420-00097277-00097478 and another in Egypt against the usurper
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00421-00097479-00097718 firmus Aurelian was obliged to return to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00422-00097719-00098021 Palmyra in 273 when that city rebelled
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00423-00098022-00098324 once more this time Aurelian allowed his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00424-00098325-00098522 soldiers to sack the city and Palmyra
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00425-00098523-00098806 never recovered more honors came his way
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00426-00098807-00099023 he was now known as parthak as Maximus
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00427-00099024-00099278 and Resta tutor Orientis restorer of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00428-00099279-00099575 east the rich province of Egypt was also
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00429-00099576-00099797 recovered by Aurelian the bruschi and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00430-00099798-00100028 royal quarter in Alexandria was burned
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00431-00100029-00100276 to the ground this section of the city
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00432-00100277-00100472 once contained the Library of Alexandria
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00433-00100473-00100691 although the extent of the surviving
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00434-00100692-00101197 library in Orleans time is uncertain
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00435-00101198-00101746 topic conquest of the Gallic Empire
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00436-00101747-00102097 in 274 the victorious Emperor turned his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00437-00102098-00102319 attention to the West in the Gallic
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00438-00102320-00102589 Empire which had already been reduced in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00439-00102590-00102867 size by Claudius the second Aurelian won
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00440-00102868-00103044 this campaign largely through diplomacy
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00441-00103045-00103402 the Gallic Emperor tetrakis was willing
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00442-00103403-00103593 to abandon his throne and allow Gaul and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00443-00103594-00103794 Britain to return to the Empire but
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00444-00103795-00103982 could not openly submit to Aurelian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00445-00103983-00104224 instead the two seemed to have conspired
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00446-00104225-00104430 so that when the armies met at châlons
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00447-00104431-00104614 and champagne that autumn Tetrick is
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00448-00104615-00104808 simply deserted to the Roman camp and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00449-00104809-00105022 Aurelian easily defeated the Gallic army
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00450-00105023-00105298 facing him tetrakis was rewarded for his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00451-00105299-00105445 part in the conspiracy with a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00452-00105446-00105748 high-ranking position in illy itself or
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00453-00105749-00105955 really in return to Rome and won his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00454-00105956-00106168 last honorific from the Senate restitute
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00455-00106169-00106477 er Orbis restorer of the world this
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00456-00106478-00106696 title was first assumed by Aurelian in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00457-00106697-00106990 late summer of 272 and had been carried
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00458-00106991-00107167 previously by both Valyrian and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00459-00107168-00107467 Gallienus in four years Aurelian had
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00460-00107468-00107665 secured the frontiers of the Empire and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00461-00107666-00107845 reunified it effectively giving the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00462-00107846-00108055 Empire a new lease on life that lasted
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00463-00108056-00108421 200 years
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00464-00108422-00108906 topic reforms
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00465-00108907-00109174 Elian was a reformer and settled many
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00466-00109175-00109359 important functions of the Imperial
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00467-00109360-00109552 apparatus dealing with the economy and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00468-00109553-00109809 religion he restored many public
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00469-00109810-00110023 buildings reorganized the management of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00470-00110024-00110254 the food reserves set fixed prices for
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00471-00110255-00110464 the most important Goods and prosecuted
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00472-00110465-00110905 misconduct by the public officers
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00473-00110906-00111416 topic religious reform
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00474-00111417-00111629 Aurelian strengthened the position of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00475-00111630-00111827 the sun god sol invictus as the main
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00476-00111828-00112082 divinity of the roman pantheon his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00477-00112083-00112274 intention was to give to all the peoples
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00478-00112275-00112472 of the empire civilian or soldiers
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00479-00112473-00112694 Easterners or Westerners a single God
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00480-00112695-00112829 that could believe in without betraying
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00481-00112830-00113108 their own gods the center of the cult
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00482-00113108-00113378 was a new temple built in 274 and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00483-00113379-00113642 dedicated on December 25th of that year
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00484-00113643-00113858 in the campus Agra Pi in Rome with great
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00485-00113858-00114068 decorations financed by the spoils of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00486-00114069-00114455 the Palmyra Empire during his short rule
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00487-00114456-00114674 Aurelian seemed to follow the principle
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00488-00114675-00115001 of one faith one Empire which would not
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00489-00115002-00115169 be made official until the Edict of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00490-00115170-00115406 Thessalonica he appears with the title
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00491-00115407-00115658 Deus at da minha status God and born
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00492-00115658-00115960 ruler on some of his coins a style also
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00493-00115961-00116258 later adopted by Diocletian lactantius
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00494-00116258-00116461 argued that Aurelian would have outlawed
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00495-00116463-00116645 all the other gods if he had had enough
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00496-00116646-00116894 time he was recorded by Christian
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00497-00116895-00117047 historians as having organized
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00498-00117048-00117458 persecutions
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00499-00117458-00117668 topic felissa simmias rebellion and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00500-00117669-00118058 coinage reform
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00501-00118059-00118250 Aurelia pnes rain records the only
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00502-00118251-00118521 uprising of mint workers the rationale
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00503-00118522-00118707 is felicia samus a senior public
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00504-00118708-00118856 financial official whose
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00505-00118857-00119097 responsibilities included supervision of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00506-00119098-00119264 the mint at rome revolted against
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00507-00119265-00119516 Aurelian the revolt seems to have been
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00508-00119517-00119706 caused by the fact that the mint workers
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00509-00119707-00119895 and feliz isa miss first were accustomed
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00510-00119896-00120101 to stealing the silver for the coins and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00511-00120102-00120328 producing coins of inferior quality
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00512-00120329-00120566 Aurelian wanted to eliminate this and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00513-00120567-00120783 put felici tzimmes on trial the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00514-00120783-00120989 rationale is incited the mint workers to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00515-00120990-00121034 revolt
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00516-00121035-00121221 the rebellion spread in the streets even
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00517-00121222-00121415 if it seems that felicia samus was
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00518-00121416-00121639 killed immediately presumably executed
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00519-00121640-00121932 the palmyra in rebellion in egypt had
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00520-00121933-00122114 probably reduced the grain supply to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00521-00122115-00122285 rome thus dis affecting the population
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00522-00122286-00122603 to the emperor this rebellion also had
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00523-00122604-00122804 the support of some senators probably
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00524-00122805-00122978 those who had supported the election of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00525-00122979-00123149 Quinn Tillis and thus had something to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00526-00123150-00123447 fear from Aurelian Aurelian ordered the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00527-00123448-00123699 urban cohorts reinforced by some regular
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00528-00123700-00123878 troops of the Imperial Army to attack
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00529-00123879-00124107 the rebelling mob the resulting battle
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00530-00124108-00124286 fought on the caelian hill marked the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00531-00124287-00124454 end of the revolt even if at a high
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00532-00124455-00124649 price some sources give the figure
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00533-00124650-00124951 probably exaggerated of 7,000 casualties
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00534-00124952-00125247 many of the rebels were executed also
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00535-00125248-00125435 some of the supporting senators were put
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00536-00125436-00125675 to death the mint of Rome was closed
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00537-00125676-00125874 temporarily and the institution of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00538-00125875-00126069 several other mints caused the main mint
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00539-00126070-00126266 of the Empire to lose its hegemony his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00540-00126267-00126458 monetary Reformation included the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00541-00126459-00126665 introduction of Antony Miyagi containing
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00542-00126666-00127034 5% silver they bore the mark 21 or it's
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00543-00127035-00127233 Greek numerals form calm which meant
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00544-00127233-00127415 that 20 of such coins would contain the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00545-00127416-00127616 same silver quantity of an old silver
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00546-00127617-00127896 Denarius considering that this was an
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00547-00127897-00128054 improvement over the previous situation
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00548-00128055-00128279 gives an idea of the severity of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00549-00128280-00128591 economic situation Aurelian faced the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00550-00128592-00128772 emperors struggled to introduce the new
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00551-00128773-00129124 good coined by recalling all the old bad
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00552-00129125-00129719 coins prior to their introduction
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00553-00129720-00130144 topic death
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00554-00130145-00130492 in 275 Aurelian marched towards Asia
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00555-00130493-00130717 Minor preparing another campaign against
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00556-00130718-00130911 the sassanids the deaths of Kings should
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00557-00130913-00131268 pure the first 272 and Hormuz the first
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00558-00131269-00131566 273 in quick succession and the rise to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00559-00131567-00131746 power of a weakened ruler Barham the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00560-00131747-00131944 first presented the opportunity to
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00561-00131945-00132253 attack the sassanid empire on his way
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00562-00132254-00132439 the emperor's suppressed a revolt in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00563-00132440-00132685 gaul possibly against Faustina's an
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00564-00132686-00132892 officer or usurper of tetrakis and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00565-00132893-00133132 defeated barbarian Marauders in ving
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00566-00133133-00133468 delecia Germany however Aurelian never
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00567-00133469-00133654 reached Persia as he was murdered while
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00568-00133655-00133828 waiting in Thrace to cross into Asia
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00569-00133829-00134146 Minor as an administrator Aurelian had
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00570-00134147-00134338 been very strict and handed out severe
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00571-00134339-00134515 punishments to corrupt officials or
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00572-00134516-00134821 soldiers a secretary of Aurelian called
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00573-00134822-00135037 eros by Zosima s-- had told a lie on a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00574-00135038-00135310 minor issue in fear of what the Emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00575-00135311-00135523 might do he forged a document listing
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00576-00135524-00135688 the names of high officials marked by
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00577-00135689-00135868 the Emperor for execution and showed it
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00578-00135869-00136132 to collaborators the note arias ma
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00579-00136133-00136327 Cooper and other high-ranking officers
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00580-00136328-00136456 of the Praetorian Guard
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00581-00136457-00136612 fearing punishment from the Emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00582-00136613-00136903 murdered him in September 275 in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00583-00136904-00137289 California race modern Turkey
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00584-00137290-00137490 Aurelia ng's enemies in the senate
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00585-00137491-00137706 briefly succeeded in passing damnatio
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00586-00137707-00137916 memoriae on the emperor but this was
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00587-00137917-00138084 reversed before the end of the year in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00588-00138085-00138297 Aurelian like his predecessor Claudius
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00589-00138298-00138678 ii was deified as Divus or le anus there
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00590-00138679-00138879 is substantial evidence that or aliens
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00591-00138880-00139062 wife all pious every nough who had been
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00592-00139063-00139356 declared Augusta in 274 may have ruled
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00593-00139357-00139545 the Empire by her own power for some
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00594-00139546-00139779 time after his death the sources
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00595-00139780-00139929 indicate that there was an interregnum
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00596-00139930-00140145 between or aliens death in the election
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00597-00140146-00140334 of Marcus Claudius Tacitus as his
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00598-00140335-00140619 successor additionally some of opus
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00599-00140620-00140787 coins appeared to have been minted after
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00600-00140788-00141166 or aliens death
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00601-00141167-00141682 topic legacy
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00602-00141683-00141922 or really in short reign reunited a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00603-00141923-00142144 fragmented Empire while saving Rome from
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00604-00142145-00142321 barbarian invasions that had reached
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00605-00142322-00142615 Italy itself his death prevented a full
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00606-00142616-00142840 restoration of political stability in a
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00607-00142841-00143023 lasting dynasty that could end the cycle
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00608-00143024-00143239 of assassination of emperors and civil
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00609-00143240-00143536 war that marked this period even so he
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00610-00143537-00143677 brought the Empire through a very
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00611-00143678-00143863 critical period in its history and
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00612-00143864-00144031 without Aurelian it may never have
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00613-00144032-00144223 survived the invasions and fragmentation
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00614-00144224-00144400 of the decade in which he reign
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00615-00144401-00144664 moreover the western half of the empire
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00616-00144665-00144859 would survive another two hundred years
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00617-00144860-00145000 while the East would last another
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00618-00145001-00145198 millennium and for that Aurelian must be
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00619-00145199-00145366 allowed much of the credit the city of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00620-00145367-00145531 or Leone in France is named after
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00621-00145532-00145807 Aurelian originally named soon oblem
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00622-00145808-00146029 Aurelian rebuilt and renamed it orally
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00623-00146030-00146296 aina more or Iliana Civitas city of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00624-00146297-00146587 Aurelian city aid or alien which evolved
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00625-00146588-00146785 into or lay on the city of New Orleans
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00626-00146786-00147025 in French blend nouvelle or Lian in
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00627-00147026-00147256 Louisiana United States is named after
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00628-00147257-00147475 the commune of or Lian and therefore by
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00629-00147476-00147901 extension or alien
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00630-00147902-00148401 topic notes
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00631-00148402-00148919 topic references
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00632-00148920-00149452 topic primary sources
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00633-00149453-00149738 Aurelius Viktor epitome de Caesar Abbess
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00634-00149739-00150113 XXXV epitome de Caesar abyss fourth
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00635-00150114-00150468 century you Tropius bravi areum historia
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00636-00150469-00150797 Roman I X 13 to 15 fourth century
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00637-00150798-00151110 historian Augusta orally anus life of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00638-00151111-00151509 Aurelian part 1 part 2 part 3 Zosima s--
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00639-00151510-00151713 historian ova translation of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00640-00151714-00152022 historian ova published in 1814 book one
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00641-00152023-00152358 fifth sixth century Joanne's own eras
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00642-00152359-00152600 compendium of history compendium excerpt
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00643-00152601-00153002 Claudius two Diocletian 268 to 284
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00644-00153003-00153369 twelfth century
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00645-00153370-00153959 topic secondary sources
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00646-00153960-00154324 corner Christian the 20th of July 2001
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00647-00154325-00154661 Aurelian day Imperator abyss Romanus
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00648-00154662-00154898 archived from the original on the 20th
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00649-00154899-00155240 of October 2006 retrieved the 4th of
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00650-00155241-00155690 November 2006 corner 2001 sunders
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00651-00155691-00156077 randall titus 1992 a biography of the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00652-00156078-00156599 Emperor Aurelian ad 272 275 and Arbor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00653-00156600-00156865 Michigan Umi dissertation services
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00654-00156866-00157252 southern Pat 2001 the Roman Empire from
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00655-00157253-00157566 Severus to Constantine route Lidge key
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00656-00157567-00157973 125 is B and O four one five two three
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00657-00157974-00158344 nine four four three southern 2001
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00658-00158345-00158798 Watson Alaric 1999 Aurelian in the third
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00659-00158799-00159149 century route Lidge is B and O four one
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00660-00159150-00159746 five zero seven two four eight four
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00661-00159747-00160059 topic further reading
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00662-00160060-00160209 you
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00663-00160210-00160560 white John 2015 the Roman Emperor
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00664-00160561-00160829 Aurelian restorer of the world case made
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00665-00160830-00161120 publishers and book distributors LLC
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00666-00161121-00161418 ISBN nine seven eight one four seven
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00667-00161419-00161984 three eight four five six nine five
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00668-00161985-00162476 topic external links
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00669-00162477-00162768 or really in coinage at wild winds
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00670-00162769-00163068 dot-com on coins of Aurelian with the
+MTfEw2S5Ido-00671-00163069-00163602 title Dominus at Deus section 1:9
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00000-00000048-00000359 what if she would get past hey guys
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00001-00000360-00000678 anna here heart of much guarantees so
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00002-00000679-00000958 tell me guys if that's something that
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00003-00000959-00001278 you afraid of
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00004-00001279-00001614 please write down in comments and also i
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00005-00001616-00001726 can tell you that
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00006-00001727-00002007 a lot of ukrainian men afraid the same
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00007-00002007-00002126 i'm pretty sure you
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00008-00002127-00002550 are too and this topic quite tricky
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00009-00002551-00002783 but today i hope we will discover some
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00010-00002784-00002895 messages
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00011-00002896-00003134 how you can be that achieve to find out
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00012-00003135-00003286 that it wouldn't have
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00013-00003288-00003504 happened with you in future and your
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00014-00003506-00004283 [Music]
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00015-00004284-00004422 partner
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00016-00004423-00004767 so guys we have expressions
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00017-00004768-00005079 in ukraine that if you want to know how
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00018-00005080-00005343 we'll look for your future life look at
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00019-00005344-00005518 her mother
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00020-00005519-00005799 and i can tell you why ukrainian man
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00021-00005800-00005847 follow
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00022-00005848-00006151 this advice a lot of them very
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00023-00006152-00006391 like really eager to see family to be
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00024-00006392-00006606 introduced to see how mama looks
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00025-00006608-00006951 so they have approximate imagination
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00026-00006952-00007406 how he's potential life looks in future
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00027-00007408-00007727 uh it's a big part of genetics you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00028-00007728-00008110 if mother looks good with age you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00029-00008111-00008287 probably the same will give us her
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00030-00008288-00008439 daughter
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00031-00008440-00008727 but there is also i want you to
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00032-00008728-00008791 understand
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00033-00008792-00009023 if you were introduced to parents and
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00034-00009024-00009191 then you find out some other
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00035-00009192-00009463 like big-sized woman it doesn't mean
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00036-00009464-00009639 that you have to stop relationship with
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00037-00009640-00009742 a woman you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00038-00009743-00009927 she's different personality with
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00039-00009928-00010127 different perception of the world with
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00040-00010128-00010191 different
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00041-00010192-00010567 um lifestyle you know and maybe
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00042-00010568-00010863 uh you know it's not invaluable from
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00043-00010864-00010910 other
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00044-00010911-00011263 of life values but ensure as well you
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00045-00011264-00011335 know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00046-00011336-00011655 so in that case i just advise you to
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00047-00011656-00011878 to watch lifestyle of the lady and to
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00048-00011879-00012095 listen and to see what she eats you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00049-00012096-00012238 if she do any sport
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00050-00012239-00012606 or like um because basically
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00051-00012607-00012863 this one you know these things like if
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00052-00012863-00013063 she eats all-time unhealthy food it's
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00053-00013063-00013158 okay when she
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00054-00013159-00013407 like 20 years old you know but when she
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00055-00013408-00013551 will be 30 plus
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00056-00013552-00013903 it will affect her body you know and
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00057-00013904-00014158 also if the way how she will care about
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00058-00014159-00014351 you in future you know as a husband and
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00059-00014352-00014543 children also so
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00060-00014544-00014919 um i would rather for you to look at the
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00061-00014919-00015191 mothers who you know put a little bit of
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00062-00015191-00015238 force
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00063-00015240-00015543 in having more a healthy lifestyle and
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00064-00015544-00015855 then eating more healthy food you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00065-00015856-00016199 and but anyway it's um
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00066-00016200-00016535 if we talk about 20 years old woman
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00067-00016536-00016735 she looks beautiful just because she's
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00068-00016736-00016958 very young and normally doesn't put a
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00069-00016959-00017135 lot of word to that you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00070-00017136-00017383 compare when we take talk about ladies
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00071-00017384-00017599 like 30 40 years old
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00072-00017600-00017975 uh if they look beautiful i can tell you
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00073-00017976-00018014 it's
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00074-00018015-00018343 a result of their inner desire to look
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00075-00018344-00018399 beautiful
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00076-00018400-00018791 and off work what they do um
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00077-00018792-00019047 money time but everything starts from
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00078-00019048-00019111 desire
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00079-00019112-00019414 right so don't worry about this
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00080-00019415-00019719 if she like 30 plus looks good probably
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00081-00019720-00019750 in
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00082-00019751-00020135 her 40s 50s 60s she will look really
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00083-00020136-00020214 great
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00084-00020215-00020567 also if lady has children and she's slim
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00085-00020568-00020758 you know if she's single mom you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00086-00020759-00020886 for now but if you
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00087-00020887-00021143 have additional child with you probably
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00088-00021144-00021350 the same situation will be with her body
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00089-00021351-00021422 you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00090-00021423-00021783 it will not change um but sometimes when
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00091-00021784-00021863 you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00092-00021864-00022143 lady have first child it can affect her
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00093-00022144-00022239 body
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00094-00022240-00022567 in very unpredictable ways so it's kind
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00095-00022568-00022719 of
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00096-00022720-00022975 sometimes can be surprising to you so
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00097-00022976-00023063 depends on
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00098-00023064-00023350 genetics but i believe that you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00099-00023351-00023542 woman if she really have inner
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00100-00023543-00023822 desire to you know work with her you
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00101-00023823-00024014 know body to change it you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00102-00024015-00024207 she will find the way to do that you
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00103-00024208-00024463 know and if it's important she lacks a
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00104-00024464-00024503 man
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00105-00024504-00024839 and she you know knows that
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00106-00024840-00025167 it can cause you know broken marriage
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00107-00025168-00025422 she will put all her efforts towards
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00108-00025423-00025614 that you know
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00109-00025616-00025958 so guys i hope this video was
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00110-00025960-00026246 inspiring for you not to be afraid
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00111-00026247-00026470 because as you know i'll hear they block
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00112-00026472-00026527 us
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00113-00026527-00026767 in moving direction with one but we will
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00114-00026768-00026911 just make
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00115-00026912-00027127 will take practical advices from this
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00116-00027127-00027311 video and just
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00117-00027312-00027518 move towards finding your loved one here
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00118-00027519-00027646 in ukraine
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00119-00027647-00027911 that i always wish for you guys thank
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00120-00027912-00028158 you for being with me today
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00121-00028160-00028383 have a great evening bye bye see you in
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00122-00028383-00028543 my upcoming videos make sure you
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00123-00028544-00028687 subscribe to our channel
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00124-00028688-00029644 bye bye
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00125-00029645-00030095 [Music]
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00126-00030095-00030311 have you been searching for a beautiful
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00127-00030312-00030462 wife
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00128-00030463-00030695 do you dream of meeting the perfect
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00129-00030695-00030807 woman
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00130-00030808-00031158 but haven't found her
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00131-00031160-00031414 well imagine if there was a simple way
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00132-00031416-00031495 this could all
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00133-00031495-00031862 change for you imagine if there was a
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00134-00031863-00032039 canadian marriage agency
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00135-00032039-00032231 that would introduce you to as many
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00136-00032232-00032462 beautiful women as it takes
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00137-00032463-00032831 until you find the one ukraine
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00138-00032832-00033071 a lost world of beautiful traditional
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00139-00033072-00033151 women
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00140-00033152-00033383 at last a place where you can find the
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00141-00033384-00033527 beautiful wife you have
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00142-00033528-00033927 always dreamed of every ukrainian woman
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00143-00033928-00034190 dreams of having a happy family now you
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00144-00034191-00034383 can have a traditional beautiful wife
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00145-00034384-00034518 from ukraine
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00146-00034519-00034831 creating happy family memories forever
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00147-00034832-00035046 so what are you waiting for register
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00148-00035047-00035279 right now and skype our beautiful ladies
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00149-00035280-00035390 completely free
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00150-00035391-00035567 so what makes us different you might ask
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00151-00035568-00035790 why not ask google simply by searching
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00152-00035791-00037695 match guarantee reviews
+MUP_eqNn9sg-00153-00037696-00037903 you
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00000-00000008-00000223 hello mayday family how are you doing
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00001-00000224-00000375 today for those of you that are new to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00002-00000376-00000543 my channel my name is may i'm a licensed
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00003-00000544-00000734 counselor with a youtube channel
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00004-00000735-00000975 so let's go ahead and get started today
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00005-00000976-00001127 i want to talk about
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00006-00001128-00001487 kylie jenner and i want to talk about
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00007-00001488-00001655 kylie jenner because i think
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00008-00001655-00002095 that a lot of people have this
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00009-00002096-00002367 impression of kylie jenner that she's a
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00010-00002368-00002439 a good
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00011-00002440-00002855 person or she's like nice to everyone
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00012-00002856-00003158 and that is because of the narrative
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00013-00003159-00003319 that they put out there for us to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00014-00003320-00003390 consume
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00015-00003392-00003727 as consumers so a lot of marketing that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00016-00003728-00003831 they put out there
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00017-00003832-00004215 to make kylie have this image of being a
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00018-00004216-00004351 nice person
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00019-00004352-00004702 now recently it has come to the light
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00020-00004703-00004743 and
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00021-00004744-00005095 come to our attention that kylie jenner
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00022-00005096-00005470 is most likely not such a nice person
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00023-00005471-00005815 so kylie jenner most recently has been
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00024-00005816-00005886 facing
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00025-00005887-00006231 some criticism in regards to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00026-00006232-00006575 some very very critical allegations that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00027-00006576-00006670 are being made
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00028-00006672-00006975 about her and about her character and so
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00029-00006976-00007095 if you want to learn a little bit more
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00030-00007095-00007134 about
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00031-00007136-00007423 what's going on definitely make sure to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00032-00007423-00007510 stick around
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00033-00007511-00007710 through the rest of this video to find
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00034-00007711-00007823 out more
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00035-00007823-00008134 now wendy williams is one of the people
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00036-00008136-00008335 that actually covered this story most
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00037-00008336-00008407 recently
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00038-00008408-00008559 went ahead and looked into it a little
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00039-00008560-00008783 bit more and what i found was so
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00040-00008784-00009095 interesting so so interesting and so
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00041-00009096-00009374 unexpected it's not something that i
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00042-00009375-00009471 expected
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00043-00009472-00009774 to find so before we get into that let's
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00044-00009775-00009967 take a look at what wendy williams had
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00045-00009968-00010606 to say about this particular situation
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00046-00010607-00010831 they were instructed not to talk to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00047-00010832-00011014 kylie or take pictures with her or look
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00048-00011015-00011103 at her
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00049-00011104-00011695 uh and she also never spoke to the staff
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00050-00011696-00011910 on one hand oh wow on the other hand
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00051-00011911-00012142 she's not there to do all that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00052-00012143-00012438 she's there to put on a hazmat suit her
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00053-00012439-00012551 hair in a bun
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00054-00012552-00012886 smell back forth back forth and whoever
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00055-00012887-00012991 is running
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00056-00012991-00013151 for that particular day whoever the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00057-00013152-00013311 manager is uh
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00058-00013312-00013615 should be then recommended you know with
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00059-00013616-00013727 the workers coming out
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00060-00013728-00013886 saying they want to lean into her while
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00061-00013887-00014503 she's trying to sniff smell and
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00062-00014504-00014615 something could have been arranged
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00063-00014616-00014799 though you know the factory super
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00064-00014800-00014935 advisor this is your fault
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00065-00014936-00015111 you could have had a lunchtime signing
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00066-00015112-00015279 with kylie or something like that or
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00067-00015280-00015350 maybe
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00068-00015351-00016311 that kind of assigned a whole bunch of
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00069-00016312-00016511 kylie jenner has workers that work for
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00070-00016512-00016622 her and her
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00071-00016623-00016935 own workers are calling her out
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00072-00016936-00017294 on the fact that they are
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00073-00017295-00017607 basically instructed to not even look
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00074-00017608-00017999 at kylie and here we have wendy williams
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00075-00018000-00018135 doing what she usually does
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00076-00018136-00018486 being a fan of stand
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00077-00018487-00018783 and supporting that behavior that is
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00078-00018784-00018927 ridiculous like
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00079-00018928-00019119 the the manager what the heck does the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00080-00019120-00019286 manager have to do with anything what
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00081-00019287-00019447 are you even saying like
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00082-00019448-00019630 like are you even in the right state of
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00083-00019631-00019847 mind like that this is the thing
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00084-00019848-00020150 i don't understand why
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00085-00020151-00020463 wendy williams is so far up the butt
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00086-00020464-00020703 of the kardashians every episode that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00087-00020704-00020767 she does
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00088-00020768-00021158 that has a kardashian in it she never
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00089-00021159-00021358 ever speaks the truth you have people
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00090-00021359-00021527 that are working for you and this is how
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00091-00021528-00021678 you treat them
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00092-00021679-00021975 y'all and that speaks a lot to her
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00093-00021976-00022086 character
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00094-00022087-00022343 that speaks a lot to the way that she
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00095-00022344-00022391 really
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00096-00022392-00022639 is and that tells me that what she's
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00097-00022640-00022694 been
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00098-00022695-00023007 trying to portray on social media as
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00099-00023008-00023303 being the victim or being a good person
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00100-00023304-00023471 is inaccurate this is
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00101-00023472-00023639 not a sign of someone that's a good
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00102-00023640-00023807 person and it's also not a sign of
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00103-00023808-00023919 someone that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00104-00023920-00024214 um isn't is in a healthy state of being
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00105-00024215-00024294 mentally
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00106-00024295-00024655 are you gonna go see your employees and
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00107-00024656-00024839 they can't even talk to you
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00108-00024840-00025283 or look in your direction are you
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00109-00025284-00025599 jesus so the situation is
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00110-00025600-00025831 two former employees claim that they
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00111-00025832-00025927 were ordered
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00112-00025927-00026255 not to look at kylie or chris jenner
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00113-00026256-00026535 they say that they were degraded and
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00114-00026536-00026799 they also claimed that kylie never even
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00115-00026800-00027046 talked to any of the factory staff while
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00116-00027047-00027167 they were there
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00117-00027168-00027470 so the company was launched in 2015
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00118-00027472-00027767 kylie cosmetics and this factory
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00119-00027768-00027887 essentially
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00120-00027888-00028246 is responsible for making kylie's
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00121-00028247-00028374 cosmetics
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00122-00028375-00028631 so whenever they go whenever kris jenner
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00123-00028632-00028758 and kylie go
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00124-00028760-00029079 apparently they order the staff
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00125-00029080-00029383 workers to not even look at them
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00126-00029383-00029727 which is so insane to me like
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00127-00029727-00030046 who does who does that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00128-00030047-00030390 i so now you own my eyes i can't
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00129-00030391-00030614 look at whatever the heck i want to look
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00130-00030616-00030711 at is this
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00131-00030712-00031023 even real right now especially during
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00132-00031024-00031351 times where workers are always being
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00133-00031352-00031439 abused
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00134-00031439-00031751 you come in you can't even say hello
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00135-00031752-00031999 who raised you i don't know what the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00136-00032000-00032246 heck wendy is talking about the manager
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00137-00032247-00032431 what the heck is the manager supposed to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00138-00032432-00032583 do about that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00139-00032583-00032767 right like so now you want to blame the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00140-00032768-00033007 manager some person in the show who
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00141-00033008-00033255 knows if there's even actually a manager
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00142-00033256-00033583 so it makes no sense to try to pass on
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00143-00033584-00033774 blame when clearly
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00144-00033775-00033959 these people try to make it seem like
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00145-00033960-00034087 they're good people
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00146-00034088-00034374 but they're most likely not not if you
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00147-00034375-00034590 treat your employees like second-class
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00148-00034591-00034679 citizens
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00149-00034680-00035007 as though you don't have the same red
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00150-00035008-00035295 blood flowing in your body as they do
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00151-00035296-00035446 very humiliating
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00152-00035447-00035727 one of the people that brought first
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00153-00035728-00035943 brought this to light about
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00154-00035944-00036295 kylie jenner and her business practices
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00155-00036296-00036607 uh her name is irene and she's 32 years
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00156-00036608-00036823 old and during her interview this is
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00157-00036824-00036974 exactly what she said
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00158-00036975-00037255 she said before they would come in our
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00159-00037256-00037439 supervisors would tell us
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00160-00037440-00037702 you are not allowed to talk with them
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00161-00037703-00037927 you guys are supposed to keep on working
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00162-00037928-00038143 as are not allowed to take any pictures
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00163-00038144-00038327 or ask any questions
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00164-00038328-00038543 the former employee added that kylie
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00165-00038544-00038711 would never talk to the staff
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00166-00038712-00038951 just watch silently as her glossy range
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00167-00038952-00039151 was made right in front of her eyes
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00168-00039152-00039343 as though you know as though she were
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00169-00039344-00039502 jesus or something
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00170-00039503-00039815 so that that that really hit home to me
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00171-00039816-00040118 i mean people and employees are so
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00172-00040119-00040446 mistreated nowadays it's
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00173-00040447-00040718 baffling it's another former spats
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00174-00040719-00040799 laboratory
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00175-00040800-00041135 employee martha molasco
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00176-00041136-00041487 who worked there from 2015 to 2017
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00177-00041488-00041702 said there were rules for staff when
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00178-00041703-00041830 kylie visited
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00179-00041831-00042174 the factory so she said in her words
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00180-00042175-00042351 supervisors would say
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00181-00042352-00042567 don't talk to them don't even look at
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00182-00042568-00042799 them and that is what
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00183-00042800-00043118 and that is what in martha's words quote
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00184-00043119-00043351 unquote what she reported and martha
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00185-00043352-00043567 molaska was 31 years old
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00186-00043568-00043807 so she said the supervisors would say
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00187-00043808-00043943 don't talk to them
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00188-00043944-00044262 don't even look at them can you imagine
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00189-00044263-00044558 working in such a place like that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00190-00044559-00044702 working in that type of a
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00191-00044703-00045039 toxic environment for such toxic
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00192-00045040-00045351 people i cannot even
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00193-00045352-00045662 imagine it's to treat human beings like
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00194-00045663-00045774 that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00195-00045775-00046023 that's that just blows my mind
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00196-00046024-00046143 understandably
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00197-00046144-00046446 irene said that she felt degraded during
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00198-00046447-00046599 her time at the company
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00199-00046600-00046774 and also said that the staff were
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00200-00046775-00046958 expected to complete quotas
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00201-00046959-00047286 of up to 1200 products every day
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00202-00047287-00047623 with no appreciation nothing that would
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00203-00047624-00047662 work
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00204-00047663-00048015 or help them in performing their tests
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00205-00048016-00048335 in a most effective way possible and so
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00206-00048336-00048639 we kind of see the greed and the level
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00207-00048640-00048751 of mistreatment
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00208-00048752-00049127 in this and it's just a perfect example
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00209-00049128-00049423 of the type of world that we live in
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00210-00049424-00049502 today
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00211-00049503-00049758 so said and i quote this is a direct
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00212-00049759-00049879 quote from her
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00213-00049880-00050055 when she was doing the interview she
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00214-00050056-00050302 said the supervisors i had there
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00215-00050303-00050518 had been very degrading towards
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00216-00050519-00050623 everybody
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00217-00050624-00050886 everything had to be perfectly made if
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00218-00050887-00050974 it wasn't
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00219-00050975-00051174 they would throw it away in your face
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00220-00051175-00051319 like it was trash
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00221-00051320-00051558 if you didn't go fast enough you were
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00222-00051559-00051670 going to get
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00223-00051671-00052046 fired that is crazy to me i that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00224-00052047-00052358 this is just blowing my mind so the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00225-00052359-00052487 former employees
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00226-00052488-00052775 said that she was often left in tears
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00227-00052776-00052919 after being scolded
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00228-00052920-00053103 for not being fast enough on the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00229-00053104-00053254 production line
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00230-00053255-00053535 once she claims her supervisor threw all
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00231-00053536-00053791 of her completed project products
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00232-00053791-00054047 right into the trash forcing her to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00233-00054048-00054319 start all over again
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00234-00054320-00054663 i'm again like wow irene also claims
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00235-00054664-00054838 that she was expected to produce the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00236-00054839-00055007 popular makeup items
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00237-00055008-00055247 after she was trained for only five
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00238-00055248-00055335 minutes
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00239-00055336-00055638 and was verbally threatened and degraded
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00240-00055639-00055838 if she asked any questions to her
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00241-00055839-00056047 supervisors
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00242-00056048-00056366 this is such a toxic work environment
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00243-00056367-00056591 the staff were told that they could be
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00244-00056591-00056854 laid off from the minimum wage job
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00245-00056855-00057119 and replaced by someone else from the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00246-00057120-00057159 temp
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00247-00057160-00057463 agency if they were to do anything wrong
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00248-00057464-00057766 artha also said that physical labor with
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00249-00057767-00057871 her
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00250-00057872-00058247 with her health issues and pain
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00251-00058248-00058566 uh from her hands to her elbows after
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00252-00058567-00058750 working 12 hours shifts
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00253-00058751-00059071 from 4 pm to 4 am while standing in the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00254-00059072-00059159 factory
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00255-00059160-00059463 really really affected her on a
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00256-00059464-00059654 mental health perspective as well as a
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00257-00059655-00059823 physical health perspective
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00258-00059824-00060103 and irene claimed that she worked eight
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00259-00060104-00060199 hour shifts
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00260-00060200-00060430 but was often pressured to come in on
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00261-00060432-00060526 weekends
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00262-00060527-00060830 in fear of being fired oh
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00263-00060832-00061142 my goodness the single mother of two
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00264-00061144-00061503 irene uh said that she struggled to find
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00265-00061504-00061703 child care on the weekends but was still
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00266-00061704-00061830 made to come in
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00267-00061832-00062038 or she was threatened with losing her
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00268-00062039-00062254 job so irene also
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00269-00062255-00062575 claimed workers were crammed in together
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00270-00062576-00062782 especially during the pandemic
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00271-00062783-00063063 meanwhile martha said that she had to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00272-00063064-00063159 ensure
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00273-00063160-00063454 cold conditions in the winter and
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00274-00063455-00063591 sweltering heat
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00275-00063591-00063799 in the summer during those months she
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00276-00063800-00063935 had to endure
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00277-00063936-00064238 through all of those things so irene
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00278-00064239-00064511 of course thankfully no longer works at
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00279-00064512-00064599 the factory
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00280-00064600-00064863 but she did say that she has been told
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00281-00064864-00065038 by the current employees that the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00282-00065039-00065263 conditions are still the same
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00283-00065264-00065511 and online reviews from fellow
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00284-00065512-00065703 disgruntled employees
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00285-00065704-00065903 paint a similar picture one of the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00286-00065904-00066071 online reviews read
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00287-00066072-00066359 people have to go through an employment
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00288-00066360-00066615 agency to get a job at this place
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00289-00066616-00066806 so that the company doesn't have a
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00290-00066807-00066959 problem firing you
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00291-00066960-00067247 if you pull or if you can't pull a 10 to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00292-00067248-00067294 12
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00293-00067295-00067647 hour shift hr does not care if you're a
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00294-00067648-00067831 hard worker or not
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00295-00067832-00068126 if you if you're not part of the company
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00296-00068127-00068367 they don't care about your opinion or
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00297-00068368-00068455 your concerns
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00298-00068456-00068663 put up this huge front like everything
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00299-00068664-00068767 is good
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00300-00068768-00069063 the people that i talked to didn't like
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00301-00069064-00069126 the job
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00302-00069127-00069359 i mean this place is a mess i'm
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00303-00069360-00069575 surprised it hasn't shut down
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00304-00069576-00069926 i would give this place zero stars but
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00305-00069927-00070223 that option isn't there another
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00306-00070224-00070406 scorching review on indeed
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00307-00070407-00070791 from 2019 said if you are looking to get
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00308-00070792-00071167 minimum but work like a dog 50 hours a
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00309-00071168-00071367 week on the holiday season
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00310-00071368-00071687 just so you can get laid off after or
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00311-00071688-00072031 get four hours a day when it's not
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00312-00072032-00072326 seasonal then go for it management only
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00313-00072327-00072382 wants
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00314-00072383-00072719 the numbers former employees have also
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00315-00072720-00072831 filed complaints
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00316-00072832-00073079 with the california labor commissioner's
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00317-00073080-00073135 office
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00318-00073136-00073335 this is crazy to me you guys what do you
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00319-00073336-00073511 guys think about this this is why this
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00320-00073512-00073711 was so insane to me
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00321-00073712-00073911 i could not believe what i was hearing
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00322-00073912-00074159 especially in 2021
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00323-00074160-00074438 because so many people this year are
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00324-00074439-00074487 either
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00325-00074488-00074719 thinking about quitting their jobs or
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00326-00074720-00074943 have already quit their jobs i made a
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00327-00074944-00075023 video
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00328-00075024-00075350 on why 40 of americans are
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00329-00075351-00075487 either thinking about quitting their
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00330-00075488-00075726 jobs or have already quit their jobs if
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00331-00075727-00075894 you haven't watched that video
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00332-00075895-00076062 go ahead and make sure to watch that
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00333-00076063-00076199 video i will leave
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00334-00076200-00076591 the link below so what do you think
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00335-00076592-00076862 this is exactly why this is why people
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00336-00076863-00076999 are quitting their jobs and starting to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00337-00077000-00077062 realize
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00338-00077063-00077255 it's not worth it working for anyone
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00339-00077256-00077494 else even people in the public eye
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00340-00077495-00077711 that you expect or you would think are
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00341-00077712-00077799 good people
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00342-00077800-00077967 because that's the narrative that they
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00343-00077968-00078182 put out all the time
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00344-00078183-00078415 actually are not and they treat other
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00345-00078416-00078550 human beings like trash
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00346-00078551-00078743 because they feel like they have a lot
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00347-00078744-00078879 of money and
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00348-00078880-00079159 that's the way that they go about doing
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00349-00079160-00079262 what they do
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00350-00079263-00079494 but this is this is crazy this is why i
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00351-00079495-00079567 believe
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00352-00079568-00079871 every word of of this story
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00353-00079872-00080126 is this everything that i found in
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00354-00080127-00080271 regards to this story
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00355-00080272-00080438 but go ahead and leave a comment below
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00356-00080439-00080606 let me know what you think and
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00357-00080607-00080935 again as i always caution all of you
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00358-00080936-00081167 please please please do not compare
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00359-00081168-00081271 yourself to
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00360-00081272-00081606 these rich people or famous people
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00361-00081607-00081894 because they are not who they seem they
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00362-00081895-00081950 just
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00363-00081951-00082191 are not someone that you're thinking is
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00364-00082192-00082431 a good person most likely is not
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00365-00082432-00082662 so be careful this is another really
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00366-00082663-00082799 good example
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00367-00082800-00083006 of why it's so important from a mental
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00368-00083007-00083135 health perspective
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00369-00083136-00083455 to be careful with what you're seeing
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00370-00083456-00083703 and what you're choosing to believe is
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00371-00083704-00083782 the truth
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00372-00083783-00084094 whatever they're showing you is not the
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00373-00084095-00084199 truth it's just
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00374-00084200-00084375 what they've made up and what they want
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00375-00084376-00084535 you to do it's true
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00376-00084536-00084838 right so now we're seeing the truth and
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00377-00084839-00085047 bits and pieces of the truth come out
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00378-00085048-00085287 and which is so sad it's terrible to see
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00379-00085288-00085462 i will talk to you guys later go ahead
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00380-00085463-00085615 and smash that like button
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00381-00085616-00085815 for me if this was at all informative
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00382-00085816-00085950 entertaining or anything
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00383-00085951-00086150 else go ahead and smash the subscribe
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00384-00086151-00086335 button to see more content such as this
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00385-00086336-00086382 one
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00386-00086383-00086591 i will talk to you guys soon see you in
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00387-00086592-00086694 the next video
+MVQsZdt8xdY-00388-00086695-00086992 bye
+MWzISyAvPQA-00000-00000130-00001411 [Music]
+MWzISyAvPQA-00001-00001412-00001707 thank you
+MWzISyAvPQA-00003-00005016-00005195 foreign
+MWzISyAvPQA-00004-00005196-00005947 [Music]
+MWzISyAvPQA-00005-00005948-00007370 [Music]
+MWzISyAvPQA-00006-00007372-00009695 [Music]
+MWzISyAvPQA-00007-00009696-00009837 foreign
+MWzISyAvPQA-00008-00009838-00011106 [Music]
+MWzISyAvPQA-00009-00011107-00012111 [Music]
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00000-00000003-00000316 hello everybody did this maj7 a few days
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00001-00000317-00000614 ago had an epic battle with Davy 504 and
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00002-00000615-00000899 I had to admit I can't stock the bass so
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00003-00000900-00001064 here I am
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00004-00001065-00001244 day one of these experience I'm gonna
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00005-00001245-00001415 learn how to stop the bass I would
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00006-00001416-00001577 probably still suck at the end of OTT
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00007-00001578-00001735 I'll give it my best shot
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00008-00001736-00001955 Davy Phi before uploading a track to jam
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00009-00001955-00002165 with him I'm gonna try to practice and
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00010-00002166-00002375 then at the end of the practice to jump
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00011-00002376-00002525 with him to see if there is an
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00012-00002526-00002720 improvement so let's get these things
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00013-00002721-00002930 started checking number one I've been
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00014-00002931-00003191 practicing for roughly 15 minutes on
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00015-00003192-00003365 this exercise that I found online that
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00016-00003365-00003767 goes something like Tom slap pong index
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00017-00003768-00004247 finger my hands are a little bit cold
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00018-00004248-00005061 but I'm getting the hang of it
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00019-00005062-00005300 checking number two I've been going on
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00020-00005301-00005633 for full 45 45 I've been going on for 45
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00021-00005634-00005888 minutes I am getting the hang of this
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00022-00005889-00006195 pattern here
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00023-00006196-00006428 I've been going on for roughly an hour
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00024-00006429-00006646 and I'm starting to have a problem with
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00025-00006647-00007467 my index finger I am growing a blister
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00026-00007468-00007751 one hour and 20 minutes in and my
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00027-00007752-00008242 blister is getting worse and worse I am
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00028-00008243-00008449 starting to add notes to the whole thing
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00029-00008450-00009089 something like I think I'm gonna give it
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00030-00009090-00009362 a name if you have any suggestions for a
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00031-00009363-00009608 name for this thing well please write it
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00032-00009609-00009683 in the comments
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00033-00009684-00009848 before leaving it's time for my first
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00034-00009849-00010139 jam we take five or four I've got here
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00035-00010140-00010388 the video you know what let's jam
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00036-00010389-00010575 together now
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00037-00010576-00011277 [Music]
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00038-00011278-00013880 [Music]
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00039-00013881-00014333 [Music]
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00040-00014334-00014772 today so tomorrow maybe it would be
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00041-00014772-00014961 better stay tuned if you wanna know if I
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00042-00014962-00015135 will be able to actually learn how to
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00043-00015136-00015333 slap debase see you tomorrow
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00044-00015334-00015497 bye bye bye major seven
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00045-00015499-00016496 [Music]
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00046-00016497-00017085 [Music]
+MWBK1AQJYXu-00047-00017086-00017394 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00000-00000162-00001529 foreign
+MX_aRxguLL4-00001-00001530-00002375 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00002-00002376-00003474 guys
+MX_aRxguLL4-00003-00003475-00003847 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00004-00003847-00004036 thank you
+MX_aRxguLL4-00005-00004037-00005122 okay
+MX_aRxguLL4-00006-00005123-00005225 yeah
+MX_aRxguLL4-00007-00005226-00006202 let's go now soon
+MX_aRxguLL4-00008-00006203-00006395 as your promises rain but promise
+MX_aRxguLL4-00009-00006396-00006781 promise Way Beyond that
+MX_aRxguLL4-00010-00006781-00007031 stands are packed here people have done
+MX_aRxguLL4-00011-00007031-00007175 everything they can
+MX_aRxguLL4-00012-00007176-00008141 oh
+MX_aRxguLL4-00013-00008142-00008345 yeah
+MX_aRxguLL4-00014-00008346-00008705 okay sorry
+MX_aRxguLL4-00015-00008706-00009009 okay
+MX_aRxguLL4-00016-00009010-00009505 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00017-00009506-00009869 he's pulled off a fine save well what
+MX_aRxguLL4-00018-00009870-00010228 can I say truly wonderful goalkeeping
+MX_aRxguLL4-00019-00010229-00010385 played it short
+MX_aRxguLL4-00020-00010386-00010774 and it's Davis
+MX_aRxguLL4-00021-00010775-00010987 a whistle's gone
+MX_aRxguLL4-00022-00010988-00011327 the referee has given a free kick just
+MX_aRxguLL4-00023-00011328-00011496 outside the box
+MX_aRxguLL4-00024-00011497-00011777 well that looks like a final warning
+MX_aRxguLL4-00025-00011778-00011981 still no card
+MX_aRxguLL4-00026-00011982-00012448 foreign
+MX_aRxguLL4-00027-00012449-00013449 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00028-00013450-00013968 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00029-00013969-00014597 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00030-00014597-00014685 Sanchez
+MX_aRxguLL4-00031-00014686-00015108 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00032-00015109-00015653 yes Cristiano Ronaldo rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00033-00015654-00016075 uh
+MX_aRxguLL4-00034-00016076-00016399 more than decent attempt Peter
+MX_aRxguLL4-00035-00016400-00016691 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00036-00016692-00016829 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00037-00016830-00017099 Sanchez tries to get it Forward quickly
+MX_aRxguLL4-00038-00017100-00017515 oh great ball how's it going
+MX_aRxguLL4-00039-00017516-00017879 big relief just needed better contact oh
+MX_aRxguLL4-00040-00017880-00018053 look I don't want to sound too
+MX_aRxguLL4-00041-00018054-00018275 dismissive but from here that looks the
+MX_aRxguLL4-00042-00018276-00018785 harder thing to do
+MX_aRxguLL4-00043-00018786-00019013 and it's paid forward
+MX_aRxguLL4-00044-00019014-00019980 Manchester United
+MX_aRxguLL4-00045-00019981-00020285 sends that a long way
+MX_aRxguLL4-00046-00020286-00020494 just to point out Peter that the
+MX_aRxguLL4-00047-00020495-00020680 fullbacks are quite high and what are
+MX_aRxguLL4-00048-00020681-00020880 they trying
+MX_aRxguLL4-00049-00020881-00021250 oh that's a terrific save for the keeper
+MX_aRxguLL4-00050-00021251-00021479 the keeper really dug out his defense
+MX_aRxguLL4-00051-00021480-00021827 then a magnificent effort
+MX_aRxguLL4-00052-00021828-00021961 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00053-00021962-00022313 see some progress down the left oh
+MX_aRxguLL4-00054-00022314-00022724 Sanchez
+MX_aRxguLL4-00055-00022725-00023425 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00056-00023426-00023794 and here's Cristiano Ronaldo Ronaldo
+MX_aRxguLL4-00057-00023795-00024948 spreads it towards the left
+MX_aRxguLL4-00058-00024949-00025583 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00059-00025584-00026231 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00060-00026232-00026645 rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00061-00026645-00026993 man
+MX_aRxguLL4-00062-00026994-00027335 oh Manchester United
+MX_aRxguLL4-00063-00027336-00027737 yeah Manchester United Take the Lead
+MX_aRxguLL4-00064-00027738-00027977 Manchester United are looking stronger
+MX_aRxguLL4-00065-00027977-00028187 winning the ball in Midfield is one
+MX_aRxguLL4-00066-00028188-00028367 thing but it's their clever use of
+MX_aRxguLL4-00067-00028368-00028523 counter-attacking that's the real
+MX_aRxguLL4-00068-00028524-00028870 highlight
+MX_aRxguLL4-00069-00028872-00029405 s
+MX_aRxguLL4-00070-00029406-00030033 emblem
+MX_aRxguLL4-00071-00030033-00030545 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00072-00030545-00030862 Ford it goes but more than happy to take
+MX_aRxguLL4-00073-00030863-00031174 the muscular approach I certainly caught
+MX_aRxguLL4-00074-00031175-00031840 him there's a free kick
+MX_aRxguLL4-00075-00031841-00032389 ing
+MX_aRxguLL4-00076-00032389-00032602 now it's k
+MX_aRxguLL4-00077-00032603-00032947 foreign
+MX_aRxguLL4-00078-00032948-00035031 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00079-00035032-00036631 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00080-00036632-00037540 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00081-00037541-00038156 foreign
+MX_aRxguLL4-00082-00038157-00039374 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00083-00039375-00040259 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00084-00040260-00040427 for a moment you felt that was going
+MX_aRxguLL4-00085-00040428-00041599 somewhere but they'll have to go again
+MX_aRxguLL4-00086-00041600-00041951 and they've got their lead back
+MX_aRxguLL4-00087-00041952-00042173 yeah looking back at that that's how you
+MX_aRxguLL4-00088-00042174-00042485 play a quick and decisive and ruthless
+MX_aRxguLL4-00089-00042486-00042623 with the finish I thought it was a
+MX_aRxguLL4-00090-00042624-00042983 stunning stunning Breakaway
+MX_aRxguLL4-00091-00042984-00043295 well this is what we've been waiting for
+MX_aRxguLL4-00092-00043296-00044299 yeah I'm waiting for oh
+MX_aRxguLL4-00093-00044300-00044635 Alex tell us
+MX_aRxguLL4-00094-00044636-00044855 what's up
+MX_aRxguLL4-00095-00044856-00045049 I did that
+MX_aRxguLL4-00096-00045050-00045677 they really should have been made to pay
+MX_aRxguLL4-00097-00045678-00045943 um
+MX_aRxguLL4-00098-00045944-00046229 he needs special attention to stop
+MX_aRxguLL4-00099-00046230-00046757 making a run okay
+MX_aRxguLL4-00100-00046758-00047261 gets his head to it oh great save real
+MX_aRxguLL4-00101-00047262-00047555 fast well as Tesco YouTube The Keeper
+MX_aRxguLL4-00102-00047556-00047842 you've just received an A plus
+MX_aRxguLL4-00103-00047843-00048312 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00104-00048313-00048557 oh that's a foul free Kick's been given
+MX_aRxguLL4-00105-00048558-00049037 well that's it
+MX_aRxguLL4-00106-00049038-00050912 foreign
+MX_aRxguLL4-00107-00050913-00051069 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00108-00051070-00052426 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00109-00052427-00052654 son young men
+MX_aRxguLL4-00110-00052655-00052835 song young Min
+MX_aRxguLL4-00111-00052836-00053200 Ford it goes back to the keeper and try
+MX_aRxguLL4-00112-00053201-00053447 something new
+MX_aRxguLL4-00113-00053448-00054011 Sanchez
+MX_aRxguLL4-00114-00054012-00054203 it's rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00115-00054204-00054503 Bruno Fernandez a scorer already in the
+MX_aRxguLL4-00116-00054504-00055069 game
+MX_aRxguLL4-00117-00055070-00055319 and here's rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00118-00055320-00056063 and he's there to cut it out
+MX_aRxguLL4-00119-00056064-00056242 picks it away
+MX_aRxguLL4-00120-00056244-00056360 yeah
+MX_aRxguLL4-00121-00056361-00056509 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00122-00056510-00056815 I'm threatening to pull clear
+MX_aRxguLL4-00123-00056816-00057192 well you know
+MX_aRxguLL4-00124-00057194-00057703 because it took them seconds
+MX_aRxguLL4-00125-00057704-00058007 yeah the whistle goes for half time well
+MX_aRxguLL4-00126-00058008-00058216 Peter I think the score is a fair
+MX_aRxguLL4-00127-00058217-00058444 reflection of what we've witnessed so
+MX_aRxguLL4-00128-00058445-00058897 far and all right that being this is
+MX_aRxguLL4-00129-00058898-00059159 if those players I think can carry on
+MX_aRxguLL4-00130-00059160-00059513 where they left off they should impose
+MX_aRxguLL4-00131-00059514-00059800 themselves even more and probably only
+MX_aRxguLL4-00132-00059801-00060107 one result coming here but Manchester
+MX_aRxguLL4-00133-00060108-00060371 United or broadly in charge but the
+MX_aRxguLL4-00134-00060372-00060592 contest is still alive at three goals to
+MX_aRxguLL4-00135-00060594-00060730 one
+MX_aRxguLL4-00136-00060732-00060929 oh so we're already into the second
+MX_aRxguLL4-00137-00060929-00061073 period
+MX_aRxguLL4-00138-00061074-00061294 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00139-00061295-00061516 what's in there that's just an example
+MX_aRxguLL4-00140-00061517-00061738 of over committing and they're fortunate
+MX_aRxguLL4-00141-00061739-00062230 for the quality of the integration
+MX_aRxguLL4-00142-00062232-00062372 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00143-00062373-00062616 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00144-00062617-00062879 maybe the target really should have been
+MX_aRxguLL4-00145-00062879-00062911 hit
+MX_aRxguLL4-00146-00062912-00063071 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00147-00063072-00063394 I'm sorry
+MX_aRxguLL4-00148-00063395-00063809 Pogba
+MX_aRxguLL4-00149-00063810-00063953 the song
+MX_aRxguLL4-00150-00063954-00064163 he's got through
+MX_aRxguLL4-00151-00064164-00064444 Cristiano Ronaldo
+MX_aRxguLL4-00152-00064445-00064638 he'll hit it
+MX_aRxguLL4-00153-00064639-00064949 oh what a wonderful stop yeah yeah
+MX_aRxguLL4-00154-00064950-00065219 that's more than that a difficult moment
+MX_aRxguLL4-00155-00065220-00065579 he simply had to deal with
+MX_aRxguLL4-00156-00065580-00066856 Los also
+MX_aRxguLL4-00157-00066857-00066977 speared forward
+MX_aRxguLL4-00158-00066978-00067223 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00159-00067224-00067679 dashing forward at PACE
+MX_aRxguLL4-00160-00067680-00067913 and it's rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00161-00067914-00068206 Manchester United one emphatic it's
+MX_aRxguLL4-00162-00068207-00068423 Cristiano oh
+MX_aRxguLL4-00163-00068424-00068779 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00164-00068780-00069061 surely that settles it
+MX_aRxguLL4-00165-00069062-00069317 the keeper deserves some sympathy there
+MX_aRxguLL4-00166-00069318-00070578 he may not have seen that until too late
+MX_aRxguLL4-00167-00070579-00071447 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00168-00071448-00072185 so now the difference is three
+MX_aRxguLL4-00169-00072186-00072252 Davis
+MX_aRxguLL4-00170-00072253-00072473 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00171-00072474-00072694 it's always a good time to register and
+MX_aRxguLL4-00172-00072695-00072919 lay down
+MX_aRxguLL4-00173-00072920-00073175 they clearly had exactly that in mind
+MX_aRxguLL4-00174-00073176-00073387 and have gone about their business with
+MX_aRxguLL4-00175-00073388-00073706 absolutely the right commitment
+MX_aRxguLL4-00176-00073707-00073987 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00177-00073988-00074237 oh rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00178-00074238-00074556 and here's Cristiano Ronaldo
+MX_aRxguLL4-00179-00074557-00074788 Paul needed to be better there it's a
+MX_aRxguLL4-00180-00074789-00075241 wasted chance
+MX_aRxguLL4-00181-00075242-00075902 that is away
+MX_aRxguLL4-00182-00075903-00076200 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00183-00076201-00076456 it's a red card
+MX_aRxguLL4-00184-00076457-00076619 the players are making their point but
+MX_aRxguLL4-00185-00076620-00077005 the ref clearly isn't interested
+MX_aRxguLL4-00186-00077006-00077287 Manchester United
+MX_aRxguLL4-00187-00077288-00077525 well I think the alternative was to
+MX_aRxguLL4-00188-00077526-00077711 stand there and do nothing while he
+MX_aRxguLL4-00189-00077712-00077891 tried to score and obviously he's not
+MX_aRxguLL4-00190-00077892-00078838 going to allow that Peter is he
+MX_aRxguLL4-00191-00078839-00080437 Yankee
+MX_aRxguLL4-00192-00080438-00081060 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00193-00081061-00081394 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00194-00081395-00081791 men to men Jonah
+MX_aRxguLL4-00195-00081792-00082253 but
+MX_aRxguLL4-00196-00082254-00082450 thank you
+MX_aRxguLL4-00197-00082451-00082817 Bruno Fernandez goes looking but come
+MX_aRxguLL4-00198-00082818-00083441 back to the keeper
+MX_aRxguLL4-00199-00083442-00083615 Los also
+MX_aRxguLL4-00200-00083616-00083774 Sanchez
+MX_aRxguLL4-00201-00083775-00084875 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00202-00084876-00085085 Fred looking to penetrate opposition
+MX_aRxguLL4-00203-00085086-00085229 lines
+MX_aRxguLL4-00204-00085230-00085999 Bruno from Bruno Fernandez
+MX_aRxguLL4-00205-00086000-00086525 and far away no catching them now
+MX_aRxguLL4-00206-00086526-00086855 that really is quite fabulous all his
+MX_aRxguLL4-00207-00086856-00087065 own doing well none of us were exactly
+MX_aRxguLL4-00208-00087066-00087275 sure how that was gonna end up then but
+MX_aRxguLL4-00209-00087276-00087485 I'm delighted to see such a happy ending
+MX_aRxguLL4-00210-00087486-00087671 after such a splendid dribbling run I
+MX_aRxguLL4-00211-00087672-00087856 mean he really did fill that defense
+MX_aRxguLL4-00212-00087857-00088018 into wondering what he was going to do
+MX_aRxguLL4-00213-00088019-00088097 next
+MX_aRxguLL4-00214-00088098-00088271 but
+MX_aRxguLL4-00215-00088272-00089026 Manchester United totally rampant here
+MX_aRxguLL4-00216-00089027-00089206 oh no that's not I've only wanted
+MX_aRxguLL4-00217-00089207-00089344 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00218-00089345-00089599 but
+MX_aRxguLL4-00219-00089600-00090311 he's still away
+MX_aRxguLL4-00220-00090312-00090493 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00221-00090494-00090881 and I don't think he knew either
+MX_aRxguLL4-00222-00090882-00091043 there's going to be another change here
+MX_aRxguLL4-00223-00091044-00091276 yeah it's pretty obvious as to who was
+MX_aRxguLL4-00224-00091277-00091475 going to be taken off his energy levels
+MX_aRxguLL4-00225-00091476-00091750 began to to Sag and he was never going
+MX_aRxguLL4-00226-00091751-00092003 to last until the final whistle
+MX_aRxguLL4-00227-00092004-00092279 Bruno Fernandez is effectively being
+MX_aRxguLL4-00228-00092280-00092482 marked out of the game here yeah and the
+MX_aRxguLL4-00229-00092483-00092656 fact that he's registered Peter simply
+MX_aRxguLL4-00230-00092657-00092926 encourages more attention of um of a
+MX_aRxguLL4-00231-00092927-00093137 closer nature
+MX_aRxguLL4-00232-00093138-00093629 always broken through
+MX_aRxguLL4-00233-00093630-00093994 that intervention was very necessary
+MX_aRxguLL4-00234-00093995-00094168 well it seems as if he's just had a
+MX_aRxguLL4-00235-00094169-00094379 momentary lapse and and slipped into
+MX_aRxguLL4-00236-00094380-00094709 television because he had good options
+MX_aRxguLL4-00237-00094710-00094882 around him and he failed to get his head
+MX_aRxguLL4-00238-00094883-00095141 up
+MX_aRxguLL4-00239-00095142-00095356 rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00240-00095357-00095722 Bruno Fernandez
+MX_aRxguLL4-00241-00095723-00095941 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00242-00095942-00096103 oh
+MX_aRxguLL4-00243-00096104-00096425 my God
+MX_aRxguLL4-00244-00096426-00096688 and it was a chance but meet and drink
+MX_aRxguLL4-00245-00096689-00096935 for the keeper Sancho certainly caught
+MX_aRxguLL4-00246-00096936-00097144 it well enough but that was never really
+MX_aRxguLL4-00247-00097145-00097337 going to trouble the keeper
+MX_aRxguLL4-00248-00097338-00097569 rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00249-00097570-00097890 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00250-00097891-00098362 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00251-00098363-00099053 Fernandez
+MX_aRxguLL4-00252-00099054-00099331 Cecilio plays it forward
+MX_aRxguLL4-00253-00099332-00099575 they might they just couldn't get into
+MX_aRxguLL4-00254-00099576-00099856 an attacking area
+MX_aRxguLL4-00255-00099857-00100200 and it's Cristiano Ronaldo
+MX_aRxguLL4-00256-00100201-00100600 Sancho drops one in
+MX_aRxguLL4-00257-00100601-00100712 um
+MX_aRxguLL4-00258-00100713-00100730 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00259-00100731-00100915 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00260-00100916-00101129 straight back
+MX_aRxguLL4-00261-00101130-00101518 oh and that is that they're just United
+MX_aRxguLL4-00262-00101519-00101782 enjoy their perfect day for their
+MX_aRxguLL4-00263-00101783-00102067 victims it is entirely imperfect
+MX_aRxguLL4-00264-00102068-00102329 comprehensive winners of a one-sided
+MX_aRxguLL4-00265-00102330-00102575 contest any reflections of what you've
+MX_aRxguLL4-00266-00102576-00102851 seen Jim yeah they had a gameplay which
+MX_aRxguLL4-00267-00102852-00103051 was they were hammering away
+MX_aRxguLL4-00268-00103052-00103336 and it paid off for me they were
+MX_aRxguLL4-00269-00103338-00103942 persistent
+MX_aRxguLL4-00270-00103943-00104470 foreign
+MX_aRxguLL4-00272-00108359-00108749 Humanity
+MX_aRxguLL4-00273-00108750-00109066 well good day to you okay a great day
+MX_aRxguLL4-00274-00109067-00109393 here
+MX_aRxguLL4-00275-00109394-00109669 should be a really good game of football
+MX_aRxguLL4-00276-00109670-00109943 the stands are packed here people have
+MX_aRxguLL4-00277-00109944-00110213 done everything they can to get here to
+MX_aRxguLL4-00278-00110214-00110473 get here
+MX_aRxguLL4-00279-00110474-00110734 but I think most of the traffic issues
+MX_aRxguLL4-00280-00110735-00110958 have been settled
+MX_aRxguLL4-00281-00110959-00111294 most people
+MX_aRxguLL4-00282-00111295-00112201 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00283-00112202-00112504 certainly this is a very very impressive
+MX_aRxguLL4-00284-00112505-00113027 venue quite a sight to behold
+MX_aRxguLL4-00285-00113028-00113243 just joining us we are already on the
+MX_aRxguLL4-00286-00113244-00113454 way
+MX_aRxguLL4-00287-00113455-00113728 Bruno Fernandez
+MX_aRxguLL4-00288-00113729-00113910 fell there
+MX_aRxguLL4-00289-00113911-00114075 and the shots
+MX_aRxguLL4-00290-00114076-00114619 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00291-00114620-00114893 absolutely sparkly his reflexes were
+MX_aRxguLL4-00292-00114894-00115939 Ultra Sharp rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00293-00115940-00116116 the way
+MX_aRxguLL4-00294-00116117-00116302 Bruno Fernandez
+MX_aRxguLL4-00295-00116303-00116555 Christian
+MX_aRxguLL4-00296-00116556-00117036 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00297-00117038-00117377 and what a contribution from the main
+MX_aRxguLL4-00298-00117378-00117581 man I had a feeling he might do
+MX_aRxguLL4-00299-00117582-00117863 something given his reputation right to
+MX_aRxguLL4-00300-00117864-00118102 do it like that absolutely brilliant I
+MX_aRxguLL4-00301-00118103-00118254 wasn't expecting that
+MX_aRxguLL4-00302-00118255-00118523 Laura even some of the imposing fans are
+MX_aRxguLL4-00303-00118524-00118666 clapping there you just have to
+MX_aRxguLL4-00304-00118667-00118895 appreciate it you know Peter from the
+MX_aRxguLL4-00305-00118896-00119100 moment
+MX_aRxguLL4-00306-00119101-00119220 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00307-00119221-00119465 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00308-00119466-00119729 foreign
+MX_aRxguLL4-00309-00119730-00121185 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00310-00121186-00121229 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00311-00121230-00123336 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00312-00123338-00123751 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00313-00123752-00124693 a lot of people
+MX_aRxguLL4-00314-00124694-00125082 that's too far for anyone yeah yeah
+MX_aRxguLL4-00315-00125083-00125765 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00316-00125766-00126247 oh what's up
+MX_aRxguLL4-00317-00126248-00127128 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00318-00127129-00127890 explosive Victory
+MX_aRxguLL4-00319-00127891-00128263 goal lead and things should be good
+MX_aRxguLL4-00320-00128264-00128554 well it's been an absolutely fabulous
+MX_aRxguLL4-00321-00128555-00128728 spell for them and they're starting to
+MX_aRxguLL4-00322-00128729-00128981 look Unstoppable there could be more on
+MX_aRxguLL4-00323-00128982-00129208 the way
+MX_aRxguLL4-00324-00129209-00129978 hey
+MX_aRxguLL4-00325-00129979-00130421 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00326-00130422-00130595 starting to fall here it has been
+MX_aRxguLL4-00327-00130596-00131315 looking that way for a little while yeah
+MX_aRxguLL4-00328-00131316-00132175 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00329-00132176-00132487 but good challenge he just stood firm
+MX_aRxguLL4-00330-00132488-00132754 Manchester United don't want to steer
+MX_aRxguLL4-00331-00132755-00132940 clear of any disciplinary issues this
+MX_aRxguLL4-00332-00132941-00133211 time around suspensions to start turning
+MX_aRxguLL4-00333-00133212-00133619 up again
+MX_aRxguLL4-00334-00133620-00133831 out to the right
+MX_aRxguLL4-00335-00133832-00134213 and it's rash for something
+MX_aRxguLL4-00336-00134214-00134387 I'm trying to make
+MX_aRxguLL4-00337-00134388-00134671 it big big
+MX_aRxguLL4-00338-00134672-00134902 distance on it
+MX_aRxguLL4-00339-00134903-00135154 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00340-00135155-00135781 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00341-00135782-00137190 and already they're looking to run away
+MX_aRxguLL4-00342-00137191-00138095 this is becoming a stroll
+MX_aRxguLL4-00343-00138096-00138827 good idea just poorly executed
+MX_aRxguLL4-00344-00138828-00140531 United
+MX_aRxguLL4-00345-00140532-00140861 Ronaldo goes looking
+MX_aRxguLL4-00346-00140862-00141037 oh
+MX_aRxguLL4-00347-00141038-00141457 tries to get it Forward quickly
+MX_aRxguLL4-00348-00141458-00141719 it is good to see someone running at the
+MX_aRxguLL4-00349-00141720-00142128 defense like that
+MX_aRxguLL4-00350-00142129-00142843 and here's the chance to counter
+MX_aRxguLL4-00351-00142844-00143497 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00352-00143498-00143851 Manchester United are really tense
+MX_aRxguLL4-00353-00143852-00144071 we're talking seconds for an
+MX_aRxguLL4-00354-00144072-00144919 interception to the fact that I met him
+MX_aRxguLL4-00355-00144920-00145199 who has the momentum here now the only
+MX_aRxguLL4-00356-00145200-00145537 doubt is how many is coming
+MX_aRxguLL4-00357-00145538-00145945 forward quickly
+MX_aRxguLL4-00358-00145946-00146166 just brushed off the ball there
+MX_aRxguLL4-00359-00146167-00146495 whistle's gone that's uh foul
+MX_aRxguLL4-00360-00146496-00147673 oh
+MX_aRxguLL4-00361-00147674-00148054 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00362-00148055-00148633 look up
+MX_aRxguLL4-00363-00148634-00149051 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00364-00149052-00150469 gets it back yes
+MX_aRxguLL4-00365-00150470-00150607 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00366-00150608-00150913 for the first 45 minutes
+MX_aRxguLL4-00367-00150914-00151261 barrage that looks set to continue
+MX_aRxguLL4-00368-00151262-00151564 Manchester United I've been more or less
+MX_aRxguLL4-00369-00151565-00151811 perfect I would say they're managers all
+MX_aRxguLL4-00370-00151812-00152195 smiles and he's got every reason to be
+MX_aRxguLL4-00371-00152196-00152717 United pretty much out of sight here yes
+MX_aRxguLL4-00372-00152718-00153126 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00373-00153127-00153478 as it gets
+MX_aRxguLL4-00374-00153479-00153719 well I wasn't expecting to go this big
+MX_aRxguLL4-00375-00153720-00154276 Peter but they have been superb
+MX_aRxguLL4-00376-00154277-00155459 whatever
+MX_aRxguLL4-00377-00155460-00156028 foreign
+MX_aRxguLL4-00378-00156029-00156384 yes
+MX_aRxguLL4-00379-00156385-00156954 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00380-00156955-00157895 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00381-00157896-00158416 and here's Cristiano Ronaldo wow
+MX_aRxguLL4-00382-00158417-00158711 you always have to measure if that was
+MX_aRxguLL4-00383-00158712-00158926 the first touch to die for and it set
+MX_aRxguLL4-00384-00158927-00159214 him up
+MX_aRxguLL4-00385-00159215-00159545 place it out to the wing but
+MX_aRxguLL4-00386-00159546-00159745 it's gone out of plate
+MX_aRxguLL4-00387-00159746-00160099 yeah going through
+MX_aRxguLL4-00388-00160100-00160475 it's loose who's getting there oh one
+MX_aRxguLL4-00389-00160476-00160709 basaka very Furman standing his ground
+MX_aRxguLL4-00390-00160710-00161278 there it is a tough full contact contest
+MX_aRxguLL4-00391-00161279-00161916 Ed
+MX_aRxguLL4-00392-00161917-00162233 and it's paid forward questions were
+MX_aRxguLL4-00393-00162234-00162539 asked but he's given the answers Bruno
+MX_aRxguLL4-00394-00162540-00162893 Fernandez spreads it towards the left oh
+MX_aRxguLL4-00395-00162894-00163097 it's come loose
+MX_aRxguLL4-00396-00163098-00163416 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00397-00163417-00163823 ah hey one straight back
+MX_aRxguLL4-00398-00163824-00164166 it's rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00399-00164167-00164379 and it's paid forward
+MX_aRxguLL4-00400-00164380-00164751 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00401-00164752-00164921 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00402-00164922-00165119 needless to say he was expecting a
+MX_aRxguLL4-00403-00165120-00165389 better ball than that
+MX_aRxguLL4-00404-00165390-00165563 great strength too strong for his
+MX_aRxguLL4-00405-00165564-00165845 opponent Sancho looks to get on the end
+MX_aRxguLL4-00406-00165846-00166199 of this
+MX_aRxguLL4-00407-00166200-00166583 rashford
+MX_aRxguLL4-00408-00166584-00167154 um
+MX_aRxguLL4-00409-00167155-00167464 control that with such ease and really
+MX_aRxguLL4-00410-00167465-00168175 ought to have followed it up with a dog
+MX_aRxguLL4-00411-00168176-00168620 it's Cristiano Ronaldo yeah
+MX_aRxguLL4-00412-00168621-00169319 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00413-00169320-00169489 all right
+MX_aRxguLL4-00414-00169490-00169852 lays it out to the flank oh no oh no
+MX_aRxguLL4-00415-00169853-00170195 it's quite a run and he's not done yet
+MX_aRxguLL4-00416-00170196-00170638 foreign
+MX_aRxguLL4-00417-00170639-00171212 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00418-00171213-00172045 [Laughter]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00419-00172046-00172301 quality deserted and when they really
+MX_aRxguLL4-00420-00172302-00172614 needed it yeah
+MX_aRxguLL4-00421-00172615-00172895 the defense is wary about opposition
+MX_aRxguLL4-00422-00172896-00173093 pace so they're just not getting too
+MX_aRxguLL4-00423-00173094-00173290 tight yeah they know that if they they
+MX_aRxguLL4-00424-00173291-00173507 step up their their keeper could get a
+MX_aRxguLL4-00425-00173508-00173802 whole lot busier
+MX_aRxguLL4-00426-00173803-00174071 no no way through that
+MX_aRxguLL4-00427-00174072-00174293 sit forward
+MX_aRxguLL4-00428-00174294-00174616 now shortly
+MX_aRxguLL4-00429-00174617-00174838 yes
+MX_aRxguLL4-00430-00174839-00176611 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00431-00176612-00176837 you just think that's really good
+MX_aRxguLL4-00432-00176838-00176999 management introducing one of his
+MX_aRxguLL4-00433-00177000-00177173 younger players when the pressure's tilt
+MX_aRxguLL4-00434-00177174-00177388 me off just allowing him some valuable
+MX_aRxguLL4-00435-00177389-00177722 easy on field experience
+MX_aRxguLL4-00436-00177723-00178393 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00437-00178394-00178685 Manchester United really are almost
+MX_aRxguLL4-00438-00178686-00178883 trying to pass the ball through a brick
+MX_aRxguLL4-00439-00178884-00179099 wall at the moment you can see the sense
+MX_aRxguLL4-00440-00179100-00179556 of anxiety has has now shifted yes
+MX_aRxguLL4-00441-00179557-00180325 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00442-00180326-00180593 to win it back
+MX_aRxguLL4-00443-00180594-00180966 and it's Cristiano Ronaldo
+MX_aRxguLL4-00444-00180967-00181469 beautifully no
+MX_aRxguLL4-00445-00181470-00181741 restaurant
+MX_aRxguLL4-00446-00181742-00181961 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00447-00181962-00182696 is it out of Harm's Way
+MX_aRxguLL4-00448-00182697-00183078 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00449-00183079-00183231 yes
+MX_aRxguLL4-00450-00183232-00183717 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00451-00183718-00184093 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00452-00184094-00184581 four opponents left chasing Shadows
+MX_aRxguLL4-00453-00184582-00184652 [Music]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00454-00184653-00186349 [Applause]
+MX_aRxguLL4-00455-00186350-00186996 see you in the next game of bye-bye
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00000-00000000-00000371 morning folks I'm here with Nicole Penny
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00001-00000372-00000668 o2 one of our longest term members and a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00002-00000669-00000947 very successful salon owner from the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00003-00000948-00001193 little country town of sale in Victoria
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00004-00001194-00001312 thanks for joining me
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00005-00001313-00001834 Nicole you've been in business there for
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00006-00001835-00001913 a long time
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00007-00001914-00002217 tell us the story how did you start I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00008-00002218-00002729 started with a little salon behind a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00009-00002730-00002912 hairdressers which is true treatment
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00010-00002913-00003415 rooms and I didn't really I was going
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00011-00003417-00003631 through a bit of a could I say midlife
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00012-00003632-00004015 crisis at 21 not sure but anyway and I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00013-00004017-00004147 didn't know what I wanted to do with my
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00014-00004148-00004376 life sauce at all let's open up a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00015-00004377-00004808 business crazy and that's how I started
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00016-00004809-00005006 I just had two rooms I worked on my own
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00017-00005007-00005533 I put a little ad in a newspaper to do I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00018-00005534-00005870 think it was like $30 pedicures or
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00019-00005871-00006086 something like that and I got bombarded
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00020-00006087-00006478 with people and I hired my first staff
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00021-00006479-00006864 member like four or five months in and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00022-00006865-00007244 yeah two and a half years later I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00023-00007245-00007598 thought what am I gonna do do I go
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00024-00007598-00007876 overseas and backpack no that's not me
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00025-00007877-00008345 so I opened up a big Asylum we have 11
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00026-00008346-00008606 treatment rooms now we just had our 10th
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00027-00008607-00008738 birthday this year
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00028-00008739-00009302 and yeah so you started from scratch
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00029-00009303-00009719 with next to nothing and you're now
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00030-00009720-00009878 turning you're the biggest you're by far
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00031-00009879-00010192 the biggest in town aren't you yes so
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00032-00010193-00010406 how many how many residents live in your
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00033-00010407-00011051 little town in sail alone sort of the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00034-00011052-00011345 main town for little towns around us so
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00035-00011346-00011588 we have a lot of surrounding farming
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00036-00011589-00012274 community and so you were 21 when you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00037-00012275-00012724 started and yeah really had no idea
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00038-00012725-00013294 about business yeah no idea so what
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00039-00013296-00013663 the learning curve you're learning
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00040-00013665-00014402 everyday I I joined worldwide I think
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00041-00014403-00014836 I've been in business for a year and I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00042-00014837-00015065 realized I needed to do something
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00043-00015066-00015230 different when I was getting these
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00044-00015231-00015541 things called tax bills funny things
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00045-00015543-00016202 those aren't I yeah yeah got no money
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00046-00016203-00016372 because I'm 21 and I've been having
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00047-00016374-00016961 really good weekends yeah I joined
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00048-00016962-00017357 worldwide and they you guys have taught
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00049-00017358-00017852 me so much and yeah and then I got an
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00050-00017853-00018275 accountant and and then yeah realized
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00051-00018276-00018833 you have to be a great artist so you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00052-00018834-00019145 joined our membership program and you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00053-00019146-00019415 got all of our marketing materials what
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00054-00019416-00019918 happened after that I went you're like
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00055-00019919-00020389 seminar day things and I've never even
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00056-00020390-00020663 even you know realize that those things
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00057-00020664-00021044 happen and I there was a few different
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00058-00021045-00021200 speakers and I signed up with you guys
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00059-00021201-00021977 then after that I I had to put on
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00060-00021978-00022175 another staff member because we just put
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00061-00022176-00022474 we did things like a newsletter and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00062-00022475-00023183 birthday vouchers and I I think I did a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00063-00023184-00023471 Hollywood woman remember those things
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00064-00023472-00023666 that one about one of our famous
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00065-00023667-00024083 promotions yeah yeah and I I pounded the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00066-00024084-00024680 pavement with that and and then I yeah I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00067-00024681-00024848 had to put another staff member on and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00068-00024849-00025061 we battled through in the small salon
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00069-00025062-00025442 with three of us just working around the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00070-00025443-00025793 clock to sort of fit people in and work
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00071-00025794-00026245 around each other and and then yeah we
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00072-00026247-00026495 realized I really I went through a yeah
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00073-00026495-00026672 I went through a stage where I wasn't
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00074-00026673-00026995 sure whether to keep banging business or
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00075-00026997-00027425 go traveling and be young so I decided
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00076-00027426-00027757 that I was going to stay in business and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00077-00027758-00028124 yeah what do you love about being in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00078-00028125-00028508 business I love the challenge
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00079-00028508-00028754 I love being challenged every day
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00080-00028755-00028919 there's never a dull moment in my life
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00081-00028920-00029516 as you know yeah I love the challenge of
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00082-00029517-00029882 it because it's not easy ever for our
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00083-00029883-00030114 what do you hate about being in business
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00084-00030116-00030704 staff well as they say you know business
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00085-00030705-00030926 would be so much easier if weren't
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00086-00030927-00031151 having to employ staff and have
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00087-00031152-00031586 customers this is so true
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00088-00031587-00031808 so you build the business and you build
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00089-00031808-00031927 the business and you built the business
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00090-00031929-00032267 using a lot of the marketing tools and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00091-00032268-00032758 templates and systems we we teach then
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00092-00032760-00033149 you got married and had a couple of
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00093-00033150-00033349 little kids
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00094-00033350-00033964 and how did that impact on the business
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00095-00033965-00034256 with my first child I didn't really take
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00096-00034257-00034406 a lot of time off because I thought that
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00097-00034407-00034765 splash was going to fall to pieces
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00098-00034766-00035267 however it didn't with my second child I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00099-00035268-00035765 hired a manager and I pretty much I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00100-00035766-00035993 nearly had a year off I work you know
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00101-00035994-00036223 random days I didn't have set days and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00102-00036224-00036542 oh my god this Allen did not fall to
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00103-00036543-00036875 pieces and it was awesome and it would
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00104-00036876-00037234 I've found a new appreciation I guess
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00105-00037235-00037517 for my business and for my staff and for
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00106-00037518-00038371 my life really and yeah it's when you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00107-00038372-00038758 instead of in the business you are a lot
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00108-00038759-00039322 more can I say successful I don't know
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00109-00039323-00039587 it's a it's a different there's a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00110-00039588-00039765 difference
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00111-00039766-00039984 what have you found the difference being
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00112-00039985-00040349 off the tools compared with on the tools
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00113-00040350-00040599 you can see what's happening more in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00114-00040600-00040842 your business when you're looking from
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00115-00040843-00041085 afar rather than working in it all the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00116-00041086-00041226 time
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00117-00041227-00041448 you can keep track of what's happening
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00118-00041449-00041652 with your team and you can work on
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00119-00041653-00041832 things so that your team are constantly
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00120-00041833-00042054 busy whereas if you're constantly busy
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00121-00042055-00042366 with clients you don't have a lot of
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00122-00042367-00042558 time to do anything else which is what
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00123-00042559-00042837 I'm currently doing so I'm back in the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00124-00042838-00043086 salon on clients 4 days a week because
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00125-00043087-00043674 you can't find enough stuff from having
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00126-00043675-00044319 8 to 9 staff to having 4 to 5 so yeah
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00127-00044320-00044514 I've built up this great business with
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00128-00044515-00044847 lots of clients but I just don't have
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00129-00044848-00045194 the staff to service these clients so
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00130-00045195-00045860 I'm hoping that next year 2018 we can
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00131-00045861-00046158 change that so I can go back to being on
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00132-00046159-00046737 the business do you well you you started
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00133-00046738-00046953 as a 21 year old working full time on
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00134-00046954-00047322 the on the clients yes what have you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00135-00047323-00047678 found the difference being between
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00136-00047679-00047916 working on the clients and working on
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00137-00047917-00048201 the business your business is so much
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00138-00048202-00048380 better when you're working on it
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00139-00048381-00048690 although you don't think it is because
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00140-00048691-00048936 you're not seeing actual dollars coming
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00141-00048937-00049080 to your bank you can up from working on
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00142-00049081-00049515 it you will see them coming in because
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00143-00049516-00049827 your staff they're better you can do
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00144-00049828-00050157 more marketing you can work on figures
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00145-00050158-00050445 and you can do a lot more things when
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00146-00050446-00050745 you have the time away from clients
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00147-00050746-00051006 don't get me wrong I love I'm loving
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00148-00051007-00051498 being on clients but it makes not time
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00149-00051499-00051690 see my house very busy because I'm
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00150-00051691-00052095 trying to do all that stops to tell me
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00151-00052096-00052374 the the the biggest thing that you've
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00152-00052375-00052607 learned being part of a group black
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00153-00052608-00053073 house the support is amazing in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00154-00053074-00053322 a lot of members will see especially on
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00155-00053323-00053478 the Facebook group if I'm having a bad
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00156-00053479-00053988 day I'll express it and the support has
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00157-00053989-00054444 just been amazing and having people
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00158-00054445-00054773 like-minded people to bounce ideas off
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00159-00054774-00055284 and there's just so many things so many
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00160-00055285-00055592 like marketing ideas that you can use if
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00161-00055594-00055866 you're sort of having a bit of a lull
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00162-00055866-00056105 time in your business but I think also
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00163-00056107-00056316 being organized with it we don't really
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00164-00056316-00056709 have low times because we're prepared
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00165-00056710-00056988 for that because of the things that
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00166-00056989-00057251 worldwide have provided us so we're
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00167-00057252-00057519 pretty consistent throughout the year
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00168-00057520-00057830 obviously there's busier times but
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00169-00057832-00058110 because I have put in systems and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00170-00058111-00058316 marketing plans and things like that I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00171-00058317-00058596 we don't get anymore so tell me about
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00172-00058597-00058805 your marketing plans you're a big one
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00173-00058807-00058986 for systems you're a big one for having
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00174-00058987-00059415 a calendar that the essentially you you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00175-00059416-00059760 load up with stuff the year ahead how
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00176-00059761-00060004 has that impacted on the business yes
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00177-00060005-00060410 also men are aware of what's coming up
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00178-00060411-00060680 but you know I've been doing it for
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00179-00060682-00061038 probably I would be ii's now at least
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00180-00061039-00061236 that I've been doing that for so I have
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00181-00061237-00061512 a yearly planner in my office at home
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00182-00061513-00061854 that has got literally the days that I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00183-00061854-00062286 am doing things and you know the months
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00184-00062287-00062654 leading up to Mother's Day for example I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00185-00062654-00063138 know when I need to start my planning
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00186-00063139-00063603 for that to get it out in time and yeah
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00187-00063604-00063873 having our little newsletters and all
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00188-00063874-00064094 that sort of stuff the birthday batches
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00189-00064095-00064329 and the first of the month is always
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00190-00064329-00064526 crazy because that's when all that sort
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00191-00064527-00064950 of stuff happens so yeah it just it
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00192-00064951-00065385 makes your life so much better because
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00193-00065386-00065694 you know what's coming up and you know
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00194-00065695-00065993 you can look from we had a we had a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00195-00065994-00066357 pretty I can say average August
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00196-00066358-00066738 down here so I know that next year I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00197-00066739-00066942 need to do something else
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00198-00066943-00067122 I live in what we've just been doing
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00199-00067123-00067455 just sort of bring that back up so if
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00200-00067456-00067685 I'm already prepped for August next year
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00201-00067686-00068163 now that's interesting now as you know
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00202-00068164-00068385 we talk to a hell of a lot of salon
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00203-00068386-00068631 owners and one of the big things that
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00204-00068632-00068772 come in comes out of all of those
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00205-00068773-00069099 conversations is I'm I'm too busy to do
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00206-00069100-00069267 lots of other stuff to market the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00207-00069268-00069504 business and from what you're saying
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00208-00069505-00069792 it's it's very structured and very easy
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00209-00069793-00070167 and and it's just a linear process but I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00210-00070168-00070566 get the feeling that it is healthy scale
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00211-00070567-00070788 for sometimes it's not it's not
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00212-00070789-00071160 perfectly smooth no definitely not but
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00213-00071161-00071523 you know I put in the hours and I put in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00214-00071524-00071805 the effort so that I get bored really
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00215-00071806-00072084 easily and I think if I'm bored then one
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00216-00072085-00072336 of my staff so I've got to keep thinking
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00217-00072337-00072579 of new and exciting things to keep
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00218-00072580-00072840 everyone motivated including myself
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00219-00072841-00073317 so and I know week to week what I've got
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00220-00073318-00073584 to get done and I know the planning that
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00221-00073585-00073881 I have to get done Jan and Feb you know
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00222-00073882-00074172 can potentially be really quiet so well
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00223-00074173-00074532 you know got them sorted but that's
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00224-00074533-00075039 happened in October okay so you're
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00225-00075040-00075303 working months in advance but listening
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00226-00075304-00075570 to you talk a lot of people watching
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00227-00075571-00075810 this or listening to this this as a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00228-00075811-00076053 podcast would go old she's she's
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00229-00076054-00076308 successful because she's got you know
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00230-00076309-00076548 she's got staff and and and she can just
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00231-00076549-00076869 spend time organizing herself but I only
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00232-00076870-00077166 had one or two staff and and it doesn't
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00233-00077167-00077427 work for me I mean it works for you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00234-00077428-00077550 because you put in the hours
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00235-00077551-00077820 that's right you've got two little kids
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00236-00077821-00078164 and you're still burn midnight oil yeah
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00237-00078165-00078504 yeah you know you have to you can't you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00238-00078505-00078741 can't expect to have good things if
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00239-00078742-00078882 you're not willing to put in the effort
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00240-00078883-00079110 and trust me I've had those times where
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00241-00079111-00079338 I'm like I just can't even deal with it
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00242-00079339-00079725 but then you go
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00243-00079726-00079989 well I haven't put in the effort so then
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00244-00079990-00080220 I really want that whatever you want to
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00245-00080221-00080514 buy I'm a shopper I love spending money
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00246-00080515-00080751 I've got to have it in my account the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00247-00080752-00081393 truth the truth and one of the things
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00248-00081394-00081746 you touched on was being a member of a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00249-00081747-00082179 high profile like-minded group a lot of
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00250-00082180-00082539 people try to do it on their own it's a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00251-00082540-00082806 sign of weakness when you ask for help I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00252-00082807-00083178 think it's you know it it probably has
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00253-00083179-00083511 made me the business owner that I am
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00254-00083512-00083928 today has a lot of credit to worldwide
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00255-00083929-00084159 because it you have these people that
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00256-00084160-00084537 are there you literally are there to
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00257-00084538-00084783 help and they've got the answers to
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00258-00084784-00084981 pretty much all the problems that you'll
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00259-00084982-00085262 have you know Harold beauty salon issue
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00260-00085263-00085782 and it it has has made my life a lot
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00261-00085783-00085977 easier I guess because it's all done for
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00262-00085978-00086460 you and it's proven to work well have
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00263-00086461-00086912 made the mistakes for people yeah yeah
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00264-00086913-00087183 bear in mind that there's nothing new in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00265-00087184-00087432 the world any challenge that you've had
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00266-00087433-00087780 you have has been solved by somebody
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00267-00087781-00088131 somewhere yes and why try to reinvent
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00268-00088132-00088374 the wheel that's right so what you've
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00269-00088375-00088563 done is not trying to reinvent well you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00270-00088564-00088797 were the wheel you've just copied what's
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00271-00088798-00089298 worked for other people and when I first
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00272-00089299-00089700 started with worldwide you know the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00273-00089701-00089958 response from clients or like I've never
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00274-00089959-00090246 seen anyone like your marketing is
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00275-00090247-00090477 amazing and I'm like well thank you like
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00276-00090478-00090822 you know it then they hadn't had any one
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00277-00090823-00091047 that cared for their clients that wanted
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00278-00091048-00091368 to show them things that they could do I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00279-00091369-00091800 guess and I guess in hair and beauty we
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00280-00091801-00092046 think that our clients no one else can
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00281-00092047-00092250 do that treatment you know you think
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00282-00092251-00092481 that girl's not going to do service as
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00283-00092482-00092856 well as I do but you know if you work on
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00284-00092857-00093100 the business you have time to Train
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00285-00093101-00093373 your clients will learn to love someone
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00286-00093374-00093574 else as much as you and they'll
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00287-00093575-00093715 appreciate you more because you're gonna
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00288-00093716-00093976 have the time to reward them with a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00289-00093977-00094219 birthday about Cheryl you know send them
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00290-00094220-00094480 a text message to say hey we're doing
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00291-00094481-00094732 this facial promo for the month of June
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00292-00094733-00094990 love to come in and see it whereas if
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00293-00094991-00095134 you're working on these clients all the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00294-00095135-00095491 time you don't have time to do that it
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00295-00095492-00095758 turns you from being a technician into
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00296-00095759-00095950 being a business owner and public
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00297-00095951-00096589 relations person doesn't love to see my
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00298-00096590-00096892 face in the salon and I always will stop
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00299-00096893-00097159 and have a chat whatever I think they
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00300-00097160-00097336 appreciate that someone don't have being
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00301-00097337-00097552 in the salon but I could be sitting
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00302-00097553-00097768 there on my laptop you know doing things
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00303-00097769-00098200 it's not always you know painting nails
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00304-00098201-00098470 and waxing eyebrows so I do do a lot of
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00305-00098471-00098665 stuff in this element clients love to
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00306-00098666-00099382 see you is there any challenge that
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00307-00099383-00099718 you've come across in business that
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00308-00099719-00100143 can't be solved as a marketing issue
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00309-00100144-00100732 apart from getting staff I mean any just
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00310-00100733-00100906 about any challenge in business is a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00311-00100907-00101413 marketing challenge isn't yeah to get
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00312-00101414-00101776 your name out to get people to know who
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00313-00101777-00101944 you are and what you're about is so
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00314-00101945-00102313 important I think a big challenge in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00315-00102314-00102507 business is each time we're but
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00316-00102508-00102868 everyone's timeful so you know you just
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00317-00102869-00103458 have to make the time to do it how do
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00318-00103459-00103686 you make the time I mean you get home
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00319-00103688-00103938 from work and you've got two toddlers
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00320-00103939-00104551 who demand your your input and there's
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00321-00104552-00104718 not much you can do until they go to bed
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00322-00104719-00105234 is there no I when they go to bed I get
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00323-00105235-00105775 up early in the mornings I I know I just
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00324-00105776-00105946 know that I've got to do it I'm have a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00325-00105947-00106096 list on my phone
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00326-00106097-00106339 and that I need to get through each week
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00327-00106340-00106471 and I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00328-00106472-00106663 just have to I just know I've got to get
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00329-00106664-00106888 it done so how early do you get up in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00330-00106889-00107113 the morning five or six o'clock
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00331-00107114-00107649 depending on my son my baby he's
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00332-00107650-00107839 one-and-a-half and he doesn't like to
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00333-00107840-00108088 sleep every night so just don't how
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00334-00108089-00108309 rough a night we have that five six
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00335-00108310-00108631 o'clock usually so you've got two little
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00336-00108632-00108891 kids and you can get up at 5:00 a.m. and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00337-00108892-00109099 work through to a midnight if necessary
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00338-00109100-00109314 yeah
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00339-00109315-00109600 people who don't have kids presumably
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00340-00109601-00109897 could do at least I'm not saying don't
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00341-00109898-00110083 sleep but I'm just saying make some
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00342-00110083-00110272 things parties if you don't have kids
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00343-00110273-00110593 then you know do whatever do know like
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00344-00110594-00111208 I'm you know I don't know I I just know
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00345-00111208-00111408 what I want to do and what do I want to
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00346-00111409-00111615 achieve and I guess now that I have kids
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00347-00111616-00112147 I have certain you know expectations in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00348-00112148-00112456 myself because I want to have things in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00349-00112457-00112878 my life so it I do just have to do it I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00350-00112879-00113154 guess and I love spending money so I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00351-00113155-00113406 need to earn it
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00352-00113407-00113650 well there's the old joke about my
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00353-00113651-00113833 brother's wife who had her credit card
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00354-00113833-00114015 stolen and he didn't report it from us
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00355-00114016-00114189 because the thief was spending rest and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00356-00114190-00115120 she was just I think if you reset
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00357-00115121-00115501 yourself even a daily target to start
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00358-00115502-00115849 with a weekly target and make a list of
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00359-00115850-00116046 the things that you want to get done and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00360-00116047-00116553 prioritize that I think is one of the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00361-00116554-00116773 best things you can do and at the start
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00362-00116774-00117049 like starting out it's not easy and it
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00363-00117050-00117336 is so time consuming it's not gonna
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00364-00117338-00117578 happen overnight and you might spend
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00365-00117579-00117895 hours like my Christmas cards we send
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00366-00117896-00118160 Christmas cards to every single client
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00367-00118161-00118363 my husband
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00368-00118364-00118600 Lee see I was like if I see another
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00369-00118601-00118975 Christmas card look out like our dining
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00370-00118976-00119263 room table for two months was just
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00371-00119264-00119565 covered in pouches and Christmas cards
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00372-00119566-00119681 and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00373-00119682-00120333 everything so and it's not gonna happen
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00374-00120333-00121029 quickly the result yeah so success is
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00375-00121030-00121358 messy isn't it yeah yeah and you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00376-00121359-00121494 probably will fight with your husband
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00377-00121495-00121709 boyfriend girlfriend whoever you may be
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00378-00121710-00121983 with but it's worth it in the end
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00379-00121983-00122529 because if you gonna be giving it your
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00380-00122530-00123045 own yeah and I don't like to come second
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00381-00123046-00123393 I like to be number one and you got to
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00382-00123394-00123615 work at it and you are number one in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00383-00123616-00124041 town aren't you yeah yeah and others are
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00384-00124042-00124226 always trying to knock you ass
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00385-00124227-00124527 absolutely and so to stay number one
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00386-00124528-00124821 you've got to keep pouring in the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00387-00124822-00125031 marketing you've got to keep pouring in
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00388-00125032-00125258 online and offline I mean you do both
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00389-00125259-00126408 don't you yeah but I've got these girls
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00390-00126408-00126930 that can fling it out on Instagram do a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00391-00126931-00127133 snapchat in three seconds before I've
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00392-00127134-00127431 even I can be app so that's their job so
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00393-00127432-00127760 a delegation is also I guess a good
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00394-00127761-00127958 thing and learning what to delegate and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00395-00127959-00128159 how to do it because I'm control freak
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00396-00128160-00128335 too
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00397-00128336-00128688 here's another challenge so one of the
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00398-00128689-00128880 key takeaways from what you're talking
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00399-00128881-00128909 about
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00400-00128910-00129386 is that you don't rely on one form of
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00401-00129388-00129693 getting clients you don't rely on one
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00402-00129694-00130283 thing like Facebook or Google or Direct
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00403-00130284-00130586 Mail you're doing all of them yeah we
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00404-00130588-00130830 don't I guess when I first started with
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00405-00130831-00131289 worldwide Direct Mail was a massive
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00406-00131290-00131481 thing like we did a lot of that I used
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00407-00131482-00131847 to mail out my newsletters every single
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00408-00131848-00132129 month and that would take time we don't
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00409-00132130-00132741 do that now we it's too expensive first
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00410-00132742-00132878 rate post
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00411-00132879-00133127 it's so time-consuming and because we do
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00412-00133128-00133448 have so many clients but we do mail out
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00413-00133449-00133772 and use up a birthday bash up to every
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00414-00133773-00134048 client and at Christmas time everyone
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00415-00134049-00134303 gets a Christmas card and clients love
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00416-00134304-00134576 that like you do not get you only get
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00417-00134577-00134762 bills in the mail these days mmm
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00418-00134763-00135143 did you get something nice yeah
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00419-00135144-00135629 clients love it yeah yeah well that's
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00420-00135630-00135971 been a fantastic thing to hear of how
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00421-00135972-00136297 you've done everything you've you've
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00422-00136298-00136691 hassle than youth for and you've kicked
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00423-00136692-00137050 and scratched your way to the top and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00424-00137051-00137321 it's inspirational to hear how you've
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00425-00137322-00137741 done it with certain disadvantages I
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00426-00137742-00138224 mean you are time for yeah but it's
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00427-00138225-00138413 inspirate must be inspirational for
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00428-00138414-00138599 other salon owners to hear that it can
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00429-00138600-00139084 be done in a small town out in the scrub
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00430-00139085-00139427 what sort of advice what's the biggest
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00431-00139428-00139666 piece of advice that you could give a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00432-00139667-00139922 salon owner who's either struggling or
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00433-00139923-00140492 just starting out find some time and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00434-00140493-00141011 work out what you want to achieve and do
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00435-00141012-00141320 some bloody marketing get your name out
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00436-00141321-00141560 there and you know if you're just
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00437-00141561-00141740 starting out and you've only got a few
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00438-00141741-00142043 clients and pick your best ones and get
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00439-00142044-00142223 them to tell all their friends about
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00440-00142224-00142499 them and you know reward your clients
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00441-00142500-00143101 for helping you along the way you know
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00442-00143102-00143318 giving if someone at when it all about
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00443-00143319-00143519 it doesn't cost you $20 they might use
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00444-00143520-00143708 it for an eyebrow wax which cost you 7
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00445-00143709-00143978 cents like you know you've got a giving
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00446-00143979-00144358 a little can get you a lot you can
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00447-00144359-00144602 particularly to attract a new client
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00448-00144603-00144953 yeah and you know working out what a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00449-00144954-00145559 client is worth to her yeah and and you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00450-00145560-00145841 know you just put putting in the effort
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00451-00145842-00146045 it's gonna get your reward but if you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00452-00146046-00146246 you know half
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00453-00146247-00146488 do it then you get half the reward so
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00454-00146489-00146650 you know what a client is going to be
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00455-00146651-00146773 worth to you in a year
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00456-00146774-00147253 absolutely so give us some numbers so we
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00457-00147254-00147529 average on clients spending between a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00458-00147530-00147766 hundred and two hundred dollars a year a
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00459-00147767-00148249 year each month sorry yeah so you're
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00460-00148250-00149038 looking at 2015 a year on average yep so
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00461-00149039-00149278 it's worth you saying well I'm going to
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00462-00149279-00149574 spend a hundred dollars to get a new car
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00463-00149575-00149875 absolutely because that clients worth up
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00464-00149876-00150056 to two thousand dollars to you in a year
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00465-00150057-00150299 and that's a concept that a lot of
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00466-00150300-00150584 business owners don't understand yeah
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00467-00150585-00151073 it's the concept of giving away part of
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00468-00151074-00151390 a profit you never would have got to get
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00469-00151391-00151627 a profit that was never gonna happen
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00470-00151628-00152396 anyway yeah yeah and you know if you'd
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00471-00152397-00152582 give a bad service that person's gonna
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00472-00152583-00152786 say tell ten or twenty people if you
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00473-00152787-00152911 give a good service they'll probably
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00474-00152912-00153245 tell two but those two people that could
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00475-00153246-00153528 be five thousand dollars in your pocket
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00476-00153529-00155227 you know I'm sure you'd always help yeah
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00477-00155228-00155437 absolutely but advise folks if you're
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00478-00155438-00155578 watching this or listening to this and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00479-00155579-00155899 you want some help go to worldwide so on
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00480-00155900-00156075 marketing.com
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00481-00156076-00156458 plenty of ways to contact us you too can
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00482-00156459-00156688 have a business like nicole has built up
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00483-00156689-00157144 over relatively short time ten years and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00484-00157145-00157387 we can help you do a lot of that so
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00485-00157388-00157472 Thank You Nicole
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00486-00157473-00157784 preciate your time today onward and
+MXIL_Rqr1Zo-00487-00157785-00158210 upward and have a great Christmas yeah
+MaXHfTecTo4-00000-00000022-00000178 [Applause]
+MaXHfTecTo4-00001-00000179-00000329 [Music]
+MaXHfTecTo4-00002-00000330-00000372 foreign
+MaXHfTecTo4-00003-00000373-00000501 [Music]
+MaXHfTecTo4-00004-00000501-00000754 [Applause]
+MaXHfTecTo4-00005-00000755-00000801 [Music]
+MaXHfTecTo4-00006-00000802-00000946 [Applause]
+MaXHfTecTo4-00007-00000947-00003769 [Music]
+MaXHfTecTo4-00008-00003770-00004593 thank you
+MaXHfTecTo4-00009-00004594-00004722 [Music]
+MaXHfTecTo4-00010-00004723-00004977 [Applause]
+MaXHfTecTo4-00011-00004978-00005745 [Music]
+MaXHfTecTo4-00012-00005746-00006099 [Music]
+MbttFVxxdOA-00000-00000079-00000307 Ryze is the capital city of rise
+MbttFVxxdOA-00001-00000308-00000501 province in the eastern part of the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00002-00000502-00001186 Black Sea region of Turkey
+MbttFVxxdOA-00003-00001187-00001885 topic name the name comes from Greek
+MbttFVxxdOA-00004-00001886-00002173 Reesa Reesa or resilient rezaian meaning
+MbttFVxxdOA-00005-00002174-00002539 mountain slopes raiser in Greek means
+MbttFVxxdOA-00006-00002540-00002830 root in modern times its name in Greek
+MbttFVxxdOA-00007-00002831-00003166 was usually risen to Rozonda its Latin
+MbttFVxxdOA-00008-00003167-00003409 forms arises and rise iam the latter of
+MbttFVxxdOA-00009-00003410-00003604 which is used in the Catholic Church's
+MbttFVxxdOA-00010-00003604-00003799 list of titular seas as the name of
+MbttFVxxdOA-00011-00003800-00003988 bishopric of the town which was once
+MbttFVxxdOA-00012-00003989-00004177 part of the late Roman province of
+MbttFVxxdOA-00013-00004178-00004516 Pontus Paulo maniacae s' the name rises
+MbttFVxxdOA-00014-00004517-00004747 spelled in Ottoman Turkish and rise in
+MbttFVxxdOA-00015-00004748-00005056 Georgian the name in Laz is Rossini
+MbttFVxxdOA-00016-00005057-00005579 risen
+MbttFVxxdOA-00017-00005580-00006300 topic history the first written mention
+MbttFVxxdOA-00018-00006301-00006536 of rise is made by Aryan in a work named
+MbttFVxxdOA-00019-00006537-00006783 para plus of the uke scene see as a city
+MbttFVxxdOA-00020-00006784-00006951 founded at the mouth of the homonymous
+MbttFVxxdOA-00021-00006952-00007220 River the ancient and Byzantine ratios
+MbttFVxxdOA-00022-00007222-00007791 Potamus dated at 130 to 131 ad and
+MbttFVxxdOA-00023-00007792-00007980 written as a letter to Roman Emperor
+MbttFVxxdOA-00024-00007981-00008232 Hadrian the work records how its author
+MbttFVxxdOA-00025-00008233-00008474 the governor of Cappadocia made an
+MbttFVxxdOA-00026-00008475-00008696 inspection tour of the eastern Black Sea
+MbttFVxxdOA-00027-00008697-00008865 territories that were part of his
+MbttFVxxdOA-00028-00008866-00009120 jurisdiction first visiting the Roman
+MbttFVxxdOA-00029-00009121-00009345 Empire's eastern Anatolian frontier
+MbttFVxxdOA-00030-00009346-00009534 Garrison's before pushing on to the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00031-00009535-00009720 Black Sea coast in the traps on
+MbttFVxxdOA-00032-00009721-00009996 trebizond region the city of rise formed
+MbttFVxxdOA-00033-00009997-00010205 part of historic Georgian province of
+MbttFVxxdOA-00034-00010206-00010641 chana T Georgian tonight from 1547 chana
+MbttFVxxdOA-00035-00010642-00010841 T province was incorporated by the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00036-00010842-00011073 Ottoman Empire and became a part of the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00037-00011074-00011405 Sanka coffie Stan the city was claimed
+MbttFVxxdOA-00038-00011406-00011627 by the short-lived Democratic Republic
+MbttFVxxdOA-00039-00011628-00012056 of Georgia between 1918 and 1920 on the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00040-00012057-00012428 basis of the 1921 Treaty of cars Soviet
+MbttFVxxdOA-00041-00012429-00012663 Russia granted rise to Turkey just as
+MbttFVxxdOA-00042-00012664-00012858 the other territories of art van are
+MbttFVxxdOA-00043-00012859-00013627 darhan and ho / Georgian
+MbttFVxxdOA-00044-00013628-00014353 topic geography the city is built around
+MbttFVxxdOA-00045-00014354-00014596 a small Bay on the Black Sea coast on a
+MbttFVxxdOA-00046-00014597-00014794 narrow strip of flat land between the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00047-00014794-00015112 sea in the mountains behind the coastal
+MbttFVxxdOA-00048-00015113-00015334 strip is being expanded with landfill
+MbttFVxxdOA-00049-00015335-00015511 and the city is growing up the steep
+MbttFVxxdOA-00050-00015512-00015805 hillsides away from the coast rise
+MbttFVxxdOA-00051-00015806-00016075 enjoys a mild extremely wet climate
+MbttFVxxdOA-00052-00016076-00016279 vulnerable to storms coming off the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00053-00016280-00016462 Black Sea and therefore the surrounding
+MbttFVxxdOA-00054-00016463-00016696 countryside is rich with vegetation and
+MbttFVxxdOA-00055-00016697-00016867 is attracting more and more visitors
+MbttFVxxdOA-00056-00016868-00016977 every year
+MbttFVxxdOA-00057-00016978-00017272 rise is a center for processing and
+MbttFVxxdOA-00058-00017273-00017491 shipping rice tea the tea grown in the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00059-00017492-00017812 surrounding area tea was introduced in
+MbttFVxxdOA-00060-00017813-00018076 the region in the 1940s and 1950s
+MbttFVxxdOA-00061-00018077-00018337 changing the destiny of the region which
+MbttFVxxdOA-00062-00018338-00018658 was desperately poor until then the city
+MbttFVxxdOA-00063-00018659-00018904 has a tea Research Institute founded in
+MbttFVxxdOA-00064-00018905-00019207 1958 and tea gardens of the main site in
+MbttFVxxdOA-00065-00019208-00019534 the town's panoramic view tea and kiwi
+MbttFVxxdOA-00066-00019535-00019765 fruit plants are even planted in gardens
+MbttFVxxdOA-00067-00019766-00020083 around the town the secondary activity
+MbttFVxxdOA-00068-00020084-00020365 is fishing rise is linked by road with
+MbttFVxxdOA-00069-00020366-00020547 traps on 41 miles
+MbttFVxxdOA-00071-00025217-00025764 topic climate
+MbttFVxxdOA-00072-00025766-00026050 Rhys has a humid subtropical climate
+MbttFVxxdOA-00073-00026051-00026379 köppen climate classification CFA
+MbttFVxxdOA-00074-00026380-00026725 snowfall can be heavy once it snows the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00075-00026726-00027007 climate turns continental DFB on the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00076-00027008-00027304 hillsides and subarctic DFC on mountain
+MbttFVxxdOA-00077-00027305-00027568 slopes and Yalies a term used in Turkish
+MbttFVxxdOA-00078-00027569-00027913 for Highlands and Highland plateaus rise
+MbttFVxxdOA-00079-00027914-00028111 in the eastern part of the Black Sea
+MbttFVxxdOA-00080-00028112-00028314 coast where it is situated has the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00081-00028316-00028513 highest precipitation in Western Asia
+MbttFVxxdOA-00082-00028514-00028756 with an annual precipitation averaging
+MbttFVxxdOA-00083-00028757-00029122 around 2,500 millimetres 100 in with
+MbttFVxxdOA-00084-00029123-00029329 heavy rainfall year round and a maximum
+MbttFVxxdOA-00085-00029330-00029586 in late autumn October to December the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00086-00029587-00029872 Black Sea coast receives the greatest
+MbttFVxxdOA-00087-00029873-00030108 amount of precipitation in Turkey and is
+MbttFVxxdOA-00088-00030110-00030322 the only region of Turkey that receives
+MbttFVxxdOA-00089-00030323-00030550 high precipitation throughout the year
+MbttFVxxdOA-00090-00030551-00030823 the water temperature as in the whole
+MbttFVxxdOA-00091-00030824-00031066 Turkish Black Sea coast is always cool
+MbttFVxxdOA-00092-00031067-00031318 fluctuating between 8 and 20 degrees
+MbttFVxxdOA-00093-00031319-00031642 Celsius 46 and 68 degrees Fahrenheit
+MbttFVxxdOA-00094-00031643-00032262 throughout the year
+MbttFVxxdOA-00095-00032263-00032820 topic economy
+MbttFVxxdOA-00096-00032821-00033151 historically rise grew oranges however
+MbttFVxxdOA-00097-00033152-00033400 weather destroyed the crops in the early
+MbttFVxxdOA-00098-00033401-00033666 20th century and the industry declined
+MbttFVxxdOA-00099-00033667-00033997 the area also produced small amounts of
+MbttFVxxdOA-00100-00033998-00034234 manganese the economic structure of rise
+MbttFVxxdOA-00101-00034235-00034486 is based primarily around its geographic
+MbttFVxxdOA-00102-00034487-00034834 location rise is a very mountainous city
+MbttFVxxdOA-00103-00034835-00035092 making industrial development difficult
+MbttFVxxdOA-00104-00035093-00035374 and impractical given the lack of air
+MbttFVxxdOA-00105-00035375-00035593 and rail transit most Goods have to
+MbttFVxxdOA-00106-00035594-00035797 travel by truck or ship which makes
+MbttFVxxdOA-00107-00035798-00036139 exporting and importing difficult Rises
+MbttFVxxdOA-00108-00036140-00036385 primary trading partner is traps on the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00109-00036386-00036610 most developed city of Northeast Black
+MbttFVxxdOA-00110-00036611-00036931 Sea region Rises main exports are
+MbttFVxxdOA-00111-00036932-00037171 agriculturally based tea and kiwi fruit
+MbttFVxxdOA-00112-00037172-00037921 are among its most popular commodities
+MbttFVxxdOA-00113-00037922-00038490 topic education
+MbttFVxxdOA-00114-00038491-00038877 Rize university was founded in 2006 and
+MbttFVxxdOA-00115-00038878-00039063 its name was changed to recep tayyip
+MbttFVxxdOA-00116-00039064-00039357 erdogan university by the university
+MbttFVxxdOA-00117-00039358-00039984 Senate's approval
+MbttFVxxdOA-00118-00039985-00040514 topic culture
+MbttFVxxdOA-00119-00040515-00040823 Rhys Castle a partly ruined medieval
+MbttFVxxdOA-00120-00040824-00041572 castle southwest of the city centre
+MbttFVxxdOA-00121-00041573-00042128 topic sports
+MbttFVxxdOA-00122-00042129-00042425 sports venues in rise arise Ataturk
+MbttFVxxdOA-00123-00042426-00042683 Stadium yeni rise sir her study and rise
+MbttFVxxdOA-00124-00042684-00042932 sports complex consisting of rice Sports
+MbttFVxxdOA-00125-00042933-00043268 Hall and rise indoor swimming pool the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00126-00043269-00043529 football team of K choruses Paul play in
+MbttFVxxdOA-00127-00043530-00043745 the Super League pisar sport football
+MbttFVxxdOA-00128-00043746-00044504 team compete in the tff third league
+MbttFVxxdOA-00129-00044505-00044945 topic history
+MbttFVxxdOA-00130-00044946-00045420 you
+MbttFVxxdOA-00131-00045421-00046038 topic notable natives
+MbttFVxxdOA-00132-00046039-00046347 kazeem Ava's Olympic medalist and world
+MbttFVxxdOA-00133-00046348-00046529 champion in wrestling
+MbttFVxxdOA-00134-00046530-00046944 Zafer burial football player nikos
+MbttFVxxdOA-00135-00046945-00047133 Cappetta nudists journalist and
+MbttFVxxdOA-00136-00047134-00047451 newspaper publisher ibrahim Kollek
+MbttFVxxdOA-00137-00047452-00047732 member of istanbul provincial council
+MbttFVxxdOA-00138-00047733-00048060 recep tayyip erdogan politician former
+MbttFVxxdOA-00139-00048061-00048273 prime minister and current president of
+MbttFVxxdOA-00140-00048274-00048573 turkey Tamil Cottle aeronautical
+MbttFVxxdOA-00141-00048574-00049008 engineer and CEO of Turkish Airlines Tim
+MbttFVxxdOA-00142-00049009-00049338 Jay mater Archie born 1935 convicted
+MbttFVxxdOA-00143-00049339-00049653 former government minister Mehmet Akif
+MbttFVxxdOA-00144-00049654-00049890 Purim Olympic medalist in greco-roman
+MbttFVxxdOA-00145-00049891-00050442 wrestling pokel Tipton politician Ismail
+MbttFVxxdOA-00146-00050443-00050676 turret singer of folk music of the Black
+MbttFVxxdOA-00147-00050677-00051186 Sea region yo-yo Ma's wrestler maze at
+MbttFVxxdOA-00148-00051187-00051411 Yilmaz politician and former prime
+MbttFVxxdOA-00149-00051412-00051636 minister kekua Reza's poor the local
+MbttFVxxdOA-00150-00051637-00051840 football team play in the turkish super
+MbttFVxxdOA-00151-00051841-00052079 league and a local heroes occasionally
+MbttFVxxdOA-00152-00052080-00052272 capable of defeating even the biggest
+MbttFVxxdOA-00153-00052273-00052580 and ball teams they play in green and
+MbttFVxxdOA-00154-00052582-00052794 blue reflecting the blue of the sea and
+MbttFVxxdOA-00155-00052795-00052947 the green of the tea growing on the
+MbttFVxxdOA-00156-00052948-00053352 hillsides others who have never lived in
+MbttFVxxdOA-00157-00053353-00053648 rise but come from rice families include
+MbttFVxxdOA-00158-00053649-00053976 Suzanne Axew singer and songwriter born
+MbttFVxxdOA-00159-00053977-00054179 in Izmir but originally from Pazza
+MbttFVxxdOA-00160-00054180-00054913 rise tarkin pop singer
+MbttFVxxdOA-00161-00054914-00055480 topic population
+MbttFVxxdOA-00162-00055482-00055855 equals equals notes
+McdJgsWznsE-00000-00000112-00000768 [Music]
+McdJgsWznsE-00001-00000769-00001041 food and beverages from China have been
+McdJgsWznsE-00002-00001042-00001248 part of global daily life for over a
+McdJgsWznsE-00003-00001249-00001498 thousand years from soy thoughts and
+McdJgsWznsE-00004-00001499-00001818 noodle to tea and one that many of the
+McdJgsWznsE-00005-00001819-00002052 food and drinks we consume today have
+McdJgsWznsE-00006-00002053-00002343 their origins in China the history of
+McdJgsWznsE-00007-00002344-00002539 food and drink in China is a fascinating
+McdJgsWznsE-00008-00002540-00002806 story that is told through objects in
+McdJgsWznsE-00009-00002807-00003108 the exhibition ancient vessel a visual
+McdJgsWznsE-00010-00003109-00003325 and material history of food and drink
+McdJgsWznsE-00011-00003326-00003645 in China she majored in partnership with
+McdJgsWznsE-00012-00003646-00003838 the museum in East Asian art and math
+McdJgsWznsE-00013-00003839-00004102 who provided the beautiful objects for
+McdJgsWznsE-00014-00004103-00004393 the exhibition ancient vessels opened at
+McdJgsWznsE-00015-00004394-00004609 the Rastas brunei gallery in January
+McdJgsWznsE-00016-00004610-00004924 2020 exhibits state funds were later
+McdJgsWznsE-00017-00004925-00005259 Neolithic period in China circa 2000 BC
+McdJgsWznsE-00018-00005260-00005599 to the 19th century and are made from a
+McdJgsWznsE-00019-00005600-00005868 wide range of material including jade
+McdJgsWznsE-00020-00005869-00006343 Koren lacquer bran and glad the south
+McdJgsWznsE-00021-00006344-00006606 exhibition presents the objects in 11
+McdJgsWznsE-00022-00006608-00006856 different but related themed affection
+McdJgsWznsE-00023-00006856-00007126 through these new interpretations of the
+McdJgsWznsE-00024-00007127-00007405 object viewers can explore historical
+McdJgsWznsE-00025-00007406-00007627 Chinese material culture from a fresh
+McdJgsWznsE-00026-00007628-00007939 perspective and gain an insight into the
+McdJgsWznsE-00027-00007940-00008155 material world of food and drink in
+McdJgsWznsE-00028-00008156-00008560 China before the 20th century the first
+McdJgsWznsE-00029-00008561-00008806 section raising livestock agriculture
+McdJgsWznsE-00030-00008807-00009037 and cooking includes some of the
+McdJgsWznsE-00031-00009038-00009312 earliest objects in the exhibition
+McdJgsWznsE-00032-00009313-00009523 archaeological evidence shows that
+McdJgsWznsE-00033-00009524-00009745 people in China domesticated animals
+McdJgsWznsE-00034-00009746-00010053 from the Neolithic period onward by
+McdJgsWznsE-00035-00010054-00010216 about 4000 BCE
+McdJgsWznsE-00036-00010217-00010452 domestication seemed to be widespread
+McdJgsWznsE-00037-00010453-00010749 among the common animals kept were pig
+McdJgsWznsE-00038-00010750-00010966 which provided a ready source of meat
+McdJgsWznsE-00039-00010967-00011274 and water buffalo that pulled clouds in
+McdJgsWznsE-00040-00011275-00011533 this case for example you can see a
+McdJgsWznsE-00041-00011534-00011809 ceramic model of a pig sty showing a pig
+McdJgsWznsE-00042-00011810-00011953 and piglet
+McdJgsWznsE-00043-00011954-00012212 the two important early crops in China
+McdJgsWznsE-00044-00012213-00012481 rice and millet were more suitable for
+McdJgsWznsE-00045-00012482-00012745 boiling in contrast to wheat and barley
+McdJgsWznsE-00046-00012746-00013055 which could be ground and baked as a
+McdJgsWznsE-00047-00013056-00013274 consequence early Chinese cooking
+McdJgsWznsE-00048-00013275-00013607 vessels such as the ding and Li were
+McdJgsWznsE-00049-00013608-00013841 designed for boiling they have a wide
+McdJgsWznsE-00050-00013841-00014102 body to hold water and food and three
+McdJgsWznsE-00051-00014103-00014450 legs to stand over fire a number of
+McdJgsWznsE-00052-00014451-00014636 cooking vessels have been found in -
+McdJgsWznsE-00053-00014637-00014930 such as those shown here in the section
+McdJgsWznsE-00054-00014931-00015138 on leading spirits
+McdJgsWznsE-00055-00015140-00015355 archaeological evidence indicates that
+McdJgsWznsE-00056-00015356-00015590 people in ancient China believed that
+McdJgsWznsE-00057-00015591-00015752 the Living should replicate the
+McdJgsWznsE-00058-00015753-00016005 lifestyle of the dead in the afterlife
+McdJgsWznsE-00059-00016006-00016313 including catering for their gustatory
+McdJgsWznsE-00060-00016313-00016685 pleasure some elite tombs are decorated
+McdJgsWznsE-00061-00016686-00016946 with murals of banqueting scenes some
+McdJgsWznsE-00062-00016947-00017194 contain a kitchen and food storage room
+McdJgsWznsE-00063-00017195-00017438 accompanied with cooking utensils and
+McdJgsWznsE-00064-00017439-00017744 figurines of chef the inner area jars
+McdJgsWznsE-00065-00017745-00018028 often with fanciful shapes such as this
+McdJgsWznsE-00066-00018029-00018227 large skeleton one in the form of a
+McdJgsWznsE-00067-00018228-00018536 granary was used to store rice and other
+McdJgsWznsE-00068-00018537-00018775 grains to ensure the spirits would not
+McdJgsWznsE-00069-00018776-00019069 be hungry wine vessel such as this
+McdJgsWznsE-00070-00019070-00019330 ceramic example with painted decoration
+McdJgsWznsE-00071-00019331-00019574 used for by the storing and serving
+McdJgsWznsE-00072-00019575-00019991 alcohol were also buried into eating the
+McdJgsWznsE-00073-00019992-00020209 spirit was one way to help maintain the
+McdJgsWznsE-00074-00020210-00020556 bond between the deceased and the living
+McdJgsWznsE-00075-00020557-00020894 whether for the living or dead vessel is
+McdJgsWznsE-00076-00020895-00021083 used for eating and drinking in China
+McdJgsWznsE-00077-00021084-00021392 are usually decorated in this section
+McdJgsWznsE-00078-00021393-00021665 eating and drinking design we can see
+McdJgsWznsE-00079-00021666-00021862 that often the decoration relates to
+McdJgsWznsE-00080-00021863-00022078 their function or to the setting in
+McdJgsWznsE-00081-00022079-00022325 which they are to be used a white
+McdJgsWznsE-00082-00022326-00022537 porcelain bowl in this case shows a
+McdJgsWznsE-00083-00022538-00022862 picnic scene another example the
+McdJgsWznsE-00084-00022863-00023065 decoration on food and drink vessels
+McdJgsWznsE-00085-00023066-00023342 relates to the visual art and is taken
+McdJgsWznsE-00086-00023343-00023558 from narrative illustration that should
+McdJgsWznsE-00087-00023559-00023803 be seen on a large porcelain jar with
+McdJgsWznsE-00088-00023804-00024122 polychrome decoration the banquet scene
+McdJgsWznsE-00089-00024123-00024337 on this jar is typical the lavish ones
+McdJgsWznsE-00090-00024338-00024542 appearing in illustrated books in the
+McdJgsWznsE-00091-00024543-00024788 16th and 17th century
+McdJgsWznsE-00092-00024789-00025034 the banquet here may be a court banquet
+McdJgsWznsE-00093-00025035-00025274 for a festival or commemorative occasion
+McdJgsWznsE-00094-00025275-00025508 as indicated by the senior official
+McdJgsWznsE-00095-00025509-00025756 seated at the table and the musical
+McdJgsWznsE-00096-00025757-00026063 entertainment the card laughter tray in
+McdJgsWznsE-00097-00026064-00026300 this case depicts a similar event taking
+McdJgsWznsE-00098-00026301-00026564 place in an elegant storied building in
+McdJgsWznsE-00099-00026564-00026885 a watery landscape scenes like this were
+McdJgsWznsE-00100-00026886-00027110 often reproduced in popular prints and
+McdJgsWznsE-00101-00027111-00027401 pictorial album during the late Ming and
+McdJgsWznsE-00102-00027402-00027695 Qing dynasties in other examples
+McdJgsWznsE-00103-00027695-00027938 symbolic food items formed the main
+McdJgsWznsE-00104-00027939-00028199 decorative motif such as the peach on
+McdJgsWznsE-00105-00028200-00028469 the small ceramic dish imitating lacquer
+McdJgsWznsE-00106-00028470-00028682 which is a traditional symbol of
+McdJgsWznsE-00107-00028683-00029060 longevity associated with Taoism here it
+McdJgsWznsE-00108-00029061-00029249 is accompanied by the Chinese character
+McdJgsWznsE-00109-00029250-00029636 for long life shown at the next section
+McdJgsWznsE-00110-00029637-00029894 which explores rituals and politics
+McdJgsWznsE-00111-00029895-00030197 demonstrates many bronze vessels cast in
+McdJgsWznsE-00112-00030198-00030488 the Shang and Joe Dynasty that is from
+McdJgsWznsE-00113-00030489-00030998 about 1500 BC to 221 BC were used in
+McdJgsWznsE-00114-00030999-00031223 rituals for offering food and wine to
+McdJgsWznsE-00115-00031224-00031469 ancestors from whom ancient Chinese
+McdJgsWznsE-00116-00031470-00031694 people obtained help and direction in
+McdJgsWznsE-00117-00031695-00031744 life
+McdJgsWznsE-00118-00031745-00032014 large numbers of various vessel types
+McdJgsWznsE-00119-00032016-00032231 suggest that many different foods and
+McdJgsWznsE-00120-00032232-00032504 wines were available through a system of
+McdJgsWznsE-00121-00032505-00032702 etiquette the vessel is used to feed
+McdJgsWznsE-00122-00032702-00032933 ritual feasts came to play an important
+McdJgsWznsE-00123-00032934-00033113 role in governing relation and
+McdJgsWznsE-00124-00033114-00033398 reinforcing hierarchies in early Chinese
+McdJgsWznsE-00125-00033399-00033686 society the political symbolism of these
+McdJgsWznsE-00126-00033687-00033902 food vessel particularly that of the
+McdJgsWznsE-00127-00033903-00034115 littered bronze ding shown in its case
+McdJgsWznsE-00128-00034116-00034430 is still important today this is
+McdJgsWznsE-00129-00034431-00034589 demonstrated by the bronze ding
+McdJgsWznsE-00130-00034590-00034727 commissioned by the Chinese government
+McdJgsWznsE-00131-00034728-00035084 in 2010 that is now on permanent display
+McdJgsWznsE-00132-00035085-00035290 at the Great Hall of the people of
+McdJgsWznsE-00133-00035291-00035582 Beijing Chinese rulers also
+McdJgsWznsE-00134-00035583-00035801 traditionally made sacrificial offering
+McdJgsWznsE-00135-00035802-00036077 into the Sun on the spring equinox which
+McdJgsWznsE-00136-00036078-00036374 since the Ming Dynasty from the 14 to
+McdJgsWznsE-00137-00036375-00036668 the 17th century required red offering
+McdJgsWznsE-00138-00036669-00036881 vessels like the porcelain stem cup
+McdJgsWznsE-00139-00036882-00037037 shown here
+McdJgsWznsE-00140-00037038-00037260 Bethel's are an integral part of
+McdJgsWznsE-00141-00037261-00037496 religious practice in China as the
+McdJgsWznsE-00142-00037497-00037683 object in this section on religion
+McdJgsWznsE-00143-00037684-00037992 reveal but the three main belief systems
+McdJgsWznsE-00144-00037993-00038310 prevalent in China with ism Taoism and
+McdJgsWznsE-00145-00038311-00038570 Confucianism it is Buddhism that
+McdJgsWznsE-00146-00038571-00038827 requires vessels for many of its rituals
+McdJgsWznsE-00147-00038828-00039155 food was offered on trays to deities and
+McdJgsWznsE-00148-00039156-00039449 in begging bowls to monks the small
+McdJgsWznsE-00149-00039450-00039743 sculptures in this case show a monk with
+McdJgsWznsE-00150-00039744-00040029 a begging bowl in addition to figures
+McdJgsWznsE-00151-00040030-00040277 Buddhist imagery appears on a number of
+McdJgsWznsE-00152-00040278-00040565 vessels not all of which were used in
+McdJgsWznsE-00153-00040566-00040886 religious context on the lacus dem cap
+McdJgsWznsE-00154-00040887-00041096 in this case you can see the popular
+McdJgsWznsE-00155-00041097-00041387 motif of the eight Buddhist emblem which
+McdJgsWznsE-00156-00041388-00041604 originated in early Buddhist virtual
+McdJgsWznsE-00157-00041605-00041883 culture in South Asia and then became
+McdJgsWznsE-00158-00041884-00042045 part of the decorative repertoire in
+McdJgsWznsE-00159-00042046-00042380 China during the Tang Dynasty from 618
+McdJgsWznsE-00160-00042381-00042740 to 906 other belief systems are
+McdJgsWznsE-00161-00042741-00042954 represented by their symbolism such as
+McdJgsWznsE-00162-00042955-00043170 the red pomegranate painted on the white
+McdJgsWznsE-00163-00043171-00043421 porcelain stem Bowl which has many seeds
+McdJgsWznsE-00164-00043422-00043692 and is associated with the Confucian
+McdJgsWznsE-00165-00043693-00044012 wish for many son the bronze offerings
+McdJgsWznsE-00166-00044013-00044258 down below this has a 28 character
+McdJgsWznsE-00167-00044259-00044499 inscription on its foot which notes it
+McdJgsWznsE-00168-00044500-00044861 was made in 1485 for use in a Confucian
+McdJgsWznsE-00169-00044862-00045249 temple the next section on imperial
+McdJgsWznsE-00170-00045250-00045515 dining presents tableware made for the
+McdJgsWznsE-00171-00045516-00045795 Chinese Court during the Ming and Qing
+McdJgsWznsE-00172-00045796-00046151 dynasties from the 14th century to the
+McdJgsWznsE-00173-00046152-00046430 very early 20th century the scale of
+McdJgsWznsE-00174-00046431-00046617 infrastructure needed to provide food
+McdJgsWznsE-00175-00046618-00046829 for the imperial court was in men's
+McdJgsWznsE-00176-00046830-00047057 there were different kitchens and
+McdJgsWznsE-00177-00047058-00047235 offices responsible for the supply of
+McdJgsWznsE-00178-00047236-00047507 ingredients the preparation of meals and
+McdJgsWznsE-00179-00047508-00047745 the maintenance of dinner services and
+McdJgsWznsE-00180-00047746-00048074 utensils the use of food vessels which
+McdJgsWznsE-00181-00048075-00048395 strictly regulated and hierarchical for
+McdJgsWznsE-00182-00048396-00048636 example in this case we can see plates
+McdJgsWznsE-00183-00048637-00048885 covered with yellow glades both on the
+McdJgsWznsE-00184-00048886-00049196 interior and exterior that were reserved
+McdJgsWznsE-00185-00049197-00049505 for the Emperor and the Empress we can
+McdJgsWznsE-00186-00049506-00049704 also see plates decorated with green
+McdJgsWznsE-00187-00049705-00049943 dragons on a yellow ground that were
+McdJgsWznsE-00188-00049944-00050230 used by lower ranking concubines
+McdJgsWznsE-00189-00050231-00050415 more informal
+McdJgsWznsE-00190-00050416-00050646 is represented in the next section which
+McdJgsWznsE-00191-00050647-00050874 explores snacks and light meals in
+McdJgsWznsE-00192-00050875-00051165 pre-modern China there was no dessert a
+McdJgsWznsE-00193-00051166-00051369 sweet course that comes at the end of a
+McdJgsWznsE-00194-00051370-00051645 meal sweet and savory snacks could be
+McdJgsWznsE-00195-00051646-00051904 served alongside main dishes or consumed
+McdJgsWznsE-00196-00051904-00052162 outside a proper meal at any time of the
+McdJgsWznsE-00197-00052163-00052500 day compartmented boxes in plate such as
+McdJgsWznsE-00198-00052501-00052753 the one shown in this case we used to
+McdJgsWznsE-00199-00052754-00052990 present snacks or serve light meals as
+McdJgsWznsE-00200-00052991-00053181 they ensure that a variety of choices
+McdJgsWznsE-00201-00053182-00053488 could be offered at the same time they
+McdJgsWznsE-00202-00053489-00053750 were also practical when picnicking
+McdJgsWznsE-00203-00053751-00054040 during the lunar year when spring rolls
+McdJgsWznsE-00204-00054041-00054276 were traditionally eaten various
+McdJgsWznsE-00205-00054277-00054444 ingredients to be wrapped in thin
+McdJgsWznsE-00206-00054445-00054615 pancakes would be placed in different
+McdJgsWznsE-00207-00054616-00054925 compartments these types of boxes and
+McdJgsWznsE-00208-00054926-00055131 plates can also help make a selection of
+McdJgsWznsE-00209-00055132-00055326 snacks or a light meal with variants
+McdJgsWznsE-00210-00055327-00055684 element look visually coherent snacks
+McdJgsWznsE-00211-00055685-00055891 and light meals were consumed along with
+McdJgsWznsE-00212-00055891-00056140 hot beverages including tea which is the
+McdJgsWznsE-00213-00056141-00056400 focus of this section tea has been
+McdJgsWznsE-00214-00056401-00056625 produced and consumed in China since at
+McdJgsWznsE-00215-00056626-00056959 least the fifth century BC 2000 year old
+McdJgsWznsE-00216-00056960-00057154 tea leaves were recently discovered in
+McdJgsWznsE-00217-00057154-00057354 the tomb of an emperor who died in
+McdJgsWznsE-00218-00057355-00057699 one-for-one BC from the 8th century AD
+McdJgsWznsE-00219-00057700-00057975 tea drinking became much more widespread
+McdJgsWznsE-00220-00057976-00058234 after its promotion as both an aid to
+McdJgsWznsE-00221-00058235-00058530 meditation by Buddhist monks as well as
+McdJgsWznsE-00222-00058532-00058692 an antidote to the drunkenness
+McdJgsWznsE-00223-00058694-00059011 associated with wine the objects in this
+McdJgsWznsE-00224-00059012-00059248 case represent a range of vessels to use
+McdJgsWznsE-00225-00059249-00059479 in the consumption of tea we're serving
+McdJgsWznsE-00226-00059479-00059844 drinking and storage in China tea was
+McdJgsWznsE-00227-00059845-00060097 often sold along with tea vessels such
+McdJgsWznsE-00228-00060098-00060330 as the brownstone where bowls shown here
+McdJgsWznsE-00229-00060332-00060531 which were made in the tea producing
+McdJgsWznsE-00230-00060532-00060711 region of junk sheep robbing in
+McdJgsWznsE-00231-00060712-00061024 southeast China from the late Ming
+McdJgsWznsE-00232-00061025-00061279 Dynasty tea pots with short spouts and
+McdJgsWznsE-00233-00061279-00061500 tall handles were made in his unique
+McdJgsWznsE-00234-00061501-00061779 brown stoneware clay which is only found
+McdJgsWznsE-00235-00061780-00062070 in eating and jeongsu problem
+McdJgsWznsE-00236-00062071-00062279 these sangria is made with this clay
+McdJgsWznsE-00237-00062280-00062616 such as the teapot in this case became
+McdJgsWznsE-00238-00062616-00062736 highly sought-after
+McdJgsWznsE-00239-00062737-00062940 and are still admired today for their
+McdJgsWznsE-00240-00062941-00063176 ability to enhance the flavor of tea in
+McdJgsWznsE-00241-00063177-00063501 the Qin Dynasty the channel Emperor who
+McdJgsWznsE-00242-00063502-00063929 reigned from 1736 to 1795 noted that
+McdJgsWznsE-00243-00063930-00064134 jade bowls such as the example shown
+McdJgsWznsE-00244-00064135-00064367 here would used to serve butter tea
+McdJgsWznsE-00245-00064369-00064578 which is a completely different tea
+McdJgsWznsE-00246-00064579-00064925 tradition during celebratory ceremonies
+McdJgsWznsE-00247-00064926-00065286 in contrast to tea wine and alcoholic
+McdJgsWznsE-00248-00065287-00065487 drinks have an even longer history in
+McdJgsWznsE-00249-00065488-00065790 China in this section we learned that
+McdJgsWznsE-00250-00065791-00065973 the earliest evidence of wine production
+McdJgsWznsE-00251-00065974-00066243 in China exists from a Neolithic period
+McdJgsWznsE-00252-00066244-00066507 and was found in pottery jars dating to
+McdJgsWznsE-00253-00066508-00066656 7,000 BC
+McdJgsWznsE-00254-00066657-00066969 wine made from both grain and crepes was
+McdJgsWznsE-00255-00066970-00067191 used in both virtual and secular setting
+McdJgsWznsE-00256-00067192-00067482 and is recorded in numerous early texts
+McdJgsWznsE-00257-00067483-00067899 from the Shang period circa 1500 BCE to
+McdJgsWznsE-00258-00067900-00068235 circa 1046 onward wine vessels made of
+McdJgsWznsE-00259-00068236-00068484 cast bronze like the large jar in this
+McdJgsWznsE-00260-00068485-00068793 case were buried in elite tomb along
+McdJgsWznsE-00261-00068794-00069057 with similar vessels for food it is
+McdJgsWznsE-00262-00069058-00069294 during the next dynasty the Jo period
+McdJgsWznsE-00263-00069295-00069510 that the first test denouncing
+McdJgsWznsE-00264-00069511-00069804 drunkenness start to appear yet wine
+McdJgsWznsE-00265-00069805-00069993 continued to be an important drink in
+McdJgsWznsE-00266-00069994-00070218 China and vessels made in areas that
+McdJgsWznsE-00267-00070219-00070485 produce wine like the cream-colored
+McdJgsWznsE-00268-00070486-00070757 stemware bottle shown here were made
+McdJgsWznsE-00269-00070758-00071037 alongside wine and used in everyday life
+McdJgsWznsE-00270-00071038-00071334 and drinking establishment in the sung
+McdJgsWznsE-00271-00071335-00071787 period from 960 to 1279 AD wine was
+McdJgsWznsE-00272-00071788-00072048 drunk warm and served from corsola newer
+McdJgsWznsE-00273-00072049-00072315 and it was drunk from Cortland cups such
+McdJgsWznsE-00274-00072316-00072534 as this one which were passed around in
+McdJgsWznsE-00275-00072535-00072828 a stand wine cups were also made in
+McdJgsWznsE-00276-00072829-00073106 other materials in Chinese poetry
+McdJgsWznsE-00277-00073107-00073356 numerous references to wine can be found
+McdJgsWznsE-00278-00073357-00073631 often praising the drinking of wine from
+McdJgsWznsE-00279-00073632-00073866 cups made for precious material like
+McdJgsWznsE-00280-00073867-00074286 jade as can be seen here wine and tea
+McdJgsWznsE-00281-00074287-00074478 were not the only liquids consumed in
+McdJgsWznsE-00282-00074479-00074650 traditional China as
+McdJgsWznsE-00283-00074651-00074884 in this section on condiments and other
+McdJgsWznsE-00284-00074885-00075181 liquid in the Song Dynasty tax the
+McdJgsWznsE-00285-00075182-00075454 ejecta from the 12th century it was
+McdJgsWznsE-00286-00075455-00075726 stated that there were seven essential
+McdJgsWznsE-00287-00075727-00075985 things for every family namely firewood
+McdJgsWznsE-00288-00075986-00076431 rice oil salt soy sauce paste vinegar
+McdJgsWznsE-00289-00076432-00076747 and tea with the long history of soy
+McdJgsWznsE-00290-00076748-00076962 cultivation in China it is not
+McdJgsWznsE-00291-00076963-00077163 surprising that soy sauce known as
+McdJgsWznsE-00292-00077164-00077451 johnnyo in Chinese is first mentioned in
+McdJgsWznsE-00293-00077452-00077850 a Chinese text from a tomb dated 168 BC
+McdJgsWznsE-00294-00077851-00078087 which knows that it was prepared as a
+McdJgsWznsE-00295-00078088-00078373 paste and remains of this were found in
+McdJgsWznsE-00296-00078374-00078715 that same tomb as today soy sauce
+McdJgsWznsE-00297-00078716-00078888 traditionally were served from small
+McdJgsWznsE-00298-00078889-00079162 Ewers or pots like the turquoise example
+McdJgsWznsE-00299-00079163-00079419 in this case which were also used to
+McdJgsWznsE-00300-00079420-00079762 serve vinegar salt was another important
+McdJgsWznsE-00301-00079763-00079965 addition to cooking for seasoning and
+McdJgsWznsE-00302-00079966-00080230 fermentation and its cultivation made
+McdJgsWznsE-00303-00080231-00080605 many family very wealthy in the mid as
+McdJgsWznsE-00304-00080606-00080884 today it was served in small pots such
+McdJgsWznsE-00305-00080885-00081225 as the enamel one shown here the final
+McdJgsWznsE-00306-00081226-00081462 section of the exhibition foodstuffs and
+McdJgsWznsE-00307-00081463-00081709 medicine explorers medicinal foods in
+McdJgsWznsE-00308-00081710-00081940 China there is no essential difference
+McdJgsWznsE-00309-00081941-00082246 between foodstuffs and medicine it would
+McdJgsWznsE-00310-00082247-00082441 widely recognized that a balanced diet
+McdJgsWznsE-00311-00082442-00082624 had the ability to prevent disease
+McdJgsWznsE-00312-00082625-00082869 promote longevity and help treat
+McdJgsWznsE-00313-00082870-00083140 existing condition the famous physician
+McdJgsWznsE-00314-00083141-00083392 sun zoom al active in the seventh
+McdJgsWznsE-00315-00083393-00083662 century believed that the truly good
+McdJgsWznsE-00316-00083663-00083884 physician first treats the patient with
+McdJgsWznsE-00317-00083885-00084148 food only when food failed does he
+McdJgsWznsE-00318-00084149-00084478 resort to drugs rhinoceros horn such as
+McdJgsWznsE-00319-00084479-00084690 the carved Cup in this case for example
+McdJgsWznsE-00320-00084691-00084940 would lead to treat a variety of
+McdJgsWznsE-00321-00084941-00085204 ailments including fever rheumatism and
+McdJgsWznsE-00322-00085205-00085543 gout snuff with tobacco as the main
+McdJgsWznsE-00323-00085544-00085837 ingredient was used to expel cold sheer
+McdJgsWznsE-00324-00085838-00086125 dizziness and treat headaches storied
+McdJgsWznsE-00325-00086126-00086329 and exquisite small bottles like those
+McdJgsWznsE-00326-00086330-00086550 shown here tobacco was in fact
+McdJgsWznsE-00327-00086551-00086793 classified as a type of alcohol in the
+McdJgsWznsE-00328-00086794-00087067 Qin Dynasty because if a person consumed
+McdJgsWznsE-00329-00087068-00087322 too many pots of tobacco smoke he would
+McdJgsWznsE-00330-00087323-00087541 quote fall down drunk and it will take a
+McdJgsWznsE-00331-00087542-00087949 long time to revive him this brings us
+McdJgsWznsE-00332-00087950-00088048 to the end of the
+McdJgsWznsE-00333-00088049-00088261 submission it'sh stories like those
+McdJgsWznsE-00334-00088262-00088476 recounted in this exhibition that bring
+McdJgsWznsE-00335-00088477-00088756 museum objects to light and in the case
+McdJgsWznsE-00336-00088757-00089032 of ancient vessels we have reminded that
+McdJgsWznsE-00337-00089033-00089232 museum exhibits can play an important
+McdJgsWznsE-00338-00089233-00089494 role in recreating the material worlds
+McdJgsWznsE-00339-00089495-00089666 of our past
+McdJgsWznsE-00340-00089667-00090006 [Music]
+McdJgsWznsE-00341-00090007-00090213 you
+McB9pg72uoU-00000-00000007-00000284 the electric power industry covers the
+McB9pg72uoU-00001-00000285-00000530 generation transmission distribution and
+McB9pg72uoU-00002-00000531-00000709 sale of electric power to the general
+McB9pg72uoU-00003-00000710-00000947 public in industry the commercial
+McB9pg72uoU-00004-00000948-00001150 distribution of electric power started
+McB9pg72uoU-00005-00001151-00001397 in 1882 when electricity was produced
+McB9pg72uoU-00006-00001398-00001684 for electric lighting in the 1880s and
+McB9pg72uoU-00007-00001685-00001922 1890s growing economic and safety
+McB9pg72uoU-00008-00001923-00002114 concerns lead to the regulation of the
+McB9pg72uoU-00009-00002115-00002368 industry once an expensive novelty
+McB9pg72uoU-00010-00002369-00002509 limited to the most densely populated
+McB9pg72uoU-00011-00002510-00002789 areas reliable and economical electric
+McB9pg72uoU-00012-00002790-00002992 power has become an essential aspect for
+McB9pg72uoU-00013-00002993-00003160 normal operation of all elements of
+McB9pg72uoU-00014-00003161-00003443 developed economies by the middle of the
+McB9pg72uoU-00015-00003444-00003686 20th century electricity was seen as a
+McB9pg72uoU-00016-00003686-00003986 natural monopoly only efficient if a
+McB9pg72uoU-00017-00003986-00004172 restricted number of organizations
+McB9pg72uoU-00018-00004173-00004411 participated in the market in some areas
+McB9pg72uoU-00019-00004412-00004619 vertically integrated companies provide
+McB9pg72uoU-00020-00004620-00004847 all stages from generation to retail and
+McB9pg72uoU-00021-00004848-00005063 only governmental supervision regulated
+McB9pg72uoU-00022-00005064-00005266 the rate of return and cost structure
+McB9pg72uoU-00023-00005267-00005611 since the 1990s many regions have opened
+McB9pg72uoU-00024-00005612-00005786 up the generation and distribution of
+McB9pg72uoU-00025-00005787-00005945 electric power to provide a more
+McB9pg72uoU-00026-00005946-00006197 competitive electricity market while
+McB9pg72uoU-00027-00006198-00006356 such markets can be abusively
+McB9pg72uoU-00028-00006357-00006542 manipulated with consequent adverse
+McB9pg72uoU-00029-00006543-00006721 price and reliability impact to
+McB9pg72uoU-00030-00006722-00006889 consumers generally competitive
+McB9pg72uoU-00031-00006890-00007081 production of electrical energy leads to
+McB9pg72uoU-00032-00007083-00007264 worthwhile improvements in efficiency
+McB9pg72uoU-00033-00007265-00007495 however transmission and distribution
+McB9pg72uoU-00034-00007497-00007723 are harder problem since returns on
+McB9pg72uoU-00035-00007725-00008474 investment are not as easy to find topic
+McB9pg72uoU-00036-00008475-00009056 history although electricity had been
+McB9pg72uoU-00037-00009057-00009235 known to be produced as a result of the
+McB9pg72uoU-00038-00009236-00009439 chemical reactions that take place in an
+McB9pg72uoU-00039-00009440-00009664 electrolytic cell since Alessandro Volta
+McB9pg72uoU-00040-00009665-00009920 developed the voltaic pile in 1800 its
+McB9pg72uoU-00041-00009921-00010117 production by this means was and still
+McB9pg72uoU-00042-00010118-00010469 is expensive in 1831 michael faraday
+McB9pg72uoU-00043-00010470-00010663 devised a machine that generated
+McB9pg72uoU-00044-00010664-00010862 electricity from rotary motion but it
+McB9pg72uoU-00045-00010863-00011012 took almost 50 years for the technology
+McB9pg72uoU-00046-00011013-00011348 to reach a commercially viable stage in
+McB9pg72uoU-00047-00011349-00011671 1878 in the United States Thomas Edison
+McB9pg72uoU-00048-00011672-00011839 developed and sold a commercially viable
+McB9pg72uoU-00049-00011840-00012023 replacement for gas lighting and heating
+McB9pg72uoU-00050-00012024-00012194 using locally generated and distributed
+McB9pg72uoU-00051-00012195-00012542 direct current electricity the world's
+McB9pg72uoU-00052-00012543-00012742 first public electricity supply was
+McB9pg72uoU-00053-00012743-00012988 provided in late 1881 when the streets
+McB9pg72uoU-00054-00012989-00013151 of the Surrey town of God or me in the
+McB9pg72uoU-00055-00013152-00013372 UK were lit with electric light
+McB9pg72uoU-00056-00013374-00013544 this system was powered from a water
+McB9pg72uoU-00057-00013544-00013712 wheel on the river way which drove a
+McB9pg72uoU-00058-00013713-00013880 Siemens alternator that supplied a
+McB9pg72uoU-00059-00013881-00014147 number of arc lamps within the town this
+McB9pg72uoU-00060-00014147-00014381 supply scheme also provided electricity
+McB9pg72uoU-00061-00014382-00014563 to a number of shops and premises to
+McB9pg72uoU-00062-00014565-00014872 light 34 incandescent Swan light bulbs
+McB9pg72uoU-00063-00014872-00015065 additionally Robert Hammond Indiana
+McB9pg72uoU-00064-00015066-00015344 December 1881 demonstrated the new
+McB9pg72uoU-00065-00015344-00015518 electric light in the Sussex town of
+McB9pg72uoU-00066-00015519-00015703 Brighton in the UK for a trial period
+McB9pg72uoU-00067-00015704-00015962 the ensuing success of this installation
+McB9pg72uoU-00068-00015963-00016172 enabled Hammond to put this venture on
+McB9pg72uoU-00069-00016172-00016355 both a commercial and legal footing as a
+McB9pg72uoU-00070-00016356-00016556 number of shop owners wanted to use the
+McB9pg72uoU-00071-00016557-00016793 new electric light thus the Hammond
+McB9pg72uoU-00072-00016794-00017009 electricity supply Co was launched
+McB9pg72uoU-00073-00017010-00017189 whilst the god--all Ming and Holborn
+McB9pg72uoU-00074-00017190-00017417 viaduct schemes closed after a few years
+McB9pg72uoU-00075-00017418-00017609 the Brighton scheme continued on and
+McB9pg72uoU-00076-00017610-00017927 supply was in 1887 made available for 24
+McB9pg72uoU-00077-00017928-00018305 hours per day in early 1882 Edison
+McB9pg72uoU-00078-00018306-00018476 opened the world's first steam powered
+McB9pg72uoU-00079-00018477-00018659 electricity generating station at
+McB9pg72uoU-00080-00018660-00018866 Holborn viaduct in London where he had
+McB9pg72uoU-00081-00018867-00019022 entered into an agreement with the City
+McB9pg72uoU-00082-00019023-00019202 Corporation for a period of three months
+McB9pg72uoU-00083-00019203-00019499 to provide street lighting in time he
+McB9pg72uoU-00084-00019500-00019700 had supplied a number of local consumers
+McB9pg72uoU-00085-00019701-00019961 with electric light the method of supply
+McB9pg72uoU-00086-00019962-00020315 was direct current DC it was later on in
+McB9pg72uoU-00087-00020316-00020546 the year in September 1882 that Edison
+McB9pg72uoU-00088-00020547-00020753 opened the pole street power station in
+McB9pg72uoU-00089-00020754-00020936 New York City and again it was a DC
+McB9pg72uoU-00090-00020937-00021182 supply it was for this reason that the
+McB9pg72uoU-00091-00021183-00021350 generation was closed tor on the
+McB9pg72uoU-00092-00021351-00021554 consumers premises as Edison had no
+McB9pg72uoU-00093-00021555-00021818 means of voltage conversion the voltage
+McB9pg72uoU-00094-00021819-00022013 chosen for any electrical system is a
+McB9pg72uoU-00095-00022014-00022241 compromise for a given amount of power
+McB9pg72uoU-00096-00022242-00022406 transmitted increasing the voltage
+McB9pg72uoU-00097-00022407-00022565 reduces the current and therefore
+McB9pg72uoU-00098-00022566-00022831 reduces the required wire thickness
+McB9pg72uoU-00099-00022832-00023036 unfortunately it also increases the
+McB9pg72uoU-00100-00023037-00023258 danger from direct contact and increases
+McB9pg72uoU-00101-00023259-00023455 the required insulation thickness
+McB9pg72uoU-00102-00023456-00023675 furthermore some load types were
+McB9pg72uoU-00103-00023676-00023846 difficult or impossible to make work
+McB9pg72uoU-00104-00023847-00024134 with higher voltages the overall effect
+McB9pg72uoU-00105-00024135-00024320 was that Edison's system required power
+McB9pg72uoU-00106-00024321-00024497 stations to be within a mile of the
+McB9pg72uoU-00107-00024498-00024758 consumers while this could work in city
+McB9pg72uoU-00108-00024759-00024893 centers it would be unable to
+McB9pg72uoU-00109-00024894-00025112 economically supply suburbs with power
+McB9pg72uoU-00110-00025113-00025313 the mid to late 1880s saw the
+McB9pg72uoU-00111-00025314-00025499 introduction of alternating current AC
+McB9pg72uoU-00112-00025500-00025747 systems in Europe and the USA sea Power
+McB9pg72uoU-00113-00025748-00025949 had an advantage in that transformers
+McB9pg72uoU-00114-00025950-00026152 installed at power stations could be
+McB9pg72uoU-00115-00026154-00026300 used to raise the voltage from the
+McB9pg72uoU-00116-00026301-00026501 generators and transformers at local
+McB9pg72uoU-00117-00026502-00026687 substations could reduce voltage to
+McB9pg72uoU-00118-00026688-00026808 supply low
+McB9pg72uoU-00119-00026810-00027023 increasing the voltage reduced the
+McB9pg72uoU-00120-00027024-00027155 current in the transmission and
+McB9pg72uoU-00121-00027156-00027350 distribution lines and hence the size of
+McB9pg72uoU-00122-00027351-00027626 conductors and distribution losses this
+McB9pg72uoU-00123-00027627-00027812 made it more economical to distribute
+McB9pg72uoU-00124-00027813-00028070 power over long distances generators
+McB9pg72uoU-00125-00028070-00028268 such as hydroelectric sites could be
+McB9pg72uoU-00126-00028269-00028580 located far from the Lodz AC and DC
+McB9pg72uoU-00127-00028581-00028787 competed for a while during a period
+McB9pg72uoU-00128-00028788-00029087 called the war of currents the DC system
+McB9pg72uoU-00129-00029088-00029264 was able to claim slightly greater
+McB9pg72uoU-00130-00029264-00029462 safety but this difference was not great
+McB9pg72uoU-00131-00029463-00029606 enough to overwhelm the enormous
+McB9pg72uoU-00132-00029607-00029783 technical and economic advantages of
+McB9pg72uoU-00133-00029783-00029969 alternating current which eventually won
+McB9pg72uoU-00134-00029970-00030344 out the AC power system used today
+McB9pg72uoU-00135-00030345-00030512 developed rapidly backed by
+McB9pg72uoU-00136-00030513-00030664 industrialists such as George
+McB9pg72uoU-00137-00030666-00030839 Westinghouse with Michael dole Evo
+McB9pg72uoU-00138-00030839-00031136 dobrovolsky galileo ferraris Sebastien's
+McB9pg72uoU-00139-00031137-00031361 eonni de fer auntie Lucy and Guillard
+McB9pg72uoU-00140-00031362-00031595 John Dickson Gibbs karl wilhelm siemens
+McB9pg72uoU-00141-00031595-00031850 William Stanley jr. Nikola Tesla and
+McB9pg72uoU-00142-00031851-00032138 others contributed to this field while
+McB9pg72uoU-00143-00032139-00032395 high-voltage direct-current HVDC is
+McB9pg72uoU-00144-00032397-00032588 increasingly being used to transmit
+McB9pg72uoU-00145-00032589-00032768 large quantities of electricity over
+McB9pg72uoU-00146-00032769-00032984 long distances or to connect adjacent
+McB9pg72uoU-00147-00032985-00033185 asynchronous power systems the bulk of
+McB9pg72uoU-00148-00033186-00033353 electricity generation transmission
+McB9pg72uoU-00149-00033354-00033605 distribution and retailing takes place
+McB9pg72uoU-00150-00033606-00034388 using alternating current topic market
+McB9pg72uoU-00151-00034389-00034928 reform the business model behind the
+McB9pg72uoU-00152-00034929-00035120 electric utility has changed over the
+McB9pg72uoU-00153-00035121-00035291 years playing a vital role in shaping
+McB9pg72uoU-00154-00035292-00035504 the electricity industry into what it is
+McB9pg72uoU-00155-00035505-00035681 today from generation transmission
+McB9pg72uoU-00156-00035682-00035924 distribution to the final local
+McB9pg72uoU-00157-00035925-00036170 retailing this has occurred prominently
+McB9pg72uoU-00158-00036171-00036350 since the reform of the electricity
+McB9pg72uoU-00159-00036351-00036548 supply industry in England and Wales in
+McB9pg72uoU-00160-00036549-00036866 1990 in some countries wholesale
+McB9pg72uoU-00161-00036867-00037046 electricity markets operate with
+McB9pg72uoU-00162-00037047-00037217 generators and retailers trading
+McB9pg72uoU-00163-00037218-00037373 electricity in a similar manner to
+McB9pg72uoU-00164-00037374-00037667 shares and currency as deregulation
+McB9pg72uoU-00165-00037668-00037874 continues further utilities are driven
+McB9pg72uoU-00166-00037875-00038033 to sell their assets as the energy
+McB9pg72uoU-00167-00038034-00038195 market follows in line with the gas
+McB9pg72uoU-00168-00038196-00038384 market in use of the futures and spot
+McB9pg72uoU-00169-00038385-00038585 markets and other financial arrangements
+McB9pg72uoU-00170-00038586-00038837 even globalization with foreign
+McB9pg72uoU-00171-00038838-00038969 purchasers are taking place
+McB9pg72uoU-00172-00038970-00039212 one such purchase was when the UK's
+McB9pg72uoU-00173-00039213-00039404 National Grid the largest private
+McB9pg72uoU-00174-00039405-00039605 electric utility in the world bought New
+McB9pg72uoU-00175-00039606-00039806 England's electric system for 3.2
+McB9pg72uoU-00176-00039807-00040121 billion dollars between 1995
+McB9pg72uoU-00177-00040122-00040367 in 1997 seven of the 12 regional
+McB9pg72uoU-00178-00040368-00040616 electric companies re seized in England
+McB9pg72uoU-00179-00040617-00040793 and Wales were bought by US energy
+McB9pg72uoU-00180-00040794-00041090 companies domestically local electric
+McB9pg72uoU-00181-00041091-00041309 and gas firms have merged operations as
+McB9pg72uoU-00182-00041310-00041456 they saw the advantages of joint
+McB9pg72uoU-00183-00041457-00041651 affiliation especially with the reduced
+McB9pg72uoU-00184-00041652-00041927 cost of joint metering technological
+McB9pg72uoU-00185-00041928-00042089 advances will take place in the
+McB9pg72uoU-00186-00042090-00042281 competitive wholesale electric markets
+McB9pg72uoU-00187-00042282-00042500 such examples already being utilized
+McB9pg72uoU-00188-00042501-00042728 include fuel cells used in Space Flight
+McB9pg72uoU-00189-00042729-00042968 aero derivative gas turbines used in jet
+McB9pg72uoU-00190-00042969-00043142 aircraft solar engineering and
+McB9pg72uoU-00191-00043143-00043391 photovoltaic systems offshore wind farms
+McB9pg72uoU-00192-00043392-00043586 and the communication advances spawned
+McB9pg72uoU-00193-00043587-00043772 by the digital world particularly with
+McB9pg72uoU-00194-00043773-00043937 micro processing which aids in
+McB9pg72uoU-00195-00043938-00044138 monitoring and dispatching electricity
+McB9pg72uoU-00196-00044139-00044327 is expected to see growing demand in the
+McB9pg72uoU-00197-00044328-00044594 future the information revolution is
+McB9pg72uoU-00198-00044595-00044816 highly reliant on electric power other
+McB9pg72uoU-00199-00044817-00045014 growth areas include emerging new
+McB9pg72uoU-00200-00045015-00045212 electricity exclusive technologies
+McB9pg72uoU-00201-00045213-00045398 developments in space conditioning
+McB9pg72uoU-00202-00045399-00045638 industrial processes and transportation
+McB9pg72uoU-00203-00045639-00046372 for example hybrid vehicles locomotives
+McB9pg72uoU-00204-00046373-00047045 topic organization the electric power
+McB9pg72uoU-00205-00047046-00047249 industry is commonly split up into four
+McB9pg72uoU-00206-00047250-00047471 processors these are electricity
+McB9pg72uoU-00207-00047472-00047651 generations such as a power station
+McB9pg72uoU-00208-00047652-00047903 electric power transmission electricity
+McB9pg72uoU-00209-00047904-00048092 distribution and electricity retailing
+McB9pg72uoU-00210-00048093-00048347 in many countries electric power
+McB9pg72uoU-00211-00048348-00048536 companies own the whole infrastructure
+McB9pg72uoU-00212-00048537-00048746 from generating stations to transmission
+McB9pg72uoU-00213-00048747-00049001 and distribution infrastructure for this
+McB9pg72uoU-00214-00049002-00049190 reason electric power is viewed as a
+McB9pg72uoU-00215-00049191-00049442 natural monopoly the industry is
+McB9pg72uoU-00216-00049443-00049634 generally heavily regulated often with
+McB9pg72uoU-00217-00049635-00049793 price controls in is frequently
+McB9pg72uoU-00218-00049794-00050054 government owned and operated however
+McB9pg72uoU-00219-00050055-00050204 the modern trend has been growing
+McB9pg72uoU-00220-00050205-00050408 deregulation in at least the latter two
+McB9pg72uoU-00221-00050409-00050630 processes the nature and state of market
+McB9pg72uoU-00222-00050631-00050819 reform of the electricity market often
+McB9pg72uoU-00223-00050820-00050990 determines whether electric companies
+McB9pg72uoU-00224-00050991-00051170 are able to be involved in just some of
+McB9pg72uoU-00225-00051171-00051332 these processes without having to own
+McB9pg72uoU-00226-00051333-00051539 the entire infrastructure or citizens
+McB9pg72uoU-00227-00051540-00051658 choose which components of
+McB9pg72uoU-00228-00051659-00051938 infrastructure to patronize in countries
+McB9pg72uoU-00229-00051939-00052088 where electricity provision is
+McB9pg72uoU-00230-00052089-00052325 deregulated end users of electricity may
+McB9pg72uoU-00231-00052326-00053026 opt for more costly green electricity
+McB9pg72uoU-00232-00053027-00053629 topic generation all forms of
+McB9pg72uoU-00233-00053629-00053848 electricity generation have positive and
+McB9pg72uoU-00234-00053849-00053963 negative aspects
+McB9pg72uoU-00235-00053964-00054151 technology will probably eventually
+McB9pg72uoU-00236-00054152-00054379 declare the most preferred forms but in
+McB9pg72uoU-00237-00054379-00054576 a market economy the options with less
+McB9pg72uoU-00238-00054577-00054775 overall costs generally will be chosen
+McB9pg72uoU-00239-00054776-00055029 above other sources it is not clear yet
+McB9pg72uoU-00240-00055030-00055198 which form can best meet the necessary
+McB9pg72uoU-00241-00055199-00055447 energy demands or which process can best
+McB9pg72uoU-00242-00055448-00055704 solve the demand for electricity there
+McB9pg72uoU-00243-00055705-00055863 are indications that renewable energy
+McB9pg72uoU-00244-00055864-00056071 and distributed generation are becoming
+McB9pg72uoU-00245-00056072-00056374 more viable in economic terms a diverse
+McB9pg72uoU-00246-00056375-00056596 mix of generation sources reduces the
+McB9pg72uoU-00247-00056597-00057361 risks of electricity price spikes topic
+McB9pg72uoU-00248-00057362-00057951 world electricity industries the
+McB9pg72uoU-00249-00057952-00058165 organization of the electrical sector of
+McB9pg72uoU-00250-00058166-00058375 a country or region varies depending on
+McB9pg72uoU-00251-00058376-00058621 the economic system of the country in
+McB9pg72uoU-00252-00058622-00058804 some places all electric power
+McB9pg72uoU-00253-00058804-00058992 generation transmission and distribution
+McB9pg72uoU-00254-00058994-00059224 is provided by a government controlled
+McB9pg72uoU-00255-00059225-00059517 organization other regions have private
+McB9pg72uoU-00256-00059519-00059749 or investor owned utility companies city
+McB9pg72uoU-00257-00059750-00059899 or municipally owned companies
+McB9pg72uoU-00258-00059900-00060088 cooperative companies owned by their own
+McB9pg72uoU-00259-00060089-00060400 customers or combinations generation
+McB9pg72uoU-00260-00060401-00060588 transmission and distribution may be
+McB9pg72uoU-00261-00060589-00060790 offered by a single company or different
+McB9pg72uoU-00262-00060791-00060976 organizations may provide each of these
+McB9pg72uoU-00263-00060977-00061356 portions of the system equals equals see
+McB9pg72uoU-00264-00061357-00061597 also
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00000-00000000-00000335 I found it really interesting that we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00001-00000336-00000548 have been talking about three rather
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00002-00000549-00000815 different things first artery's talked
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00003-00000816-00001211 about open data helping people make the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00004-00001212-00001547 most of open data then Terry talked
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00005-00001548-00002174 about open information that is the the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00006-00002175-00002396 transparency that's required to actually
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00007-00002397-00002624 exercise your your right to free speech
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00008-00002625-00002900 and then at the end we had you who
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00009-00002901-00003142 talked about open innovation and it
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00010-00003143-00003356 really struck me that although you come
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00011-00003357-00003679 from maybe three different directions
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00012-00003679-00003965 you're all talking about openness in a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00013-00003965-00004247 very broad sense and it seems to me that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00014-00004248-00004420 you're all calling for the three kind
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00015-00004421-00004663 the same kind of ingredients in order to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00016-00004664-00004910 make this work first you said Therese
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00017-00004911-00005174 that we have moved from thinking about
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00018-00005175-00005522 open data as an end in itself and now we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00019-00005523-00005788 should really shift our focus to make it
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00020-00005789-00005977 more like a tool and that is really
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00021-00005978-00006097 important to think about it in a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00022-00006098-00006361 strategic way you you you actually said
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00023-00006362-00006587 that originally it seemed that people
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00024-00006588-00006970 would open up data in order to to hope
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00025-00006972-00007226 for serendipity to you know come up with
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00026-00007227-00007456 with great solutions out of the blue but
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00027-00007458-00007699 it's it's probably better to have some
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00028-00007700-00007859 kind of strategy and to be clear what
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00029-00007859-00008027 kind of problems you're trying to solve
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00030-00008028-00008330 and it it occurred to me that you're all
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00031-00008331-00008524 talking about requirements in terms of a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00032-00008525-00008816 an open mindset lots and lots of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00033-00008817-00009056 collaboration you Terry talked about the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00034-00009057-00009323 fact that you actually try to help the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00035-00009324-00009514 government authorities that may struggle
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00036-00009515-00009853 because now more people actually request
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00037-00009854-00010142 documents and and obviously you're a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00038-00010143-00010337 connector you're trying to bring people
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00039-00010338-00010508 together for them to collaborate you're
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00040-00010509-00010663 all talking about that the time and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00041-00010664-00011035 effort required and somehow you're all
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00042-00011036-00011246 talking about money some of you would
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00043-00011247-00011453 probably call it funding hopefully you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00044-00011454-00011876 will you will say profit could could you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00045-00011877-00012224 did you have any sort of perspectives on
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00046-00012225-00012413 each other's presentations in terms of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00047-00012414-00012551 these things because you come from
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00048-00012552-00012685 different directions but you're all
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00049-00012686-00013111 talking about the same thing basically
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00050-00013112-00013283 [Music]
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00051-00013284-00013480 yeah maybe I'll have a reflection on the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00052-00013481-00013718 industry hack presentation I find it
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00053-00013719-00013943 quite interesting that companies are so
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00054-00013944-00014258 interested in opening up and sharing a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00055-00014259-00014458 lot of their information in their data
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00056-00014459-00014690 with startups that they haven't met yet
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00057-00014691-00014893 and I think it kind of shows that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00058-00014894-00015191 companies see a value in openness and in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00059-00015191-00015469 sharing and an open innovation which we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00060-00015470-00015625 see as well at the ODI with the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00061-00015626-00016111 accelerators rerun is it difficult for
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00062-00016112-00016325 you to convince those companies to kind
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00063-00016326-00016502 of move towards that open innovation
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00064-00016503-00016685 concept or do you see a lot of interest
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00065-00016686-00016928 coming from them I think kind of like
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00066-00016929-00017183 it's it's it's starting to starting get
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00067-00017184-00017360 there and I think it's sort of like
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00068-00017361-00017578 important also to you know they study
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00069-00017579-00017708 they are not really opening that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00070-00017709-00017950 publicly so they are not that busy
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00071-00017951-00018283 sensitive data is not there I mean the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00072-00018284-00018433 kind of like in the open but what does
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00073-00018434-00018619 kind of like you talked about this
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00074-00018620-00018847 closed shared and open it's somewhere in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00075-00018848-00019025 the kind of like shared on it's it's
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00076-00019026-00019196 shared to a specific group of people
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00077-00019197-00019444 that it's kind of like a sort of view
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00078-00019445-00019628 within every challenge there is sort of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00079-00019629-00019900 this confidentially circle that all the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00080-00019901-00020093 companies and people who are they they
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00081-00020094-00020278 are kind of accept the terms that we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00082-00020279-00020459 talk real things but we don't really
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00083-00020460-00020666 disclose those to the third-party and I
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00084-00020667-00020844 think that's an important sort of like a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00085-00020845-00021221 step maybe becoming even more open in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00086-00021222-00021386 the future but if we start to take that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00087-00021387-00021583 okay now you actually have to open your
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00088-00021584-00021767 for example manufacturing process data
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00089-00021768-00022022 open it open to to anybody then kind of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00090-00022023-00022178 like it's that that's not the way to go
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00091-00022179-00022343 but exactly kind of building slowly the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00092-00022344-00022558 capabilities and the ladder to to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00093-00022559-00022747 benefit more and more of the openness
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00094-00022748-00022961 but I think it's to answer your
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00095-00022962-00023108 questions more and more and more
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00096-00023109-00023252 companies are starting to be ready and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00097-00023253-00023474 understanding the value of this more
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00098-00023475-00023636 open collaboration but of course some
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00099-00023637-00023858 companies are still logging more behind
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00100-00023859-00024715 than than others because both of you are
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00101-00024716-00025297 are helping different startups in in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00102-00025298-00025675 your own ways and I mean in both your
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00103-00025676-00025965 presentations you you you touch upon
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00104-00025966-00026276 many different groups that you are in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00105-00026277-00026554 touch with
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00106-00026555-00027073 open open data is somehow this the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00107-00027074-00027561 working material for all of this but
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00108-00027562-00027795 both of you also obviously must
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00109-00027797-00028048 encounter a lot of negotiations and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00110-00028049-00028449 possibly tough discussions on
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00111-00028450-00028885 intellectual rights around how how to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00112-00028886-00029127 monetize on this raw material which
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00113-00029128-00029407 which we all want and we all use and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00114-00029408-00030135 analyze well I haven't been working on
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00115-00030136-00030582 on that arena I'm very curious on your
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00116-00030583-00030846 perspectives on on these initial
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00117-00030847-00031120 discussions between what is open and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00118-00031120-00031498 free what is such unique utilization of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00119-00031499-00031789 this raw material that somebody
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00120-00031789-00031987 specifically can monetize on it and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00121-00031988-00032412 nobody else could could you bring some
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00122-00032413-00032640 some experiences from the start of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00123-00032641-00033082 negotiations yeah I think like it
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00124-00033083-00033315 depends of course a bit on the what is
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00125-00033316-00033483 the data if it's the kind of data shared
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00126-00033484-00033736 by the initial company about kind of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00127-00033737-00033877 like their processes it is of course
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00128-00033878-00034135 their their IP n and and and and sort of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00129-00034136-00034279 then it's about the kind of like
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00130-00034280-00034480 negotiate with the startup how to how to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00131-00034481-00034626 monetize it how to connect that with
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00132-00034627-00034798 then the IP that the startup has created
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00133-00034799-00034962 within within the challenge and I'm kind
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00134-00034963-00035086 of like that's exactly the kind of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00135-00035087-00035314 touching point that how to find the the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00136-00035315-00035520 mutual agreement to to go forward and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00137-00035521-00035751 for example we've tried to easin up that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00138-00035752-00035958 processing in creating templates also
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00139-00035959-00036310 form in within the format from the legal
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00140-00036311-00036445 perspective that you know this is
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00141-00036446-00036757 actually the standard terms how how you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00142-00036758-00036967 participate and this is how what what we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00143-00036968-00037324 usually do and kind of like instead of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00144-00037325-00037524 starting to really kind of like dig into
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00145-00037525-00037714 the deep legal departments of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00146-00037715-00037890 corporations are starting to kind of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00147-00037891-00038104 like find the solution from there but
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00148-00038105-00038314 rather develop something from experience
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00149-00038315-00038539 and then iterated when whenever whenever
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00150-00038540-00038782 needed so that's maybe one one angle to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00151-00038783-00039157 try to tackle the tackle the issue yeah
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00152-00039158-00039420 I agree and kind of following up on
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00153-00039421-00039679 points raised earlier that companies and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00154-00039680-00039868 government increasingly severe
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00155-00039869-00040198 an openness and an open innovation on
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00156-00040199-00040360 one of the startup accelerators
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00157-00040361-00040513 rerunning currently which is called data
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00158-00040514-00040786 pitch we actually connect businesses
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00159-00040787-00040975 that want to solve a particular
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00160-00040976-00041365 challenge and provide data with startups
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00161-00041366-00041572 to help solve that challenge so kind of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00162-00041573-00041839 highlighting that direct benefit to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00163-00041840-00042172 opening your data helps in bringing that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00164-00042173-00042469 argument across I guess you could talk
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00165-00042470-00042712 about a wider discussion of whether data
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00166-00042713-00042976 is a raw material like any other where
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00167-00042977-00043282 there's actually clear ownership if I
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00168-00043283-00043519 make a phone call to you who owns the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00169-00043520-00043690 data is at me because I'm making the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00170-00043691-00043876 call is that the company that makes the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00171-00043877-00044035 connection is it you because you're
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00172-00044036-00044383 receiving we tend to not think as data
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00173-00044384-00044641 of being owned by one specific
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00174-00044642-00044857 organizational person but rather focus
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00175-00044858-00045055 around how that data is being managed
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00176-00045056-00045331 and used maybe one actually we had an
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00177-00045332-00045475 interesting discussion before entering
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00178-00045476-00045706 the yeah this this this room with one of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00179-00045707-00045868 the persons in the in the audience about
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00180-00045869-00046117 I talked the company called Viner who is
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00181-00046118-00046342 actually aggregating a lot of open data
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00182-00046343-00046558 from different sources and sort of like
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00183-00046559-00046759 making a tool for people to search
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00184-00046760-00046969 knowledge about companies and they've
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00185-00046970-00047227 actually grown very fast I think which
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00186-00047228-00047386 is something hundred fifty people our
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00187-00047387-00047599 organization within three years so
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00188-00047600-00047872 really growing fast and heavily based
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00189-00047873-00048118 basting the business model on on on the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00190-00048119-00048382 data that is openly available so that's
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00191-00048383-00048571 also I think an interesting perspective
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00192-00048572-00049033 in the in the discussion it could pose I
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00193-00049034-00049282 think some interesting dilemmas this the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00194-00049283-00049462 openness of the data but then the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00195-00049463-00049735 closeness of of the profits that you may
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00196-00049736-00049993 make from data or the insights that you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00197-00049994-00050236 get from data or whatever and I think
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00198-00050237-00050443 it's interesting that now you're seated
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00199-00050444-00050623 in the middle Terrier and and you're
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00200-00050624-00050905 actually working boy you're not working
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00201-00050906-00051130 in a kind of closed bubble because as
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00202-00051131-00051315 you said in the beginning your paper
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00203-00051316-00051598 needs funding to you have made in soon
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00204-00051599-00051844 dot you know because you wanted to make
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00205-00051845-00052114 this kind of of information this kind of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00206-00052115-00052377 tool available to the world and you had
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00207-00052378-00052579 a question did that act that did that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00208-00052579-00052864 actually increase traffic on your
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00209-00052865-00053086 newspaper website because obviously we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00210-00053087-00053258 all realize that even if you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00211-00053259-00053380 doing a lot of this for ideological
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00212-00053382-00053651 reasons you still need to live and you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00213-00053652-00053888 can only be an investigative journalist
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00214-00053889-00054248 if somebody pays your bills so what do
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00215-00054249-00054419 you think about that in terms of the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00216-00054420-00054638 freedom of speech the right to to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00217-00054639-00054860 information and the money side of things
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00218-00054861-00055066 and I also touched a partner on that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00219-00055067-00055211 when I asked you the other way around
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00220-00055212-00055532 that do public authorities get upset
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00221-00055533-00055790 when when you ask them so many questions
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00222-00055791-00055985 and they have to allocate funds to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00223-00055986-00056225 actually respond to these requests which
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00224-00056226-00056591 are you know you're covered by law you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00225-00056591-00056885 have the right to ask but you know could
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00226-00056886-00057116 it be that these this money that they
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00227-00057116-00057299 spend trying to answer your question
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00228-00057300-00057446 could be spent on something better
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00229-00057447-00057788 and there's another dilemma there so how
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00230-00057789-00058250 do you feel about the money side well I
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00231-00058251-00058625 I have my job as a as a journalist what
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00232-00058626-00058886 I'm always struggling for is it's the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00233-00058887-00059080 resource which is the developer that I'm
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00234-00059082-00059336 cooperating with he has other tasks as
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00235-00059337-00059605 well of course we all need good coders
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00236-00059607-00059861 for different purposes so there is a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00237-00059862-00060746 resource side since we made our tool
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00238-00060747-00061334 free it did encourage cooperation we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00239-00061335-00061565 gave it away to our competitors some of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00240-00061566-00061820 our competitors came back and said this
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00241-00061821-00062123 is wonderful can we help you so we are a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00242-00062124-00062408 commercial newspaper owned by shipstead
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00243-00062409-00062603 which is also a big media company here
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00244-00062604-00063004 in Sweden the Public Broadcasting
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00245-00063005-00063404 Corporation came and said can we help
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00246-00063404-00063803 you and that that doesn't happen we are
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00247-00063804-00064208 supposed to be enemies okay so we did
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00248-00064209-00064754 did encourage some some some some some
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00249-00064754-00065282 good new connections in a short term
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00250-00065283-00065534 I see no income perspective for what we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00251-00065535-00065945 do at indirectly only hoping that it
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00252-00065946-00066334 will improve journalism in the future
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00253-00066335-00066556 maybe
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00254-00066557-00066875 we will keep the services we have now
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00255-00066876-00067247 open and free but maybe on top of that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00256-00067248-00067466 we can build something because we are
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00257-00067467-00067724 making a big database with struct
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00258-00067725-00068021 structured information on the document
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00259-00068022-00068366 flow in public sector and as that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00260-00068367-00068567 material grows and gets better
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00261-00068568-00068921 maybe that is worth something to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00262-00068922-00069298 government maybe we could build a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00263-00069299-00069653 subscription that you can be notified
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00264-00069654-00069929 when when there are documents that you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00265-00069930-00070316 might be specifically interested in this
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00266-00070317-00070526 is a hint you might want to send a FOIA
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00267-00070527-00071017 for this document because our data grows
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00268-00071018-00071366 and maybe that at least can can pay some
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00269-00071367-00071555 of the bills because my local newspaper
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00270-00071556-00072025 is now taking most of the bill and then
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00271-00072026-00072479 stiffness in Quito which is a charity is
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00272-00072480-00072833 paying some of it yeah but what you're
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00273-00072834-00073022 basically saying that all of you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00274-00073023-00073205 actually when when you start to throw
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00275-00073206-00073622 open in in the mix sometimes magic for
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00276-00073623-00073832 want of a better word starts happening
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00277-00073833-00073994 because people will actually come to you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00278-00073995-00074207 and say can we be part of this can we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00279-00074208-00074876 contribute somehow but but I think in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00280-00074877-00075239 the long term a project is viable if it
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00281-00075240-00075515 solves the problem if it doesn't solve a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00282-00075516-00075653 problem it doesn't have the right to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00283-00075654-00076133 live if it solves a problem it may find
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00284-00076134-00076415 a way to live here do you think it's a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00285-00076416-00076796 good measure of the sort of the the size
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00286-00076797-00077036 of the problem it solves is whether or
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00287-00077037-00077204 not people are willing to pay for it
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00288-00077205-00077402 because you know it may solve a problem
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00289-00077403-00077585 but if people are not willing in the end
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00290-00077586-00077834 to pay something for it it may just be a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00291-00077835-00078119 nice to have and not a need to have even
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00292-00078120-00078257 though I think most of us would agree
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00293-00078258-00078485 that actually having the tools to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00294-00078486-00078701 exercise our right to freedom of speech
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00295-00078702-00078944 is not just a nice to have it's
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00296-00078945-00079124 definitely a need to have but do we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00297-00079125-00079469 realize that on a daily basis I wouldn't
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00298-00079470-00079700 necessarily say that it's based on the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00299-00079701-00079895 amount that users pay for it one of the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00300-00079896-00079928 exact
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00301-00079929-00080143 as I mentioned with citymapper and it's
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00302-00080144-00080362 a completely free application anyone can
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00303-00080363-00080731 use it and it's easy and it's free and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00304-00080732-00080930 it's very helpful in its solving a very
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00305-00080931-00081118 big problems I don't think necessarily
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00306-00081119-00081512 you can measure it based on that I think
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00307-00081513-00081700 what businesses are realizing as well as
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00308-00081701-00081962 that release date the value isn't
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00309-00081963-00082219 necessarily in the data itself but in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00310-00082220-00082391 the analytics and any insights that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00311-00082392-00082553 you're getting from that data and that's
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00312-00082554-00082709 where the value comes in and I think
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00313-00082710-00082955 we're realizing that shift a little bit
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00314-00082956-00083216 and with that realization the open
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00315-00083217-00083491 culture is growing a little bit as well
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00316-00083492-00083743 actually Therese you talked about the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00317-00083744-00084007 the need not just for data scientists
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00318-00084008-00084248 and data science skills but a lot more
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00319-00084249-00084524 perhaps for a data literacy so that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00320-00084525-00084761 everybody should be able to understand
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00321-00084762-00085075 at least the basics of of data I see you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00322-00085076-00085330 nodding - yeah I'm not surprised I was
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00323-00085331-00085547 just wondering do you see that there's a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00324-00085548-00085790 general shift towards that towards an
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00325-00085791-00085961 understanding that this is not just
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00326-00085962-00086261 about tech startups this is not just
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00327-00086262-00086450 about grassroots who wants to do
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00328-00086451-00086618 something open for the sake of being
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00329-00086619-00086943 open or very sort of idealistic
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00330-00086944-00087301 investigative journalists who will you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00331-00087302-00087455 know do things in their spare time
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00332-00087456-00087631 because they think it's the right thing
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00333-00087632-00087787 to do do you think there's a shift
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00334-00087788-00087994 towards the the idea that this is
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00335-00087995-00088225 something we should all somehow embrace
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00336-00088226-00088468 and we all have a responsibility to to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00337-00088469-00088735 promote it well I think so I think
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00338-00088736-00089003 things are happening and we need to kind
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00339-00089004-00089267 of catch up with it because data affects
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00340-00089268-00089435 all of us and the way data is used
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00341-00089436-00089660 effects the way our lives are being
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00342-00089661-00089948 designed and we need to learn to keep up
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00343-00089949-00090130 with it I'm always amazed now when I go
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00344-00090131-00090262 on Facebook and there are advertisements
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00345-00090263-00090605 on the side every advertisement is so
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00346-00090606-00090775 interesting to me it used to be that I
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00347-00090776-00090941 buy a pair of shoes and then they put
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00348-00090942-00091130 the same pair of shoes and I already
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00349-00091131-00091312 bottoms or know things but now
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00350-00091313-00091687 everything is just tailored for me and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00351-00091688-00091922 in a way that's amazing because it's
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00352-00091923-00092176 very useful but in the other hand that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00353-00092177-00092401 means that my bubble is shrinking and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00354-00092402-00092563 shrinking so I think we're all
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00355-00092564-00092771 confronted with data and the impacts of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00356-00092772-00092960 data every day and so we need to learn
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00357-00092961-00093197 and understand those impacts to react to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00358-00093198-00093275 them
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00359-00093276-00093392 agreed and I think it was a great
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00360-00093393-00093563 question from the audience about the Tao
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00361-00093564-00093800 how is this actually teach to the future
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00362-00093801-00093968 generations and how is the kind of like
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00363-00093969-00094166 how are we helping to you to shape the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00364-00094167-00094328 mindset of the kind of what future
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00365-00094329-00094535 makers that how do they understand a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00366-00094536-00094697 winner will understand the change
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00367-00094698-00095072 because in any case the change won't we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00368-00095073-00095261 will become faster and faster all the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00369-00095262-00095408 time and really I think it's it's
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00370-00095409-00095765 important to to sort of like be be aware
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00371-00095766-00096071 and and be aboard and sort of also take
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00372-00096072-00096287 the responsibility responsibility of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00373-00096288-00096452 making our future generations to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00374-00096453-00097103 understand it as well I think we all
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00375-00097104-00097298 have a responsibility but we can't all
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00376-00097299-00097700 do the same I think I will try to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00377-00097701-00098105 encourage my kids to learn code to my
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00378-00098106-00098585 parents maybe that's a bit too late but
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00379-00098586-00098870 but I'll still spend time giving them
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00380-00098871-00099134 examples given them stories how this is
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00381-00099135-00099533 relevant so that I understand it so that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00382-00099534-00099755 they participate in the debates around
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00383-00099756-00100253 around it because they still do but but
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00384-00100254-00100442 in the end when we're not all going to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00385-00100443-00100682 be programmers somebody is going to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00386-00100683-00101012 drive that truck and a good programmer
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00387-00101013-00101462 made that guy's day easier somebody is
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00388-00101463-00101675 going to drive trains at least some of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00389-00101676-00101810 the trains will still be driven by
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00390-00101811-00102323 people for a while and somebody must
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00391-00102324-00102539 construct and assign it so so we're not
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00392-00102540-00102971 all going to be IT people but we need to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00393-00102972-00103298 understand it and encourage the use of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00394-00103299-00103673 all of this now you represent three
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00395-00103674-00103885 different countries what what are your
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00396-00103886-00104141 impressions of what's being done to make
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00397-00104142-00104351 sure that younger generations actually
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00398-00104352-00104683 if not grow up understanding this but at
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00399-00104684-00104864 least have some chance of grasping
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00400-00104865-00105041 what's going on around them and grasping
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00401-00105042-00105398 the importance of of paying attention to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00402-00105399-00105851 these kind of things well in Finland
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00403-00105852-00106078 areas are different kind of initiatives
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00404-00106079-00106376 for example one to my mind one that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00405-00106377-00106556 comes to my mind is is it's called me
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00406-00106557-00106664 Hackett which is kind of like
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00407-00106665-00106979 all about teaching the high school kids
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00408-00106980-00107213 they're kind of very basics on beat
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00409-00107214-00107375 coding on being creating something
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00410-00107376-00107504 visual or really kind of like just
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00411-00107505-00107642 understanding the opportunities and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00412-00107643-00107828 possibilities of technology and I think
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00413-00107829-00107975 it was good with what you said that it's
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00414-00107976-00108158 it's not about making everyone like a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00415-00108158-00108467 deep deep understanding and and doer of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00416-00108468-00108731 that kind of like very very hardcore
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00417-00108732-00108902 tech but really understanding the basics
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00418-00108903-00109094 and and tying it to the concept context
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00419-00109095-00109325 of of sort of like a normal life is
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00420-00109326-00109664 super super important and if we say look
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00421-00109665-00109904 of fighting like university students at
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00422-00109905-00110086 the moment if we take 10 years back no
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00423-00110088-00110209 one was even thinking about
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00424-00110210-00110372 entrepreneurship but actually doing
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00425-00110373-00110594 something their own as a viable option
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00426-00110595-00110750 but they were looking for very different
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00427-00110751-00110879 directions and now if you're going to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00428-00110880-00111034 ask from the freshmen that are they
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00429-00111035-00111278 aspiring to maybe you know make a great
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00430-00111279-00111422 impact and build something of their own
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00431-00111423-00111632 80% raises their hands so it's kind of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00432-00111633-00111866 like also the demerged shift and culture
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00433-00111867-00112108 shift what has been a pretty pretty
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00434-00112109-00112424 pretty big unexperienced in female at
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00435-00112425-00112598 least but I think it's touching them the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00436-00112599-00112868 whole area of knowledge and world even
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00437-00112869-00113549 what kind of like still yeah I think the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00438-00113550-00113816 important thing is to highlight the fact
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00439-00113817-00114038 that it's not just for technology and to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00440-00114039-00114167 make it tangible and to make it
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00441-00114168-00114409 approachable to younger kids I think in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00442-00114410-00114647 a way they might find it easier because
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00443-00114648-00114821 they grow up with these challenges and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00444-00114822-00115067 if we understand them then we can teach
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00445-00115068-00115271 them as well but I think a lot of work
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00446-00115272-00115814 still needs to be done well the role of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00447-00115815-00116057 the journalist is easier here we can
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00448-00116058-00116225 find the good stories about this and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00449-00116226-00116536 write them and thereby spread awareness
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00450-00116538-00116801 on how this can be used in in sound
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00451-00116802-00117527 manners so I I'll try to do that and try
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00452-00117528-00117704 to encourage some of my colleagues to do
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00453-00117705-00118141 the same it's good stuff to read about I
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00454-00118142-00118408 think you mentioned Therese that some of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00455-00118409-00118595 your friends know exactly what you're
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00456-00118596-00118730 talking about when you talk about your
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00457-00118731-00118892 jobs but you always know people who have
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00458-00118893-00119105 absolutely no idea of what what open
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00459-00119106-00119375 data is about is the thing like perhaps
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00460-00119376-00119531 that's what you're suggesting tell you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00461-00119532-00119798 that sometimes we shouldn't talk about
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00462-00119799-00119951 open data we should talk about the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00463-00119952-00120101 things that we can do now that we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00464-00120102-00120365 a digital world that we tend to either
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00465-00120366-00120632 talk about the digital world in very
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00466-00120633-00120833 abstract sense or we talk very
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00467-00120833-00121043 specifically about open data and that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00468-00121044-00121253 sort of naturally excludes a lot of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00469-00121254-00121433 people who think well that's the sort of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00470-00121433-00121568 thing that you talk about if you're a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00471-00121569-00121913 geek or something at least it was my
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00472-00121914-00122086 impression from when I worked in the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00473-00122088-00122246 Danish government that it was pretty
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00474-00122247-00122495 much either-or we talked about digital
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00475-00122496-00122678 society as a whole and then we talked
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00476-00122679-00122873 about open data and that had a lot to do
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00477-00122874-00123082 with hackathons and data portals and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00478-00123083-00123385 developers full stop sometimes we threw
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00479-00123386-00123854 in the word innovation but often not so
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00480-00123855-00124009 you're talking again about you're
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00481-00124010-00124256 defining the problem or you know making
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00482-00124257-00124589 it useful in a broader sense yeah
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00483-00124590-00124984 totally I mean open data is great just
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00484-00124985-00125192 in itself because it gives us access to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00485-00125193-00125405 information but it only really becomes
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00486-00125406-00125659 valuable when it's being used and in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00487-00125660-00125980 reality from our startup incubation
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00488-00125981-00126206 programs we see that jobs are being
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00489-00126207-00126446 created we see that new industries are
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00490-00126447-00126674 being developed we see new products that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00491-00126675-00126851 make people's lives easier so there are
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00492-00126852-00127118 tangible results that are linked to open
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00493-00127119-00127352 data and it's worth talking about them
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00494-00127353-00127538 and highlighting them and understanding
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00495-00127539-00127763 open data as an important ingredient to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00496-00127764-00128096 make that happen I think and it's about
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00497-00128097-00128276 the kind of like the outcome and data
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00498-00128277-00128453 what is the impact you want to achieve
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00499-00128454-00128699 and what's kind of like sort of where
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00500-00128700-00128846 are we aiming and then what kind of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00501-00128847-00129050 tools are we using to actually aim to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00502-00129051-00129211 that and I think open data provides a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00503-00129213-00129527 very very interesting opportunities for
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00504-00129528-00129665 that but it's just kind of like it's
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00505-00129666-00129968 it's it's one tool among many others so
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00506-00129969-00130163 in a way like it's it's sort of like
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00507-00130164-00130384 thinking of what what what is wanted to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00508-00130385-00130589 be achieve and then then kind of like I
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00509-00130590-00130775 use is the best knowledge and best
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00510-00130776-00131027 resources possible to go there towards
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00511-00131028-00132041 that when I I try it wasn't necessary in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00512-00132042-00132299 this audience to use a picture of me
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00513-00132300-00132503 with the paper piles but it was
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00514-00132504-00132896 necessary to communicate with with my
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00515-00132897-00133055 parents
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00516-00133056-00133490 and their friends in the neighborhood in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00517-00133491-00133877 my hometown why on earth are we doing
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00518-00133878-00134234 this we we had to be very concrete we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00519-00134235-00134537 had to show the problem and then provide
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00520-00134538-00134717 the solution in order to create an
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00521-00134718-00135077 understanding on what can be done with
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00522-00135078-00135827 these tools and all all of your
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00523-00135828-00136172 innovators I assume are solving one or
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00524-00136173-00136697 more concrete problems so the more those
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00525-00136698-00136907 stories are told and visualized in easy
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00526-00136908-00137228 ways that awareness will will will
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00527-00137229-00137510 spread the storytelling plays an
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00528-00137511-00137717 important part here definitely I agree
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00529-00137718-00137987 and that's why I liked the picture
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00530-00137988-00138167 actually because it showed clearly you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00531-00138168-00138350 are facing a problem and you were trying
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00532-00138351-00138581 to find a solution for it and in my
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00533-00138582-00138806 experience that usually is how things
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00534-00138807-00139043 happen so it's not someone who's a coder
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00535-00139044-00139376 and thinks what could I code it's more
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00536-00139377-00139616 that people do things and they face a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00537-00139617-00139808 challenge and they find a solution for
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00538-00139809-00140084 that and yeah definitely it's very
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00539-00140085-00140258 important to communicate those success
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00540-00140259-00140774 ORS well and I have been asked so many
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00541-00140775-00140963 times I don't even know how many times
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00542-00140964-00141242 what kind of impact can we expect from
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00543-00141243-00141449 opening up data or opening up
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00544-00141450-00141689 information or even just opening up our
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00545-00141690-00141914 processes to allow other people to come
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00546-00141915-00142127 in contribute to our innovation and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00547-00142128-00142408 that's why I was so happy to see that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00548-00142409-00142664 you actually include some numbers on
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00549-00142665-00142925 that I know the ODI has been very good
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00550-00142926-00143153 at trying to quantify what kind of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00551-00143154-00143390 change are we actually trying to make
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00552-00143391-00143597 here and and how does it work and also
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00553-00143598-00143858 you you actually showed how many teams
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00554-00143859-00144080 did you did you have to go through the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00555-00144081-00144269 the challenges how many challenges did
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00556-00144270-00144458 you have and how many many prototypes
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00557-00144459-00144683 and products did you get out in the end
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00558-00144684-00144935 because apart from telling stories to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00559-00144936-00145163 people who may not be interested in in
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00560-00145164-00145415 sort of the data the nitty-gritty parts
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00561-00145416-00145517 of the data itself
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00562-00145518-00145784 I suppose it's also important to you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00563-00145785-00145946 know in order to get funding to show
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00564-00145947-00146201 that you're not just having fun I mean
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00565-00146202-00146336 it is I hope you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00566-00146337-00146498 having fun it sounds like you're having
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00567-00146499-00146675 fun and I hope that that also goes for
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00568-00146676-00147026 for everybody here but you're actually
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00569-00147027-00147188 making some kind of change there's an
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00570-00147189-00147566 impact and you can somehow quantify the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00571-00147567-00147785 impact and say well if we didn't open up
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00572-00147786-00147983 this data or if we didn't help these
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00573-00147984-00148181 people in this way this would not have
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00574-00148182-00148382 been possible like that you can show
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00575-00148383-00148646 that you could not have written some of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00576-00148647-00148829 the stories that you wanted to write you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00577-00148830-00149003 could not have exposed what was really
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00578-00149004-00149249 going on if you didn't have access to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00579-00149250-00149543 searchable records rather than piles and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00580-00149544-00149894 piles of paper do you think there's a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00581-00149895-00150158 there's a challenge in in finding the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00582-00150159-00150383 right way to document that this actually
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00583-00150384-00151403 makes a difference in in my case you can
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00584-00151404-00151864 quantify it by FOIA request sent or
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00585-00151865-00152594 stories written to keep it in in in the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00586-00152595-00153641 in the media sector but I personally get
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00587-00153642-00153890 more and even more inspired when I see
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00588-00153891-00154061 that we are being used by somebody else
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00589-00154062-00154316 someone from the outside of my media
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00590-00154317-00154716 bubble and even though I have written
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00591-00154717-00155041 more than 100 critical articles about
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00592-00155042-00155264 the Armed Forces and perhaps
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00593-00155265-00155813 non-positive I was really glad when I
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00594-00155814-00156023 got my first phone call from from
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00595-00156024-00156206 somebody working in the arms industry
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00596-00156207-00156641 who was using my tool filing FOIA
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00597-00156642-00156890 requests to sell weapons to no region
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00598-00156891-00157124 Armed Forces in a more efficient way
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00599-00157125-00157438 because then it worked then it had been
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00600-00157439-00157712 spreading awareness to to to somebody
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00601-00157713-00158006 completely other than me and other than
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00602-00158007-00158554 my friends and that's good even though I
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00603-00158555-00158840 don't really like what he's doing
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00604-00158841-00159166 III see that it can be used in different
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00605-00159167-00159671 ways so so it's difficult to find a good
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00606-00159672-00159726 measure of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00607-00159727-00160143 everything but but we're created in the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00608-00160144-00160401 archives is one of the one of the good
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00609-00160402-00160986 meshes because it means practical
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00610-00160987-00161367 transparency yeah yeah the opening up is
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00611-00161368-00161508 a kind of it's it's one part of the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00612-00161509-00161646 process but it's the critical part
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00613-00161647-00161856 because in the end that's that's where
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00614-00161857-00162006 it all starts that's how you can
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00615-00162007-00162195 actually things like that happened that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00616-00162196-00162354 someone actually has the possibility
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00617-00162355-00162636 they use and it kind of like it has two
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00618-00162637-00162867 possibilities thread so in a way of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00619-00162868-00163014 thinking of the industry context that's
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00620-00163015-00163182 the whole starting point nothing no
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00621-00163183-00163299 results nada
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00622-00163300-00163575 if there wasn't this opening up and kind
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00623-00163576-00163797 of like willingness to to do that an
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00624-00163798-00164010 experiment what could actually follow
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00625-00164011-00164352 from that yeah I think it's important to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00626-00164353-00164529 measure what we can measure and to use
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00627-00164530-00164811 that also for us to kind of measure how
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00628-00164812-00164976 successful we are at what we're doing so
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00629-00164977-00165180 not only to convince the outside world
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00630-00165181-00165401 but also to hold ourselves to account
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00631-00165402-00165707 but there's a limit so we measure jobs
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00632-00165708-00165921 people employed by the startups we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00633-00165922-00166260 incubate how much investment they
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00634-00166261-00166593 received and and so on but like the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00635-00166594-00166776 stories you mentioned you may publish a
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00636-00166777-00166989 story and then you can read and you can
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00637-00166990-00167181 check how many people read it but that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00638-00167182-00167469 only tells you so much of what an impact
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00639-00167470-00167652 you had because people might read the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00640-00167653-00167781 story and then share it with someone
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00641-00167782-00167964 else they may it may influence their
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00642-00167965-00168123 decisions and I think their wider
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00643-00168124-00168366 impacts beyond the narrow things that we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00644-00168367-00168552 can measure that we also need to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00645-00168553-00168936 recognize and perhaps also now that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00646-00168937-00169155 we've had these interesting insights
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00647-00169156-00169365 into how the three of you actually work
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00648-00169366-00169659 just hearing the story of how you make
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00649-00169660-00169932 things happen I mean often it of course
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00650-00169933-00170133 it's interesting to know what you do but
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00651-00170134-00170337 I think it's a lot more interesting to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00652-00170338-00170535 know exactly how you do it so you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00653-00170536-00170763 actually explain the mechanics that if
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00654-00170764-00171021 if this data was not available nobody
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00655-00171022-00171156 could have done anything if these
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00656-00171157-00171366 experts were not on hand to help
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00657-00171367-00171543 facilitate the process this would not
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00658-00171544-00171702 have done if we did not have a good
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00659-00171703-00171915 screening process to match the right
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00660-00171916-00172134 teams with the right company this would
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00661-00172135-00172371 not happen to explain those stories and
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00662-00172372-00172638 I suppose also from you know a media
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00663-00172639-00172869 point of view explaining that the story
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00664-00172870-00173106 you just read was made because
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00665-00173107-00173331 we made a FOIA request and that would
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00666-00173332-00173513 not have been possible had we not had
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00667-00173514-00173738 this tool in which we could search for
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00668-00173739-00173946 records and things like to explain the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00669-00173947-00174171 sort of the inside of things without
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00670-00174172-00174551 having to go into the details of of all
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00671-00174552-00174974 the the tech stuff do we have do you
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00672-00174975-00175248 like just one question for for the panel
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00673-00175249-00175449 from from the crowd now that you have
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00674-00175450-00175698 the chance otherwise we're going to
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00675-00175699-00176141 release you to lunch we have one
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00676-00176142-00176795 question
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00677-00176796-00177284 first just about economics figures from
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00678-00177285-00177733 United Kingdom your presentation was it
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00679-00177734-00178336 what was the year of those maybe the
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00680-00178337-00178865 sorry sorry uh her what was the figures
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00681-00178866-00179111 economic figures what was the source of
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00682-00179112-00179336 the year of those what your president
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00683-00179337-00179585 the economic figures yeah that
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00684-00179586-00179929 estimation was done I think in 2016 okay
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00685-00179930-00180818 yeah okay thanks yeah I think so alright
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00686-00180819-00181141 I think that wraps up our first session
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00687-00181142-00181441 on open data thank you very much thanks
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00688-00181442-00181565 for great questions from the audience
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00689-00181566-00181949 now you may go and have lunch but I hope
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00690-00181950-00182147 to see you again this afternoon where we
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00691-00182148-00182321 have a second session with two
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00692-00182322-00182688 interesting speakers see you later
+Mg50vEcvrKo-00693-00182689-00182947 [Applause]
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00000-00000003-00000260 Oh to Ducati name again a patch on a
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00001-00000261-00000430 patch on my leg and you know it had the
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00002-00000431-00000647 opportunity pull an end masolino patch
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00003-00000648-00000902 on agenda but Charlie you know concerned
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00004-00000902-00001166 about tango who may not only did you not
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00005-00001167-00001507 give eloquently no soon as I apologized
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00006-00001508-00001691 who may no no party no my knowledge I've
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00007-00001692-00001847 done about Tina may know just chillin
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00008-00001848-00002138 solo job at any company Tata PC the
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00009-00002139-00002359 tunnel do come back with all you ever
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00010-00002360-00002575 see any her back with all you ever seen
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00011-00002576-00002741 because I about only person you know
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00012-00002742-00002935 okay cause I'm at abyss you ever say
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00013-00002936-00003199 about you can open the energy up do but
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00014-00003200-00003410 Charlie okay of concern I gotta boom
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00015-00003411-00003736 Bali but gently with though totally not
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00016-00003738-00003953 jealous at all Galatea nice at all
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00017-00003954-00004202 galaxies no Jeff do a galaxy no moon
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00018-00004203-00004420 angle at Yaga yeah I got a pulling in a
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00019-00004421-00004760 bunion Lou Elmo hope I got a Chino hope
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00020-00004761-00004934 I got achievements along I joined up
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00021-00004935-00005120 it'll cut into them up they don't know
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00022-00005121-00005327 okay that's a mommy I will be no blood
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00023-00005328-00005651 no so nice I'm funny Wong and a possum
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00024-00005652-00006059 Naidu dotes on so Cheney love I don't
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00025-00006060-00006254 achieve mobile opieop load the plethora
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00026-00006255-00006311 do
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00027-00006312-00006713 esatto Cooper cheaper what a and
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00028-00006714-00007133 happy to help with them I'll do okay hey
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00029-00007134-00007548 and they have a look at oh no oh no
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00030-00007550-00007931 Pablo perche a purpose OG&E so I thought
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00031-00007931-00008141 I don't know what's on outside
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00032-00008142-00008456 no bunny won't gain on path so no no
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00033-00008457-00008987 okay no pan so warm again my lovely
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00034-00008988-00009194 little concern right now Kunene de
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00035-00009195-00009698 Kooning this our Cho is a turning and
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00036-00009699-00009983 doing what are the you 2d maybe you want
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00037-00009984-00010192 a lipid you've had him when you want a
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00038-00010193-00010399 let's see DD Maggie I'm humble appeal
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00039-00010400-00010896 air balloon locomobile smin yatha AP -
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00040-00010897-00011185 demon say yeah I do Paducah mchao
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00041-00011186-00011438 console has a Yamaha do want a Paducah
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00042-00011439-00011653 Mandy to me I'm on board Yakima Valley
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00043-00011654-00011999 on DNA Nepali Nevada could you to the
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00044-00012000-00012281 Melissa did the movie an independent
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00045-00012282-00012610 pearl what are certainly do you know
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00046-00012611-00013015 leaving home again edge of doom again an
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00047-00013016-00013349 appalling again upon a an apology
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00048-00013350-00013653 botanical Menino today collodial chimp
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00049-00013654-00013919 and our local air see we pueden Oh
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00050-00013921-00014072 Jennifer since you were pulling movie
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00051-00014074-00014232 the noodle pudding my real alibi the
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00052-00014233-00014519 money I've been in put him away my
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00053-00014521-00014871 buddy Tony holiday you have no family no
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00054-00014872-00015054 home lovely lady get on a plane movie
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00055-00015055-00015303 the noodle premium by tomorrow I know I
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00056-00015304-00015552 know my homologue a concern I said a
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00057-00015553-00015822 limit on how long wanta okay concern I
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00058-00015822-00016097 gotta pee - I'm gonna be happy to come
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00059-00016099-00016311 and they told me and I mumble dopey to
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00060-00016312-00016554 do a cool movie or do not I do the
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00061-00016555-00016848 college in Pinal and a pass any movie
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00062-00016849-00017348 yet oh no put him away anybody - no
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00063-00017349-00018486 tiene so much funnier than a minimal Oh
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00064-00018487-00019143 Billy we do Meccano Jabba du up where si
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00065-00019144-00019461 de Sade on ojou-sama bar okey other
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00066-00019462-00019707 people preside other Anaheim about
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00067-00019708-00019953 needles are they layin a lotta Lotta
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00068-00019954-00020196 come uncle ollie up with I know Michael
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00069-00020197-00020930 origami know a microplane tomono-san
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00070-00020931-00021225 now yeah we done a bunch o Angela Chen
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00071-00021226-00021489 Lin um no no party no job to do it a
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00072-00021490-00021732 button a plunge Abdul ok console
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00073-00021733-00022080 igano-kun indianepal ooh I'm a balloon
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00074-00022081-00022319 from balloon Tito blogger named Monica
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00075-00022320-00022728 on sonogram do autumny another button a
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00076-00022729-00022935 proton of my balloon Tito local Indian
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00077-00022936-00023483 oh I know mama Constance I Diana he
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00078-00023484-00023834 panting Danny may possibly die nobody
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00079-00023835-00024491 wanna come lo que pasa man
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00080-00024492-00024846 Monica care concern about yesterday no
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00081-00024847-00025447 mark on Sonya you know path of knowledge
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00082-00025448-00025670 but in a community ecology not
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00083-00025672-00025782 abandoning
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00084-00025783-00026022 learning Belapur knows that we su peep
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00085-00026023-00026169 with me and want
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00086-00026170-00026408 what am I now why not much knowledge
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00087-00026410-00026697 about chalice kill her company Jack a
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00088-00026698-00026907 child a paper do you know qui gonn why I
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00089-00026908-00027213 named him buddy Tony went on we're
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00090-00027214-00027399 talking about the woman yeah no Polly
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00091-00027400-00027645 nobody no Jack Dukas I'll set this up
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00092-00027645-00027810 well judging by the party I know how
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00093-00027811-00028026 cake on somebody you want a homo back
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00094-00028027-00028266 when BIA her cold with a pediment if you
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00095-00028267-00028458 I don't know anything about young as I
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00096-00028458-00028806 say bueno get tenure do a lesson on me
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00097-00028807-00029027 mock what you don't know what soon as a
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00098-00029029-00029223 quarry a name but I will - Emma you know
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00099-00029224-00029504 oweme oweme Morocco and a yoga suit
+Mj1YbPoPNqE-00100-00029505-00029922 empirical science on our side
+Mkj2R16rvtU-00000-00000071-00000233 be
+Mkj2R16rvtU-00001-00000234-00000512 w
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00000-00005105-00005320 can't understand what is happening to me
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00001-00005321-00005604 this isn't real this is only a dream
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00002-00005605-00006017 I never felt this way before
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00003-00006018-00006317 I'm looking down at my body below I like
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00004-00006318-00006509 a slave in the midst of a dream it's not
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00005-00006509-00007895 very pretty
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00006-00007895-00008701 [Applause]
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00007-00008702-00008825 can't wait
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00008-00008826-00009360 [Applause]
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00009-00009361-00010285 Heaven can't wait till another day
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00010-00010286-00010601 I'm ready
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00011-00010602-00010787 it's not to clean till the lights
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00012-00010788-00010969 Eternal Fighters
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00013-00010970-00011260 and all of the people standing there and
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00014-00011261-00011506 further me
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00015-00011507-00011819 into the pants of life this is the place
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00016-00011820-00012023 where the living Joy not that I want
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00017-00012024-00012305 some music is only just a nightmare
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00018-00012306-00012689 every time waits
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00019-00012690-00013075 [Applause]
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00020-00013076-00013594 in another day haven't had words
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00021-00013594-00013993 [Applause]
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00023-00017942-00018577 take my hands I'll lead you to the
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00024-00018578-00018786 promised land
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00025-00018787-00019999 check my hands I'll get up whoever
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00026-00020000-00020850 I'll take you to the Earth
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00027-00020851-00021700 [Music]
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00028-00021701-00022036 oh
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00029-00022037-00022343 oh
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00030-00022344-00024011 hello
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00031-00024012-00025258 hello
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00032-00025259-00025678 oh
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00033-00025679-00026633 oh
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00035-00032172-00032464 nobody Tinkles the fields are straight I
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00036-00032466-00032657 feel so tired I feel today and I'm
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00037-00032658-00032885 wondering if I live and be the same
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00038-00032886-00033252 again
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00039-00033253-00033562 baby you're going down there as well I
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00040-00033563-00034818 can't accept my soul to Forever
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00041-00034819-00035006 can't wait
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00042-00035007-00035479 [Applause]
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00043-00035480-00035864 Heaven can't wait till another day
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00044-00035865-00036601 [Applause]
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00045-00036602-00036757 every time
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00046-00036758-00037262 [Applause]
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00047-00037263-00038274 [Music]
+MmF5vUPZ_j4-00048-00038275-00038772 another day foreign
+NoflZnIpqVg-00000-00000000-00000316 hello Omega Pro family I'm very very
+NoflZnIpqVg-00001-00000317-00000833 excited because this August 16th I'm
+NoflZnIpqVg-00002-00000834-00001066 going to be providing a very special
+NoflZnIpqVg-00003-00001067-00001243 private
+NoflZnIpqVg-00004-00001244-00001691 Global training on how you can develop a
+NoflZnIpqVg-00005-00001692-00002002 million dollar mindset in your business
+NoflZnIpqVg-00006-00002003-00002279 make sure you're there make sure
+NoflZnIpqVg-00007-00002280-00002579 everyone on your team is there it's
+NoflZnIpqVg-00008-00002580-00002923 going to be an explosive Global
+NoflZnIpqVg-00009-00002924-00003173 mind-expanding event and it's not going
+NoflZnIpqVg-00010-00003174-00003401 to be the same without you okay so click
+NoflZnIpqVg-00011-00003402-00003793 on the link and I'll see you August 16th
+NoflZnIpqVg-00012-00003794-00004188 [Music]
+NoflZnIpqVg-00013-00004189-00004520 she's got that
+N0IsvbIYuY4-00000-00000158-00000419 totally also known as tallit Olli is a
+N0IsvbIYuY4-00001-00000420-00000611 Sulawesi language of the Austronesian
+N0IsvbIYuY4-00002-00000612-00000914 language family spoken by 25,000 people
+N0IsvbIYuY4-00003-00000915-00001501 of Central Sulawesi Indonesia
+N0IsvbIYuY4-00004-00001502-00001802 references
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00000-00000000-00001726 oh it's you again I've been up to
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00001-00001727-00001988 surprisingly little in the last few days
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00002-00001989-00002317 I'm trying to be peaceful and spend time
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00003-00002318-00002575 reading and taking things in instead of
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00004-00002576-00002798 always being on the go and trying to
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00005-00002799-00003047 make things otherwise I'll wear myself
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00006-00003048-00003440 out that's maybe crushingly obvious but
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00007-00003440-00003631 I've managed to avoid noticing of myself
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00008-00003632-00004565 for years let an apple tree be planted
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00009-00004566-00004874 close beside a ditch of mud let its
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00010-00004875-00005135 roots be parched and aching ever waiting
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00011-00005136-00005438 for the blood so it's small and bitter
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00012-00005439-00005849 apples overhang the streambed dry cursed
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00013-00005850-00006218 to live and never flourish painful grow
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00014-00006219-00006784 and painful die yet this tree shall be
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00015-00006786-00007060 transplanted to a meadow by a stream
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00016-00007061-00007328 clouds shall shower down their mercies
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00017-00007329-00007660 sunlight throw it kindest beam roots
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00018-00007661-00007973 recall the feel of fullness by the river
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00019-00007973-00008339 in the rain branches shall be pruned and
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00020-00008340-00009482 ready hope and apples grow again
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00021-00009483-00009915 adam says happy birthday Eve Eve says
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00022-00009916-00011102 it's today not tomorrow
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00023-00011103-00011409 mitochondria are tiny living things
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00024-00011410-00011709 rather like bacteria they live inside
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00025-00011710-00011979 the cells of almost all animals plants
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00026-00011980-00012297 and fungi where their job is to process
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00027-00012298-00012534 glucose in order to provide a source of
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00028-00012535-00012795 power for the rest of the cell without
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00029-00012796-00013251 their help we wouldn't be here what
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00030-00013252-00013461 fascinates me particularly about
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00031-00013462-00013691 mitochondria is that they have their own
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00032-00013693-00013980 DNA which is not at all like human DNA
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00033-00013981-00014229 much more like the DNA of bacteria
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00034-00014230-00014451 they're essentially a different creature
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00035-00014452-00014741 and because you inherit all your
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00036-00014743-00014969 mitochondria only from your mother
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00037-00014969-00015237 mitochondrial DNA is very useful in
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00038-00015238-00015636 tracing your ancestry so how did we come
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00039-00015637-00015828 to have these creatures living inside
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00040-00015829-00016091 our cells the most commonly accepted
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00041-00016093-00016401 explanation is that two billion years
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00042-00016402-00016619 ago when complex cells were just
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00043-00016620-00016884 starting out the mitochondria discovered
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00044-00016885-00017052 that the cells were a good place to live
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00045-00017053-00017277 inside there's lots of glucose to feed
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00046-00017278-00017508 on it was just as useful for the cell
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00047-00017509-00017714 which needed the glucose processed
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00048-00017715-00018057 symbiosis the mitochondria hitched a
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00049-00018058-00018287 lift and they've been with us ever since
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00050-00018288-00018569 so even when you think you're alone
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00051-00018570-00018905 remember you're also a sort of walking
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00052-00018906-00019953 mitochondrial City a birthday by
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00053-00019954-00020310 Christina Rossetti my heart is like a
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00054-00020311-00020592 singing bird whose nest is in a watered
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00055-00020593-00020856 shoot my heart is like an apple tree
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00056-00020857-00021057 whose boughs are bent with fixed set
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00057-00021058-00021360 fruit my heart is like a rainbow shell
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00058-00021361-00021687 that paddles in a healthy on see my
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00059-00021688-00021975 heart is glad ur than all these because
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00060-00021976-00022425 my love is come to me raise me a dais of
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00061-00022426-00022689 silk and down hang it with their and
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00062-00022690-00022974 purple dies carve it in dubs and
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00063-00022975-00023253 pomegranates and peacocks with a hundred
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00064-00023254-00023562 eyes work it in gold and silver grapes
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00065-00023563-00023837 and leaves and silver fleur-de-lis
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00066-00023838-00024195 because the birthday of my life is
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00067-00024196-00024651 my love is coming to me see you next
+N2rGhUyfsCI-00068-00024652-00024876 time
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00000-00000077-00000438 from New York City it's the cube
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00001-00000440-00000705 covering welcome to the new edge
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00002-00000706-00001121 brought to you by pensando systems hey
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00003-00001122-00001250 welcome back here ready Jeff Rick here
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00004-00001251-00001373 with the cube we are in downtown
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00005-00001374-00001570 Manhattan at the top of goldman sachs it
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00006-00001571-00001708 was a beautiful day now the clouds
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00007-00001709-00001873 coming in but that's appropriate because
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00008-00001874-00002008 we're talking about cloud we're talking
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00009-00002009-00002209 about edge and the launch of a brand new
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00010-00002210-00002401 company is pensando and their event it's
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00011-00002402-00002560 called welcome to the new edge and we're
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00012-00002561-00002767 happy to have since we're goldman the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00013-00002768-00002968 guys who have the money
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00014-00002969-00003211 we're barry Eggers a founding partner of
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00015-00003213-00003434 Lightspeed ventures and randy pond the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00016-00003435-00003697 CFO a pensando gentlemen welcome thank
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00017-00003699-00003908 you thank you so Barry let's start with
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00018-00003909-00004064 you you think you were involved at this
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00019-00004065-00004484 early on why did you get involved what
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00020-00004485-00004691 what kind of sparked your interest we
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00021-00004692-00004964 got involved in this round and the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00022-00004965-00005165 reason we got involved were mainly
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00023-00005166-00005333 because we've worked with this team
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00024-00005334-00005504 before at Cisco we know they're
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00025-00005505-00005693 fantastic they're probably the most
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00026-00005694-00005971 prolific team and the enterprise and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00027-00005972-00006233 they're going after a big opportunity so
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00028-00006234-00006403 we were pleased when the company said
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00029-00006404-00006529 hey you guys want to work with us on
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00030-00006530-00006770 this as a financial investor and we did
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00031-00006770-00007084 some diligence and dug in and found you
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00032-00007085-00007223 know everything to our liking and jump
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00033-00007223-00007373 right in didn't anybody tell them this
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00034-00007373-00007660 startup is a young man's game they mixed
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00035-00007661-00007895 up the twenty-something I think yeah
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00036-00007895-00008123 they sort of turned the startup on its
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00037-00008123-00008423 head if you will no pun intended that's
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00038-00008424-00008630 going right yeah yeah and Randy you've
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00039-00008631-00008801 joined him a CFO you've known them for a
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00040-00008802-00008984 while I mean what is it about this group
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00041-00008985-00009292 of people that execute kind of
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00042-00009293-00009458 forward-looking transformation
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00043-00009459-00009670 transformational technologies time and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00044-00009671-00009827 time again that's not a very common
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00045-00009828-00009985 trait it's a it's a great question so
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00046-00009986-00010135 you know the key for these guys have
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00047-00010136-00010252 been well they've been together since
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00048-00010253-00010513 the 80s so Mario look and primitive this
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00049-00010514-00010720 is the 80s I work with them at their
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00050-00010721-00010934 previous startup before Christian two
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00051-00010935-00011191 ladies and they're the combination of
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00052-00011192-00011371 their skills are phenomenal together so
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00053-00011372-00011519 you know one of them has some of the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00054-00011520-00011641 vision of where they want to go the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00055-00011642-00011812 second guy is a substantive sort of
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00056-00011813-00012112 engineer takes it from concept first
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00057-00012113-00012331 drawing and then the Prem takes over the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00058-00012332-00012473 execution perspective and then drives
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00059-00012474-00012585 this thing and they've really been
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00060-00012586-00012758 incredible together and then we added
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00061-00012759-00013001 Sony at crescendo as a as a product
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00062-00013002-00013172 marketing person and she's really
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00063-00013172-00013284 stepped up and become
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00064-00013285-00013443 integral part on the team so they work
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00065-00013444-00013653 together so well it just makes a huge
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00066-00013654-00013866 difference yeah it's it's it's amazing
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00067-00013866-00014082 that that a that they keep doing it and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00068-00014083-00014232 B that they want to keep doing it
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00069-00014233-00014379 right because they've got a few bucks in
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00070-00014380-00014532 the bank and they don't really need to
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00071-00014533-00014691 do it but still to take on a big
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00072-00014691-00014805 challenge and then to keep it under
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00073-00014806-00014979 wraps for two and a half years that's
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00074-00014980-00015255 pretty pretty amazing so curious Barry
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00075-00015256-00015378 from your point of view venture
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00076-00015379-00015483 investing you guys kind of see the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00077-00015484-00015612 future you get pitched by smart people
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00078-00015613-00015927 all day when you looked at John Chambers
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00079-00015928-00016101 kind of conversation of these ten-year
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00080-00016102-00016434 kind of big cycles you know what did you
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00081-00016435-00016482 think of that
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00082-00016483-00016701 how do you guys kind of slice and dice
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00083-00016702-00016851 your opportunities and looking at these
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00084-00016852-00017094 big Nick's yeah going back going back to
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00085-00017095-00017223 the team a little bit they've been
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00086-00017224-00017394 pretty good at identifying a lot of
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00087-00017395-00017517 these cycles they brought us land
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00088-00017518-00017754 switching a long time ago with crescendo
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00089-00017755-00018138 they sort of redefined the data center
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00090-00018139-00018285 several times and so there's another
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00091-00018286-00018447 opportunity what's driving this
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00092-00018448-00018731 opportunity really is the fact that
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00093-00018732-00019002 explosion of applications in the network
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00094-00019003-00019179 and of course east-west traffic in the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00095-00019180-00019383 network so networks were more designed
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00096-00019384-00019605 north-south and they're slowly becoming
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00097-00019606-00019854 more east-west but because the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00098-00019855-00020109 applications are closer to the edge and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00099-00020110-00020349 networks today mostly provide services
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00100-00020350-00020601 in the core the idea for pensando is
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00101-00020602-00020748 well why don't we bring the service
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00102-00020749-00020916 deliver the services closer to the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00103-00020917-00021126 applications improve performance better
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00104-00021127-00021417 security and better monitoring yeah and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00105-00021418-00021546 then just the just the hyper
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00106-00021547-00021738 acceleration of you know the amount of
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00107-00021739-00021921 data the amount of applications and then
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00108-00021922-00022113 this age-old it's we're going to use the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00109-00022114-00022296 data to the computer do you move the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00110-00022297-00022449 compute to the data now the answer is
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00111-00022450-00022995 yes all the above so you got some money
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00112-00022996-00023331 to work with we do you got a round that
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00113-00023332-00023475 he could be around you guys are closing
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00114-00023476-00023780 the C round so I think 180 people
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00115-00023781-00023973 approximately I think somebody told me
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00116-00023974-00024258 close enough so as you put some of this
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00117-00024259-00024435 capital to work what are some of your
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00118-00024436-00024648 priorities going forward so we will
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00119-00024649-00024897 continue to hire both in the engineering
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00120-00024898-00025017 side but more importantly now we're
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00121-00025018-00025203 hiring in sales and service we've been
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00122-00025204-00025359 waiting for the product quite frankly so
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00123-00025360-00025500 we've just got our first few sales guys
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00124-00025501-00025680 hired we've got a pretty aggressive ramp
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00125-00025681-00025928 especially with the HP relationship to
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00126-00025929-00026043 put people out into the field we've
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00127-00026044-00026163 hired a couple guys in New York will
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00128-00026164-00026361 continue to hire at the sales team we're
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00129-00026362-00026546 ramping the supply chain and we've got a
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00130-00026547-00026610 relative
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00131-00026611-00026748 complicated supply chain model but that
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00132-00026749-00026877 has to react now that we're going to
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00133-00026877-00027065 market all that might be pretty used to
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00134-00027066-00027270 do that we're changing facilities we
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00135-00027270-00027507 need to grow we're sort of cramped in a
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00136-00027508-00027720 one-story building open up one floor of
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00137-00027720-00027876 a building right now so the money is
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00138-00027877-00028017 going to be used sort of critically to
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00139-00028018-00028199 really scale the business down they can
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00140-00028200-00028346 go to market okay but a pretty
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00141-00028347-00028661 impressive list of both partners and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00142-00028662-00028870 customers on launch day you don't see
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00143-00028871-00029355 Goldman HPE Equinix I think it was quite
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00144-00029356-00029537 a slide some of that is the uniqueness
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00145-00029538-00029892 of the way we went to market and did the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00146-00029893-00030060 original due diligence on the product
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00147-00030061-00030282 and bringing customers in early and then
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00148-00030283-00030452 converting them to investors you end up
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00149-00030453-00030645 with a customer investment model so they
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00150-00030645-00030818 stayed with us Goldman's been through
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00151-00030819-00031005 all three rounds we've been about HP and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00152-00031006-00031214 last model we had NetApp has been um two
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00153-00031215-00031407 rounds now so we've we've continued to
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00154-00031408-00031623 develop as a business with this small
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00155-00031624-00031758 core group of customers and investors
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00156-00031758-00031964 that we could try to expand every time
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00157-00031965-00032096 we move to the next round and as Barry
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00158-00032097-00032255 said earlier this is the first time we
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00159-00032256-00032474 had a traditional financial investor in
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00160-00032475-00032604 our rounds the rest of them have all
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00161-00032605-00032730 been customers they've been friends and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00162-00032731-00032990 family for the most part did you join
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00163-00032991-00033308 the board too right I did yeah so what
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00164-00033309-00033455 are you what are you excited about what
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00165-00033456-00033699 what do you see is I mean just clearly
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00166-00033700-00033986 your side you invested but is there
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00167-00033987-00034248 something just extra special here you
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00168-00034249-00034283 know
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00169-00034284-00034511 react chambers put in a 10-year 10-year
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00170-00034512-00034698 cycle yeah we've talked about it I mean
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00171-00034699-00034923 I'm excited to work with the team right
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00172-00034924-00035240 there best-in-class working closely with
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00173-00035241-00035567 John again is a lot of fun a chance to
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00174-00035568-00036017 not exhaust yeah yeah you know a chance
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00175-00036018-00036296 to read redefine the data center and be
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00176-00036297-00036470 part of the next way even as a VC you
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00177-00036471-00036726 love waves and build my Connick company
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00178-00036727-00036899 right and I think we have a real
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00179-00036900-00037110 opportunity in front of us it it takes a
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00180-00037111-00037311 lot of money to do this and do it right
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00181-00037312-00037557 and I think we have the team that proven
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00182-00037558-00037727 they can execute on this kind of
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00183-00037728-00037929 opportunities from I'm excited to see
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00184-00037930-00038070 what the next five years hold for this
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00185-00038071-00038270 company good well it was funny John
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00186-00038271-00038468 teased him a little bit about you know
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00187-00038469-00038661 all the M&A stuff that he was famous for
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00188-00038662-00038805 at Cisco he's like I don't do that
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00189-00038806-00039002 anymore now I'm an investor I want IPOs
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00190-00039003-00039270 all the way what's all 18 thinks it is
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00191-00039271-00039411 18 companies in his portfolio their
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00192-00039412-00039585 routes they're going to IPO all the way
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00193-00039586-00039869 yeah that's that's a good point actually
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00194-00039870-00040169 this team has been prolific and they've
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00195-00040170-00040355 delivered products that have generated
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00196-00040356-00040655 fifty billion dollars and any walk into
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00197-00040656-00040793 any data center in the world you're
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00198-00040794-00041036 gonna see a product this team has built
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00199-00041037-00041294 however this team has not taken a
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00200-00041295-00041450 company public so that's really the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00201-00041451-00041582 opportunity I think that's what excites
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00202-00041583-00041855 them Randy's here it's why Jon's here
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00203-00041856-00041966 that's why I'm here
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00204-00041967-00042131 we want to build a company that can be
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00205-00042132-00042287 an independent company be a lasting
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00206-00042288-00042602 leader in a new category yeah so last
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00207-00042603-00042914 word Randy for you for people that
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00208-00042915-00043040 aren't familiar with the team that
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00209-00043041-00043199 aren't familiar with with with what
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00210-00043200-00043376 they've done what would you tell them
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00211-00043377-00043625 about why you came to this opportunity
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00212-00043626-00043733 and why you're excited about it
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00213-00043734-00043997 well this there is no higher quality
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00214-00043998-00044141 engineering team in the world didn't
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00215-00044142-00044459 these people so it's to get re-engaged
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00216-00044460-00044672 with them again with an entirely new
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00217-00044673-00044906 concept that's catching a transition and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00218-00044907-00045008 the market was just too good an
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00219-00045009-00045232 opportunity to pass I mean I had retired
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00220-00045233-00045506 for 15 months and I came out of
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00221-00045507-00045668 retirement to join this team much to the
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00222-00045669-00045914 chagrin of my wife but I just couldn't
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00223-00045915-00046322 pass up the opportunity high caliber
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00224-00046323-00046538 talent it's um every day is is
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00225-00046539-00046763 interesting I have to say well thanks
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00226-00046764-00046955 for for sharing the story with us and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00227-00046956-00047153 and congratulations on a great day and
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00228-00047154-00047315 in a terrific event thank you thank you
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00229-00047316-00047366 very much
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00230-00047367-00047519 all right he's berry he's Randy I'm Jeff
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00231-00047520-00047702 you're watching the cube from the top of
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00232-00047703-00047855 goldman sachs in Manhattan thanks for
+N3LTbcfyeJU-00233-00047856-00048137 watching we'll see you next time
+N6FUfY84B50-00000-00000079-00000304 food
+N6FUfY84B50-00001-00000305-00002895 [Music]
+N6FUfY84B50-00002-00002896-00003561 uh
+N6FUfY84B50-00003-00003561-00003678 [Music]
+N6FUfY84B50-00004-00003679-00003833 [Applause]
+N6FUfY84B50-00005-00003834-00005332 [Music]
+N6FUfY84B50-00006-00005333-00005481 [Applause]
+N6FUfY84B50-00007-00005482-00005799 [Music]
+N6FUfY84B50-00008-00005800-00006695 me
+N6FUfY84B50-00009-00006697-00009004 [Music]
+N6FUfY84B50-00010-00009005-00009287 [Applause]
+N6FUfY84B50-00011-00009288-00009588 hmm
+N8dwalT1SCU-00000-00000055-00000647 [Music]
+N8dwalT1SCU-00001-00000648-00000790 welcome back to the cube's coverage of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00002-00000791-00001007 red hat summit 21 virtual
+N8dwalT1SCU-00003-00001008-00001158 i'm john furrier host of thecube we got
+N8dwalT1SCU-00004-00001159-00001343 two great guests here returning back
+N8dwalT1SCU-00005-00001344-00001495 cube alumni is here to give us their
+N8dwalT1SCU-00006-00001496-00001679 perspective dave lindquist gm
+N8dwalT1SCU-00007-00001680-00001863 vp of engineering hybrid cloud
+N8dwalT1SCU-00008-00001864-00002039 management red hat joe fitzgerald
+N8dwalT1SCU-00009-00002039-00002183 general manager and vp of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00010-00002184-00002342 the management business unit red hat
+N8dwalT1SCU-00011-00002343-00002487 guys welcome back to the cube
+N8dwalT1SCU-00012-00002488-00002671 congratulations red hat summit's ongoing
+N8dwalT1SCU-00013-00002672-00002750 virtual
+N8dwalT1SCU-00014-00002751-00003071 great to see you thank you john thanks
+N8dwalT1SCU-00015-00003072-00003118 joe
+N8dwalT1SCU-00016-00003119-00003327 so love to get the low down a lot going
+N8dwalT1SCU-00017-00003328-00003503 on the productivity this year
+N8dwalT1SCU-00018-00003504-00003799 looking back from last year a lot's been
+N8dwalT1SCU-00019-00003800-00004006 done we've been in the pandemic now
+N8dwalT1SCU-00020-00004007-00004263 now circling back a full year a lot's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00021-00004264-00004431 happened a lot of productivity a lot of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00022-00004432-00004551 clear visibility on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00023-00004552-00004759 on what's working what's not you guys
+N8dwalT1SCU-00024-00004760-00004902 got some great news let's just jump
+N8dwalT1SCU-00025-00004903-00004999 right into it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00026-00005000-00005311 what's the big announcement
+N8dwalT1SCU-00027-00005312-00005422 so one of the things that we announced
+N8dwalT1SCU-00028-00005423-00005622 here at summit john is an expansion of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00029-00005623-00005735 our red hat insights
+N8dwalT1SCU-00030-00005736-00006022 brand uh basically we announced red hat
+N8dwalT1SCU-00031-00006023-00006167 insights for our rel
+N8dwalT1SCU-00032-00006168-00006495 platform back in 2015. um over the years
+N8dwalT1SCU-00033-00006495-00006631 we've increased the amount of data and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00034-00006631-00006823 visibility into those systems
+N8dwalT1SCU-00035-00006823-00006998 here at summit we've now announced red
+N8dwalT1SCU-00036-00007000-00007214 hat insights for both openshift
+N8dwalT1SCU-00037-00007215-00007398 and for the red hat ansible platform so
+N8dwalT1SCU-00038-00007400-00007551 it's a pretty significant
+N8dwalT1SCU-00039-00007552-00007742 increase in the visibility that we have
+N8dwalT1SCU-00040-00007743-00007919 to the platforms oh so can you repeat
+N8dwalT1SCU-00041-00007920-00008119 that one more time so the expansion is
+N8dwalT1SCU-00042-00008120-00008263 through which platform style
+N8dwalT1SCU-00043-00008264-00008446 specifically
+N8dwalT1SCU-00044-00008447-00008599 so red hat insights is a way that we
+N8dwalT1SCU-00045-00008600-00008807 connect up to different platforms
+N8dwalT1SCU-00046-00008808-00009006 that red hat provides historically it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00047-00009007-00009231 was for red hat enterprise linux or rel
+N8dwalT1SCU-00048-00009232-00009391 we've now expanded it to the red hat
+N8dwalT1SCU-00049-00009392-00009623 openshift family platforms
+N8dwalT1SCU-00050-00009624-00009831 as well as the red hat ansible
+N8dwalT1SCU-00051-00009832-00010023 automation platform as well
+N8dwalT1SCU-00052-00010024-00010214 so nice broad expansion people want that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00053-00010215-00010391 data what's what was the motivation
+N8dwalT1SCU-00054-00010392-00010478 behind it was it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00055-00010479-00010687 uh customer demand was it more access to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00056-00010688-00010791 the data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00057-00010792-00010967 just was it on the roadmap what's the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00058-00010968-00011174 motivation where is this going what's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00059-00011175-00011319 what's the purpose
+N8dwalT1SCU-00060-00011320-00011535 of all this well i don't think customers
+N8dwalT1SCU-00061-00011536-00011710 say hey please you know take more data i
+N8dwalT1SCU-00062-00011711-00011774 think it's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00063-00011775-00011974 customers say can you keep me more
+N8dwalT1SCU-00064-00011975-00012183 secure can you keep my systems more
+N8dwalT1SCU-00065-00012184-00012327 optimized can you help me
+N8dwalT1SCU-00066-00012328-00012583 set more things to automatic and that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00067-00012584-00012727 requires that you get data from these
+N8dwalT1SCU-00068-00012728-00012919 systems so that you can auto tune auto
+N8dwalT1SCU-00069-00012919-00012974 secure
+N8dwalT1SCU-00070-00012975-00013215 auto optimize right so it's really all
+N8dwalT1SCU-00071-00013216-00013415 those benefits that we
+N8dwalT1SCU-00072-00013416-00013575 get by connecting to these systems
+N8dwalT1SCU-00073-00013576-00013711 bringing the telemetry the data the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00074-00013712-00013791 config
+N8dwalT1SCU-00075-00013791-00013951 different kinds of information and using
+N8dwalT1SCU-00076-00013952-00014143 that on the customer behalf to optimize
+N8dwalT1SCU-00077-00014144-00014303 secured to those systems
+N8dwalT1SCU-00078-00014304-00014438 you know one of the biggest trends i
+N8dwalT1SCU-00079-00014440-00014583 think now for multiple years has been
+N8dwalT1SCU-00080-00014584-00014711 observability
+N8dwalT1SCU-00081-00014712-00014903 um with cloud native more services are
+N8dwalT1SCU-00082-00014904-00015055 being turned on and off
+N8dwalT1SCU-00083-00015056-00015222 enterprises are getting a lot of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00084-00015223-00015391 pressure to be modern in their
+N8dwalT1SCU-00085-00015391-00015519 in their application development
+N8dwalT1SCU-00086-00015519-00015766 processes why is data more important
+N8dwalT1SCU-00087-00015768-00015911 than ever now can you guys take a minute
+N8dwalT1SCU-00088-00015912-00016063 and expand on that because
+N8dwalT1SCU-00089-00016063-00016230 this idea of telemetry across the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00090-00016231-00016415 platform is a very interesting
+N8dwalT1SCU-00091-00016416-00016791 um announcement because you're turning
+N8dwalT1SCU-00092-00016792-00017055 that data into value but can you guys
+N8dwalT1SCU-00093-00017056-00017222 explain where's that value
+N8dwalT1SCU-00094-00017223-00017447 coming turning into what is the value
+N8dwalT1SCU-00095-00017448-00017583 proposition
+N8dwalT1SCU-00096-00017584-00017903 where are people seeing the the key
+N8dwalT1SCU-00097-00017904-00018263 key value points well a couple of points
+N8dwalT1SCU-00098-00018264-00018375 john
+N8dwalT1SCU-00099-00018376-00018743 as you started out is in in a hybrid
+N8dwalT1SCU-00100-00018744-00018911 cloud environment with
+N8dwalT1SCU-00101-00018912-00019094 cloud native applications and a lot of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00102-00019095-00019294 application modernization
+N8dwalT1SCU-00103-00019295-00019599 and um the current progressiveness of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00104-00019600-00019807 devops and sre teams you're seeing a lot
+N8dwalT1SCU-00105-00019808-00019943 of dynamics
+N8dwalT1SCU-00106-00019944-00020214 in workloads and continuous delivery and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00107-00020215-00020375 deployments that are in
+N8dwalT1SCU-00108-00020376-00020543 public environments and private
+N8dwalT1SCU-00109-00020544-00020775 environments distributed models
+N8dwalT1SCU-00110-00020776-00020991 and so consequently there's a lot of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00111-00020992-00021207 change in dynamics in the environment so
+N8dwalT1SCU-00112-00021208-00021511 to sustain these high levels of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00113-00021512-00021750 service levels to sustain the security
+N8dwalT1SCU-00114-00021751-00021871 of the compliance
+N8dwalT1SCU-00115-00021872-00022119 the ability to gather data from all
+N8dwalT1SCU-00116-00022120-00022271 these different points to be able to get
+N8dwalT1SCU-00117-00022272-00022455 visibility into that data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00118-00022456-00022678 to be able the ability to process that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00119-00022679-00022822 with various analytics
+N8dwalT1SCU-00120-00022823-00022991 and understand what when something's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00121-00022992-00023199 gone wrong or when an update is needed
+N8dwalT1SCU-00122-00023200-00023463 or when a configuration is drifted is
+N8dwalT1SCU-00123-00023464-00023607 increasingly critical
+N8dwalT1SCU-00124-00023608-00023894 in a hybrid cloud environment so on the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00125-00023895-00024022 telemetry piece
+N8dwalT1SCU-00126-00024023-00024303 is that in open shift as well that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00127-00024304-00024414 that's supporting that is
+N8dwalT1SCU-00128-00024415-00024767 in there how does that work
+N8dwalT1SCU-00129-00024768-00025103 it's it's in openshift as joe mentioned
+N8dwalT1SCU-00130-00025104-00025430 it's in rel it's in we have feeds from
+N8dwalT1SCU-00131-00025431-00025575 ansible
+N8dwalT1SCU-00132-00025576-00025855 in the openshift space we have an
+N8dwalT1SCU-00133-00025856-00025974 offering
+N8dwalT1SCU-00134-00025975-00026167 advanced cluster management that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00135-00026168-00026302 understands fleets
+N8dwalT1SCU-00136-00026304-00026583 of deployments clusters wherever they're
+N8dwalT1SCU-00137-00026583-00026655 deployed
+N8dwalT1SCU-00138-00026656-00026887 however they're running infrastructure
+N8dwalT1SCU-00139-00026888-00027062 public private hybrid environments and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00140-00027063-00027270 it also collects in the context
+N8dwalT1SCU-00141-00027272-00027495 of the workloads uh that are deployed on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00142-00027495-00027646 those on those clusters the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00143-00027647-00027799 multi-cluster environment
+N8dwalT1SCU-00144-00027800-00027967 i want to ask you guys a question i get
+N8dwalT1SCU-00145-00027968-00028102 this all the time on the cube hey you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00146-00028104-00028143 know
+N8dwalT1SCU-00147-00028144-00028327 i need more data i have multiple systems
+N8dwalT1SCU-00148-00028327-00028511 i need to pull that data into one
+N8dwalT1SCU-00149-00028512-00028774 kind of control plane but i'm being
+N8dwalT1SCU-00150-00028775-00028967 pushed more and more to keep scaling
+N8dwalT1SCU-00151-00028968-00029231 operations and this becomes a huge
+N8dwalT1SCU-00152-00029232-00029367 question mark for
+N8dwalT1SCU-00153-00029368-00029583 the enterprises because they they have
+N8dwalT1SCU-00154-00029583-00029718 to turn up more
+N8dwalT1SCU-00155-00029719-00029999 more scale so this is becomes a data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00156-00030000-00030087 problem
+N8dwalT1SCU-00157-00030088-00030262 does this solve it here how do you guys
+N8dwalT1SCU-00158-00030263-00030407 answer that and what was what would be
+N8dwalT1SCU-00159-00030408-00030662 your response to that trend
+N8dwalT1SCU-00160-00030663-00030935 well i think the um the you know thirst
+N8dwalT1SCU-00161-00030936-00031055 for data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00162-00031056-00031239 right there's a lot of things you can do
+N8dwalT1SCU-00163-00031239-00031455 with more data there is a point where
+N8dwalT1SCU-00164-00031456-00031527 you can't ship
+N8dwalT1SCU-00165-00031527-00031711 all the data everywhere right if you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00166-00031712-00031879 think about logs and metrics and all the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00167-00031880-00031958 data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00168-00031960-00032127 it's too heavy weight to move everything
+N8dwalT1SCU-00169-00032127-00032327 everywhere right so part of it is
+N8dwalT1SCU-00170-00032327-00032495 you know selecting the kind of data that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00171-00032495-00032735 you're going to get from these systems
+N8dwalT1SCU-00172-00032736-00032862 and the purpose you're going to use it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00173-00032863-00033046 for and in the case of red hat we take
+N8dwalT1SCU-00174-00033047-00033174 data from these different systems
+N8dwalT1SCU-00175-00033175-00033359 regardless of where they're deployed
+N8dwalT1SCU-00176-00033360-00033502 bring it in and then we do predictive
+N8dwalT1SCU-00177-00033503-00033662 analytics against that data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00178-00033663-00033855 and we use that telemetry that can take
+N8dwalT1SCU-00179-00033856-00033983 that health data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00180-00033984-00034262 right to do everything from optimize for
+N8dwalT1SCU-00181-00034263-00034343 performance
+N8dwalT1SCU-00182-00034344-00034655 or security cost things like that but
+N8dwalT1SCU-00183-00034656-00034807 we're not moving
+N8dwalT1SCU-00184-00034808-00035007 you know huge quantities of data from
+N8dwalT1SCU-00185-00035008-00035255 every system to red hat in order to you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00186-00035256-00035302 know
+N8dwalT1SCU-00187-00035303-00035551 pour through it we are very selectively
+N8dwalT1SCU-00188-00035552-00035639 moving
+N8dwalT1SCU-00189-00035640-00035871 um certain kinds of data for very
+N8dwalT1SCU-00190-00035872-00036102 specific purposes
+N8dwalT1SCU-00191-00036103-00036239 dave what's your take on that because
+N8dwalT1SCU-00192-00036240-00036351 you know you got to engineer these
+N8dwalT1SCU-00193-00036352-00036527 systems what's the optimized path for
+N8dwalT1SCU-00194-00036528-00036630 data do you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00195-00036631-00036879 you keep it in silo do you bring it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00196-00036880-00037118 together what's the customer's view on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00197-00037119-00037439 on how to deal with the data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00198-00037440-00037702 yeah it's a complex problem no doubt you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00199-00037703-00037974 don't want to be pulling all the data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00200-00037975-00038174 and trying to transmit all that data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00201-00038175-00038359 back into your
+N8dwalT1SCU-00202-00038360-00038743 analytics system so you end up curating
+N8dwalT1SCU-00203-00038744-00038855 some data some of you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00204-00038856-00039111 forward on often it's done it'll be done
+N8dwalT1SCU-00205-00039112-00039327 under control of policy so that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00206-00039328-00039567 data that is sensitive that should stay
+N8dwalT1SCU-00207-00039568-00039727 within the environment that it's in will
+N8dwalT1SCU-00208-00039728-00039887 stay
+N8dwalT1SCU-00209-00039888-00040271 but curated or alerts or
+N8dwalT1SCU-00210-00040272-00040543 information is particularly relevant say
+N8dwalT1SCU-00211-00040544-00040807 to configurations updates
+N8dwalT1SCU-00212-00040808-00040983 any any of that type of information will
+N8dwalT1SCU-00213-00040984-00041215 go up into the analytics into the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00214-00041216-00041327 insights
+N8dwalT1SCU-00215-00041328-00041487 and then in turn the alerts will come
+N8dwalT1SCU-00216-00041488-00041807 back down in a manner that are presented
+N8dwalT1SCU-00217-00041808-00041943 to the user so they understand what
+N8dwalT1SCU-00218-00041944-00042143 actions need to be taken place whether
+N8dwalT1SCU-00219-00042144-00042174 it's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00220-00042175-00042479 automated actions or they have to get
+N8dwalT1SCU-00221-00042480-00042646 approvals to maybe make an update to a
+N8dwalT1SCU-00222-00042647-00042774 certain environment
+N8dwalT1SCU-00223-00042775-00042943 all right you got telemetry data power
+N8dwalT1SCU-00224-00042944-00043207 the uh the advanced cluster manager acm
+N8dwalT1SCU-00225-00043208-00043455 what's the overlap of the visibility and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00226-00043456-00043630 automation here can you guys talk about
+N8dwalT1SCU-00227-00043631-00043862 that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00228-00043863-00044030 well it's a great question john what we
+N8dwalT1SCU-00229-00044031-00044174 like to do is we like to sort of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00230-00044175-00044343 separate the different areas
+N8dwalT1SCU-00231-00044344-00044551 there's the seeing right of what's going
+N8dwalT1SCU-00232-00044552-00044662 on in these environments right so
+N8dwalT1SCU-00233-00044663-00044799 getting the data analyzing it and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00234-00044800-00045007 determining what needs to be done and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00235-00045008-00045087 then
+N8dwalT1SCU-00236-00045088-00045239 the either the recommendation of the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00237-00045240-00045390 automation as dave said
+N8dwalT1SCU-00238-00045391-00045630 in a lot of environments um there's a
+N8dwalT1SCU-00239-00045631-00045695 process
+N8dwalT1SCU-00240-00045696-00045999 of either approvals or checkpoints or
+N8dwalT1SCU-00241-00046000-00046246 um you know evaluation of the changes
+N8dwalT1SCU-00242-00046247-00046399 being made to the system
+N8dwalT1SCU-00243-00046400-00046646 right so separating the data and the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00244-00046647-00046735 analysis
+N8dwalT1SCU-00245-00046736-00046862 from the what do you want to do with
+N8dwalT1SCU-00246-00046863-00046999 this and making that configurable i
+N8dwalT1SCU-00247-00047000-00047318 think is really powerful
+N8dwalT1SCU-00248-00047319-00047455 yeah that's i mean i think that's the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00249-00047456-00047607 number one thing it's like you know
+N8dwalT1SCU-00250-00047608-00047711 everyone always asks what do you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00251-00047712-00047846 optimize for do you optimize for the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00252-00047847-00048023 automation or the visibility
+N8dwalT1SCU-00253-00048024-00048151 and i think you know there's always a
+N8dwalT1SCU-00254-00048152-00048343 trade-off and that's always an
+N8dwalT1SCU-00255-00048344-00048471 interesting question david love to get
+N8dwalT1SCU-00256-00048472-00048615 your thoughts if someone asks you hey
+N8dwalT1SCU-00257-00048616-00048695 i'm
+N8dwalT1SCU-00258-00048696-00048815 i have a team of people what do i
+N8dwalT1SCU-00259-00048816-00049046 optimize for the visibility or the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00260-00049047-00049118 automation
+N8dwalT1SCU-00261-00049119-00049335 or both is there is there a rule of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00262-00049336-00049558 thumb or is there a playbook
+N8dwalT1SCU-00263-00049559-00049855 which how would you answer that question
+N8dwalT1SCU-00264-00049856-00049983 well there's a couple of things
+N8dwalT1SCU-00265-00049984-00050286 um i first i think the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00266-00050287-00050583 ability to pull the data together to get
+N8dwalT1SCU-00267-00050584-00050767 visibility across the environment
+N8dwalT1SCU-00268-00050768-00051111 is critical and then
+N8dwalT1SCU-00269-00051112-00051407 what becomes often complex is how the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00270-00051408-00051454 different
+N8dwalT1SCU-00271-00051455-00051687 disciplines how the different parts of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00272-00051688-00051879 the system are able to work together
+N8dwalT1SCU-00273-00051879-00052014 and common understanding of the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00274-00052015-00052190 resources common understanding the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00275-00052191-00052326 applications
+N8dwalT1SCU-00276-00052327-00052623 um that's usually where systems start
+N8dwalT1SCU-00277-00052624-00052719 falling down
+N8dwalT1SCU-00278-00052720-00052975 and so it's too siloed so one of the key
+N8dwalT1SCU-00279-00052976-00053175 things we have with
+N8dwalT1SCU-00280-00053176-00053382 with our systems particularly with
+N8dwalT1SCU-00281-00053383-00053479 openshift
+N8dwalT1SCU-00282-00053479-00053799 and rel and with acm
+N8dwalT1SCU-00283-00053800-00054150 and ansible is the ability to have
+N8dwalT1SCU-00284-00054151-00054326 a common back plane and the ability to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00285-00054327-00054471 have a common understanding of the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00286-00054472-00054703 resources and the applications
+N8dwalT1SCU-00287-00054704-00054903 and then you can start integrating the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00288-00054904-00055135 data around that common those common
+N8dwalT1SCU-00289-00055136-00055375 data models and take appropriate actions
+N8dwalT1SCU-00290-00055376-00055623 on that so that's how you end up getting
+N8dwalT1SCU-00291-00055624-00055719 the visibility
+N8dwalT1SCU-00292-00055720-00055959 integrated with the automation when you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00293-00055960-00056071 think about this
+N8dwalT1SCU-00294-00056072-00056303 uh joe about the security aspect of it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00295-00056304-00056430 and the edge of the network which has
+N8dwalT1SCU-00296-00056432-00056566 been a big theme this year
+N8dwalT1SCU-00297-00056567-00056766 and going into next year a lot more
+N8dwalT1SCU-00298-00056767-00057023 discussion and just the industrial edge
+N8dwalT1SCU-00299-00057024-00057391 you know um that's important
+N8dwalT1SCU-00300-00057391-00057519 you've got to take all this into account
+N8dwalT1SCU-00301-00057520-00057703 how do how would you talk about folks
+N8dwalT1SCU-00302-00057704-00057838 who are thinking about embedding
+N8dwalT1SCU-00303-00057839-00058015 security and thinking about now the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00304-00058016-00058111 distributed edge
+N8dwalT1SCU-00305-00058112-00058430 specifically right so we thought was
+N8dwalT1SCU-00306-00058432-00058559 complicated before right
+N8dwalT1SCU-00307-00058560-00058815 it goes up a notch here right as you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00308-00058816-00058903 have you know
+N8dwalT1SCU-00309-00058904-00059126 more and more edge applications i think
+N8dwalT1SCU-00310-00059127-00059238 at the end you're going to want
+N8dwalT1SCU-00311-00059239-00059430 automated policies and automated
+N8dwalT1SCU-00312-00059432-00059623 configurations in force
+N8dwalT1SCU-00313-00059624-00059775 so that when a device connects up to a
+N8dwalT1SCU-00314-00059776-00059935 network or is uh
+N8dwalT1SCU-00315-00059936-00060135 you know analyzed that there's a set of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00316-00060136-00060366 policies and a set of configurations and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00317-00060367-00060447 versions
+N8dwalT1SCU-00318-00060448-00060654 that need to be applied to that device
+N8dwalT1SCU-00319-00060655-00060838 these devices aren't always connected
+N8dwalT1SCU-00320-00060839-00061023 there's not always high bandwidth
+N8dwalT1SCU-00321-00061024-00061271 um so you basically want a high degree
+N8dwalT1SCU-00322-00061272-00061375 of automation
+N8dwalT1SCU-00323-00061376-00061535 in that case and to get back to your
+N8dwalT1SCU-00324-00061536-00061703 early point there are certain things you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00325-00061704-00061926 can set like policies about security or
+N8dwalT1SCU-00326-00061927-00062094 configuration you say i always want it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00327-00062095-00062199 to be like this
+N8dwalT1SCU-00328-00062200-00062406 make it so and there's other things
+N8dwalT1SCU-00329-00062407-00062550 where they're more
+N8dwalT1SCU-00330-00062551-00062815 uh you know complicated right to to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00331-00062816-00062935 address or have
+N8dwalT1SCU-00332-00062936-00063238 regulatory requirements or oversight
+N8dwalT1SCU-00333-00063239-00063406 issues and those things you want to tell
+N8dwalT1SCU-00334-00063407-00063559 somebody i think
+N8dwalT1SCU-00335-00063560-00063759 this should be done is this the right
+N8dwalT1SCU-00336-00063760-00063903 thing to do is it okay
+N8dwalT1SCU-00337-00063904-00064071 do it but at the end you're going to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00338-00064072-00064303 have a lot more sort of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00339-00064304-00064535 lights out automation to keep these
+N8dwalT1SCU-00340-00064536-00064694 things secure to configure right
+N8dwalT1SCU-00341-00064695-00064847 it's funny i thought the ansible guys
+N8dwalT1SCU-00342-00064848-00065023 are talking about you know code for code
+N8dwalT1SCU-00343-00065024-00065223 changing code all the time and dynamic
+N8dwalT1SCU-00344-00065224-00065342 nature of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00345-00065344-00065511 some of the emerging tech coming out of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00346-00065512-00065679 the the red hat teams
+N8dwalT1SCU-00347-00065680-00065815 it's pretty interesting you guys have
+N8dwalT1SCU-00348-00065816-00065967 going on there but you know you bring it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00349-00065968-00066094 down to the average
+N8dwalT1SCU-00350-00066095-00066311 enterprise and main street uh you know
+N8dwalT1SCU-00351-00066312-00066438 enterprise out there
+N8dwalT1SCU-00352-00066439-00066671 you know they're looking at okay i got
+N8dwalT1SCU-00353-00066672-00066871 some public cloud now i got hybrid
+N8dwalT1SCU-00354-00066872-00067047 i'm going 100 hybrid that's pretty much
+N8dwalT1SCU-00355-00067048-00067191 the general consensus of all the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00356-00067192-00067279 enterprises
+N8dwalT1SCU-00357-00067280-00067494 okay so now you say okay if i understand
+N8dwalT1SCU-00358-00067495-00067671 this correctly you got insights on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00359-00067672-00067991 rel open shift and ansible platform
+N8dwalT1SCU-00360-00067992-00068294 so am i set up for an open hybrid cloud
+N8dwalT1SCU-00361-00068295-00068431 that's the question i want to ask you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00362-00068432-00068663 guys does that give me the foundation
+N8dwalT1SCU-00363-00068664-00068871 to allow me to start the cloud adoption
+N8dwalT1SCU-00364-00068872-00069326 with in a true distributed open way
+N8dwalT1SCU-00365-00069327-00069503 well i'll offer to go first i think
+N8dwalT1SCU-00366-00069504-00069615 there's a couple of things you need in
+N8dwalT1SCU-00367-00069616-00069823 order to run across cyber clouds
+N8dwalT1SCU-00368-00069824-00069975 and i think red hat from a platform
+N8dwalT1SCU-00369-00069976-00070103 point of view the fact that red hat
+N8dwalT1SCU-00370-00070104-00070287 platforms run across all those different
+N8dwalT1SCU-00371-00070288-00070391 environments
+N8dwalT1SCU-00372-00070392-00070638 from the public cloud to on-premise
+N8dwalT1SCU-00373-00070639-00070815 physical vert to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00374-00070816-00071094 edge devices now you have consistency of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00375-00071095-00071231 those platforms whether it's your
+N8dwalT1SCU-00376-00071232-00071382 traditional workloads on rel
+N8dwalT1SCU-00377-00071383-00071511 your container-based workloads on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00378-00071512-00071703 openshift um or
+N8dwalT1SCU-00379-00071704-00071847 automation that's being driven by
+N8dwalT1SCU-00380-00071848-00072159 ansible those are consistent across all
+N8dwalT1SCU-00381-00072160-00072303 these different hybrid cloud
+N8dwalT1SCU-00382-00072304-00072423 environments so it reduces the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00383-00072424-00072599 complexity by standardizing those
+N8dwalT1SCU-00384-00072600-00072759 platforms across any and all of those
+N8dwalT1SCU-00385-00072760-00072831 different
+N8dwalT1SCU-00386-00072832-00073199 um substrates
+N8dwalT1SCU-00387-00073200-00073359 then when you can take the data from
+N8dwalT1SCU-00388-00073360-00073535 those systems bring them centrally and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00389-00073536-00073662 use it to manage those things to a
+N8dwalT1SCU-00390-00073663-00073791 higher degree of automation
+N8dwalT1SCU-00391-00073792-00074006 now you've taken another sort of chunk
+N8dwalT1SCU-00392-00074007-00074223 of complexity out of the problem
+N8dwalT1SCU-00393-00074224-00074415 right consistency of getting data from
+N8dwalT1SCU-00394-00074416-00074535 all those different systems
+N8dwalT1SCU-00395-00074536-00074711 being able to set policies and enforce
+N8dwalT1SCU-00396-00074712-00074862 things across all those distributed
+N8dwalT1SCU-00397-00074863-00074999 environments is huge
+N8dwalT1SCU-00398-00075000-00075159 yeah and then yes you know it fills in
+N8dwalT1SCU-00399-00075160-00075294 the gaps when you start thinking about
+N8dwalT1SCU-00400-00075295-00075471 the silo teams
+N8dwalT1SCU-00401-00075472-00075662 you know that uh i think one of the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00402-00075663-00075799 messages that i've been hearing out of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00403-00075800-00075950 red hat summit in the industry that's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00404-00075951-00076047 consistent is
+N8dwalT1SCU-00405-00076048-00076279 the unification trend that's going on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00406-00076280-00076438 unifying development teams
+N8dwalT1SCU-00407-00076439-00076671 in a way that creates more of an
+N8dwalT1SCU-00408-00076672-00076862 exponential value curve rather than just
+N8dwalT1SCU-00409-00076863-00076919 linear
+N8dwalT1SCU-00410-00076920-00077294 progressions in traditional i.t
+N8dwalT1SCU-00411-00077295-00077487 um are you guys seeing that as well i
+N8dwalT1SCU-00412-00077488-00077606 mean what's your
+N8dwalT1SCU-00413-00077607-00077831 take on this uh that's that piece of the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00414-00077832-00077950 story
+N8dwalT1SCU-00415-00077951-00078167 well i think the shift that we've seen
+N8dwalT1SCU-00416-00078168-00078343 for the last few years actually quite a
+N8dwalT1SCU-00417-00078344-00078455 few years
+N8dwalT1SCU-00418-00078456-00078735 uh with devops and sre it started to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00419-00078736-00078903 bring a lot of the disciplines together
+N8dwalT1SCU-00420-00078904-00078991 that you mentioned that are
+N8dwalT1SCU-00421-00078992-00079159 traditionally silos
+N8dwalT1SCU-00422-00079160-00079391 and you'll find the effectiveness of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00423-00079392-00079567 that is really around
+N8dwalT1SCU-00424-00079568-00079694 many of the areas that we've been
+N8dwalT1SCU-00425-00079695-00080006 discussing here which is open platforms
+N8dwalT1SCU-00426-00080007-00080206 that can run consistently across a
+N8dwalT1SCU-00427-00080207-00080350 hybrid environment
+N8dwalT1SCU-00428-00080351-00080655 the ability to get data and visibility
+N8dwalT1SCU-00429-00080656-00080894 out of those platforms so you can see
+N8dwalT1SCU-00430-00080895-00081103 across the distributed environment
+N8dwalT1SCU-00431-00081104-00081287 across the hybrid environment
+N8dwalT1SCU-00432-00081288-00081687 and then the ability to take actions
+N8dwalT1SCU-00433-00081688-00082047 enforce or um update environments
+N8dwalT1SCU-00434-00082048-00082182 through automation
+N8dwalT1SCU-00435-00082183-00082503 um is is really this was critical to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00436-00082504-00082591 bring things to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00437-00082592-00082750 to bring it all together yeah i think
+N8dwalT1SCU-00438-00082751-00082903 that's such an important point joe you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00439-00082904-00083047 know i was talking with chris wright
+N8dwalT1SCU-00440-00083048-00083111 around
+N8dwalT1SCU-00441-00083112-00083303 and we've covered this in the past uh
+N8dwalT1SCU-00442-00083304-00083518 red hat's success with academics
+N8dwalT1SCU-00443-00083519-00083718 um and the young people coming into the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00444-00083719-00083903 universities with computer science
+N8dwalT1SCU-00445-00083904-00084047 it's not just computer science anymore
+N8dwalT1SCU-00446-00084048-00084247 now you have engineering degrees
+N8dwalT1SCU-00447-00084248-00084462 kind of cross-disciplinary with sres as
+N8dwalT1SCU-00448-00084463-00084582 sre movement
+N8dwalT1SCU-00449-00084583-00084735 because you're looking at cloud
+N8dwalT1SCU-00450-00084736-00084918 operations at scale
+N8dwalT1SCU-00451-00084919-00085159 that's not an i.t problem anymore it's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00452-00085160-00085318 actually an i.t
+N8dwalT1SCU-00453-00085319-00085606 next-gen problem this is kind of what
+N8dwalT1SCU-00454-00085607-00085767 there's no real degree there's no
+N8dwalT1SCU-00455-00085768-00086118 real credential for you know large-scale
+N8dwalT1SCU-00456-00086119-00086271 hybrid cloud environments you just got
+N8dwalT1SCU-00457-00086272-00086511 the mass open cloud initiative
+N8dwalT1SCU-00458-00086512-00086703 i saw that going on that's some really
+N8dwalT1SCU-00459-00086704-00086887 pretty big things this is a
+N8dwalT1SCU-00460-00086888-00087199 a change in and talent what's your
+N8dwalT1SCU-00461-00087200-00087335 what's your uh view on this because i
+N8dwalT1SCU-00462-00087336-00087462 think people want to learn what
+N8dwalT1SCU-00463-00087463-00087615 what do i need to be in the future what
+N8dwalT1SCU-00464-00087616-00087879 position so john it's a great question i
+N8dwalT1SCU-00465-00087880-00087935 think um
+N8dwalT1SCU-00466-00087936-00088143 ansible actually addresses a number of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00467-00088144-00088335 the issues you brought up which is
+N8dwalT1SCU-00468-00088336-00088471 you know historically there have been
+N8dwalT1SCU-00469-00088472-00088599 different tools for each of the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00470-00088600-00088759 different groups
+N8dwalT1SCU-00471-00088760-00088918 so developers had their favorite set of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00472-00088919-00089126 tools and different i.t areas had their
+N8dwalT1SCU-00473-00089127-00089335 favorite set of tools and technologies
+N8dwalT1SCU-00474-00089336-00089494 and it was sort of like a tower battle
+N8dwalT1SCU-00475-00089495-00089671 people did not share the same
+N8dwalT1SCU-00476-00089672-00089903 sort of languages and tools ansible
+N8dwalT1SCU-00477-00089904-00089999 crosses
+N8dwalT1SCU-00478-00090000-00090238 both your your development test and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00479-00090239-00090359 operational teams
+N8dwalT1SCU-00480-00090360-00090535 so it creates a common language now that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00481-00090536-00090750 can be used across different teams
+N8dwalT1SCU-00482-00090751-00090943 it's easy to understand so it sort of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00483-00090944-00091118 democratizes automation
+N8dwalT1SCU-00484-00091119-00091503 you don't have to be deeply skilled
+N8dwalT1SCU-00485-00091504-00091775 in some you know bespoke language or
+N8dwalT1SCU-00486-00091776-00091959 technology in order to be able to do
+N8dwalT1SCU-00487-00091960-00092175 some level of automation so i think sort
+N8dwalT1SCU-00488-00092176-00092399 of sharing the same technology and tools
+N8dwalT1SCU-00489-00092400-00092662 like an ansible um democratizing it so
+N8dwalT1SCU-00490-00092663-00092838 that more people can get involved in
+N8dwalT1SCU-00491-00092839-00092943 automating
+N8dwalT1SCU-00492-00092944-00093150 sharing that automation across teams and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00493-00093151-00093318 unifying those worlds
+N8dwalT1SCU-00494-00093319-00093559 is huge right so i think that's a game
+N8dwalT1SCU-00495-00093560-00093726 changer as well in terms of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00496-00093727-00093882 uh getting these teams to work
+N8dwalT1SCU-00497-00093883-00094023 holistically and integrated in the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00498-00094024-00094103 future
+N8dwalT1SCU-00499-00094104-00094255 yeah and there's also a better together
+N8dwalT1SCU-00500-00094256-00094455 panel an ansible and advanced cluster
+N8dwalT1SCU-00501-00094456-00094567 management session
+N8dwalT1SCU-00502-00094568-00094774 folks watching should check it out on on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00503-00094775-00094950 the virtual event platform
+N8dwalT1SCU-00504-00094951-00095191 on that point while i got you here on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00505-00095192-00095271 that point let's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00506-00095272-00095447 let's talk about the portfolio updates
+N8dwalT1SCU-00507-00095448-00095591 for advanced cluster management for
+N8dwalT1SCU-00508-00095592-00095711 kubernetes
+N8dwalT1SCU-00509-00095712-00095982 um what's new since the ansible ansible
+N8dwalT1SCU-00510-00095983-00096167 fest announcements
+N8dwalT1SCU-00511-00096168-00096303 there's quite a bit that's been new
+N8dwalT1SCU-00512-00096304-00096606 since uh ansible fest that ansible best
+N8dwalT1SCU-00513-00096607-00096638 um
+N8dwalT1SCU-00514-00096639-00096862 well actually going back to summit last
+N8dwalT1SCU-00515-00096863-00096991 year we introduced
+N8dwalT1SCU-00516-00096992-00097326 advanced cluster management we for years
+N8dwalT1SCU-00517-00097327-00097471 we've been seeing the growth
+N8dwalT1SCU-00518-00097472-00097806 of kubernetes with cloud native and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00519-00097807-00098126 clusters and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00520-00098127-00098406 what what what acm really allows
+N8dwalT1SCU-00521-00098407-00098518 enterprises to do
+N8dwalT1SCU-00522-00098519-00098887 is is scale out their deployments
+N8dwalT1SCU-00523-00098888-00099159 of of openshift one of the things we
+N8dwalT1SCU-00524-00099160-00099199 found
+N8dwalT1SCU-00525-00099200-00099487 is that as you're deploying workloads or
+N8dwalT1SCU-00526-00099488-00099671 clusters or trying to take care of the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00527-00099672-00099759 compliance
+N8dwalT1SCU-00528-00099760-00099911 the importance of integrating that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00529-00099912-00100135 environment with the breadth of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00530-00100136-00100303 capabilities that ansible has in
+N8dwalT1SCU-00531-00100304-00100494 automation so that's what we announced
+N8dwalT1SCU-00532-00100495-00100679 at ansible best following last year's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00533-00100680-00100911 summit what we've done is
+N8dwalT1SCU-00534-00100912-00101318 put a lot more focus on that integration
+N8dwalT1SCU-00535-00101319-00101599 with with ansible so when you bring up
+N8dwalT1SCU-00536-00101600-00101855 you know provision a cluster
+N8dwalT1SCU-00537-00101856-00102055 maybe you need to make some storage or
+N8dwalT1SCU-00538-00102056-00102262 security configurations on behalf of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00539-00102263-00102335 that cluster
+N8dwalT1SCU-00540-00102336-00102582 or if you're taking care of the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00541-00102583-00102775 compliance how do you remediate any
+N8dwalT1SCU-00542-00102776-00102839 issues
+N8dwalT1SCU-00543-00102840-00103094 with ansible or one of the things that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00544-00103095-00103182 gets shown a lot
+N8dwalT1SCU-00545-00103183-00103375 demonstrated a lot of customers like is
+N8dwalT1SCU-00546-00103376-00103527 when you're deploying applications in
+N8dwalT1SCU-00547-00103528-00103606 production
+N8dwalT1SCU-00548-00103607-00103934 how do you configure uh the network uh
+N8dwalT1SCU-00549-00103935-00104078 do the network configurations like a
+N8dwalT1SCU-00550-00104079-00104342 load balancer maybe a ticket into your
+N8dwalT1SCU-00551-00104343-00104510 service management system
+N8dwalT1SCU-00552-00104511-00104710 along with say uh threat detection on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00553-00104711-00104823 your security
+N8dwalT1SCU-00554-00104824-00105175 so a lot of advances with acm
+N8dwalT1SCU-00555-00105176-00105327 in the integration with the broader
+N8dwalT1SCU-00556-00105328-00105647 ecosystem of it in particular
+N8dwalT1SCU-00557-00105648-00105975 with uh with ansible what's the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00558-00105976-00106158 ecosystem update for partners and this
+N8dwalT1SCU-00559-00106159-00106271 comes up all the time i want to make
+N8dwalT1SCU-00560-00106272-00106383 sure i get this in there
+N8dwalT1SCU-00561-00106383-00106566 i missed it last time we chatted you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00562-00106567-00106710 know the partner impact
+N8dwalT1SCU-00563-00106711-00106999 to this you mentioned the ecosystem and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00564-00107000-00107207 you got native kubernetes non-native
+N8dwalT1SCU-00565-00107208-00107302 what's native to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00566-00107303-00107463 everything you guys got a lot of native
+N8dwalT1SCU-00567-00107464-00107607 things and sometimes it's just support
+N8dwalT1SCU-00568-00107608-00107734 for other clouds so
+N8dwalT1SCU-00569-00107735-00107895 you start to get into the integration
+N8dwalT1SCU-00570-00107896-00108095 questions partners are very interested
+N8dwalT1SCU-00571-00108096-00108231 in what you guys are doing can you share
+N8dwalT1SCU-00572-00108232-00108447 the partner update on how they play and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00573-00108448-00108975 what impacts them the most here
+N8dwalT1SCU-00574-00108976-00109327 yeah on the advanced
+N8dwalT1SCU-00575-00109328-00109710 cluster management the acm front uh
+N8dwalT1SCU-00576-00109711-00110102 first with this integration with ansible
+N8dwalT1SCU-00577-00110103-00110375 that actually allows us to integrate
+N8dwalT1SCU-00578-00110376-00110439 with
+N8dwalT1SCU-00579-00110440-00110695 the wealth of partner ecosystem the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00580-00110696-00110863 hands of glass which is huge
+N8dwalT1SCU-00581-00110864-00111239 so that's that's one one space and then
+N8dwalT1SCU-00582-00111240-00111815 the way acm works this policy
+N8dwalT1SCU-00583-00111816-00112095 desire state model is we've been able to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00584-00112096-00112158 integrate
+N8dwalT1SCU-00585-00112159-00112390 with a large number of partners around
+N8dwalT1SCU-00586-00112391-00112566 particularly the security space
+N8dwalT1SCU-00587-00112567-00112839 of the service management space with age
+N8dwalT1SCU-00588-00112840-00113007 where we can enforce the use of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00589-00113008-00113343 certain security tools uh on the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00590-00113344-00113527 on the clusters themselves so it's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00591-00113528-00113647 really opened up
+N8dwalT1SCU-00592-00113648-00114063 how quickly partner offerings can be
+N8dwalT1SCU-00593-00114064-00114231 integrated into the openshift
+N8dwalT1SCU-00594-00114232-00114415 environment at scale across all the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00595-00114416-00114583 clusters that you want
+N8dwalT1SCU-00596-00114583-00114727 that you need to support it on with the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00597-00114728-00114990 appropriate configurations and policies
+N8dwalT1SCU-00598-00114991-00115166 joe i got to ask you on the inside
+N8dwalT1SCU-00599-00115167-00115343 side you mentioned the expansion across
+N8dwalT1SCU-00600-00115344-00115478 the platforms now if you go out take it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00601-00115479-00115607 out to the ecosystem
+N8dwalT1SCU-00602-00115608-00115766 you know there's guardrails around
+N8dwalT1SCU-00603-00115767-00115990 governance how far can partners push
+N8dwalT1SCU-00604-00115991-00116078 their data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00605-00116079-00116215 in terms of sharing that's something
+N8dwalT1SCU-00606-00116216-00116358 that might come up when you comment on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00607-00116359-00116510 that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00608-00116511-00116831 sure so uh red hat um you know takes
+N8dwalT1SCU-00609-00116832-00116966 you know our customer data very
+N8dwalT1SCU-00610-00116967-00117166 seriously more a trusted
+N8dwalT1SCU-00611-00117167-00117390 partner to our customers so the data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00612-00117391-00117583 that we get from systems we
+N8dwalT1SCU-00613-00117583-00117758 make sure that we are following all of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00614-00117759-00117951 the governance and oversight necessary
+N8dwalT1SCU-00615-00117952-00118095 to protect that data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00616-00118096-00118334 so far we have basically been collecting
+N8dwalT1SCU-00617-00118335-00118607 that data and using that data at red hat
+N8dwalT1SCU-00618-00118608-00118886 our plan really is to allow partners
+N8dwalT1SCU-00619-00118888-00119071 with the right degree of governance and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00620-00119072-00119143 control
+N8dwalT1SCU-00621-00119144-00119375 to be able to use some of that data in
+N8dwalT1SCU-00622-00119376-00119510 the future
+N8dwalT1SCU-00623-00119511-00119654 under the right conditions whether it's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00624-00119655-00119886 anonymized or aggregated
+N8dwalT1SCU-00625-00119888-00120023 things like that to be able to take that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00626-00120024-00120319 data and to add value to customers
+N8dwalT1SCU-00627-00120320-00120583 if they can enrich customers or or help
+N8dwalT1SCU-00628-00120583-00120663 customers
+N8dwalT1SCU-00629-00120664-00120831 by getting some access to that data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00630-00120832-00120975 without every
+N8dwalT1SCU-00631-00120976-00121119 vendor or partner having to go out to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00632-00121120-00121310 systems and having to connect and pull
+N8dwalT1SCU-00633-00121311-00121407 data back
+N8dwalT1SCU-00634-00121408-00121702 that's a pretty tough situation for
+N8dwalT1SCU-00635-00121703-00121799 customers to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00636-00121800-00122095 live with but i think that fact that red
+N8dwalT1SCU-00637-00122096-00122207 head is trusted
+N8dwalT1SCU-00638-00122208-00122343 we've been doing this for a while we
+N8dwalT1SCU-00639-00122344-00122510 know how to handle the data we know how
+N8dwalT1SCU-00640-00122511-00122663 to provide the governance
+N8dwalT1SCU-00641-00122664-00122927 but our plan really is to enable
+N8dwalT1SCU-00642-00122928-00122990 partners
+N8dwalT1SCU-00643-00122991-00123310 to use that data ecosystem i will say
+N8dwalT1SCU-00644-00123311-00123375 that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00645-00123376-00123534 in addition what dave said about acm and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00646-00123535-00123743 partners ansible has been
+N8dwalT1SCU-00647-00123744-00123919 um working with partners on the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00648-00123920-00124078 automation side
+N8dwalT1SCU-00649-00124079-00124319 uh at a very large scale right so if you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00650-00124320-00124478 look at the amount of partners that are
+N8dwalT1SCU-00651-00124479-00124702 doing automation work with us we have
+N8dwalT1SCU-00652-00124703-00124863 some pretty strong
+N8dwalT1SCU-00653-00124864-00125102 you know depth there in terms of working
+N8dwalT1SCU-00654-00125103-00125183 with partners
+N8dwalT1SCU-00655-00125183-00125343 our plan is to take the data ecosystem
+N8dwalT1SCU-00656-00125344-00125486 and expand that as well
+N8dwalT1SCU-00657-00125488-00125654 it's really a nice mix between ansible
+N8dwalT1SCU-00658-00125655-00125831 open shift and then rel you guys have
+N8dwalT1SCU-00659-00125832-00126014 great insights across now
+N8dwalT1SCU-00660-00126015-00126247 i think the open innovation just
+N8dwalT1SCU-00661-00126248-00126390 continues to be
+N8dwalT1SCU-00662-00126391-00126566 every year i i say the same thing it's
+N8dwalT1SCU-00663-00126567-00126775 almost like a broken record but every
+N8dwalT1SCU-00664-00126776-00126958 year it just gets better and better
+N8dwalT1SCU-00665-00126959-00127134 you know innovation out in the open you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00666-00127135-00127343 guys doing a great job and continuing
+N8dwalT1SCU-00667-00127344-00127543 and now certainly as the pandemic looks
+N8dwalT1SCU-00668-00127544-00127727 like it's coming to an end soon
+N8dwalT1SCU-00669-00127728-00127975 post pandemic a lot more projects are
+N8dwalT1SCU-00670-00127976-00128063 being
+N8dwalT1SCU-00671-00128064-00128343 worked on a lot more productivity as we
+N8dwalT1SCU-00672-00128344-00128495 said at the top
+N8dwalT1SCU-00673-00128496-00128654 so to end this segment out i'd love to
+N8dwalT1SCU-00674-00128655-00128878 get you guys to weigh in on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00675-00128879-00129023 what happens next as we come out of the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00676-00129024-00129278 pandemic the table has been set the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00677-00129279-00129463 foundation's there
+N8dwalT1SCU-00678-00129464-00129702 cloud native is continuing to accelerate
+N8dwalT1SCU-00679-00129703-00129831 rapidly
+N8dwalT1SCU-00680-00129832-00130007 in the open open source going to another
+N8dwalT1SCU-00681-00130008-00130166 level
+N8dwalT1SCU-00682-00130167-00130478 what's next what's what's gonna what
+N8dwalT1SCU-00683-00130479-00130614 what's next for customers are they gonna
+N8dwalT1SCU-00684-00130615-00130807 continue to double down on those the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00685-00130808-00130943 wins they're gonna shut down certain
+N8dwalT1SCU-00686-00130944-00131063 projects
+N8dwalT1SCU-00687-00131064-00131271 what happens after this pandemic how do
+N8dwalT1SCU-00688-00131272-00131663 people grow dave will start with you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00689-00131664-00131999 well i think yes we all see the light at
+N8dwalT1SCU-00690-00132000-00132183 the end of the tunnel john
+N8dwalT1SCU-00691-00132184-00132607 is great and i think if
+N8dwalT1SCU-00692-00132608-00132935 a positive is really throughout this
+N8dwalT1SCU-00693-00132936-00133151 we've been accelerating the digitization
+N8dwalT1SCU-00694-00133152-00133343 and app modernization across the board
+N8dwalT1SCU-00695-00133344-00133390 across
+N8dwalT1SCU-00696-00133391-00133702 industries okay and that
+N8dwalT1SCU-00697-00133703-00134078 is really teaching all of us a lot about
+N8dwalT1SCU-00698-00134079-00134278 the importance of how do you start
+N8dwalT1SCU-00699-00134279-00134439 managing and running this at scale and
+N8dwalT1SCU-00700-00134440-00134654 securing this at scale so i think what
+N8dwalT1SCU-00701-00134655-00134711 we'll see
+N8dwalT1SCU-00702-00134712-00134966 coming out of this is just that much
+N8dwalT1SCU-00703-00134967-00135087 more effort
+N8dwalT1SCU-00704-00135088-00135399 and open ecosystems how you really bring
+N8dwalT1SCU-00705-00135400-00135471 together
+N8dwalT1SCU-00706-00135472-00135799 data across insights how you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00707-00135800-00136135 bring in increasing amount of analytics
+N8dwalT1SCU-00708-00136136-00136454 ai to now do something uh turn that data
+N8dwalT1SCU-00709-00136455-00136631 into information that you can respond
+N8dwalT1SCU-00710-00136632-00136687 with
+N8dwalT1SCU-00711-00136688-00136863 and that in turn close it closing the
+N8dwalT1SCU-00712-00136864-00137031 loop with automation
+N8dwalT1SCU-00713-00137032-00137263 against your against your hybrid cloud
+N8dwalT1SCU-00714-00137264-00137359 environment
+N8dwalT1SCU-00715-00137360-00137502 we're just going to the acceleration of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00716-00137503-00137743 that occurring awesome great insights
+N8dwalT1SCU-00717-00137744-00137871 there open
+N8dwalT1SCU-00718-00137872-00138054 data insights automation all kind of
+N8dwalT1SCU-00719-00138055-00138247 coming together ai if you don't have ai
+N8dwalT1SCU-00720-00138248-00138319 in your
+N8dwalT1SCU-00721-00138320-00138519 your plans someone was wall street was
+N8dwalT1SCU-00722-00138520-00138639 joking that's going to be the future
+N8dwalT1SCU-00723-00138640-00138799 stable stakes get listed on wall
+N8dwalT1SCU-00724-00138800-00138975 street you got to have some sort of ai
+N8dwalT1SCU-00725-00138976-00139135 piece there's great insight
+N8dwalT1SCU-00726-00139136-00139375 joe your take on what's next what what
+N8dwalT1SCU-00727-00139376-00139487 what's going to what's going to happen
+N8dwalT1SCU-00728-00139488-00139775 as we come out of the pandemic
+N8dwalT1SCU-00729-00139776-00139959 yeah we're definitely seeing people you
+N8dwalT1SCU-00730-00139960-00140095 know advance their digital
+N8dwalT1SCU-00731-00140096-00140263 transformation
+N8dwalT1SCU-00732-00140264-00140407 and i don't think it's going to stop
+N8dwalT1SCU-00733-00140408-00140590 right so the speed scale and complexity
+N8dwalT1SCU-00734-00140591-00140735 are just going to put more pressure on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00735-00140736-00140943 teams right to be able to support these
+N8dwalT1SCU-00736-00140944-00141102 environments that are evolving at light
+N8dwalT1SCU-00737-00141103-00141199 speed
+N8dwalT1SCU-00738-00141200-00141383 so i think red hat is really well
+N8dwalT1SCU-00739-00141384-00141551 positioned and is a great partner for
+N8dwalT1SCU-00740-00141552-00141623 folks
+N8dwalT1SCU-00741-00141624-00141919 who are trying to get more digital
+N8dwalT1SCU-00742-00141920-00142007 faster
+N8dwalT1SCU-00743-00142008-00142175 trying to leverage these technologies
+N8dwalT1SCU-00744-00142176-00142375 from the hybrid cloud to the edge
+N8dwalT1SCU-00745-00142376-00142519 they're going to need lots of help red
+N8dwalT1SCU-00746-00142520-00142743 hat is in a great position to help them
+N8dwalT1SCU-00747-00142744-00142902 you guys doing great work dave lindquist
+N8dwalT1SCU-00748-00142903-00143078 joe fitzgerald great to have you back on
+N8dwalT1SCU-00749-00143079-00143143 again
+N8dwalT1SCU-00750-00143144-00143502 open always wins and as end users become
+N8dwalT1SCU-00751-00143503-00143663 much more participants in the open
+N8dwalT1SCU-00752-00143664-00143823 source ecosystem
+N8dwalT1SCU-00753-00143824-00144095 end user contributions and user
+N8dwalT1SCU-00754-00144096-00144343 interactions software at scale
+N8dwalT1SCU-00755-00144344-00144543 it's it's now a new next generation
+N8dwalT1SCU-00756-00144544-00144647 commercial
+N8dwalT1SCU-00757-00144648-00144807 environment guys doing a great job thank
+N8dwalT1SCU-00758-00144808-00145095 you for sharing appreciate it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00759-00145096-00145375 thank you john thanks john okay red hat
+N8dwalT1SCU-00760-00145376-00145654 summit 21 cube coverage i'm john furrier
+N8dwalT1SCU-00761-00145655-00145799 getting all the action from the experts
+N8dwalT1SCU-00762-00145800-00145983 have been there done that living through
+N8dwalT1SCU-00763-00145984-00146023 it
+N8dwalT1SCU-00764-00146024-00146166 being more productive and bringing
+N8dwalT1SCU-00765-00146167-00146366 benefits to you being open source
+N8dwalT1SCU-00766-00146367-00147654 thanks for watching
+N8dwalT1SCU-00767-00147655-00147864 you
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00000-00000208-00000471 what's going on y'all what's happening
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00001-00000472-00000607 you know what
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00002-00000608-00000839 today just one of them days i feel like
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00003-00000840-00000935 just
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00004-00000936-00001150 letting y'all hear some of these
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00005-00001151-00001391 great sounds from this elisa's qx6
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00006-00001392-00001527 synthesizer
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00007-00001528-00001807 i use it all the time in my mixes
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00008-00001807-00001895 and
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00009-00001896-00002087 i just had to bring it out man because
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00010-00002088-00002310 it sounds so good i'm gonna go ahead and
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00011-00002311-00002637 let y'all hear something right quick
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00012-00002638-00003007 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00013-00003008-00003239 y'all hear how it sounds
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00014-00003240-00004151 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00015-00004152-00004319 now i'm only doing this
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00016-00004320-00004473 just to kind of
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00017-00004474-00004622 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00018-00004623-00004751 you know
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00019-00004752-00005135 bring out the fact that
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00020-00005136-00005479 you know even though
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00021-00005480-00005727 this stuff came out like what
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00022-00005728-00005902 20 years ago or something like that
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00023-00005903-00006143 maybe more
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00024-00006144-00006202 is that
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00025-00006203-00006470 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00026-00006472-00006727 a lot of times it's not about how old it
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00027-00006728-00006806 is
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00028-00006808-00006967 it's just about
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00029-00006968-00007437 how well you know how to work it
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00030-00007438-00008930 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00031-00008931-00009548 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00032-00009549-00009751 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00033-00009752-00009959 now you know what y'all
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00034-00009960-00010191 i want to show y'all something
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00035-00010192-00010342 about this keyboard here i don't know
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00036-00010343-00010503 whether or not y'all can see it but
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00037-00010504-00010947 check this out
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00038-00010948-00011599 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00039-00011600-00011846 this keyboard man
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00040-00011847-00012046 really helps out i don't know about
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00041-00012047-00012278 y'all but i like good sounds
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00042-00012279-00012693 here let me check out another one
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00043-00012694-00012943 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00044-00012944-00013102 let me go ahead and bring a groove back
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00045-00013103-00013679 in
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00046-00013680-00013799 this is called
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00047-00013800-00014222 p n o in rows together now that sounds i
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00048-00014223-00014547 like the sound but
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00049-00014549-00015152 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00050-00015153-00015743 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00051-00015744-00015911 i likes that
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00052-00015912-00016119 i likes that right there and this is
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00053-00016119-00016366 called soft fm
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00054-00016368-00016486 ep
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00055-00016487-00016663 let me go ahead and bring up bring up
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00056-00016664-00016917 beat to help it out
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00057-00016918-00017167 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00058-00017168-00017352 y'all hear that
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00059-00017353-00018894 [Music]
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00060-00018895-00019319 that's called a raised road
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00061-00019320-00019822 let's try out some more
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00062-00019823-00020022 i likes that
+N8y5FBmDuDY-00063-00020023-00020384 i likes that right there
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00000-00000059-00000623 Stanford plays multiplayer save six
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00001-00000624-00000911 all right I've only got Dan's turns to
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00002-00000911-00000983 do
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00003-00000984-00001162 um Dave is unavailable
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00004-00001163-00001349 so we're just playing the games where
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00005-00001350-00001511 I'm playing with Dan
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00006-00001512-00001953 so here I was fighting Baltimore
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00007-00001954-00002845 [Music]
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00008-00002846-00003365 so I don't see it here but
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00009-00003365-00003856 it looks like I lost my medic
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00010-00003857-00004193 but I don't see how
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00011-00004194-00004427 I guess maybe by
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00012-00004428-00004631 an Archer but it's I'm surprised it
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00013-00004632-00004997 didn't tell me here that I lost my medic
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00014-00004998-00005191 but so it goes
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00015-00005192-00005345 [Music]
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00016-00005346-00005627 all right so
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00017-00005628-00005931 um let's see I think I'm gonna
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00018-00005932-00006101 [Music]
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00019-00006102-00007120 focus on taking this guy out
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00020-00007122-00007498 all right that gets rid of him
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00021-00007500-00007733 foreign
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00022-00007734-00007889 excellent
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00023-00007890-00008219 so now this guy he can't reach him huh I
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00024-00008220-00008399 wonder if they can reach him then
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00025-00008400-00008910 all right let's start attacking the city
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00026-00008911-00009173 okay this Knight can wait for a minute
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00027-00009174-00009726 these guys can go
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00028-00009727-00010081 [Music]
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00029-00010082-00010319 all right now this City's in bad shape
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00030-00010320-00011069 let's see if we have this guy attack
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00031-00011070-00011291 we've almost but not quite got Baltimore
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00032-00011292-00012305 but I bet this guy can take Baltimore
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00033-00012306-00012664 there we go
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00034-00012665-00012808 azah
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00035-00012809-00012994 all right in the meanwhile this guy
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00036-00012995-00013372 continues to explore
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00037-00013373-00013577 out this way I guess all right we found
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00038-00013578-00013936 somebody Maybe
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00039-00013937-00014183 laventa they want me to construct a holy
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00040-00014184-00014458 site I might have done all the holy site
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00041-00014459-00014615 construction I'm going to do
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00042-00014616-00014836 all right so production let's do ancient
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00043-00014837-00015058 walls
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00044-00015059-00015419 um
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00045-00015419-00015688 all right some of my folks may be able
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00046-00015690-00015916 to upgrade now maybe oh this guy can get
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00047-00015918-00016169 named which is nice
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00048-00016169-00016294 um
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00049-00016295-00016553 I guess I upgraded them already
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00050-00016554-00016703 or maybe it's because they already took
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00051-00016704-00016822 their turn
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00052-00016823-00017033 that's probably what it is
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00053-00017034-00017261 so I thought I had some upgrades
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00054-00017262-00017447 um I just I just needed my guys to be in
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00055-00017448-00017639 their territory
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00056-00017640-00017950 all right well that nope I thought that
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00057-00017951-00018125 finished that turn but it didn't all
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00058-00018126-00018311 right Sid means orders no this guy here
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00059-00018312-00018544 needs to know where to go because now
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00060-00018545-00018983 plans have changed somewhat
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00061-00018984-00019600 um let's see let's have him well
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00062-00019601-00020411 I heard uh it uh
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00063-00020412-00020639 we may just need to take right here to
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00064-00020640-00020872 it's kind of in the way to get to St
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00065-00020873-00021100 Louis because all these mountains
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00066-00021101-00021479 so yeah I guess I guess there we go here
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00067-00021480-00022000 we go
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00068-00022001-00022235 all right so here we are in the game
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00069-00022236-00022486 where I'm dueling Dan I had given myself
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00070-00022487-00022714 a bunch of spots to work
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00071-00022715-00023128 so I will go ahead and do that
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00072-00023129-00023363 Dan has accepted my deal which I think
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00073-00023364-00023627 was for peace
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00074-00023628-00023921 um so I finished the Oracle while Dan
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00075-00023922-00024185 finished Petra
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00076-00024186-00024398 it's gonna be interesting
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00077-00024399-00024983 [Music]
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00078-00024984-00025313 all right there we go to the main menu
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00079-00025314-00025631 all right Dan played his turn so now
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00080-00025632-00025840 we've got Military Academy Cavalry and
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00081-00025841-00026008 line Infantry
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00082-00026010-00026596 all right so
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00083-00026597-00026770 um
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00084-00026772-00027196 uh I don't know let's do rifling since
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00085-00027197-00027502 we are in the middle of a battle then
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00086-00027504-00027712 let's do some chemistry which is gonna
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00087-00027713-00027977 be awesome sauce
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00088-00027977-00028187 um
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00089-00028188-00028655 Advanced flight rocketry
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00090-00028656-00028781 hmm
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00091-00028782-00029057 ballistics
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00092-00029058-00029507 um synthetic materials nukes
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00093-00029508-00029735 um these things those things those
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00094-00029736-00029924 things that stuff
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00095-00029925-00030064 [Music]
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00096-00030066-00030401 um robots Fusion Nano
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00097-00030402-00030562 all right I think that gets us most of
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00098-00030563-00030916 the way through the rest of the game
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00099-00030917-00031399 [Music]
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00100-00031400-00031751 all right let's go to Q let's do ancient
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00101-00031752-00032123 walls first because
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00102-00032124-00032243 um
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00103-00032244-00032495 they need to be able to defend
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00104-00032495-00032645 um then I think
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00105-00032645-00033257 [Music]
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00106-00033258-00033461 they need amenities but that might just
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00107-00033462-00033712 be because they are um currently
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00108-00033713-00034193 occupied so let's go for a uni a bank no
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00109-00034194-00034415 no no no no let's move that
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00110-00034416-00034552 I guess we gotta put this in first let's
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00111-00034553-00034762 do a workshop first because that'll get
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00112-00034763-00034959 things going then you need the bank
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00113-00034960-00035759 [Music]
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00114-00035760-00035987 all right I think that's good
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00115-00035988-00036379 all right so now
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00116-00036380-00036683 all right we've got this
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00117-00036684-00037079 Knight who's in trouble somewhat
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00118-00037080-00037307 all right can this guy shoot over there
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00119-00037308-00037577 or what all right finally
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00120-00037578-00038579 so let's shoot that guy
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00121-00038580-00039023 all right can this guy shoot anybody
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00122-00039024-00039293 not really let's bring him closer
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00123-00039294-00039817 and we might as well promote him
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00124-00039818-00040049 attack after moving seems like an
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00125-00040050-00040301 awesome promotion we'll use this guy to
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00126-00040302-00040780 attack our pikemen
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00127-00040781-00041021 awesome he's got a promotion available
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00128-00041022-00041387 now it looks like maybe
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00129-00041388-00041651 they both die or something so that seems
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00130-00041652-00041962 kind of dumb so what if I attack well
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00131-00041963-00042107 what if I get this guy out of the city
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00132-00042108-00042424 bring that guy into the city
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00133-00042425-00042629 promote him
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00134-00042630-00042923 to be awesome against damage units
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00135-00042924-00043187 all right we'll let him have a name all
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00136-00043188-00043415 right I knew we could upgrade something
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00137-00043416-00043829 I upgraded that guy to a medic
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00138-00043830-00044189 and continue to be an escort formation
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00139-00044190-00044423 let this guy heal
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00140-00044424-00044746 uh it's no okay battering ram we don't
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00141-00044747-00044915 have enough gold to turn him into a
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00142-00044916-00045035 medic
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00143-00045036-00045346 so we'll just skip his turn
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00144-00045347-00045551 this guy can get oops this guy can get
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00145-00045552-00045701 his promotion we'll make him awesome
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00146-00045702-00045940 against damage units heck yeah let him
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00147-00045941-00047135 get a name
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00148-00047136-00047237 all right
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00149-00047238-00047446 we'll attack this guy I mean this is a
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00150-00047447-00047608 no-brainer man my guys are Knights and
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00151-00047609-00048107 they're attacking archers
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00152-00048108-00048293 look at this guy over here waiting to be
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00153-00048294-00048508 captured
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00154-00048509-00048724 um
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00155-00048725-00048893 I have someone that can capture him
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00156-00048894-00049246 somewhere
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00157-00049247-00049468 bugger
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00158-00049469-00049637 oh can this guy capture units because
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00159-00049638-00050008 that would be awesome sauce
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00160-00050009-00050165 guess not
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00161-00050166-00050267 all right
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00162-00050268-00050362 um
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00163-00050363-00050645 gotta be unit somewhere
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00164-00050646-00050890 nobody huh
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00165-00050891-00051143 all right well
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00166-00051144-00051364 this guy maybe can you go back and grab
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00167-00051365-00051682 this dude
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00168-00051683-00051880 at least he won't be able to disappear
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00169-00051882-00051988 from me
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00170-00051989-00052601 all right let's give
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00171-00052602-00053092 all right how about to EuroVan why not
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00172-00053094-00053519 cool this guy weigh the F over here
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00173-00053520-00054394 I can keep going
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00174-00054395-00054599 all right we've got a ranged attack this
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00175-00054600-00055187 guy's dealing with pirates again
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00176-00055188-00055750 and that's that I guess
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00177-00055751-00055985 all right so back to my duel with Dan
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00178-00055986-00056092 game
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00179-00056094-00056315 get this copper and I can get rid of
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00180-00056316-00056494 that marker
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00181-00056495-00056735 all right and that was that that was
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00182-00056736-00056800 easy
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00183-00056801-00057082 foreign
+N9AJTZxQzN4-00184-00057083-00057383 cool
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00000-00000008-00000223 i'm a reconstructionist personally and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00001-00000224-00000383 there's many ways to say that but my
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00002-00000384-00000519 favorite way to say that
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00003-00000520-00001614 is that i'm an annoying nerd
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00004-00001616-00001847 so let's set up the stage a little bit
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00005-00001848-00002023 until very recently what is largely
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00006-00002023-00002215 considered paganism was a hodgepodge of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00007-00002216-00002399 movements that were generally rooted
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00008-00002400-00002615 in personal exploration through ritual
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00009-00002616-00002742 ceremonial magic
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00010-00002743-00002966 and spirituality some of these movements
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00011-00002967-00003079 appealed to history but
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00012-00003080-00003279 some of that history was a romanticized
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00013-00003279-00003422 image that we've
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00014-00003423-00003719 later learned isn't entirely accurate
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00015-00003720-00003919 through a series of movements two very
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00016-00003920-00004099 prominent camps have arisen
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00017-00004100-00004359 reconstructionism and eclecticism and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00018-00004360-00004543 recons and eclectics will often get into
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00019-00004544-00004711 disagreements and scuffles about how to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00020-00004712-00004886 approach their pagan practices
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00021-00004887-00005263 and which one is quote right bias noted
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00022-00005264-00005438 i am a reconstructionist but
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00023-00005439-00005599 i want to go into this a bit and give a
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00024-00005600-00005743 comparison between these approaches to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00025-00005744-00005831 paganism
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00026-00005832-00005999 because what i'm generally interested in
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00027-00006000-00006159 regarding these subjects
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00028-00006160-00006334 is the argument that each perspective
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00029-00006335-00006534 has and how they get addressed
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00030-00006536-00006687 now i'm going to be dealing with trends
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00031-00006688-00006846 and broad strokes both among
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00032-00006847-00007078 eclectics and reconstructionists none of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00033-00007079-00007246 these things are universals and both of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00034-00007247-00007342 these movements are
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00035-00007343-00007527 wide and varied and filled with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00036-00007528-00007678 individuals who are distinct from the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00037-00007679-00007767 trends
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00038-00007768-00008070 including myself but let's get into it
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00039-00008072-00008263 so let's start with eclecticism
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00040-00008264-00008431 eclecticism has a few perspectives
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00041-00008432-00008567 within it but there are two main through
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00042-00008568-00008639 lines
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00043-00008640-00008807 one is that it pulls from several
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00044-00008808-00008967 spiritual traditions all over the world
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00045-00008968-00009119 and isn't really committed to one
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00046-00009120-00009383 specific cultural or religious tradition
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00047-00009384-00009527 another is it is rooted in the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00048-00009528-00009727 experience of the practitioner
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00049-00009728-00009967 that spirituality is a personal path and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00050-00009968-00010071 that experience
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00051-00010072-00010246 guides you on your journey but it needs
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00052-00010247-00010463 to be noted that experience often isn't
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00053-00010464-00010655 dependable there's an element of doubt
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00054-00010656-00010751 in ourselves
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00055-00010752-00010983 that both approaches face but eclectics
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00056-00010984-00011078 especially
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00057-00011079-00011238 can feel the weight of that doubt when
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00058-00011239-00011438 their practices are grounded largely
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00059-00011439-00011663 in personal experience and importantly
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00060-00011664-00011806 experience alone
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00061-00011807-00012038 can lead to wrong conclusions our
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00062-00012039-00012246 experiences are not always exactly what
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00063-00012247-00012351 they seem to be
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00064-00012352-00012542 and honestly any pagan not just
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00065-00012543-00012719 eclectics should be aware that the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00066-00012720-00012807 danger of divine
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00067-00012808-00012974 experiences lies not in the experience
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00068-00012975-00013271 itself but in the interpretation
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00069-00013272-00013591 developing discernment is its own beast
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00070-00013591-00013807 reconstructionism shifts that grounding
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00071-00013808-00014007 away from experience and roots itself in
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00072-00014008-00014238 historical research and scholarship
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00073-00014240-00014407 though experience is still a huge part
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00074-00014408-00014655 of the equation the intention also
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00075-00014656-00014735 shifts where
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00076-00014736-00014943 instead of personalized exploration and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00077-00014944-00015047 spirituality
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00078-00015047-00015279 reconstructionism aspires to rebuild an
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00079-00015280-00015455 ancient tradition in the modern world
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00080-00015456-00015663 with what information we have the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00081-00015663-00015847 underlying justification being if
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00082-00015847-00015999 ancient peoples were connected to the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00083-00016000-00016222 gods rebuilding those traditions to the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00084-00016223-00016335 best of our ability
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00085-00016336-00016599 allows us to connect to the gods as well
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00086-00016600-00016703 therefore
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00087-00016704-00016927 history has primacy in validating our
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00088-00016928-00017030 spiritual quest
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00089-00017031-00017230 now leaning on history and the weight of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00090-00017231-00017447 scholarship can give a sense of security
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00091-00017448-00017615 that appears to alleviate the doubts
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00092-00017616-00017750 eclectics face
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00093-00017751-00017958 however that security can become an
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00094-00017959-00018143 illusion of certainty
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00095-00018144-00018358 any study of history is going to carry
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00096-00018359-00018575 with it the bias of the historian
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00097-00018576-00018775 and the reader doing the research and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00098-00018776-00018991 our historical sources themselves
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00099-00018992-00019247 carry biases of their own both written
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00100-00019248-00019399 and in terms of what archaeological
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00101-00019400-00019543 evidence we have available
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00102-00019544-00019799 for the study which can create an
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00103-00019800-00019935 incomplete picture
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00104-00019936-00020199 as such historical scholarship cannot
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00105-00020200-00020255 grant
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00106-00020256-00020471 certainty a discovery tomorrow could
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00107-00020472-00020558 overturn
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00108-00020559-00020886 decades of consensus and has it's part
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00109-00020887-00021014 of the game
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00110-00021015-00021343 so that uncertainty is still there
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00111-00021344-00021711 and will always be there as you can see
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00112-00021712-00021911 both approaches have their strengths and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00113-00021912-00022014 weaknesses
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00114-00022015-00022158 and the division between them shouldn't
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00115-00022159-00022343 be as strong as it seems to be in our
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00116-00022344-00022439 communities
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00117-00022440-00022694 as eclecticism often references the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00118-00022695-00022911 strategies of reconstructionism
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00119-00022912-00023091 in their exploration and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00120-00023092-00023327 reconstructionism is incomplete
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00121-00023328-00023503 without elements of the eclectic
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00122-00023504-00023647 approach i think that
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00123-00023648-00023807 also let me talk about a personal pet
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00124-00023808-00023975 peeve here eclecticism is
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00125-00023976-00024335 wrongfully termed neopagan as opposed to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00126-00024336-00024527 reconstructionism which often rejects
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00127-00024528-00024719 the term neopig and even seeing it as a
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00128-00024720-00024830 pejorative
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00129-00024831-00025094 but if we consider the term neopagan to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00130-00025095-00025175 mean
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00131-00025176-00025430 new pagan movements reconstructionism
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00132-00025431-00025606 fits that definition as we're
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00133-00025607-00025814 not practicing the same religion as the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00134-00025816-00026014 religion that we're reconstructing
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00135-00026016-00026255 we are practicing a reconstruction of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00136-00026256-00026479 that faith out of old books and dirt
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00137-00026480-00026735 which isn't the same thing and on top of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00138-00026736-00026918 that reconstructionist movements
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00139-00026919-00027135 are younger than modern eclectic
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00140-00027136-00027239 movements so
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00141-00027239-00027535 arguably the term fits us recons more
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00142-00027536-00027695 than it does eclectics
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00143-00027695-00027887 so if you're a recon and using the term
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00144-00027888-00028143 neopagan as a dismissal
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00145-00028144-00028470 you might need to look inward but
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00146-00028472-00028687 moving on the eclectic generally chases
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00147-00028688-00028870 engagement with the gods or exploration
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00148-00028872-00028983 of the self or
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00149-00028983-00029158 a relationship with an ambiguous higher
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00150-00029160-00029327 power that they rightfully and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00151-00029327-00029431 justifiably
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00152-00029432-00029631 make no claims about other than having
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00153-00029632-00029807 seen a hint of it through their genuine
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00154-00029808-00029983 exploration of experience
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00155-00029983-00030167 the reconstructionist on the other hand
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00156-00030168-00030287 has more specific
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00157-00030288-00030502 goals in mind they generally have a
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00158-00030503-00030655 concrete idea of what it is that they're
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00159-00030656-00030767 reaching out to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00160-00030768-00030902 and they're more likely to be what's
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00161-00030903-00031118 considered a hard polytheist or what i
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00162-00031119-00031262 just call polytheist
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00163-00031263-00031423 the emphasis on history in the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00164-00031424-00031574 reconstructionist approach
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00165-00031575-00031774 allows the justification of more
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00166-00031775-00031879 specificity
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00167-00031880-00032055 in discussions of deity there are
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00168-00032056-00032231 attributes of the gods generally
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00169-00032232-00032511 and of particular gods specifically thor
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00170-00032512-00032646 has certain attributes
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00171-00032647-00032831 as dictated by the historical records
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00172-00032832-00032959 related to thor
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00173-00032960-00033287 same with odin or poseidon or anubis
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00174-00033288-00033479 an eclectic might follow these gods but
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00175-00033480-00033687 is doing so a little bit differently
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00176-00033688-00033887 the eclectic is trying things out in
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00177-00033888-00034046 spirituality often pulling from an
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00178-00034047-00034183 assortment of cultures
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00179-00034184-00034351 all around the world in order to get as
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00180-00034352-00034583 much perspective as they can
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00181-00034584-00034887 the experience for them has primacy
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00182-00034888-00035046 and they might reach and grasp and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00183-00035047-00035215 combine traditional practices
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00184-00035216-00035439 from unrelated areas of spirituality in
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00185-00035440-00035655 order to explore an element of their own
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00186-00035656-00035887 spirituality that the practice may not
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00187-00035888-00035967 have been quite
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00188-00035968-00036174 intended for originally and while
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00189-00036175-00036335 there's nothing inherently wrong with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00190-00036336-00036423 this approach
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00191-00036424-00036607 it can land you in a bit of trouble when
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00192-00036608-00036783 the experiment wanders into a culture
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00193-00036784-00036911 with oppression dynamics
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00194-00036912-00037102 or becomes appropriation due to the lack
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00195-00037103-00037302 of respect toward a tradition that's
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00196-00037303-00037439 being approached when the eclectic
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00197-00037440-00037623 pilfers a concept into their grab bag of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00198-00037624-00037774 spiritual tools
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00199-00037775-00037999 the abuse of consumerism of white sage
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00200-00038000-00038167 will often come up around this issue
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00201-00038168-00038367 or the often insensitive approach to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00202-00038368-00038487 native american or african
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00203-00038488-00038599 spiritualities
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00204-00038600-00038767 by people looking to take from living
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00205-00038768-00038918 traditions without concern for the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00206-00038919-00039127 cultures and peoples attached to them
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00207-00039128-00039439 especially especially when bastardized
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00208-00039440-00039574 versions of these traditions
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00209-00039575-00039823 are taught to others as correct
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00210-00039824-00040007 regardless of profit
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00211-00040008-00040102 this is not to say that
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00212-00040103-00040311 reconstructionists are immune to this
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00213-00040312-00040502 they can be just as guilty of this same
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00214-00040503-00040702 action approaching something with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00215-00040703-00040951 a historical or scholastic method does
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00216-00040952-00041190 not override the oppression dynamics
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00217-00041191-00041423 as often historical scholarship is
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00218-00041424-00041583 dripping with that same oppression
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00219-00041584-00041671 narrative
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00220-00041672-00041967 history as much as i love it is steeped
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00221-00041968-00042127 in the bias of narrative
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00222-00042128-00042335 and often that narrative is of one
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00223-00042336-00042518 attempting to justify the fact
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00224-00042519-00042807 that their culture crushed another this
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00225-00042808-00042927 should not be a surprise to any
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00226-00042928-00043046 reconstructionist
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00227-00043047-00043223 who has dug around the history of pagan
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00228-00043224-00043374 faiths and found writing on them in
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00229-00043375-00043446 antiquity
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00230-00043447-00043702 even up to the past decade where our
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00231-00043703-00043918 religions have been described in such a
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00232-00043919-00043974 way
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00233-00043975-00044127 that is steeped in biased
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00234-00044128-00044295 misrepresentation and assumptions
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00235-00044296-00044399 without evidence
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00236-00044400-00044646 we are painted as devil worshipers as
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00237-00044647-00044871 simplistic barbarians as liars as
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00238-00044872-00045062 atheists as secret christians
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00239-00045063-00045390 as anything but what we are and in the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00240-00045391-00045574 context of religious traditions subject
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00241-00045575-00045679 to this dynamic
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00242-00045680-00045958 the problem is multiplied and without
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00243-00045959-00046023 sufficient
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00244-00046024-00046246 representation for correction but let's
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00245-00046247-00046439 talk about the substantive difference
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00246-00046440-00046615 between eclectics and reconstructionists
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00247-00046616-00046846 that often gets discussed between them
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00248-00046847-00047046 recons will save eclectics that they
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00249-00047047-00047239 don't seem to care about context
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00250-00047240-00047423 that their approach is too wide with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00251-00047424-00047590 nothing to focus it allowing them to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00252-00047591-00047623 just
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00253-00047624-00047807 believe whatever they want regardless of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00254-00047808-00048062 reality the term upg
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00255-00048063-00048279 unverified personal gnosis seems to have
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00256-00048280-00048511 started as a way to dismiss eclectics
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00257-00048512-00048686 from discussing their experiences that
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00258-00048687-00048799 are divorced from historical
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00259-00048800-00048902 justification
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00260-00048903-00049095 as they are unverified by history and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00261-00049096-00049302 therefore just a fluke experience
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00262-00049303-00049599 a hiccup of the brain and dismissible on
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00263-00049600-00049695 that basis
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00264-00049696-00049902 and it's true that eclecticism will
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00265-00049903-00050062 sometimes be done without any focusing
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00266-00050063-00050135 element
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00267-00050136-00050295 and leave the eclectic open to some
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00268-00050296-00050527 fairly out there beliefs guided simply
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00269-00050528-00050799 by anecdotes and shaky justification
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00270-00050800-00050990 this leaves them open to pseudoscience
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00271-00050991-00051174 and potentially harmful beliefs and we
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00272-00051175-00051399 see this among eclectics some of the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00273-00051400-00051494 most aggressive
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00274-00051495-00051711 anti-science movements in paganism such
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00275-00051712-00051999 as anti-vax pagans are eclectics
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00276-00052000-00052207 and that can and should damn well be
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00277-00052208-00052430 criticized eclectics however will point
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00278-00052432-00052582 out to recons that they are far too
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00279-00052583-00052647 stuffy
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00280-00052648-00052823 that not everyone can go rifling through
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00281-00052824-00052966 books and learn the vast history of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00282-00052967-00053150 every culture in the world
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00283-00053151-00053319 this restricts the accessibility of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00284-00053320-00053479 spirituality and makes it so that you
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00285-00053479-00053566 have to be this
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00286-00053567-00053719 learned scholar in order to have any
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00287-00053720-00053935 connection with deity it's classist it's
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00288-00053936-00054071 elitist and furthermore
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00289-00054072-00054350 eclectic practices work if the gods
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00290-00054351-00054503 required us to approach them in this
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00291-00054504-00054711 certain way that the recons demand with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00292-00054712-00054894 their dogmatic approach to religion
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00293-00054895-00055071 that eclectics would not have meaningful
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00294-00055072-00055342 experiences with spirituality
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00295-00055344-00055663 and yet they do and this objection has
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00296-00055664-00055775 to land with any honest
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00297-00055776-00055926 reconstructionist
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00298-00055927-00056079 and actually it brings the point home of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00299-00056079-00056287 what we're discussing in the first place
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00300-00056288-00056454 why are we even bothering looking
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00301-00056455-00056599 through history to rebuild anything at
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00302-00056600-00056703 all
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00303-00056704-00056903 isn't it the case that the sources we're
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00304-00056904-00057063 reading were once traditional stories
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00305-00057064-00057142 within a culture
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00306-00057144-00057471 weren't they once upg yes
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00307-00057472-00057647 furthermore the strategy of saying your
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00308-00057648-00057847 spiritual experiences are invalid unless
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00309-00057848-00058007 they're found in history as arbitrary
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00310-00058008-00058111 anyway
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00311-00058112-00058294 on what basis are we applying this
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00312-00058295-00058463 standard when comparing to spirituality
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00313-00058464-00058526 today
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00314-00058527-00058711 it's not like there are more historical
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00315-00058712-00058919 examples than there are modern examples
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00316-00058920-00059175 and historical examples aren't more
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00317-00059176-00059382 accessible they're infinitely less so
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00318-00059383-00059550 you can't interview any of these ancient
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00319-00059551-00059823 people but you can with people who exist
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00320-00059824-00059919 today
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00321-00059920-00060063 the strategy that reconstructionists
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00322-00060064-00060366 will often engage in of dismissing upg
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00323-00060367-00060750 simply on the basis of it being only upg
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00324-00060751-00061015 is to undermine themselves upg can be
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00325-00061016-00061063 wrong
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00326-00061064-00061303 sure but if it was always wrong there'd
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00327-00061304-00061423 be no justification for the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00328-00061424-00061550 reconstructionist to have their
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00329-00061551-00061735 spirituality in the first place
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00330-00061736-00061942 in fact to do this is to be a bad
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00331-00061944-00062142 reconstructionist as you wind up gutting
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00332-00062144-00062311 the ability to establish
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00333-00062312-00062630 spg or vpg as you've undermined the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00334-00062632-00062799 first step of reaching either of those
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00335-00062800-00062871 stages
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00336-00062872-00063006 my point here is is that often
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00337-00063007-00063166 reconstructionism is strawmanned and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00338-00063167-00063254 misused
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00339-00063255-00063366 even by self-proclaimed
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00340-00063367-00063535 reconstructionists the point of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00341-00063536-00063647 reconstructionism
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00342-00063648-00063847 has much to do with the desire of the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00343-00063848-00064054 practitioner to connect with an approach
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00344-00064055-00064182 to spirituality
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00345-00064183-00064438 far more ancient than themselves as we
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00346-00064439-00064535 have felt the pull
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00347-00064536-00064838 of the gods so the method we turn to is
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00348-00064839-00065023 to look to the example of people who
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00349-00065024-00065191 were closer to these gods
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00350-00065191-00065366 when their worship was standard in
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00351-00065367-00065671 culture those practices worked for them
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00352-00065672-00065887 so they may as well work for us and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00353-00065888-00066055 often the reason why we're pulled to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00354-00066056-00066103 this
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00355-00066104-00066375 is the same reason eclectics are we want
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00356-00066376-00066582 to connect with the gods
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00357-00066583-00066847 and the dismissal of upg simply because
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00358-00066848-00067055 it's upg and reconstruction in circles
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00359-00067056-00067350 is to undermine the very basis of why
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00360-00067351-00067543 many of us are even spiritual
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00361-00067544-00067791 in the first place this dismissal also
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00362-00067792-00067950 runs the risk of an obsession with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00363-00067951-00068159 reconstruction to the point of rigidity
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00364-00068160-00068350 where we fossilize even the versions of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00365-00068351-00068567 our faith practice in the modern day
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00366-00068568-00068775 because we're afraid of the uncertainty
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00367-00068776-00068919 of eclecticism
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00368-00068920-00069199 this over correction smothers the joy
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00369-00069200-00069247 from
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00370-00069248-00069479 the very direct experiences which cause
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00371-00069480-00069694 us pagans to grow out of the ground in
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00372-00069695-00069806 the first place
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00373-00069807-00069935 if these faiths had been allowed to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00374-00069936-00070119 survive into the modern day they would
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00375-00070120-00070294 have continued to evolve and change with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00376-00070295-00070455 the cultures that practiced them
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00377-00070456-00070591 and as we've seen in the historical
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00378-00070592-00070823 record they did even back then
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00379-00070824-00070982 so how do these changes happen do you
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00380-00070983-00071119 think that there's some arbitrary date
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00381-00071120-00071238 in history in which
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00382-00071239-00071550 upg suddenly ceased in its validity or
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00383-00071551-00071599 is there some
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00384-00071600-00071759 modern bias at work in the way that we
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00385-00071760-00071982 approach these things what right do we
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00386-00071983-00072038 have
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00387-00072039-00072303 to strip the agency of the gods in how
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00388-00072304-00072455 they choose to interact with potential
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00389-00072456-00072631 worshipers
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00390-00072632-00072871 none likewise the eclectic
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00391-00072872-00073047 criticism that historical scholarship
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00392-00073048-00073247 can be easily discarded doesn't quite
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00393-00073248-00073359 work either
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00394-00073360-00073519 as the distinction between what
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00395-00073520-00073679 historical information eclectics will
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00396-00073680-00073847 use for their practice and what they
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00397-00073848-00073959 don't use
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00398-00073960-00074126 align directly with what is widely
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00399-00074127-00074382 available such as associations between
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00400-00074383-00074431 zeus
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00401-00074432-00074694 and lightning or thor and lightning or
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00402-00074695-00074750 set
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00403-00074751-00075135 and well lightning but the associations
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00404-00075136-00075343 with zeus and hospitality or thor
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00405-00075344-00075671 and protection and set with courage are
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00406-00075672-00075879 less known in our culture so the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00407-00075880-00076071 associations aren't quite made as often
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00408-00076072-00076206 with an eclecticism
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00409-00076207-00076399 easing accessibility of information
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00410-00076400-00076606 benefits both camps
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00411-00076607-00076775 as the eclectic has more tools with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00412-00076776-00076959 which to explore their experiences with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00413-00076960-00077031 thor
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00414-00077032-00077262 and the recon has a new aspect of zeus
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00415-00077263-00077431 with which to honor him
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00416-00077432-00077606 and either could find the confidence to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00417-00077607-00077862 reach out to set during a trying time
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00418-00077863-00078087 so the trick is to make that information
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00419-00078088-00078223 more accessible
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00420-00078224-00078543 not dismiss that which is less
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00421-00078544-00078750 accessible if this historical approach
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00422-00078751-00078919 didn't matter to eclectics they wouldn't
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00423-00078920-00079094 be so fascinated with the practices that
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00424-00079095-00079279 they themselves tout as
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00425-00079280-00079494 ancient just without the evidence to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00426-00079495-00079662 actually back up the claim
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00427-00079663-00079894 revisionist history is a huge contention
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00428-00079895-00080071 point between reconstructionists and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00429-00080072-00080167 eclectics
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00430-00080168-00080382 and eclectic practice is perfectly valid
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00431-00080383-00080606 but revising history in order to give
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00432-00080607-00080767 your practices authority
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00433-00080768-00081111 is not upg can be valid on its own
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00434-00081112-00081367 a practice can be valid on its own
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00435-00081368-00081647 giving it a revisionist justification
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00436-00081648-00081950 removes that validity this brings in the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00437-00081951-00082150 issue of lording one's upg over others
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00438-00082151-00082350 which is simply an abusive practice
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00439-00082351-00082550 saying to bring up a totally random
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00440-00082551-00082694 example that
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00441-00082695-00082879 people can't criticize your wearing of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00442-00082880-00083087 the black sun a uniquely nazi symbol
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00443-00083088-00083247 created by the nazis for their nazi
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00444-00083248-00083318 castle
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00445-00083319-00083631 because you have upg that dionysus gave
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00446-00083632-00083799 it to you in a dream doesn't track
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00447-00083800-00084150 and yes people can criticize you for it
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00448-00084151-00084279 and i really wish i made that up but i
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00449-00084280-00084479 didn't
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00450-00084480-00084750 but using upg as an excuse to wear a
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00451-00084751-00084871 nazi symbol
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00452-00084872-00085167 can and will net you criticism even if
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00453-00085168-00085271 you whinge about it
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00454-00085272-00085487 and reconstructionists will lord upg
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00455-00085488-00085638 over others as well when
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00456-00085639-00085806 they claim that the only way the gods
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00457-00085807-00085991 interact with us is through
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00458-00085992-00086238 their version of reconstruction just
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00459-00086239-00086303 because
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00460-00086304-00086543 you found your practice meaningful
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00461-00086544-00086679 doesn't mean it's the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00462-00086680-00086918 only meaningful practice you might come
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00463-00086919-00087031 away from all of this with the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00464-00087032-00087206 impression that we're all so
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00465-00087207-00087415 why bother with community at all maybe
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00466-00087416-00087511 you should just
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00467-00087512-00087631 run off into the woods somewhere and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00468-00087632-00087782 avoid interaction with anyone who's even
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00469-00087783-00087903 possibly thought about the gods at some
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00470-00087904-00088031 point
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00471-00088032-00088287 and i've been there honestly i'm still
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00472-00088288-00088375 there but
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00473-00088376-00088487 there's a few things that we can
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00474-00088488-00088671 recognize if you want to express that
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00475-00088672-00088855 your position is the right one
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00476-00088856-00089038 you know often you will back it up with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00477-00089039-00089159 the justification
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00478-00089160-00089423 and sometimes people will get so focused
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00479-00089424-00089575 on their own lens through which they
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00480-00089576-00089726 view spirituality
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00481-00089727-00089918 they forget that there are other lenses
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00482-00089919-00090182 through which others view spirituality
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00483-00090183-00090318 there are multiple avenues to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00484-00090319-00090455 justification which is part of what
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00485-00090456-00090615 makes paganism and polytheism so
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00486-00090616-00090767 interesting in the first place
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00487-00090768-00090911 and i've made this point before in other
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00488-00090912-00091159 videos but we lack the ability to have
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00489-00091160-00091311 any absolute certainty about the nature
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00490-00091312-00091575 of reality in general much less the gods
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00491-00091576-00091806 this problem has plagued philosophers
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00492-00091807-00091982 going back to socrates
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00493-00091983-00092175 it's the foundation of skepticism as
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00494-00092176-00092423 first introduced by ancient polytheists
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00495-00092424-00092638 it's mentioned again by cicero of rome
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00496-00092639-00092799 and is still discussed
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00497-00092800-00093079 by philosophers today but we have our
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00498-00093080-00093191 ideas
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00499-00093192-00093367 models that we build out of observing a
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00500-00093368-00093511 series of correlations through the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00501-00093512-00093662 limited windows that we have into the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00502-00093663-00093782 outside world
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00503-00093783-00093918 this is honestly the foundation of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00504-00093919-00094079 science at the end of the day and within
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00505-00094080-00094231 philosophy we have naturalism
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00506-00094232-00094526 physicalism idealism even solipsism
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00507-00094527-00094694 all of which have their fair and valid
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00508-00094695-00094887 justifications and coming back to
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00509-00094888-00094967 paganism
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00510-00094968-00095174 the situation is very similar with the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00511-00095175-00095406 eclectic and reconstructionist approach
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00512-00095407-00095687 spiritually they have very similar goals
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00513-00095688-00095847 they just have a different approach
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00514-00095848-00096103 to reaching those goals so why are we
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00515-00096104-00096247 shaming those differences
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00516-00096248-00096494 that amount to simple differences what
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00517-00096495-00096687 we should probably be focusing on as
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00518-00096688-00096799 eclectics and recons
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00519-00096800-00096959 floating down the same tiny river in the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00520-00096960-00097159 same tiny boat is that claiming
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00521-00097160-00097311 superiority over each other
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00522-00097312-00097535 is a waste of time that could be spent
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00523-00097536-00097694 enjoying the religion instead of arguing
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00524-00097695-00097791 about it
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00525-00097792-00097967 it wastes the collective energy of the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00526-00097968-00098206 community that is better spent
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00527-00098207-00098438 identifying the actually harmful beliefs
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00528-00098439-00098559 and practices
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00529-00098560-00098823 into which we sometimes stumble pulling
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00530-00098824-00098943 each other out of them
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00531-00098944-00099174 and actually growing in our individual
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00532-00099175-00099335 faiths and traditions
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00533-00099336-00099511 i've learned during my time as a recon
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00534-00099512-00099703 that we have a pile of dusty books with
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00535-00099704-00099894 a wealth of information
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00536-00099895-00100062 and we can be the people that eclectics
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00537-00100063-00100182 can come to for information and
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00538-00100183-00100303 clarification
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00539-00100304-00100543 on the histories of our various faiths
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00540-00100544-00100679 and provide them with a wealth of
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00541-00100680-00100903 resources on what they seek
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00542-00100904-00101103 but eclectics often have far more
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00543-00101104-00101294 knowledge on what it's like to actually
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00544-00101295-00101415 experience
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00545-00101416-00101679 and experiment with our faith and we can
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00546-00101680-00101887 damn well learn from them too
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00547-00101888-00102159 and should and with that hail to my
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00548-00102160-00102374 patrons for making this content possible
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00549-00102375-00102582 it's good to have people at your back
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00550-00102583-00102742 hit that subscribe button and tell the
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00551-00102743-00102942 bell to get its facts straight
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00552-00102943-00103247 and remember to find a way
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00553-00103248-00104560 or make one
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00554-00104561-00104641 [Music]
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00555-00104642-00104941 [Applause]
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00556-00104942-00105140 [Music]
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00557-00105141-00105471 [Applause]
+N9HDoWaaoB4-00558-00105472-00105679 you
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00000-00000126-00000245 foreign
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00001-00000246-00000467 doesn't mean it can't be fun or good or
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00002-00000468-00002093 anything it's just I don't
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00003-00002094-00003556 [Applause]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00004-00003557-00004086 know
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00005-00004087-00004372 what kind of game would I make
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00006-00004373-00004585 if I could make a game
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00007-00004586-00004985 like Snap My Fingers game into existence
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00008-00004986-00005274 like open World Daisy type of game
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00009-00005275-00005399 [Music]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00010-00005400-00005885 with like basically tarkov like Gunplay
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00011-00005886-00006149 but in an open world like Survival game
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00012-00006150-00006406 but make it focused on PVP instead of
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00013-00006408-00008345 survival
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00014-00008346-00008521 and you'd have to
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00015-00008522-00008783 make the bat the map would have to be
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00016-00008784-00008945 like
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00017-00008946-00009545 more urban setting instead of like
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00018-00009546-00009760 Daisy [__] where it's a whole bunch of
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00019-00009761-00010342 trees everywhere
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00020-00010343-00012471 how does that not kill either of them
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00021-00012472-00013438 [Music]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00022-00013440-00013555 [Music]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00023-00013556-00014208 thought he went inside man
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00024-00014209-00014419 foreign
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00025-00014419-00014735 my gun's gonna break bro it's at 87
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00026-00014736-00015143 durability already this thing's toast
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00027-00015144-00015538 this thing's toasted
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00028-00015540-00016025 I thought two of them went in too
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00029-00016026-00016193 I gotta get out of this raid there's
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00030-00016194-00016415 more people downstairs from like from
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00031-00016416-00016571 that group with the guy that I killed
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00032-00016572-00016847 but my gun's gonna Jam
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00033-00016848-00017027 I heard him healing I thought he was
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00034-00017028-00018580 inside right around the corner
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00035-00018581-00018772 the load back so I shot some people
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00036-00018773-00019079 let's hope [__]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00037-00019080-00019289 multiplayer game doesn't need quests and
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00038-00019290-00019564 stuff like I because if you if you make
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00039-00019565-00019793 a game focused on quests
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00040-00019794-00020021 once people are done with the quests
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00041-00020022-00020213 there's nothing to do you need to make
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00042-00020214-00020464 the gameplay like sustainable on it on
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00043-00020465-00020663 its own
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00044-00020664-00020891 maybe you could add quests but like the
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00045-00020892-00021136 first first thing should be like a good
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00046-00021137-00021286 gameplay Loop that keeps people
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00047-00021287-00022103 interested
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00048-00022104-00022385 damn this gun's gases look at that thing
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00049-00022386-00023219 you got the mini Mosin
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00050-00023220-00023464 yo and did we just have a twitch baby
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00051-00023465-00023747 name
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00052-00023748-00024257 I guess so
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00053-00024258-00024935 when I drop my bag
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00054-00024936-00026362 Chad Where'd I drop it
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00055-00026363-00026668 is it here oh
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00056-00026669-00027089 would you look at that
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00057-00027089-00027424 oh come on Stadium I never really played
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00058-00027425-00027758 Pokemon games I played like
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00059-00027758-00028133 [Music]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00060-00028133-00028499 Pokemon Red
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00061-00028500-00029862 poor guy
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00062-00029863-00030089 brother you cannot pull out a grenade
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00063-00030089-00030346 that close I played Pokemon Red back in
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00064-00030347-00030707 the day and that was it really
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00065-00030708-00030935 Pokemon Snap was that the [__] where you
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00066-00030936-00031390 were like the wildlife photographer
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00067-00031391-00031858 blessed thanks to the prime min
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00068-00031860-00032218 hey yo thanks for the prayer
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00069-00032219-00033161 good I I don't think I ever played it
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00070-00033162-00034031 scarves
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00071-00034032-00034487 well that scared the [__] out of me
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00072-00034488-00034811 anyone else just pooped themselves
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00073-00034812-00036323 this guy was level 45 how
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00074-00036324-00036581 Jay thank you very much bro Bob sure and
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00075-00036582-00037001 fugazi thank you Paper Mario again never
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00076-00037002-00037318 really played many of those games
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00077-00037319-00037583 I played Mario on like
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00078-00037584-00037961 Game Boy
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00079-00037962-00038261 but I never owned the only Nintendo
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00080-00038262-00038717 console I ever owned was N64 and then I
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00081-00038718-00038824 had
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00082-00038825-00038999 Game Boy
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00083-00039000-00039299 and Game Boy Advance that was it never
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00084-00039300-00039671 had anything else from Nintendo
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00085-00039672-00039874 and yeah Mario
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00086-00039875-00040217 bro I'm from New York we say Mario
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00087-00040218-00040390 get used to it all right that's just how
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00088-00040391-00040930 it is
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00089-00040931-00041633 I don't know what to tell you
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00090-00041634-00041915 I say coffee I say chocolate I say Mario
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00091-00041916-00042190 I say orange like
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00092-00042191-00042527 this is just the way it is all right
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00093-00042528-00042718 you're from New York Buffalo bro that's
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00094-00042719-00043180 not even New York that's like
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00095-00043181-00044105 I'm talking Long Island in New York City
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00096-00044106-00046645 it's glucosamine
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00097-00046646-00047062 [Music]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00098-00047063-00047812 where in the hell are you going
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00099-00047813-00048605 22 injector but
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00100-00048606-00048835 Europe
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00101-00048836-00049339 sending love from upstate NY Tony
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00102-00049340-00049667 36 months when is my room going to be
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00103-00049668-00052126 done at home
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00104-00052127-00053621 did I kill that guy on the swing
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00105-00053622-00055241 oh
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00107-00058848-00059050 those dudes got toasted that first guy
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00108-00059051-00059230 song I killed too
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00109-00059232-00059441 yeah I saw that light on the door I
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00110-00059441-00059597 don't know if it was his light bugs or
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00111-00059598-00059782 someone else's that's why I went and
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00112-00059783-00060125 just peaked it real quick
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00113-00060126-00060461 juice Cannon sold out it's yup
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00114-00060462-00061115 you guys bought the [__] out of it
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00115-00061116-00061757 toss your salad
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00116-00061758-00062957 hmm
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00117-00062958-00065944 foreign
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00118-00065945-00067493 dude
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00119-00067494-00068387 do you hear that
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00120-00068388-00069221 [Music]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00121-00069222-00069821 can you guys hear that
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00122-00069822-00070121 it's like vibrated what is that
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00123-00070122-00070432 it's the game or my PC I muted my audio
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00124-00070433-00070775 and I hear it dude gokhan's holy [__]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00125-00070776-00070900 dude
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00126-00070901-00071297 bro
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00127-00071298-00071675 oh my God 30 gifted go cons thank you
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00128-00071676-00071926 rules thanks for the 23 months it's like
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00129-00071927-00072191 a phone vibrating
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00130-00072192-00072479 but it's the game because look now you
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00131-00072480-00072961 don't hear it right
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00132-00072962-00073756 why hear somebody
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00133-00073757-00074705 wait
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00134-00074706-00075767 yeah your phone
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00135-00075768-00076273 is it the alarm but it's bugged
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00136-00076274-00078035 that's the alarm but bugged
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00137-00078036-00079944 foreign
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00138-00079945-00080219 can we leave the alarm like that I like
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00139-00080220-00080556 that noise way better
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00140-00080557-00080950 no Factory thank you for the 34 months
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00141-00080951-00081137 bro left fan thank you for the two
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00142-00081138-00081419 months dude I lit I thought I was losing
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00143-00081420-00081647 my mind to hearing like something
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00144-00081648-00081755 oh
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00145-00081756-00081976 hearing something vibrate
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00146-00081977-00082181 Factory thank you so much dude go cons
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00147-00082182-00082829 your nuts legit thank you bro
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00148-00082830-00084299 get the [__] out of here [__]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00149-00084300-00084521 I would be so pissed some dude
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00150-00084522-00084773 does a [__] Olympic long jump across
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00151-00084774-00084941 the doorway and then blows your knees
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00152-00084942-00085450 out
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00153-00085451-00086676 foreign
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00154-00086677-00087515 how that grenade just landed there what
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00155-00087516-00087850 I got Olympic long jump legs but I got
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00156-00087851-00089261 little Timmy arms they can't throw
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00157-00089262-00089353 um
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00158-00089354-00089609 I gotta go the other way if I want to
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00159-00089610-00089759 get down there
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00160-00089760-00090047 you're getting hummus with fries
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00161-00090048-00090682 what
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00162-00090683-00090923 hummus with pita bread bro that's a leaf
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00163-00090924-00091632 fries
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00164-00091633-00092068 of course Jesus Christ you know that
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00165-00092069-00092261 brown paper towel roll that they used to
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00166-00092262-00092735 have in school
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00167-00092736-00093082 come on
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00168-00093083-00093509 that's me bro
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00169-00093510-00093676 that [__] you could you could remove
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00170-00093677-00093917 paint from a car with that thing it's so
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00172-00099580-00100061 [Music]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00173-00100062-00100606 what's up
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00175-00104754-00106481 foreign
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00176-00106482-00107597 why is he shooting my legs with an M4
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00178-00113490-00114071 ugh
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00179-00114072-00114889 how is he doing so much damage
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00180-00114890-00115084 whoa
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00181-00115085-00116004 shut up God damn it yeah
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00182-00116005-00116357 that was really fortunate timing
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00183-00116358-00116627 that I got my gun up that fast
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00184-00116628-00116795 bro this guy could not have been more
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00185-00116796-00117269 geared for factory look at this dude
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00186-00117270-00117515 pissed by the way let me get my bag this
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00187-00117516-00117616 guy's
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00188-00117617-00117995 mad
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00189-00117996-00118175 where the [__] is my bag now would I
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00190-00118176-00118702 drop this thing
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00191-00118703-00119219 ammo did he have in this gun
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00193-00122682-00123343 foreign
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00195-00129558-00129760 damn I didn't kill that guy they were
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00196-00129761-00132131 doing as a bralo armor
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00197-00132132-00132335 I heard this shooting like that and I
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00198-00132336-00132581 figured what was going on oh I did kill
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00199-00132582-00132773 him
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00200-00132774-00133204 oh he's doing gazelle not the bralo
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00201-00133205-00134137 that sucks bro
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00202-00134138-00134314 [Applause]
+Ns5-zuBg8JI-00203-00134315-00134594 and we're out
+NxknRPrYTQY-00000-00000008-00001311 [Music]
+NxknRPrYTQY-00001-00001312-00001491 [Music]
+NxknRPrYTQY-00002-00001492-00001732 hey
+NxknRPrYTQY-00003-00001734-00004479 [Music]
+NxknRPrYTQY-00004-00004480-00004687 you
+N_LYjOVkEqc-00000-00000431-00000736 hey Spyro press the jump button twice to
+N_LYjOVkEqc-00001-00000737-00001169 Glide and and don't be afraid afraid of
+N_LYjOVkEqc-00002-00001170-00001423 what falling from high mountain peaks
+N_LYjOVkEqc-00003-00001424-00001775 plummeting into prehistoric glaciers
+N_LYjOVkEqc-00004-00001776-00002096 oh that
+NE3LhSAvUJ8-00001-00003402-00005464 [Music]
+NE3LhSAvUJ8-00002-00005465-00006217 [Music]
+NE3LhSAvUJ8-00003-00006218-00006981 [Music]
+NE3LhSAvUJ8-00004-00006983-00007512 [Applause]
+NE3LhSAvUJ8-00006-00018129-00019429 [Music]
+NE3LhSAvUJ8-00007-00019430-00020195 [Applause]
+NE3LhSAvUJ8-00008-00020196-00020475 [Music]
+NE3LhSAvUJ8-00009-00020476-00021001 [Applause]
+NFa59P9H3F8-00000-00000039-00000271 waking up from sleep can be difficult
+NFa59P9H3F8-00001-00000272-00000567 but time waits for no one a brighter
+NFa59P9H3F8-00002-00000568-00000999 future demands hard work and dreams
+NFa59P9H3F8-00003-00001000-00001231 dreams of success
+NFa59P9H3F8-00004-00001232-00001511 everyone has dreams but only the dreams
+NFa59P9H3F8-00005-00001512-00001734 pursued with clarity and courage are
+NFa59P9H3F8-00006-00001735-00001998 ever realized through quality education
+NFa59P9H3F8-00007-00002000-00002295 tcf is empowering thousands of children
+NFa59P9H3F8-00008-00002296-00002502 to bring their dreams to life this
+NFa59P9H3F8-00009-00002503-00002791 ramadan give your zakat to educate the
+NFa59P9H3F8-00010-00002792-00003184 underprivileged children of pakistan
+NISowMq52jy-00000-00000500-00000881 this video is a paid advertisement from
+NISowMq52jy-00001-00000882-00001378 the future Google team and Mars red box
+NISowMq52jy-00002-00001379-00001839 are not responsible for the content
+NISowMq52jy-00003-00001841-00003179 enjoy enjoy and
+NISowMq52jy-00004-00003180-00003538 ladies and gentlemen and organisms of
+NISowMq52jy-00005-00003539-00004009 all ages m2 technology is pleased to
+NISowMq52jy-00006-00004010-00004252 present the cronometer
+NISowMq52jy-00007-00004253-00004597 of your future soon after it was
+NISowMq52jy-00008-00004598-00004867 discovered that mankind is the only
+NISowMq52jy-00009-00004868-00005106 living organism in the known universe
+NISowMq52jy-00010-00005107-00005581 that can't go back in time we decided to
+NISowMq52jy-00011-00005582-00005953 send this advertisement back in time so
+NISowMq52jy-00012-00005954-00006204 hopefully you will use it to go forward
+NISowMq52jy-00013-00006205-00006562 in time and we've called upon mr. brain
+NISowMq52jy-00014-00006563-00006769 to come out and show us some of the fine
+NISowMq52jy-00015-00006770-00007030 features of your chronometer of the
+NISowMq52jy-00016-00007031-00008106 future mr. brain mr. brain break well
+NISowMq52jy-00017-00008108-00008424 ladies and gentlemen this is the crew
+NISowMq52jy-00018-00008425-00008724 number of your future and you'll notice
+NISowMq52jy-00019-00008725-00009217 here that we have put a 20 hour battery
+NISowMq52jy-00020-00009218-00009607 built right into the strength of your
+NISowMq52jy-00021-00009608-00009910 chronometer of the future and during
+NISowMq52jy-00022-00009911-00010357 your for our solar sleep cycles feel a
+NISowMq52jy-00023-00010358-00010660 full discharge or your chronometer
+NISowMq52jy-00024-00010661-00010996 that's right here you'll notice we have
+NISowMq52jy-00025-00010997-00011145 twin
+NISowMq52jy-00026-00011146-00011461 4d cameras built right in
+NISowMq52jy-00027-00011462-00011896 they are five a-tearin pixels each which
+NISowMq52jy-00028-00011897-00012112 may surprise you and quite frankly
+NISowMq52jy-00029-00012113-00012373 overwhelm you but in the parlance of our
+NISowMq52jy-00030-00012374-00012733 times it's quite common here you'll
+NISowMq52jy-00031-00012734-00012975 notice we have a panic and medical alert
+NISowMq52jy-00032-00012976-00013246 button should you be in a panic or
+NISowMq52jy-00033-00013247-00013428 medical condition you just push this
+NISowMq52jy-00034-00013429-00013719 button here that's right and also it
+NISowMq52jy-00035-00013720-00014166 comes fully equipped with ACE
+NISowMq52jy-00036-00014166-00014516 a very popular feature ladies and
+NISowMq52jy-00037-00014518-00014816 gentlemen the self-destruct feature or
+NISowMq52jy-00038-00014818-00015111 use of the self-destruct feature will
+NISowMq52jy-00039-00015112-00015675 void your warranty yes yes well fed well
+NISowMq52jy-00040-00015676-00016050 be a memory kind of guy let's get over
+NISowMq52jy-00041-00016051-00016407 to the memory portable memory is called
+NISowMq52jy-00042-00016408-00016868 snap in memory you get a full eight
+NISowMq52jy-00043-00016869-00017253 thousand terabytes a portable snap in
+NISowMq52jy-00044-00017254-00017667 memory and we want our memory on a clock
+NISowMq52jy-00045-00017668-00018119 speed infinity minus a that's right
+NISowMq52jy-00046-00018120-00018483 infinity minus a since we discovered
+NISowMq52jy-00047-00018484-00018855 that we can't go faster than the fastest
+NISowMq52jy-00048-00018856-00019191 possible clock ever built so therefore
+NISowMq52jy-00049-00019192-00019719 we use infinity minus a factor yes yes
+NISowMq52jy-00050-00019720-00020325 quite quite right ladies and gentlemen
+NISowMq52jy-00051-00020326-00020862 we have the Intel I named Minnie that's
+NISowMq52jy-00052-00020863-00021264 right Intel 9x Minnie and we have it
+NISowMq52jy-00053-00021265-00021756 coupled with the risin eight nine that's
+NISowMq52jy-00054-00021757-00021975 right Minnie that's right so we've got
+NISowMq52jy-00055-00021976-00022514 the Intel 9x and the rising by Andy many
+NISowMq52jy-00056-00022515-00023219 processors giving you that's right
+NISowMq52jy-00057-00023220-00023316 ladies and gentlemen
+NISowMq52jy-00058-00023317-00024000 a total of 880 cars yes yes well said
+NISowMq52jy-00059-00024001-00024372 and to support those processors you need
+NISowMq52jy-00060-00024373-00024864 a lot of RAM I love memory and you're
+NISowMq52jy-00061-00024865-00025169 gonna get the bus of the future that's
+NISowMq52jy-00062-00025170-00025597 right
+NISowMq52jy-00063-00025598-00027936 that's right advantage mr. brain why
+NISowMq52jy-00064-00027937-00028058 don't you go on to some of the other
+NISowMq52jy-00065-00028060-00028395 features yes yes of course I get excited
+NISowMq52jy-00067-00032991-00033336 major award is already loaded into your
+NISowMq52jy-00068-00033337-00033585 cronometer of the future that's right
+NISowMq52jy-00069-00033586-00033933 and it will be viewable in ultra turbo
+NISowMq52jy-00070-00033934-00034419 10 star 4d technology which surpasses
+NISowMq52jy-00071-00034420-00034821 your current HD technology by a factor
+NISowMq52jy-00072-00034822-00035169 of 1000 that's right and not only do you
+NISowMq52jy-00073-00035170-00035436 get every movie nominated for a major
+NISowMq52jy-00074-00035437-00035738 award which can be called up instantly
+NISowMq52jy-00075-00035739-00036194 you get every published song in
+NISowMq52jy-00076-00036195-00036573 billboard that's right every song ever
+NISowMq52jy-00077-00036574-00036858 published in billboard is loaded into
+NISowMq52jy-00078-00036859-00037173 your chronometer of the future and this
+NISowMq52jy-00079-00037174-00037518 is documented by music brain that's
+NISowMq52jy-00080-00037519-00037890 right music brain our brain is the
+NISowMq52jy-00081-00037891-00038217 great-great grandchild of music brain
+NISowMq52jy-00082-00038218-00038388 that's right we got our music brain
+NISowMq52jy-00083-00038389-00038561 right here
+NISowMq52jy-00084-00038562-00039089 oh right I miss old papi and I do okay
+NISowMq52jy-00085-00039090-00039547 we'll just remember this is loaded in
+NISowMq52jy-00086-00039548-00040079 ultra ten star 4d technology and can be
+NISowMq52jy-00087-00040080-00040406 called up instantly on your chronometer
+NISowMq52jy-00088-00040407-00040727 of the future but even more exciting
+NISowMq52jy-00089-00040728-00041159 than that look at this we have operating
+NISowMq52jy-00090-00041160-00041453 temperatures that have surpassed any
+NISowMq52jy-00091-00041454-00041783 known operating temperatures for any
+NISowMq52jy-00092-00041784-00043385 device anywhere oh that's very exciting
+NISowMq52jy-00093-00043386-00043652 mr. brain why don't we just tell them
+NISowMq52jy-00094-00043653-00044218 where they can get their watch
+NISowMq52jy-00095-00044219-00045423 [Music]
+NISowMq52jy-00096-00045424-00045837 ladies and gentlemen your chronometer of
+NISowMq52jy-00097-00045838-00046360 your future is now available at Mars
+NISowMq52jy-00098-00046361-00046683 Mart that's right
+NISowMq52jy-00099-00046684-00047035 if you should happen to be flying by
+NISowMq52jy-00100-00047036-00047232 Mars
+NISowMq52jy-00101-00047233-00047615 remember our parking lots are available
+NISowMq52jy-00102-00047616-00048183 twenty four seven at the
+NISowMq52jy-00103-00048184-00048639 intergalactically known Mars Mart your
+NISowMq52jy-00104-00048640-00049290 favorite place to shop your cronometer
+NISowMq52jy-00105-00049291-00049702 of the future is also available at
+NISowMq52jy-00106-00049703-00050287 googas on that's right your favorite
+NISowMq52jy-00107-00050288-00050607 ordering palace
+NISowMq52jy-00108-00050608-00051033 gugus on now available on your
+NISowMq52jy-00109-00051034-00051601 cronometer of the future
+NISowMq52jy-00110-00051602-00051862 and sure to watch out for other exciting
+NISowMq52jy-00111-00051863-00052380 products such as the IBM model 350 with
+NISowMq52jy-00112-00052382-00052954 just under five megabytes of memory and
+NISowMq52jy-00113-00052954-00053655 of course the new Seagate's 60 terabyte
+NISowMq52jy-00114-00053657-00054112 portable hard drive SSD technology and
+NISowMq52jy-00115-00054113-00054700 bono from u2 coming at you live through
+NISowMq52jy-00116-00054701-00055351 PCI Express 3.0 times four and sponsored
+NISowMq52jy-00117-00055352-00056124 by Dell you to technology and of course
+NISowMq52jy-00118-00056125-00056623 MDOT to memory devices brought to you by
+NISowMq52jy-00119-00056624-00056982 m2 technology are you looking for the
+NISowMq52jy-00120-00056983-00057138 very finest and karaoke music
+NISowMq52jy-00121-00057139-00057429 entertainment into technology karaoke
+NISowMq52jy-00122-00057430-00057640 king and Markson mixer will exceed your
+NISowMq52jy-00123-00057641-00058069 expectations in every way guaranteed
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00000-00000308-00001414 [Music]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00001-00001415-00001589 [Applause]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00002-00001590-00001660 [Music]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00003-00001661-00002968 [Applause]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00004-00002969-00004003 [Music]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00005-00004004-00004149 [Applause]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00006-00004150-00005683 [Music]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00007-00005684-00005817 so
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00008-00005818-00007083 [Music]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00009-00007084-00007536 so
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00011-00016959-00017866 [Music]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00013-00021084-00022701 so
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00015-00029393-00030295 [Music]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00017-00036902-00037479 [Music]
+NJSSHsjDhWY-00018-00037480-00037688 you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00000-00000066-00000114 [Music]
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00001-00000115-00000470 yeah welcome back to the walkthrough you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00002-00000471-00001006 know what I haven't done for a while and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00003-00001007-00001429 yeah the mailbox it probably replaced
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00004-00001430-00001609 some of the ones I didn't see by now
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00005-00001610-00002009 probably oh oh wait oh no so that means
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00006-00002010-00002485 that okay so I just have to check the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00007-00002486-00002645 ones that I had before and then I can
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00008-00002646-00002879 get the other ones later then cuz I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00009-00002880-00003066 never had this problem before because I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00010-00003067-00003386 check the mail but if it's unconcerned
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00011-00003386-00003788 on the dueling alright so what do we
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00012-00003789-00004115 have here okay so yeah I will be able to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00013-00004116-00004345 get the others a little bit later on all
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00014-00004346-00004541 right well it was a little worried about
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00015-00004542-00004927 that so this is Ronald about dear number
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00016-00004928-00005331 three stack I was checking my Mac I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00017-00005332-00005558 secured some more important information
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00018-00005559-00005774 about team's yard this time pull all the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00019-00005775-00006031 stops to let my first go to i7 shadow
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00020-00006032-00006202 injera number three lately is deck is an
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00021-00006203-00006523 alpha grass and fire he sets up as
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00022-00006523-00006842 executor a banana execute are its big
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00023-00006843-00007087 explosion can really hurt so be careful
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00024-00007088-00007598 Ronal the stern face and dr. Mason deck
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00025-00007598-00007824 diagnosis - it's basically that that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00026-00007825-00008141 analysis system went yeah it's in the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00027-00008142-00008669 step - dealio label on now on on the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00028-00008670-00008987 machine so yeah but I already kind of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00029-00008988-00009196 talked you how to do a whole bunch of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00030-00009197-00009521 that Canales and building and stuff like
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00031-00009522-00009898 that so you might not exactly need it
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00032-00009899-00010337 but it is there and also happy face at
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00033-00010338-00010880 the end also step 3 alas alas he
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00034-00010881-00011167 probably has stuff to be ready for us
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00035-00011168-00011424 already
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00036-00011425-00011749 go ahead any decks have been uploaded in
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00037-00011750-00011914 my all of that machine why not come back
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00038-00011915-00012121 and visit my research center sometime I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00039-00012122-00012359 don't I check them out eventually
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00040-00012360-00012578 the auto tech Machine assembles very
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00041-00012579-00012749 them very quickly for you let you know
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00042-00012750-00012961 about future updates as they develop dr.
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00043-00012962-00013071 Mason
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00044-00013072-00013452 happy face and a booster pack is the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00045-00013453-00013566 kind of things that I was worried about
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00046-00013566-00014141 missing oh yes elective office Oh
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00047-00014143-00014427 regular all right on here yeah horn
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00048-00014428-00014484 attack
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00049-00014485-00014862 we got a ram it's not that yeah it
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00050-00014863-00015054 forces the switch and right ons got a
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00051-00015055-00015336 lot of HP but it costs a lot a lot of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00052-00015337-00015612 energy cards to use that bad boy hello
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00053-00015613-00016113 extra vocalist yes pokemon trainer -
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00054-00016113-00016776 very nice hmm ok alright so let's just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00055-00016777-00017199 see what dog ok guy that's the end of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00056-00017200-00017463 let's see what happens if we wipe out
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00057-00017464-00017901 some of these things here and yes go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00058-00017902-00017937 ahead
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00059-00017938-00018672 there we go ha ha yes please so I'm
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00060-00018673-00019011 hoping that they'll send more after I do
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00061-00019012-00019449 this because otherwise I technically
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00062-00019450-00019782 missed some messages is there gonna go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00063-00019783-00020190 out of here when you come no box no no
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00064-00020191-00020556 mail ok so maybe we have to wait for
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00065-00020557-00020790 more mail or maybe you have to turn off
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00066-00020791-00020946 the game or something like that so we're
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00067-00020947-00021219 we're good for now I think if not I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00068-00021220-00021569 have to find the transcript or something
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00069-00021570-00022053 alright do the psychic star ball after
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00070-00022054-00022319 cleaning out our mail or other cleaning
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00071-00022320-00022464 out our mailbox you made it here quickly
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00072-00022465-00022764 mint it's me Ronald good to see you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00073-00022765-00022932 again is it
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00074-00022933-00023094 did you have some trouble in the gr
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00075-00023095-00023313 fighting fortress labyrinth I got sick
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00076-00023314-00023391 of waiting phew
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00077-00023392-00023628 listen I have new team gr Intel there's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00078-00023629-00023808 a man called the GR King in the gr
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00079-00023809-00024021 castle just north of here there's a cat
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00080-00024022-00024204 stuff you need two coins to meet them
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00081-00024205-00024414 those would be the gr psychic coin and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00082-00024415-00024609 the gr colorless coin you should get
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00083-00024610-00024810 them quickly and attack that castle I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00084-00024811-00024939 do my best
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00085-00024940-00025149 it depends on if there's a lick a tongue
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00086-00025150-00025362 but seeing how slowly work I bet I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00087-00025363-00025458 get there first
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00088-00025459-00025627 I'm off later mints
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00089-00025629-00025749 [Music]
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00090-00025750-00026224 he's off and let's take a look around
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00091-00026225-00026362 here whoa
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00092-00026363-00026495 so you've already made a here Ament
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00093-00026495-00026680 that's great now but you'll never defeat
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00094-00026681-00026945 our King Vilasini maybe you should
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00095-00026945-00027118 rethink your minute mortars before
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00096-00027119-00027457 continuing I almost see about that oh
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00097-00027458-00027689 come on say no pehoe
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00098-00027689-00027902 I wish the shaky cards look before it
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00099-00027902-00028151 dark hypno level 26 giving my rare
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00100-00028152-00028420 Mewtwo level 60 card in exchange what do
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00101-00028422-00028661 you say mmm lulu miss y-yes I wasn't
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00102-00028662-00028898 like that as a matter of fact I'm just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00103-00028899-00029167 like darling you to level 60 care of you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00104-00029168-00029677 what's the movie promo Mewtwo a powerful
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00105-00029678-00030002 mutant it's yeah you might know the song
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00106-00030002-00030262 from another one grab to energy cartoon
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00107-00030263-00030427 this kind of I'll attach them and then
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00108-00030428-00030832 cyber 440 saw yeah it's pretty versatile
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00109-00030833-00031145 little kitty there well kind of mid game
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00110-00031145-00031223 so to speak
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00111-00031224-00031973 I'm so very happy the card you gave me
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00112-00031974-00032137 here's a document delivery tae sik's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00113-00032138-00032405 I've been using it well that's good to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00114-00032406-00032624 hear you haven't seen you would leave my
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00115-00032625-00032845 sight anyway I've been trying my hardest
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00116-00032846-00033104 thing a good deck 14 gr but I just can't
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00117-00033105-00033326 after all team Jared decks are known to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00118-00033327-00033562 be any known as the best of the best
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00119-00033563-00033860 I don't know about that was I make huh
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00120-00033861-00034070 I'm going to do a high D a psychic
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00121-00034071-00034460 member of team gr all right so I guess
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00122-00034461-00034858 we're good here and receptionist's thank
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00123-00034859-00035018 you for visiting this is team gear
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00124-00035019-00035207 psychic stronghold as fortress is the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00125-00035208-00035515 last structure protecting gr castle not
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00126-00035516-00035689 really we just heard from Ronald that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00127-00035690-00036062 there's the colorless I mean grx but
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00128-00036063-00036214 there's the color that nevermind they'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00129-00036215-00036407 hear the psychic strongholds a woman
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00130-00036408-00036617 named Claire alongside of her are four
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00131-00036618-00036893 other teams your members to fight whoa
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00132-00036894-00037043 out of these four you only need to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00133-00037044-00037315 defeat three members to move on well you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00134-00037316-00037601 know I'm gonna battle them all so let's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00135-00037602-00038006 throw that off the table
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00136-00038007-00038231 shall battle rules inside that is all
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00137-00038232-00038438 please enjoy dealing in team gr psychic
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00138-00038439-00039002 stronghold thank you thank you so got
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00139-00039003-00039578 some spikes you got some test tubes how
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00140-00039579-00039749 are you seeing anything around here so
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00141-00039750-00040649 no no maybe no one's home name is Claire
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00142-00040650-00040927 I need a team chair psychic stronghold
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00143-00040928-00041192 does it to do so you're the troublemaker
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00144-00041193-00041518 trying to recover the cards you stolen
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00145-00041519-00041963 you called me a troublemaker and then
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00146-00041964-00042479 say you stole cards let that sink in for
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00147-00042480-00042734 a bit even deed come far I won't praise
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00148-00042735-00042956 their efforts though I assume you set
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00149-00042957-00043208 your sights on a gr castle well you've
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00150-00043209-00043421 got to get through me first kid I won't
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00151-00043422-00043511 go easy on you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00152-00043512-00043712 however if you do happen to beat me I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00153-00043713-00043883 have been quite the feat allow me to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00154-00043884-00044063 introduce my fellow stronghold members
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00155-00044064-00044678 first is Clyde to my left's thanks much
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00156-00044679-00044977 I'm Clyde next is the young and talented
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00157-00044978-00045329 Victoria mint
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00158-00045330-00045839 I've been waiting huh huh it's easy
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00159-00045840-00046040 Victoria is wait for me to complete my
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00160-00046041-00046376 instructions wasn't that loud you don't
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00161-00046377-00046613 have to be so strict there you go again
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00162-00046614-00046885 listen to a word I say
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00163-00046886-00047171 violence okay okay oh stop it please
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00164-00047172-00047645 I'll decoy rope I bet you Turner
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00165-00047646-00047927 suspected the famed ER number three
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00166-00047928-00048074 could be so pretty
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00167-00048075-00048287 wait a second she said gr number three
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00168-00048288-00048456 which she's clearly gr number four
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00169-00048457-00048703 [Music]
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00170-00048704-00048826 they must have been a tight ball
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00171-00048827-00049048 somewhere that's right little Victoria
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00172-00049049-00049279 was gr number three the whole time
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00173-00049280-00050197 okay maybe not help next is Kevin yeah
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00174-00050198-00050544 hi I'm Kevin we're well met Mintz
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00175-00050545-00050761 finally allow me to introduce my
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00176-00050762-00050866 daughter Heidi
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00177-00050867-00051054 [Music]
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00178-00051055-00051274 you only need to defeat three of these
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00179-00051275-00051465 stronghold members to move on if you can
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00180-00051466-00051670 manage that I'll turn my elevator on for
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00181-00051671-00051826 you I'll be waiting for you in the upper
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00182-00051827-00052261 room and so she goes and I'm gonna go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00183-00052262-00052426 from left to right for the sake of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00184-00052427-00052738 organization I'm Kevin team dear and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00185-00052739-00052939 psychic fortress members battles with me
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00186-00052940-00053134 are a bit extreme I use a custom rule
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00187-00053135-00053398 for resistance and said the usual -30
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00188-00053399-00053730 all resistance is a minus 10 reduction
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00189-00053732-00054079 and done we feel confident we're -10
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00190-00054079-00054370 resistance lets us start the duel no
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00191-00054371-00054547 feel free to challenge the other members
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00192-00054548-00054796 if you like it's a bouquet you'll all
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00193-00054797-00055075 mint you got for a card battle like the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00194-00055076-00055204 change the game mechanics a bit for
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00195-00055204-00055378 resistance in my duels it's going to the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00196-00055379-00055588 30 another 10 remember shall I begin
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00197-00055589-00055885 then sure we should be just fine with
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00198-00055886-00056344 fireweed super effective lower
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00199-00056345-00056764 resistance is a factor but that is okay
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00200-00056765-00057105 so yeah I'm using my fire weed so this
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00201-00057107-00057271 everything should be okay it's all gonna
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00202-00057272-00057682 come out pretty even overall oh except
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00203-00057683-00058041 if I don't have energy and Basic Pokemon
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00204-00058042-00058438 that match the energy that I have I mean
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00205-00058439-00058729 yeah mark bass boat okay we got
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00206-00058729-00059064 something here got something here um
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00207-00059065-00059329 yeah this this Avril by the way I keep
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00208-00059329-00059479 forgetting to mention might be a slight
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00209-00059479-00059779 upgrade over the original Abra because
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00210-00059779-00060028 if it's it's got the same sized shock
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00211-00060029-00060328 but it's also got vanish but in exchange
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00212-00060329-00060717 for the extra HP of 10 as well it's got
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00213-00060719-00060973 our cheap cost of 1 instead of 0 keep
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00214-00060974-00061167 forgetting to mention that and issues
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00215-00061169-00061441 yeah that could be a problem of a Mewtwo
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00216-00061441-00061775 anyway I guess I'll just attack
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00217-00061776-00062039 the tackle can't really do much anything
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00218-00062040-00062204 else it's like it's siphoned out this
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00219-00062204-00062546 I'm just kind of let that go and see how
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00220-00062547-00062960 things flow mm Bareilles of course
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00221-00062961-00063119 of course you're gonna get you're gonna
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00222-00063120-00063329 the head flips all day and all night
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00223-00063329-00063722 aren't you aren't you know another fire
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00224-00063723-00063954 [Music]
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00225-00063955-00064202 and you know I didn't take out my grass
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00226-00064203-00064436 energy by the way I give that the site
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00227-00064437-00064658 there and call it a turn because yeah I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00228-00064659-00064816 have not tweaked my back since yeah I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00229-00064817-00065066 see that and I was still grassing it up
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00230-00065066-00065576 so yeah okay oh I can freely tackle or
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00231-00065577-00065789 retreat over to site there and finish
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00232-00065790-00066011 off the Abra but I probably will do I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00233-00066012-00066365 sure now because I want to go to site
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00234-00066366-00066602 there and also gonna use one of my
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00235-00066603-00066836 overabundance of fire so I could just do
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00236-00066837-00067397 a slash and save my good ol Bulbasaur if
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00237-00067398-00067631 a later that possibly could come in
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00238-00067632-00067673 handy
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00239-00067674-00067901 mostly I don't get a Charmander at this
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00240-00067902-00068138 rate because yeah I got Charmeleon in my
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00241-00068139-00068369 hand already you saw plus a double
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00242-00068370-00068588 colorless we'll see how things go and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00243-00068589-00068846 hammer is probably gonna cause paralysis
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00244-00068847-00069272 to me based on my luck okay no I guess
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00245-00069273-00069431 it was only that guy who is using the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00246-00069432-00070100 gameshark alrights fire well grass I'm
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00247-00070101-00070643 gonna put that in there I could Pokemon
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00248-00070644-00070853 traitor into a Charmander and then start
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00249-00070854-00071048 attacking with Charmeleon but then I'd
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00250-00071049-00071306 have to get off my Charizard and we'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00251-00071307-00071405 just see how things go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00252-00071406-00071654 I'm a decent position anyway you know so
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00253-00071655-00071864 there to see how things well he's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00254-00071865-00072158 talking a retreat abra probably really
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00255-00072159-00072431 okay but I'm gonna bet you were gonna
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00256-00072432-00072686 retreat unless you knew the coin flip
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00257-00072687-00072854 was gonna go ahead because you turned on
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00258-00072855-00073316 your gameshark who knows who knows all I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00259-00073317-00073426 know is
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00260-00073427-00073733 maybe I should Pokemon trigger I'll go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00261-00073734-00074078 Charizard swap farm a minimum which
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00262-00074079-00074243 Charmander though this one or the other
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00263-00074244-00074429 charm man I'm thinking the other charm
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00264-00074430-00074756 man there because he yeah it's got more
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00265-00074757-00075034 HP and I might actually need that and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00266-00075035-00075215 we'll call it a turn
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00267-00075216-00075425 I'm just probably gonna end up evolving
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00268-00075426-00075671 it straight over to Charmeleon ASAP
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00269-00075672-00076027 anyway but ooh that could be a problem
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00270-00076028-00076790 we'll see that yeah alright so that is a
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00271-00076791-00077102 goner so I'll get another prize card and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00272-00077103-00077423 oh sure now I can after I played pokemon
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00273-00077424-00077675 trainer sure now you give me I'm playing
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00274-00077676-00077819 the first song oh oh you like those
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00275-00077820-00078283 apples just because despite that draw
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00276-00078284-00078575 probably got else are merely in my deck
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00277-00078576-00079057 - that's like I got both of all times
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00278-00079058-00079355 alright saw the bench manipulation could
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00279-00079356-00079577 cause decent amount of damage but I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00280-00079578-00079739 probably be I was gonna say I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00281-00079740-00079997 probably be 20 but ya did
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00282-00079998-00080540 no no oh I got all those tails yeah I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00283-00080541-00080714 forgotten well okay you're getting the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00284-00080715-00080963 coin flips Gibbs I'll prepare a
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00285-00080964-00081380 Bulbasaur like like so does like set up
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00286-00081381-00081590 in the future because I could do 5 by 50
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00287-00081591-00081815 damage with Charmeleon so in the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00288-00081816-00081959 meantime I'm just gonna do a little
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00289-00081960-00082192 scratch with ya
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00290-00082193-00082403 so yeah in the meantime I'm just gonna
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00291-00082404-00082634 do that and tackle it Bulbasaur I'll let
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00292-00082635-00082913 them knock out hypno if you want cereal
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00293-00082914-00083171 they'll be okay just finish them off
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00294-00083172-00083432 really quickly with that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00295-00083433-00083687 Charmeleon when the time is a right are
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00296-00083688-00084221 nope go ah and now he's until this is
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00297-00084222-00084581 like yeah you don't really have all that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00298-00084582-00084797 much to go by here that Mewtwo with the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00299-00084798-00085057 side crash would be handy if I was using
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00300-00085058-00085652 psychic pokémon but I'm not so I'm gonna
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00301-00085653-00085967 go set that up for the future
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00302-00085968-00086419 and discard one fire and there goes a
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00303-00086420-00086806 dark hip no very nice here comes the me
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00304-00086807-00087049 too I pretty much expected that but it's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00305-00087050-00087422 not really gonna be it's not gonna make
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00306-00087423-00087757 it it you can't attach that many energy
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00307-00087758-00088223 per turn and yeah so I'm gonna I should
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00308-00088224-00088426 actually do this I'm gonna go scarred
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00309-00088427-00088750 that and grab some of those fires just a
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00310-00088751-00089035 case things go south and flamethrower
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00311-00089036-00089287 there we go it's probably gonna retreat
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00312-00089288-00089635 Mewtwo but it shouldn't be that big of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00313-00089636-00089810 an issue at least like I thought he was
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00314-00089811-00090053 gonna retreat the other critter well
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00315-00090054-00090292 that didn't work out so okay he's doing
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00316-00090293-00090532 that and no he's not because it cost two
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00317-00090533-00090728 energy cards to retreat Mewtwo soul he's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00318-00090729-00091115 a goner you're just like I might as well
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00319-00091116-00091385 just evolve that for the fun of it and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00320-00091386-00091573 yeah just use flamethrower for the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00321-00091574-00091924 fanciness and the guy could use slash as
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00322-00091925-00092494 well but yeah voila I think I was in
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00323-00092495-00092887 pretty decent control that game I guess
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00324-00092888-00093041 I lost your stuff minute except in the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00325-00093042-00093403 early game but happens sometimes
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00326-00093404-00093790 no man yeah
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00327-00093791-00094063 Manama now there's a lick my nemesis
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00328-00094064-00094599 liquor tongue well legends booster pack
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00329-00094600-00095377 we get duplicated on the leave regular
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00330-00095378-00095611 Rhyhorn I've had the penny Pokemon can't
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00331-00095612-00095815 attack this Pokemon day then your bonus
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00332-00095816-00096028 extern and a heart attack for 30 so
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00333-00096029-00096250 again like the ride on its cost a lot of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00334-00096251-00096625 energy female leader and ten now hums
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00335-00096626-00096835 love our heads and call for family you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00336-00096836-00097011 know building you know fighting energy
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00337-00097012-00097246 it's there for my psychic powers to be
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00338-00097247-00097471 so inaccurate oh I guess I should act to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00339-00097472-00097834 me my elevators a few then when it over
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00340-00097835-00097993 you're late Charlotte you can use it to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00341-00097994-00098137 meet Claire you can't reach her any
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00342-00098138-00098299 other way I'm afraid so you just walk
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00343-00098300-00098446 off switch and it automatically
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00344-00098447-00098725 activates it kind of makes sense all
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00345-00098726-00098998 right let's do lists you choosing me as
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00346-00098999-00099421 one of your battle opponents in the turn
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00347-00099422-00099637 fighter there's no way you'll be able to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00348-00099638-00099811 top my back this time nope
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00349-00099812-00099976 my challenger requirement is a
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00350-00099977-00100141 restriction on energy type you know
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00351-00100142-00100279 energy cards you're allowed to use our
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00352-00100280-00100519 psychic energy cards every deck is made
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00353-00100520-00100735 of a sucky type in mind come on come on
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00354-00100736-00101482 let's fight yes you think you're doing
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00355-00101483-00101737 got energy cards on a sec eating type in
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00356-00101738-00101866 your deck you want to test you might
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00357-00101867-00102061 against me correct get rid of that other
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00358-00102062-00102244 energy in your place of its psychic type
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00359-00102245-00102706 energy well you're in luck because I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00360-00102707-00102991 have set up my paralyzed ahead of time
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00361-00102992-00103782 like something forgot the energy I guess
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00362-00103783-00104095 did I forget to do that's a whopper
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00363-00104096-00104446 Swampert I don't know I don't know but
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00364-00104447-00104689 look at that we got 220 there we are
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00365-00104690-00105028 good all right so let's give another
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00366-00105029-00105202 look-see I'm gonna try this version
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00367-00105203-00105439 after I was I'm saying might be a slight
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00368-00105440-00105505 upgrade
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00369-00105506-00105861 Kadabra this jinx Oh actually why that's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00370-00105863-00106063 right it uses the water
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00371-00106064-00106543 forgot about let's see another jinx to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00372-00106544-00106785 like maybe that one got that chinks I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00373-00106786-00106935 got this new too because of psychic
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00374-00106936-00107167 energy yeah
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00375-00107168-00107368 complete recovery back you maybe I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00376-00107369-00107566 use the other Mewtwo promo that I got I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00377-00107567-00107791 thought I'd use this Mewtwo as well just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00378-00107792-00108108 for the sake of variety now why do I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00379-00108109-00108363 even chew stuff that stinks of disease
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00380-00108364-00108970 um Rattata resistance to psychic ahaha
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00381-00108971-00109284 sing with Raticate scene with the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00382-00109285-00109438 Jigglypuff and Wigglytuff
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00383-00109439-00109669 tor else as well so I'm still pretty
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00384-00109670-00110064 well prepared aside from a certain
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00385-00110065-00110719 certain issue down below here and I use
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00386-00110720-00111097 the energy of session all right so we're
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00387-00111098-00111181 good to go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00388-00111182-00111397 hope your deck is made with only suck
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00389-00111398-00111622 you type energy cards if it is accepted
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00390-00111623-00111757 challenge and show you how strong I've
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00391-00111758-00112132 become no oh you're gonna fight the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00392-00112133-00112303 other members that said oh my get out of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00393-00112304-00112485 my face them and the meh meh meh meh
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00394-00112486-00112681 aha your decks energy cars and all
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00395-00112682-00112843 psychic type that you're all water type
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00396-00112844-00113089 at some point but let's start that's so
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00397-00113090-00113473 right with for Fry's cars and she's got
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00398-00113474-00113644 like a fanfare going on in the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00399-00113645-00113724 background
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00400-00113725-00113977 you could have a little fun reading that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00401-00113978-00114574 off on the side yeah as you know she's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00402-00114575-00114832 kind of on the popular side especially
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00403-00114833-00115200 in the Lightning place why did I do that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00404-00115201-00115546 they're just laughing at the hell all
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00405-00115547-00115825 right let's go a playbill from next turn
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00406-00115826-00116092 I got my resistance going on here so I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00407-00116093-00116527 should be alright yeah oh man its energy
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00408-00116528-00117118 spike version but yeah I kind of swaps
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00409-00117119-00117382 the energies around so if something goes
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00410-00117383-00117885 awry with my toros but yeah he's just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00411-00117886-00118110 gonna end up powering up my yeah and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00412-00118111-00118528 then that kind of nulls my tauros anyway
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00413-00118529-00118648 but anyway
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00414-00118649-00119170 gonna do the bill and I'm gonna go pop
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00415-00119171-00119545 that on there I guess I will power up
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00416-00119546-00119722 totall select I'm gonna set them up for
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00417-00119723-00119916 the future and let her do the energy
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00418-00119917-00120216 transfer and then outline energy removal
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00419-00120217-00120550 and pulling out dark Kedavra that's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00420-00120551-00120829 alright if you'd like to they gonna give
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00421-00120830-00121315 the energy wait what that you have no
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00422-00121316-00121884 energy cards oh no that's not good for
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00423-00121885-00122290 you go oh man especially since I got the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00424-00122291-00122818 energy removal tech well she probably
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00425-00122819-00122989 won't be able to do that much unless she
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00426-00122990-00123328 gets some good draw cards ok energy
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00427-00123329-00123489 removal that will help her a little bit
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00428-00123490-00123791 no that's yeah that's not an energy card
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00429-00123792-00124114 so we're gonna go flop that on there and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00430-00124115-00124303 I even got professor open my home but I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00431-00124304-00124474 don't want to dump my energy removals
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00432-00124475-00124669 when I'm in this sort of position you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00433-00124670-00125020 know so I'm just gonna keep on stomping
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00434-00125021-00125572 on and allow myself to wipe out this oh
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00435-00125573-00125947 yeah did you see on the picture and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00436-00125948-00126246 allow myself to wipe out them you to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00437-00126247-00127119 probably yeah other than huh well sorry
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00438-00127120-00127426 that's the site that's my prowess is
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00439-00127427-00127710 tech in a nutshell all right let's do
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00440-00127711-00128141 the stomper and wipe out the view to ah
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00441-00128142-00128466 here we go ah so much for that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00442-00128467-00128815 resistance up I mean I know weak this
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00443-00128816-00129054 air resistance applied there
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00444-00129055-00129284 okay so I guess I'll start going for
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00445-00129285-00129576 that I mean I don't really have to but
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00446-00129577-00129849 as long as I just want to make sure tor
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00447-00129850-00130002 else is powered up and whatnot like the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00448-00130003-00130350 rampage you know it's a yeah you'd have
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00449-00130351-00130554 with more damage counter so I'm gonna
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00450-00130555-00130821 focus on that just to stop for now I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00451-00130822-00131016 just want to make sure Taurus is good to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00452-00131017-00131069 go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00453-00131070-00131400 nothing nothing
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00454-00131401-00131817 I find this hard the police plopped out
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00455-00131818-00132369 on the bench yeah oh my Cadabra -
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00456-00132370-00132624 thought I really don't want to I really
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00457-00132625-00132813 don't want to Professor drunk now all
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00458-00132814-00132950 right stop
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00459-00132951-00133206 let's go I thought was gonna knock out
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00460-00133207-00133257 Rattata
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00461-00133258-00133608 cuz I figured my tail flips would end it
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00462-00133609-00134106 did knots oh okay we got something here
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00463-00134107-00134487 Oh a bra Oh No then I'll be able to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00464-00134488-00134778 Professor Oak so on the next turn inside
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00465-00134779-00135648 saw oh jeez I could say my deck is
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00466-00135649-00135879 working perfectly technically because
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00467-00135880-00136212 I'm protecting her from using anything
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00468-00136213-00136740 oh okay so just stall a little bit more
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00469-00136741-00137130 there um let's go ahead and power up
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00470-00137131-00137463 something else here know what that I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00471-00137464-00137649 think I got enough okay the kind I think
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00472-00137650-00137790 I got enough from you to see the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00473-00137791-00138096 professor wrong can fill up my hand once
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00474-00138097-00138585 again and let's see if she actually
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00475-00138586-00138963 accepts it really I figured happy to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00476-00138964-00139154 thin your deck a little bit there
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00477-00139155-00139536 alright oh that's right Oh anyway let's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00478-00139537-00139914 see here yeah I think I think I'm just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00479-00139915-00140231 gonna stop heads please thank you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00480-00140232-00140681 this is about time and I think I ran out
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00481-00140682-00140903 of energy removal anyway and up
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00482-00140904-00141143 finishing the turn not gonna not gonna
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00483-00141144-00141368 retreat much who'd have retreated but
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00484-00141369-00141700 maybe Toros is just too too threatening
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00485-00141701-00142433 mmm so what that's and so that's the key
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00486-00142434-00142721 oh and I guess you would have had the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00487-00142722-00142973 retreat anyway technically Kangaskhan
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00488-00142974-00143117 yeah so I thought you were treated to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00489-00143118-00143273 retreat you to do you see your face
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00490-00143274-00144431 there I get up oh yeah and what can I do
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00491-00144432-00144710 I can't like attack the King has gone
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00492-00144711-00144881 very quickly with anything I've got
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00493-00144882-00145028 right now so that might actually be
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00494-00145029-00145253 quite helpful for her especially with
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00495-00145254-00145409 fetch as long as he doesn't
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00496-00145410-00145655 she's got an energy card but for now I'm
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00497-00145656-00145877 gonna go with that and continue stopping
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00498-00145878-00146258 away cuz yeah if I put all Kadabra to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00499-00146259-00146600 try and do 50 he'll only do 30 there
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00500-00146601-00146852 Kadabra if you don't have energy though
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00501-00146853-00147056 that's not okay there you go see the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00502-00147057-00147305 fetch here is gonna be that's gonna be
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00503-00147306-00147586 probably the deal breaker of things
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00504-00147587-00147821 we're a plus power that could be a nice
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00505-00147822-00147907 surprise
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00506-00147908-00148303 wait wait which which me to is which I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00507-00148304-00148613 probably want to go with the first mew
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00508-00148614-00149093 to them and stop let's go and yeah I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00509-00149094-00149294 don't want to confuse myself with tor
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00510-00149295-00149435 else either so I just thought I'd
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00511-00149436-00149858 consistently do 20 or 30 damage uh-huh
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00512-00149859-00150200 so next turn I can actually stay the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00513-00150201-00150401 turn after next turn I will win because
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00514-00150402-00150590 I have plus power unless she swaps out
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00515-00150591-00150881 the kangaskhan but yeah it's like she's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00516-00150882-00151169 not really doing much of anything I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00517-00151170-00151265 wonder if I should give her another
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00518-00151266-00151685 chance i ah I was kind of kind of a long
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00519-00151686-00152039 duel as it is just based on her by HP
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00520-00152040-00152351 critters it will see though but yeah
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00521-00152352-00152593 actually I don't need the plus power no
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00522-00152594-00152972 that's uh
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00523-00152973-00153444 hmm might as well not doing anything
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00524-00153445-00153648 else I can conceive Rinku faults you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00525-00153649-00153930 seen I drew there geez
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00526-00153931-00154272 well well
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00527-00154273-00154512 yeah I really she couldn't really do
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00528-00154513-00154985 anything
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00529-00154986-00155286 was I that tougher did you just get bad
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00530-00155287-00156155 dross and pop it up it up pop pop okay
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00531-00156156-00156393 okay here you go yep we're gonna get
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00532-00156394-00157115 some new cards here or maybe knots maybe
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00533-00157116-00157485 maybe not okay it's no one that I lost
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00534-00157486-00157728 so badly in your prior confrontations
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00535-00157729-00157902 yeah I'd like to make my search you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00536-00157903-00158024 could thank me later
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00537-00158025-00158280 push me aside you know they'd like to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00538-00158281-00158484 let the elevator has activated I bet you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00539-00158485-00158607 know you already knew that from before
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00540-00158608-00158874 right yeah I already beat me if they're
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00541-00158875-00159123 super stupid superhuman abilities what
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00542-00159124-00159357 are they you defeat the other members
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00543-00159358-00159564 now if you want to go on all right I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00544-00159565-00159606 do it
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00545-00159607-00159822 dude you again what you want to fight
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00546-00159823-00160361 against fear your abilities at get weak
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00547-00160362-00160745 superior doesn't that mean you're a
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00548-00160746-00161121 stronger player than others but I just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00549-00161122-00161331 never mind don't get too cocky just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00550-00161332-00161562 because you beat me okay previous duels
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00551-00161563-00161763 alright I've been raring to go I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00552-00161764-00161937 remember I with special rules or section
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00553-00161938-00162306 of energy yes all right this is your
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00554-00162307-00162975 last chance now watch her beat me just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00555-00162976-00163434 just because okay at or else again
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00556-00163435-00163800 let's try that again then I suppose see
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00557-00163801-00164139 how things go I only got the Rattata for
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00558-00164140-00164316 resistance in the future and whatnot
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00559-00164317-00164451 hopefully she doesn't leave with the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00560-00164452-00164934 Mewtwo that has no she did well we'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00561-00164935-00165003 see how things go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00562-00165004-00165300 I guess I'll this is a very similar
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00563-00165301-00165620 beginning here done
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00564-00165621-00166014 all rights bosses laid our cadaver for
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00565-00166015-00166386 the opera's of course and here comes the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00566-00166387-00166671 energy spike maybe she'll be able to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00567-00166672-00167103 move it maybe she won't she did nuts so
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00568-00167104-00167535 I will go ahead plop down there I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00569-00167536-00167778 even do that I'm definitely doing that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00570-00167779-00168471 and heads please thank you and if she
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00571-00168472-00168609 just has low energy in her doctor
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00572-00168610-00168729 something like that I don't know
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00573-00168730-00168972 all right energy spike maybe she'll be
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00574-00168973-00169107 able to offset nope
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00575-00169108-00169376 so I could still knock out that Mewtwo
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00576-00169377-00169734 pretty rapidly actually I actually I'll
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00577-00169735-00170001 guarantee I'll knock out that Mewtwo if
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00578-00170002-00170325 I get tails won't matter cap just just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00579-00170326-00170502 to be sure that's gonna cause some
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00580-00170503-00170673 higher with the energy swapping
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00581-00170674-00171083 so yeah there's the other Mewtwo I'm
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00582-00171084-00171354 trying to get rid of this one as quickly
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00583-00171355-00171462 as possible
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00584-00171463-00171807 oh well well let's see how things go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00585-00171808-00172155 here is you put it on the retina so I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00586-00172156-00172350 can just keep Toral's probably filled
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00587-00172351-00172526 with energy to continue stomping away
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00588-00172527-00172782 yeah that's looking pretty good there
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00589-00172783-00173037 and just let her power up my other
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00590-00173038-00173358 Pokemon in whatever way she pleases I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00591-00173359-00173505 guess this to me she'll get head coin
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00592-00173506-00173987 flips and had coin flip of the up okay
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00593-00173988-00174945 yeah that's okay oh no I did not just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00594-00174946-00175109 guess
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00595-00175110-00176026 oh no well now she's not gonna be sigh
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00596-00176027-00176318 burning energy removal okay that might
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00597-00176319-00176483 be working for you because then if you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00598-00176484-00176749 get the heads up here that will prevent
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00599-00176750-00176872 Toros from attacking
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00600-00176873-00177110 okay you've actually got something going
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00601-00177111-00177604 here I don't I definitely get a cadaver
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00602-00177605-00178268 I probably going there should I don't
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00603-00178269-00178424 flowers should I just go for the rattan
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00604-00178425-00178745 uh yeah I think I'll go for the Kadabra
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00605-00178746-00179065 and in the turn she can go ahead and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00606-00179066-00179284 knock all Toro so she wants to hike yes
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00607-00179285-00179624 I've got a bunch of other stuff waiting
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00608-00179625-00179866 in the wings cleaning the other hammer
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00609-00179867-00180161 up and they're at a DAT to boot so there
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00610-00180162-00180236 you go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00611-00180237-00180499 you can you can just do a little little
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00612-00180500-00180901 bit of that okay okay we got that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00613-00180902-00181247 oh that up Dan and determine yeah cuz
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00614-00181248-00181397 I'm in an awkward spot because of the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00615-00181398-00181753 head coin flips so yeah it's kind of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00616-00181754-00182009 forced to do other sorts of powering up
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00617-00182010-00182186 otherwise which is no big deal because
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00618-00182187-00182419 energy car just kind of moved around
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00619-00182420-00182836 just go over your tatah and flop down
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00620-00182837-00183186 there cut that bra and we will bytes
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00621-00183187-00183494 take a little piece out of that some u2
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00622-00183495-00183845 and side that pop salts she seems pretty
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00623-00183846-00184012 happy with that job maybe because she's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00624-00184013-00184307 getting energy this time she's not gonna
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00625-00184308-00184537 be a little early yeah not really gonna
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00626-00184538-00184781 really attack of that professor all that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00627-00184782-00185111 will be very helpful for her and bosses
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00628-00185112-00185396 way dark cadaver again I'm gonna guess
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00629-00185397-00185854 it's okay anyway oh yeah
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00630-00185855-00186124 dark goal doc it's uh needs a lot of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00631-00186125-00186411 stuff a lot of stuff I think
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00632-00186412-00186620 Rattata will take care of that before
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00633-00186621-00187033 the four things get out of hand probably
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00634-00187034-00187453 will see it is a water pokemon though so
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00635-00187454-00187661 there's no no sort of resistance going
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00636-00187662-00187987 on I see I sell if you're still not
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00637-00187988-00188265 you're not powering up okay
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00638-00188266-00188768 all right lights and call it a turn
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00639-00188769-00189024 so yeah I was I was expecting her to use
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00640-00189025-00189218 dark gold luck because I'm using
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00641-00189219-00189519 colorless resistance so I thought you
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00642-00189520-00189693 would use that to kind of try and sweep
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00643-00189694-00190146 my field which is not maybe I maybe I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00644-00190147-00190311 shouldn't have given her another chance
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00645-00190312-00190608 you know I just not be one of the best
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00646-00190609-00191019 players out there I'm gonna defend it
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00647-00191020-00191360 Rattata just in case and do a bite
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00648-00191361-00191786 because something else maybe are coming
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00649-00191787-00192084 maybe I don't know and I'm not counting
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00650-00192085-00192153 on it
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00651-00192154-00192462 so she says she put outside knock and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00652-00192463-00192675 she's got the dizziness the dark are
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00653-00192676-00192984 that's not gonna do any damage at all I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00654-00192985-00193134 mean it even as a matter of fact that
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00655-00193135-00193365 sie doch can't do any damage because
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00656-00193366-00193839 she's only got psychic energy um just go
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00657-00193840-00194159 ahead because power up the jinx and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00658-00194160-00194598 nibble away I could actually switch over
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00659-00194599-00194967 to cadaver on just win if I let's just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00660-00194968-00195198 see what she does I mean I gotta
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00661-00195199-00195438 literally win any time now even on the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00662-00195439-00196098 last turn so I go just pop it on the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00663-00196099-00196326 Jigglypuff and keysaw Wigglytuff
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00664-00196327-00196602 yeah yeah and you know Ratan has got a
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00665-00196603-00196811 free or cheat cost too right
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00666-00196812-00197220 and your Pokemon trader and yeah I just
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00667-00197221-00197562 oh we got we got something going on here
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00668-00197563-00198045 we got something going on here and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00669-00198046-00198255 actually if I if I still search over
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00670-00198256-00198432 Kadabra it's still an automatic one
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00671-00198433-00198729 because a double psychic damage so yeah
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00672-00198730-00198813 all right
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00673-00198814-00199131 there's the mind shock ignores the
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00674-00199132-00199607 weakness and resistance sorry
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00675-00199608-00199848 now I have a Wigglytuff but I don't know
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00676-00199849-00200079 yet I got the super sized you'll do a
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00677-00200080-00200418 hundred art gala Kazaam yeah is I think
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00678-00200419-00200676 your deck purchases my ie my deck is
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00679-00200677-00201009 just too too well built versus Harris
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00680-00201010-00201189 because it just has a counter for
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00681-00201190-00201408 everything yep that might just be yet in
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00682-00201409-00201624 general what why
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00683-00201625-00202004 lose I'm so strong I even gave her
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00684-00202005-00202241 second chance and multiple chances in
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00685-00202242-00202845 that game it's not not happening it's
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00686-00202846-00203277 not happening not her day and for me
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00687-00203278-00203538 runs again and I'm a champ
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00688-00203539-00204299 oh no all anyway
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00689-00204300-00204600 okay look good I don't think your house
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00690-00204601-00204723 self just because you all became my
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00691-00204724-00205492 strength well I did it twice so I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00692-00205494-00205683 technically didn't have that many issues
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00693-00205684-00205991 with you normally and anyway so I I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00694-00205992-00206192 don't know I don't know what to make of
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00695-00206194-00206502 this all I know is that I'm gonna end
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00696-00206503-00206727 off the FIR here I hope you enjoyed and
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00697-00206728-00206864 I'll see you in the next start when I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00698-00206865-00207089 beat the other two members probably I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00699-00207090-00207269 mean maybe they'll be so powerful I
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00700-00207271-00207351 won't be able to
+NLuFoYIRtVI-00701-00207352-00207859 [Music]
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00000-00000026-00000313 further Eastern European time fete is a
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00001-00000314-00000524 time zone defined as three hours ahead
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00002-00000525-00000805 of UTC UTC plus three o'clock without
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00003-00000806-00001087 daylight saving time as of September
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00004-00001088-00001370 2016 it is used in Belarus Western
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00005-00001371-00001570 Russia and Turkey and is also called
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00006-00001571-00001880 Minsk time Moscow time msk or turkey
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00007-00001880-00002249 time trt the zone was established in
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00008-00002250-00002498 October 2011 as the official time for
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00009-00002499-00002690 the Kaliningrad Oblast in Russia and
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00010-00002691-00002939 then followed by Belarus it was
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00011-00002940-00003142 originally called Kaliningrad time in
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00012-00003143-00003410 Russia however on the 26th of October
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00013-00003411-00003500 2014
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00014-00003501-00003758 most of Russia moved the UTC offset back
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00015-00003759-00003950 one hour meaning that Kaliningrad time
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00016-00003951-00004222 is now UTC plus two o'clock and Moscow
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00017-00004223-00004477 time as UTC plus three o'clock
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00018-00004478-00004681 several African and Middle Eastern
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00019-00004682-00004991 countries use UTC plus three o'clock all
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00020-00004992-00005188 year long where it called East Africa
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00021-00005189-00005951 time eat and Arabia Standard Time asked
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00022-00005952-00006450 topic history
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00023-00006451-00006771 until 2011 further Eastern European time
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00024-00006772-00006981 was identical to Eastern European time
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00025-00006982-00007416 UTC +2 UTC + 3 with daylight saving time
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00026-00007417-00007795 however on the 27th of March 2011 Russia
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00027-00007795-00007977 moved to the so-called year-round
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00028-00007978-00008289 daylight saving time so that clocks
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00029-00008290-00008455 would remain on what had been the summer
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00030-00008456-00008667 time all year round making Kaliningrad
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00031-00008668-00008923 time permanently set to UTC + 3
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00032-00008924-00009114 peculiarly placing its time ahead of
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00033-00009115-00009314 countries to its east during winter
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00034-00009315-00009591 Belarus followed Russia on the 15th of
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00035-00009592-00009846 September 2011 and the same decision was
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00036-00009847-00010033 made by the Ukrainian Parliament on the
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00037-00010034-00010353 20th of September 2011 after strong
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00038-00010354-00010555 criticism from the mass media on the
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00039-00010556-00010816 18th of October 2011 the Ukrainian
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00040-00010817-00010980 Parliament cancelled its previous
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00041-00010981-00011257 decision Transnistria a breakaway
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00042-00011258-00011473 territory from Moldova on the eastern
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00043-00011474-00011632 side of the kneestr River bordering
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00044-00011633-00011838 Ukraine followed Ukraine by at first
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00045-00011839-00012055 adopting further Eastern European Time
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00046-00012056-00012258 but later canceling this decision the
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00047-00012259-00012580 name further Eastern European time seems
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00048-00012581-00012733 to have come from work on the TZ
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00049-00012734-00013271 database
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00050-00013272-00013808 topic see also
+NLNQTXNVsgu-00051-00013809-00014111 time in Ukraine
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00000-00000000-00000505 [Music]
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00001-00000505-00000743 wondering how to access books at Jenks
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00002-00000744-00000914 library if you're not on campus the
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00003-00000915-00001148 answer is ebooks Jenks library has over
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00004-00001149-00001333 a hundred and fifty thousand ebooks
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00005-00001334-00001535 available all searchable within our
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00006-00001536-00001751 noble catalog ebooks are really useful
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00007-00001752-00001960 for distance learners because you can
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00008-00001961-00002132 access them from your device wherever
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00009-00002133-00002354 you are this video will walk you through
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00010-00002355-00002582 how to find and access ebooks within the
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00011-00002583-00002774 noble catalog to begin searching for
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00012-00002775-00002968 e-books in the noble catalog go to the
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00013-00002969-00003320 library homepage at WWE to slash library
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00014-00003321-00003542 under the search library section click
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00015-00003543-00003745 on the more' catalog search options link
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00016-00003746-00003986 under the noble tab you will be directed
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00017-00003986-00004145 to the basic search screen in the online
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00018-00004146-00004420 catalog finding ebooks is almost exactly
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00019-00004421-00004627 the same process is finding print books
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00020-00004628-00004820 at Jenks you enter your search terms in
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00021-00004821-00004997 the Box provided and you click search
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00022-00004998-00005192 however there are a few filtering
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00023-00005193-00005366 options you can set on your search if
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00024-00005367-00005540 you know the only thing you want to look
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00025-00005541-00005765 for is ebooks let's say we wanted to
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00026-00005766-00005975 search by title for the book naming the
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00027-00005976-00006200 elephant by James desire I'm going to
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00028-00006201-00006379 enter my title search terms and then
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00029-00006380-00006592 change this keyword drop down to a title
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00030-00006593-00006830 search then using the all formats drop
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00031-00006831-00007070 down I'm going to select book electronic
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00032-00007070-00007316 from my list to scope my search only to
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00033-00007317-00007502 ebooks and then go ahead and click
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00034-00007503-00007673 search now notice that instead of
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00035-00007673-00007817 searching it across the entire library
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00036-00007818-00008078 we are filtering by that format
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00037-00008079-00008291 electronic book to access the e-book
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00038-00008292-00008510 click on the green title link to open
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00039-00008511-00008684 the record a link to access the e-book
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00040-00008685-00008867 is contained below the electronic
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00041-00008868-00009049 resources header there are two primary
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00042-00009050-00009274 ways to access ebooks at Jenks the first
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00043-00009275-00009488 as shown in this example is an e-book
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00044-00009489-00009713 available on EPS cohost click on the
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00045-00009714-00009884 access link below the electronic
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00046-00009885-00010130 resources header to open the e-book for
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00047-00010131-00010346 e-books available on EPS co-hosts this
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00048-00010347-00010577 will open it in eBSCO's ereader platform
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00049-00010578-00010784 you can use the left navigation to
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00050-00010785-00011003 browse and jump into specific chapters
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00051-00011004-00011231 within the book also notice the toolbar
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00052-00011232-00011471 across the page allows you to save a
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00053-00011472-00011687 certain range of pages or maybe email
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00054-00011688-00011896 pages to yourself and more let's again
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00055-00011897-00012064 return to our noble catalog and run
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00056-00012065-00012251 another search to look at the second way
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00057-00012252-00012428 in which you can access ebooks from
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00058-00012429-00012613 Jencks this time we're going to search
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00059-00012614-00012794 for the book leadership in turbulent
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00060-00012795-00012941 times by Doris Goodwin and we're going
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00061-00012941-00013091 to keep everything about our search the
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00062-00013091-00013159 same
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00063-00013160-00013333 search by title and we're going to
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00064-00013334-00013549 filter by book electronic once again
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00065-00013550-00013722 click on the green title link to access
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00066-00013724-00013918 the record and notice this time how the
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00067-00013919-00014094 link under our electronic resources
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00068-00014096-00014329 header has changed now instead of saying
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00069-00014330-00014593 access via EPS co-host this says access
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00070-00014594-00014824 title from overdrive note also that for
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00071-00014825-00015034 overdrive titles you'll see a status bar
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00072-00015035-00015196 next to it this is because you actually
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00073-00015197-00015352 need to check out the e-book on
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00074-00015353-00015556 overdrive in order to access it so
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00075-00015557-00015724 you're able to see how many copies are
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00076-00015725-00015925 currently available in this case for our
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00077-00015926-00016150 book there are three copies of six still
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00078-00016151-00016366 available for us tomorrow to access this
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00079-00016366-00016549 ebook and overdrive go ahead and click
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00080-00016550-00016723 on the access link you'll be directed to
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00081-00016724-00016933 the overdrive borrowing page to check
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00082-00016934-00017089 out the book click on the blue borrow
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00083-00017090-00017248 button you'll first be asked to sign in
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00084-00017249-00017416 with your library card from at the
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00085-00017417-00017596 select your library drop-down choose the
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00086-00017597-00017791 noble library patrons option and then
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00087-00017792-00017989 enter your library barcode number your
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00088-00017990-00018178 card number is the number on the back of
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00089-00018179-00018388 your Gordon ID card once you sign in
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00090-00018389-00018550 you'll be prompted to finish borrowing
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00091-00018551-00018718 the book you can change the number of
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00092-00018719-00018865 days that you'd like to borrow this book
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00093-00018866-00019087 for by default that's set to 14 days but
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00094-00019088-00019306 you can choose up to 21 days once you
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00095-00019307-00019456 set that go ahead and click on borrow
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00096-00019457-00019618 and you'll see your book has been
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00097-00019619-00019795 checked out a pop-up message will appear
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00098-00019796-00020008 confirming your selection you'll also
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00099-00020009-00020182 have options from this popup message
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00100-00020183-00020380 just choose how you would actually like
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00101-00020381-00020530 to start reading the book you can either
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00102-00020531-00020722 choose to download the book and import
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00103-00020723-00020956 it into your favorite device or you can
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00104-00020957-00021268 open this up in the web browser and use
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00105-00021269-00021493 OverDrive's online eReader to click see
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00106-00021494-00021718 the pages of the book and also use the
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00107-00021719-00021910 table of contents to jump into specific
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00108-00021911-00022129 chapters let's go back to that overdrive
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00109-00022130-00022321 landing page that we were just on note
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00110-00022322-00022477 that when you clicked on that overdrive
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00111-00022478-00022711 link you were directed to the noble dry
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00112-00022712-00022978 overdrive calm overdrive has lots of
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00113-00022979-00023161 other potential resources that could be
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00114-00023162-00023329 useful for you as a distance learner as
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00115-00023330-00023515 well check out the subjects tab and
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00116-00023516-00023719 browse other potential formats such as
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00117-00023720-00023986 other ebooks or even audiobooks that you
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00118-00023987-00024193 can select and download and read or
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00119-00024194-00024409 listen to as you'd like thanks for
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00120-00024410-00024568 watching and if you have any questions
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00121-00024569-00024754 about accessing ebooks or other online
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00122-00024755-00025021 resources asked
+NNxS-LI9n2g-00123-00025022-00025547 [Music]
+NphIToUV1mg-00000-00000308-00000518 hey guys happy Monday
+NphIToUV1mg-00001-00000519-00000947 it's Kyle and peeling here yes you don't
+NphIToUV1mg-00002-00000948-00001204 wanna be part of the video but happy
+NphIToUV1mg-00003-00001205-00001406 Monday I hope you guys had a great
+NphIToUV1mg-00004-00001407-00001735 weekend and today I wanna CLE want to
+NphIToUV1mg-00005-00001736-00002051 talk about social media so you guys
+NphIToUV1mg-00006-00002052-00002317 obviously see me on social media and I
+NphIToUV1mg-00007-00002318-00002542 have tried to commit myself this year to
+NphIToUV1mg-00008-00002543-00002974 being a useful resource to you guys but
+NphIToUV1mg-00009-00002975-00003274 social media also has huge pitfall and
+NphIToUV1mg-00010-00003275-00003656 one of those pitfalls I think that is at
+NphIToUV1mg-00011-00003657-00003972 the forefront of all of our lives is
+NphIToUV1mg-00012-00003973-00004306 comparison and that's where we see the
+NphIToUV1mg-00013-00004307-00004526 life or the projected life of somebody
+NphIToUV1mg-00014-00004527-00004756 else we instantly think about how their
+NphIToUV1mg-00015-00004757-00005009 life is so much better than mine why why
+NphIToUV1mg-00016-00005010-00005225 aren't I doing I might not achieve it
+NphIToUV1mg-00017-00005226-00005465 that much but I'd like to just kind of
+NphIToUV1mg-00018-00005466-00005747 refocus us and remind us all of that
+NphIToUV1mg-00019-00005748-00006017 that's a little snippet of someone's
+NphIToUV1mg-00020-00006018-00006247 life and that's what they choose to show
+NphIToUV1mg-00021-00006248-00006520 you to do most people choose to show you
+NphIToUV1mg-00022-00006522-00006859 the wins or the feelings you most people
+NphIToUV1mg-00023-00006861-00007244 choose to show you the fun or the boring
+NphIToUV1mg-00024-00007245-00007478 part of their lives when do you take the
+NphIToUV1mg-00025-00007479-00007634 most pictures just think to yourself
+NphIToUV1mg-00026-00007634-00007870 learner when you're on vacation we're at
+NphIToUV1mg-00027-00007872-00007919 a party
+NphIToUV1mg-00028-00007920-00008105 when you know you've been working for
+NphIToUV1mg-00029-00008106-00008312 the tenth hour and you're stressed out
+NphIToUV1mg-00030-00008313-00008609 at you that's why cam Harrison
+NphIToUV1mg-00031-00008610-00008924 especially as it relates to social media
+NphIToUV1mg-00032-00008925-00009209 is a huge downfall and you need to stay
+NphIToUV1mg-00033-00009210-00009410 in your own lane don't worry about
+NphIToUV1mg-00034-00009411-00009626 comparing yourself to anybody but
+NphIToUV1mg-00035-00009627-00009706 yourself
+NphIToUV1mg-00036-00009707-00009998 from yesterday so just wanted to leave
+NphIToUV1mg-00037-00009999-00010156 you guys with that know if you have a
+NphIToUV1mg-00038-00010157-00010360 great rest of your week let's get after
+NphIToUV1mg-00039-00010361-00010505 it I will see you all
+NphIToUV1mg-00040-00010506-00011220 [Music]
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00000-00000000-00000202 did some research unique and there's
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00001-00000204-00000350 still a connection to me sit down
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00002-00000351-00000536 there's still over there's still over
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00003-00000537-00000740 457 people that are watching this that
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00004-00000741-00000919 are not subscribed can you please tell
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00005-00000921-00001289 them again it's your turn thank you I
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00006-00001290-00001718 know it's ridiculous isn't a last time
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00007-00001719-00001838 you did that for me though like so many
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00008-00001839-00002518 people subscribed I say thank you guys
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00009-00002519-00003122 if you don't want to subscribe morning
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00010-00003123-00003251 everyone welcome back to another video
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00011-00003252-00003445 so I got a ton of comments on my last
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00012-00003446-00003754 video basically saying I want to explain
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00013-00003755-00003890 this really quick so my house is
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00014-00003890-00004147 basically in escrow right now Liars have
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00015-00004148-00004354 about 30 days until they actually move
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00016-00004355-00004538 into my house which is why we have a
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00017-00004539-00004658 couple of weeks to go house shopping
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00018-00004659-00004888 before I actually have to decide so I
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00019-00004889-00005143 will be gone but just stop not yet I'm
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00020-00005144-00005417 not moving yet guys social distancing
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00021-00005418-00005647 better we just looked at a couple of
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00022-00005648-00005888 houses everybody loved number five
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00023-00005889-00005975 number five
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00024-00005976-00006158 definitely was the best of the game
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00025-00006159-00006365 today we're going against because I
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00026-00006366-00006581 still didn't find a house that I was
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00027-00006581-00006719 entirely happy with we're gonna go look
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00028-00006720-00006845 at some more houses that I'm gonna need
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00029-00006845-00007073 your guys's help I need your opinion if
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00030-00007073-00007301 you see any houses that are better than
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00031-00007302-00007481 number five from the last video comment
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00032-00007481-00007621 down below I love going to shop for
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00033-00007622-00007784 houses and that's actually a house that
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00034-00007784-00008105 I'm potentially going to move to tell
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00035-00008106-00009022 them again
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00036-00009023-00010445 [Music]
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00037-00010446-00011255 [Music]
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00038-00011256-00011594 [Music]
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00039-00011595-00012439 No yeah I think so what it is it's very
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00040-00012440-00013484 [Music]
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00041-00013485-00014277 sorry also this time we brought along
+NpXoiN6HD9o-00042-00014278-00016178 [Music]
+NO2RsINMWS4-00000-00000206-00000466 let's just walk through this experiences
+NO2RsINMWS4-00001-00000467-00000804 that matter for a few minutes this is
+NO2RsINMWS4-00002-00000805-00000912 how we're going to communicate it out
+NO2RsINMWS4-00003-00000913-00001168 and engage our 23,000 employees first in
+NO2RsINMWS4-00004-00001169-00001449 our 22 million guests second experiences
+NO2RsINMWS4-00005-00001450-00001864 that matter is our mission and this is
+NO2RsINMWS4-00006-00001864-00002167 new for us now we've been doing a lot of
+NO2RsINMWS4-00007-00002168-00002427 this quietly ourselves but we're making
+NO2RsINMWS4-00008-00002428-00002722 it part of our brand going forward we're
+NO2RsINMWS4-00009-00002723-00002971 going to do that through and encouraging
+NO2RsINMWS4-00010-00002972-00003157 all of our employees to focus on three
+NO2RsINMWS4-00011-00003158-00003346 words as we're working through
+NO2RsINMWS4-00012-00003347-00003700 everything we do to explore inspire and
+NO2RsINMWS4-00013-00003701-00003925 act and I'm just going to walk through
+NO2RsINMWS4-00014-00003926-00004401 each of those for a minute exploring
+NO2RsINMWS4-00015-00004402-00004834 which is discovering the wonders the
+NO2RsINMWS4-00016-00004835-00005194 wild of nature in all of our attractions
+NO2RsINMWS4-00017-00005195-00005397 in our parks you know I don't have to
+NO2RsINMWS4-00018-00005398-00005679 tell you that there's not much wild left
+NO2RsINMWS4-00019-00005680-00006052 in the world at least terrestrially if
+NO2RsINMWS4-00020-00006053-00006256 you want to see some of the large
+NO2RsINMWS4-00021-00006257-00006423 mammals that are left on earth you have
+NO2RsINMWS4-00022-00006425-00006628 to either go to Africa to a safari or
+NO2RsINMWS4-00023-00006629-00007059 you have to go to a zoo and see them or
+NO2RsINMWS4-00024-00007061-00007556 come to see rodebush Gardens both parks
+NO2RsINMWS4-00025-00007558-00007785 without zoos and aquariums you have no
+NO2RsINMWS4-00026-00007786-00007984 exposure to these animals and you don't
+NO2RsINMWS4-00027-00007984-00008317 have a chance for this connection on the
+NO2RsINMWS4-00028-00008318-00008539 sea roll side there's still one place
+NO2RsINMWS4-00029-00008540-00009078 that is undiscovered there's really one
+NO2RsINMWS4-00030-00009079-00009346 part of our world that the veil of the
+NO2RsINMWS4-00031-00009347-00009751 known does not exist and is the ocean we
+NO2RsINMWS4-00032-00009752-00010006 know more about space than we know about
+NO2RsINMWS4-00033-00010007-00010399 the ocean and we think as a company and
+NO2RsINMWS4-00034-00010400-00010656 so of all the resources Jeff Bezos and
+NO2RsINMWS4-00035-00010657-00010821 some of the others who want to point
+NO2RsINMWS4-00036-00010822-00011031 rockets out into the space we think a
+NO2RsINMWS4-00037-00011032-00011209 lot of that energy should go to the
+NO2RsINMWS4-00038-00011210-00011538 oceans the last frontier that of
+NO2RsINMWS4-00039-00011539-00011803 unexplored areas so that is what we
+NO2RsINMWS4-00040-00011804-00012045 think we can do for land and sea with
+NO2RsINMWS4-00041-00012046-00012298 the word explore and that in Anthony is
+NO2RsINMWS4-00042-00012299-00012412 going to talk a little bit about that in
+NO2RsINMWS4-00043-00012413-00012744 a minute so if we do a good job creating
+NO2RsINMWS4-00044-00012745-00013015 experiences of exploration a sense of
+NO2RsINMWS4-00045-00013016-00013219 exploration for our guests we think we
+NO2RsINMWS4-00046-00013219-00013352 can inspire them
+NO2RsINMWS4-00047-00013353-00013658 every one of us if you watch any child
+NO2RsINMWS4-00048-00013659-00013975 in our park it is clear that we can
+NO2RsINMWS4-00049-00013976-00014363 touch their heart and then we can teach
+NO2RsINMWS4-00050-00014363-00014576 their mind and that's a motto of ours
+NO2RsINMWS4-00051-00014577-00014855 connect to the heart to teach the mind
+NO2RsINMWS4-00052-00014856-00015085 and that's where fun and meaningful
+NO2RsINMWS4-00053-00015086-00015497 comes from experiences that matter if we
+NO2RsINMWS4-00054-00015497-00015833 can inspire our guests then we can get
+NO2RsINMWS4-00055-00015834-00016166 them to act and I would say as an
+NO2RsINMWS4-00056-00016166-00016334 organization this is where we have not
+NO2RsINMWS4-00057-00016335-00016685 done enough we can engage 22 million
+NO2RsINMWS4-00058-00016686-00016919 guests in our cause
+NO2RsINMWS4-00059-00016920-00017171 just think of each of them just gave 50
+NO2RsINMWS4-00060-00017172-00017336 cents it's ten million dollars it's
+NO2RsINMWS4-00061-00017337-00017549 there's a lot that can happen and we're
+NO2RsINMWS4-00062-00017550-00017840 just beginning there
+NPJNG2rubrc-00000-00000080-00000398 Zealandia also known as the new zealand
+NPJNG2rubrc-00001-00000399-00000682 continent or Tasman tiss is an almost
+NPJNG2rubrc-00002-00000683-00000952 entirely submerged mass of continental
+NPJNG2rubrc-00003-00000953-00001237 crust that sank after breaking away from
+NPJNG2rubrc-00004-00001238-00001607 Australia 60 to 85 million years ago
+NPJNG2rubrc-00005-00001607-00001934 having separated from Antarctica between
+NPJNG2rubrc-00006-00001935-00002465 85 and 130 million years ago it has
+NPJNG2rubrc-00007-00002466-00002668 variously been described as a
+NPJNG2rubrc-00008-00002669-00003010 continental fragment a micro continent a
+NPJNG2rubrc-00009-00003011-00003419 submerged continent and a continent the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00010-00003420-00003677 name and concept for Zealandia was
+NPJNG2rubrc-00011-00003678-00004153 proposed by Bruce lujah dick in 1995
+NPJNG2rubrc-00012-00004154-00004475 Zealandia status as a continent is not
+NPJNG2rubrc-00013-00004476-00004766 universally accepted but New Zealand
+NPJNG2rubrc-00014-00004767-00005045 geologist Nick Mortimer has commented
+NPJNG2rubrc-00015-00005046-00005431 that if it wasn't for the ocean it would
+NPJNG2rubrc-00016-00005432-00005693 have been recognized as such long ago
+NPJNG2rubrc-00017-00005694-00005972 the landmass may have been completely
+NPJNG2rubrc-00018-00005973-00006284 submerged about 23 million years ago
+NPJNG2rubrc-00019-00006285-00006653 and most of it 93% remained submerged
+NPJNG2rubrc-00020-00006654-00007067 beneath the Pacific Ocean with a total
+NPJNG2rubrc-00021-00007068-00007334 area of approximately four million nine
+NPJNG2rubrc-00022-00007334-00007562 hundred and twenty thousand square
+NPJNG2rubrc-00023-00007563-00007789 kilometres one million nine hundred
+NPJNG2rubrc-00024-00007790-00008126 thousand square miles it is the world's
+NPJNG2rubrc-00025-00008127-00008402 largest current micro-continent more
+NPJNG2rubrc-00026-00008403-00008651 than twice the size of the next largest
+NPJNG2rubrc-00027-00008652-00008942 micro continent and more than half the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00028-00008943-00009338 size of the Australian continent as such
+NPJNG2rubrc-00029-00009339-00009571 and due to other geological
+NPJNG2rubrc-00030-00009572-00009863 considerations such as crustal thickness
+NPJNG2rubrc-00031-00009864-00010169 and density it is arguably a continent
+NPJNG2rubrc-00032-00010170-00010489 in its own right this was the argument
+NPJNG2rubrc-00033-00010490-00010939 which made news in 2017 when geologists
+NPJNG2rubrc-00034-00010940-00011195 from New Zealand New Caledonia and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00035-00011196-00011467 Australia concluded that Zealandia
+NPJNG2rubrc-00036-00011468-00011708 fulfills all the requirements to be
+NPJNG2rubrc-00037-00011709-00011945 considered a continent rather than a
+NPJNG2rubrc-00038-00011946-00012248 micro continent or continental fragment
+NPJNG2rubrc-00039-00012249-00012553 Zealandia supports substantial inshore
+NPJNG2rubrc-00040-00012554-00012841 fisheries and contains gas fields of
+NPJNG2rubrc-00041-00012842-00013124 which the largest known is New Zealand's
+NPJNG2rubrc-00042-00013125-00013363 Maui gas field near Tarin
+NPJNG2rubrc-00043-00013365-00013741 oki permits for oil exploration in the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00044-00013743-00014185 great south basin were issued in 2007
+NPJNG2rubrc-00045-00014186-00014488 offshore mineral resources include iron
+NPJNG2rubrc-00046-00014490-00014822 sands volcanic massive sulfides and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00047-00014822-00015628 ferromanganese nodule deposits
+NPJNG2rubrc-00048-00015629-00016211 topic geology
+NPJNG2rubrc-00049-00016212-00016505 Zealandia is largely made up of two
+NPJNG2rubrc-00050-00016506-00016803 nearly parallel ridges separated by a
+NPJNG2rubrc-00051-00016804-00017076 failed rift where the rift breakup of
+NPJNG2rubrc-00052-00017077-00017340 the continent stops and becomes a filled
+NPJNG2rubrc-00053-00017341-00017669 graben the ridges rise above the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00054-00017670-00018083 seafloor to heights of 1000 to 1500
+NPJNG2rubrc-00055-00018084-00018750 meters 3,300 to 4900 feet with few rocky
+NPJNG2rubrc-00056-00018751-00019119 islands rising above sea level the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00057-00019120-00019368 ridges are continental rock but are
+NPJNG2rubrc-00058-00019369-00019560 lower in elevation than normal
+NPJNG2rubrc-00059-00019561-00019803 continents because the crust is thinner
+NPJNG2rubrc-00060-00019804-00020124 than usual approximately 20 kilometers
+NPJNG2rubrc-00061-00020125-00020454 12 miles thick and consequently they do
+NPJNG2rubrc-00062-00020455-00020669 not float as high above the Earth's
+NPJNG2rubrc-00063-00020670-00021183 mantle about 25 million years ago the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00064-00021184-00021419 southern part of Zealandia on the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00065-00021420-00021711 Pacific plate began to shift relative to
+NPJNG2rubrc-00066-00021712-00021960 the northern part on the indo-australian
+NPJNG2rubrc-00067-00021961-00022338 plate the resulting displacement by
+NPJNG2rubrc-00068-00022339-00022794 approximately 500 kilometers 310 miles
+NPJNG2rubrc-00069-00022795-00023106 along the Alpine Fault is evident in
+NPJNG2rubrc-00070-00023107-00023484 geological maps movement along this
+NPJNG2rubrc-00071-00023485-00023763 plate boundary has also offset the New
+NPJNG2rubrc-00072-00023764-00024031 Caledonia Basin from its previous
+NPJNG2rubrc-00073-00024032-00024419 continuation through the bounty trough
+NPJNG2rubrc-00074-00024420-00024666 compression across the boundary has
+NPJNG2rubrc-00075-00024667-00024944 uplifted the Southern Alps although due
+NPJNG2rubrc-00076-00024945-00025206 to rapid erosion their height reflects
+NPJNG2rubrc-00077-00025207-00025525 only a small fraction of the uplift
+NPJNG2rubrc-00078-00025526-00025683 farther north
+NPJNG2rubrc-00079-00025683-00025970 subduction of the Pacific plate has led
+NPJNG2rubrc-00080-00025972-00026246 to extensive volcanism including the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00081-00026247-00026675 Coromandel in Taupo volcanic zone x'
+NPJNG2rubrc-00082-00026676-00026955 associated rifting and subsidence has
+NPJNG2rubrc-00083-00026956-00027233 produced the hierarchy graben and more
+NPJNG2rubrc-00084-00027235-00027495 recently the fuk atonic Robin and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00085-00027495-00027951 Whanganui Basin volcanism on Zealandia
+NPJNG2rubrc-00086-00027952-00028227 has also taken place repeatedly in
+NPJNG2rubrc-00087-00028227-00028458 various parts of the continental
+NPJNG2rubrc-00088-00028458-00028719 fragment before during and after it
+NPJNG2rubrc-00089-00028720-00028920 rifted away from the supercontinent
+NPJNG2rubrc-00090-00028920-00029077 Gondwana
+NPJNG2rubrc-00091-00029078-00029339 although Zealandia has shifted
+NPJNG2rubrc-00092-00029339-00029566 approximately 6,000
+NPJNG2rubrc-00093-00029567-00030052 meters 3,700 miles to the northwest with
+NPJNG2rubrc-00094-00030052-00030286 respect to the underlying mantle from
+NPJNG2rubrc-00095-00030287-00030552 the time when it rifted from Antarctica
+NPJNG2rubrc-00096-00030554-00030814 recurring intra continental volcanism
+NPJNG2rubrc-00097-00030814-00031111 exhibits magma compositions similar to
+NPJNG2rubrc-00098-00031112-00031420 that of volcanoes in previously adjacent
+NPJNG2rubrc-00099-00031420-00031833 parts of Antarctica in Australia this
+NPJNG2rubrc-00100-00031835-00032152 volcanism is widespread across Zealandia
+NPJNG2rubrc-00101-00032152-00032422 but generally of low volume apart from
+NPJNG2rubrc-00102-00032423-00032676 the huge mid to late myosin shield
+NPJNG2rubrc-00103-00032677-00032944 volcanoes that develop the banks and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00104-00032945-00033361 otago penninsula z' in addition it took
+NPJNG2rubrc-00105-00033362-00033625 place continually in numerous limited
+NPJNG2rubrc-00106-00033626-00033795 regions all through the Late Cretaceous
+NPJNG2rubrc-00107-00033796-00034270 in the Cenozoic however its cause is a
+NPJNG2rubrc-00108-00034271-00034600 still in dispute during the Maya scene
+NPJNG2rubrc-00109-00034601-00034888 the northern section of Zealandia Lord
+NPJNG2rubrc-00110-00034889-00035134 Howe rise might have slid over a
+NPJNG2rubrc-00111-00035135-00035443 stationary hotspot forming the Lord Howe
+NPJNG2rubrc-00112-00035444-00035899 seamount chain Zealandia is occasionally
+NPJNG2rubrc-00113-00035900-00036178 divided by scientists into two regions
+NPJNG2rubrc-00114-00036179-00036538 north Zealandia or western province and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00115-00036539-00036874 south Zealandia or eastern province the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00116-00036875-00037102 latter of which contains most of the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00117-00037103-00037441 median batholith crust these two
+NPJNG2rubrc-00118-00037442-00037705 features are separated by the Alpine
+NPJNG2rubrc-00119-00037706-00037939 Fault and comedic trench and by the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00120-00037940-00038206 wedge-shaped he Kerrang II Plateau and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00121-00038207-00038952 are moving separately to each other
+NPJNG2rubrc-00122-00038953-00039645 topic classification is a continent
+NPJNG2rubrc-00123-00039646-00039954 the case for Zealandia being a continent
+NPJNG2rubrc-00124-00039955-00040191 in its own right was argued by Nik
+NPJNG2rubrc-00125-00040192-00040443 Mortimer and Hamish Campbell in the book
+NPJNG2rubrc-00126-00040444-00040848 Zealandia our continent revealed in 2014
+NPJNG2rubrc-00127-00040849-00041121 citing geological and ecological
+NPJNG2rubrc-00128-00041122-00041505 evidence to support the proposal in 2017
+NPJNG2rubrc-00129-00041506-00041841 a team of 11 geologists from New Zealand
+NPJNG2rubrc-00130-00041842-00042168 New Caledonia and Australia concluded
+NPJNG2rubrc-00131-00042169-00042366 that Zealandia fulfills all the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00132-00042367-00042610 requirements to be considered a drowned
+NPJNG2rubrc-00133-00042611-00042906 continent rather than a micro continent
+NPJNG2rubrc-00134-00042907-00043279 or continental fragment this was widely
+NPJNG2rubrc-00135-00043280-00043971 covered by news media
+NPJNG2rubrc-00136-00043972-00044583 topic biogeography
+NPJNG2rubrc-00137-00044584-00044886 New Caledonia lies at the northern end
+NPJNG2rubrc-00138-00044887-00045126 of the ancient continent while New
+NPJNG2rubrc-00139-00045127-00045381 Zealand rises at the plate boundary that
+NPJNG2rubrc-00140-00045382-00045756 bisects it these land masses are two
+NPJNG2rubrc-00141-00045757-00045987 outposts of the Antarctic flora
+NPJNG2rubrc-00142-00045988-00046393 including our carriers and Podocarpus a
+NPJNG2rubrc-00143-00046394-00046767 curio bay logs of a fossilized forest
+NPJNG2rubrc-00144-00046768-00047034 closely related to modern carry in
+NPJNG2rubrc-00145-00047035-00047289 Norfolk pine can be seen that grew on
+NPJNG2rubrc-00146-00047290-00047658 Zealandia about 180 million years ago
+NPJNG2rubrc-00147-00047659-00047921 during the Jurassic period before it
+NPJNG2rubrc-00148-00047922-00048294 split from Gondwana these were buried by
+NPJNG2rubrc-00149-00048295-00048606 volcanic mudflows and gradually replaced
+NPJNG2rubrc-00150-00048607-00048879 by silica to produce the fossils now
+NPJNG2rubrc-00151-00048880-00049269 exposed by the sea during glacial
+NPJNG2rubrc-00152-00049270-00049593 periods more of Zealandia becomes a
+NPJNG2rubrc-00153-00049594-00049787 terrestrial rather than a marine
+NPJNG2rubrc-00154-00049788-00050162 environment Zealandia was originally
+NPJNG2rubrc-00155-00050163-00050409 thought to have no native land mammal
+NPJNG2rubrc-00156-00050410-00050781 fauna but the discovery in 2006 of a
+NPJNG2rubrc-00157-00050782-00051018 fossil mammal door from the Maya scene
+NPJNG2rubrc-00158-00051019-00051858 in the Otago region shows otherwise
+NPJNG2rubrc-00159-00051859-00052509 topic political divisions
+NPJNG2rubrc-00160-00052510-00052826 the total land area including inland
+NPJNG2rubrc-00161-00052827-00053132 water bodies of Zealandia is two hundred
+NPJNG2rubrc-00162-00053133-00053415 and eighty six thousand six hundred and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00163-00053416-00053787 fifty five square kilometers 110
+NPJNG2rubrc-00164-00053788-00054024 thousand six hundred and seventy eight
+NPJNG2rubrc-00165-00054025-00054431 square miles of this new zealand
+NPJNG2rubrc-00166-00054432-00054735 comprises the majority at two hundred
+NPJNG2rubrc-00167-00054736-00054978 and sixty seven thousand nine hundred
+NPJNG2rubrc-00168-00054979-00055272 and eighty eight square kilometers one
+NPJNG2rubrc-00169-00055273-00055503 hundred and three thousand four hundred
+NPJNG2rubrc-00170-00055504-00055937 and seventy-one square miles or 93%
+NPJNG2rubrc-00171-00055938-00056196 which includes the mainland nearby
+NPJNG2rubrc-00172-00056197-00056456 islands and most outlying islands
+NPJNG2rubrc-00173-00056457-00056762 including the antipodes islands Auckland
+NPJNG2rubrc-00174-00056763-00056837 Islands
+NPJNG2rubrc-00175-00056838-00057113 bounty Islands Campbell Islands and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00176-00057114-00057362 Chatham Islands but not the comedic
+NPJNG2rubrc-00177-00057363-00057660 islands or Macquarie Island Australia
+NPJNG2rubrc-00178-00057661-00058104 which a part of the rift New Caledonia
+NPJNG2rubrc-00179-00058104-00058335 in the islands surrounding it comprise
+NPJNG2rubrc-00180-00058336-00058590 some eighteen thousand five hundred and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00181-00058591-00058904 seventy-six square kilometres seven
+NPJNG2rubrc-00182-00058905-00059121 thousand one hundred and seventy two
+NPJNG2rubrc-00183-00059122-00059441 square miles or seven percent and the
+NPJNG2rubrc-00184-00059442-00059649 remainder is made up of various
+NPJNG2rubrc-00185-00059650-00059937 territories of Australia including Lord
+NPJNG2rubrc-00186-00059938-00060356 Howe Island Group New South Wales at 56
+NPJNG2rubrc-00187-00060357-00060797 square kilometres 22 square miles or
+NPJNG2rubrc-00188-00060798-00061241 0.2% Norfolk Island at 35 square
+NPJNG2rubrc-00189-00061242-00061779 kilometres 14 square miles or 0.01% as
+NPJNG2rubrc-00190-00061779-00062022 well as Elizabeth and Middleton reefs
+NPJNG2rubrc-00191-00062023-00062466 Coral Sea Islands territory with 0.25
+NPJNG2rubrc-00192-00062466-00063504 square kilometres 0.097 square miles
+NPJNG2rubrc-00193-00063505-00064076 topic population
+NPJNG2rubrc-00194-00064077-00064417 the total human population of Zealandia
+NPJNG2rubrc-00195-00064419-00064922 today is about 5 million people new
+NPJNG2rubrc-00196-00064923-00065155 zealand 4 million eight hundred and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00197-00065157-00065408 twenty three thousand one hundred and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00198-00065409-00065621 ninety three
+NPJNG2rubrc-00199-00065622-00065942 New Caledonia two hundred and sixty
+NPJNG2rubrc-00200-00065943-00066125 eight thousand seven hundred and
+NPJNG2rubrc-00201-00066126-00066619 sixty-seven Norfolk Island
+NPJNG2rubrc-00202-00066620-00067336 2210 Lord Howe Island Group 382
+NPJNG2rubrc-00203-00067337-00067835 Elizabeth reef and Middleton reef zero
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00000-00000049-00000369 today in China there are more than 8,000
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00001-00000370-00000587 academic journals of which more than
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00002-00000588-00001054 4,600 can be considered scientific about
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00003-00001055-00001353 1,400 cover health science medicine and
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00004-00001354-00001930 public health
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00005-00001930-00002443 topic journals
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00006-00002444-00002716 most scientific journals in China are
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00007-00002717-00002946 supported by central regional or local
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00008-00002947-00003297 governments some scientific journals are
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00009-00003298-00003577 owned by professional associations there
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00010-00003578-00003822 are very few privately owned scientific
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00011-00003823-00004117 journals some journals mainly those
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00012-00004118-00004342 supported by the national government are
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00013-00004343-00004582 regarded as high prestige journals and
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00014-00004583-00004774 authors preferentially select these
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00015-00004775-00005083 journals for their best papers lists of
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00016-00005084-00005371 those top journals can be found at HTTP
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00017-00005372-00005910 colon slash slash wwp periodicals net CN
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00018-00005911-00006468 HTTP colon slash slash wwt dot-com and
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00019-00006469-00007023 HTTP colon slash slash WWC and k net
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00020-00007025-00007371 slash such top-tier journals include the
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00021-00007372-00007633 67 journals published by the Chinese
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00022-00007634-00007963 Medical Association those journals and
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00023-00007964-00008202 most other academic journals are indexed
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00024-00008203-00008581 by major indexing services in China most
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00025-00008582-00008788 scientific journals in China are
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00026-00008789-00009037 published monthly bimonthly or quarterly
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00027-00009038-00009415 a few are published twice a month the
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00028-00009416-00009721 average time to publication as 14.1
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00029-00009722-00009988 months most journals are available only
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00030-00009989-00010269 in print form or only in electronic form
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00031-00010270-00010573 most scientific journals in China are
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00032-00010574-00010819 published in Chinese a few have English
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00033-00010820-00011046 translations of abstracts for research
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00034-00011047-00011458 articles some 189 scientific journals
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00035-00011459-00011727 are published in English of which 29 are
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00036-00011728-00011929 health science journals most articles
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00037-00011930-00012177 published in english-language scientific
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00038-00012178-00012421 journals in China are indexed by science
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00039-00012422-00012652 Citation Index and engineering index
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00040-00012653-00012901 most scientific journals in China are
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00041-00012902-00013111 not published in English which has meant
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00042-00013112-00013246 that much of current scientific
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00043-00013247-00013477 development in China is not readily
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00044-00013478-00013687 available to non Chinese speaking
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00045-00013688-00013975 scientists a large portion of these
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00046-00013976-00014203 journals however also have an abstract
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00047-00014204-00014769 in English in 1999 only 661 Chinese
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00048-00014770-00014932 journals were indexed in the
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00049-00014933-00015262 international index systems science
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00050-00015263-00015618 Citation Index 13 engineering
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00051-00015619-00016002 index 96 index of Science and Technology
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00052-00016003-00016646 programs 110 science abstracts 117
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00053-00016647-00016950 Center for bio photonics Science and
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00054-00016951-00017520 Technology 132 abstract journal 193 as
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00055-00017521-00017673 of June 2001
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00056-00017674-00018033 62 Chinese journals 44 in English were
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00057-00018034-00018234 indexed in the science Citation Index
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00058-00018235-00018522 expanded the evaluation criteria for
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00059-00018523-00018753 Chinese scientific journals our impact
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00060-00018754-00019020 factor cited number of journal reaction
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00061-00019021-00019260 index means sighting rate and non self
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00062-00019261-00019521 cited rate the impact factor of Chinese
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00063-00019522-00019859 scientific journals is relatively low in
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00064-00019860-00020226 1999 the top cited journal mining and
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00065-00020227-00020508 geological Sinica had an impact factor
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00066-00020509-00020823 of 1.4 87 and the average number of
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00067-00020824-00021054 citations per article published in the
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00068-00021055-00021258 chinese journals covered by science
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00069-00021259-00021573 Citation Index was 0.326
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00070-00021574-00021882 one reason for the low impact factor is
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00071-00021883-00022086 that Chinese scientists tend to use
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00072-00022087-00022284 relatively few references in their
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00073-00022285-00022530 publications average six point six
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00074-00022531-00022824 references per article a second reason
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00075-00022825-00023076 is that scientists in China like those
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00076-00023077-00023286 in other countries prefer to publish
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00077-00023287-00023481 their best papers in major or top
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00078-00023482-00023802 english-language journals in fact for
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00079-00023803-00024018 such purposes as promotion to senior
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00080-00024019-00024261 positions Chinese scientists must have
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00081-00024262-00024561 published in Western journals according
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00082-00024562-00024729 to the Institute of Science and
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00083-00024730-00024927 Technology of China the number of
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00084-00024928-00025164 articles written by Chinese scientists
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00085-00025165-00025374 and published in non Chinese journals
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00086-00025375-00025864 increased from 13,000 134 in 1995 to
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00087-00025866-00026977 24,000 476 in 1999 a 95 percent increase
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00088-00026977-00027369 topic initiatives
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00089-00027370-00027524 you
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00090-00027525-00027797 Chinese colleges and universities have
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00091-00027798-00028027 few scientific writing courses so
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00092-00028029-00028238 improvement in scientific writing is
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00093-00028239-00028564 slow most first-time authors writing in
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00094-00028566-00028838 Chinese for publication in China usually
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00095-00028839-00029063 follow the format used in the journal to
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00096-00029064-00029183 which they are submitting their
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00097-00029183-00029519 manuscripts to improve scientific
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00098-00029520-00029738 publishing in China the government has
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00099-00029739-00029911 instituted initiatives to improve
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00100-00029912-00030197 scientific writing a format for
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00101-00030198-00030470 scientific and technical reports degree
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00102-00030470-00030722 theses and scientific papers has been
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00103-00030723-00031195 developed gb 7 7 1 3 - 87 the
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00104-00031197-00031376 recommendations closely follow
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00105-00031377-00031625 international standards including using
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00106-00031626-00031814 the structured abstract for biomedical
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00107-00031814-00032111 research articles by supporting
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00108-00032112-00032294 standards set by the government and
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00109-00032295-00032498 international bodies it is hoped that
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00110-00032499-00032683 health science journals improve their
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00111-00032685-00033014 scientific communication a few books
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00112-00033015-00033236 about biomedical writing have now been
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00113-00033237-00033584 published in China also a program based
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00114-00033585-00033857 in China to teach biomedical writing and
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00115-00033858-00034073 editing has been established with grants
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00116-00034074-00034277 from the China Medical Board of New York
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00117-00034278-00034586 the purpose of this program which began
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00118-00034587-00034907 in 1996 is to increase publication of
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00119-00034908-00035120 Chinese and other Asian research in
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00120-00035121-00035324 english-language biomedical journals
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00121-00035325-00035513 both by providing instruction in
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00122-00035514-00035696 biomedical writing and by developing
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00123-00035697-00036019 editors at the researchers institutions
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00124-00036020-00036242 typically the writing courses have
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00125-00036243-00036404 focused on the introduction and
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00126-00036405-00036632 discussion sections of articles prepared
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00127-00036633-00036929 for health science journals in China the
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00128-00036930-00037139 introduction section of the paper has
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00129-00037140-00037286 tended to be incomplete
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00130-00037287-00037520 so editors and readers do not understand
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00131-00037521-00037823 the point of the paper editors envisage
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00132-00037824-00038027 the introduction as being rather like a
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00133-00038028-00038201 funnel beginning with what is known
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00134-00038202-00038432 about the particular problem leading to
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00135-00038433-00038627 what is unknown and important to find
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00136-00038628-00038815 out and ending with the objectives of
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00137-00038816-00039121 the research Chinese authors typically
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00138-00039122-00039287 begin the discussion with a reiteration
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00139-00039288-00039496 of well-known knowledge with little
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00140-00039497-00039662 attempt to indicate how their research
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00141-00039663-00039938 adds to the body of knowledge the
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00142-00039939-00040169 discussion section rarely discusses the
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00143-00040170-00040433 limitations of the research
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00144-00040434-00040700 typical Chinese manuscripts contain few
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00145-00040701-00040913 references although that may be a
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00146-00040914-00041108 long-standing tradition in Chinese
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00147-00041109-00041309 publishing it also may occur because
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00148-00041310-00041573 many University and local libraries in
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00149-00041574-00041777 China lack extensive collections of
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00150-00041778-00042032 world literature most articles posted on
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00151-00042033-00042272 the worldwide web are not in free access
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00152-00042273-00042458 scientific journals and there is
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00153-00042459-00042689 generally low awareness of international
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00154-00042690-00042917 websites that provide free access to
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00155-00042918-00043124 journals such as Health internet work
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00156-00043125-00043372 access to research initiative hinari
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00157-00043373-00043862 HTTP colon slash slash wwl internet work
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00158-00043863-00044267 org slash superb PHP closing parentheses
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00159-00044268-00044512 in the directory of open access journals
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00160-00044513-00045565 HTTP colon slash slash WWD oaj org
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00161-00045566-00045955 topic see also
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00162-00045956-00046114 you
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00163-00046115-00046426 Chinese science citation database
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00164-00046427-00046858 Chinese Social Sciences Citation Index
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00165-00046859-00047241 nature China publishing in China
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00166-00047242-00047604 academic databases and search engines
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00167-00047605-00047973 Citation Index science Citation Index
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00168-00047974-00048355 impact factor list of scientific
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00169-00048356-00048846 journals ScienceDirect PubMed Central
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00170-00048847-00049480 MEDLINE hinari China Medical Board te e
+NR3kWoW2Uyu-00171-00049481-00050047 al scientific research publishing
+NV726P2PmQu-00000-00000041-00000383 [Music]
+NV726P2PmQu-00001-00000384-00000519 the scope of the lab
+NV726P2PmQu-00002-00000520-00000831 is really to think again how light
+NV726P2PmQu-00003-00000832-00001158 interacts with solids and how we can
+NV726P2PmQu-00004-00001159-00001582 convert solar energies into electricity
+NV726P2PmQu-00005-00001583-00001855 or how we can store solar energies into
+NV726P2PmQu-00006-00001855-00002014 chemical bonds
+NV726P2PmQu-00007-00002016-00002207 so it's really how you can collect
+NV726P2PmQu-00008-00002208-00002318 effectively
+NV726P2PmQu-00009-00002319-00002623 solar photons using thin film materials
+NV726P2PmQu-00010-00002624-00002655 with
+NV726P2PmQu-00011-00002656-00002839 specific optical and electrical
+NV726P2PmQu-00012-00002840-00003063 properties and how these photons can be
+NV726P2PmQu-00013-00003064-00003175 effectively
+NV726P2PmQu-00014-00003176-00003463 converted into electrical charges thin
+NV726P2PmQu-00015-00003464-00003575 film technologies
+NV726P2PmQu-00016-00003576-00003903 are really ways to deposit
+NV726P2PmQu-00017-00003904-00004206 an alloy with specific elements onto a
+NV726P2PmQu-00018-00004207-00004399 substrate and the main way
+NV726P2PmQu-00019-00004400-00004599 to create these thin films is really
+NV726P2PmQu-00020-00004600-00004735 with vacuum chambers
+NV726P2PmQu-00021-00004736-00004983 again where you have the physical piece
+NV726P2PmQu-00022-00004984-00005038 of metal
+NV726P2PmQu-00023-00005039-00005254 either you can evaporate that metal or
+NV726P2PmQu-00024-00005255-00005486 you can bombard this metal with ions
+NV726P2PmQu-00025-00005487-00005822 to create a vapor of a specific
+NV726P2PmQu-00026-00005823-00006063 element and again this plume is going to
+NV726P2PmQu-00027-00006064-00006143 just
+NV726P2PmQu-00028-00006144-00006351 travel into the vacuum chamber and
+NV726P2PmQu-00029-00006352-00006495 eventually condense
+NV726P2PmQu-00030-00006495-00006687 onto the substrate to form your thin
+NV726P2PmQu-00031-00006688-00006934 film in terms of efficiency i would say
+NV726P2PmQu-00032-00006936-00007006 thin films
+NV726P2PmQu-00033-00007008-00007255 and standard crystalline silicon are
+NV726P2PmQu-00034-00007256-00007414 pretty much at the same level at about
+NV726P2PmQu-00035-00007415-00007623 23 to 25
+NV726P2PmQu-00036-00007623-00007831 solar to electricity conversion the
+NV726P2PmQu-00037-00007831-00008014 reasoning behind using thin films is
+NV726P2PmQu-00038-00008015-00008159 really to try to reduce either the
+NV726P2PmQu-00039-00008159-00008231 weight
+NV726P2PmQu-00040-00008232-00008527 or the cost and the cost to create these
+NV726P2PmQu-00041-00008528-00008599 solar panels
+NV726P2PmQu-00042-00008600-00008878 will be greatly reduced if you use cheap
+NV726P2PmQu-00043-00008879-00009095 synthesis processes as opposed to vacuum
+NV726P2PmQu-00044-00009096-00009231 based technologies
+NV726P2PmQu-00045-00009232-00009374 what we try to do in my lab is to
+NV726P2PmQu-00046-00009375-00009567 replace these very costly and labor
+NV726P2PmQu-00047-00009568-00009646 intensive
+NV726P2PmQu-00048-00009647-00009951 techniques with cheaper methods
+NV726P2PmQu-00049-00009952-00010246 using molecular inks that contains
+NV726P2PmQu-00050-00010247-00010406 already all the chemical elements
+NV726P2PmQu-00051-00010407-00010623 we can formulate and create this ink
+NV726P2PmQu-00052-00010624-00010751 directly in the glovebox
+NV726P2PmQu-00053-00010752-00011023 and we can essentially print or spray
+NV726P2PmQu-00054-00011024-00011119 these inks
+NV726P2PmQu-00055-00011120-00011319 onto a substrate we don't need a vacuum
+NV726P2PmQu-00056-00011320-00011478 chamber for this we don't need high
+NV726P2PmQu-00057-00011479-00011678 power we don't need vacuum pumps
+NV726P2PmQu-00058-00011679-00011919 this type of approach allows us to study
+NV726P2PmQu-00059-00011920-00012127 new materials that simply cannot be
+NV726P2PmQu-00060-00012128-00012367 deposited with vacuum techniques either
+NV726P2PmQu-00061-00012368-00012446 because they are not
+NV726P2PmQu-00062-00012447-00012767 compatible in a vacuum chamber or
+NV726P2PmQu-00063-00012768-00013007 they just require very high temperature
+NV726P2PmQu-00064-00013008-00013127 to be evaporated
+NV726P2PmQu-00065-00013128-00013422 when you report efficiencies in the pv
+NV726P2PmQu-00066-00013423-00013583 world on the solar world
+NV726P2PmQu-00067-00013584-00013830 you have to do that under very specific
+NV726P2PmQu-00068-00013831-00013951 illumination
+NV726P2PmQu-00069-00013952-00014151 conditions and so instead of being
+NV726P2PmQu-00070-00014152-00014358 outside and waiting for the sun
+NV726P2PmQu-00071-00014359-00014591 and the weather to cooperate we actually
+NV726P2PmQu-00072-00014591-00014719 have an artificial
+NV726P2PmQu-00073-00014719-00014966 sunlight in the lab so we can just do
+NV726P2PmQu-00074-00014968-00015094 all our tests
+NV726P2PmQu-00075-00015095-00015319 in the lab comfortably sitting behind
+NV726P2PmQu-00076-00015319-00015407 the computer
+NV726P2PmQu-00077-00015408-00015630 with the ac running we work with
+NV726P2PmQu-00078-00015631-00015775 stanford university
+NV726P2PmQu-00079-00015776-00016086 the university of lebanon nrel as well
+NV726P2PmQu-00080-00016087-00016222 as lawrence livermore national
+NV726P2PmQu-00081-00016223-00016383 laboratory so it's really through the
+NV726P2PmQu-00082-00016384-00016543 collaboration that we actually
+NV726P2PmQu-00083-00016544-00016783 flourish and and expand our research
+NV726P2PmQu-00084-00016784-00016919 really here in hawaii
+NV726P2PmQu-00085-00016920-00017063 i should say that the work that we do in
+NV726P2PmQu-00086-00017064-00017239 the lab is not necessarily out for
+NV726P2PmQu-00087-00017240-00017383 commercialization yet
+NV726P2PmQu-00088-00017384-00017575 still looking at technologies that could
+NV726P2PmQu-00089-00017576-00017855 be applied maybe 10 15 years from now
+NV726P2PmQu-00090-00017856-00018079 and i think as far as hni is concerned
+NV726P2PmQu-00091-00018080-00018230 and the collaboration that we have
+NV726P2PmQu-00092-00018231-00018375 it's extremely important to look at the
+NV726P2PmQu-00093-00018376-00018575 technologies there are today and see how
+NV726P2PmQu-00094-00018576-00018743 these technologies can be integrated
+NV726P2PmQu-00095-00018744-00019047 in the grid and overall could we even
+NV726P2PmQu-00096-00019048-00019255 add more of these pv modules onto the
+NV726P2PmQu-00097-00019256-00019447 grid with the help of storage
+NV726P2PmQu-00098-00019448-00019679 as batteries or through the integration
+NV726P2PmQu-00099-00019680-00020559 of fuel cell and hydrogen technology
+NVxVyx35L3E-00000-00000048-00000279 reading blogs and watching videos on
+NVxVyx35L3E-00001-00000280-00000390 porosity
+NVxVyx35L3E-00002-00000391-00000615 can make you feel like high porosity is
+NVxVyx35L3E-00003-00000616-00000774 always self-inflicted
+NVxVyx35L3E-00004-00000775-00000911 and that it's something that needs to be
+NVxVyx35L3E-00005-00000911-00001278 reversed that's not always the case
+NVxVyx35L3E-00006-00001279-00001503 many people have naturally higher
+NVxVyx35L3E-00007-00001504-00001655 porosity hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00008-00001655-00001863 meaning the new growth that comes out of
+NVxVyx35L3E-00009-00001864-00001959 their scalp
+NVxVyx35L3E-00010-00001960-00002183 has thinner and more fragile cuticle
+NVxVyx35L3E-00011-00002184-00002279 layers
+NVxVyx35L3E-00012-00002280-00002518 so people with naturally high porosity
+NVxVyx35L3E-00013-00002519-00002583 hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00014-00002584-00002934 tend to also have finer hair strands
+NVxVyx35L3E-00015-00002935-00003199 if you find your balance high porosity
+NVxVyx35L3E-00016-00003200-00003327 hair types can retain
+NVxVyx35L3E-00017-00003328-00003559 a lot of length with some serious hang
+NVxVyx35L3E-00018-00003560-00003911 time without ever having to use heat
+NVxVyx35L3E-00019-00003911-00004151 porosity does not determine your hair's
+NVxVyx35L3E-00020-00004152-00004270 potential
+NVxVyx35L3E-00021-00004271-00004638 and porosity is not the be-all end-all
+NVxVyx35L3E-00022-00004639-00004847 check out these youtube channels these
+NVxVyx35L3E-00023-00004848-00004975 ladies have healthy
+NVxVyx35L3E-00024-00004976-00005311 thriving naturally high porosity hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00025-00005312-00005447 and they talk about it from their
+NVxVyx35L3E-00026-00005448-00005615 perspective
+NVxVyx35L3E-00027-00005616-00005831 and as you saw in the last video high
+NVxVyx35L3E-00028-00005832-00006102 porosity can also be self-inflicted
+NVxVyx35L3E-00029-00006103-00006399 through heat damage greenhouse overload
+NVxVyx35L3E-00030-00006400-00006518 over manipulation
+NVxVyx35L3E-00031-00006519-00006863 and neglect and chemical damage
+NVxVyx35L3E-00032-00006864-00007083 while these two scenarios are both high
+NVxVyx35L3E-00033-00007084-00007423 porosity they don't always look the same
+NVxVyx35L3E-00034-00007423-00007646 hair strands that are naturally higher
+NVxVyx35L3E-00035-00007647-00007751 in porosity
+NVxVyx35L3E-00036-00007752-00007974 does not always have to have damaged
+NVxVyx35L3E-00037-00007975-00008263 torn or have exaggerated lifts
+NVxVyx35L3E-00038-00008264-00008431 the cuticles could just be slightly
+NVxVyx35L3E-00039-00008432-00008599 lifted or relaxed
+NVxVyx35L3E-00040-00008600-00008774 or the cuticles could just be thinner
+NVxVyx35L3E-00041-00008775-00008959 than average
+NVxVyx35L3E-00042-00008960-00009271 a self-inflicted increase in porosity is
+NVxVyx35L3E-00043-00009272-00009478 where you'll see more severe tears
+NVxVyx35L3E-00044-00009479-00009783 lifts and missing cuticles it doesn't
+NVxVyx35L3E-00045-00009784-00009878 matter if you have
+NVxVyx35L3E-00046-00009879-00010191 naturally high porosity hair or if you
+NVxVyx35L3E-00047-00010192-00010438 caused your hair to become more porous
+NVxVyx35L3E-00048-00010439-00010799 high porosity is permanent but there are
+NVxVyx35L3E-00049-00010800-00010983 minor tweaks you can make to your hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00050-00010984-00011174 regimen to find your balance
+NVxVyx35L3E-00051-00011175-00011471 and keep your hair thriving apart from
+NVxVyx35L3E-00052-00011472-00011631 keeping your scalp clean
+NVxVyx35L3E-00053-00011632-00011919 your hair moisturized and lubricated and
+NVxVyx35L3E-00054-00011920-00012063 your ends happy
+NVxVyx35L3E-00055-00012064-00012255 there are a few things high porosity
+NVxVyx35L3E-00056-00012256-00012583 hair types should pay extra attention to
+NVxVyx35L3E-00057-00012584-00012935 here are some tips protein treatments
+NVxVyx35L3E-00058-00012936-00013127 are especially beneficial to high
+NVxVyx35L3E-00059-00013128-00013311 porosity hair types
+NVxVyx35L3E-00060-00013312-00013535 they create a thin film over your hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00061-00013536-00013775 strands that acts as a temporary
+NVxVyx35L3E-00062-00013776-00014015 protective coat and gives your cuticles
+NVxVyx35L3E-00063-00014016-00014255 a little break for a while
+NVxVyx35L3E-00064-00014256-00014447 protein molecules come in different
+NVxVyx35L3E-00065-00014447-00014607 shapes and sizes
+NVxVyx35L3E-00066-00014608-00014815 some create a thick coat around your
+NVxVyx35L3E-00067-00014816-00015007 hair and barely penetrate
+NVxVyx35L3E-00068-00015008-00015191 and others create a thinner more
+NVxVyx35L3E-00069-00015191-00015375 breathable coat around your hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00070-00015376-00015727 and absorb deeper into your hair strands
+NVxVyx35L3E-00071-00015728-00016015 high porosity hair can handle using most
+NVxVyx35L3E-00072-00016016-00016191 store-bought protein treatments
+NVxVyx35L3E-00073-00016191-00016503 with larger protein molecules
+NVxVyx35L3E-00074-00016504-00016735 but it's best to use a protein treatment
+NVxVyx35L3E-00075-00016736-00016975 with smaller protein molecules
+NVxVyx35L3E-00076-00016976-00017199 like the real protein treatment because
+NVxVyx35L3E-00077-00017200-00017407 it's small enough to penetrate and bind
+NVxVyx35L3E-00078-00017408-00017630 with deeper parts of your hair strands
+NVxVyx35L3E-00079-00017631-00017799 and create a more breathable and
+NVxVyx35L3E-00080-00017800-00018014 flexible coat
+NVxVyx35L3E-00081-00018015-00018222 this way your hair strands are strong
+NVxVyx35L3E-00082-00018223-00018414 and breakage resistant
+NVxVyx35L3E-00083-00018415-00018735 but still flexible and soft
+NVxVyx35L3E-00084-00018736-00018991 if your hair is high in porosity try
+NVxVyx35L3E-00085-00018992-00019150 adding protein treatments to your
+NVxVyx35L3E-00086-00019151-00019327 regimen
+NVxVyx35L3E-00087-00019328-00019527 keeping high porosity hair strands
+NVxVyx35L3E-00088-00019528-00019735 properly coated and protected
+NVxVyx35L3E-00089-00019736-00020063 is very beneficial so if you feel like
+NVxVyx35L3E-00090-00020064-00020294 your hair regimen is missing something
+NVxVyx35L3E-00091-00020295-00020519 try adding the product with a mucilage
+NVxVyx35L3E-00092-00020520-00020678 texture
+NVxVyx35L3E-00093-00020679-00020871 they stick onto and coat your hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00094-00020872-00021014 strands really well
+NVxVyx35L3E-00095-00021015-00021278 and don't have to be reapplied as much
+NVxVyx35L3E-00096-00021279-00021455 experiment with ingredients like
+NVxVyx35L3E-00097-00021456-00021575 slippery elm
+NVxVyx35L3E-00098-00021576-00021863 marshmallow root chai seeds or flax
+NVxVyx35L3E-00099-00021864-00021911 seeds
+NVxVyx35L3E-00100-00021912-00022158 just to name a few or look for them in
+NVxVyx35L3E-00101-00022159-00022439 the ingredients list and products
+NVxVyx35L3E-00102-00022440-00022783 all textured hair hates being dry
+NVxVyx35L3E-00103-00022784-00023022 but high porosity hair is especially
+NVxVyx35L3E-00104-00023023-00023263 prone and sensitive to dryness
+NVxVyx35L3E-00105-00023264-00023471 it breaks a lot more than low porosity
+NVxVyx35L3E-00106-00023472-00023639 hair types when it's dry
+NVxVyx35L3E-00107-00023640-00024014 and dries out a lot faster as well so
+NVxVyx35L3E-00108-00024015-00024286 it's important to take extra efforts to
+NVxVyx35L3E-00109-00024287-00024503 always keep this hair type from drying
+NVxVyx35L3E-00110-00024504-00024678 out to a certain point
+NVxVyx35L3E-00111-00024679-00024919 this looks different for everyone the
+NVxVyx35L3E-00112-00024920-00025022 goal is to stay
+NVxVyx35L3E-00113-00025023-00025311 ahead of the dryness for some people it
+NVxVyx35L3E-00114-00025312-00025535 means re-moisturizing every night
+NVxVyx35L3E-00115-00025536-00025855 or every other night or every week
+NVxVyx35L3E-00116-00025856-00026094 i can't talk about high porosity hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00117-00026095-00026367 without talking about gentle handling
+NVxVyx35L3E-00118-00026368-00026599 when you hear anything about tension
+NVxVyx35L3E-00119-00026600-00026814 it's usually referring to your scalp
+NVxVyx35L3E-00120-00026816-00026999 we don't hear much about tension to your
+NVxVyx35L3E-00121-00027000-00027183 hair strands
+NVxVyx35L3E-00122-00027183-00027399 the cuticle layer on high porosity hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00123-00027400-00027599 strands are already fragile
+NVxVyx35L3E-00124-00027600-00027902 so it's easy to damage them
+NVxVyx35L3E-00125-00027904-00028111 avoid pulling on your hair strands or
+NVxVyx35L3E-00126-00028112-00028390 forcing it into tight braids or twists
+NVxVyx35L3E-00127-00028391-00028607 practice installing your braids and
+NVxVyx35L3E-00128-00028608-00028855 twist looser
+NVxVyx35L3E-00129-00028856-00029079 at least loose enough where your braid
+NVxVyx35L3E-00130-00029080-00029270 isn't stiff and still has some wiggle
+NVxVyx35L3E-00131-00029272-00029423 room
+NVxVyx35L3E-00132-00029424-00029727 and switch these tight hair ties to
+NVxVyx35L3E-00133-00029727-00030031 these satin hair ties or
+NVxVyx35L3E-00134-00030032-00030383 stockings to a puff cuff
+NVxVyx35L3E-00135-00030383-00030607 these small changes to your hair regimen
+NVxVyx35L3E-00136-00030608-00030839 can make a huge difference down the road
+NVxVyx35L3E-00137-00030839-00031151 to the health and look of your hair as a
+NVxVyx35L3E-00138-00031152-00031239 recap
+NVxVyx35L3E-00139-00031239-00031431 four things worth adding to your hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00140-00031432-00031662 regimen if your hair is high in porosity
+NVxVyx35L3E-00141-00031663-00032031 are real protein treatments
+NVxVyx35L3E-00142-00032032-00032351 products with mucilage anti dryness
+NVxVyx35L3E-00143-00032352-00032462 regimen
+NVxVyx35L3E-00144-00032463-00032767 and extra tlc
+NVxVyx35L3E-00145-00032768-00032935 there's a lot of confusion out there
+NVxVyx35L3E-00146-00032936-00033174 when it comes to the topic of porosity
+NVxVyx35L3E-00147-00033175-00033446 so i recently posted a porosity series
+NVxVyx35L3E-00148-00033447-00033655 in hopes to make it less confusing
+NVxVyx35L3E-00149-00033656-00033855 and try to answer all your questions in
+NVxVyx35L3E-00150-00033856-00034023 one place
+NVxVyx35L3E-00151-00034024-00034318 i talked about the pros and cons and how
+NVxVyx35L3E-00152-00034319-00034567 to identify if your hair is high
+NVxVyx35L3E-00153-00034568-00034879 low or medium porosity and what their
+NVxVyx35L3E-00154-00034880-00035031 differences are
+NVxVyx35L3E-00155-00035032-00035311 this series is packed with information
+NVxVyx35L3E-00156-00035312-00035471 so make sure to check them out
+NVxVyx35L3E-00157-00035472-00035646 you can find them in the complete hair
+NVxVyx35L3E-00158-00035647-00035943 type playlist on my youtube page
+NVxVyx35L3E-00159-00035944-00036487 giveaway giveaway giveaway giveaway
+NVxVyx35L3E-00160-00036488-00036702 so that's it for the complete hair type
+NVxVyx35L3E-00161-00036703-00036799 series
+NVxVyx35L3E-00162-00036800-00036990 i hope these videos helped you figure
+NVxVyx35L3E-00163-00036991-00037102 out where you fit on
+NVxVyx35L3E-00164-00037103-00037374 every one of these lines because for me
+NVxVyx35L3E-00165-00037375-00037646 learning this was a game changer
+NVxVyx35L3E-00166-00037647-00037943 so here's the giveaway question what
+NVxVyx35L3E-00167-00037944-00038111 method do i use
+NVxVyx35L3E-00168-00038112-00038439 to keep my hair stretched and get full
+NVxVyx35L3E-00169-00038440-00038783 sebum coverage you can find the answer
+NVxVyx35L3E-00170-00038784-00039167 to this question in one of these videos
+NVxVyx35L3E-00171-00039168-00039399 in order to qualify you must be
+NVxVyx35L3E-00172-00039400-00039607 subscribed to the green beauty youtube
+NVxVyx35L3E-00173-00039608-00039695 channel
+NVxVyx35L3E-00174-00039696-00040039 and follow at green beauty on instagram
+NVxVyx35L3E-00175-00040040-00040327 and of course have the correct answer
+NVxVyx35L3E-00176-00040328-00040543 after leaving your answer below
+NVxVyx35L3E-00177-00040544-00040767 leave your youtube name and the answer
+NVxVyx35L3E-00178-00040768-00040935 to the giveaway question
+NVxVyx35L3E-00179-00040936-00041230 as a comment on this instagram post
+NVxVyx35L3E-00180-00041231-00041295 that's up
+NVxVyx35L3E-00181-00041296-00041630 right now on my instagram page so
+NVxVyx35L3E-00182-00041631-00041799 answer the giveaway question here on
+NVxVyx35L3E-00183-00041800-00042046 youtube then leave your youtube
+NVxVyx35L3E-00184-00042047-00042255 name and the giveaway answer in this
+NVxVyx35L3E-00185-00042256-00042479 instagram post
+NVxVyx35L3E-00186-00042480-00042807 it's that easy the winner will be
+NVxVyx35L3E-00187-00042808-00043023 announced on the green beauty instagram
+NVxVyx35L3E-00188-00043024-00043087 page
+NVxVyx35L3E-00189-00043088-00043462 one week from now on sunday april 28th
+NVxVyx35L3E-00190-00043463-00043751 and will get one four ounce real protein
+NVxVyx35L3E-00191-00043752-00043862 treatment
+NVxVyx35L3E-00192-00043863-00044199 one four ounce herbal hot oil treatment
+NVxVyx35L3E-00193-00044200-00044535 one pure tea tree essential oil and one
+NVxVyx35L3E-00194-00044536-00044846 eight ounce ph stabilizing spritz
+NVxVyx35L3E-00195-00044847-00045158 oh and a pack of the ph test strips
+NVxVyx35L3E-00196-00045159-00045351 so you can test the ph of all your
+NVxVyx35L3E-00197-00045352-00045543 water-based products
+NVxVyx35L3E-00198-00045544-00045855 as always thanks for watching see you in
+NVxVyx35L3E-00199-00045856-00046408 the next video
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00000-00000018-00000436 live from Atlanta Georgia it's the cube
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00001-00000437-00000841 covering Citrix energy Atlanta 2019
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00002-00000842-00001406 brought to you by Citrix hi welcome back
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00003-00001407-00001591 to the cube Lisa Martin with Keith
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00004-00001592-00001783 Townsend and we are live in Atlanta
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00005-00001784-00002167 Georgia for Citrix energy 2019 we are
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00006-00002168-00002335 pleased to welcome Jack gold to the cube
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00007-00002336-00002524 president and founder of juggled and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00008-00002525-00002716 associates Jack it's great to have you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00009-00002717-00002875 join Keitha me this afternoon
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00010-00002876-00003058 thank you for having me so we had a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00011-00003059-00003227 great day we've talked to eight or nine
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00012-00003228-00003518 folks or so lots of really relevant
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00013-00003519-00003803 exciting news from Citrix this morning
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00014-00003804-00004127 talking about the employee experience as
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00015-00004128-00004319 and how I kind of interpreted as a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00016-00004320-00004550 catalyst for digital transformation
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00017-00004551-00004727 cultural transformation you've been
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00018-00004728-00004916 working with Citrix for a long time I'd
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00019-00004917-00005228 love to get your perspective on not just
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00020-00005229-00005453 what you heard today from Citrix and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00021-00005454-00005666 with Google and Microsoft but in the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00022-00005667-00005837 last year or so since they've really
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00023-00005838-00006035 kind of done a rebrand effort what are
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00024-00006036-00006293 your thoughts on that yeah it's it's
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00025-00006294-00006448 interesting from a Citrix perspective
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00026-00006450-00006725 Citrix the old Citrix I guess I put in
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00027-00006726-00006956 quotes right was always known as the VDI
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00028-00006956-00007238 company I've got you know the screen
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00029-00007239-00007433 that will talk to the server that will
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00030-00007434-00007667 talk to whether ever apps I need to talk
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00031-00007668-00008000 to and I can have a nice thin client
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00032-00008001-00008159 sitting on my desktop and I don't have
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00033-00008159-00008282 to spend a lot of money and I also don't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00034-00008283-00008396 have to worry about if I'm in a bank
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00035-00008397-00008633 people stealing stuff off the hard drive
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00036-00008634-00008969 or whatever they made a pretty
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00037-00008970-00009245 significant transition that was the the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00038-00009246-00009635 old work space if you will the modern
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00039-00009636-00009857 work spaces which is where Citrix is
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00040-00009858-00010256 really moving is one where look we've
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00041-00010257-00010418 all grown up with smartphones for the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00042-00010419-00010637 last 10 or 15 years our our kids don't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00043-00010638-00010799 know anything different they're not
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00044-00010800-00011048 gonna deal with anything that's complex
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00045-00011049-00011231 anything where I have to drag in and out
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00046-00011232-00011441 of applications anything where I have to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00047-00011442-00011723 switch between screens this just doesn't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00048-00011724-00011945 make any sense for them and so what
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00049-00011946-00012032 we're seeing
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00050-00012033-00012302 Citrix do is move into an environment
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00051-00012303-00012545 where as I said it's about the modern
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00052-00012546-00012739 workspace it's about being able to help
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00053-00012740-00013012 me do my job not getting in my way of me
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00054-00013013-00013307 doing my job and that's really the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00055-00013308-00013511 transition it's not just citrix the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00056-00013512-00013652 industry is moving in that direction as
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00057-00013653-00013850 well but Citrix is really at the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00058-00013851-00014047 forefront of making a lot of that work
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00059-00014049-00014572 now so it's about the new promise of the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00060-00014574-00014894 new Citrix the crew member may have to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00061-00014894-00015053 be made about seven years ago I did a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00062-00015054-00015362 blog post of running Windows XP on your
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00063-00015363-00015734 iPad it was taking you know the Zen
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00064-00015735-00015935 desktop solution and running it on your
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00065-00015936-00016208 iPad it was a cool trick but we talked
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00066-00016209-00016379 about today you know we were we would
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00067-00016380-00016625 hope by today that mobile technology
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00068-00016626-00016874 would have forced companies to rewrite
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00069-00016875-00017300 applications for the mobile first
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00070-00017301-00017477 experience but that simply hasn't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00071-00017478-00018002 happened so presenting a bad application
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00072-00018003-00018209 onto a mobile dot on a mobile
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00073-00018210-00018461 workstation or a mobile device doesn't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00074-00018462-00018674 work we end up packing in trying and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00075-00018675-00018830 squeezing and trying to get our work
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00076-00018831-00018922 done
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00077-00018923-00019325 how was Citrix promising to change that
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00078-00019326-00019580 experience even versus their competitors
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00079-00019581-00019844 sure well first of all so tube ads don't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00080-00019845-00020141 make it good right having a bad app on a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00081-00020142-00020342 bad device doesn't make it good doesn't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00082-00020343-00020483 make it easy to use doesn't help me get
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00083-00020484-00020711 my job done what we really are talking
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00084-00020712-00021089 about now is the ability to to build a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00085-00021090-00021365 workspace something where I I sit and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00086-00021366-00021638 look at that helps me get my job done as
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00087-00021639-00021767 opposed to getting in the way which
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00088-00021768-00022037 means that instead of having a punch 14
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00089-00022038-00022400 different holes or you know icons and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00090-00022401-00022694 città my my keyboard and type 48
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00091-00022695-00022907 different commands and and do 38
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00092-00022908-00023066 different logins because each one is
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00093-00023067-00023186 different and by the way I couldn't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00094-00023187-00023303 remember them so I just calls the help
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00095-00023304-00023477 desk in between and that's another half
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00096-00023478-00023615 an hour of my time that I didn't want to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00097-00023616-00023933 waste it to be my WordPerfect templates
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00098-00023934-00024125 there you go there you go we're perfect
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00099-00024126-00024394 I remember that not so well I remember
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00100-00024395-00024710 it well not so nicely what we're really
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00101-00024711-00024908 trying to focus on now is is user
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00102-00024909-00025049 experience right what we're really
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00103-00025050-00025355 trying to focus on is if if you want to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00104-00025356-00025607 get your work done I want to make it
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00105-00025608-00025793 easy think about it as going to a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00106-00025794-00026018 grocery store if you can't if you've got
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00107-00026019-00026189 a list of groceries and you can't find
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00108-00026189-00026342 what you want and then in five minutes
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00109-00026343-00026510 you leave you go somewhere else you go
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00110-00026511-00026666 to another grocery store where things
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00111-00026667-00026902 much easier to find it's the same at
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00112-00026904-00027104 work or should be the same at work now
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00113-00027105-00027476 that said a lot of apps in organizations
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00114-00027477-00027658 especially big enterprises where they
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00115-00027660-00027938 have some can have literally thousands
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00116-00027939-00028264 of apps are not going away the notion
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00117-00028266-00028414 that everything is going to go into the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00118-00028416-00028570 modern workspace where everything looks
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00119-00028572-00028886 like a phone it's a nice idea it's
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00120-00028887-00029006 probably not going to happen
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00121-00029007-00029237 legacy apps will be legacy apps for a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00122-00029238-00029399 very long time it's like mainframes are
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00123-00029400-00029572 dead guess what they're still around
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00124-00029573-00029855 that said that doesn't mean that you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00125-00029856-00030089 can't take some of those legacy apps it
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00126-00030089-00030326 makes them easier to use with the proper
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00127-00030327-00030554 front-end and that's really what Citrix
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00128-00030555-00030767 is trying to do with with the workspaces
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00129-00030768-00030970 and and others again are it's not just
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00130-00030972-00031100 Citrix in the industry we have to be
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00131-00031101-00031226 fair there are lots of people working in
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00132-00031227-00031457 this space but if you can make the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00133-00031458-00031724 front-end workspace more attractive
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00134-00031725-00031939 easier to use easier to navigate even if
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00135-00031941-00032174 I've got old clunky stuff in the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00136-00032175-00032447 background for me as a user you can give
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00137-00032448-00032663 me back 15 20 30 minutes a day an hour a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00138-00032664-00032885 day that's real productivity look if
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00139-00032886-00033287 you're paying me $100 an hour and you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00140-00033288-00033605 save me an hour a day you've just made
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00141-00033606-00033869 $100 every day that I'm working at that
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00142-00033870-00034139 company that's a sounds like a lot but
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00143-00034140-00034301 there are people who make that kind of
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00144-00034302-00034544 money or even a 50 or $25 it all adds up
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00145-00034545-00034733 and so what we're really doing is trying
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00146-00034734-00034916 to move into an environment where if I
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00147-00034917-00035150 can make you more productive
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00148-00035151-00035372 by making things easier for you to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00149-00035373-00035558 navigate and getting to app in and out
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00150-00035559-00035720 of applications more quickly getting
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00151-00035721-00035900 information to me more quickly which
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00152-00035901-00036104 makes the overall organization more
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00153-00036105-00036200 productive because I'm sharing
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00154-00036201-00036383 information with you then that's a real
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00155-00036384-00036563 win-win and that's where I think Citrix
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00156-00036564-00036764 is really trying to position itself and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00157-00036765-00037067 and doing a fairly good job of doing
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00158-00037068-00037268 that I clearly don't have all of the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00159-00037269-00037460 components yet but then no one does it's
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00160-00037461-00037685 this is an ongoing process so employee
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00161-00037686-00037958 experience is table stakes for any
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00162-00037959-00038108 business as we look at the modern
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00163-00038109-00038387 workforce it's highly distributed yes
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00164-00038388-00038537 it's composed of five different
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00165-00038538-00038801 generations yes who have varying
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00166-00038802-00039169 expertise with technology it is also
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00167-00039170-00039416 demanding because we're all consumers
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00168-00039417-00039638 and so we have this expectation or this
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00169-00039639-00039890 I'd say expectation that I want to be
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00170-00039891-00040001 able to go in and have this
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00171-00040002-00040165 personalized experience I don't want to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00172-00040166-00040301 have to become an expert in Salesforce
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00173-00040302-00040480 because I might need to understand can I
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00174-00040481-00040643 talk to that customer and ask them to be
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00175-00040644-00040840 a reference oneself how much time are
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00176-00040841-00041036 you gonna take but this personalization
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00177-00041037-00041330 is becoming more and more critical as we
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00178-00041331-00041510 say this influence from the consumer
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00179-00041511-00041683 side with some of the things that you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00180-00041684-00042023 heard today from Citrix what are your
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00181-00042024-00042280 thoughts on how they're going to be able
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00182-00042281-00042502 to improve that more personalized
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00183-00042503-00042767 employee experience so so people think
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00184-00042768-00043046 of personalization I think sometimes too
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00185-00043047-00043307 narrowly for some people personalization
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00186-00043308-00043499 is you know I'll get my phone out and I
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00187-00043500-00043699 have the apps that I want on my phone
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00188-00043700-00043927 and that's personalization I think of it
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00189-00043928-00044114 a little bit differently we need to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00190-00044115-00044317 extend personalization when I'm at work
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00191-00044318-00044593 what I want is not just the apps I want
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00192-00044594-00044885 clearly I want those right but also the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00193-00044886-00045124 ability to get help with those apps as I
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00194-00045125-00045337 need it right and so where Citrix is
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00195-00045338-00045614 going is trying to put intelligence into
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00196-00045615-00045827 the system so that when I'm interacting
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00197-00045828-00046085 with back-end solutions or my neighbors
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00198-00046086-00046379 or with teams collaboration I get the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00199-00046380-00046570 assistance I need to make it easier for
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00200-00046571-00046799 me to do that work it's not just the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00201-00046800-00047039 apps it's also helped with the apps and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00202-00047040-00047276 if we can do that that's really what we
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00203-00047277-00047507 want we go you know if I have a problem
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00204-00047508-00047660 with my laptop I'm gonna come to you and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00205-00047661-00047914 say hey you did this yesterday
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00206-00047915-00048046 what was the result can you help me for
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00207-00048047-00048170 five minutes five minutes it's never
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00208-00048171-00048346 five minutes it's usually an hour and a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00209-00048347-00048574 half but still I'll come to you why
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00210-00048575-00048793 can't I have an app on my desk that does
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00211-00048794-00049018 the same thing I'm having trouble help
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00212-00049019-00049246 me fix it let me know what I'm doing
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00213-00049247-00049385 wrong or let me know how I can do it
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00214-00049386-00049540 better and that's where Citrix is trying
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00215-00049541-00049649 to go with the analytics that they've
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00216-00049650-00049918 got in place which is huge I think
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00217-00049919-00050057 they're under playing that because I
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00218-00050058-00050271 think that the the whole analytics space
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00219-00050272-00050624 in making things easier for people to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00220-00050625-00050743 use because understanding where my
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00221-00050744-00050951 problems are is huge and that's gonna
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00222-00050952-00051310 pick up the the notion of having a nice
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00223-00051311-00051526 who's gonna say pretty-pretty might not
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00224-00051527-00051715 be the right word but but attractive at
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00225-00051716-00052042 least workspace for me to go in doesn't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00226-00052044-00052235 get me frustrated frustration is a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00227-00052236-00052379 killer and productivity as everyone
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00228-00052379-00052661 knows there are examples I've heard
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00229-00052662-00052819 multiple people tell me now that they go
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00230-00052820-00052951 out and hire especially with Millennials
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00231-00052952-00053111 to go out and hire twenty or thirty new
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00232-00053112-00053240 employees and have
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00233-00053241-00053378 them quit within a week because their
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00234-00053379-00053522 systems are so bad that they get so
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00235-00053523-00053680 frustrated or they're not gonna work
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00236-00053682-00054002 there so the notion of having a modern
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00237-00054003-00054203 workspace where I get the applications I
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00238-00054204-00054461 need I get the assistance I need because
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00239-00054462-00054671 of the analytics at the back end telling
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00240-00054672-00054953 the the system's what I need and making
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00241-00054954-00055157 it easier for me to do it and then
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00242-00055158-00055400 allowing me to be productive not just
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00243-00055401-00055571 for myself but for the organization is
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00244-00055572-00055739 where we all need to go and I said
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00245-00055740-00055937 Citrix is making some real progress
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00246-00055938-00056207 going that way so Jack we're talking
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00247-00056208-00056357 about products that have been quite
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00248-00056358-00056495 being released yet so I'm trying to get
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00249-00056496-00056905 a sense or Worth's the right bill versus
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00250-00056907-00057320 by stage it complexity citrus should be
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00251-00057321-00057515 you know I can make an apple pie by
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00252-00057516-00057872 going out and picking the Apple and and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00253-00057873-00058279 making my own crust or I can go by
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00254-00058280-00058504 filling or I can just go by intamin
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00255-00058505-00058676 spine sticking in the oven warm it up
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00256-00058677-00059075 three very different experiences three
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00257-00059076-00059430 different layers of investment and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00258-00059432-00059849 outcomes frankly in this world I can go
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00259-00059850-00060041 higher application developers to write
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00260-00060041-00060191 these mini apps to write these
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00261-00060191-00060449 customizations to might to write these
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00262-00060450-00060728 integrations but that's like I I think
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00263-00060729-00061028 that's akin to picking the Apple and and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00264-00061029-00061339 that just simply doesn't scale but also
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00265-00061340-00061652 while enamines pie is okay every now and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00266-00061653-00061946 again I want you know somehow follow tea
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00267-00061947-00062225 where do you think Citrix is on the kind
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00268-00062226-00062441 of range of bill versus vibe with this
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00269-00062441-00062735 intelligent experience so so build
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00270-00062736-00062870 versus buy is a very interesting
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00271-00062871-00063086 phenomenon and it's interesting because
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00272-00063087-00063344 it a lot of it has to do with where you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00273-00063345-00063563 think you are right now in the world
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00274-00063564-00063803 right you know you mentioned going out
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00275-00063804-00063935 getting developers and building your own
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00276-00063936-00064058 that's all well and good it doesn't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00277-00064059-00064220 scale and by the way in today's market
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00278-00064221-00064373 you can't find them to begin with so you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00279-00064374-00064604 know often don't even have a choice so
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00280-00064604-00064802 that's number one number two is that
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00281-00064803-00064991 there are companies out there that still
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00282-00064991-00065213 think for competitive advantage they
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00283-00065214-00065387 have to do everything from scratch like
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00284-00065388-00065606 building your PI yes you probably make
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00285-00065607-00065795 the best pie in the world but guess what
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00286-00065796-00065966 sometimes a good enough pie is good
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00287-00065967-00066179 enough right and if you're in business
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00288-00066180-00066347 sometimes good enough is the only way
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00289-00066348-00066584 you survive it doesn't have to be 100
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00290-00066585-00066791 and perfect 90 percents okay - and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00291-00066792-00066974 people can deal with that so that's the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00292-00066975-00067156 other piece the third piece of it is
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00293-00067157-00067375 from an end-user perspective right
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00294-00067376-00067709 if end-users are accustomed to having an
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00295-00067710-00067892 interaction in a certain way and then
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00296-00067893-00068074 you go out and get developers that come
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00297-00068075-00068141 in and do it something completely
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00298-00068142-00068275 different which they're apt to do
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00299-00068276-00068423 because each will have their own kind of
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00300-00068424-00068711 flavor to it then you just force them to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00301-00068712-00068899 learn one two three four or five
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00302-00068900-00069197 different interface interactions I'm not
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00303-00069198-00069392 gonna do that I'm gonna get frustrated
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00304-00069393-00069574 as heck and I'm gonna go call the help
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00305-00069575-00069740 desk or I'm gonna go get my admins they
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00306-00069741-00069923 do this for me both of which are
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00307-00069924-00070099 counterproductive to the company and to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00308-00070100-00070541 me so I it really depends on where you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00309-00070542-00070796 are in the stage of where your company
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00310-00070797-00071056 is I would say build versus buy it's not
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00311-00071057-00071324 it's not a 1 or a 0 there's lots of
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00312-00071325-00071573 shades of grey in between it's also not
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00313-00071574-00071903 all or nothing so some applications
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00314-00071904-00072187 might be built internally some you may
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00315-00072188-00072469 want to buy externally some you may have
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00316-00072470-00072674 a hybrid and and the nice thing about
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00317-00072675-00072968 the where workspaces are going now is
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00318-00072969-00073160 that you can plug all of those into the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00319-00073161-00073351 same environment that's really the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00320-00073352-00073669 ultimate goal is to make it as easy and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00321-00073670-00073967 transparent for the organization as
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00322-00073968-00074117 possible and also for the user because
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00323-00074118-00074354 the user ultimately is the end consumer
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00324-00074355-00074563 and if it's not good for the end
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00325-00074564-00074690 consumer it's not good for the company
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00326-00074691-00074762 either
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00327-00074763-00075088 so delivering this great game-changing
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00328-00075089-00075380 customer experience for this as we
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00329-00075381-00075560 talked about for this distributed modern
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00330-00075561-00075728 workforce that wants to be able to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00331-00075729-00076061 access mobile apps SAS apps web apps
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00332-00076062-00076565 from tablet PC phone desktop your car
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00333-00076566-00076732 your refrigerator anything with the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00334-00076733-00076984 screen refrigerators wherever you are
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00335-00076985-00077317 but I think ok people sure we're people
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00336-00077318-00077551 and we are the biggest single security
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00337-00077552-00077816 threat there is so in your perspective
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00338-00077817-00078022 how is what Citrix is talking about
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00339-00078023-00078422 balancing security as an essential
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00340-00078423-00078647 component of this employee experience so
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00341-00078648-00079018 there are few things number one is a lot
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00342-00079019-00079180 of companies think that if they limit
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00343-00079181-00079340 the end-user experience they're more
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00344-00079341-00079600 secure the truth of the matter is yes I
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00345-00079601-00079748 mean if you if you don't let me get into
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00346-00079749-00079970 an app I can't steal application
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00347-00079971-00080201 you know information or lose it somehow
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00348-00080202-00080414 but I also can't get my work done so
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00349-00080415-00080615 there's a balance between security and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00350-00080616-00080816 privacy which many companies don't talk
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00351-00080817-00080963 about which is not exactly the same
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00352-00080964-00081197 thing there are two unique things more
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00353-00081198-00081389 and more privacy is becoming as big or
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00354-00081390-00081614 bigger an issue than security but we you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00355-00081615-00081781 know we can get that out in a minute but
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00356-00081782-00082175 the notion of security really relates to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00357-00082176-00082310 what I was talking about earlier which
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00358-00082311-00082565 is analytics if I know what you're
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00359-00082566-00082910 supposed to be doing you're here at
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00360-00082911-00083225 Cynergy if someone just got your
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00361-00083226-00083471 credentials and logged in from Los
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00362-00083472-00083660 Angeles or New York or Chicago or Denver
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00363-00083661-00084029 or wherever I know it's not you I can
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00364-00084030-00084239 shut that thing down very quickly and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00365-00084240-00084368 not have to worry about them stealing
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00366-00084369-00084614 information also if your if I know
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00367-00084615-00084890 you're not supposed to be in a certain
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00368-00084891-00085067 version of sa P you're not supposed to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00369-00085068-00085328 be doing some ERP system and and you're
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00370-00085329-00085592 in it then again the analytics tells me
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00371-00085593-00085739 that there's something going on there's
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00372-00085740-00085994 something anomalous going on that I need
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00373-00085995-00086469 to investigate so having a system that
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00374-00086470-00086759 protects because there's a kind of a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00375-00086760-00086885 front end to everything that's going on
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00376-00086886-00087086 in the backend and a realization of
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00377-00087087-00087317 what's going on behind that screen gives
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00378-00087318-00087563 me a much higher sense of security from
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00379-00087564-00087826 a corporate perspective it's not perfect
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00380-00087827-00087953 there is no such thing as perfect
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00381-00087954-00088094 security but it's a lot better than just
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00382-00088095-00088310 letting us kind of do our own thing and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00383-00088311-00088505 put your loading semantics or McAfee or
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00384-00088506-00088736 whatever on your PC and that's where
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00385-00088737-00088928 we're all the in the industry autumn
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00386-00088929-00089078 Utley has to go that becomes part of the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00387-00089079-00089279 of the new modern workspace it's not
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00388-00089280-00089480 just about more productive it's about
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00389-00089481-00089696 more secure it's about more private it's
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00390-00089697-00089894 about not letting information escape
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00391-00089895-00090094 that shouldn't be there to begin with
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00392-00090095-00090503 so less question on data gravity because
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00393-00090504-00090659 we haven't talked about data and data is
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00394-00090660-00090839 you know probably the most important
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00395-00090840-00091076 thing in this topic the importance of
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00396-00091077-00091346 the azure and Google announcement you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00397-00091347-00091616 know we the Yoda byte and first time
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00398-00091617-00091823 I've heard that term Yoda byte of data
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00399-00091824-00092021 and that data is gonna be spread across
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00400-00092022-00092396 the world and this this idea of
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00401-00092397-00092634 centralized compute and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00402-00092635-00092850 and us being able to present compute
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00403-00092851-00093048 into a data center is no longer gonna
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00404-00093049-00093285 work that we're not the applications are
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00405-00093286-00093464 going to be spread all across the world
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00406-00093465-00094011 whether you see Citrix in advancing that
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00407-00094012-00094299 discipline of providing apps where they
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00408-00094300-00094494 need to be with these relationships so
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00409-00094495-00094629 it's an interesting phenomenon what
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00410-00094630-00094740 we're going through right now if you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00411-00094741-00094893 look back a couple of decades ago
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00412-00094894-00095085 everything was centralized people were
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00413-00095086-00095214 centralized they all work in one
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00414-00095215-00095457 building computing was centralized it
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00415-00095458-00095601 was all in the data center IT was
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00416-00095602-00095763 centralized it was all you know working
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00417-00095764-00096189 around the the servers the cloud is the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00418-00096190-00096300 opposite direction although I would
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00419-00096301-00096537 argue that the cloud is that new cloud
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00420-00096538-00096663 is just I'm sure in a different
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00421-00096664-00096903 environment for us old people who
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00422-00096904-00097106 remember the old IBM timeshare computers
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00423-00097107-00097353 but everything is becoming distributed
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00424-00097354-00097536 data is distributed people are
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00425-00097537-00097746 distributed applications to distributed
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00426-00097747-00098064 networks are distributed you name it the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00427-00098065-00098340 the key critical factor for companies
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00428-00098341-00098616 and keeping them productivity or keeping
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00429-00098617-00098793 up the productivity is to make sure that
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00430-00098794-00099075 the that distributed environment doesn't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00431-00099076-00099279 get in the way of doing work so you've
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00432-00099280-00099465 got things like latency if it takes me
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00433-00099466-00099768 if I'm in we're having a party behind it
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00434-00099769-00100179 they agree with you you know if I'm here
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00435-00100180-00100341 at Cynergy but I have to work back am I
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00436-00100342-00100503 my office is near Boston
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00437-00100504-00100659 I can't wait five minutes for
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00438-00100660-00100782 information to come back and forth it
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00439-00100783-00100938 was like the old days
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00440-00100939-00101181 latency now has to be within 5
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00441-00101182-00101436 microseconds or people get frustrated so
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00442-00101437-00101621 that becomes a network issue
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00443-00101622-00101838 applications same way if I have to go to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00444-00101839-00102045 a data center the data isn't local to my
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00445-00102046-00102399 server here it has to go to London I'm
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00446-00102400-00102536 not gonna wait three minutes for it to
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00447-00102538-00102696 come back like we used to or 10 minutes
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00448-00102697-00102891 or an hour and a half or come back the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00449-00102892-00103071 next morning you know you you want a
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00450-00103072-00103248 book of a flight on an airline are you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00451-00103249-00103418 gonna wait 30 minutes for them to find
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00452-00103419-00103532 you a seat you're gonna go to another
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00453-00103533-00103736 airline so the whole notion of
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00454-00103738-00103934 distributed means that it's very
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00455-00103935-00104057 different now even though it's
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00456-00104058-00104304 distributed everything is local and by
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00457-00104305-00104565 local keeping it local it means that you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00458-00104566-00104711 have to have latency below a certain
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00459-00104713-00104979 points so that I don't realize that it's
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00460-00104980-00105120 distributed or I don't care that that
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00461-00105121-00105294 it's distributed yota bytes of data
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00462-00105295-00105492 means that we're gonna have data
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00463-00105493-00105758 everywhere accessible all the time and
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00464-00105759-00105933 we're going to produce data like
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00465-00105933-00106233 crazy you know a typical car autonomous
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00466-00106233-00106409 car will produce a gigabyte of data
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00467-00106410-00106529 every minute
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00468-00106530-00106886 hundreds of every you know hour so the
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00469-00106888-00107043 amount of data is going to be fantastic
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00470-00107044-00107220 that we have to deal with then the big
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00471-00107221-00107376 question becomes okay so I can't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00472-00107377-00107532 personally deal with all this data it's
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00473-00107533-00107733 impossible I have to have the assistance
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00474-00107733-00107979 the intelligence within the system to go
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00475-00107980-00108150 off and make something of their data so
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00476-00108151-00108276 that I can actually interact with it
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00477-00108277-00108432 meaningful in a meaningful fashion
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00478-00108433-00108627 that's where Citrix would like to go
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00479-00108628-00108756 that's what others like to go they can't
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00480-00108757-00108969 do it alone because the problem is just
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00481-00108970-00109350 too darn big but it we will get there
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00482-00109351-00109608 companies will get there eventually not
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00483-00109608-00109821 all of them perhaps the only the ones
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00484-00109822-00109923 that are going to be successful long
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00485-00109924-00110127 term are going to get there well Jack I
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00486-00110128-00110289 wish we had more time to chat with you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00487-00110290-00110483 this is I just feel like going dot dot
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00488-00110484-00110703 to be continued and I want to say
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00489-00110704-00110883 coincidence I don't know there were two
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00490-00110883-00110994 rounds of applause when you talked about
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00491-00110995-00111330 latency we're just waiting for the bar
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00492-00111331-00111528 to open it's taking too long you think
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00493-00111529-00111654 that's what it is probably all right
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00494-00111655-00111801 well we'll get you over there thank you
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00495-00111802-00111930 again for joining key to me this
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00496-00111931-00111972 afternoon
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00497-00111973-00112211 thank you very much our pleasure for
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00498-00112213-00112380 Keith Townsend I'm Lisa Martin you're
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00499-00112381-00112563 watching the cube live from Citrix
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00500-00112564-00113371 energy 2019 thanks for watching
+NZhiSDrs2D4-00501-00113372-00113677 [Music]