Spaces:
Configuration error
Configuration error
contract to work in specified mines and mills. There seemed to be no | |
limit to the factories, forges, refineries, and railways that could be | |
built, to the multitudes that could be employed in conquering a | |
continent. As for the future, that was in the hands of Providence! | |
=Business Theories of Politics.=--As the statesmen of Hamilton's school | |
and the planters of Calhoun's had their theories of government and | |
politics, so the leaders in business enterprise had theirs. It was | |
simple and easily stated. "It is the duty of the government," they | |
urged, "to protect American industry against foreign competition by | |
means of high tariffs on imported goods, to aid railways by generous | |
grants of land, to sell mineral and timber lands at low prices to | |
energetic men ready to develop them, and then to leave the rest to the | |
initiative and drive of individuals and companies." All government | |
interference with the management, prices, rates, charges, and conduct of | |
private business they held to be either wholly pernicious or intolerably | |
impertinent. Judging from their speeches and writings, they conceived | |
the nation as a great collection of individuals, companies, and labor | |
unions all struggling for profits or high wages and held together by a | |
government whose principal duty was to keep the peace among them and | |
protect industry against the foreign manufacturer. Such was the | |
political theory of business during the generation that followed the | |
Civil War. | |
THE SUPREMACY OF THE REPUBLICAN PARTY (1861-85) | |
=Business Men and Republican Policies.=--Most of the leaders in industry | |
gravitated to the Republican ranks. They worked in the North and the | |
Republican party was essentially Northern. It was moreover--at least so | |
far as the majority of its members were concerned--committed to | |
protective tariffs, a sound monetary and banking system, the promotion | |
of railways and industry by land grants, and the development of internal | |
improvements. It was furthermore generous in its immigration policy. It | |
proclaimed America to be an asylum for the oppressed of all countries | |
and flung wide the doors for immigrants eager to fill the factories, man | |
the mines, and settle upon Western lands. In a word the Republicans | |
stood for all those specific measures which favored the enlargement and | |
prosperity of business. At the same time they resisted government | |
interference with private enterprise. They did not regulate railway | |
rates, prosecute trusts for forming combinations, or prevent railway | |
companies from giving lower rates to some shippers than to others. To | |
sum it up, the political theories of the Republican party for three | |
decades after the Civil War were the theories of American | |
business--prosperous and profitable industries for the owners and "the | |
full dinner pail" for the workmen. Naturally a large portion of those | |
who flourished under its policies gave their support to it, voted for | |
its candidates, and subscribed to its campaign funds. | |
=Sources of Republican Strength in the North.=--The Republican party was | |
in fact a political organization of singular power. It originated in a | |
wave of moral enthusiasm, having attracted to itself, if not the | |
abolitionists, certainly all those idealists, like James Russell Lowell | |
and George William Curtis, who had opposed slavery when opposition was | |
neither safe nor popular. To moral principles it added practical | |
considerations. Business men had confidence in it. Workingmen, who | |
longed for the independence of the farmer, owed to its indulgent land | |
policy the opportunity of securing free homesteads in the West. The | |
immigrant, landing penniless on these shores, as a result of the same | |
beneficent system, often found himself in a little while with an estate | |
as large as many a baronial domain in the Old World. Under a Republican | |
administration, the union had been saved. To it the veterans of the war | |
could turn with confidence for those rewards of service which the | |
government could bestow: pensions surpassing in liberality anything that | |
the world had ever seen. Under a Republican administration also the | |
great debt had been created in the defense of the union, and to the | |
Republican party every investor in government bonds could look for the | |
full and honorable discharge of the interest and principal. The spoils | |
system, inaugurated by Jacksonian Democracy, in turn placed all the | |
federal offices in Republican hands, furnishing an army of party workers | |
to be counted on for loyal service in every campaign. | |
Of all these things Republican leaders made full and vigorous use, | |
sometimes ascribing to the party, in accordance with ancient political | |
usage, merits and achievements not wholly its own. Particularly was this | |
true in the case of saving the union. "When in the economy of | |
Providence, this land was to be purged of human slavery ... the | |
Republican party came into power," ran a declaration in one platform. | |
"The Republican party suppressed a gigantic rebellion, emancipated four | |
million slaves, decreed the equal citizenship of all, and established | |
universal suffrage," ran another. As for the aid rendered by the | |
millions of Northern Democrats who stood by the union and the tens of | |
thousands of them who actually fought in the union army, the Republicans | |
in their zeal were inclined to be oblivious. They repeatedly charged the | |
Democratic party "with being the same in character and spirit as when it | |
sympathized with treason." | |
=Republican Control of the South.=--To the strength enjoyed in the | |
North, the Republicans for a long time added the advantages that came | |
from control over the former Confederate states where the newly | |
enfranchised negroes, under white leadership, gave a grateful support to | |
the party responsible for their freedom. In this branch of politics, | |
motives were so mixed that no historian can hope to appraise them all at | |
their proper values. On the one side of the ledger must be set the | |
vigorous efforts of the honest and sincere friends of the freedmen to | |
win for them complete civil and political equality, wiping out not only | |
slavery but all its badges of misery and servitude. On the same side | |
must be placed the labor of those who had valiantly fought in forum and | |
field to save the union and who regarded continued Republican supremacy | |
after the war as absolutely necessary to prevent the former leaders in | |
secession from coming back to power. At the same time there were | |
undoubtedly some men of the baser sort who looked on politics as a game | |
and who made use of "carpet-bagging" in the South to win the spoils that | |
might result from it. At all events, both by laws and presidential acts, | |
the Republicans for many years kept a keen eye upon the maintenance of | |
their dominion in the South. Their declaration that neither the law nor | |
its administration should admit any discrimination in respect of | |
citizens by reason of race, color, or previous condition of servitude | |
appealed to idealists and brought results in elections. Even South | |
Carolina, where reposed the ashes of John C. Calhoun, went Republican in | |
1872 by a vote of three to one! | |
Republican control was made easy by the force bills described in a | |
previous chapter--measures which vested the supervision of elections in | |
federal officers appointed by Republican Presidents. These drastic | |
measures, departing from American tradition, the Republican authors | |
urged, were necessary to safeguard the purity of the ballot, not merely | |
in the South where the timid freedman might readily be frightened from | |
using it; but also in the North, particularly in New York City, where it | |
was claimed that fraud was regularly practiced by Democratic leaders. | |
The Democrats, on their side, indignantly denied the charges, replying | |
that the force bills were nothing but devices created by the Republicans | |
for the purpose of securing their continued rule through systematic | |
interference with elections. Even the measures of reconstruction were | |
deemed by Democratic leaders as thinly veiled schemes to establish | |
Republican power throughout the country. "Nor is there the slightest | |
doubt," exclaimed Samuel J. Tilden, spokesman of the Democrats in New | |
York and candidate for President in 1876, "that the paramount object and | |
motive of the Republican party is by these means to secure itself | |
against a reaction of opinion adverse to it in our great populous | |
Northern commonwealths.... When the Republican party resolved to | |
establish negro supremacy in the ten states in order to gain to itself | |
the representation of those states in Congress, it had to begin by | |
governing the people of those states by the sword.... The next was the | |
creation of new electoral bodies for those ten states, in which, by | |
exclusions, by disfranchisements and proscriptions, by control over | |
registration, by applying test oaths ... by intimidation and by every | |
form of influence, three million negroes are made to predominate over | |
four and a half million whites." | |
=The War as a Campaign Issue.=--Even the repeal of force bills could not | |
allay the sectional feelings engendered by the war. The Republicans | |
could not forgive the men who had so recently been in arms against the | |
union and insisted on calling them "traitors" and "rebels." The | |
Southerners, smarting under the reconstruction acts, could regard the | |
Republicans only as political oppressors. The passions of the war had | |
been too strong; the distress too deep to be soon forgotten. The | |
generation that went through it all remembered it all. For twenty | |
years, the Republicans, in their speeches and platforms, made "a | |
straight appeal to the patriotism of the Northern voters." They | |
maintained that their party, which had saved the union and emancipated | |
the slaves, was alone worthy of protecting the union and uplifting the | |
freedmen. | |
Though the Democrats, especially in the North, resented this policy and | |
dubbed it with the expressive but inelegant phrase, "waving the bloody | |
shirt," the Republicans refused to surrender a slogan which made such a | |
ready popular appeal. As late as 1884, a leader expressed the hope that | |
they might "wring one more President from the bloody shirt." They | |
refused to let the country forget that the Democratic candidate, Grover | |
Cleveland, had escaped military service by hiring a substitute; and they | |
made political capital out of the fact that he had "insulted the | |
veterans of the Grand Army of the Republic" by going fishing on | |
Decoration Day. | |
=Three Republican Presidents.=--Fortified by all these elements of | |
strength, the Republicans held the presidency from 1869 to 1885. The | |
three Presidents elected in this period, Grant, Hayes, and Garfield, had | |
certain striking characteristics in common. They were all of origin | |
humble enough to please the most exacting Jacksonian Democrat. They had | |
been generals in the union army. Grant, next to Lincoln, was regarded as | |
the savior of the Constitution. Hayes and Garfield, though lesser lights | |
in the military firmament, had honorable records duly appreciated by | |
veterans of the war, now thoroughly organized into the Grand Army of the | |
Republic. It is true that Grant was not a politician and had never voted | |
the Republican ticket; but this was readily overlooked. Hayes and | |
Garfield on the other hand were loyal party men. The former had served | |
in Congress and for three terms as governor of his state. The latter had | |
long been a member of the House of Representatives and was Senator-elect | |
when he received the nomination for President. | |
All of them possessed, moreover, another important asset, which was not | |
forgotten by the astute managers who led in selecting candidates. All | |
of them were from Ohio--though Grant had been in Illinois when the | |
summons to military duties came--and Ohio was a strategic state. It lay | |
between the manufacturing East and the agrarian country to the West. | |
Having growing industries and wool to sell it benefited from the | |
protective tariff. Yet being mainly agricultural still, it was not | |
without sympathy for the farmers who showed low tariff or free trade | |
tendencies. Whatever share the East had in shaping laws and framing | |
policies, it was clear that the West was to have the candidates. This | |
division in privileges--not uncommon in political management--was always | |
accompanied by a judicious selection of the candidate for Vice | |
President. With Garfield, for example, was associated a prominent New | |
York politician, Chester A. Arthur, who, as fate decreed, was destined | |
to more than three years' service as chief magistrate, on the | |
assassination of his superior in office. | |
=The Disputed Election of 1876.=--While taking note of the long years of | |
Republican supremacy, it must be recorded that grave doubts exist in the | |
minds of many historians as to whether one of the three Presidents, | |
Hayes, was actually the victor in 1876 or not. His Democratic opponent, | |
Samuel J. Tilden, received a popular plurality of a quarter of a million | |
and had a plausible claim to a majority of the electoral vote. At all | |
events, four states sent in double returns, one set for Tilden and | |
another for Hayes; and a deadlock ensued. Both parties vehemently | |
claimed the election and the passions ran so high that sober men did not | |
shrink from speaking of civil war again. Fortunately, in the end, the | |
counsels of peace prevailed. Congress provided for an electoral | |
commission of fifteen men to review the contested returns. The | |
Democrats, inspired by Tilden's moderation, accepted the judgment in | |
favor of Hayes even though they were not convinced that he was really | |
entitled to the office. | |
THE GROWTH OF OPPOSITION TO REPUBLICAN RULE | |
=Abuses in American Political Life.=--During their long tenure of | |
office, the Republicans could not escape the inevitable consequences of | |
power; that is, evil practices and corrupt conduct on the part of some | |
who found shelter within the party. For that matter neither did the | |
Democrats manage to avoid such difficulties in those states and cities | |
where they had the majority. In New York City, for instance, the local | |
Democratic organization, known as Tammany Hall, passed under the sway of | |
a group of politicians headed by "Boss" Tweed. He plundered the city | |
treasury until public-spirited citizens, supported by Samuel J. Tilden, | |
the Democratic leader of the state, rose in revolt, drove the ringleader | |
from power, and sent him to jail. In Philadelphia, the local Republican | |
bosses were guilty of offenses as odious as those committed by New York | |
politicians. Indeed, the decade that followed the Civil War was marred | |
by so many scandals in public life that one acute editor was moved to | |
inquire: "Are not all the great communities of the Western World growing | |
more corrupt as they grow in wealth?" | |
In the sphere of national politics, where the opportunities were | |
greater, betrayals of public trust were even more flagrant. One | |
revelation after another showed officers, high and low, possessed with | |
the spirit of peculation. Members of Congress, it was found, accepted | |
railway stock in exchange for votes in favor of land grants and other | |
concessions to the companies. In the administration as well as the | |
legislature the disease was rife. Revenue officers permitted whisky | |
distillers to evade their taxes and received heavy bribes in return. A | |
probe into the post-office department revealed the malodorous "star | |
route frauds"--the deliberate overpayment of certain mail carriers whose | |
lines were indicated in the official record by asterisks or stars. Even | |
cabinet officers did not escape suspicion, for the trail of the serpent | |
led straight to the door of one of them. | |
In the lower ranges of official life, the spoils system became more | |
virulent as the number of federal employees increased. The holders of | |
offices and the seekers after them constituted a veritable political | |
army. They crowded into Republican councils, for the Republicans, being | |
in power, could alone dispense federal favors. They filled positions in | |
the party ranging from the lowest township committee to the national | |
convention. They helped to nominate candidates and draft platforms and | |
elbowed to one side the busy citizen, not conversant with party | |
intrigues, who could only give an occasional day to political matters. | |
Even the Civil Service Act of 1883, wrung from a reluctant Congress two | |
years after the assassination of Garfield, made little change for a long | |
time. It took away from the spoilsmen a few thousand government | |
positions, but it formed no check on the practice of rewarding party | |
workers from the public treasury. | |
On viewing this state of affairs, many a distinguished citizen became | |
profoundly discouraged. James Russell Lowell, for example, thought he | |
saw a steady decline in public morals. In 1865, hearing of Lee's | |
surrender, he had exclaimed: "There is something magnificent in having a | |
country to love!" Ten years later, when asked to write an ode for the | |
centennial at Philadelphia in 1876, he could think only of a biting | |
satire on the nation: | |
"Show your state legislatures; show your Rings; | |
And challenge Europe to produce such things | |
As high officials sitting half in sight | |
To share the plunder and fix things right. | |
If that don't fetch her, why, you need only | |
To show your latest style in martyrs,--Tweed: | |
She'll find it hard to hide her spiteful tears | |
At such advance in one poor hundred years." | |
When his critics condemned him for this "attack upon his native land," | |
Lowell replied in sadness: "These fellows have no notion of what love of | |
country means. It was in my very blood and bones. If I am not an | |
American who ever was?... What fills me with doubt and dismay is the | |
degradation of the moral tone. Is it or is it not a result of democracy? | |
Is ours a 'government of the people, by the people, for the people,' or | |
a Kakistocracy [a government of the worst], rather for the benefit of | |
knaves at the cost of fools?" | |
=The Reform Movement in Republican Ranks.=--The sentiments expressed by | |
Lowell, himself a Republican and for a time American ambassador to | |
England, were shared by many men in his party. Very soon after the close | |
of the Civil War some of them began to protest vigorously against the | |
policies and conduct of their leaders. In 1872, the dissenters, calling | |
themselves Liberal Republicans, broke away altogether, nominated a | |
candidate of their own, Horace Greeley, and put forward a platform | |
indicting the Republican President fiercely enough to please the most | |
uncompromising Democrat. They accused Grant of using "the powers and | |
opportunities of his high office for the promotion of personal ends." | |
They charged him with retaining "notoriously corrupt and unworthy men in | |
places of power and responsibility." They alleged that the Republican | |
party kept "alive the passions and resentments of the late civil war to | |
use them for their own advantages," and employed the "public service of | |
the government as a machinery of corruption and personal influence." | |
It was not apparent, however, from the ensuing election that any | |
considerable number of Republicans accepted the views of the Liberals. | |
Greeley, though indorsed by the Democrats, was utterly routed and died | |
of a broken heart. The lesson of his discomfiture seemed to be that | |
independent action was futile. So, at least, it was regarded by most men | |
of the rising generation like Henry Cabot Lodge, of Massachusetts, and | |
Theodore Roosevelt, of New York. Profiting by the experience of Greeley | |
they insisted in season and out that reformers who desired to rid the | |
party of abuses should remain loyal to it and do their work "on the | |
inside." | |
=The Mugwumps and Cleveland Democracy in 1884.=--Though aided by | |
Republican dissensions, the Democrats were slow in making headway | |
against the political current. They were deprived of the energetic and | |
capable leadership once afforded by the planters, like Calhoun, Davis, | |
and Toombs; they were saddled by their opponents with responsibility for | |
secession; and they were stripped of the support of the prostrate | |
South. Not until the last Southern state was restored to the union, not | |
until a general amnesty was wrung from Congress, not until white | |
supremacy was established at the polls, and the last federal soldier | |
withdrawn from Southern capitals did they succeed in capturing the | |
presidency. | |
The opportune moment for them came in 1884 when a number of | |
circumstances favored their aspirations. The Republicans, leaving the | |
Ohio Valley in their search for a candidate, nominated James G. Blaine | |
of Maine, a vigorous and popular leader but a man under fire from the | |
reformers in his own party. The Democrats on their side were able to | |
find at this juncture an able candidate who had no political enemies in | |
the sphere of national politics, Grover Cleveland, then governor of New | |
York and widely celebrated as a man of "sterling honesty." At the same | |
time a number of dissatisfied Republicans openly espoused the Democratic | |
cause,--among them Carl Schurz, George William Curtis, Henry Ward | |
Beecher, and William Everett, men of fine ideals and undoubted | |
integrity. Though the "regular" Republicans called them "Mugwumps" and | |
laughed at them as the "men milliners, the dilettanti, and carpet | |
knights of politics," they had a following that was not to be despised. | |
The campaign which took place that year was one of the most savage in | |
American history. Issues were thrust into the background. The tariff, | |
though mentioned, was not taken seriously. Abuse of the opposition was | |
the favorite resource of party orators. The Democrats insisted that "the | |
Republican party so far as principle is concerned is a reminiscence. In | |
practice it is an organization for enriching those who control its | |
machinery." For the Republican candidate, Blaine, they could hardly find | |
words to express their contempt. The Republicans retaliated in kind. | |
They praised their own good works, as of old, in saving the union, and | |
denounced the "fraud and violence practiced by the Democracy in the | |
Southern states." Seeing little objectionable in the public record of | |
Cleveland as mayor of Buffalo and governor of New York, they attacked | |
his personal character. Perhaps never in the history of political | |
campaigns did the discussions on the platform and in the press sink to | |
so low a level. Decent people were sickened. Even hot partisans shrank | |
from their own words when, after the election, they had time to reflect | |
on their heedless passions. Moreover, nothing was decided by the | |
balloting. Cleveland was elected, but his victory was a narrow one. A | |
change of a few hundred votes in New York would have sent his opponent | |
to the White House instead. | |
=Changing Political Fortunes (1888-96).=--After the Democrats had | |
settled down to the enjoyment of their hard-earned victory, President | |
Cleveland in his message of 1887 attacked the tariff as "vicious, | |
inequitable, and illogical"; as a system of taxation that laid a burden | |
upon "every consumer in the land for the benefit of our manufacturers." | |
Business enterprise was thoroughly alarmed. The Republicans | |
characterized the tariff message as a free-trade assault upon the | |
industries of the country. Mainly on that issue they elected in 1888 | |
Benjamin Harrison of Indiana, a shrewd lawyer, a reticent politician, a | |
descendant of the hero of Tippecanoe, and a son of the old Northwest. | |
Accepting the outcome of the election as a vindication of their | |
principles, the Republicans, under the leadership of William McKinley in | |
the House of Representatives, enacted in 1890 a tariff law imposing the | |
highest duties yet laid in our history. To their utter surprise, | |
however, they were instantly informed by the country that their program | |
was not approved. That very autumn they lost in the congressional | |
elections, and two years later they were decisively beaten in the | |
presidential campaign, Cleveland once more leading his party to victory. | |
=References= | |
L.H. Haney, _Congressional History of Railways_ (2 vols.). | |
J.P. Davis, _Union Pacific Railway_. | |
J.M. Swank, _History of the Manufacture of Iron_. | |
M.T. Copeland, _The Cotton Manufacturing Industry in the United States_ | |
(Harvard Studies). | |
E.W. Bryce, _Progress of Invention in the Nineteenth Century_. | |
Ida Tarbell, _History of the Standard Oil Company_ (Critical). | |
G.H. Montague, _Rise and Progress of the Standard Oil Company_ | |
(Friendly). | |
H.P. Fairchild, _Immigration_, and F.J. Warne, _The Immigrant Invasion_ | |
(Both works favor exclusion). | |
I.A. Hourwich, _Immigration_ (Against exclusionist policies). | |
J.F. Rhodes, _History of the United States, 1877-1896_, Vol. VIII. | |
Edward Stanwood, _A History of the Presidency_, Vol. I, for the | |
presidential elections of the period. | |
=Questions= | |
1. Contrast the state of industry and commerce at the close of the Civil | |
War with its condition at the close of the Revolutionary War. | |
2. Enumerate the services rendered to the nation by the railways. | |
3. Explain the peculiar relation of railways to government. | |
4. What sections of the country have been industrialized? | |
5. How do you account for the rise and growth of the trusts? Explain | |
some of the economic advantages of the trust. | |
6. Are the people in cities more or less independent than the farmers? | |
What was Jefferson's view? | |
7. State some of the problems raised by unrestricted immigration. | |
8. What was the theory of the relation of government to business in this | |
period? Has it changed in recent times? | |
9. State the leading economic policies sponsored by the Republican | |
party. | |
10. Why were the Republicans especially strong immediately after the | |
Civil War? | |
11. What illustrations can you give showing the influence of war in | |
American political campaigns? | |
12. Account for the strength of middle-western candidates. | |
13. Enumerate some of the abuses that appeared in American political | |
life after 1865. | |
14. Sketch the rise and growth of the reform movement. | |
15. How is the fluctuating state of public opinion reflected in the | |
elections from 1880 to 1896? | |
=Research Topics= | |
=Invention, Discovery, and Transportation.=--Sparks, _National | |
Development_ (American Nation Series), pp. 37-67; Bogart, _Economic | |
History of the United States_, Chaps. XXI, XXII, and XXIII. | |
=Business and Politics.=--Paxson, _The New Nation_ (Riverside Series), | |
pp. 92-107; Rhodes, _History of the United States_, Vol. VII, pp. 1-29, | |
64-73, 175-206; Wilson, _History of the American People_, Vol. IV, pp. | |
78-96. | |
=Immigration.=--Coman, _Industrial History of the United States_ (2d | |
ed.), pp. 369-374; E.L. Bogart, _Economic History of the United States_, | |
pp. 420-422, 434-437; Jenks and Lauck, _Immigration Problems_, Commons, | |
_Races and Immigrants_. | |
=The Disputed Election of 1876.=--Haworth, _The United States in Our Own | |
Time_, pp. 82-94; Dunning, _Reconstruction, Political and Economic_ | |
(American Nation Series), pp. 294-341; Elson, _History of the United | |
States_, pp. 835-841. | |
=Abuses in Political Life.=--Dunning, _Reconstruction_, pp. 281-293; see | |
criticisms in party platforms in Stanwood, _History of the Presidency_, | |
Vol. I; Bryce, _American Commonwealth_ (1910 ed.), Vol. II, pp. 379-448; | |
136-167. | |
=Studies of Presidential Administrations.=--(_a_) Grant, (_b_) Hayes, | |
(_c_) Garfield-Arthur, (_d_) Cleveland, and (_e_) Harrison, in Haworth, | |
_The United States in Our Own Time_, or in Paxson, _The New Nation_ | |
(Riverside Series), or still more briefly in Elson. | |
=Cleveland Democracy.=--Haworth, _The United States_, pp. 164-183; | |
Rhodes, _History of the United States_, Vol. VIII, pp. 240-327; Elson, | |
pp. 857-887. | |
=Analysis of Modern Immigration Problems.=--_Syllabus in History_ (New | |
York State, 1919), pp. 110-112. | |
CHAPTER XVIII | |