Hummer: Towards Limited Competitive Preference Dataset

Preference datasets are essential for incorporating human preferences into pre-trained language models, playing a key role in the success of Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback. However, these datasets often demonstrate conflicting alignment objectives, leading to increased vulnerability to jailbreak attacks and challenges in adapting downstream tasks to prioritize specific alignment objectives without negatively impacting others. In this work, we introduce a novel statistical metric, Alignment Dimension Conflict, to quantify the degree of conflict within preference datasets. We then present Hummer and its fine-grained variant, <PRE_TAG>Hummer-F</POST_TAG>, as innovative pairwise preference datasets with reduced-conflict alignment objectives. Hummer is built based on UltraFeedback and is enhanced by AI feedback from GPT-4, marking as the first preference dataset aimed at reducing the competition between alignment objectives. Furthermore, we develop reward models, <PRE_TAG>HummerRM</POST_TAG> and <PRE_TAG><PRE_TAG>HummerRM</POST_TAG>-F</POST_TAG>, which employ a hybrid sampling approach to balance diverse alignment objectives effectively. This sampling method positions <PRE_TAG>HummerRM</POST_TAG> as an ideal model for domain-specific further fine-tuning and reducing vulnerabilities to attacks.